You are on page 1of 14

Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Clinical Nutrition
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/clnu

Original article

Medium-chain triglycerides and the impact on fat absorption, growth,


nutritional status and clinical outcomes in children with cholestatic
liver disease: A scoping review
Sara Mancell a, b, *, Karishma Manwani b, Anil Dhawan c, Kevin Whelan a
a
Department of Nutritional Sciences, King's College London, London, UK
b
Department of Nutrition & Dietetics, King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
c
Paediatric Liver, GI and Nutrition, King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK

a r t i c l e i n f o s u m m a r y

Article history: Background & aims: Medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) supplementation is recommended in cholestatic
Received 14 April 2023 liver disease, despite unclear evidence and no consensus on the ideal percentage of fat that should be
Accepted 10 September 2023 MCT. The aim was to undertake a scoping review to identify the extent and type of evidence regarding
how MCT supplementation, and percentage of MCT, affects fat absorption, growth, nutritional status and
Keywords: clinical outcomes (morbidity, mortality, transplant) in children with cholestatic liver disease.
Absorption
Methods: Nine databases (MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PubMed, AMED, Cochrane Library, Global Health,
Biliary atresia
Scopus, Proquest) were searched from inception, with hand-searching conference abstracts and forward/
Cholestasis
Growth
backward citation searching. Eligible studies investigated oral/enteral MCT supplementation in children
Medium-chain triglycerides under 18y with cholestatic liver disease. There were no language limits. Two reviewers performed
MCT screening and data extraction independently. Data were synthesised narratively.
Results: Following title/abstract screening (1202 studies) and full-text review (40 studies), 24 studies
were included comprising three small RCTs (n ¼ 19 patients), one non-randomised controlled trial
(n ¼ 2), seven uncontrolled trials (n ¼ 83) and thirteen case series/reports (n ¼ 211). Seventeen studies
were published before 1994. Outcomes included absorption, growth and nutritional status. MCT sup-
plementation was associated with greater fat absorption (9/9 studies) and improved growth in some
children (2/4). Higher percentage MCT was associated with greater magnesium and calcium absorption
(1/1), essential fatty acid (EFA) deficiency (4/4), but not growth (3/3).
Conclusions: The limited, mostly observational evidence from >30 years ago points to greater fat ab-
sorption on MCT and EFA deficiency on very high percentage MCT. High quality RCTs are required,
particularly examining the impact of MCT at different percentages on growth, nutritional status and
clinical outcomes.
© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

1. Introduction triglycerides (LCT) [1]. Fat is a major source of energy, comprising


40e50% of energy in human milk or formula milk fed to infants [3]
Cholestatic liver disease is characterised by reduced bile forma- and 20e35% of total dietary energy is recommended in older chil-
tion or bile flow resulting in a depletion of small intestinal bile salts dren across Europe [4,5]. Fat malabsorption therefore increases the
[1]. The most common causes of cholestatic liver disease in early risk of growth failure and malnutrition with growth failure being
childhood are biliary atresia and genetic disorders [2]. One important prevalent in children with biliary atresia, particularly in infancy [6].
nutritional consequence of cholestatic liver disease is impaired fat For example, in a study of 755 children with biliary atresia awaiting
absorption as small intestinal bile salts are necessary to facilitate the liver transplant more than 40% had growth failure [7]. Poor growth in
emulsification and absorption of fat, specifically long-chain infants with cholestatic liver disease has been shown to be associ-
ated with an increased need for liver transplant [6] and mortality [7].
* Corresponding author. Department of Nutritional Sciences, King's College
Dietary management of children with cholestatic liver disease
London, London, UK. involves supplementation with medium-chain triglycerides (MCT).
E-mail address: sara.mancell@kcl.ac.uk (S. Mancell).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2023.09.010
0261-5614/© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

MCTs are comprised of fatty acids with medium chain lengths, five organisations were hand-searched; and 4) Citation searching,
primarily caprylic (C8) and capric (C10) fatty acids and a very small during which backwards and forwards citation of all eligible studies
amount (2e4%) of caproic (C6) and lauric (C12) fatty acids [8]. Unlike was performed using Google Scholar.
LCT, MCTs are partially water soluble. Following lipolysis of MCT, For the electronic search, nine databases were searched
medium-chain fatty acids can be passively absorbed without the including MEDLINE (Ovid); Embase (Ovid); Cumulative Index to
need for extensive emulsification and can therefore be absorbed in Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL); PubMed; Allied and
the absence of bile salts [9]. Medium-chain fatty acids do not Complementary Medicine Database (AMED); Cochrane Library;
require chylomicron formation and are transported directly to the Global Health (Ovid); Scopus; and Proquest Dissertations and
liver via the portal vein [10]. The aim of MCT supplementation is to Theses Global. Databases were searched from inception until 25/10/
replace the energy lost due to LCT malabsorption, with the goal to 2022. Each database was searched separately with search terms
facilitate improved growth and nutritional status. This is important relevant to that database. A full search strategy for one electronic
as optimised nutritional status may improve outcomes before and database is shown (Supplementary Table 1).
after liver transplant for children with liver failure [11,12]. There is For the manual search, all abstracts presented over the previous
therefore considerable potential for MCT supplementation to ten years (2013e2022) from conferences or annual research
improve fat absorption, growth, nutritional status and clinical meetings (n ¼ 35) from the following five organisations were hand
outcomes in cholestatic liver disease. searched: British Dietetic Association (Journal of Human Nutrition
Some studies have investigated the impact of MCT supplemen- and Dietetics); British Society of Paediatric Gastroenterology Hep-
tation on fat absorption and growth using various oils and formula atology and Nutrition (Frontline Gastroenterology); European So-
milks containing a range of MCT percentages (the proportion of ciety of Pediatric Gastroenterology Hepatology and Nutrition;
total fat derived from MCT) [13e15]. First, there is limited under- North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology
standing of the extent and quality of research evidence investi- and Nutrition; and World Congress of Pediatric Gastroenterology
gating the impact of MCT on physiological and clinical outcomes in Hepatology and Nutrition (all Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology
cholestatic liver disease, secondly, there is no consensus on the and Nutrition).
ideal MCT percentage to use. For example, clinical guidelines from
Europe and North America (ESPGHAN, NASPGHAN) recommend 2.2. Study eligibility
30% MCT with adjustments based on growth [12], from India
recommend 30e50% MCT [16], from Mexico recommend 30e70% Studies were considered that met the following criteria, based
MCT [17], while clinical reviews recommend 50% MCT [18], 30e70% on population, concept, context: 1) participants aged under 18
MCT [18,19] and up to 75% MCT [20]. All authors advised against years with cholestatic liver disease (population); 2) investigated an
giving >80% MCT as they do not contain any of the essential fatty intervention of MCT supplementation with or without a compar-
acids (EFA), all of which are LCT, and therefore there is a potential ator (concept); 3) MCT given as a supplement added to the diet (e.g.
risk of EFA deficiency. as an oil added to breastmilk, formula milk, food or drink) or
The aim of this scoping review was to identify the extent and incorporated into formula milk, oral nutritional supplements or
type of evidence regarding how MCT supplementation, and the enteral formulas (concept); 4) evaluated at least one of the
percentage of MCT, affects fat absorption, growth, nutritional status following outcomes: fat absorption, growth, nutritional status or
and clinical outcomes (morbidity, mortality, transplant) in children clinical outcome (e.g. morbidity, mortality, transplant) (concept); 5)
with cholestatic liver disease. in any setting (context). Growth refers to anthropometric measures
of weight, length/height, head circumference, mid upper arm
2. Materials and methods circumference (MUAC) or triceps skinfold thickness (TSF) measured
at two or more time points [25].
The scoping review was conducted according to JBI methodol- Studies were included that were published from database
ogy for scoping reviews [21] and the methods were established and inception until 2023. This broad time period was chosen in order to
published a priori in a protocol [22]. include all relevant studies since MCTs were first introduced clin-
A scoping rather than systematic review was chosen as scoping ically in the 1950s [8]. There were no limits on language to ensure
reviews provide a rigorous framework to analyse and highlight inclusion of all potentially relevant studies and to reduce the risk of
knowledge gaps and allow for wider inclusion criteria than sys- language bias [26]. Google Translate, shown to be an accurate tool
tematic reviews [23]. They can be used to provide an overview or for translating studies as part of systematic reviews [27], was used
map of a broad range of evidence. to screen and extract data from non-English-language studies.
Studies were excluded if: 1) participants had a diagnosis of in-
2.1. Identification of relevant studies testinal failure, a metabolic disorder or cystic fibrosis unless the
data from only children with cholestatic liver disease could be
The search strategy aimed to identify published as well as un- extracted; 2) they investigated MCT administered intravenously
published studies and was developed with support from a Senior unless the data from only those receiving oral/enteral MCT sup-
Library Assistant at King's College London. A PRESS checklist was plementation could be extracted; and 3) they were qualitative
used to ensure comprehensiveness and precision of the search studies, commentary, opinion pieces, editorials, reviews or narra-
strategy [24]. tive book chapters.
Broadly speaking, the search followed four steps: 1) Search
development and optimisation, during which relevant studies were 2.3. Study screening
identified through an initial search of two databases (Ovid Medical
Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online [MEDLINE] and Two independent reviewers performed screening and data
Excerpta Medica Database [EMBASE]) and the titles, abstracts and extraction with disagreements resolved through discussion and
index terms of eligible studies were extracted; 2) Electronic search, where consensus could not occur, arbitration with a third reviewer
during which the optimised search terms identified in step one (KW). All identified citations were uploaded into Covidence sys-
were used to perform an electronic search across nine databases; 3) tematic review software (Veritas Health Innovation, Melbourne,
Manual search, during which the abstracts from conferences from Australia) and duplicates were automatically removed. A pilot test
2160
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

of the screening was carried out independently by both reviewers 3.3. Characteristics of included participants
on 25 titles/abstracts. Following comparison and discussion be-
tween the two reviewers and when >75% agreement on eligibility The summarized characteristics of participants are shown in
of these 25 titles/abstracts was achieved, screening of the remain- Supplementary Table 2. There were 315 participants (50.2% female)
ing titles/abstracts continued independently by both reviewers for on MCT in the included studies, (this includes children receiving
assessment against the inclusion criteria [21]. Those that were MCT only and excludes those in control groups or who were not on
potentially eligible were retrieved in full text and screened against MCT). There were 213 (90.3%) children aged under one year and the
the eligibility criteria. most common diagnoses were biliary atresia (81.5%) followed by
idiopathic cholestasis (7%) (see Supplementary Table 2). There was
no information provided relating to sex for 72 (22.9%) children,
2.4. Data extraction, analysis and presentation diagnosis for 28 (8.9%) and age for 89 (28.3%) children on MCT in
the included studies. As shown in Fig. 2b, there were a total of 19
The same two independent reviewers extracted data from children (6%) on MCT in the three RCTs [30e32]. The remaining
eligible studies using a pre-defined data extraction form that was studies included between one and 30 children except for two large
pilot tested on two studies to ensure consistency and was contin- case series with 88 children [44] and 40 children [43] on MCT.
ually updated in an iterative process [28]. The data extracted
included details regarding the participants, concept, context, 3.4. Characteristics of MCT supplementation
methods and key findings relevant to the review question. Where
required, authors of studies were contacted to request missing or The type of supplementation included MCT formula milk only in
additional data. The extracted data are presented as a narrative 19 (79.2%) studies, MCT oil or emulsion only in one (4.2%) and a
summary and in figures or tabular form with frequency counts and combination of formula milk and oil or emulsion in four (16.7%).
percentages related to study characteristics to summarise the The MCT percentages ranged from 21% to 100% (Supplementary
publication features, research outcomes and brief findings of the Table 3). For five studies the percentage of MCT was not reported,
studies [29]. For the purposes of this study, MCT percentages were only the product name, and therefore the percentage was assumed
classified as low (<40% of total fat from MCT), medium (40e60%), to be the same as reported by studies published around the same
high (60e80%) and very high (>80%). time that did report both the name and MCT percentage
[14,30,37,50] or where there were no other studies it was assumed
3. Results to be the same as the currently available product of the same name
[39]. The MCT percentages investigated in the studies are shown in
3.1. Study inclusion Fig. 4. Information about MCT intake, rather than just percentage
supplementation, was provided in four (16.7%) studies as MCT g/kg
Following electronic database searching, 1680 studies were [15,39] or g/day [15,33,36] but was not provided in other studies.
identified, 481 duplicates were removed and title and abstract Information about the duration of MCT supplementation was pro-
screening was carried out on 1199 studies. There were 1163 ineli- vided in 20 (83.3%) studies and ranged from one day to 12 months
gible studies and 36 potentially eligible studies. Manual searching (Supplementary Table 2).
of all conferences and annual research meetings from the previous MCT was compared with no MCT in 13 (54.2%) studies; different
ten years (n ¼ 35) identified two studies, both of which had already percentages of MCT were compared in five (20.8%) studies and in
been identified through electronic database searching. Forward six (25%) studies (five case series and one case report) that reported
citation searching and backward reference searching identified a growth in children on MCT there was no comparator
further four studies, three of which were potentially eligible. Full (Supplementary Table 2). In 21 (87.5%) studies the impact of MCT
text review was carried out on 40 studies and 24 studies met the supplementation on outcomes was one of the key aims, whereas for
inclusion criteria and were included in the scoping review (Fig. 1). three (12.5%) studies, children received MCT supplementation but
this was not the main focus of the study despite relevant outcomes
being reported.
3.2. Characteristics of included studies
3.5. Outcomes
Of the 24 included studies, there were three RCTs, one non-
randomised controlled trial, seven uncontrolled trials, eight case The outcomes reported in included studies were absorption
series and five case reports (of which, three were individually (n ¼ 11), growth (n ¼ 14) and biochemical nutritional status (n ¼ 5)
extracted from case series) (Table 1). (Fig. 5). Some studies reported more than one outcome. No studies
As shown in Fig. 2a, the majority of studies (n ¼ 13) were reported clinical outcomes (e.g. progression to transplant,
observational (five case reports and eight case series) (shown in mortality).
blue) while there were 11 intervention studies (seven uncontrolled
trials, one non-randomised controlled trial and three RCTs) (shown 3.6. Absorption
in red). Seventeen were full papers and seven were conference
abstracts only. Seventeen (70.8%) studies were published between In the 11 studies reporting absorption, 10 measured fat ab-
1964 and 1993 (Fig. 3). Of only seven studies published in the last sorption in 87 children [13e15,32,33,35e37,39,47] and one
30 years, six were conference abstracts only and the other was a measured calcium and magnesium absorption in 13 children [31].
case report. All of the studies were published prior to 1994. Of those reporting
Study locations included United Kingdom (n ¼ 7), United States fat absorption, two reported stool fat content only (g) [13,37] while
(n ¼ 7), Japan (n ¼ 3), Australia (n ¼ 2), Canada (n ¼ 2), France, eight reported the coefficient of fat absorption (CFA) (%) or reported
Netherlands, Poland and Switzerland (n ¼ 1 each). There were fat intake and stool fat content such that CFA could be calculated.
three non-English language studies published in French [41], Only one study provided information regarding how fat intake was
German [33] and Polish [49]. The summarised characteristics of measured (weighing bottles before and after formula milk feeds)
included studies are shown in Supplementary Table 2. [32]. In terms of stool assessment and collection, four studies
2161
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

Fig. 1. Flow diagram of identification, screening and inclusion of studies.

reported using the oral dye markers carmine red [32,33,35] or 3.7. Growth
charcoal [37] to signal the start and end of the stool collection
period and one reported using a plastic bag in the nappy to ensure Growth was reported in 249 children on MCT in 14 studies.
complete stool collection [32]. In order to analyse the fat content of Growth measurements included: weight (n ¼ 13), MUAC (n ¼ 5),
stool, the methods described by van de Kamer [51] were used in length (n ¼ 4) and TSF (n ¼ 3). Growth measurements were pre-
five studies [14,15,33,37,47], Jeejeehboy [52] in two [32,37] Bligh sented as z-scores in six studies [34,38,40,42e44] and weight gain
and Dyer [53] in one [39] and Saxon [54] in one study [35] while (g/kg/day, kg/month, kg) in four [13,32,41,49]. There was no growth
two studies used their own method involving petroleum ether data provided for four studies [14,30,33,37] although they provided
extraction [15,33] and in one the stool fat analysis method used was qualitative statements relating to growth (e.g. MCT supplementa-
not reported [36]. In one of the studies both the methods of van de tion had “no effect on the weight of patients”) [37].
Kamer [51] and Jeejeebohy [52] were used and found to be equiv- In four studies that compared growth on MCT versus no MCT,
alent [37]. growth was greater on MCT than on no MCT in nine children [13,14]
In the nine studies that investigated the impact of MCT versus and there was no difference in 30 children [14,33,37]. In three
no MCT on fat absorption, fat absorption was greater on MCT than studies comparing different percentages of MCT there was no dif-
on no MCT in all studies [13e15,33,35e37,39,47]. Only one study ference in growth [30,32,38] while in one study, a conference ab-
compared fat absorption on different MCT percentages and found stract that included nine children, growth was greater on 30% and
that there was no difference in fat absorption when similar MCT 70% MCT than on 50% MCT [34]. Growth was measured over
percentages were given (42% and 48%) [32]. different time periods ranging from three days [32,33,37] to 12
Where it was possible to determine individual values of CFA, months [38] and in two cases the timing of measurements was not
absorption on MCT varied between 73% and 100% while absorption provided [14,34] (Supplementary Table 2). In the six studies that
on no MCT ranged from 20% to 97% [14,15,33,35,36,39]. The MCT did not include a comparator, growth in children given MCT sup-
percentages used in the studies were 87e100% [13e15,33,47], 25.1% plementation either declined over time [44,49] or improved
[35] not stated [36] and a 50% MCT emulsion [39]. In most studies [40e43].
infants received both MCT and LCT when on the MCT diet and so the
CFA relates to total fat absorbed rather than the CFA of only the MCT
3.8. Biochemical nutritional status
or LCT. In two studies where it was possible to determine the ab-
sorption of each specific fat, the CFA for MCT was median 92.6%
In the five studies reporting biochemical nutritional status, four
(range 83.3e96.7%) and for LCT was 47.6% (30e70%) [36] and in one
measured EFA status in 10 children using triene-tetraene ratio
child it was 94% versus 82% [47].
(n ¼ 3)30,45,50 or EFA concentrations (n ¼ 1) [46]. The other reported
For the RCT that investigated the impact of MCT on calcium and
serum lipid concentrations (cholesterol, palmitoleic acid and lino-
magnesium absorption in 13 children, calcium and magnesium ab-
leic acid) in one child [48]. No other markers of nutritional status
sorption were greater on very high MCT (98%) versus low MCT (21%)
(e.g. fat soluble vitamin status) were investigated. In one RCT of
(Ca 46.9% versus 34.1%, Mg 43.6% versus 34.7% respectively) [31].
only four children there was EFA deficiency on very high MCT (87%

2162
Table 1
Characteristics of studies investigating MCT supplementation in children with cholestatic liver disease.

Author, publication Participants Design Method MCT type (MCT as % Comparator Outcomes Key findings
year, country (number, sex, of total fat)
diagnosis, age)

Kaufman et al., 4 children (2F) with RCT The impact of MCT MCT formula milks: Different MCT EFA status (triene- EFA deficiency on
1992 [30] (US) alpha-1-antitrypsin percentage on EFA Pregestimil (55%) percentages tetraene ratio) very high but not
deficiency (n ¼ 2), status Portagen (87%) Growth (TSF, medium MCT
biliary atresia 55% MCT given for "2 MUAC) (n ¼ 2). No
(n ¼ 1), Alagille months and then Measured at the deficiency on either
syndrome (n ¼ 1) infants randomised to end of each month % (n ¼ 2)
Age 2.5e13 months very high (87%) or No difference in
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al.

medium (55%) MCT for growth on the


one month followed by formulas (although
crossover to the other no numerical data
formula for 1 month. reported).
Participants were
blinded to treatment.
Kobayashi et al., 13 children with RCT The impact of MCT MCT formula milks: Different MCT Ca and Mg Ca and Mg
1974 [31] (Japan) biliary atresia percentage on calcium Crown Dia-G (21%) percentages absorption (% absorption greater
Sex not reported and magnesium Lipomeal (98%) absorption) over 3 on very high MCT
Age <15 months absorption to 4-day period versus low MCT.
(no data reported) Random assignment to Ca 46.9% (32.3
groups: e60.6) v 34.1%
Low MCT (21%) (n ¼ 10) (20.4e45.2)
Low MCT (21%) with Mg 43.6% (29.7
oral vitamin D (n ¼ 4) e55.7) v 34.7% (5.4
Low MCT (21%) with IV e46.7).
vitamin D (n ¼ 5)
Very high MCT (98%)

2163
(n ¼ 4)
In some, 2 or 3 studies
carried out.
Measurements
performed after 5d.
Lifschitz et al., 1986 2 children (F) with RCT The impact of MCT MCT formula milks: Different MCT Fat absorption No difference in fat
[32] (US) biliary atresia percentage on fat Pregestimil (42%) percentages (Stool fat, % absorption
Age 5m and 11.9m absorption and growth. Alfare (48%) absorption) over 3 between formulas
Infants given medium days No significant
MCT (48% or 42%) for 4 Growth (weight difference in
days and then gain g/kg/day) growth on formulas
absorption measured (0.3 versus 0.3 g/kg/
over 3 days followed by day and 0.7 versus
crossover to the other 0.4 g/kg/day).
formula for the same
period. The order the
milks were given in was
randomised.
Kuhni 1968 [33] 2 children with Non-randomised The use of MCT in MCT oil and No MCT (Normal Fat absorption Fat absorption
(Switzerland) biliary atresia controlled trial children with formula milk: diet) (Intake, stool fat, % greater on MCT
Sex not reported steatorrhoea due to Un-named (97%) absorption) versus no MCT
Age 2m and 4.5m different causes, measured for 3- (83.1% versus 42.7%
including in 2 children days twice in each and 79.9% versus
with biliary atresia. 6-day period. 23.3%).
Very high (97%) MCT Growth (weight) No difference in
given for 6 days daily growth (although
followed by crossover no numerical data
to no MCT for 6 days. reported).
(continued on next page)
Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172
Table 1 (continued )

Author, publication Participants Design Method MCT type (MCT as % Comparator Outcomes Key findings
year, country (number, sex, of total fat)
diagnosis, age)

The order in which this


was done was
alternated.
Beath et al., 1996 10 children Uncontrolled trial The impact of MCT MCT formula milk: Different MCT Growth (weight, Growth on 30% and
[34] (UK) Sex, diagnosis, age percentage on Un-named (30%, percentages length, TSF, MUAC 70% MCT was better
(abstract only) not reported duodenal bile salt 50%, 70%) z-score change) than 50% MCT.
concentrations, fat measured over Weight:
solubilisation and unspecified time. 30% ¼ 0.4(0.5),
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al.

growth 50% ¼ 0.02 (0.3),


Infants given low (30%), 70% ¼ 0.2(0.3)
medium (50%) and high Length: 30% ¼ -0.06
(70%) MCT for an (0.7), 50% ¼ -
unspecified time. Group 1.3(0.8), 70% ¼ -
allocation details not 1.3(0.7)
reported. TSF: 30% ¼ 0.5 (0.8),
50% ¼ #0.2(0.5),
70% ¼ 0.6(0.7)
MUAC:
30% ¼ 0.49(0.6),
50% ¼ -0.14(0.7),
70% ¼ 0.4 (0.5)
Kobayashi et al., 7 children with Uncontrolled trial The impact of MCT formula milk: No MCT (FA milk) Fat absorption (% Mean (SD) fat
1983 [35] (Japan) biliary atresia unrepaired versus Formula No. 721 absorption) absorption was
Sex, age not repaired biliary atresia (25.1%) measured for 3e5 greater on MCT
reported on fat absorption and days (infants) or 1 than no MCT (90%
the impact of MCT on e3 days (children). (9.5) versus 84%

2164
fat absorption in 7 (11)). Greater
infants with repaired improvement in fat
biliary atresia. absorption on MCT
No MCT for "5 days and for those with
then low (25.1%) MCT jaundice versus
given. No report of how those without.
long MCT given before
measurement.
Burke and 11 children with Uncontrolled trial MCT use reviewed in MCT formula milk No MCT (Normal Fat absorption Stool fat mean (SD)
Anderson 1967 neonatal hepatitis children with Un-named (95%) diet) (Stool fat) over 3- 22g (8.8) on no MCT
[13] (Australia) (n ¼ 6), biliary malabsorption from day period v. 4g (1.8) MCT.
atresia (n ¼ 5) various causes Growth (weight Weight increased
Sex, age not including in 8 children gain/kg/month) on MCT: case
reported with liver disease. 1 ¼ 0.7, 1.1 no MCT
Fat absorption reported v. 1.5 MCT; Case
in 8 children given very 2 ¼ 1, 0.25 no MCT
high (95%) MCT for 3 v. 1.1, 0.7 MCT;
days followed by Case 3 ¼ 0.2 no
crossover to no MCT for MCT v. 1.0, 0.9, 0.5
3days. MCT
Growth reported in 3
children on alternate
months on very high
(95%) MCT/no MCT for 3
e5m.
Burke and Dank 18 children Uncontrolled trial The impact of MCT MCT oil and No MCT (Normal Fat absorption (Fat Mean (SD) stool fat
1966 [36] Sex, diagnosis, age versus no MCT on fat formula milk: diet) intake, stool fat) 14.2g (9.1) no MCT
(Australia) not reported absorption Un-named (95%) over 3-day period versus 3.3g (2.0)
Very high (95%) MCT MCT.
Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172
given for 3 days Mean (SD) fat
followed by crossover absorption 88.9%
to no MCT for 3 days (6.7) MCT and
45.4% (12.7) no
MCT.
Cohen and Gartner 11 children with Uncontrolled trial The use of MCT in the MCT formula milk: No MCT (Cow's Fat absorption (% Fat absorption
1971 [14] (US) biliary atresia management of biliary Portagen (95%) milk) absorption) over 3- mean (SD) 82% (5.7)
Sex, age not atresia day period MCT and 60% (15.7)
reported No MCT given for 3 days Growth (weight, no MCT.
and then crossover to length) at each No change in
very high (95%) MCT visit, admission growth (group 1)
for: improved growth
on MCT (group 2,
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al.

4e23 weeks (n ¼ 5)
11e29m (n ¼ 3) 3). (No data
6e12 months (n ¼ 3) reported).
Leyland et al., 1969 3 children (2M) Uncontrolled trial The use of MCT in MCT formula milk: No MCT (Normal Fat absorption (fat Mean (SD) fat
[15] (UK) with unknown children with Portagen (95%) diet) intake, stool fat) absorption greater
cause (n ¼ 2), malabsorption due to MCT oil: measured for 3 to on MCT versus no
biliary atresia different causes Unnamed (98%) 5-day period MCT (93.6% (2.2)
(n ¼ 1) including in 3 with liver versus 59.5% (3.4)).
Age 9me15.5 y disease.
Very high (95% or 98%)
MCT given for "1 week
before fat absorption
measured followed by
crossover to no MCT.
Weber and Roy 23 children (13M) Uncontrolled trial Malabsorption and the MCT formula milk: No MCT (Normal Fat absorption Stool fat 10.9g (7
1972 [37] with biliary atresia impact of a low-fat diet Portagen (95%) diet) (stool fat) e14) on no MCT
(Canada) (n ¼ 14), paucity of supplemented with MCT oil: Growth (weight) versus 6.5g (2e8)
intrahepatic bile MCT in children with Un-named (100%) measured over a 3- MCT and for

2165
ducts (n ¼ 4), post- liver disease. day period decompensated
hepatic cirrhosis No MCT given for 3- liver disease (21.4g
(n ¼ 5) days followed by (19e32g) versus 6g
Age median 15m crossover to very high (2e9.5g).
(range 1.5m (95%) MCT for 3 days. No change in
e16.5y) MCT supplementation growth (although
was MCT formula milk no numerical data
and oil plus skimmed reported)
milk added to low fat
foods.
Martincevic et al., 24 children (15F) Case series To evaluate growth MCT formula milks: Different MCT Growth (weight, No difference in
2019 [38] with biliary atresia. following KPE before Enfamil Enfacare percentages length, MUAC, TSF growth for those
(Canada) Pre-change ¼ 17 and after change of (30%) z-scores) at first 2 given medium MCT
(abstract only) (10F) median age nutrition protocol Pregestimil (55%) visits post-KPE and before the protocol
70 d (25e90) Medium (55%) MCT at 6, 12 months. was changed and
Post-change ¼ 7 given before the change those given low
(5F) age 58 d (20 in protocol and low MCT after the
e111d) (30%) MCT given after change.
the change
Beath et al., 1993 9 children (5F) with Case series Absorption of MCT emulsion: LCT Fat absorption (fat MCT absorption
[39] (UK) biliary atresia individual fatty acids of Liquigen (50%) intake, was 98e100% and
(abstract only) (n ¼ 6), neonatal MCT and LCT % absorption) over LCT absorption was
hepatitis (n ¼ 2), MCT given alongside 3 days 36e82%.
Alagille (n ¼ 1) LCT for 3 days
Age <2 y
Bruggink et al., 30 children (22F) Case series Growth and nutritional MCT formula milk: No comparator Growth (weight, Growth increased
2018 [40] with biliary atresia status following KPE. Heparon MUAC z-scores) from baseline to 8
(Netherlands) Mean age 61 d Infants given medium Junior(49%) measured at 1, 4, 8 weeks
(abstract only) weeks post KPE Weight
(continued on next page)
Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172
Table 1 (continued )

Author, publication Participants Design Method MCT type (MCT as % Comparator Outcomes Key findings
year, country (number, sex, of total fat)
diagnosis, age)

(49%) MCT following approximately #0.6


KPE to 0 MUAC
approximately #1.8
to #1.1
Gaudier et al., 1974 4 children (2F) with Case series MCT use reviewed in MCT formula milks: No comparator Growth (weight) All patients gained
[41] (France) biliary atresia children with Portagen (95%) over 5e14 months weight (1e5 kg)
Age 1e4 m malabsorption from Triceryl (95%) over 5e14 months.
various causes (No baseline data
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al.

including 4 children reported).


with biliary atresia.
Very high (95%) MCT
given for 5e14 months
Houchin et al., 2010 7 children (4F) with Case series The safety and efficacy MCT formula milk: No comparator Growth (weight, Median z scores
[42] (UK) biliary atresia of the MCT formula Heparon Junior length, MUAC z- increased on MCT
(abstract only) (n ¼ 4), idiopathic investigated. (49%) score change) at 4, from baseline to
(n ¼ 2), alpha-1- Medium (49%) MCT 12 w (n ¼ 7), 24 w final measurement:
antitrypsin given for up to 24 (n ¼ 3) weight change 1.09
deficiency (n ¼ 1) weeks as "60% of (0.53e1.62); length
Median age 9 w (5 energy intake change 0.47 (0.15
e28) e4.55); MUAC
change 1.10
(#0.01-3.0).
Kamat et al., 2010 40 children (27M) Case series The use of MCT MCT formula milks: No comparator Growth (weight z- Median weight at:
[43] (UK) with biliary atresia formulas and Generaid Plus (32%) score) measured on Baseline #2.27
(abstract only) (n ¼ 18), idiopathic nutritional Pregestimil (55%) starting and (#4.51- - 0.13)
management of Caprilon (75%) stopping/changing Stopping MCT-2

2166
(n ¼ 18), alpha-1-
antitrypsin cholestatic infants MCT (#4.34 to þ1.7)
deficiency (n ¼ 2), reviewed Changing to 32%
PFIC (n ¼ 1), High (75%) or medium MCT -2.04 (#0.38
Alagille (n ¼ 1); (55%) MCT given until to #4.34).
Median age 8 w (3 jaundice resolved at
e25) median 13 w (2e50)
(n ¼ 31) or until
changed to low (32%)
MCT (n ¼ 9) after 30 w
(27e47).
Kamat et al., 2016 88 children (45M) Case series The use of MCT in MCT formula milks: No comparator Growth (weight z- Mean weight z-
[44] (UK) with biliary atresia infants with biliary Generaid Plus (32%) score) measured at score dropped from
(abstract only) Median age 7.4 w atresia. Heparon Junior baseline and 6 birth until 6 weeks
(2.3e40.4) at time MCT given at different (49%) weeks. post KPE (#0.45
of KPE percentages following Pepti-Junior (50%) to #1.5).
KPE for 6 weeks. Pregestimil (55%)
Caprilon (75%)
Pettei et al., 1991 4 children (2F) with Case series The impact of MCT MCT formula milk: No MCT (Soybean EFA status (triene- There was EFA
[45] (US) Biliary atresia versus no MCT on EFA Portagen (87%) oil, cow's milk) tetraene ratio) deficiency in all
(n ¼ 3), neonatal status measured on MCT patients which
cholestasis (n ¼ 1) Very high (87%) MCT and no MCT. Details resolved after
Age 2.5e16 m given for unspecified of timing not stopping MCT.
period followed by no provided.
MCT for: 18 weeks
(n ¼ 1), unspecified
period after transplant
(n ¼ 2), 6 weeks (n ¼ 1)
Hirono et al., 1977 1 child (M) with Case report from Parenteral nutrition or MCT formula milk: No MCT (Cow's EFA status (serum Levels of
[46] (Japan) neonatal hepatitis case series MCT given and EFA Un-named (100%) milk formula) EFA arachidonic and
Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172
Age 3m status examined in concentrations) linoleic acid were
Healthy controls children with after 3 weeks lower than controls
(n ¼ 4) Age 5e11m malabsorption from while 5,8,11-
Sex not reported various causes eicosatrienoic acid
including in one with was higher,
liver disease on MCT. indicating EFA
Very high (100%) MCT deficiency
given for 3 weeks.
Healthy controls given
no MCT.
Holt et al., 1965 1 child (F) with Case report from The use of MCT was MCT formula milk: No MCT (Formula Fat absorption (% Fat absorption was
[47] (US) biliary atresia case series reported in patients Un-named (100%) milk, un-named) absorption) over a 94% on MCT, 82% on
Age 2.5 y with malabsorption 4-day period no MCT.
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al.

due to various causes


including in one child
with biliary atresia.
Very high (100%) MCT
given for "3 days
followed by no MCT
and then very high
(100%) MCT again.
Tamir et al., 1969 1 child (M) with Case report from The impact of MCT on MCT formula milk: No MCT (Pre-MCT Serum lipid Cholesterol,
[48] (UK) unknown cause case series serum and adipose Un-named (91%) diet) concentrations palmitoleic acid
Age 2 years tissue lipids in 13 (cholesterol, and linoleic acid
children with palmitoleic acid concentrations
malabsorption from and linoleic acid) were lower on MCT
different causes, compared to no
including one with liver MCT.
disease.
No MCT given for 1

2167
week followed by very
high (91%) MCT for 3
weeks.
Jankowska et al., 1 child (M) with Case report The nutritional MCT formula milk: No comparator Growth (weight) Poor growth on
2008 [49] biliary atresia management was Un-named (70%) MCT. Weight was
(Poland) Age 18 m at reported of a child with 4.2 kg at 3 weeks,
transplant biliary atresia 6.4 kg at 9 months,
transplanted at 18 7.3 kg at 1 year.
months of age.
High (70%) MCT given
from 3 weeks until
transplant
Levy et al., 1990 1 child (M) with Case report To report on a child MCT formula milk: LCT (Microlipid) EFA status (triene- There was EFA
[50] (US) Alagille syndrome with EFA deficiency on Portagen (87%) tetraene ratio) deficiency on MCT
Age 3 y MCT. which resolved
Healthy controls EFA measured on very when LCT was
(n ¼ 44) high (87%) MCT and given
Mean age 13.1y then after an
(3.1) Sex not unspecified period on
reported an LCT supplement.
Information not
provided on whether
the MCT formula milk
continued during LCT
supplementation. EFA
compared to controls.

KPE: kasai portoenterostomy, PFIC: progressive familial intrahepatic cholestasis; CHB: conjugated hyperbilirubinaemia; EFA Essential fatty acid; *Data only available for one participant in the case series.
Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

Fig. 2. Published research studies on MCT in cholestatic liver disease.


Of the 24 included studies data represent (a) the number of studies with each study design (b) the number of participants in each type of study design (data are for the number of
children receiving MCT only, excluding those not on MCT/in the control group). Observational studies (case reports and case series) are shown in shades of blue and intervention
studies (trials with or without control groups) are shown in shades of red. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the Web
version of this article.)

Fig. 3. Year of publication of studies on MCT in cholestatic liver disease.


Data represent the year of publication of studies. Observational studies (case reports and case series) are shown in blue and intervention studies (trials with or without control
groups) are shown in red. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the Web version of this article.)

MCT) but not medium MCT (55%) for two children but no difference 4. Discussion
for the other two children [30]. In two studies there was EFA
deficiency on very high MCT (87%) which resolved on no MCT [45] The findings of this scoping review on MCT supplementation in
or when an LCT supplement was given [50] and in another study a children with cholestatic liver disease indicate that most of the
child had EFA deficiency after having 100% MCT [46]. In two of the evidence is from small studies published over 30 years ago, with
studies EFA status was measured after three weeks [46] or four almost a third of the studies published as conference abstracts only.
weeks [30] of MCT supplementation, while in the other two studies The studies used formula milks with MCT ranging from 21% to 100%
the duration was not specified [45,50]. In the case report that to investigate the impact of MCT supplementation on absorption,
investigated the impact of three weeks of MCT supplementation on growth and nutritional status, but no studies investigated the
serum lipids, the concentrations of cholesterol, palmitoleic acid and impact of MCT on clinical outcomes such as progression to trans-
linoleic acid were lower on MCT compared to no MCT [48]. plant, morbidity or mortality. The findings indicate improved fat
2168
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

Fig. 4. MCT percentages in formula milks used in the 24 studies of MCT supplementation in children with cholestatic liver disease.
Data represent the MCT percentages of products used in the included studies. Percentages are grouped by colour: green ¼ low MCT (<40%), blue ¼ medium MCT (40e59%);
purple ¼ high MCT (60e80%); red ¼ very high MCT (>80%). (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the Web version of this
article.)

absorption on MCT compared to no MCT, no impact of MCT on was provided, the CFA specifically of MCT absorption (as a pro-
growth in most studies and higher prevalence of EFA deficiency portion of total MCT) was much greater than LCT [36,47].
during very high MCT supplementation. However, most of the ev- In the studies that investigated fat absorption, most used the
idence is observational and where a trial was conducted the studies three-day fat balance method (fat intake e fat excretion ¼ fat ab-
were very small with the three RCTs including between only four sorption) [56] and is considered the gold standard for measuring
and 13 participants. Some studies did not include a comparator, CFA [57] ideally using oral dye markers to signify the start and end of
particularly those that reported growth and many did not present the stool collection period [56]. Despite the use of this gold-standard
full data. All of these factors make it extremely difficult to make method, only one study described methods for measuring fat intake
conclusions that are rigorous enough to inform practice or be (weighing feeding bottles) and four reported using dye markers. A
included in clinical guidelines. challenge in infant stool collection is ensuring all stool is collected
In some of the studies there was limited information regarding from the nappy, which can be difficult when there are frequent
the MCT supplementation with most studies stating MCT per- semisolid or liquid stools, as in children with cholestatic liver disease
centages but few providing information regarding actual MCT [39] and only one study used methods to overcome this [32].
intake. This is mirrored in the literature with expert opinion re- Many of the studies used an alternative or modified van de
views frequently making reference to MCT percentage rather than Kamer [51] method due to concerns that the original method
intake [12,18e20]. Where MCT percentage alone is presented it is incompletely extracts MCT from stool due to its water solubility
potentially difficult to make comparisons and draw conclusions [15]. Modifying extraction methods to account for this increases
about outcomes as differences in formula milk volume, prescription MCT extraction from 6 to 60% up to 100% [33]. The concern is that
or consumption or total fat content in addition to the MCT per- studies using the original van de Kamer method alone may fail to
centage would impact total MCT intake. Reporting both MCT sup- fully extract MCT from stool, thus incorrectly appearing to suggest
plementation (% of total fat) and MCT intake (g/d or g/kg/d) avoids improved absorption.
this issue. Another challenge was that some studies did not report Only one study investigated the impact of MCT on micronutrient
MCT product names or MCT percentages were either missing or absorption, reporting moderately higher absorption of calcium and
different to current formulations. magnesium absorption on very high MCT (98%) versus low MCT
The studies that reported fat absorption showed that fat ab- (21%) [31], a finding similar to that reported in premature infants
sorption on MCT was much higher than on no MCT, but only one without cholestastic liver disease [58,59] but in contrast to adults
study investigated absorption on different percentages. The CFA on with fat malabsorption secondary to intestinal resection [60]. The
no MCT was in most cases well below that expected in healthy premise is that in the presence of steatorrhoea, unabsorbed fatty
subjects (90e95%) [55]. The CFA on MCT, although improved, acids may bind calcium and magnesium in the intestinal lumen to
indicated ongoing fat malabsorption in some cases. This might be form insoluble soap complexes [12,60]. Thus, replacing LCT with
because in all but two studies, that gave 100% MCT [33,47], children MCT could potentially reduce luminal fatty acids, resulting in
were given some LCT alongside MCT and therefore may have improved calcium and magnesium absorption. This is important in
continued to malabsorb LCT. In the two studies where information cholestasis where malabsorption of calcium and magnesium

2169
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

Fig. 5. Outcomes reported in 24 studies of MCT supplementation in children with cholestatic liver disease.
The outcomes reported in the included studies are grouped by categories including: growth, absorption and biochemical nutritional status. MUAC ¼ mid-upper arm circumference;
TSF ¼ triceps skinfold thickness; EFA ¼ essential fatty acids.

further risks bone health in a group of children who are already at linoleic acid and 0.7e1% from alpha-linolenic acid to prevent EFA
risk of metabolic bone disease [12]. deficiency [12].
MCT supplementation was associated with improved growth in There were no other measures of nutritional status investigated
just nine children from two studies [13,14] and in the other eight in relation to MCT supplementation, for example fat-soluble
studies there was no difference irrespective of the presence or vitamin status. Fat soluble vitamin deficiency is common in chil-
absence or percentage of MCT. This is surprising given the data on dren with cholestatic liver disease [64,65] particularly vitamins D
improved fat absorption described earlier and may in some cases be and E at first presentation [66]. As MCT is not a source of fat-soluble
due to inadequate duration between measurements to assess vitamins, the impact of MCT supplementation and its percentage on
growth change, for example, in three studies weight change was FSV status could be an important area of investigation.
measured over just three days [32,33,37]. It is difficult to interpret
and synthesise studies due to variations in the measurements used 4.1. Strengths and limitations
to assess growth and the lack of data presented in many studies.
Only six studies presented z-scores, all published in the last 30 The strength of this scoping review is that it is the first to
years, which enables comparison between ages and sex and is comprehensively review the evidence for the use of MCT supple-
recommended by the World Health Organisation [25]. mentation in children with cholestatic liver disease. The wide time
High MCT supplementation was associated with EFA deficiency, period studied, comprehensive search strategy and the inclusion of
although there were few studies including few children. The non-English language studies helped to ensure all relevant studies
triene-tetraene ratio or triene levels were regularly reported were captured. The major limitation relates to the publication date
although this measure may not be suitable in cholestasis [61,62]. of the studies. Many studies had missing or insufficient data and
The risk of EFA deficiency may relate to low intake of EFA from because they were published "30 years ago it was not possible to
MCT formula milks and fat malabsorption [30] rather than due to contact the authors for clarification, as this predated widespread
MCT supplementation per se. For example, previous studies re- availability of email addresses. This made it difficult to assess the
ported that children with cholestasis not receiving MCT supple- evidence in some cases where the methods were unclear or where
mentation had significantly depleted plasma EFA compared to information (e.g. % MCT), was not provided. Assumptions about the
controls [62,63]. The recommendation is to supplement with EFA MCT percentages used in studies published so long ago may have
during MCT supplementation [45] providing 3% energy from been incorrect.

2170
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

5. Conclusion [8] Traul KA, Driedger A, Ingle DL, Nakhasi D. Review of the toxicologic properties
of medium-chain triglycerides. Food Chem Toxicol 2000;38:79e98.
[9] Schonfeld P, Wojtczak L. Short- and medium-chain fatty acids in energy
In conclusion, the limited, mostly observational evidence from metabolism: the cellular perspective. J Lipid Res 2016;57:943e54.
more than 30 years ago points to greater fat absorption on MCT [10] Marten B, Pfeuffer M, Schrezenmeir J. Medium-chain triglcyerides. Int Dairy J
compared to no MCT and EFA deficiency on high MCT in children 2006;16:1374e82.
[11] Shepherd RW, Chin SE, Cleghorn GJ, Patrick M, Ong TH, Lynch SV, et al.
with cholestatic liver disease. High quality RCTs are required, Malnutrition in children with chronic liver disease accepted for liver trans-
particularly examining the impact of MCT at different percentages plantation: clinical profile and effect on outcome. J Paediatr Child Health
(including 0%) on growth, nutritional status and outcomes. Future 1991;27:295e9.
[12] Mouzaki M, Bronsky J, Gupte G, Hojsak I, Jahnel J, Pai N, et al. Nutrition
studies should ideally additionally report MCT intake to enable support of children with chronic liver disease: a joint position paper of
comparison with the literature. NASPGHAN and ESPGHAN. JPGN 2019;69(4):498e511.
[13] Burke V, Anderson CM. Experience with medium chain triglycerides in mal-
absorptive states in childhood. Aust paediat J 1967;3(3):135e43.
Funding statement [14] Cohen M, Gartner L. The use of medium chain triglycerides in the manage-
ment of biliary atresia. J Pediatr 1971;79(3):379e84.
Sara Mancell, Clinical Doctoral Research Fellow (NIHR302152), is [15] Leyland FC, Fosbrooke AS, Lloyd JK, Segall MM, Tamir I, Tomkins R, et al. Use of
medium-chain triglyceride diets in children with malabsorption. Arch Dis
funded by Health Education England (HEE)/National Institute for Child 1969;44(234):170e9.
Health Research (NIHR) for this research. The views expressed in [16] Puri P, Dhiman RK, Taneja S, Tandon P, Merli M, Anand AC, et al. Nutrition in
this publication are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those chronic liver disease: consensus statement of the Indian national association
for the study of the liver. J Clin Exp Hepatol 2021;11(1):97e143.
of the NIHR, National Health Service or the UK Department of [17] Flores-Calderon J, Cisneros-Garza LE, Chavez-Barrera JA, Vazquez-Frias R,
Health and Social Care. Reynoso-Zarzosa FA, Martinez-Bejarano DL, et al. Consensus on the man-
agement of complications of cirrhosis of the liver in pediatrics. Rev Gastro-
enterol Me !xico 2022;87(4):462e85.
Author contribution [18] Smart K, Alex G, Hardikar W. Feeding the child with liver disease: a review
and practical feeding guide. J Gastroenterol Hepatol 2011;26:810e5.
Sara Mancell: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal Analysis, [19] Baker A, Stevenson R, Dhawan A. Guidelines for nutritional care for infants
with cholestatic liver disease before liver transplantation. Pediatr Transplant
Investigation, Writing- Original draft, Funding acquisition. Kar- 2007;11:825e34.
ishma Manwani: Investigation, Writing-review and editing. Anil [20] Yang C, Perumpail BJ, Yoo ER, Ahmed A, Kerner Jr JA. Nutritional needs and
Dhawan: Conceptualization, Writing-review and editing, Funding support for children with chronic liver disease. Nutrients 2017;9(10):1e16.
[21] Peters M.D.J., Godfrey C., McInerney P., Munn Z., Tricco A.C., Khalil H. Chapter
acquisition. Kevin Whelan: Conceptualization, Methodology, 11: scoping reviews. In: Aromataris E., Munn Z., editors. JBI manual for evi-
Writing-review and editing, Supervision, Funding acquisition. dence synthesis, JBI; 2020. Available at: https://synthesismanual.jbi.global.
[Accessed 1 March 2023].
[22] Mancell S, Manwani K, Whelan K. Scoping review to evaluate the evidence for
Conflict of interest how medium-chain triglycerides impact on fat absorption, growth, nutritional
status and clinical outcomes in children with cholestastic liver disease. OSF;
There are no conflicts of interest in this project. 2022. https://osf.io/bdztc. [Accessed 1 March 2023]. Published Nov 18.
[23] Munn Z, Peters MDJ, Stern C, Tufanaru C, McArthur A, Aromataris E. Sys-
tematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing be-
Acknowledgement tween a systematic or scoping review approach. BMC Med Res Methodol
2018;18(143):1e7.
[24] McGowan J, Sampson M, Salzwedel DM, Cogo E, Foerster V, Lefebvre C. PRESS
We would like to acknowledge the Library Assistants at King's peer review of electronic search strategies: 2015 guideline statement. J Clin
College London for their support with developing the search Epidemiol 2016;75:40e6.
strategy. [25] De Onis M, Blossner M. The World Health Organisation global database on
child growth and malnutrition: methodology and applications. Int J Epidemiol
2003;32:518e26.
Appendix A. Supplementary data [26] Pieper D, Puljak L. Language restrictions in systematic reviews should not be
imposed in the search strategy but in the eligibility criteria if necessary. J Clin
Epidemiol 2020;132:146e7.
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at [27] Jackson JL, Kurijama A, Anton A, Choi A, Fournier J, Geier A, et al. The accuracy
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2023.09.010. of Google Translate for abstracting data from non-English-language trials for
systematic reviews. Ann Intern Med 2019;171(9):677e9.
[28] Pollock D, Davies EL, Peters MDJ, Tricco AC, Alexander L, McInerney P, et al.
References Undertaking a scoping review: a practical guide for nursing and midwifery
students, clinicians, researchers and academics. J Adv Nurs 2021;77:2102e13.
[1] Tessitore M, Sorrentino E, Sciano Di Cola G, Colucci A, Vajro P, Mandato C. [29] Peters MDJ, Godfrey C, McInerney P, Khalil H, Larsen P, Marnie C, et al. Best
Malnutrition in pediatric chronic cholestatic disease: an up-to-date overview. practice guidance and reporting items for the development of scoping review
Nutrients 2021;13:1e23. protocols. JBI Evid Synth 2022;20(4):953e68.
[2] Fawaz R, Baumann U, Ekong U, Fischler B, Hadzic N, Mack CL, et al. Guideline [30] Kaufman SS, Scrivner DJ, Murray ND, Vanderhoof JA, Hart MH, Antonson DL.
for the evaluation of cholestatic jaundice in infants: joint recommendations of Influence of Portagen and Pregestimil on essential fatty acid status in infantile
the North American society for pediatric gastroenterology hepatology and liver disease. Pediatrics 1992;89(1):151e4.
nutrition and the European society for pediatric gastroenterology hepatology [31] Kobayashi A, Utsunomiya T, Ohbe Y, Nagashima Y. Intestinal absorption of
and nutrition. JPGN 2017;64:154e68. calcium and magnesium in hepatobiliary disease in infancy. Arch Dis Child
[3] Perretta L, Ouldibbat L, Hagadorn JI, Brumberg HL. High versus low medium 1974;49(2):90e6.
chain triglyceride content of formula for promoting short-term growth of [32] Lifschitz CH, Gopalakrishna GS, Nichols B. Tolerance and fat absorption of a
preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2021;23(2):CD0027777. special infant formula. Nutr Rep Int 1986;33(4):585e93.
[4] Department of Health. Dietary reference values: a guide. London: HMSO; [33] Kuhni M. [Nutrition of children with steatorrhea using fats of medium-chain
1991. fatty acids]. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 1968;98(20):755e9.
[5] EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA). Scientific [34] Beath S, Jonson S, Willis KD, Kelly DA, Booth IW. Growth and luminal fat
opinion on dietary reference values for fats, including saturated fatty acids, solubilisation in cholestatic infants on medium chain triglyceride (MCT). JPGN
polyunsaturated fatty acids, monounsaturated fatty acids, trans fatty acids and 1996;22(4):443.
cholesterol. EFSA J 2010;8(3):1461. [35] Kobayashi A, Utsunomiya T, Ohbe Y, Nagashima Y. Fat absorption in patients
[6] DeRusso PA, Ye W, Shepherd R, Haber BA, Shneider BL, Whitington PF, et al. with surgically repaired biliary atresia. Helv Paediatr Acta 1983;38(4):
Growth failure and outcomes in infants with biliary atresia: a report from the 307e14.
biliary atresia research consortium. Hepatology 2007;46(5):1632e8. [36] Burke V, Dank D. Medium chain triglyceride diet: its use in treatment of liver
[7] Utterson EC, Shepherd RW, Sokol RJ. Biliary atresia: clinical profiles, risk disease. BMJ 1966;2(5521):1050e1.
factors and outcomes of 755 patients listed for liver transplantation. J Pediatr [37] Weber A, Roy CC. The malabsorption associated with chronic liver disease in
2005;147:180e5. children. Pediatrics 1972;50(1):73e83.

2171
S. Mancell, K. Manwani, A. Dhawan et al. Clinical Nutrition 42 (2023) 2159e2172

[38] Martincevic I, Haliburton B, Ng VL, Ling SC, Kamath BM. Early growth pat- [52] Jeejeebhoy KN, Ahmad S, Kozak G. Determination of fecal fats containing both
terns of infants following kasai portoenterostomy: QI update of single medium and long chain triglycerides and fatty acids. Clin Biochem 1970;3:
center standardized nutrition protocol. JPGN 2019;68(Supplement 1): 157e63.
842e3. [53] Bligh EG, Dyer WJ. A rapid method of total lipid extraction and purification.
[39] Beath S, Johnson T, Willis K, Hooley I, Brown G, Booth I, et al. Superior ab- Can J Biochem Physiol 1959;37(8):911e7.
sorption of medium-chain triacylglycerols compared with conventional di- [54] Saxon GJ. A method for the determination of the total fats of undried feces and
etary long-chain fats in children with chronic liver disease. Proc Nutr Soc other moist masses. J Biol Chem 1914;17:99.
1993;52(3):253A. [55] Borowitz D, Konstan MW, O’Rourke A, Cohen M, Hendeles L, Murray FT. Co-
[40] Bruggink J, Grutters LA, Verkade HJ, Hulscher JBF, De Kleine RHJ, Dijkstra T. efficients of fat and nitrogen absorption in healthy subjects and individuals
Nutritional care for infants with biliary atresia after kasai hepatoportoenter- with cystic fibrosis. J Pediatr Pharmacol Therapeut 2007;12:47e52.
ostomy: regular or aggressive? JPGN 2018;66(Supplement 2):720e1. [56] Borowitz D, Aronoff N, Cummings LC, Maqbool A, Mulberg AE. Coefficient of
[41] Gaudier B, Nuyts JP, Ryckewaert P, Giard P. [Indications for medium-chain fat absorption to measure the efficacy of pancreatic enzyme replacement
triglycerides in pediatrics]. Pediatrie 1974;26(6):641e54. therapy in people with cystic fibrosis. Gold standard or coal standard?
[42] Houchin M, Kamat D, Leibbrandt C, Hind J, Dhawan A. Safety and efficacy of Pancreas 2022;51(4):310e8.
Heparon Junior in infants with cholestatic liver disease. JPGN 2010;50(Sup- [57] Dorsey J, Buckley D, Summer S, Jandacek RJ, Rider T, Tso P, et al. Fat malab-
plement 7):E53. sorption in cystic fibrosis: comparison of quantitative fat assay and a novel assay
[43] Kamat D, Houchin M, Hind J, Dhawan A. Nutritional management of infants using fecal lauric/behenic acid. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 2010;50(4):441e6.
with cholestasis in a tertiary paediatric liver unit. JPGN 2010;50(Supplement [58] Sulkers EJ, Lafeber HN, Degenhart HJ, Lindemans J, Sauer PJJ. Comparison of
7):E1e2. two pretem formulas with or without addition of medium-chain triglycerides
[44] Kamat D, Mancell S, Kyrana S, Fatima T, Mortimer H, Moolenschot K, et al. The (MCT) II: effects on mineral balance. JPGN 1992;15:42e7.
use of specialist medium chain triglyceride (MCT) formulas in infants with [59] Tantibhedhyangkul P, Hashim SA. Medium-chain triglyceride feeding in pre-
biliary atresia. JPGN 2016;62(Supplement 1):769. mature infants: effects on calcium and magnesium absorption. Pediatrics
[45] Pettei MJ, Daftary S, Levine JJ. Essential fatty acid deficiency associated with 1978;61(4):537e45.
the use of a medium-chain-triglyceride infant formula in pediatric hep- [60] Hadderslev KV, Jeppesen PB, Morensen PB, Saun M. Absorption of calcium and
atobiliary disease. Am J Clin Nutr 1991;53(5):1217e21. magnesium in patients with intestinal resections treated with medium chain
[46] Hirono H, Suzuki H, Igarashi Y, Konno T. Essential fatty acid deficiency fatty acids. Gut 2000;46:819e23.
induced by total parenteral nutrition and by medium-chain triglyceride [61] Pavlovski CJ. Screening for essential fatty acid deficiency in at risk infants. Med
feeding. Am J Clin Nutr 1977;30(1):1670e6. Hypotheses 2009;73:910e6.
[47] Holt PR, Hashim SA, Vanitallie TB. Treatment of malabsorption syndrome and [62] Socha P, Koletzko B, Pawlowska J, Socha J. Essential fatty acid status in chil-
exudative enteropathy with synthetic medium chain triglycerides. Am J dren with cholestasis in relation to serum bilirubin concentration. J Pediatr
Gastroenterol 1965;43:549e59. 1997;131(5):700e6.
[48] Tamir I, Gould S, Fosbrooke AS, Lloyd JK. Serum and adipose tissue lipids in [63] Socha P, Koletzko B, Swiatkowska E, Pawlowska J, Stolarczyk A, Socha J.
children receiving medium-chain triglyceride diets. Arch Dis Child Essential fatty acid metabolism in infants with cholestasis. Acta Paediatr
1969;44(234):180e6. 1998;87:278e83.
[49] Jankowska I, Neuhoff-Murawksa J, Socha P, Pawlowska J, Socha J. Clinical [64] Shneider BL, Magee JC, Bezerra JA, Haber B, Karpen SJ, Raghunathan T, et al.
aspects of nutrition in children with chronic cholestasis- on the basis of a Efficacy of fat-soluble vitamin supplementation in infants with biliary atresia.
selected case. Przegla˛ d Gastroenterol 2008;3(3):139e42. Pediatrics 2012;130:e607e14.
[50] Levy J, DeFelice A, Lepage G. Essential fatty acid deficiency mimicking [65] Ng J, Paul A, Wright N, Hadzic N, Davenport M. Vitamin D levels in infants with
porphyria cutanea tarda in a patient with chronic cholestasis. JPGN biliary atresia: pre- and post-kasai portoenterostomy. JPGN 2016;62:746e50.
1990;10(2):242e5. [66] Mancell S, Islam M, Dhawan A, Whelan K. Fat-soluble vitamin assessment,
[51] van de Kamer JH, Bokkel Huinink TEN, Weyers JA. Rapid method for the deficiency and supplementation in infants with cholestasis. JHND 2021;35(2):
determination of fat in feces. J Biol Chem 1949;177:347e55. 273e9.

2172

You might also like