You are on page 1of 146

           !


" "#$% & "'( )$ "*  "#$# " 

The Impact of Using Social Media in Customer


Relationship Management performance: A field study on
private Jordanian universities student view point

:+++ 
#  - !

:.++
&# /#  0 %
#1 &   

"#$  %  #  " 4' - '( 2   "  301 
"#$  % 
 % "#'
( % 5 "&

2015 / ‫أر‬
‫ب‬
‫ج‬
‫د‬

‫ ‪#6‬‬

‫    ‬ ‫               ‬

‫‪.‬‬

‫"‬ ‫    ‪#$ %&'&  & (  )& *  &$ %&  + , %‬‬

‫(‪.0   & "  1('   .‬‬ ‫   & ‪ /‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪& "-‬‬

‫ ‪%3‬‬ ‫* ‪  3 4$‬‬ ‫‪ "    )  /$ %& .2   )3‬‬

‫& ‪.5#‬‬ ‫ ‪*  '/ +‬‬

‫‪  %&  +  %3 0   -  %‬‬ ‫‪6‬‬ ‫‪& %3  *+‬‬ ‫  ‪  )&$‬‬

‫ ‪"7/ #$ %&  ++‬‬ ‫  ( &  ‪& * ( - 87‬‬ ‫ &)  ‪3‬‬

‫& ‪.9 :  "  %3 " & ( * ( - * ( " %3 8‬‬

‫‪5#  7‬‬




1

8      8 #- 1 '&  $*  81  7 ( "#9  4

 : $#  $

; 3  7 ( < 4

#&  ' "#- 4 8- $  4

  $  $    4

=> * 01 <1

/-
‫و‬

‫ت‬ ‫ ا‬

"-? :+++++>+++
A @#?
B " $ "$ 
 #6 
3 1
 #- "
C  "
<  "
D 5-  "
 "#& "9' E'
 "##'$ "9' E'
% ?
13G1 " +++ "++6
2 #++++*++ :(1.1)
4 "+++ ++++ "'+++ :(2.1)
5 "++ ++++ .+++1 :(3.1)
5 " +++++++ "#+++1 :(4.1)
6 " +++++ B0+++$ :(5.1)
7 " +++++ #+++> :(6.1)
9 "++++ +++ ++- :(7.1)
10 " ++++ ++++- :(8.1)
10 "#+++T -'++( :(9.1)
$! ?
45G14 "6    <)$ (T
15 "6 :(1.2)
15 <)$ (T :(2.2)
16  ; :(1.2.2)
17     "  #$ :(2.2.2)
‫ز‬

"-? :>
24  4'  <T )$ :(3.2.2)
25 "#      :(4.2.2)
31    :(5.2.2)
35 "6    :(3.2)
45 "6     "  301 ##  :(3.3.2)

57;46 T "6#( :/! ?


47 "6 :(1.3)
47 "  U*$ :(2.3)
47 *$#  "  = :(3.3)
48 "  "$# % "#9# E :(4.3)
51 '& 4' -  "   :(4.3)
54 "  "#-T "& :(6.3)
56 *! "   5 :(7.3)
94;58 #>?  U$ := ?
59 "6 :(1.4)
59 "  $# #'- :(2.4)
67 "  #>  > $# "  V #'- :(3.4)
69 "  #>  :(4.4)
104;96 # U$ :W ?
97 "  U$ " $ :(1.5)
104 # :(2.5)
123;106 = "
106 "#& = :(1.6)
108 "#$% = :(2.6)
‫ح‬

 "

"< V- -
*
48 .W$ #9 A - "$#&  =# (1G3)
48 .A( "- #9 A - "$#&  =# (2G3)
49 .& #9 A - "$#&  =# (3G3)
49 .  U$ #9 A - "$#&  =# (4G3)
50 ."& #9 A - "$#&  =# (5G3)
50 ."& 5- #9 A - "$#&  =# (6G3)
51 ."#' #9 A - "$#&  =# (7G3)
57 (? X$ W#6) "$  &% ' 5  & (8G3)
60 . ; "#1 V  "##& -$ "# - (  (1G4)
61  "  #$ "#1 V  "##& -$ "# - (  (2G4)
.  
63 4'  <T )$ "#1 V  "##& -$ "# - (  (3G4)
.
64     "#1 V  "##& -$ "# - (  (4G4)
."# 
66 .   "#1 V  "##& -$ "# - (  (5G4)
68 . & ; C  # # >  U$ (6G4)
69  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (7G4)
  5#6-   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &  
72  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (8G4)
  > 5#6-   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &
74  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (9G4)
   5#6-   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &
‫ط‬

76  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (10G4)
   #&  4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &  "# 
78  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (11G4)
  ?  #&   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% & 
80  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (12G4)
 '& $   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &
82  "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (13G4)
 "  #&   4'  <T )$   
." "#$% &
84  "#      #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (14G4)
." "#$% &     5#6-
86  "#      #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (15G4)
." "#$% &   > 5#6-
88  "#      #!Y & -$ #'-  U$ (16G4)
." "#$% &    5#6-
95  ;'  #Z  !%  56-'   #'-  U$ (17G4)
 4'  <T )$     "  #$
."#          5#6- 
‫ي‬

‫" ‬
‫‬ ‫>‪:‬‬ ‫‬
‫?‪"-‬‬
‫‪6‬‬ ‫ '=  "‬ ‫)‪( 1‬‬
‫‪94‬‬ ‫‪'"()" *+‬ت ا!&‪ !" #$ %‬ات ارا ا‬ ‫)‪( 2‬‬
‫ك‬

‫" '‪6-‬‬
‫?‪"-‬‬ ‫>‪:‬‬ ‫‬
‫'‪5-‬‬

‫‪124‬‬ ‫‪"0‬‬ ‫& &‪*0‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬

‫‪126‬‬ ‫ ‪("&( ) "   $ %‬‬ ‫‪ $‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬

‫‪127‬‬ ‫‪("&( ) "   $‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬


‫ل‬

"#$# "  :           !

" "#$% & "'( )$ "* 

: FFFFFE

  E  H

:I FFFFFFFFFE

% 6 & '&

/ E   J & 

.-  E %3 " J&   &  7+   & H$ &J( "  1'/ .3/

 E . -   7+ .- $ :)& %3 +  +& 4 K 2  7+

 &( "&  , 6 - "  I / :)&  .9 L&  " & ( 7+ .-

 ( "   9 :  "  "9  "  5 & & 6 ") .  

(375) "  " .L  &   8   %   %3   "/(   "  

."  * (%33.3) " + " 9  9

%3 " J&   &  +   & "7E " ( 4' H$    "  .&

# ) 7+ .- $ :)& %3 +  +& 4 K 2  7+ .-  E


‫م‬

.   + *<&  E) 7+ .-  E . -   (7+ ( 7+

 "9 P  :/+ $ .&  "  "  .J .9 L&  (" &(

<2 )& %3 % & ( * & .  "  0&< .   " & ( 5- 

.  *<& "J "  .  . E  9)3 % &  8   K 

.0 " &( "  ")&  "  "9 .Q  .   I & % & ( * &

.-  E . - % & ( * & . 7+ .-  E :"7 .9

.7+ .- $ " & ( 7+


‫ن‬

The Impact of Using Social Media in Customer


Relationship Management performance: A field study on
private Jordanian universities student view point

Prepared by:
Othman Ihsan Idan
Supervised by:
Prof. Laith Al Rubaiee
Dr. Khalid Assad Ibrahim

Abstract
This study aimed to investigate the impact of customer orientation, CRM
Technology Use, and Customer-Centric Management System to achieve
Customer Relationship Management Performance and the role of Social CRM
Capabilities as moderator. To achieve the objectives of the study, the researcher
prepare a questionnaire based on previous studies. the study population of the
Middle East at the University, Isra University, and Amman Ahlia University of
bachelor's and master's program, reaching the study sample (375) students
distributed by (33%) for each University. The results revealed that there was a
positive indirect impact of customer orientation, CRM Technology Use, and
Customer-Centric Management System on Customer Relationship Management
Performance (Customer Satisfaction, and Customer loyalty) through Social CRM
‫س‬

Capabilities (Customer Interaction Management, Information Dissemination,


Responsiveness) as mediator.
The study arrived to set of practical recommendations among the foremost
are: to involve students across the websites of the universities and official pages
on social media in staff and administrators assess, not only the teaching staff, and
the necessity of activating the role of social media to identify current and future
needs and wishes of the students, and the speed of the response to these needs and
desires.
Key words: Customer Relationship management, Social media, Social CRM
Capabilities, Customer Relationship Performance.
1

% ++++?
"+++++ ++++ "++++++++6

#++++*++ :(1.1)
"+++ ++++ "'+++ :(2.1)
"++ ++++ .+++1 :(3.1)
" +++++++ "#+++1 :(4.1)
" +++++ B0+++$ :(5.1)
" +++++ #+++> :(6.1)
"++++ +++ ++- :(7.1)
" ++++ ++++- :(8.1)
"#+++T -'++( :(9.1)
2

% ?
"+++++++ ++ "++++6

#*++ :(1.1)

 /   "23  ) *& ' "3  "7 %3  . 2 * &

. 2 .0 & P ' :)&  0&Q  0&  "&   07+ 5 "- "-  E *J

P&  I &  07+ 5 * ( "9 "-  E  0 & 7+ .-  E  J& 

 0 & %&   &  J&  .(Reinartz, Werner, & Kumar, 2000) .Q  . 

 . 2  H . & 6 0 * & ("<& ) 1 &( "7H *&( .  *0&

 I0 7+ .-  $ %3 % & ( * & . *H "7   &  J&

(Rigby, 07+ 5 + &  "- .- ++& 9&  I0& %& .   0& 

 -  H   *& - .Darrell, Reicheld, & Schefter, 2002)

  % & ( * & . . R "H &  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &

:.  1'/ * & 6 07+ " 2 "-  E %3 S   &    .  1'/

%  (Blog) :  (You Tube) & (LinkedIn)   (Facebook) P<

(Photo Sharing)  "   (Mobile Application) *) I&0 .)9& (Wiki)

.  1'/   .(Kim, & Ko, 2012) / Q (Video Sharing) < 59) "  

%80  .7( . 02 6 * ( *  - *-  5  :9  S  J&&
3

 K  " 0 % & ( * & . . $  J&    * ( *  - 

 J& . &( % J&  %46  )    .7( .    7+ .-

. &(  . J  . &  . - 'J& %3 0& % & ( * & .

.-  E %3 " J&   & .$ % &  .(Deloitte University Press, 2013)

   ." 2  " 2& "3)H  $+ & ( S + % & ( * & . "H & 7+

V  +  +& 4 K 2 3 07+ 5 *<&  . 2  &   &

0&  * 7+  .   * " 3 + " 2  5 %3 <2

4 K 2  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &  +   & 3 '  0&Q 

(Jaychandran, etal., " & ( 7+ .-  E . - +  4W& +  +&

. ) 1'0 " &0 * ( . 2  .  H&(  H .' . ) 1'/   .2005)

 & .<& " E 7+ 5 " 7  .-  2< " 3 ") 9 0 I &( 

/(  0 " &(  " 2 *J  /  7+ .Q  .  "J .  5&& 0

7+ 03  " 2  & 7+ .-  E 5 " & ( .  X  P' 

+ & . ) 1'/   .(Van Boskirk, Overby, & Takvorian, 2011) 0    &/( 

*J  0&Q  0&  " &( I0 "& .H %3 7+ P   %$ *

. &  7+ 0 Q  %& . L& 6   . J  . &  & %3 0 

(Hooley, 7+ ( # :)&   7+  "23   P ' " & . J 

 - " .$  %  & .W   .Greenley, Cadogan, & Fahy, 2005)
4

 K  8 & "7/ #$ <2 *#3 I2& / 0 & 4' 4&  "3 

"  ++& " 0 . $ &    % & ( * & .   "9 *#3 ' 

(Wang, Dugan, & Sajka, &( + "   " & X   . J  & %3 "9

.2013)

.-  E $ %3 % & ( * & .  J& H$ &J "  1'/ . &/ '

("J "  .  "9 2 "0   "  " ) :7+

"  "' :(2.1)

*  7+ .Q  .  "& : 9 *#3$  6 *& * ( . 2 

5 & * &  # 0   P ' :)&  0 "23 % &  (  # +

. 2 .0 & ' .0 " & %  .Q  .  P&  I & *  07+

5 "- *#3$  E *  7+ .-  E  J&  %  & .W 0 

. 2 00 & %& ")   .Q  .  P&  I &  0 & % &  +

+ "- 1'/  K 0 J&   %&   & Y / ZJ * .    *

0&Q  0&  "9 00  %& *  .-  I &  / & *<& ++&

  & %3 "79 [  . H& . 2    &( 'J(   ")&  " 

P / */ :% & *W& H   07+ 0&-  E %3 % & ( * & . *H "7

\"J "  .  %3 7+ .-  E $ %3 % & ( * & .  J&( H

"  .1 :(3.1)


5

7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &  +   & H$   E "  I0&

.-  E . -   7+ .- $ ++& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2 

:*J  P ' "J "  .  %3 9 L&  " & ( 7+

4 ( 2  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &  +   & H$  .1

.7+ .- $ ++& %3 +  +&

4 ( 2  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &  +   & H$  .2

." & ( 7+ .-  E . - ++& %3 +  +&

.7+ .- $ ++& %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E . - H$  .3

"  "#1 :(1.4)


0& L& HR&  *J    %3 "J .  . E J& "& "   3& .1

.  

*J  " & ( * ( %3 " 0 .(   4'  * '/ %3 H  .2

."  1'/ 0 *&& I %& X7&

.-  E $ %3 % & ( * & .  " /$ ]#&  & "  1'/  .3

."J "  .  %3 7+


6

"  B0$ :(5.1)

  &  7+   & :")& . L&  4' "  =' $ (1) - * 

:"9 . L&  +  +& 4 K 2  7+ .-  E %3 " J&

.7+ .- $ :"& . L&  " & ( 7+ .-  E . -

9': ‫ات ا‬4'; ‫ا‬

‫&رات إدارة ! ت ا‬


'! (‫ا‬

‫إدارة  ان‬ 


‫ ات‬ 
 !" ‫ا‬ 
Ho4 2< /‫ات ا‬4'; ‫ا‬

  ‫ا‬
= ‫ات ا‬4'; ‫ا‬ Ho3
Ho2
‫ إدارة‬+, -&. /‫ا *)  ' ا‬
‫أداء ! ت ا‬ ‫! ت ا‬

‫ر  ا‬  Ho1 ‫ك‬$%&' 


‫و ء ا‬  ‫)&ب‬ 
‫ل‬+,‫ ا‬-.‫ت ا‬+&$/ 

‫ ا ن‬12! *34‫داري ا‬6‫م ا‬8)‫ا‬

"  B0$ (1)  

(Wang, & Feng, 2012; Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & :   4' $  "  B0$ $ 

Agnihotri, 2013; Choudhury, & Harrigan, 2014)


7

"  #> :(6.1)

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H$   ( :(HO1) 4 "# # "#>?

.-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

" ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 (7+ ( 7+ # ) 6  7+

(α ≤ 0.05)

:" & .# < "# < 1'/  Y <&&

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H$   ( :(HO1-1) 4 "# ? "#>?

%3 7+ # :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H$   ( :(HO1-2) 4 "# ? "#>?

%3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO2) "#$! "# # "#>?

  . - ++& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.  %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) 6  " & ( 7+ .-

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J " 

:" & .# < "# < 1'/  Y <&&


8

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO2-1) 4 "# ? "#>?

*<&   ++& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 +

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO2-2) "#$! "# ? "#>?

%3 .   %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO2-3) "!! "# ? "#>?

%3 " &( ++& +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

7+ .-   . - "7 " ( ' H$   ( :(HO3) "!! "# # "#>?

.-  :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) 6  " & (

α ≤ ) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 (7+ ( 7+ # ) 6  7+

.(0.05

:" & .# < "# < 1'/  Y <&&

7+ .-   . ) "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO3-1) 4 "# ? "#>?

%3 7+ # :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) 6  " & (

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 


9

7+ .-   . - "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO3-2) "#$! "# ? "#>?

%3 7+ ( :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) 6  " & (

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

  &  7+   & "7 " ( ' H   ( :(HO4) "& "# # "#>?

.-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

*<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . -   (7+ (  7+ # ) 7+

" ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 9 L&  (" &(  .   +

.(α ≤ 0.05)

"  - :(7.1)

:"#$ - o

"   ( "  9 :  "  ) :%/ "J " .  "HH "9 "  . 

("/(  

:"#$ - o

%H *<  2014/2013 %H *<  $& "  + K : L&& %& " +  &<

2015/2014
10

:"# - o

HR& "3   + & %&  "J "  .  %3 "9  "  1'/ E &-

.7+ .-  E $ %3 % & ( * & .  J&

"  - :(8.1)

"  9 :  "  ) :%/   %3 "J .  "HH  "  1'/ . &- o

.("/(   "   (

.9)3 .  %3 `H   "9  "  1'/ . &- o

"#T -'( :(9.1)

 &  & .)9&  " %/ :(Social Media)    

0  3 < 59)  )   Z "   *& 0 J& ] & 2.0 

.(Kaplan, & Haenlein, 2010)

*& %& "  &  "&-( .0 &  "    / :(Web 2:0) 2:0 A#

 J& "  6  + &  # H$  4' . &(  ) * " &

. (Musser, & O’Reilly, 2005) 0 a&<( 


11

% & ( * & .  9 ZJ 4E / :(Social Customer)   

* "  "9  $ - 5 .   . J  . )&   3   b *&

.(Acker, Grone, Akkad, Potscher, & Yazbek, 2011) 0 )& %& . J

. J  & %3 "9 "   & / :(Customer Engagement)  "

.(Choudhury, & Harrigan, 2014) % & ( * & .  J& " & X  

. &(  07 & . & %/ :(Online Communities) $$ 4' "#'- &

0& J  & %3 "   "9  &  * & "   "   & "9 5 *<&

.(Verhoef, Reinartz, & Krafft, 2010)

. & &(  " :(Customer Relationship Management)   

* 0& E  " &  0 .-  "9 .   E 0  %& 2  .)& 

.(Greenberg, 2009) ]

" J&   & +   & : ‫ آ‬+!%‫&ات ا‬3!‫ ا‬4! "‫را‬5‫ ا‬67‫اض ه‬12‫و‬

(Wang, & Feng, 2012) +  +& 4 K 2 7+ .-  E %3

"9  &  "& <2  & 23)1‫ و‬:(Customer Orientation)  ;

.(Brown, Mowen, Todd, & Licatte, 2002)


12

  & %/ :(CRM Technology Use) ‫إدارة ت ا‬  ‫ا  ا‬

(Jaychandran, etal., . - :J .  *0& *  7+ .-  E %3 " J&

.2005)
"J "<    J&   . &(  %<& 5- / :(Face book) D W#?

.(Carter, Foulger, & Ewbank, 2008)0  3 ^& *& " E 0 "J

< 59) /   J&   . &(  %<& 5- / :(You Tube) A##

(Cho, < 59)  (DisLike)  (  (Like)  (  0 :&  0&  

.Phillips, Hageman, & Patten, 2009)

I& 0 +0 $  "  "<& .)9& %/ :(Mobile Application) 6$ .* 6#(

4   &  J&    + 4$ %3 c 0# 5 * &  0 J&  & "'

.(Armbjery, 2004) . & "& (WIFI) 43

 *  2 / :(Customer- Centric Management)  4'  <T )$

.(Shenth, Sisodia, & Sharma, 2000) "9 .Q  . & "& 03

%& "9 * & / :(Social CRM Capabilities) "#     

.H %3 "9 P  % & ( * & . 5 .)& 2 .   "9  &

‫رات إدارة‬5; 4! "‫را‬5‫ ا‬67‫اض ه‬12‫ و‬.(Trainor, 2012) 0 "  "- ++& "&

 !" ‫ ا‬،‫  ات‬،‫ إدارة  ان‬:&!‫=;ت ا ا <!& آ  ا د ا‬
.(Wang, & Fing, 2012; Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Agnihotri, 2014)
13

0 J&& %& . 0 %/ :(Customer Interaction Management)   ? 

.(Reinartz, & Krafft, & Hoyer, 2004) 0 2<&(  "9 &  & " 

X   "J .   "  %/ :(Information Dissemination) '& $

(Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & "   ")& . <  J(  "9  " &

.Agnihotri, 2014)

‫ت‬5? @&A‫ و‬،$/‫ت ا‬$1‫<ت ور‬B ‫ ه ا "!  ا‬:(Responsiveness) " 

(Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & ‫ت‬$1‫<ت وا‬B‫ ا‬C D‫د ا‬,!"  &%)‫ر‬5!‫ ا‬. ‫ا  وا‬
.Agnihotri, 2014)
 E " 3  < / :(Customer Relationship Performance)   

"& *J   "9 &  0&9  "  "23  4W& %&  7+ .-

.- $ & "  1'/ c Q .(Kim, & Kim, 2009) 7+ .Q  . 

(Helgesen, & Nesset, 2007; Wang, 7+ ( 7+ # :" & (  * 7+

.& Feng, 2012)


&(  "  %3 & d  +& ( / :(Customer loyalty)  

.   3  "3 2 . L&  Q  *)& %3 0& J  * 

.(Chen, & Ching, 2007) ^ J(

0 )& %& . J  a& (  #   / :(Customer Satisfaction) "'( >

.(Kotler, & Armstrong, 2010) " 


14

$! ?

"6    <)$ (T

"6 :(1.2)

<)$ (T :(2.2)

 ; :(1.2.2)

    "  #$ :(2.2.2)

 4'  < )$ :(3.2.2)

"#      :(4.2.2)

   :(5.2.2)

"6+++   +++ :(3.2)

"6     "  301 ##  :(3.3.2)


15

$! ?

"6    <)$ (T

"6 :(1.2)

(1) - * %3 "  =' $ %3   "  . L& *<& *< '/ c 

*  *& :  " $ %3 0#  & 6 ") .  /$ 0 "- 

 +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  +   &

.-  6 H   " & ( 7+ .-   . - %H   +

.") .  5   7+

<)$ (T :(2.2)

&   . J .(&(  .   & %3  &   J( . 9& 

 %3   & 1'0 "&(  . 2  5  :9  % & ( * & .

^ J$ "0  " 2 7+ 5  "0  "  5 "  & .- : &

%  & .W 3 ' .(Woodcock, Green, & Starkey, 2011 ;2004 % + )

  )  % & ( * & . %<&  " / P & ^ J( . 2 * 0 

0&9 "   P & *   .  *& "  "9 5 / & * & .

I&0 .)9& &  P 83 *  * "J " ( "  . &/ )3 /  

.(2007  ) / Q  Q&  &&  &/( .  c .   *)


16

(Customer Orientation)  ; :(1.2.2)

P "<3 R 7+   & (Marquardt, 1989 ; Singh, & Koshy,2011) I 

*  . &( 1'/ 5 " 2 I& 30& 7+ . & 03 &   

،2)$‫(ا‬Narver, & Slater, 1990; $ ."3& + :)& % &  3 ( 0&&

7+ .  "3   0<&  " 2  - / 7+   & E  E (2010 ،)7‫ا‬8‫وا‬

$   ."7  0& 0& - %3  HW *   07J P ' 0&Q  30&

(Deshpande, Farley, & Webster, 1993; Wang, Dugan, & Sojka, H  *

&  ($ + " 5#& %& . )&  " / 7+   & E 2013)

.*9 ^  a  :)& P '  <2    P   Jb " 

I&  + & 0R (Saxe, &Weitz, 1982; Singh, & Koshey, 2011)  * 0 $

/ 7+   & 3 % &  . &( /'J$ 0   2<  7+ . & "&

0 & %& .   + &   '  " 2  " " 2& "3)H  $+ & ( +

.7+   & ++& E   %& . )&  )  "   E 7+ . & *

$  E * " 2 7+ " ) "  I & 9)3  #& ( 7+   &    

7 <  53 + :(Alrubaiee, 2013)  / $   &) 9 *J  " 2 P& 7+ " -

.0 * %& 53  " ) + "<& *)& $ 0 & %& "<  " ) +
17

:*J  +   & 8- &

.. 2 %3 ")&  "  7+ .Q  .   I & .$

.. 2 %3 7+ %#    I & .

.+  " 2  "<& " - :)& .=

(CRM Technology use)     "  #$ :(2.2.2)

"  .   & % * *H & 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &

 " &  7+ 5 " "-  2< " 2  - ++& %& 7+ .-  K

P ' 8 * " 2 *J  0 & & " & & .  "&  .  5 &

 ZJ& 7+ . *& 7+ 5 *<& " 3  < +  " 2  &

%    .   & J&& .(Day, 2003) 7+ .-    &  J&

 & "L& .   HW&   &  S & .H - 7+ .-   '<&

" 2  *3 + &  :) " 2  %   *H & .   &  . -

.(Keramati, Mehrabi, & Majior, 2010)

%& %  ( & .)9& 7+ .-   %3 " J&   & . * &

 & %& "<J & .)9& . .&  . J  :&  . &

7+ 5 *<& *J  %  ( &  & ،(Greenberg, 2010) . *& X 

3 & .   4+ P 9&  " 2 )& 0& 0  .  5 I0
18

.   &( 0 J    . -   7+  ")& .  5 +J&

. %<2 *  1'/ .  -  &    .(Berger, etal., 2002) :

X   J& 0& .  1'/ X  & .  1'0 7+ " J :& 

" 2  (  # + 0 2<&(  7+ " - 0&  7+ .Q 0< "J&

.(Greenberg, 2001)

4  * %/ 7+ .-    & 0< % & ( * & . 

5 " 2  %<&  *<&    J& .    &  0      

. :7)1 #;<7‫ و‬. (Kim, & Ko, 2012) 0 " 7) .- : & % &  07+

*& , ] & %&  . &(  & .)9&  " 0 % & ( * &

(Kaplan,  J&  / Q Z  3 59)  )    ^& "  

. %3 * & "  2100  (HBR) =" >1?‫'ع ا‬A!‫ ا‬2B‫ و‬.& Haenlin, 2010)

* & .  J& .   (%58) &    .   * "<&J

 J&(  &( &  0  .   (%21)   07+ 0&-  K % & (

" -  7+ * %3 . 1'/ .  ]#   3 % & ( * & .

.(Zhang, 2011) " - . ' + & .-

%3 " & &    %&  7+ .  %7  && 7+ "   

7+ "   .(Bijmolt, etal., 2010; Hennig-Thuran, etal. 2010) 7+ .-  

7+ "  .   % & ( * & .  J& 7+ 5 * &  & /
19

"  & "   " 2  + & %& + . 0 0< &   .  + &&

 ")& .(&  )&  7+ *& . J  . &  4W& %& 

* & . . - .(Hollebeek, 2011) " - :J    " 2  9  

*& c 0# 5 .-  * & P ' ^& "   7+ % & (

5 0& J " 2 . &  "J . J *& P ' " 2 5  0  3 3(  b

.(Kumar, etal., 2010)c 0#

 % 4  (Apple) * %&  0  7+ "   &0& ^  .  #  

5& *  " * %3 " < 7+ "   &  5 & 6 (IBM)

(Hoyer, Chandy, Codogan, &  < 7+ ] 0&  . J  . &

* & . .   J& "  1'/ . &/ /   .Dorotic, & Singh, 2010)

"  .  "HH  "  1'/ . & 6 7+ "  *<& *  % & (

(Choudhury, & Harrigan, 2014) :*) I&0 .)9& & P< :%/ 7+

(Face book) D W#? :(1.2.2.2)

*    J&  6  % & ( * & 5-  H  P 8< 

P 8<  S  9 J& (618,000,000)   J&  * 6  J&( 

 -(  "J   "J .  :#& .&    J& V 

.(Smith, Fischer, & Yongjian, 2012) -( .<  "& " 
20

. &/ )3 '   " % & ( * & 5-  H  / P  P 8< 

.(&(  " P 8< *J  0 "J * ( "7 L& . 2

. &(  %<& 5-  P 8< I &   .(Dickey, & Lewis, 2010) * (

" & ]  4' # 9  . &(  " . & ++&  ] 

3 ' (Carter, Foulger, & Ewbank, 2008; Stainfield, Ellison, & Lampe, 2008)

. & %3 0 I 0&( . 2 *J  .(& "- Q Z 3 ]& P 8<

  .(Kelley, Kerr, & Drennan, 2010) "  5 .-  "

 * &  *7 )& "  & "   " 2  "   . &(  " . &

 & " 2  ( :)& 7+ . &  HR& I0& 6 7+  " 2

(Algesheimer, Dhalakia, &  * 07+  " 2 I & .  

"  & * ( 5&  * % & ( * & . 3 ' Herrmann, 2005)

* 7+ "    P ' :)&   ( . &(  "   0& &  . 2 

7+ "    +& (  & & . 2   . J  . &  & %3 *3

0  %& .<& "  * & .(Ofcom, 2008) " 2   7+ " - :)& % & 

"  3 ' "  & 0&  " 2 * J + 5 +  " 2 5 +

"  H 0 %&  *-    &  %&  "   "9& .   :)&

"  & 0&  " 2 * 7+ 0  %& .) %/ . 1'/   " 2 

.(Van doorn, etal.,2010; Ver Doorn, etal., 2010) .9&( 


21

(You Tube) A## :(2.2.2.2)

H( *&( . & &  * . 2  &/  ^ . &( " 9& 

.  " / - 5  *  0 & %&  ")& ( *7  "

 "3#K .(Cormier, Ledoux, & Magnan, 2009) "   "&  "<&J

"  & 0&   " 2  (  S  HW& %&  "   "  & "  . & 0#

/ 02 & P ' 07+ 5 " 2 * & " % &  .(Muniz, & O’Guinn,2011)

 . 2    % &  (Wright, & Hinson, 2010)07+ 5 %<9 * & *J 

* ( .(&  * ++& %&  (/ Q < 59)   ) *J  0 . 

" & ( < 59) 5 * &  *( : & %/  &/  H . (  

5  "< "  < 59)     < 59) * & "    %H 

H      '0   J& 8   * "<9  .    

(Cho, Phillips, Hageman, ^ J( .  " 

/ .  6 S 7 +  '  &  . ( & .& Patten, 2009)

   6  . 2 <& " ")) P ' */ & . 2    ( '  0

   < 59) *J  0&&  "  & 0&  " 2 7+  & %3 

"' .  & & .(Chatzopoulou, Sheng, & Faloutsos, 2010) &

%3 7J  <&(  " 2   6 07+ 5 .  :J  " 2   4'

(An, Davey, & Eggleton, 2011) 7+ (  2<  :J " *&( . & &
22

 3(  b *& 7+ 5 a&< %&  " -  . 2 &    

.(Ledingham, 2003) "   7+ 5 " "-  2<  :J P '

 &  0  6 7+ 5 4  *&( *0&   & . 2  J&

59)  .)& "3# "  (Dislike)  (   (Like)  ( *J  07 o

5 "- *#3  K ^ J( % & ( * & . 5 J&&    0&   <

.     3 ]& . J  . & :& 4  # & ]   7+

(Chartzopolou, Sheng, & Faloutsos, 2010)"  & "  1 & 7+ I- 8)

(Mobile Application) 6$ .* 6#( :(3.2.2.2)

  )  7+ 5 4 3 * * &   ) / 7+ .-   / 

 . 2  & %& . ( /    .(Park, & Kim, 2003)7+ " & " - 3&

.H  J( .  %3 *) I&0 /    + 4 %3 7+ 5 4 3 * &  

7+ "3# " ) :)& %& . J  *) I&0 .)9& 5  J&  0& - 7+

I&0 .)9&  J&   % &  / Q )   (  "- &  .  . J *H

+ 0 & %& " < . J )&  "  & "   % + "  &  R *)

07+ 5 0&-   %3 *) I&0 .)9&  J&  . 2 I/   (IFPI, 2006)

# + % &  0 "J . J )&  * 07   I & *  /

 J& :&  2  & - .(Arnbjerg, 2004) *9 ^  7+ (

.  *& %3 Z)      H&(  7  )&  :*) I&0 .)9&
23

3 % &  .*) I&0 .)9& :&  * &     +  " 2  & 

.  :&  7+ .-   "K I0& %& . J ) *) I&0

(Componovo, 7+ .  *K " " .  &  J&  . J 

.Pigneur, Rangone, & Renga, 2005)

7+   6 . J  & %3 (3 7  *) I&0 .)9& &

 &( .(Dickie, 2011) W .- 4 %3     a&  0&   

Q  0 (%91) 3  "  (19) %3 ZJ (9000)  (KPMG) / " 

*) I&0 .)9& + && .(Seidel, 2009) &)9& *) I&0  J& 0&  R

:(Awashi, & Sangle, 2013) 1 '  )3  < Z7J  " 

.  I&J& *) I&0 .)9& :*&(  %J 59 < 

& *7 3 ' 9)3   ZJ  J&  ^ J( % & ( * &

.9)3   ZJ "J

07+ " 2  9& %3 (3  *) I&0  :*<& %3 9& 

..  %3 9   % & 

 7+  & "<&J 0& - *) I&0 .)9&  :*&( %3 " 

" ) 0<& /   7+    .- 4 %3    + 4 %3 .(&(

. 7  0 E *   '  &


24

(Customer-centric management)  4'  < )$ :(3.2.2)

4 ( 2 & " 2& .  & "3)H 5  & % 2& 4  2 /

)& " 2& . ( 5   #& %& "7 (  "0    +  +&

2   .(Day, 2000) " 2  "J  " *-  8  7+ . &( )3 P & 

 L&  7+  "J .  *& " . 2  ]&& +  +& 4 (

7+ 5 + & "-  2<  7+  + & %& * ( 1'/ 8 & "< :7 

2  7+  +& 4 ( 2 I  .(Wang, & Feng, 2012) / & 53 

) 6 .: .9-  : . &  (


S  7+ . & "& 03  * 

  ") 9 + " J  K  '  )& )&   + * )& -

/ 7+  +& 4 ( 2  I0  .(Sheth, Sisodia, & Sharma, 2000)

  ' (2004 ،2D( ‫ )ا)("ي وا‬7+ " J ^& %3 " <   <  - - :)&

. &  & "  & + 0 & %& .Q  .  5 I& . 2 

% & &( 99J& "  :9 & %&  7+ .Q  .   &( . J 

" 3 *H  7+  +& 4 ( 2  &   .(Wang, & Feng, 2012) %)&

& I 2 '/  && %& . 2   7+  "J ")& "9( X  " H

3 % &  "- 0&  ( 7+ 5 0&-    7+  0&  "0 

 & %& "9( 5 *  = (  /+ &  7+  + & %& . 2

(Jayachandran, etal., 7+ "3# " - :)& %& "9q *#3 " 7  : 9  7+
25

. X  9)3 )& ( 7+  +& 4 ( 2  && %& . 2   2005)

    " 2  & %&   &  J&  )& #   7+ " J :& 

% 7+  +& 4 ( 2     " 2 5 * &  3 * * &  ^&

.-   :9    7+ 5 .- "   && " / 1 3 

 ).  K + *  7+ 0 +  %& . J  . &  + / 7+

.(McArthur, & Griffin, 1997; 2004  

(Social CRM Capabilities) "#      :(4.2.2)

. %& 7+  .(&(  .   & %3 " & . 9& 

5 * & / Q *) I&0 .)9& &  && P 8< *H % & ( * &

5 *<& + " 2  + *H  *& 1'/   * ( %3 07 2 5 *<&   -(

(Andzulis, Pangopoulos, & Rapp, 2012)  . - .)&  J& : 9  7+

.-  , <&   H    4'   & ( 7+ 02 % & 

?EF3;!‫ت ا‬GEH!‫ ا‬#I J1(K ‫ة‬7? ‫رات‬M$ ‫ !)!ف‬#($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫م ادارة‬EPQ"  1‫ و‬،7+

(Payne, H 03  )3 ' .(Trainor, 2012) 2I(<!?G‫ ا‬ST‫ا‬E!‫;(ت ا‬DU ‫ام‬R!‫ ا‬#I <?(3‫ا‬

 ( "9 "- ++& "  + & I72 & " 2& "  0 & Frow, 2012)

5 "  %3 % & ( * & .  J& 0 (Coltman, 2007) 03  .7+ 5

)3 .0 " < " &(  " 2  5 %3 /  7+ . & "J . 

%& "9( * & "  %/ " & ( 7+ .- . -  (Trainor, 2012) 6
26

% & ( * & . :9& 5 .)&  .   2  "9( P ' %3   7+  &

7+ .-   . -   .7+ 5 "- ++& "& .H %3 7+ P 

8& 0  " 2& .  %3 7+ .-   "9  $+ & ( + %/ " & (

+ & .-  "23   7+ & 4W& %& 0 "3   & " 2 . 0

.(Morgan, Slotegraaf, & Vorhies,  7+ & .- 1'/  <&(  0

* &   )  7+ 5 " 7  .- 9&  " . ) 1'/ .&H - 2009)

" 2&    7+ .-     & %3 .  H&(  X+ : 9  7+ 5

5 " 3  < *<&  . 2 .   &   .(Coltman, 2007) " & &(

*-  0 J&  " 2 *J  /  7+  .  & " % &  7+

.(Ahearne, Hughes, & Schillewaert, 2007) " < 0 " &(  -   (

(Wang, :%   (  "  " & ( 7+ .-   . - +& &

& Feng, 2012; Trainor, Andulis, Rapp, & Agnihotri, 2014)

(Customer Interaction Management)   ?  :(1.4.2.2)

1'/ I0& 07+ 5 " 2 *<& / :& * %3 . 9& /    

 .  & "  7+ .Q  .   I &  " 2  & .<&

*J   .(Reinartz, Krafft, & Hoyer, 2010) 0 " &(  " 2 *J  /  +

" % &  0  3 "  Q "  ")& *7 *& 7+   .<& 1'/

. &  . J  & . - 'J& %3 " 2 "   c 0# " J 
27

" 2 0 J&& %& . 0  + *<&   I &   .(Bijmolt, etal., 2010)

0 " &(  7+ .Q  .   I & *J  0 2<&(  7+ &  &

Q * 7+  . 2  * &    Q .(Harrigan, & Miles, 2014) " <

07+ 5 " 2 * & & . - P& & %&  " & (    J& % 

. ) 1'/    %/ % & ( * & . 3 ' .(Street, & Cameron, 2007)

2&  %<& *&    ) 4'  + *<&  E *<&  " 2  E  & %&

  . - "9 * &( % & ( * & . . 2 J&& .07+ " 2 

.    " 7) 7+ .-   .   5 & 6 7+ .-

     .(Bajmolt, etal., 2010) "3& + :)&  " % & ( * &

"  & 0&  " 2  "   . &(  " . & %/ + *<&   *

 7+ .   J&  & "  1 ") 9 07+ " J  " 2  & %& 

.  99J& .  *H 7+ .-   . -  % & ( * & . *J

. & I &   . (Alavi, Ahuja, & Medury, 2012) / Q . + 5#

*<& 07+ 5 " 2 *<& . &(  07 & . & 0 . &(  "

.(Verhoef, . J  . &  & .  %3 "   7+  & 0  3 7+

 * 7+ 5 * & && ( . 2     Reinartz, & Krafft, 2010)

(Jack, . &(  " . & *J  07+ 5 *<& *#<& P ' (  0 )

" . &  -  &/  53    .Moult, Anderson, & Dodd, 2010)
28

7+   .-  "  " " -  . 2  & 0 . &(  "  

 &  J&  7+ .-   *J  . J  . &  " " -  P  

. &(  %  5  5 & %3 " 2  7+ .-    " 7) . 

.(Street, & Cameron, 2007)

(Information Dissemination) '& $ :(2.4.2.2)

 .  - *J   "  :7H  "  ") 9  .   "  &&

3 ' . (Cohendet, 2004)  &  J& *J     0  *<& *J 

" 2  .    " 2  5   Jq .    7+  &   &

 $+ & ( + / .    *)   ^ J( . 2  " 2   7+

(Srinivasan, & % & ( * & .  * 0&0 %&  . 2  4&( 9

% J&   .7 ] & % & ( * & . 3 ' .Moorman, 2005)

.    0 J& ] & 0  .   =&K    5 %3 . &(

  + % & ( * & .  J&  7+  &   .(Day, 2000)"<&J  R

"   * ( * 1 &  7+ 1 & .    . 2  -

% & ( * & .  "  .- &  ' ( HW ) 7+ 

 % & ( * & .  J& .   &   .(Jayachandran, etal., 2005)

" 2 *J  %3 .   #   %  Q  %  * ^ J  " 2


29

 0)3& .     .(Chandy & Tellis, 2000; Street, & Cameron, 2007)

  +& (  ")H + % &  *&        / & " 2  7+

")&  "  7+ .Q  .   I &  " 2  & 07+ " 2

.(Jayachandran, etal., 2005) (  # :)  0 7& . J . &  & % & 

" &(  0 & %3 /& %&  " 2 .     .   "  &&

" J :&  .  " 2  "<2 -( 5  & *J  7+ .  .Q

%& . 2   . (parvatiyer, & Sheth, 2001) .  1'/  *  7+

9& 0 , " 2 *J  " < /  7+  .     .   &   &&

 :)&  .(Baker, & Sinkula, 2009) : %3 " < 83&  & . J . &

0& - 7+ 03 " 2 *J  /  .  & . 2    7+ .-

 7+ .   ")& "9( :&   ' 3 *-  "& . & &( 

(  # :)& % &  7+ "-<& " - )& *  " 2 *J  "<&J . (

.  *& : /  +  .    .(Wood, Bhuian, & kiecker, 2000)

%)3 * .  :3&  # 4 " 2  5 %3    ")&  " 

 # ")&  "  7+ .   :&  3 "<&J -(  *J  4 

.  *&   3(  . ( 5 5 & : 9  .   *<  J&(

.(Bhuian, Menguc, & Bell, 2005) ")&  "  7+ . & ")&

(Responsiveness) "  :(3.4.2.2)


30

"9& .  % *  && " & ( 7+ .-   . - 

0 " &(  7+ . & "9& .   &  )& %&  . 2 

. & . 03 *J  7+ . &( " &( && .(Baker, & Sinkula, 2009)

0&Q  7+ . & 03  " 2  & %3 7   0  % & ( * &

3 "  .Q  . & " &( & ( 7+ .  *& *J  ")&

. & 03   .(Narver, Slater, & Maclachlan, 2004) # ")&  " &( *

3 .  P& )3 . ) 'J&  0 " &(  .  *&  / 0&Q  7+

(Kohli, & Joworski, & Kumar, 1993) 7+ . &( S  2& "  03  # ( P '

 ( 7+ . & 0< " 2 *J  " 2& -   )& "9 *<&   '

0 & 5   . J 07# *J  7+ " - 3& /  .  5 

03   ) 0 " 2 4   (Huit, Ketchen, & Slater, 2005) 7+ 5 *<& 

% &  "-<& . J )& 0 , 0 " &(  ")&  "  7+ .Q  . 

( :)& " &( 3 P ' "3#K .(Huit, & Ketchen, 2001) 7+ "-<& " - :)&

 &( "  0 + &   "  . J . & )& " & "  + &

" &(   (Wood, Bhuian, & Kiecker, 2000) &  L& 7+ .  .Q

 "<& " 03  . J . & a 9  4W& 7+  L& .Q  . 

. J . & )&  7+ .-    " 2  & .  P& "&      &(

.(Martin, & Crbac, 2003) 3  *#3


31

(Customer Relationship performance)    :(5.2.2)

*H  q  + :)&  4W&    " & ( 0& - 7+ .-   :9& 

& %& . ) 8  " 3  < :&  I & c<J : %3 % +

.  J& *J  0&Q  7+ .   0 & %& .   )3 /'J&

a ( + (  # :)& 7+  "23 + % &  % & ( * &

7+   & . 2 . J&  '  .(Kim, & Kim, 2009) "3& + :)&

+  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 % & ( * & . .)&

(Wang, Huang, Chen, & Lin, 7+ .-  ++& "#  " :)& I 0,3

7+ .  9 *J  7+ .- *< ( :)& # . 2   . 2006)

" & ( 7+ .-   & * ( .(& 5 *<&   .  5 "J 

.- + &  ]  ( :)&   .(Lingreen, Etal., 2006) " 2  " " 

. + %/ I / 1'/   *  I /$ %3 + &  a  :)& *J  & 7+

# :)& "- 0& + . "<&     : $  7+ :J

 +  "9  &3 '  7+ .-    .(Eid, & El-Gohary, 2013) 7+ (

  .)< 03 & %& . %3 * & %& . 2  ( . 2  " " R

.-  :)&   .(Andzulis, Rangopulor, & Rapp, 2012)   7+ .-

4'  : %3  Y9- %3 ")& " <   < :)&  " 2  & %3 / 7+

.- + & ( 3 % &  .Y9) '/  "3 ++ *9 ^  " - :)
32

"3  + &(  ^ J( . 2 5   Y9- %3 . 2 %3 7+

 7+ .-  +&  .(Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Angihotri, 2014)

(Helgesen, & Nesset, 2007; Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, :%   (  "

& Angihotri, 2014)

(Customer Satisfaction)  > :(1.5.2.2)

X&  X&  " )  " & *  "J $   7+  /

# Q  7+ 3 .-&  *-   ',3 &-& 5  )& %& " J 

3 .-&    + 'E #  7+ 3 .-& :3    'E

" / #   (kotler, & Armstrong, 2010) "  "  #  7+

" &(  7+ (W/ .  :)& %3 " 2 a   & /   7+ "70

 - %   % ) " 2 . &  . J   %3 / & %& 0& W

3 3 :0& $ %& .< & *J  # .    . & .(2011

* & %& " J  X&  J&  #  a& ( R(Maloney,2003) 6

 J  c-& )& %<9 + " & R(Vavra, 1997) $   ." 2  0

(Zhong, Han, & Gao, 2008)    .")& &-& " J  X&  + ")

%/ 0& &  0&Q :)& %3 " 2 a  " & 7+ "#  "  R

& %& .< &  &( .0 " ) . J  7+ *-  . &  .-&

" J $ X&  %9 8 (E /  X& $ " J  # 3 1$ / '
33

7+  + . 2 3  )&   X& $ " J 1'0 (   1  4' 

%   % ) 0& J $ 0 & %)& #  "  "   E & 0& J  <& 

07( 7+ #  ")H "- P / E (Kuusik, 2007) $ .(2011 1 -

" 2  #    ' 7+    7+  # 7+ 3

. &  #    ' 7+ 3 % &  ^ J$ . 2  0 &

." 2 5 "< 0  & * 8    $ J,  ) I " 2 . J

(Customer Loyalty)   :(2.5.2.2)

%3 " J  X&   & d  +& (  (Chein, & Ching, 2007) H 3 

 (Srinvasan, Anderson, & Pannovolu. 2002) 3    ." 2 8<  *)&

X& 8<  .  &  4W 4'  0& J " 2 . &  1 & %  I-

(Ganesh, Arnold, Reynolds, 2000) F )3 ..-  5 2&  .H * " J 

I- &    5 . J  . &  7+  & "  / 7+ ( 3

& %& %/ 7+  " 2  "- "   ."  & 0&  " 2 1 & % (

S  7+  & " )  0&  7+ " J &    ( :)& %3 ( 

.  8) (    .(Helgesen, & Nesset, 2007) (  # :)& %3 S 

(  " 2  %)) (  +  (  & 3 " 2 . J . & 

(2014 1/+) :" 2  (  Y  " &   ' .I7 +


34

& *J   && " 2 . J . &  "Q / :%)) ( 

.07 

(  "  . J . &  7+ "<& "Q / :  ( 

.0 "$ " *H & ( " J  X&      )

" 2 . J . &  %3 + "- "Q %3 *H & :I7 + ( 

."& *7     " &  .  )  

 "Q  & " J  X&  +   %3 *H & : (  

." J  X&
35

"6    :(3.2)


"#&   :(1.3.2)
4'  ; ! #&  "   " :$ - 8(2011 83 ) :" 
"" "#$% & "#  >
#  " & " J   "9  "   &  "-  I &  "  1'/ .3/
9 :  "   
S  "  .  ."J "  .  %3  .  "9
"  " .& . .  %3 "J& 0  "   "    "  
"7E " ( ' H$    "  .& .%7( *& "  "& (205) 
. .   "J "  .  %3 /#  "9  "   &

"#$%   :(2.3.2)


“ The Role of Relationship :$ - ،(Jayachandran, etal., 2005) :" 
Information Processes and Technology Use in Customer Relationship
Management”
 K " /( "L  & %&  " 2& "& .-  .  8) "  1'/ .3/
%3 % & ( * & . J&& %& ")&   &   
S #3 7+ .-
.( %3 "<&J . %3 * & .   "  5 & & .7+ .-  :)&
% & (    "<&0 .   J& .) R 6 - 6 " ( &
..  P& %3 7+ . J .  :&    (1105)  "& " 
 +  +& 4 ( 2  +   & HR&    "  .&
   7+ .-   .-  .   HR&   .-  . 
  .-  .   7+ .-   %3 " J&   & HW 9
.7+ .-
36

"Consulting Social Media in The :$ - 8(Stageman, 2011) :" 


College Transition Process: Experiential Accounts of the Class of 2014"
 %3 % & ( * & . & 4'   I &  E "  1'/ .3/

5 * & % & ( * & . "9  J&  " E " $ 5 .-

5 .) . $ 6 + & .  .) "  1'/ %3 6 J& " 

 6 & 6 + & . #$ J&  "J .    7   J

.& .  "9    (10;5)  I R&&  * Y9& * Y9& (12)

 9 & %3  * HW& ( % & ( * & .  J& E  "  1'/

P ' *9 ^  0 "23    "9 5 - .-   & 0 

." $ 5 0<2  "   "- % & ( * & . ++&

" A Conceptual Model For :$ - 8(Askool, & Nakata, 2011) :" 
Acceptance of Social CRM Systems on A Scoping Study"
 E  & %3 .    3K   HW *   I &  E "  1'/ .3/

Q .) 6 ^ $ ." %3 "3  " Y9- %3 " & ( 7+ .-

^ $   (4) /  6 " P %3 7+ .-  E -  5 " 

7+ .-  E 2 E  E "  .& .* 8< %3  & (7) 5 .)

7+   " I  %3 5& 4)& 7+ .-  E 2  *#3$ " & (

"   * & " 0 " & I  5 .-  Y '/ #<  & (

./ &( & 


37

"The Emergence of The Social Media :$ - .(O'Brien, 2011) :" 
Empowered consumer "
7+ .-  E  % & ( * & . HR& ^  I & "  1'/ .3/

"<&J   & 6 - 6 ."  .  %3 :& /<  ")&

0 &J 5 .) E   " :&  . . 5 & 

(7)  "&  P0&  + & . "H "  * '/ %3  ( 

.  J&( " &  * . L& - * K E  E "  1'/ .& - ..

" 2  .- *& *0& %3   . 1'/ &   % & ( * &

.0 "23  + 5 "- " %3 73 H$ 0  7+ & 6  + 

"CRM 2:0 With In :$ - 8(Anshari, Amunawer, & Low, 2012) :" 
E-Health Systems: Towards Achieving Health Literacy & Customer
Satisfaction"
" " X0  %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E H$ "3  "  1'/ .3/

R H - 6 ." " J  /# & c  "    ++&

 "& "  " . 6 4  %3 " .   .<& #  ]

E  )<&   " Q E "  1'/ .& - .% I2  c (366)

" & ( " " 2$  + / . &(  % & (   " & ( .

 . &( P ' c  " .   E * .)& 1'/  J&  K

.. 1'/  "9 -9


38

"Social Customer Relationship :$ - 8(Nadeem, 2012) :" 


Management (SCRM): How Connecting Social Analytics to Business
Analytics Enhances Customer Care and Loyalty?"
%3 % & ( * & .  J&  " & 7 <  I &  E "  1'/ .3/

0& $ .)  .9& 6 & "  I /$ :)& c L  7+ " J ++&

.) (Bain) "  . $ 6 & .( %3  Jo H ^ J$ .  .W

+ (1056)  "7)& .  (Barey) ^ $   "  7+  + (3000) 5

 "  "  * K *  (351)  ^ J$ "  . $ "<&J .9- . 

( ++& " & ( 7+ .-  E E  E 6 *& .(8   $) " 

"  .& .0 * K * *-    &/       " J & 7+

. ( :)& % &  7+ " J %3 +  & % & ( * & . E  E S#$

"Customer $ - 8(Anshari, Munawar, & Patrick, 2012) :" 


Empowerment In Healthcare Organization Through CRM 2:0 Survey
Results From Brunei Taking A Future Path In E-Health Research"
" & ( 7+ .-  E *JE "  R # .-& "3  "  1'/ .3/

.<&  "  5 & & ." " +  .<&  " .W %3

"  "  0+& & "&  R H - 6 4  " %3 " + 

"  1'/ .& ." + %<2  #  I2  c (366)  "&

. E  # :<&  0& "J .    9 #< # E 

." & ( " 2  +  E  % & (   " & (
39

"Elucidating social customer behavior :$ - 8( Galib, 2013) :" 


through the social behavioral model: An empirical investigation in social
CRM
/ -  HW& %& *  & : 9   & ( 7+ P 0< 1'/ .3/

.(& .( ;L ) %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E X  %3 " & ( "  

% & (    . &(  .& * , 6 - "  I /$ :)& * 

7+  E "  1'/ .& - .(305) / ) "7  "  % & ( * & .

/ 3& %& Z7J P ' "H .)&  5& & *  % & ( * & .  J&

.-  K 7+  J& %3   & "  9J   J&(  *J " 0

." & ( 7+

"A new Strategy For Customer Engagement: :$ - 8(Dutot, 2013) :" 
How Do French"
& %3 0 J& " E " & ( 7+ .-  E *& & "  1'/ .3/

6 - "  I /$ :)&  .% & ( * & .  J& 7+ 5 .-

.9- %3 * & " 3 "  (40)  / .) *J  * =+ *& ,

" & ( 7+ .-  E * 7+ . &  %  ]  "<&J "  & "

2 E  "  1'/ .& - ..  1'/ 7+  "7  "  ] *J 

 &/ P / " & ( 7+ .-  E 2  & <& ^  " < . 

" & ( 7+ .-  E 2  J& *  " < .  7+  "  "Q 

.0 0& &  E "  5 * & %3


40

" A CRM System For Social Media" :$ - ,( Ajmera , etal., 2013 ) :" 
  5&&  .    &   * $ " 2 4E  &  E "  1'/ .3/

- 6 .03 " & "  5 & % & ( * & .  7+ .(& 

"3#K "H (10385) .H   P 8<  J&  .H , 6

.-  E . -  - / & #$ P 8<  "  (63593) .L .   E

" & ( 7+ .-  E 2  & E  E "  1'/ .& ." & ( 7+

.  $ 5 7+ " & "  5 & 7+ 5 * & *0&  E 4W

.0  I    S  I &  07 .  "

"CRM Systems with Social :‫ !) ان‬B 3 ،(Wang, Dugan, & Sujka, 2013) :" 
Networks Capabilities: The Value of Incorporating A CRM 2:0 Systems In
Sales/Marketing Education"
." ( .  %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E '<& HR& ^ 8) "  1'/ .3/

2B (Public Midwestern University) "  9  L "   "  5 & &

(43) / [   "  "  0+& "&  , 6 - 6 ،‫ة‬H!<‫(ت ا‬7GE‫ا‬

‫ن‬E‫(و‬H7 DFA‫ إن ا‬W‫ ارا إ‬XFTE1‫ و‬."  %3 .  :& ) "<&J *   9

.-  E 2 E "9 )& "  0& %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E Y"‫د‬

+<& .(&( %3   "9 " & %  ++   % & ( 7+

." 
41

"The Influence of Social Media $ - ،( Clark & Melancon,2013) :" 
Investment on Relation Outcomes :A Relationship marketing perspective"
" E 7+ 5 .-  %3 % & ( * & . H$ 8) "  1'/ .3/

/'< &J  "-  H&  +  % & ( * & . . J& 6 0 "23

& .( %3 3  " : 9  Y9& , H - . (  # 

7+  + (144)  "  " .& 6 (Regional Magazine) " (

.& :)& % & ( * & . E  E "  .& - "<&J " $ . 

7+ # .& 53 & "-  %3  . & :)& "-  H& %3 " 

." 2  % (  *-& % &  % (  P '  ( 

"Elucidating social customer behavior :$ - 8( Galib, 2013) :" 


through the social behavioral model: An empirical investigation in social
CRM
/ -  HW& %& *  & : 9   & ( 7+ P 0< 1'/ .3/

- "  I /$ :)& *   ." & ( 7+ .-  E X  %3 " & ( "  

% & (    . &(  0   ") .    &( "&  & 6

 %3 "<&J .9- %3 * & .  7+  "7  "  % & ( * & .

7+  E "  1'/ .& - .(305) "  " .L 6 & .( ;L

/ 3& %& Z7J P ' "H .)&  5& & *  % & ( * & .  J&

.-  K 7+  J& %3   & "  9J   J&(  *J " 0

." & ( 7+


42

"An Exploratory Study on the Use :‫ !) ان‬B 3 ،(Rocha ,etal., 2013) ::‫درا‬
Social Networks In Building Customer Relationship"

%3 " & ( . ^  "+  .   J& " E *& "  1'/ .3/

"HH  "  .  *  "  , 6 - .7+ 5 + & .- :)&

"9 .  Y9- " & K .  Y9- = .  Y9- %/ "<&J .9-

%3 &J  :&   '<&  5 .) , 6 - 6   

. & (  = .  E "  1'/ .& - ..  1'/ %3 7+ .-  E

.7+ . J  .  )& " - - / & " & ( . J&&   "9 

"CRM to social CRM: the :$ - ,(Choudhyry, & Harrigan, 2014) :" 
integration of new technologies into customer relationship management" .
:& . 2 %9L " & ( 7+ .-  K ='  5#  E "  1'/ .3/

7+ .-  E $ 7+  -  "& "- 0< "   

+ %3 :&    :&   '<&  "  1'/ .  ." & (

.% & (    0  & .& (1000)  "  " .& 6 "7 " $

H   7+ .-    &  7+   & H$    "  .&

 %3 7+ .-   .-  .  .   7+ .-     &

.7+ .-   7+ P  H 4 & 


43

“From E-CRM to S-CRM: :$ - 8(Harrigan, & Miles, 2014) :" 
Critical Factors Underpinning The Social CRM Activities of SMEs”
7+ .-   "9 0 )& %&  HW *   I "  1'/ .3/

6 & " ; %3 "9&   L .   "  5 & & ." & (

%<2  I2 (165)  " "  % & (    J& Y9& &

.  "  " J&& "9&   L .    X7& .& .. 

(%44) P3 (%50) : (%55) && (%65) "  % & ( * &

)& *  "   %  *& I (%24) *) I&0 .)9& (%41) &

." & ( 7+ .-   "9 0

" Empowering customers in :$ - 8(Almunawer, & Anshari, 2014) :" 
electronic health (e-health)through Social Customer Relationship
Management”
*J  " & ( " " . J  *  7+  & "  1'/ .3/

 R ") .    &( 6 - ." & ( 7+ .-  E  J&

%3 " " +  .   ^  .<& 7+ %<2  +& - &

 E E "  1'/ .& .%7K *& "  "& (366) /  6 4 

5 c  " "W  c  "- ='   )& " & ( 7+ .-

.   * " E  E "3#K #  + & " J ) 2 '/    Jb

."9 "W  ")H  ( :J " 0


44

CRM/ Social Media Technology: :$ - 8(Rodriguez, etal., 2014) :" 
Impact on Customer Process and Organization Sales Performance”
7+ .-    & X  *J  +   &  *& "  1'/ .3/

%3 "  .   .  5 & & ..  :)& %3 % & ( * & .

  (1, 966)  "&  "  "  Y9& , 6 - & .(

.& .% & (    0   & 9 *J  P ' .  %3 . 

 &  % E * HW& % & ( * & . 7+ .-     "  1'/

..    E HW& /  %&  7+ 

“Social media Technology Usage and :$ - 8(Trainor, etal., 2014) :" 
Customer Relationship Performance: A Capabilities-Based Examination of
Social CRM”
7+ .-    % & ( * & .  J& I&( "  1'/ .3/

.7+ .-  :)& " & ( 7+ .-   . -  +  +&

6 " ( & .( %3 "<&J . %3 * & .   "  5 & &

.& .(B2C) (B2B) Y  .      (1200) "  " .L

 $ (B2C) * .  %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  "-   " 

4 ( 2  "  "- P / " & ( 7+ .-   . - 5 (B2B)

7+ .-   . - % & ( * & .  & +  +&

.7+ .-   % & ( * & . . ) "  "- " & (
45

"6     "  301 ##  :(3.3.2)

%3 v / Y# *&& "  "  0 ") .   "  1'/ + && .1

.. &(    &  J&   &  

+ && %&  %- .       " "   0& /$ "  1'/  && .2

P ' & & W&   9  + & "<3 %&  9&   %-  & 

.7+ .-  E % & ( * & . . -  J&

  %3 "J .   "  1'/ . &/   "<&J .7 ") .  . & .3

 ."/(   "   ( "   9 :  "  %/ ZJ   

"  "- ++& 9& %3   & E   % & ( * & . E

.] *  .L&  'E 0&9


46

/! +?+

T "6#(

"++++++++6 :(1 + 3)

"  U*$ :(2 + 3)

*$#  "  = :(3 + 3)

"  "$# % "#9# E :(4 + 3)

'& 4' -  "   :(5 + 3)

"  "#-T "& :(6 + 3)

*! "   5 :(7 + 3)


47

"++++++++6 :(1 . 3)

7+ .-  E $ %3 % & ( * & . H$   E "  "  .3/

 #F& % F *< 3  "J "  .  "9 2 "0   "  " 

. $ "F  "F  F3K "3 L  . L& I 0& "& "  " 0

: Z3 P ' " J& "7K .   .   *   " 

.0&H "   $

"  U*$ :(2 . 3)

 E Y  4 2 q ]  #& 4'  "& "< "  "  "  &

5F  ) *J  %  6  4 2 9K  "  .     5

.*&  %3 "  I /$ :)& " 7 .   .

*$#  "  = :(3 . 3)

[‫ق ا\و‬8‫(") ا‬J$ F^<!<‫ وا‬T(R‫ ا‬K‫(")(ت ا\رد‬J‫ ا‬DF_ B(‫ آ‬#" ‫ ارا‬Z<!J" ‫ن‬E;!7

،‫(ت‬a)"(J‫ ا‬aDF_ WaFI K(D!a‫( ا‬400) Za7‫ز‬E!$ bac(D‫(م ا‬+ bc ،F‫ه‬G‫<(ن ا‬I )"(?‫اء و‬G‫و?(") ا‬

Sa; K(D!a‫( ا‬125) ‫<)ل‬$ ،2(fcG‫ ا‬SFH!F >H(T K(D!‫( ا‬375) ‫(ت ا<!دة‬K(D!G‫د ا‬I XK(‫وآ‬

.‫(ت‬K(D!‫( ا‬375) XKE;1 (P3‫ ارا ا‬3I ‫(ن‬B 2(!($‫ و‬،)"(?


48

"  "$# % "#9# E :(4 + 3)

(8;3)  (7;3) (6;3) (5;3) (4;3) (3;3) (2;3) (1;3) * FF ]FF#&

w%F  X F   w   w 9 "  w8 ) "  "  3 "3 L  Z7J

.("  w"   :& ( d & w"  

&F F   '  / "  "  3$  %60.3 $ (1;3) * ]# 'E

.6K  / %39.7

(1;3) *
8 L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#

(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬


60.3 226 ‫ر‬E‫ذآ‬
j3J‫ا‬
39.7 149 ‫(ث‬K‫إ‬
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

F %80.8 $ (2;3) *  "#  X7& . )3 9 "  L&  :&  

.<2  / %19.2 &   Q <&  / "  "  3$

(2;3) *
 9 "  L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#

(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬


80.8 303 ‫غ‬Q!"
m(A‫( ا‬c
19.2 72 :nE"
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬
49

a &&  / "  "  3$  %95.7 $ (3;3) * X7& . )3   L& " 

." 34  E 25  /  $ a &&  / "  "  3$  %4.3 $ " 24  E 18  /  $

(3;3) *
 L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#

(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬


95.7 359 3 24 –3 18 #"
4.3 16 3 34 –3 25 #"
<)‫ا‬
- - 3 44 –3 35 #"
- - ^‫&آ‬B 3 45
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

$ & )3 (4;3) *  ]# /   %  X   L&  :&  

"  3  %11.2 $ 8   X   )&  / "  "  3$  %88.8

. &  X   )&  / " 

(4;3) *
%  X   L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#

(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬


88.8 333 ‫س‬E7‫ر‬E(;$
2‫ ارا‬Y"(KD‫ا‬
11.2 42 !?("
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

 %33.3 $ & )3 (5;3) *  ]# /   "  L&  :&  

/ "  "  3  %33.3 $ 9 :  "   )&  / "  "  3$


50

 / "  "  3$  %33.3 $ X7& . 02$ S J$  ( "   )& 

."/   "   )&

(5;3) *
"  L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#
(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬
33.3 125 [‫ق ا\و‬8‫ا‬
33.3 125 ‫اء‬G‫ا‬ )"(J‫ا‬
33.3 125 F‫<(ن ا\ه‬I
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

 %51.5 $ & )3 (6;3) *  ]# /   "   :& ( d & L& " 

"  "  3  %19.2 $ 2014; 2013   * *<  )&  / "  "  3$

)&  "  "  3 " $ X7& .   2014; 2013   %H *<  )&  /

)&  / "  "  3  %13.9 $ %15.5 %/ 2015 – 2014   * *< 

.2015 – 2014   %H *< 

(6;3) *
"   :& ( d & L&  "  "  3$ 5+& ]#
(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬
51.5 193 2015 - 2014 2K(^‫ ا‬SfQ‫ا‬
19.2 72 2015 - 2014 ‫ ا\ول‬SfQ‫ا‬ )"(J($ ‫(ق‬H!G‫ ا‬p7‫(ر‬1
15.5 58 2014 - 2013 2K(^‫ ا‬SfQ‫ا‬
13.9 52 2014 - 2013 ‫ ا\ول‬SfQ‫ا‬
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

"  3 "7 "   ]# (7;3) * 3 " L&  9&   

." *  03    " 


51

(7- 3) ‫ول‬J‫ا‬
F;‫ "!  ا‬mc ‫ ارا‬3I ‫اد‬B‫ أ‬Z7‫ز‬E1 qrE7
(%) 7Eg<‫ ا‬D3‫ا‬ ‫ا!;ار‬ gQ‫ا‬  !<‫ا‬
12.8 48 ‫م‬EF)‫داب وا‬t‫ا‬
- - ‫ق‬EMH‫ا‬
48.8 183 ‫<(ل‬I\‫ا‬
18.1 68 ‫"(ت‬EF)<‫?( ا‬EE3;1 F;‫ا‬
- - 7E$!‫م ا‬EF)‫ا‬
20.3 76 *<f!‫ وا)<(رة وا‬3P‫ا‬
- - ‫'م‬Iu‫ا‬
- - f‫ا‬
100 375 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

'& 4' -  "   :(5 + 3)

: / .  5 $    J&  E 6 R "  I /$ :)&

.   E "  4 2 9K "  %3 6  & 6 "#$! 

.()  .   "- . ' "   "  5  & %3 *H && %&  "H

5-  %3 " 9  6  "  Y# . & %& ") .   6    )& 

8  I & "  %3 "H      6 I/  ."<&J . &(

.H %& .  & Jo   & 'J$ P ' .  "& %3 "  "  : 9 

."  "  .# %3


52

. 5  E   & "  Y# "&   "  "#% 

  .  %&  "  "7  R / 9& 6 - %& "&( *J  " 

8)  J& & 0 " K H - %&  0&7$ "  I /$ . .  

 J& & *& c Q ." " /$ " E * .'J$ 6 Likert Scale % J . 

Amos Ver.21  *& X   SPSS Ver.21 %7K X  

:%/  + $ "HH  %  0 "&K . #&

(7) *J  "  "  3 "3 L  Z7J  ZJ + :% 

:& ( d & w"   w%  X    w   w 9 "  w8 ) %/ . L&

 "  3$ " &( . ) c E "  " I c L ("  w"  

."3 L  Z7J # %3 "  Y# . L&

7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &  7+   & 8)  #& :$! 

: * .   0& )3 9& %3 6  &  +  +& 4 K 2 

(Reinhold, & Alt, 2009; Henning-Thurau, etal., 2010; Wiliams, & Chinn, 2010;

Gummerus, Lijander, Wemen, & Pihlstrom, 2012; Tseng, & Su, 2013; Kabadyi,
& Price, 2014; Choudhury, & Harrigan, 2014; Trainor, Andulis, Rapp, &
Agnihotri, 2014)

:%&b   " ) . )< . 0)  )3 (18). #&

+& 4 K 2 %3 " J&   & " 7+   &


53

+  7+ .-  E

4 10 4 . )< 
18 - 15 14 - 5 4- 1 . )< & &

%/ "7 $ "HH " & ( 7+ .-  E . - 8)  #& :/! 

"3    . )3 9& %3 6  &  (" &( w.   w+ *<&  E)

"J "  .  %3 "  .-  5 07 , 6 - .)  &(

: * .    &( " &(  + *<&  E  9& &  3

(Srinivasan, & Moorman, 2005; Wang, & Feng, 2012; Trainor, Andulis, Rapp, &

Agnihotri, 2014).

:%&b   " ) . )< . 0) . )3 (10). #&

.-  E . -
" &( "3   + *<&  E
" & ( 7+
3 4 3 . )< 
28-26 25-22 21-19 . )< & &

( "9 # )  / 7  7+ .- $ 8)  #& := 

(Cronin, Brady, & Huil, : * .    &( 9& %3 6  &  ("9

2000; Helegesen, & Nesset, 2007; Blocker, Flint, Myers, & Slater, 2011)
54

:%&b   " ) . )< . 0) . )3 (6). #&

7+ ( 7+ # 7+ .- $

3 3 . )< 
34-32 31-29 . )< & &

"  "#-T "& :(6 + 3)

‫م‬EF)F (fcu‫ از" ا‬W‫ إ‬bc(D‫& ا‬J (P1(rB ‫(ر‬D!v‫ ارا وإ‬Fg‫ أ‬#I $(?w
SPSS - #78)‫(دي وا‬H‫ار ا‬Tu‫ ا‬Statistical Package for Social Sciences I(<!?u‫ا‬
:(!‫ ا‬m(\‫ ا‬yDA!$ >'v #" bc(D‫(م ا‬+ +‫ ـ و‬Ver.21

( Sekaran & Bougie, 2010):3<z!<‫ وا‬،2QTE‫(ء ا‬fcu‫ ا‬m(‫أ‬

2B ‫(س ا<)!<ة‬M‫ات ا‬U=" 7H1 ‫ف‬P$ Frequencies & Percent 7Eg<‫ ا‬m3‫ ا!;ارات وا‬
.(ًB‫|ا‬E<7‫ د‬SFH!‫ وا‬37()<‫ة ا‬c‫(} و‬fv SFH1‫ارا و‬
#I SFH!‫ وا‬37()<‫ة ا‬c‫اد و‬B‫ أ‬$(J!‫ى إ‬E!" 7H! Arithmetic Mean $(H‫(ت ا‬AE!<‫ ا‬
.(P1‫"! ا‬
37()<‫ة ا‬c‫اد و‬B‫(ت أ‬$(J!‫ إ‬I(D1 ?‫(س در‬M Standard Deviation ‫اف ا<)(ري‬HKu‫ ا‬
.2$(H‫( ا‬PA‫ و‬#I SFH!‫وا‬

(ًMB‫> و‬$(!c‫* إ‬1 ‫ واي‬،‫ى ا\ه< <! ات ارا‬E!" ‫(س‬M$ 2zM1 2!‫ وا‬gQ‫ل ا‬E_ ‫ ")(د‬
:(!‫<)(د ا‬F
55

:‫ن‬E;7 €‫ ذ‬WFI ‫(ء‬3$‫و‬


2.33 #" S+‫ أ‬F 1 #" zQR3<‫ا\ه< ا‬

3.67 7(  F 2.34 #" AE!<‫ا\ه< ا‬

5 "L .3.68 #" )Q1<‫ا\ه< ا‬

:" #&  % (&K K  $

:&K )  ("&( ) "   $ .H 8) (Cronbach Alpha) < $ y  *  

."&( . )3  . K "-  "  .0 %J 

(Tolerance) a  & &J  (Variance Inflation Factor) & J#& *  

.")& . L&  (Multicollinearity) 9& "&     R&

 " H$  :)& P ' (Multiple Regression Analysis) & K *& 

.  5& L&  ")& . L&

*)& L& HR& & Amos Ver.21 X    J& (Path Analysis)  *& 

.(SEM) "0 .( ='    9 L&   5& 


56

*! "   5 :(7 + 3)

‫ي‬4‫ه‬8‫&ق ا‬F‫أ( ا‬

"70 #$  '&$ (2)  .< R&    "  "&( c  &

 +  E & (2) - :     $ " & ( * ( J& " &

]#   "70 &  %3 &( = J P ' " ) . &) # %3 *& I'

.(3) - : 

"  3 ! (A

^ 8) (Cronbach Alpha) < $ y  %J  :&( &J  J& 6 -

 -   Q  8) %3   "7 *  H . E %3 :&

} (Alpha ≥ 0.60)  * $ (E  Q 0 *   " ) %3 8)

Sekaran & Bougie, ) (


S ) S $  * "K  " K  ")9& " %3

."  1'0 .H  $ X7&  (8;3) *  .(2010


57

(8;3) *

(< $ y  8) ) "&(  %J  :&( .H * 

(Q‫(خ أ‬DK‫< آو‬+ ‫ات‬MQ‫د ا‬I  !<‫ا‬ ‫ت‬


0.640 4 7+   & 1
0.863 10 7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & 2
0.708 4 P 8< 1‫ـ‬2
0.620 3 & 2‫ـ‬2
0.648 3 *) I&0 .)9& 3 ‫ ـ‬2
0.679 4 7+  +& 4 K 2 3
0.834 10 " & ( 7+ .-  E . - 4
0.632 3 + *<&  E 1 ‫ ـ‬4
0.643 4 .   2 ‫ ـ‬4
0.672 3 " &( 3‫ـ‬4
0.676 6 7+ .- $ 5
0.631 3 "9 # 1‫ـ‬5
0.616 3 "9 ( 2 ‫ ـ‬5

 7+   & (0.640)  . & %&  "7 "  . L& .H - (8;3) * ]# 'E

y  . W *& .$  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (0.863)  $

:)&  0& ) * .H *   "    "   E 5& &  1$ (Cronbach Alpha) < $

.(Sekaran & Bougie, 2010) F S)3 "  c Q$


58

= ?

#>?  U$

"++++++++6 :(1 + 4)

"  $# #'- :(2 + 4)

#>  >T $# "  V #'- :(3 + 4)

" 

"  #>  :(4 + 4)


59

"++++++++6 :(1 + 4)

. FL&  "  "  3$ " &( %7K *& X7& *< '/ c &

.9F& *FJ  0& K " b "7K . W c  *J  03 . & %&

F&J *< *&   " " /  "  . L& * "  .3 (  "

.0 * "J "7K .((  "  .# 3

"  $# #'- :(2 + 4)

 ; :(1 + 2 + 4)


.F3 K  " .9&  J&E  E 6 R 7+   & *& I

.F E (1 ; 4) *F ]# 'E .(1 ; 4) *   ]# /    )< " /$ " 

'0 " .9& . & 6 .7+   & " /R ")& .   "  "

4' % J .  8)  (4.688) 1 ) % 9&  (4.901 ; 4.584)  L&

"& ?) A##"  )3   "& %3 .  'E .7+   & 5<& ^&  E 

(4.901) [F % 9&  ""& *6  "# # U  - '  

F 3 (0.324) [F 4 F I   (4.688) [   % 9&  $ /


60

9&   J  " "&  ""& ?)  1 > 4' -"  )< .

4 F I F  (4.688) [ F  %F % 9&  $ / (4.584) %

"0   "  * .  %3 7+   & " /$ ^& $ &  * .(0.648)

.S<&  "  " 2

(1 - 4) ‫?ول‬
#($O($ >?E!‫ى أه< ا‬E!"‫ و‬7‫(ت ا<)(ر‬B‫ا‬HKG‫ وا‬$(H‫(ت ا‬AE!<‫ا‬

& & Sig* "t“ " -


^& I ( 9&
" /$ ^&  7+   & .
" / 4  %
 )< " ( "
 "  <2  
ZQ1" 1 0.000 113.512 0.324 4.901 X   . J * %&7 1
"  0 )& %& " &
%3 "  <2 % 
%& *  *  
ZQ1" 3 0.000 46.328 0.681 4.629 2
X   . J %3 00 
."  0 )& %& " &
* "  <2  &
ZQ1" 2 0.000 48.076 0.659 4.637 3
%&9 5 
  &/ *#3$  *
ZQ1" 4 0.000 47.327 0.648 4.584 4
"  %<2
<#& .-$  - ( 
ZQ1" - 0.000 97.403 0.335 4.688
 ;'
.(1.648) (α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  (t) " -
.(3) [    )< %# &3( 9  E &( "  (t) " -  &
61

    "  #$ :(2 + 2 + 4)

F  & "F /R ")& .   "  " . E (2 ; 4) * ]#

F "F7 . L&  " .9& . & 6 .7+ .-  E %3 " J&

F E F 4' % J .  8)  (4.381) 1 ) % 9&  (4.502 ; 4.121)

F F  "& %3  'E .7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & 5<& ^&

(4.381) [   % 9&  $ / (4.502) [ % 9&  "D W#?"

9&   J  "H H "&  "A+##"  *  3 .(0.396) [ 4  I  

4 F I F  (4.381) [ F  %F % 9&  $ / (4.121) %

%F3 7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & " /$ ^& $ &  * .(0.930)

.S<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * . 


(2 ; 4) *
7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & " /$ ^&  "  .3 (  " .9&
& & Sig*
^& "t“ " - I ( 9&  E %3 " J&   &
" /$ ^& ‫ت‬
" / " 4  % 7+ .-
 )< " (
$ 4'   5' 
4' "& " =#>
ZQ1" 3 0.000 36.270 0.783 4.466 5
W#? 4' "&' "#  "-?
D
4'   =  ^ 
ZQ1" 2 0.000 44.812 0.690 4.597 W#? 4' "&' "#  "-? 6
D
   "     4' -
ZQ1" 4 0.000 27.578 0.878 4.250 4' "&' "#  "-? 4' 7
D W#?
 '& "'(   $#
ZQ1" 1 0.000 52.174 0.628 4.693 8
U  - *-
62

"#  "-? 4' "# #


."&'

ZQ1" 1 0.000 73.271 0.396 4.502 ‫  ك‬G'H‫ا‬


< 59) & /
ZQ1" 2 0.000 20.168 1.121 4.168 "  .9 "J 9
&  0& 3
< 59)  & :$
ZQ1" 3 0.000 19.187 0.990 3.981 0&  "   "J 10
&  0& 3
"J < 59) P &
ZQ1" 1 0.000 22.784 1.033 4.216 )& %& .9  . <  11
%7 + 5 "  0

ZQ1" 3 0.000 23.351 0.930 4.121 A##


 % & *) I&0 .)9&
ZQ1" 2 0.000 32.940 0.802 4.365  + 4 %3 "  5 * & 12
 
%3 %7 + 5 " < * &
ZQ1" 1 0.000 71.295 0.475 4.749 .)9&  J& "  13
*) I&0  " & (
 % & *) I&0 .)9&
ZQ1" 3 0.000 28.359 0.904 4.325 14
" < "  5 %&   

ZQ1" 2 0.000 49.854 0.574 4.480 6$ .* 6#(


<#& .-$  - ( 
ZQ1" - 0.000 59.842 0.447 4.381   "  #$'
 
.(1.648) (α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I ‫و‬J‫( ا‬t) <+
.(3) ƒ(D‫ة وا‬MQF 2r‫!ا‬BG‫[ ا‬E‫ ا‬W‫(د إ‬3!G($ ‫و‬J‫( ا‬t) <+ ‫(ب‬c *1

‫ ا‬12! *34‫داري ا‬6‫م ا‬8)‫ ا‬:(3 ‫ ـ‬2 ‫ ـ‬4)


.9F&  J&E  E 6 R 7+  +& 4 K 2 *& I

* ]# 'E .(3 ; 4) *   ]# /    )< " /$ "  .3 K  "
63

.7F+  +& 4 K 2 " /R ")& .   "  " . E (3 ; 4)

1 F) %F 9&  (4.752 ; 4.637)  L& '0 " .9& . & 6

 +& 4 K 2 5<& ^&  E  4' % J .  8)  (4.698)

[F %F 9&  ""& 1 - $$ &"  )3   "& %3 .  'E .7+

(0.537) [ 4  I   (4.698) [   % 9&  $ / (4.752)

"F "F& F " +# 1 ##6 " "& $'"  )< .  3

(4.698) [ F  %F %F 9F&  $ / (4.637) % 9&   J 

7+  +& 4 K 2 " /$ ^& $ &  * .(0.553) 4  I  

.S<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * .  %3

(3 - 4) ‫?ول‬
#($O‫ ا‬WFI O;1<‫داري ا‬u‫„(م ا‬3‫ى أه< ا‬E!"‫ و‬7‫(ت ا<)(ر‬B‫ا‬HKG‫ وا‬$(H‫(ت ا‬AE!<‫ا‬
& & Sig*
^& "t“ " - I ( 9&  +& 4 K 2
" /$ ^& ‫ت‬
" / " 4  % 7+
 )< " (
ZQ1" 1 0.000 63.154 .5370 4.752 "   &/  %  15
)& "   "  % +&
ZQ1" 4 0.000 57.260 0.553 4.637 16
% & / 
 " P& & " 
%& + &  W< . )
ZQ1" 3 0.000 66.739 0.485 4.674 17
5 *<&  * &  % &
" < 0<2
+& & "  "  
ZQ1" 2 0.000 72.556 0.461 4.730 18
%& & "&  % *

ZQ1" - 0.000 119.795 0.274 4.698 <#& .-$  - ( 
64

 4'  <T )$'


.(1.648) (α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I ‫و‬J‫( ا‬t) <+
.(3) ƒ(D‫ة وا‬MQF 2r‫!ا‬BG‫[ ا‬E‫ ا‬W‫(د إ‬3!G($ ‫و‬J‫( ا‬t) <+ ‫(ب‬c *1
"#      :(4 + 2 + 4)

 E . F- "F /R ")& .   "  " . E (4 ; 4) * ]#

; 3.458)  "7 . L&  " .9& . & 6 ." & ( 7+ .-

^&F F E F 4' % J .  8)  (4.256) 1 ) % 9&  (4.700

" +'& $"    "& %3  'E ." & ( 7+ .-  E . ) 5<&

I F  (4.256) [ F  % 9&  $ / (4.700) [ % 9& 

%F 9F&   J  "H H "&  "" "  *  3 .(0.303) [ 4 

.(0.475) 4 F I F  (4.256) [   % % 9&  $ / (3.458)

*F .F  %F3 " & ( 7+ .-  E . - " /$ ^& $ &  *

.S<&  "  " 2 "0   " 

(4 ; 4) *
" & ( 7+ .-  E . - " /$ ^&  "  .3 (  " .9&
& & Sig*
^& "t“ " - I ( 9& 7+ .-  E . -
" /$ ^& ‫ت‬
" / " 4  % " & (
 )< " (
  4' "& )-
ZQ1" 2 0.000 66.732 .4780 4.648     8& 3 $! 19
.  
?) = ")$ - <
ZQ1" 3 0.000 29.665 0.508 3.778     "& 20
. 
ZQ1" 1 0.000 187.294 0.202 4.957 1 "& ?) )-# 21
65

.& #  4'  #

ZQ1" 2 0.000 108.092 0.261 4.461   ? 


%& .   *
   "   0 &
 / Q *9  * &
ZQ1" 1 0.000 115.777 0.315 4.888 22
"  5-   J& *J
.  "   "J
% & ( * &
0 * %& .   :H
ZQ1" 2 0.000 94.764 0.374 4.832 * & . *J  23
% & (
"J %& * % 
ZQ1" 4 0.000 25.638 0.958 4.269 .  J& *J  24
% & ( * &
 .  c  *
5-    J( 2(
ZQ1" 3 0.000 90.001 0.390 4.813 25
% & ( * & .
"  

ZQ1" 1 0.000 108.689 0.303 4.700 '& $


- "#&? A#  "&
 "#'6  "#- Z
ZQ1" 1 0.000 28.385 0.496 3.728 26
 #?) = * $ #
   
 V' "#&? "  #
[E!" 2 0.000 11.091 0.842 3.482    *  27
 
#& 4' "#&? "  #
 4' * AZ 
[E!" 3 0.001 3.311 0.967 3.165    8"# # U 28
   *#6
 

[E!" 3 0.000 18.668 0.475 3.458 " 


ZQ1" - 0.000 117.315 0.207 4.256 <#& .-$  - ( 
66

   6


"# 
.(1.648) (α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  (t) " -
.(3) [    )< %# &3( 9  E &( "  (t) " -  &

   :(5 + 2 + 4)

.F- $ "F /R ")& .   "  " . E (5 ; 4) * ]#

9F&  (4.732 ; 4.601)  "7 . L&  " .9& . & 6 .7+

.F-  5<& ^&  E  4' % J .  8)  (4.667) 1 ) %

F $ / (4.732) [ % 9&  " "    "& %3  'E .7+

+>"  *  3 .(0.296) [ 4  I   (4.667) [   % 9&

%F 9F&  $ / (4.601) % 9&   J  "H "&  "

 E $ " /$ ^& $ &  * .(0.388) 4  I   (4.667) [   %

.S<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * .  %3 7+ .-

(5 ; 4) *
7+ .- $ " /$ ^&  "  .3 (  " .9&
& & Sig*
^& "t“ " - I ( 9&
" /$ ^& 7+ .- $ .
" / " 4  %
 )< " (
- 4'J&( a& ( 
ZQ1" 2 0.000 53.001 0.564 4.544 29
"  1'/ %3 * &
. J  #  
ZQ1" 3 0.000 47.477 0.611 4.498 30
"  0 )& %&
 " J *#3  *
ZQ1" 1 0.000 78.968 0.432 4.762 31
"  %<2
67

ZQ1" 2 0.000 79.782 0.388 4.601 7+ #


%3 * &   J( %
ZQ1" 3 0.000 59.296 0.519 4.589 32
"  1'/
 * & - 4  
ZQ1" 2 0.000 65.969 0.496 4.690 33
"  1'/ %3 .  ^ J
1'/ %3 &( 4
ZQ1" 1 0.000 134.649 0.275 4.917 34
" 
ZQ1" 1 0.000 113.248 0.296 4.732 7+ (
<#& .-$  - ( 
ZQ1" - 0.000 111.387 0.289 4.667
  %
.(1.648) (α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  (t) " -
.(3) [    )< %# &3( 9  E &( "  (t) " -  &

"  #>  >T $# "  V #'- :(3 + 4)

cF ,F 6F - "  .# 3 &JK K *& :9& %3  *-

F  R& & 'E  K *& .# &3K . "   # * $  P ' . &JK

F& J#F& *F   J&, Multicollinearity ")& . L&  *


„  9& E  

F FL& * Tolerance  a  & &JE (VIF) Variance Inflation Factor

$ .(10) " ) (VIF)  a  & J#& *  + &   5 "  . L&

.(Devlin, & Roeder, 1999) (0.20)  $ Tolerance  a  & " - &

*  &, Normal Distribution %9 5+& . Y&E  S #$ R& &

F *F)& & K *  " - . 'E %9 5+& 5&& . E 'E Skewness & K

(Sekaran & Bougie, 2010) .. &JK 1'/ X7&  (6; 4) - *  (±1)
68

(6 ; 4) *
& ( *    a  &  & J#& &J X7&
Skewness Tolerance VIF ‫ ا‬FM!<‫ا<! ات ا‬ ‫ت‬
-0.453 0.984 1.016 #($O($ >?E!‫ا‬ 1
-0.493 0.990 1.010 #($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫ إدارة‬2B "R!<‫?( ا‬EE3;!‫ا‬ 2
-0.693 0.985 1.015 ‫ن‬E$O‫ ا‬WFI O;1<‫داري ا‬u‫„(م ا‬3‫ا‬ 3

& %9J *J &    (6 ; 4) * %3   X7&  ]#&

 E %3 " J&   & w7+   & ) ")& . L&  Multicollinearity

*  &JE  - P ' W  E (+  +& 4 K 2 w7+ .-

.-  E %3 " J&   & w7+   & ) F "H & q (VIF) & J#&

% &  (1.015 w 1.010 w 1.016) "L   (+  +& 4 K 2 w7+

 . & (Tolerance)  a  & &JE - $ ]#&   .(10)  *)& %& 

 *
„  9& E     S W '/  (0.20)  $ %/ (0.990 ; 0.984)

& ( *  &, %9 5+& 5&& . $  R& & - .")& . L&

..(Devlin, & Roeder, 1999) (±1)  *-$ ) . 6 (Skewness)

E *)& L& $  %9J *J &     R&  )&   SR&

%3 "  .# 3 &JE  K ]$ )3 %9 5+& 5#J& "  . L& .

."  * "  * . 


‫‪69‬‬

‫)‪"  #>  :(4 + 4‬‬

‫?>‪HO1 4% " # "#‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %F3 " J‬‬ ‫(   ‪  &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$‬‬

‫ ‪"  .‬‬ ‫‪%3 7+ .-‬‬ ‫&‪ :)& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫‪.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J‬‬

‫&   ‪7+‬‬ ‫& &)‪H$  :‬‬ ‫(‪( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J‬‬

‫&‪:)& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫ &  ‬

‫ ‪.(7 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .‬‬ ‫ ‪%3 7+ .-‬‬

‫?ول )‪(7 - 4‬‬


‫‪ Y(!K‬ا‪(D!v‬ر ‪ SFH1‬ا‪HKG‬ار ا<!)د !&‪ %‬ا!‪ #($O($ >?E‬وا!;‪ (?EE3‬ا<!‪ 2B "R‬ادارة ‪(+'I‬ت ا‪ #($O‬وا‪(„3‬م ا‪G‬داري‬
‫ا<‪ WFI O;1‬ا‪E$O‬ن ‪ yMH1 2B‬اداء ‪(+'I‬ت ا‪ 2B #($O‬ا‪()"(J‬ت ا\رد‪ K‬ا‪T(R‬‬
‫‪Adjusted‬‬
‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬
‫‪T‬‬ ‫‪DF‬‬ ‫‪F‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬ ‫)‪(R‬‬
‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪Beta‬‬ ‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪O-=-‬‬ ‫ا ;'‪ 4‬ا ‪L‬‬
‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫درت ا ‪4‬‬ ‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫‪ O-=-‬ا &&‬ ‫ا(ر‪N3‬ط‬
‫ا&(‬ ‫ا&(‬ ‫ا &&‬
‫ا=&ل‬

‫ا ‬ ‫‪#$‬‬


‫‪0.000‬‬ ‫‪4.855‬‬ ‫‪0.229‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫ا<‪Z"(J‬‬
‫ا *)  '‬
‫ا‪-&. /‬‬ ‫اداء‬
‫‪0.000‬‬ ‫‪5.432‬‬ ‫‪0.256‬‬ ‫‪ +,‬إدارة‬ ‫‪0.000 371‬‬ ‫ا‪ED‬ا‪2+‬‬ ‫‪28.445‬‬ ‫‪0.180‬‬ ‫‪0.187‬‬ ‫‪0.432‬‬ ‫‪(+'I‬ت‬
‫! ت‬
‫ا‬ ‫ا‪#($O‬‬
‫ا)‪8‬م‬
‫ا‪6‬داري‬
‫‪0.000‬‬ ‫‪4.373‬‬ ‫‪0.206‬‬ ‫ا‪12! *34‬‬ ‫ا<‪E<J‬ع ‪374‬‬
‫ا ن‬
70

(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & H$ (7 ; 4) * ]#

"  .  %3 7+ .- $ :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

7F+  F & "7FE "F ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E ."J

:F)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

^&  (0.432) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J "  .  %3 7+ .- 

%3 . L&  (0.187) & -  $ 4$ (0.187) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05)

  &  7+   & %3 L&  X& "J "  .  %3 7+ .- $

. 02$ & ' : %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

^&F 8  / (0.180) [ - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7&

4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/ %3

%F3 7F+ .- $  " & "  9J -  ZJ&  +  +&

(0.256)  7F+   & (0.229) β HR& "  " - .L   ."J "  . 

.F+  +& 4 ( 2 (0.206)  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   &

%3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/

7+ .- $ %3 +  E 4W +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-  

" J&F   & (0.256)  7+   & (0.229) " ) "J "  .  %3

HR& '/ " W .+  +& 4 ( 2 (0.206)  7+ .-  E %3
71

F FW '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (28.445) .L %&  " F " -

"F# < *F)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &    "7 "# < *- "

: Z& %& "

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

"  .  %3 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J

2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & HR&  :)& 

"  .  %3 7+ .-  . L&  L& *  +  +& 4 (

:%   & 3 &# 3  E   "7 "# < "7+ & & "J

HO1-1 4% "# ? "#>?

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$   (

"J "  .  %3 7+ # :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^& 

7+   & H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

:)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

.(8 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .  %3 7+ #


72

(8 G 4) 
4'  < )$     "  #$  ; #!Y & -$ #'-  U$
" "#$% &   > 5#6-  
Adjusted
Sig* Sig* (R2)
T DF F (R2) (R)
‫ ى‬/- Beta ‫ ى‬/- O-=- L ‫ ا‬4'; ‫ا‬
 / ‫ا‬ 4 ‫درت ا‬  / ‫ا‬ && ‫ ا‬O-=- ‫ط‬N3‫ا(ر‬
(&‫ا‬ (&‫ا‬ && ‫ا‬
‫ا=&ل‬

 ‫ا‬ #$
0.000 4.406 0.211  3 Z"(J<‫ا‬
'  )* ‫ا‬
-&. /‫ا‬
0.000 6.468 0.308 ‫ إدارة‬+, 2+‫ا‬ED‫ا‬ (r‫ر‬
0.000 371 24.584 0.159 0.166 0.407
‫! ت‬ #($O‫ا‬
‫ا‬
‫م‬8)‫ا‬
‫داري‬6‫ا‬
0.057 -1.908 -0.091 12! *34‫ا‬ 374 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬
‫ا ن‬
(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & H$ (8 ; 4) * ]#

."J "  .  %3 7+ # :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

F  &  7F+  F & "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E

[F 'E "J "  .  %3 7+ # :)& %3 7+ .-   %3 " J&

4$ (0.166) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α≤0.05) ^&  (0.407) R 9& ( * 

L&  X& "J "  .  %3 7+ # %3 . L&  (0.166) & -  $

X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & %3

%3 ^& 8  / (0.159) [ - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *&

F- F ZJ&F  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/

"F  "F - .L   ."J "  .  %3 7+ #  " & "  9J
73

.7F+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (0.308)  7+   & (0.211) β HR&

%3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/

"F ) "FJ "F  .F  %3 7+ # %3 +  E 4W 7+ .-  

FW .7F+ .F-  E %3 " J&   & (0.308)  7+   & (0.211)

.(α ≤ 0.05) ^&F  "  %/ (24.584) .L %&  " F " - HR& '/ "

(" <F ) "F  "# < c3 &    " < "# < *- "  W '/

: Z& %& " "# < *)&

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 7+ # :)& %3 7+

HO1-2 "#$! "# ? "#>?

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$   (

"J "  .  %3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^& 

7+   & H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

:)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

.(9 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .  %3 7+ (


74

(9 - 4) ‫&ول‬
‫ ا ن‬12! *34‫م ا(داري ا‬8)‫ ادارة ! ت ا وا‬+, -&. /‫ ا   وا *)  ' ا‬4'TU  ‫ &ار ا =&د‬V(‫ ا‬O'2 3 ‫ر‬N W‫ ا‬X V
Z.‫' ا‬V‫=ت ا[رد‬-\‫ ا‬+, ‫ و(ء ا‬Y'< 3 +,
Adjusted
Sig* Sig* (R2)
T DF F ( R 2) (R)
‫ ى‬/- Beta ‫ ى‬/- O-=- L ‫ ا‬4'; ‫ا‬
 / ‫ا‬ 4 ‫درت ا‬  / ‫ ا && ا‬O-=- ‫ط‬N3‫ا(ر‬
(&‫ا‬ (&‫ا‬ && ‫ا‬
‫ا=&ل‬

 ‫ا‬ #$
0.000 3.534 0.172  3 Z"(J<‫ا‬
'  )* ‫ا‬
-&. /‫ا‬
0.050 1.970 0.096 ‫ إدارة‬+, 2+‫ا‬ED‫ا‬ ‫ء‬G‫و‬
0.000 371 19.479 0.129 0.136 0.369
‫! ت‬ #($O‫ا‬
‫ا‬
‫م‬8)‫ا‬
‫داري‬6‫ا‬
0.000 5.840 0.284 12! *34‫ا‬ 374 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬
‫ا ن‬
(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & H$ (9 ; 4) * ]#

."J "  .  %3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

F  &  7F+  F & "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E

%3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

F $ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&F  (0.369) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J "  . 

%F3 7+ ( %3 . L&  (0.136) & -  $ 4$ (0.136) [ )3 R2 & * 

  %F3 " J&F   &  7+   & %3 L&  X& "J "  . 

$ *F& X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-

F &/ %3 ^& 8  / (0.129) [ - Adjusted R2 * & * 

F +F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & 
75

"F  .F  %F3 7+ (  " & "  9J -  ZJ&  +

F  & (0.096)  7F+  F & (0.172) β HRF& "F  " - .L   ."J

$ % '/ .+  +& 4 ( 2 (0.284)  7+ .-  E %3 " J&

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/K ^& %3   "  +

"  .  %3 7+ ( %3 +  E 4W +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (0.096)  7+   & (0.172) " ) "J

%&  " F " - HR& '/ " W .+  +& 4 ( 2 (0.284) 

"7 "# < *- "  W '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (19.479) .L

: Z& %& " "# < *)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &  "H

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

"J "  .  %3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^& 

HO2 "#$! " # "#>?

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$   (

%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

7+   & H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

++& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 
‫‪76‬‬

‫ ‪4) *  ]# /   "J "  .‬‬ ‫‪%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . -‬‬

‫; ‪.(10‬‬
‫&ول )‪(10 - 4‬‬
‫‪ X V‬ا‪N W‬ر ‪ O'2 3‬ا(‪& V‬ار ا =&د  ‪ 4'TU‬ا   وا *)  ' ا‪ +, -&. /‬ادارة ! ت ا وا)‪8‬م ا(داري ا‪ 12! *34‬ا ن‬
‫‪& =3 +,‬رات ادارة ! ت ا ا( !' ‪ +,‬ا\‪=-‬ت ا[رد‪ 'V‬ا‪Z.‬‬
‫‪Adjusted‬‬
‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬
‫‪T‬‬ ‫‪DF‬‬ ‫‪F‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬ ‫)‪(R‬‬
‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪Beta‬‬ ‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪O-=-‬‬ ‫ا ;'‪ 4‬ا ‪L‬‬
‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫درت ا ‪4‬‬ ‫‪ O-=-‬ا && ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫ا(ر‪N3‬ط‬
‫ا&(‬ ‫ا&(‬ ‫ا &&‬
‫ا=&ل‬

‫ا ‬ ‫‪#$‬‬


‫‪0.534‬‬ ‫‪.623‬‬ ‫‪0.029‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫ا<‪Z"(J‬‬
‫ا *)  '‬ ‫‪+‬رات‬
‫ا‪-&. /‬‬ ‫ادارة‬
‫‪0.000‬‬ ‫‪9.476‬‬ ‫‪0.439‬‬ ‫‪ +,‬إدارة‬
‫‪0.000 371‬‬ ‫ا‪ED‬ا‪2+‬‬ ‫‪33.553‬‬ ‫‪0.207‬‬ ‫‪0.213‬‬ ‫‪0.462‬‬ ‫‪(+'I‬ت‬
‫! ت‬
‫ا‬ ‫ا‪#($O‬‬
‫ا)‪8‬م‬ ‫ا‪I(<!?G‬‬
‫ا‪6‬داري‬
‫‪0.008‬‬ ‫‪2.655‬‬ ‫‪0.123‬‬ ‫ا‪12! *34‬‬ ‫ا<‪E<J‬ع ‪374‬‬
‫ا ن‬
‫*‪E;7‬ن ا!&‪ %‬ذا د‪ G‬إ‪E!" 3I (fc‬ى )‪(α ≤ 0.05‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫&   ‪  &  7+‬‬ ‫* )‪H$ (10 ; 4‬‬ ‫‪]#‬‬

‫&‪%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫ ‪"7FE "F ( 4' HRF&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E ."J "  .‬‬

‫&‪+F+& %F3 +  +‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫&  ‬

‫ ‪R 9F& ( *  [ 'E "J "  .‬‬ ‫‪%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . -‬‬

‫)‪F& - F $ 4$ (0.213) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  (0.462‬‬

‫ ‪"F  .F‬‬ ‫)‪%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 . L&  (0.213‬‬

‫&‪+‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫‪  & %3 L&  X& "J‬‬
77

- Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 + 

.F-   %F3 " J&   &   &/ %3 ^& 8  / (0.207) [

F "F & "  9J -  ZJ&  +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

HR& "  " - .L   ."J "  .  %3 " & ( 7+ .-   . -

+F& 4 ( 2 (0.123)  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (0.439) β

%F3 " J&F   &   &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/ .+ 

  . - ++& %3 +  E 4W +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-  

%3 " J&   & (0.439) " ) "J "  .  %3 " & ( 7+ .-

HRF& '/ " W .+  +& 4 ( 2 (0.123)  7+ .-  E

F FW '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (33.553) .L %&  " F " -

"F# < *F)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &  "H "7 "# < *- "

: Z& %& "

F2  7F+ .F-   %3 " J&   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.F  %F3 "F & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 +  +& 4 (

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J " 

2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & HR&  :)& 

7F+ .F-   . F- ++& . L&  L& *  +  +& 4 (
‫‪78‬‬

‫‪.F# 3 "FHH  E "H "7‬‬ ‫ ‪"# < "7+ & & "J "  .‬‬ ‫( & " ‪%3‬‬

‫‪:%   " 3‬‬

‫?>‪HO2-1 4% "# ? "#‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %F3 " J‬‬ ‫(   ‪  &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$‬‬

‫ ‪"F  .‬‬ ‫&‪%3 + *<&   ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫‪.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J‬‬

‫&   ‪7+‬‬ ‫& &)‪H$  :‬‬ ‫(‪( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J‬‬

‫&‪++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫ &  ‬

‫ ‪.(11 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .‬‬ ‫  &<* ‪%3 +‬‬


‫&ول )‪(11 - 4‬‬
‫‪ X V‬ا‪N W‬ر ‪ O'2 3‬ا(‪& V‬ار ا =&د  ‪ 4'TU‬ا   وا *)  ' ا‪ +, -&. /‬ادارة ! ت ا وا)‪8‬م ا(داري ا‪ 12! *34‬ا ن‬
‫‪ =3 +,‬ادارة ‪ O!H3‬ا ن ‪ +,‬ا\‪=-‬ت ا[رد‪ 'V‬ا‪Z.‬‬
‫‪Adjusted‬‬
‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬
‫‪T‬‬ ‫‪DF‬‬ ‫‪F‬‬ ‫)‪( R 2‬‬ ‫)‪(R‬‬
‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪Beta‬‬ ‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪O-=-‬‬ ‫ا ;'‪ 4‬ا ‪L‬‬
‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫درت ا ‪4‬‬ ‫‪ O-=-‬ا && ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫ا(ر‪N3‬ط‬
‫ا&(‬ ‫ا&(‬ ‫ا &&‬
‫ا=&ل‬

‫ا ‬ ‫‪#$‬‬


‫‪0.410‬‬ ‫‪- 0.825‬‬ ‫‪-0.043‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫ا<‪Z"(J‬‬
‫ا *)  '‬
‫ا‪-&. /‬‬
‫‪ +,‬إدارة‬ ‫ا‪ED‬ا‪2+‬‬ ‫ادارة ‪SI(Q1‬‬
‫‪0.050‬‬ ‫‪-1.966‬‬ ‫‪- 0.102‬‬
‫! ت‬
‫‪0.194 371‬‬ ‫‪1.581‬‬ ‫‪0.005‬‬ ‫‪0.013‬‬ ‫‪0.112‬‬ ‫ا‪E$O‬ن‬
‫ا‬
‫ا)‪8‬م‬
‫ا‪6‬داري‬
‫‪0.494‬‬ ‫‪0.685‬‬ ‫‪0.036‬‬ ‫ا‪12! *34‬‬ ‫ا<‪E<J‬ع ‪374‬‬
‫ا ن‬
‫*‪E;7‬ن ا!&‪ %‬ذا د‪ G‬إ‪E!" 3I (fc‬ى )‪(α ≤ 0.05‬‬
‫&‪.F-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫&   ‪  &  7+‬‬ ‫* )‪H$ (11 ; 4‬‬ ‫‪]#‬‬

‫ ‪"F  .‬‬ ‫&‪%3 + *<&   ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬
79

7F+  F & "7E " ( 4' HR&    %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E ."J

+F+& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

^&  (0.112) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J "  .  %3 + *<&  

%3 . L&  (0.013) & -  $ 4$ (0.013) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05)

7F+  F & %F3 FL&  X& "J "  .  %3 + *<&   ++&

: %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

F F/ (0.005) [ - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7& . 02$ & '

" & "  9J -  ZJ&  ")& . L&   &/ %3 ^& 8

(;0.043) β HRF& "  " - .L   ."J "  .  %3 + *<&   

F2 (0.036)  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (; 0.102)  7+   &

F &  F &/K ^&F %3   "  + $ % '/ .+  +& 4 (

4W +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+ 

F & (;0.043) "F ) "J "  .  %3 + *<&   ++& %3 "&  E

4 ( 2 (0.036)  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (;0.102)  7+ 

%F/ (1.581) .L %&  " F " - HR& '/ "  W .+  +&

*F)&    " < "# < *- " W '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  Q

: Z& %& "  "# <


‫‪80‬‬

‫&‪.-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫   &‪  &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR‬‬

‫ ‪"F  .‬‬ ‫&‪%3 + *<&   ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫‪.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J‬‬

‫?>‪HO2-2 "#$! "# ? "#‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %F3 " J‬‬ ‫(   ‪  &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$‬‬

‫ ‪ "J "  .‬‬ ‫ ‪%3 .‬‬ ‫&‪ %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫&^ ( " )‪.(α ≤ 0.05‬‬

‫&   ‪7+‬‬ ‫& &)‪H$  :‬‬ ‫(‪( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J‬‬

‫&‪ %3 +  +‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫ &  ‬

‫ ‪.(12 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .‬‬ ‫ ‪%3 .‬‬


‫&ول )‪(12 - 4‬‬
‫‪ X V‬ا‪N W‬ر ‪ O'2 3‬ا(‪& V‬ار ا =&د  ‪ 4'TU‬ا   وا *)  ' ا‪ +, -&. /‬ادارة ! ت ا وا)‪8‬م ا(داري ا‪ 12! *34‬ا ن‬
‫‪ 4]V +,‬ا=‪ +, ,4‬ا\‪=-‬ت ا[رد‪ 'V‬ا‪Z.‬‬
‫‪Adjusted‬‬
‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫)‪( R 2‬‬
‫‪T‬‬ ‫‪DF‬‬ ‫‪F‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬ ‫)‪(R‬‬
‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪Beta‬‬ ‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪O-=-‬‬ ‫ا ;'‪ 4‬ا ‪L‬‬
‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫درت ا ‪4‬‬ ‫‪ O-=-‬ا && ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫ا(ر‪N3‬ط‬
‫ا&(‬ ‫ا&(‬ ‫ا &&‬
‫ا=&ل‬

‫ا ‬ ‫'‬


‫‪0.109‬‬ ‫‪-1.605‬‬ ‫‪-0.065‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫ا\‪L'-‬‬
‫ا *)  '‬
‫ا‪-&. /‬‬
‫‪0.000 15.178‬‬ ‫‪0.613‬‬ ‫‪ +,‬إدارة‬ ‫ا‪ N‬ا‪+‬‬ ‫‪8K‬‬
‫! ت‬
‫‪0.000 371‬‬ ‫‪82.571‬‬ ‫‪0.396‬‬ ‫‪0.400‬‬ ‫‪0.633‬‬ ‫ا<)‪("EF‬ت‬
‫ا‬
‫ا)‪8‬م‬
‫ا‪6‬داري‬
‫‪0.058‬‬ ‫‪1.901‬‬ ‫‪0.077‬‬ ‫‪374‬‬ ‫ا\ ع‬
‫ا‪12! *34‬‬
‫ا ن‬
‫** ن ا ‪ 4'TU‬ذا د( إ`‪ /- &)! 'F‬ى )‪(α ≤ 0.05‬‬
81

.F-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & H$ (12 ; 4) * ]#

'E ."J "  .  %3 .   %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

  %F3 " J&F F  & "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$

R 9F& ( *F  [F 'E "FJ "  .  %3 .   %3 7+ .-

F& - F $ 4$ (0.400) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  (0.633)

%F3 FL& F X& "J "  .  %3 .   %3 . L&  (0.400)

*F  $ *& X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &

F &/ %3F ^&F 8F F / (0.396) [ - Adjusted R2 * &

 " & "  9J -  ZJ&  7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & 

  & (0.613) β HR& "  " - .L   ."J "  .  %3 .  

F &/K ^&F %F3 F  "  + $ % '/ .7+ .-  E %3 " J&

.F  %3 .   %3 +  E 4W 7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

'/ " W .7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & (0.613) " ) "J " 

FW '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (82.571) .L %&  " F " - HR&

"# < *)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &  "H " < "# < *- " 

: Z& %& "

F %F3 7F+ .-   %3 " J&   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 . 


‫‪82‬‬

‫?>‪HO2-3 "!! "# ? "#‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %F3 " J‬‬ ‫(   ‪  &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$‬‬

‫ ‪^&  "  .‬‬ ‫&‪%3 " &( ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫( " )‪.(α ≤ 0.05‬‬

‫&   ‪7+‬‬ ‫& &)‪H$  :‬‬ ‫(‪( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J‬‬

‫&‪++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫&‪4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫ &  ‬

‫ ‪.(13 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .‬‬ ‫(& " ‪%3‬‬


‫&ول )‪(13 - 4‬‬
‫‪ X V‬ا‪N W‬ر ‪ O'2 3‬ا(‪& V‬ار ا =&د  ‪ 4'TU‬ا   وا *)  ' ا‪ +, -&. /‬ادارة ! ت ا وا)‪8‬م ا(داري ا‪ 12! *34‬ا ن‬
‫‪ =3 +,‬ا(‪ +, \ :‬ا\‪=-‬ت ا[رد‪ 'V‬ا‪Z.‬‬
‫‪Adjusted‬‬
‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫*‪Sig‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬
‫‪T‬‬ ‫‪DF‬‬ ‫‪F‬‬ ‫)‪(R2‬‬ ‫)‪(R‬‬
‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪Beta‬‬ ‫‪ /-‬ى‬ ‫‪O-=-‬‬ ‫ا ;'‪ 4‬ا ‪L‬‬
‫ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫درت ا ‪4‬‬ ‫‪ O-=-‬ا && ا ‪ /‬‬ ‫ا(ر‪N3‬ط‬
‫ا&(‬ ‫ا&(‬ ‫ا &&‬
‫ا=&ل‬

‫ا ‬ ‫‪#$‬‬


‫‪0.018‬‬ ‫‪2.369‬‬ ‫‪0.121‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫ا<‪Z"(J‬‬
‫ا *)  '‬
‫ا‪-&. /‬‬
‫‪0.001‬‬ ‫‪3.389‬‬ ‫‪0.172‬‬ ‫‪ +,‬إدارة‬ ‫ا‪ED‬ا‪2+‬‬ ‫‪O7O)1‬‬
‫! ت‬
‫‪0.000 371‬‬ ‫‪6.494‬‬ ‫‪0.042‬‬ ‫‪0.050‬‬ ‫‪0.223‬‬ ‫ا‪$(J!G‬‬
‫ا‬
‫ا)‪8‬م‬
‫ا‪6‬داري‬
‫‪0.066‬‬ ‫‪1.843‬‬ ‫‪0.094‬‬ ‫ا‪12! *34‬‬ ‫ا<‪E<J‬ع ‪374‬‬
‫ا ن‬
‫*‪E;7‬ن ا!&‪ %‬ذا د‪ G‬إ‪E!" 3I (fc‬ى )‪(α ≤ 0.05‬‬

‫&‪.F-   %3 " J‬‬ ‫&   ‪  &  7+‬‬ ‫* )‪H$ (13 ; 4‬‬ ‫‪]#‬‬

‫&‪%3 " & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 +  +‬‬ ‫‪4 ( 2  7+‬‬

‫ ‪ & "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E ."J "  .‬‬
83

"  .  %3 " &( ++& %3 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+ 

[ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α≤0.05) ^&  (0.223) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J

"F  .F  %F3 " &( ++& %3 . L&  (0.050) & -  $ 4$ (0.050)

%F3 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & %3 L&  X& "J

/ (0.042) [ - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7& . 02$ & ' :

.F-  E %F3 " J&F   &  7+   &   &/ %3 ^& 8 

"F  .  %3 " &( ++&  " & "  9J -  ZJ&  7+

F  & (0.172)  7F+  F & (0.121) β HRF& "F  " - .L   ."J

 &   &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/ .7+ .-  E %3 " J&

%F3 " &( ++& %3 +  E 4W 7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+ 

%F3 " J&   & (0.172)  7+   & (0.121) " ) "J "  . 

"F  %/ (6.494) .L %&  " F " - HR& '/ " W .7+ .-  E

"# < c3 &  "H H " < "# < *- "  W '/ .(α≤0.05) ^& 

: Z& %& " "# < *)& (" < ) " 

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 " &( %3 7+
84

HO3 "!! " # "#>?

+ *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . ) "7E " ( ' H$   (

 "J "  .  %3  7+ .-  :)& %3 (" &(  .  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&

.-   . - H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

.- $ :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+

.(14 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .  %3  7+

(14 - 4) ‫?ول‬
‫(")(ت‬J‫ ا‬2B #" #($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫ اداء‬yMH1 2B I(<!?G‫ ا‬#($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫رات ادارة‬+ %&! ‫ار ا<!)د‬HKG‫ ا‬SFH1 ‫(ر‬D!v‫ ا‬Y(!K
T(R‫ ا‬K‫ا\رد‬
Adjusted
Sig* Sig* (R2)
T DF F ( R 2) (R)
‫ ى‬/- Beta ‫ ى‬/- O-=- L ‫ ا‬4'; ‫ا‬
 / ‫ا‬ 4 ‫درت ا‬  / ‫ا‬ && ‫ ا‬O-=- ‫ط‬N3‫ا(ر‬
(&‫ا‬ (&‫ا‬ && ‫ا‬
‫ا=&ل‬

O!H3 ‫إدارة‬ #$


0.335 0.965 0.048 ‫ا ن‬ 3 Z"(J<‫ا‬
‫أداء‬
4]V
0.000 7.039 0.350 ‫ت‬- 2=‫ا‬ 0.000 371 2+‫ا‬ED‫ا‬ 18.759 0.125 0.132 0.363 ‫(ت‬+'I
#($O‫ا‬
0.310 1.016 0.051 \ :(‫ا‬ 374 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*

*F<&   ) "F & ( 7F+ .-   . - H$ (14 ; 4) * ]#

"F  .  %3  7+ .-  :)& %3 (" &(  .   +

%F3 .F   "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E ."J

 (0.363) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J "  .  %3 7+ .-  :)&
85

F (0.132) F& - F $ 4$ (0.132) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&

 %3 L&  X& "J "  .  %3  7+ .-  :)& %3 . L&

[ - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 . 

F9J -  ZJ&  .    &/ %3 ^& 8  / (0.042)

"F  "F - .L   ."J "  .  %3 7+ .-   " & " 

F  &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/ ..   (0.350) β HR&

"F ) "FJ "F  .F  %3  7+ .-  :)& %3  E 4W . 

^&  "  %/ (18.759) .L %&  " F " - HR& '/ " W .(0.350)

"F  "# < c3 &  "H H "7 "# < *- "  W '/ .(α ≤ 0.05)

: Z& %& " "# < *)& (" < )

%F3 F 7F+ .-  :)& %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

F F+ *F<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . - HR&  :)& 

"F  .F  %3 7+ .-  . L&  L& *  (" &(  . 

:%   & 3 &# 3  E "H H "7 "# < "7+ & & "J

HO3-1 4 "# ? "#>?

+ *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . ) "7E " ( ' H$   (

 "J "  .  %3  7+ # :)& %3 (" &(  .  
86

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&

.-   . - H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

 7+ # :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+

.(15 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .  %3


(15 - 4) ‫&ول‬
Z.‫' ا‬V‫=ت ا[رد‬-\‫ ا‬+, - ‫ ا‬b‫ ر‬Y'< 3 +, '! (‫ &رات ادارة ! ت ا ا‬4'TU  ‫ &ار ا =&د‬V(‫ ا‬O'2 3 ‫ر‬N W‫ ا‬X V
Adjusted
Sig* Sig* (R2)
T DF F ( R 2) (R)
‫ ى‬/- Beta ‫ ى‬/- O-=- L ‫ ا‬4'; ‫ا‬
 / ‫ا‬ 4 ‫درت ا‬  / ‫ا‬ && ‫ ا‬O-=- ‫ط‬N3‫ا(ر‬
(&‫ا‬ (&‫ا‬ && ‫ا‬
‫ا=&ل‬

O!H3 ‫إدارة‬ #$


0.167 1.385 0.066 ‫ا ن‬ 3 Z"(J<‫ا‬
4]V (r‫ر‬
0.000 8.421 0.403 0.000 371 2+‫ا‬ED‫ا‬ 30.139 0.189 0.196 0.443
‫ت‬- 2=‫ا‬ #($O‫ا‬

0.091 -1.694 -0.082 \ :(‫ا‬ 374 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*

*F<&   ) "F & ( 7F+ .-   . - H$ (15 ; 4) * ]#

."J "  .  %3  7+ # :)& %3 (" &(  .   +

# :)& %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E

α ≤ ) ^&  (0.443) R 9& ( *  [ 'E "J "  .  %3  7+

:)& %3 . L&  (0.196) & -  $ 4$ (0.196) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(0.05

:F %F3 .   %3 L&  X& "J "  .  %3  7+ #

F F/ (0.189) [F - Adjusted R2 * & *  $ *& X7& . 02$ & '

 " & "  9J -  ZJ&  .    &/ %3 ^& 8
87

F (0.403) β HRF& "F  "F - .L   ."J "  .  %3 7+ #

%F3  E 4W .    &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/ .. 

HRF& '/ " W .(0.403) " ) "J "  .  %3  7+ # :)&

F FW '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (30.139) .L %&  " F " -

"F# < *F)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &    " < "# < *- "

: Z& %& "

.F  %F3  7+ # :)& %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J " 

HO3-2 "#$! "# ? "#>?

+ *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . ) "7E " ( ' H$   (

^&F  "J "  .  %3 7+ ( :)& %3 (" &(  .  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " (

.-   . - H$  :)& & ( *&  J& & "# < 1'/ &J(

 7+ ( :)& %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+

.(16 ; 4) *  ]# /   "J "  .  %3


88

(16 - 4) ‫&ول‬
Z.‫' ا‬V‫=ت ا[رد‬-\‫ ا‬+, - ‫ و(ء ا‬Y'< 3 +, '! (‫ &رات ادارة ! ت ا ا‬4'TU  ‫ &ار ا =&د‬V(‫ ا‬O'2 3 ‫ر‬N W‫ ا‬X V
Adjusted
Sig* Sig* (R2)
T DF F ( R 2) (R)
‫ ى‬/- Beta ‫ ى‬/- O-=- L ‫ ا‬4'; ‫ا‬
 / ‫ا‬ 4 ‫درت ا‬  / ‫ ا && ا‬O-=- ‫ط‬N3‫ا(ر‬
(&‫ا‬ (&‫ا‬ && ‫ا‬
‫ا=&ل‬

O!H3 ‫إدارة‬ #$


0.001 3.479 0.180 ‫ا ن‬ 3 Z"(J<‫ا‬
4]V ‫ء‬G‫و‬
0.003 3.003 0.156 0.000 371 2+‫ا‬ED‫ا‬ 6.700 0.044 0.051 0.227
‫ت‬- 2=‫ا‬ #($O‫ا‬

0.885 0.145 0.008 \ :(‫ا‬ 374 ‫ع‬E<J<‫ا‬

(α ≤ 0.05) ‫ى‬E!" 3I (fc‫ إ‬G‫ ذا د‬%&!‫ن ا‬E;7*


*F<&   ) "F & ( 7F+ .-   . - H$ (16 ; 4) * ]#

."J "  .  %3  7+ ( :)& %3 (" &(  .   +

F F+ *F<&  ( "7E " ( 4' HR&   %7K *& X7& . 02$ 'E

R 9F& ( *F  [ 'E "J "  .  %3  7+ ( :)& %3 . 

F& - F $ 4$ (0.051) [ )3 R2 & *   $ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  (0.227)

%3 L&  X& "J "  .  %3  7+ ( :)& %3 . L&  (0.051)

F& *F  $ *& X7& . 02$ & ' : %3 .   + *<&  E

*F<&  ,F  &/ %3 ^& 8  / (0.189) [ - Adjusted R2 *

%F3 7F+ ( F "F & "  9J -  ZJ&  .   +

 7F+ *F<&  K (0.180) β HRF& "F  " - .L   ."J "  . 

*F<&  ,F  &/K ^& %3   "  + $ % '/ ..   (0.156)
89

" ) "J "  .  %3  7+ ( :)& %3  E 4W .   7+

F "F - HRF& 'F/ " W ..   (0.156)  7+ *<&  K (0.180)

*F- "  W '/ .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  "  %/ (6.700) .L %&  "

Z& %& " "# < *)& (" < ) "  "# < c3 &  "H " < "# <

:

.F  %F3  7+ ( :)& %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&  

(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J " 

HO4 "& " # "#>?

.F-   %F3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$   (

( 7F+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

.F  F + *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . -   (7+

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 (" &( 

Amos X    J& Path Analysis  *& "&( & "# < 1'/ &J(

HR&    :)& P ' SPSS " & (  "7K " + X    Ver. 21

F +F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &

.F-   . F-   (7+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +

"F  .F  %F3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+

.(17 F 4) *  ]# /   "J


90

F  &  7F+  F & HRF&  *& X7& (17 F 4) * ]# 'E

 :F)& %F3 (F1) +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&

" & ( 7+ .-   . -   (F2) (7+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-

."J "  .  %3 (F3) (" &(  .   + *<&   )

F  .(α ≤ 0.05) ^&  " ( . ' %/ (51.952) " Chi2 " - .L 'E

"F - " - *    %/ %&  Minimum Discrepancy &   " - .L

a F&- 6F F "  ^& 8  / (3.056) DF "  .   Chi2

F (2) " )   a && $ c &<  &   " - $ (Arbuckle, 2008)

"F  W / (GFI) Goodness of Fit Index " - .L .$  (5) " )  $

[ : 8< .(" & "  ) ]   " -  E  ) /  (0.967) & -  

"F - F E  ) /  (0.924) (CFI) Comparative Fit Index  ) "  W

Root Mean Square Error % )& R9J 5 9& ' W " - .L .]  

F HRF& [ - . < " ) " - %/ (0.074) (RMSEA) of Approximation

F +F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &

  / (0.500) (7+ ( 7+ # )  7+ .-  :)& %3 +

+F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & $  E

,3 % &  (7+ ( 7+ # )  7+ .-  :)& %3 HW + 

4 ( F2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &   &/( +
91

( 7F+ F# ) F 7+ .-  %3 HR&  & R  +  +&

7F+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   &  HR& [   .(7+

  ) 1FR " & ( 7+ .-   . -  +  +& 4 ( 2 

  / (0.500) "J "  .  %3 (" &(  .   + *<&

+F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & $  E

F + *<&   ) 1R " & ( 7+ .-   . -  H + 

7+   &   &/( + ,3 % &  "J "  .  %3 (" &(  . 

RF F 7+  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

F F+ *F<&   ) 1FR " & ( 7+ .-   . -  HR&  &

  . F) HRF& [F : . ' ."J "  .  %3 (" &(  . 

 %F3 (" &F(  .   + *<&   ) 1R " & ( 7+ .-

/ (0.414) "J "  .  %3 (7+ ( 7+ # )  7+ .-

F F+ *F<&   ) 1FR " & ( 7+ .-   . - $  E  

%F3 (7F+ ( 7F+ # )  7+ .-  %3 HW& (" &(  . 

"F & ( 7F+ .-   . )  &/( + ,3 % &  "J "  . 

.F-  %F3 HR&  & R  (" &(  .   + *<&   ) 1R

FQ HRF& [ - ."J "  .  %3 (7+ ( 7+ # )  7+

+F& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & 
92

  . F- F  (7F+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 + 

.F  %F3 (" &F(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-

" & ( 7+ .-   . - & 4'  W  / (0.250) "J " 

%3 9 L&  "J "  .  %3 (" &(  .   + *<&   )

 +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & HR&

.(7+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +

  %3 " J&   &  7+   & ) *   " T " - .L -

%F/  (12.363) (7+ .-   +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-

7F+   & ) %H   " T " - .L  3 (α ≤ 0.05) ^&  " ( . '

. F-  +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & 

  . F-) 6 H   " T " - [ (11.023) (" & ( 7+ .-  

α ≤ ) ^&  " ( . ' %/ (12.511) (7+ .-   " & ( 7+ .-

  %F3 " J&F   &  7+   & S HR& P/ $  E & " & 1'/ (0.05

7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-

F F+ *F<&   ) "F & ( 7F+ .-   . -   (7+ (

F &   &/( + E 'E .9 L& "J "  .  %3 (" &(  . 

%3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+ 

.F  F F+ *F<&   ) "F & ( 7+ .-   . -   *2


93

%F3 (7+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 HR&  & R  (" &( 

*F)&  ."  I /$  + :)& /& "  " & %/ "J "  . 

: Z& %& " "7 "# <

7+ .-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&  

(7+ ( 7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2 

%3 (" &(  .   + *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . -  

.(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 


94
95
96

W ?
# U$

"  U$ :(1.5)

# :(2.5)
97

W ?
# U$

.-  E %3 " J&   &  +   & H$ &  E "  1'/ .3/

 E . -   7+ .- $ :)& %3 +  +& 4 K 2  7+

* %3 . / X7&   E "  1'/ .& - .9 L&  " & ( 7+ .-

.0&# 3 0&7$  " K  "  "

"  U$ " $ :(1.5)

 "  * "J "  .  %3 7+   &  ^& E X7& . .1

.<&  "  " 2 "0 

.-  E %3 " J&   &  ^& E %< *& X7& . $ .2

* "J "  .  %3 (*) I&0 .)9& & P 8< ) 7+

.<&  "  " 2 "0   " 

+  +& 4 K 2  ^& E %7K *& X7& .#$   .3

.<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * "J "  .  %3

" & ( 7+ .-  $ . -  ^& E %7K *& X7& .#$   .4

.<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * "J "  .  %3


98

"J "  .  %3 + *<&  E  ^& %< *& X7& . .5

.<&  "  " 2 "0   "  *

"  .  %3 .    ^& E %7K *& X7& .   .6

.<&  "  " 2 "0   "  * "J

"  * "J "  .  %3 " &(  ^& E "  . 02$   .7

.<&  "  " 2 "0  

* "J "  .  %3 7+ .- $  ^&  "  . .8

.<&  "  " 2 "0   " 

 "  * "J "  .  %3 7+ #  ^&  "  .$ .9

.<&  "  " 2 "0 

 "  * "J "  .  %3 7+ ( ^&  X7& . $ .10

.<&  "  " 2 "0 

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&   .11

.  %3 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

% )"  5 " & 1'/ .)<  (α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J " 

5 .)<&     7+   & HR&    .& %& (2010 "  

+  +& 4 K 2 HR&    .  %&  (Bolton, 2004) " 

 0&  .& 6 (Choudhury, & Harrigan, 2014) "  5 .)<&    
99

.- 5 7+ .-  E %3 " J&   & " E 9& "-   

." ( "  . 2 %3 7+

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&   .12

%3 +  +& 4 K 2 H 4$ &   7+ # :)& %3 7+

(2011  -) "  5 "  1'/ .)<&  (α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  # :)&

.  %3 #  "9   & "7E " ( 4' H    "H .& 6

(Mithas, Krishnan, & Fornell, "  5 .)<&   .  "J " 

5 .)<&  .#  +  +& 4 K 2 HR&    %3 2005)

" E "-   .&H 6 (Abdullateef, Mokhtar, & Yousoff, 2010) " 

.# 5 7+ .-  E  & 7+   &

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&   .13

"  .  %3 7+ ( :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

(Blocker, Flint, & Mayers "  5 .)<&  (α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J

:)& % &  + "<& " - :)& +   &   H *& 6 2011)

(Heller baird, & Patasnis, 2011) "  5 .)<&  ..(&( .  %3 7+ (

‫ء‬G‫ و‬Z" #($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫?( إدارة‬EE3;1 $(J7‫(ط ا‬D1‫ ار‬+'I ‫د‬E?‫ و‬W‫ن ا‬E^c(D‫ ا‬STE1 bc

4 K 2 HR&    .  %&  (Bolton, 2004) "  5 .)<&  .#($O‫ا‬

. (  +  +&


100

+& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3 " J&   & " ( 4' H$   .14

+   & H 4$ &   " & ( 7+ .-   . - ++& %3 + 

" ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 " & ( 7+ .-  E . - 

%&  (Wang, & Fing, 2012) "  5 "  1'/ X7& .<&J  .(α ≤ 0.05)

. - 5 7+  +& 4 K 2   " E 9& "-    .&

( " 3 + & " & ( 7+ .-  E . -   " & ( 7+ .-  E

" 2& *   #$ HR&&   3 7+ .-  E  & HR& " & &

.)<&  " .  %3 +  +& 4 K 2  7+   &  "3)H 

" J&   &  7+   & "  9& "-   %3 "  "  X7& 5

.7+ .-  E . - 5 7+ .-  E %3

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( ' H$   ( .15

"  .  %3 + *<&  E %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

(Wang, & Fing, "  5 "  1'/ .<&J  .(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J

" J&   &  7+   & " E 9& "-    .& %&  2012)

  + *<&  E %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+ .-   %3

.-  E  & +   &  7+ .-  K + &  " -   P&

"   7+ +<&  4W& %&  +  +& 4 K 2  7+
101

"  I & / 3  07 o a 9 *  "  5 *<& %3 " 3  <

.")&  "  0& &

 %3 7+ .-   %3 " J&   & "7E " ( 4' H$   .16

%3 +  +& 4 K 2  +   & H 4$ &   %3 . 

X7& .)<&  (α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 .  

.  6 (Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Angnihotri, 2014) "  5 "  1'/

* & .)"7   &  "H & 7+ .-  E   & H   

"  5 .<&J  " ( & " .  %3 .   %3 (% & (

4 K 2  7+   &   . %&  (Conduit, & Movondo, 2001)

 & ( P ' " &( .  %3 .    HW +  +&

"  7+ .Q  . &  I & %3    4 K 2  + 

"J .   *J  "  *J  %3 0 <&( " E % &  ")& 

.0 " &( " E % &  "   5 %3 .Q  . &(

.-   %3 " J&   &  +   & "7E " ( 4' H$   .17

%3 " &(  +  +& 4 K 2 H 4$ &   " &( %3 7+

"  5 "  1'/ .)<&  (α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  . 

" &(  7+   & % E HR&   . %&  (Martin, & Crbac, 2003)

.  %& (Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Angnihotri, 2014) "  5 .<&J 


102

%3 +  +& 4 K 2  7+ .-  E   & H   

.Q  .  " &(   .& %&  ." ( " .  %3 " &(

. "H & 7+ .-  E  & * &   :)&&    ( 7+

+ &  .    4'  +  +& 4 K 2 5 % & ( * &

% &  " 2  %3 /  7+ ")&  "  . &(  $ *

.0 " &( " E

4$ &   %3 7+ .- $ %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&   .18

α ≤ ) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 " &(  + *<&  K H

H    H *& 6 (Wang, & Feng, 2012) "  5 .<&J  .(0.05

+ *<&  E  " .  %3  5 + *<&  K "7E " ( '

0&Q  0&  "3    * 0 I &  07+ 5 *<&  "   &

%& (Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Angnihotri, 2014) "  5 #$ .<&J 

.   .  & ) " & ( 7+ .-  E . -   . 

/  7+ . & "J .  & "    . 6 (" &( 

)&   7+  "23 *  " & * & 0 " &(  " 2 *J 

*3 $ :)& % &  7+ .Q  .  )3 . &  & " & 1 & . J

.07+ "  .-


103

4$ &   %3 7+ # :)& %3 .   "7E " ( 4' HR&   .19

" ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 # %3 " &(  + *<&  K H

  H *& 6 (Wang, & Feng, 2012) "  5 .<&J  .(α ≤ 0.05)

 7+  &  P ' 7+ # %3  0    & + *<&  E

%<2  ^  "7 a 9 0& J "  . &  "J 3  b a 9

.0 " &(  0 03  " 2  & % &  % & ( * & . *J  " 2

*& 6 (Hampton, & Hampton, 2004) "  5 "  "  X7& I&J 

" + %3 #  % E * HW& 0 " &(  .     H

+& & 0 # :)& %3 HW    & " &( "   P ' "

.c  &  "&  %$ *

7+ ( :)& %3 .   + *<&  K "7E " ( 4' HR&   .20

^&  "J "  .  %3 ( :)& %3 " & H 4$ &   %3

6 (Lings, & Greenley, 2005)"  5 "  1'/ X7& .)<& .(α ≤ 0.05) " (

%3 7+ ( :)& %3 .   %   4- HR&   0&  X7& . 

*& 6 (Sicilia, & Palazon, 2008) "  5 .)<&   .%J  :& . 

5 .<&J  . (  "  %3 7+ ( 5 *<&  K H    H

   " &( "7E " ( 4' H    (Martin, & Crbac, 2003) " 

"  "-  1- H &   * & 7+    "-  6 7+ (
104

+ % &   .  &  4W& 7+   " & 3 % &    

. (

.-   %3 " J&   &  7+   & "7E " ( 4' HR&   .21

7+ # ) 7+ .-  :)& %3 +  +& 4 ( 2  7+

 + *<&   ) " & ( 7+ .-   . -   (7+ (

.)<&  .(α ≤ 0.05) " ( ^&  "J "  .  %3 (" &(  . 

#$ :<&  (Trainor, Andzulis, Rapp, & Angnihotri, 2014) "  5 "  1'/

.(Wang, & Feng, 2012)"  5

#+++++++++ :(2.5)

* & .  "  0&< .   " & ( 5-   "9 P  (1

.9)3 % &  8   K  <2 )& %3 % & (

. J 3& "  1'/ & &  ZJ "H   &  "   &/   # (2

.+ & " &

 J& ^  .  %3   & :9& ^ * .9& "     (3

."9 *-  % & ( * & .

"  "9 .Q  .   I & % & ( * & .  *<&   # (4

..Q  .  1'0 " &( "  ")& 


105

.%3& 0-<& :)& 0&  ++& "   &/   # (5

:6 %  

 E %3 & 4'   % & ( * & . * .   + 

.. 2 $ 7+ .-

.-  E %3 " J&   & ^ J .  * .   + 

 L&(  &&  "  1'/ 0 : 9&&  %&  "J "  .  %3 7+

./ Q   :

  03 % & ( * & .  J&  K ^ J$ .(  # 9& 

."   
106

= " :(6)

"#& = :(1.6)

+  E %3 .   & "3   E " .(2004)     •


<$   '& l "  "7  . Y9- %3 "  "  :"3&
  "&+ "   28;26   &< (& &  "& ) =
. 

U1$ 5( .(2009) * 4+Q "<J    %&  *    %  •
.5+&   :  :  19 .'& /-

. 2  %)&   " & (   & . .(2004) I I9  % + •
Q 1 & " 9$) .^ "23 %3 " J . 2   &J "  :" J
.:  * * "  ( 

" & ( * ( :9&  " J  "J  *  H$ .(2009)     $ •


"  (  Q 1 & " 9$) ."  * ( . 2 %3 "3& + :)&
.    "   

:  .19 .  )$ C$ 4' ; &$ #  ? .(2009)  + 4  •
.5+&   4 + 

..   & " .  2 . .(2008) <9   " /( •
.5+&   :  "W :  19
107

"3& + :%3  * 8 " .(2004) /9 % L  40 ]  4  •


) = <$   '& l "% - &-( *# %3 * ( . 2 
.    "&+ "   28;26   &< (& &  "&

$# #'- * Spss - )$ .(2004) 8 "39 *   %+ •
.  *7   :  ."#-T

"' .":< $  7+ .-  E H$ ".(2010) *7  "   6 % •


.225;201 (4)34  "#  ' "#

  " & " J  H$ ".(2011)   1 -   %   6 % •
 & l “ "J "  .  %3  .  "9 #  I 
." 0 "  "  - +  - + "  .& #'&  > %

.     :  59 .U# "#6#   .(2006) & 4  •

 l #( ##  l ."*)& .& %  & " .(2007)*   •


  &   "  " (  & #- >  & ( & #'&
.  " K

"( .  %3 %)&  &- Y ( "3)H 5-  .(2011)   *# 4   •
"  ) ." L "<# %3 9  "   Y9) '/ %3   2 "0   :"9<
.93 *J *J "  (  Q & 
108

"7 %3 #  7+   & H$ ++& %3 " J   .(2011)   1 - •


  9 :  "  (  Q &  " ) ."J "  . 
. 

:7FF+ ( FF  1 FFH$ 4 &( :FFF& .(2014) 9J /+ •


Q &  "  ) . FF7 +FFF .(FFF& "W "FFF F "FFF 
. 7+ 8    -   "  .( 

"#$% = :(2.6)

• Acker, O., Gröne, F., Akkad, F., Pötscher, F., & Yazbek, R. (2011).
Social CRM: How companies can link into the social web of consumers.
Journal of Direct, Data and Digital Marketing Practice, 13(1), 3-10.

• Ahearne, M., Hughes, D. E., & Schillewaert, N. (2007). Why sales reps
should welcome information technology: Measuring the impact of CRM-based
IT on sales effectiveness. International Journal of Research in Marketing,
24(4), 336–349.

• Ajmera, J., Ahn, H. I., Nagarajan, M., Verma, A., Contractor, D., Dill, S.,
& Denesuk, M. (2013, May). A CRM system for social media: challenges and
experiences. In Proceedings of the 22nd international conference on World
Wide Web (pp. 49-58) (on line), available: http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2488394.

• Alavi, S., Ahuja, V., & Medury, Y. (2012). Metcalfe's law and operational,
analytical and collaborative CRM-using online business communities for co-
creation. Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for
Marketing, 20(1), 35-45.

• Algesheimer, R., Dholakia, U.M., & Herrmann, A. (2005), “The social


influence of brand community: evidence from European car clubs”, Journal
of Marketing,. 69(1),19-34.
109

• Almunawar, M, N., & Anshar, M, (2014). Empowering customers in


electronic health (e-health) through social customer relationship management.
Electronic Customer Relationship Management, 8(1), 87-100.

• Alrubaiee, L., (2013). An investigation on the Relationship between New


Service Development, Market Orientation and Marketing Performance.
European Journal of Business and Management. 5(5),1-27.

• Anshari, M., Almunawar, M. N., Low, P. K., & Al-Mudimigh, A. S.


(2012). Empowering Clients through e-Health in Healthcare Services: Case
Brunei. International quarterly of community health education, 33(2), 189-
219.

• Anshari , M., Almunawar,M.,N., & Low ,P.,K. (2012).CRM 2.0 within E-


Health Systems: Towards Achieving Health Literacy & Customer Satisfaction.
Journal of Development informatics. 1(1), 88-96.

• Anshari, M., Almunawar, M. N., Low, P. K. C., & Wint, Z. (2012).


Customer Empowerment in Healthcare Organisations Through CRM 2.0:
Survey Results from Brunei Tracking a Future Path in E-Health Research.
ASEAS – Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies, 5(1), 139-151.

• Andzulis, J. M., Panagopoulos, N. G., & Rapp, A. (2012). A review of social


media and implications for the sales process. Journal of Personal Selling and
Sales Management, 32(3), 305–316.

• Arnbjerg, M. (2004), Emergence of Mobile CRM in Western Europe –


Vendor Strategies, IDC,Framingham, Massachusetts. USA.

• Askool, S., Nakata, K. (2011). A conceptual model for acceptance of social


CRM systems based on a scoping study. AI & society, 26(3), 205-220.

• Awasthi, P., & S. Sangle, P. (2013). The importance of value and context for
mobile CRM services in banking. Business Process Management Journal,
19(6), 864-891.
110

• Baker, W. E., & Sinkula, J. M. (2009). The Complementary Effects of Market


Orientation and Entrepreneurial Orientation on Profitability in Small
Businesses. Journal of Small Business Management, 47(4), 443-464.

• Berger, P, D., Ruth N. B, Douglas B, Elten B, Kumar,V, Parasuraman, A, &


Terry, C., (2002), Marketing Actions and the Value of Customer Assets: A
Framework for Customer Asset Management, Journal of Service Research, 5
(1), 39-55.

• Bhuian, S. N., Menguc, B., & Bell, S. J. (2005). Just entrepreneurial enough:
the moderating effect of entrepreneurship on the relationship between market
orientation and performance. Journal of business research, 58(1), 9-17.

• Bijmolt, T. H. A., Leeflang, P. S. H., Block, F., Eisenbeiss, M., Hardie, B. G.


S., Lemmens, A., & Saffert, P. (2010). Analytics for customer engagement.
Journal of Service Research, 13 (2), 341–356.

• Blocker, C. P., Flint, D. J., Myers, M. B., & Slater, S. F. (2011). Proactive
customer orientation and its role for creating customer value in global markets.
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 39(2), 216-233.

• Bolton, M., (2004). Customer Centric business processing. International


Journal of productivity. 53(1), 44-51.

• Brown, T.J., Mowen, J., Todd, D., & Licatta, J. (2002), the customer
orientation of service workers: personality trait determinants and effect on self
and supervisor performance ratings, Journal of Marketing Research, 39(1),
110-119.

• Carter, H.L., Foulger, T.S., & Ewbank, A.D. (2008). Have you googled your
teacher lately? Teachers’ use of social networking sites, Phi Delta Kappan,
89(9), 681-695.
111

• Camponovo, G., Pigneur, Y., Rangone, A. and Renga, F. (2005). “Mobile


customer relationship management: an explorative investigation of the Italian
consumer market”, Proceedings of 4th International Conference on Mobile
Business, 11-13 July, Sydney, Australia.

• Chandy, R, K., & Tellis, G, J., (2000). The Incumbent's Curse? Incumbency,
Size, and Radical Product Innovation, Journal of Marketing, 64 (July), 1-17.

• Chatzopoulou, G., Sheng, C., & Faloutsos, M. (2010)." A first step towards
understanding popularity in YouTube". In INFOCOM IEEE Conference on
Computer Communications Workshops, 15-19 March. San Diego. USA.

• Chen, J. S., & Ching, R. K. (2007). "The effects of mobile customer


relationship management on customer loyalty: brand image does matter". 40th
Annual Hawaii International Conference InSystem Sciences, 2007. HICSS
2007. 3-6 January. Grand Hyatt. Hawaii. USA.

• Cho, C.H., Phillips, J.R., Hageman, A.M. and Patten, D.M. (2009). Media
richness, user trust, and perception of corporate social responsibility: an
experimental investigation of visual web site disclosures, Accounting,
Auditing & Accountability Journal, 22(6), 933-952.
• Choudhury, M. M., & Harrigan, P. (2014). CRM to social CRM: the
integration of new technologies into customer relationship management.
Journal of Strategic Marketing, 22(2), 149-176.

• Clark, & Melancon, (2013). The Influence of Social Media Investment on


Relational Outcomes: A Relationship Marketing Perspective. International
Journal of Marketing Studies, 5(4), 132-142

• Coltman, T. R. (2007). Why build a customer relationship management


capability ?. Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 16(3), 301–320.

• Conduit, J., & Mavondo, F. T. (2001). How critical is internal customer


orientation to market orientation?. Journal of business research, 51(1), 11-24.
112

• Cormier, D., Ledoux, M.J. and Magnan, M. (2009). The use of web sites as a
disclosure platform for corporate performance, International Journal of
Accounting Information Systems, 10 (1), 1-24.

• Cronin, J. J., Brady, M. K., & Hult, G. T. M. (2000). Assessing the effects of
quality, value, and customer satisfaction on consumer behavioral intentions in
service environments. Journal of retailing, 76(2), 193-218.

• Day, George S. (2000), Capabilities for Forging Customer Relationships,


MSI Report No. 00-118, Marketing Science Institute. Cambridge: UK.

• Day, G., (2003). Creating a Superior Customer-Relating Capability, MIT


Sloan Management Review, 44 (3), 77-83.

• Deloitte University Press. (2013). Social business study: Shifting out of first
gear. (Online), available: http://dupress.com/articles/social-business-study.

• Deshpande, R., Farley, J.U. & Webster, F.E. (1993). Corporate culture,
customer orientation, and innovativeness in Japanese firms: a Quadrat
analysis. Journal of Marketing, 57(1). 23-7.

• Devlin, B., & Roeder, K. (1999). Genomic control for association studies.
Biometrics, 55(4), 997-1004.

• Dutot, V., (2013).A New Strategy for Customer Engagement: How Do


French Firms Use Social CRM?. International Business Research, 6(9), 54-
67.

• Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) (2007). Beyond loyalty: meeting the


challenge of customer engagement part I, (Online), available
www.adobe.com/engagement/pdfs/partI.pdf.
113

• Eid, R., & El-Gohary, H. (2013). The impact of E-marketing use on small
business enterprises' marketing success. The Service Industries Journal,
33(1), 31-50.

• Galib, M. H. (2013). Elucidating social customer behavior through the


social behavioral model: An empirical investigation in social CRM
(Unpublished Doctoral dissertation), AllIiant International University, San
Diego: USA.

• Ganesh, J., Arnold, M.J., & Reynolds, K.E. (2000). Understanding the
customer base of service providers: an examination of the differences between
switchers and stayers, Journal of Marketing, 64 (3), 65-87.

• Garrido-Moreno, A., & Padilla-Meléndez, A. (2011). Analyzing the


impact of knowledge management on CRM success: The mediating effects of
organizational factors. International Journal of Information Management,
31(5), 437-444.

• Greenberg, P., (2001), CRM at the Speed of Light. Berkeley,


Osborne/McGraw-Hill. California: USA.

• Greenberg P (2009). CRM at the speed of light: social CRM strategies,


tools, and techniques for engaging your customers, (4th ed).Osborne:
McGraw-Hill. California: USA.

• Greenberg, P. (2010). The impact of CRM 2.0 on customer insight.


Journal of Business& Industrial Marketing, 25(6), 410–419.

• Gummerus, J, Liljander, V, Weman, E., & Pihlström, M, (2012). Customer


engagement in aFacebook brand community, Management Research Review,
35 (9), 857 – 877.
• Hampton, G. M., & Hampton, D. L. (2004). Relationship of professionalism,
rewards, market orientation and job satisfaction among medical professionals:
The case of Certified Nurse–Midwives. Journal of Business Research, 57(9),
1042-1053.
114

• Harrigan, P., & Miles, M., (2014). From e-CRM to s-CRM. Critical factors
underpinning the social CRM activities of SMEs. Small Enterprise Research.
21(1), 99–116.

• Heller Baird, C., & Parasnis, G. (2011). From social media to social customer
relationship management. Strategy & Leadership, 39(5), 30-37.

• Helgesen, Ø., & Nesset, E. (2007). What accounts for students' loyalty? Some
field study evidence. International Journal of Educational
Management, 21(2), 126-143.

• Hennig-Thurau, T., Malthouse, E. C., Friege, C., Gensler, S., Lobschat, L.,
Rangaswamy, A., & Skiera, B. (2010). The impact of new media on customer
relationships. Journal of Service Research, 13, 311–330.

• Hollebeek, L. (2011). Demystifying customer brand engagement: Exploring


the loyalty nexus. Journal of Marketing Management, 27 (7–8), 785–807.

• Hooley, G. J., Greenley, G. E., Cadogan, J. W., & Fahy, J. (2005). The
performance impact of marketing resources. Journal of Business Research,
58(1), 18–27.

• Hoyer, W. D., Chandy, R., Dorotic, M., Krafft, M., & Singh, S. S. (2010).
Consumer cocreation in new product development. Journal of Service
Research, 13, 283–296.

• Huit GTM, & Ketchen DJ., (2001). Does market orientation matter? A test of
the relationship between positional advantage and performance. Strategic
Management Journal, 22(9), 899-906.

• Hult, G. T. M., Ketchen, D. J., & Slater, S. F. (2005). Market orientation and
performance: an integration of disparate approaches. Strategic Management
Journal, 26(12), 1173-1181.
115

• IFPI (2006) Digital Music Report, IFPI, London.UK.

• Jack, S., Moult, S., Anderson, A.R. & Dodd, S. (2010). An entrepreneurial
network evolving: Patterns of change. International Small Business Journal,
28(2), 315–337.

• Jayachandran, S., Sharma, S., Kaufman, P. & Raman, P. (2005), The role of
relational information processes and technology use in customer relationship
management, Journal of Marketing, 69(1), 177-192.

• Kabadayi, S., & Price, K, (2014), Consumer – brand engagement on


Facebook: liking and commenting behaviors, Journal of Research in
Interactive Marketing, 8 (3), 203 – 223.

• Kaplan, A. M., & Haenlein, M. (2010). Users of the world, unite! The
challenges and opportunities of Social Media. Business horizons, 53(1), 59-
68.
• Kelly, L., Kerr, G., & Drennan, J. (2010), Avoidance of advertising in social
networking sites: the teenage perspective, Journal of Interactive Advertising,
10 (2), 16-27.

• Keramati, A., Mehrabi, H., & Mojir, N. (2010). A process-oriented


perspective on customer relationship management and organizational
performance: An empirical investigation. Industrial Marketing
Management, 39(7), 1170-1185.

• Kim, A. J., & Ko, E. (2012). Do social media marketing activities enhance
customer equity? An empirical study of luxury fashion brand. Journal of
Business Research, 65(10), 1480-1486.

• Kim, H. S., & Kim, Y. G. (2009). A CRM performance measurement


framework: Its development process and application. Industrial Marketing
Management, 38(4), 477-489.

• Kohli, A. K., Jaworski, B. J., & Kumar, A. (1993). MARKOR: a measure of


market orientation. Journal of Marketing research, 30(4), 467-477.
116

• Kohli, A, K. & Jaworski, B, J (1990), Market Orienta- tion: The Construct,


Research Propositions, and Managerial Implications, Journal of Marketing,
54 (April), 1-18.

• Kotler, P., & Armstrong G., (2010). Principles of Marketing., (13 th ed)
New Jersey: Prentice Hall.

• Kumar, V., Aksoy, L., Donkers, B., Venkatesan, R., Wiesel, T., & Tillmanns,
S. (2010). Undervalued or overvalued customers: capturing total customer
engagement value. Journal of Service Research, 13(3), 297-310.

• Kuusik, A. (2007).Affecting Customer Loyalty: Do Different Factors Have


Various Influences in Different Loyalty Levels ?, (Unpublished doctoral
Dissertation). University of Tartu, Tartu: Estonia.

• Ledingham, J.A. (2003), Explicating relationship management as a general


theory of public relations, Journal of Public Relations Research, 15 (2), 181-
198.

• Lings, I. N., & Greenley, G. E. (2005). Measuring internal market orientation.


Journal of Service Research, 7(3), 290-305.

• Maloney, W, F. (2003). Labor-Management Cooperation and Customer


Satisfaction. Journal of Construction Engineering & Management, 2(129),
165-172.

• Marquardt, I. A. (1989), “The link between total quality improvement and


market orientation”, in Guiry, M. (Ed.), Quality and Customer Service: The
Critical Focus for a Firm, Report No. 89-117, Marketing Science Institute,
Cambridge, MA.
117

• Martin, J. H., & Grbac, B. (2003). Using supply chain management to


leverage a firm's market orientation. Industrial marketing
management, 32(1), 25-38.

• Mathies, C, M, & Gudergan, (2007). Revenue Management and Customer


Centric Marketing: How do They Influence travelers Choices?. Journal of
Revenue and Pricing management, 6(4), 331-346.

• McArthur, David B., & Tom Griffin. (1997). A Marketing Management View
of Integrated Marketing Communications. Journal of Advertising Research.
37 (1), 19-28.

• Mithas, S., Ramasubbu, N., & Sambamurthy, V. (2011). How information


management capability influences firm performance. MIS Quarterly, 35(1),
237–256.

• Morgan, N.A., Slotegraaf, R.J. and Vorhies, D. (2004), Marketing resources,


effort, and capabilities and drivers of financial performance”, working
paper.

• Muniz, M.A. and O’Guinn, C.T. (2001), “Brand community”, Journal of


Consumer Research, 27 (4), 412-432.

• Musser, J. & T. O’Reilly (2005)."Web 2.0: Principles and Best Practices


" ,(online) Available: http://dl.hackr.info/.

• Nadeem, M. (2012). Social Customer Relationship Management


(SCRM): How Connecting Social Analytics to Business Analytics Enhances
Customer Care and Loyalty?. International journal of business and social
science, 3(21), 88-102.

• Narver, J.C. & Slater, S.F. (1990).The effect of a market orientation on


business profitability.Journal of Marketing, 54(1), 20-35.
118

• Narver, J.C., Slater, S.F., & Maclachlan, D.L., (2004). Responsiveness


and Proactive Market Orientation and New-Product Success. Jornal of
Prouduct Innovation management. 21(3), 334-347.

• Ofcom (2008), Social networking: a quantitative and qualitative research


report into attitudes, behaviors and use,(Online) available at:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/bsp/hi/.

• O’Brien, C. (2011). The emergence of the social media empowered


consumer. Irish marketing review, 21(1), 32-40.

• Park, C-H., & Kim, Y-G. (2003), A framework of dynamic CRM: linking
marketing with information strategy, Business Process Management Journal.
9 (5), pp. 652-71.

• Parvatiyar, A., & Sheth, J.N., (2001), Customer Relationship Management:


Emerging Practice, Process, and Discipline, Journal of Economic & Social
Research, 3 (2), 1-35.

• Payne, A., & Frow, P. (2005), A strategic framework for customer relationship
management, Journal of Marketing, 69 (4), 167-76.

• Reinhold, O., & Alt, R. (2009). Enhancing collaborative CRM with mobile
technologies. BLED 2009 Proceedings. 14-17 June, Bled, Slovenia.

• Reinartz, W .J. & Kumar, V., (2000), On the Profitability of Long-Life


Customers in a Non-Contractual Setting: An Empirical Investigation and
Implications for Marketing, Journal of Marketing, 64 (4), 17-35.

• Reinartz, W., Krafft, M., & Hoyer, W. D. (2004). The customer


relationship management process: its measurement and impact on
performance. Journal of marketing research, 41(3), 293-305.

• Rigby, D. K., Reichheld, F., & Schefter, P., (2002). Avoid the Four Perils of
CRM, Harvard Business Review, 80 (2), 101-109
119

• Rocha,T,V , Jonsen,C,L,Lofti, & Frage,R,R,(2013). An Exploratory


Study on The Use of Social networks in Building Customer Relationship
,Rev.bus.manag Journal. 47 (15), 262-282.

• Rodriguez, M, Ajjan, H., & Peterson, R,M, (2014). CRM/Social Media


Technology: Impact on Customer Orientation Process and Organizational
Sales Performance. Journal of Marketing Development and Competitiveness.
8(1), 85-97.

• Rosman,R & Stuhura,K, (2013). The Implications of social media on


Customer Relationship Management and The Hospitaly Industry. Journal of
Management Policy and Practice. 3(14), 128-146.

• Saxe, R. & Weitz, B.A. (1982).The SOCO scale: a measure of the


customer orientation of salespeople, Journal of Marketing Research, 19(5),
343-51.

• Seidel, G. (2009). Challenges but opportunities for mobile banking, Card


Technology Today, 32(1), 5-6.

• Sheth, J. N., & Sisodia, R. S., (1997). Consumer Behavior in the Future. In
Electronic Marketing and the Consumer. Ed. Robert A. Peterson. Thousand
Oaks, CA: USA.

• Sheth and Sisodia. (1999). Revisiting Marketing’s Lawlike Generalizations.


Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 27 (1): 71-87.

• Sheth, J. N., Sisodia, R. S., & Sharma, A. (2000). The antecedents and
consequences of customer-centric marketing. Journal of the Academy of
Marketing Science, 28(1), 55-66.
120

• Sicilia, M., & Palazón, M. (2008). Brand communities on the internet: A case
study of Coca-Cola's Spanish virtual community. Corporate
Communications: An International Journal, 13(3), 255-270.

• Singh, R., & Koshy, A. (2011). Does salesperson's customer orientation create
value in B2B relationships? Empirical evidence from India. Industrial
Marketing Management, 40(1) 78-85.

• Smith, A.N., Fischer, E., & Yongjian, C. (2012). How does brand-related user-
generated content differ across YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter?, Journal of
Interactive Marketing, 26 (2), 102-113.

• Srinivasan, R., & Moorman, C. (2005). Strategic firm commitments and


rewards for customer relationship management in online retailing. Journal of
Marketing, 69(4), 193-200.

• Srinivasan, S. S., Anderson, R., & Ponnavolu, K. (2002). Customer loyalty in


e-commerce: an exploration of its antecedents and consequences. Journal of
retailing, 78(1), 41-50.

• Stageman, A., (2011). Consulting Social Media in the College Transition


Process: Experiential Accounts of the Class of 2014. (online), available:
http://epublications.marquette.edu/theses_open/83.

• Steinfield, C., Ellison, N.B., & Lampe, C. (2008). Social capital, self-esteem,
and use of online social network sites: a longitudinal analysis, Journal of
Applied Developmental Psychology, 29 (6), 434-45.

• Street, C. T., & Cameron, A. F. (2007). External relationships and the small
business: A review of small business alliance and network research. Journal
of Small Business Management, 45(2), 239-266.
121

• Trainor, K. J. (2012). Relating social media technologies to performance: A


capabilities based perspective. Journal of Personal Selling and Sales
Management, 32(3), 317–331.

• Trainor, K. J., Andzulis, J. M., Rapp, A., & Agnihotri, R. (2014). Social media
technology usage and customer relationship performance: A capabilities-based
examination of social CRM. Journal of Business Research, 67(6), 1201-1208.

• Tseng, L, M., & Su, W,P, (2013). Customer orientation, social consensus and
insurance salespeople's tolerance of customer insurance frauds, International
Journal of Bank Marketing, 31(1), 38 – 55.

• Valsecchi, M., Renga, F. M., & Rangone, A. (2007). Mobile customer


relationship management: an exploratory analysis of Italian
applications.Business Process Management Journal, 13(6), 755-770.

• VanBoskirk, S., Overby, C. S., & Takvorian, S. (2011). U.S. interactive


marketing forecast, 2011 to 2016. Cambridge, MA: Forrester Research.
Retrieved January 6, 2014, (Online), Available: www.forrester.
com/USþInteractive þ Marketing þ Forecast þ 2011 þ To þ 2016/fulltext/-/E-
RES59379? docid ¼ 59379/

• van Doorn, J., Lemon, K.N., Mittal, V., Nass, S., Doree´n, P., Pirner, P., &
Verhoef, P.C. (2010), Customer engagement behavior: theoretical foundations
and research directions, Journal of Service Research, 13 (3), 253-266.

• Vavra, T. G. (1997). Improving your measurement of customer


satisfaction: A guide to creating, conducting, analyzing, and reporting
customer satisfaction measurement programs. Milwaukee, Wisconsin: ASQ
Quality Press.
122

• Verhoef, P.C., Reinartz, W.J., & Krafft, M. (2010), Customer engagement as a


new perspective in customer management, Journal of Service Research, 13
(3), 247-252.
• Wang, X., Dugan, R., & Sojka, J. (2013). CRM Systems with Social
Networking Capabilities: The Value of Incorporating a CRM 2.0 System in
Sales/Marketing Education. Marketing Education Review, 23(3), 241-250.

• Wang, Y., & Feng, H. (2012). Customer relationship management capabilities:


Measurement, antecedents and consequences. Management Decision, 50(1),
115-129.

• Wang, C., Huang, Y., Chen, C., & Lin, Y, (2006). The influence of
customer relationship management process on management performance: The
International Journal of Organizational Innovation.

• Wiliams, J., & Chinn, S, (2010). Meeting Relationship-Marketing Goals


Through Social Media: A Conceptual Model for Sport Marketers,
International Journal of Sport Communication, 3(4), 422-237.

• Wood, V. R., Bhuian, S., & Kiecker, P. (2000). Market orientation and
organizational performance in not-for-profit hospitals. Journal of Business
Research, 48(3), 213-226.

• Woodcock, N.A, Green, A.N, & Starkey, M.A, (2011). Social CRM as a
business strategy. Journal of Database Marketing & Customer Strategy
Management, 1(18), 50-64.

• Wright, D.K. & Hinson, M.D. (2010), How new communications media are
being used in public relations: a longitudinal analysis, Public Relations
Journal, 4 (3) 1-27.

• Zhang, Z. (2011). Customer knowledge management and the strategies of


social software. Business Process Management Journal, 17(1), 82-106.
123

• Zhang, L.,Han, Z., & GAO, Q.(2008), “Empirical Study on the Student
Satisfaction Index in Higher Education”, International Journal of Business
and Management.3(9) 46-51
124
125
126

6-'
(1) 5-'
#-    

"&  6    

"#&  "& "#$   # 1. .1

(  5 "& "#$   #- &  . .2


‫‪127‬‬

‫‪ *$‬ا‡ ا‪ #<c‬ا‪*c‬‬

‫ا!‪K(D‬‬

‫‪zc‬ة ا‪ DFA‬ا‪G‬آ(رم‬

‫‪ N'c ' 3‬و=&‪- :‬‬

‫‪;U‬ا ‪(AM!G‬ع ?‪O‬ء "‪ #‬و‪(8<F *;!+‬رآ ‪ 2B‬ها ا<‪ q‬اي ه‪O? E‬ء "‪ #‬درا أآ(د‪>ffR" <7‬‬

‫‪ S3‬در? ا<(?! ‪ 2B‬ا‪(<IG‬ل ا‪!;u‬و‪ )"(? #" K‬ا‪8‬ق ا‪G‬و[‪ .‬وا ض "‪ #‬ه ارا ه‪E‬‬

‫“أ‪ 4T‬ا‪&. :‬ام ‪*Nd‬ت ا ا‪ OZ‬ا( !‪ +, +‬اداء ادارة ! ت ا‪ :‬درا‪&'- :‬ا‪ - 'V‬و‪48V e‬‬

‫‪ N2c‬ا\‪=-‬ت ا(رد‪ 'V‬ا‪ Y(!K BE! " Z.‬ه ارا ")‪("EF‬ت "‪ bc(DF ><P‬و‪ ،)"(JF‬و‪„K‬ا <(‬

‫‪()1 #" >F"&K‬و‪ *;K‬ا‪(3D‬ء ود‪<F *;<I‬ة ا)‪ 23KŠB ،<F‬ار?‪+ *;3" E‬اءة ا‪ #)<!$ K(D!G‬وا‪(PFI $(?G‬‬

‫‪ +$‬و‪ >7(3I‬و!* ا!)("‪ Z" S‬ه ا<)‪("EF‬ت ‪ >"(1 7$‬و!!‪R‬م \|اض ا‪ bHD‬ا)‪.[MB 2<F‬‬

‫‪(U‬آا ;* ‪()1 #c‬و‪,,, *;K‬‬

‫ا‪bc(D‬‬ ‫أ‪U‬اف‬
‫‪(<^I‬ن ا‪(c‬ن ‪I‬ان‬ ‫أ‪.‬د‪ b .‬ا‪2)$‬‬
‫‪128‬‬

‫او(‪ -:‬ا‪ }(fR‬ا‪ <7‬ا‪ W?7 : B‬و‪ Zr‬ا‪(U‬رة ) √( ‪ 2B‬ا<‪ Z$‬اي ‪ S^<7‬ا?(‪.€!$‬‬

‫ا‪W^K‬‬ ‫ذآ‬ ‫ا‪J‬ــ‪:j3‬‬

‫"‪:nE‬‬ ‫"!‪Q‬غ‬ ‫‪ (c‬ا‪:m(A‬‬

‫‪&B 45‬آ^‬ ‫‪44 – 35‬‬ ‫‪34 – 25‬‬ ‫‪24- 18‬‬ ‫ا)<‪:‬‬

‫"(?!‬ ‫‪E(;$‬ر‪E7‬س‬ ‫ا‪ Y"(KD‬ارا‪:2‬‬

‫ا‪ SfQ‬ا^(‪2014/2013 2K‬‬ ‫ا‪ SfQ‬ا‪G‬ول ‪2014/2013‬‬ ‫‪(1‬ر‪ p7‬ا‪(H!G‬ق ‪:)"(J($‬‬

‫ا‪ SfQ‬ا^(‪2015/2014 2K‬‬ ‫ا‪ SfQ‬ا‪G‬ول ‪2015 /2014‬‬

‫ا‪EMH‬ق‬ ‫ا‪t‬داب وا)‪EF‬م‬ ‫ا;‪:F‬‬

‫‪ (?EF3;1‬ا<)‪("EF‬ت‬ ‫ا‪(<IG‬ل‬

‫ا‪ 3P‬وا)<(رة وا!‪*<f‬‬ ‫ا)‪EF‬م ا!‪7E$‬‬

‫ا‪f‬‬ ‫ا‪'IG‬م‬
‫‪129‬‬

‫( ا‪&] YH3‬ة‬
‫‪ W?7 : (K(%‬و‪ Zr‬ا‪(U‬رة ) √( ‪ 2B‬ا)<‪E‬د اي ‪ S^<7‬ا?(‪. €!$‬‬
‫ا‪&] YH3‬ة‬

‫ا)‪(D‬رة‬ ‫ت‬
‫( ا‪YH3‬‬
‫‪& -‬‬
‫ا‪YH3‬‬

‫&   ‪7+‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1 0 )& %& " & X‬‬ ‫ "  ‪  . J * %&7‬‬ ‫  ‪<2‬‬ ‫‪.1‬‬
‫ "‪.‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1 X‬‬ ‫ " ‪  . J %3 00  %& *  *   %3‬‬ ‫ ‪<2 %‬‬ ‫‪.2‬‬
‫ "‪.‬‬ ‫& " &‪0 )& %‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬ ‫ " *  ‪.%&9 5‬‬ ‫&  ‪<2‬‬ ‫‪.3‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬ ‫ "‪.‬‬ ‫*  ‪%<2   &/ *#3$‬‬ ‫‪.4‬‬

‫ا!‪ &<,G‬ا‪ H' 5I!%‬ادارة =;ت ا‬

‫ا‪E$ jQ‬ك )‪(Face book‬‬


‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫أ‪!" L‬ار ‪ D‬ا‪,‬رات واا &‪ K‬ا‪ D   JI‬ا‪ BA‬ا"& ‪1‬‬ ‫‪.5‬‬
‫  ‪ D‬ا&‪ N‬ك‪.‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬ ‫ا‪$‬دل ا‪O‬راء وا '‪G‬ر ‪ K‬ز=‪ D H‬ا‪ BA‬ا"&   ‪ D‬ا&‪ N‬ك‪.‬‬ ‫‪.6‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫ "   "  <‪1 8‬‬ ‫ ‪"<  %7 +  " +‬‬ ‫* ‬ ‫‪.7‬‬
‫‪.P‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫)ود‪ H‬ز=‪ H‬ا‪ $/‬ت ا!‪ H‬ا‪Q .<!Q‬ل ا‪5I‬ت وا‪$‬ا‪ R‬ا!‪5‬ر)‪1 &%‬‬ ‫‪.8‬‬
‫‪ D‬ا‪ BA‬ا"&  ‪.‬‬

‫ا‪E1E‬ب )‪(You Tube‬‬


‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬ ‫ " ‪.&  0& 3‬‬ ‫)‪.9 "J < 59‬‬ ‫‪& /‬‬ ‫‪.9‬‬

‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫‪1  0& 3 0&  "   "J‬‬ ‫<‬ ‫)‪59‬‬ ‫‬ ‫‪& :$‬‬ ‫‪.10‬‬
‫&‪.‬‬
‫‪5‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬ ‫ " ‪1 5‬‬ ‫& ‪0 )& %& .9  . <  "J < 59) P‬‬ ‫‪.11‬‬
‫‪.%7 +‬‬
130

‫ ]&ة‬YH3‫( ا‬
‫ ]&ة‬YH3‫ا‬

‫(رة‬D)‫ا‬ ‫ت‬
YH3‫( ا‬
& -
YH3‫ا‬

(Mobile App) *) I&0 .)9&


5 4 3 2 1 .   + 4 %3 "  5 * &  % & *) I&0 .)9& .12
5 4 3 2 1 I&0  " & ( .)9&  J& "  %3 %7 + 5 " < * & .13
.*)
5 4 3 2 1 ." < "  5 %&     % & *) I&0 .)9& .14

7+  +& 4 ( 2


5 4 3 2 1 ."   &/  %  .15
5 4 3 2 1 .% & /  )& "   "  % +& .16
5 4 3 2 1 * &  % & %& + &   < . )  " P& & "  .17
." < 0<2 5 *<& 
5 4 3 2 1 .%& & "&  % * +& & "  "   .18

.€!$(?‫ ا‬S^<7 ‫د اي‬E<)‫ ا‬2B (√) ‫(رة‬U‫ ا‬Zr‫ و‬W?7 :I(<!?G‫ ا‬#($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫رات ادارة‬+ :(^(%

‫(رة‬D)‫ا‬ ‫ت‬
‫ة‬8$ yQ1G
‫ة‬8$ yQ1‫ا‬

7(H"
yQ1G
yQ1‫ا‬

‫ادارة  ان‬


5 4 3 2 1 * & . *J  % 1 &( %7H *&    "  23& .19
.% & (
5 4 3 2 1 .% & ( * & .  J& "  %<2 5 " 2& .  4 .20
5 4 3 2 1 .% + & .-  % & /  "  <2 23 .21

.  
5 4 3 2 1  / Q *9  * &    "   0 & %& .   * .22
.% & ( * & .  "   "J "  5-   J& *J
131

5 4 3 2 1 .% & ( * & . *J  0 * %& .   :H .23

5 4 3 2 1 % & ( * & .  J& *J  "J %& * %  .24
5 4 3 2 1 * & . 5-    J( #  .  c  * .25
."   % & (
" &(
5 4 3 2 1 0&- & %&  ")&  "  %&Q  %&  " <  && "  .26
.% & ( * & .  <2 5
5 4 3 2 1 .% & ( * & .  0 -$ %& ^ " < " &( & .27

5 4 3 2 1 X   . J  0 Q %& .&  " < " &( &
.28
.% & ( * & .  0 )& - %&  " &

.€!$(?‫ ا‬S^<7 ‫د اي‬E<)‫ ا‬2B (√ ) ‫(رة‬U‫ ا‬Zr‫ و‬W?7 :#($O‫(ت ا‬+'I ‫ اداء ادارة‬:()$‫را‬

‫(رة‬D)‫ا‬ ‫ت‬
‫ة‬8$ yQ1‫ ا‬G
‫ة‬8$ yQ1‫ا‬

yQ1‫ ا‬G
7(H"
yQ1‫ا‬

"9 #
5 4 3 2 1 ."  1'/ %3 * & - 4'J&( a& (  .29

5 4 3 2 1 ."  0 )& %& . J  #   .30

5 4 3 2 1 ."  %<2  " J *#3$  * .31

"9 (
5 4 3 2 1 ."  1'/ %3 * &   J( % .32

5 4 3 2 1 ."  1'/ %3 .  ^ J  * & - 4   .33

5 4 3 2 1 "  1'/ %3 &( 4 .34

You might also like