Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bedriye ASIMGİL
(i.e. trees, water) in urban contexts contributes to the us to learn, play, grow, and connect with both nature
quality of life in many ways. and our neighbours and communities in modern and
Balikesir University Engineering & Architecture Faculty Department of Architecture, Balıkesir, Turkey
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 1
Figure 1. Gülhane Park-İstanbul.
Figure 2. A section of the outer garden was planned as a park by the municipality and opened to the
public in 1912.
2 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
urbanised society. They replenish our air and water; by landscape ecologist due to its ecological function.
they protect or provide safe havens in cities. They de- The ecological function of open space was initially ad-
fine what a civil society is, they define what a liveable vocated by (MacHarg, 1964, p.47), followed by (Laurie,
city is. The emergence of the leading urban parks and 1979, p.89) and (Hough, 1984, p.123). They suggested
green spaces in the Turkey during the past decade re- that land use allocation should be determined by pat-
flects the growing professionalism and commitment tern of natural resources and individual ecological ele-
of the management agencies and their leaders to the ments. Nature not only represents the material basis
parks and green spaces agenda. of all human life but also provides man with optimum
The last years we have seen local authorities aimed living conditions.
to create an environment-friendly urban setting In the beginning of the urban park movement de-
through a planned landscape development in urban signers had as objective the representation of rural
areas involving the use of “naturalistic”styles. Profes- landscapes like in the central park in Turkey, but with-
sional interest in ‘naturalistic’ landscapes has certainly out any attemp to re-establish ecological functions.
been very strong across northern Europe for the last
few decades and a fashion among landscape profes- Later Park Yumurtalık Lagun evolutes in a mode to
sionals towards the production of more natural land- adapt ecological functions as wetland ecosystem and
scapes within the urban fabric has been popular (Flint, afterwards, urban park design adopted the formal de-
1985, p.37, Emery, 1986, p.127, Goode and Smart, sign principles taking into consideration ecological cri-
1986, p.156, Kendle and Forbes, 1997, p.223 and Dun- teria (Park İğneada Longoz Ormanları) (Fig. 5).
net and Hitchmough, 2004, p.47). In Turkey, according to 2010 data, there are total 40
Recently, however, the importance of open space National Park. (Dağdaş, Kırış, Ateş, 2006, s.44).Some of
and green space in cities has been strongly supported them are shown in below:
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 3
Kuşcenneti National Park, been collected as secondary data.
Balıkesir 1959 1195 ha
In the first phrase it was studied the origin of urban
Uludağ National Park parks, analysed the evolution of urban park design- by
Bursa 1961 12677 ha analysing significant urban parks and described the ex-
Yedigöller National Park pected future of the movement.
Bolu 1965 2019 ha In the second phrase was collected and analysed
Nemrut Mountain National Park information about the different components of the
Adıyaman 1988 13850 ha landscape “public parks” and “recreation areas”often
Beyşehir Lake National Park mentioned factors to make the city liveable, pleasant
Konya 1993 88750 ha and attractive for its citizens.
Dilek Peninsula The visual quality and opportunities and treats
Aydın 1994 27675 ha of the study area synthesized to evaluate the scenic
Gala Lake National Park value, cultural character and the landscape capac-
ity to absorb change of visual absorption capacity of
Edirne 2005 6090 ha open spaces rich in natural and visual landscape re-
İğneada Longoz Mountains sources. “Visual absorption capacity” is defined as the
Kırklareli 2007 3155 ha landscape’s ability to absorb physical changes with-
Tek Tek Mountains National Park out transformation in its visual character and quality.
(Amir, Gidalizon, 1990, p.258).
Şanlıurfa 2007 19335 ha
Yumurtalık Lagünü National Park High quality landscapes usually present more sensi-
tivity and low visual absorption capability (Panagopu-
Adana 2008 16430 ha
los, Vargues, 2006, p.282). From the above informa-
Presently, the movement adopted the environmen- tion was created that the Atatürk Park as an attractive
tal education function like it is presented in the Tekiro- and multifunctional space that promotes sustainable
va/Antalya-Kemer Eko Park (Fig. 4). This principle is development.
considered very important, once the development of
proactive education and training policies not only on Urban Parks Analysed in the Conception of
children but on any park user can play an essential role Visual Quality
in the sustainability of the city strengthening the im- Before analysing the case study of Atatürk Park, it
portance of urban parks and other natural areas of the will be performed a short description of some urban
contemporary city. parks that marked the urban park movementin their
Urban parks and open green spaces are of a stra- construction period and that influenced its concep-
tegic importance for the quality of life of our increas- tion- The Şehitler Park, The Park Barrier-Free Life and
ingly urbanized society (Beer, 1994, p. 131). Besides The Environmental Education Park
ecological functions, natural areas provide social and
psychological services, which are of crucial significance The Şehitler Park
for the livability of modern cities and the well-being of The Şehitler Park (Fig. 6) is located in Balıkesir and
urban dwellers. The future social implications of new has an area of approximately 74 hectares. This area is
lifestyles, values, attitudes to nature and sustainability composed by 53 hectares of lawns and meadows.
will lead to higher demands for urban parks (Thomp- The park contains roughly 375 trees, 3086 bush
son, 1994, 239). and 18200 plant groundcovers. With this structure it
Methodology intend to barrier to the exterior and to the buildings.
This vegatiation represent biophysical characteristics
The methodology was developed for the” Balıkesir of the area, renewal potential of vegetation and the
Province” area, located in South Marmara region. visual exposure of the area to observers. These rural
Table 1 shows the methodology diagram that is based and natural sceneries and its organic forms play an
in the holistic concept of landscape as a resource. important role in the Dynamics of the Park. Open and
Primary data (literature review and desk research) closed spaces can help improve the quality of life in
have been gathered. The most popular parks of urban areas, provide to the visitors of the park a vari-
Balıkesir created in recent years (The Turkey) have ety of places turning the space into a varied and mul-
4 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
Park
Origin
Second
Phase
Liveable Liveable
Landscape
Analysis
Pleansant Cultural Functional Pleansant
Data Data
Ecologie
Data
Attractive Attractive
Sustainable Biodiversity
Syntesis
Visual Biophysical
Opportunities
quality Sensitivity
Atatürk
Park
tifunctional space by increasing the attractiveness of Park is quite complex, reason why the plantation plan
the places in which people live and work. was very ambitious, not only in dimension, but also in
schedule.
The Environmental Education Park
Environmental Education Park (Fig. 7) is located in The Park Barrier-Free Life
Balıkesir. The park with an area of 9 hectares was de- The Park Barrier-Free Life (Fig. 8) is located in
signed the Department of Balıkesir Municipality. Balıkesir. The park has an area of 4350 square meters.
The park is composed by 5.5 hectares of trees and The park contains 800 trees, bushes and plant
bushes; 950 square meters of open spaces; 1400 groundcovers. On the contrary of The Environmental
square meters of roads, ways and parking lots and Education Park, the created structure does not intend
1150 squaremeters for other different uses. to represent the natural sceneries and its organic
The green stucture of The Environmental Education forms, but to create a connection witth the city center.
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 5
Figure 6. Şehitler Park - green areas and circulation.
The New Ataturk Park Case Study The Atatürk Park represents an exceptional oppor-
The park is located in Balıkesir, which is a character- tunity to establish a best practice example of sustain-
ized terrestrial anf Mediterranean climate and beatiful able urban development. The objective of the urban
landscape. Balıkesir is the west region of Turkey with park Project was to create an economically sustainable
a 45% of land occupied by forest and 32% by uncul- Project that will take into consideration the environ-
tivated land. In Balıkesir the main spacies are larch, ment and cultural heritage, and the spirit of the place
(genius loci) (Galofaro, 20007, p. 122, Schulz, 1997, p.
red pine, beech, hornbeam, oak, willow, tamarisk, and
96, Spirn, 1998, p. 121, Tilley, 1994, p. 63).
sycamore and olive trees.
Thus, it was created interest points that attract and
The population is characterized by scattered distri-
servet he population; was used different plants and
bution in the center areas and concentrated in coastal
urban equipment and materials adapted to the sur-
zones. Tourism is the main activity especially in coastal rounding landscape; was asked the people satisfaction
zones and farmer population is continuously aging. of user what they expect to see in that place.
Balıkesir boasts a rich and diversified natural heritage.
Throughout the province of Balikesir, many mounds, In order to identify the views of users in this re-
cave and even residential areas emerged in the period search, social value was measured by indicators using
between 8000-3000 BC. Agiros (Achiraus) is the first surveys before and after the project.
city that is said in this region (Hacıoğlu, Bozok, 1997, The research involved a range of questionnaires for
s. 10). Karesi principality was established in the region all ages. Separate questionnaires were developed for
after the collapse of the Anatolian Seljuk State, and teenagers and adults and 400 personal interviews con-
then the region was conquered by the Ottoman Em- ducted with users aged 12 and over. Examples of indi-
pire (Akşit, Sanır, 1981, s. 790). cators used in social survey were the following:
6 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
-the percentage of people who feel there is good “Sport”, “recreation facility”, “cultural events”,”see ani-
community spirit where they live, mal” “Leisure time”, “Picnic”, but also for human con-
tact activities, such as meeting people.
-the percentage of people who are proud of their
city, As a result the design and Project concept assent in
-the percentage of people who indicate that fresh the idea of “Urban Nature Symbiosis”.The Atatürk Park
air is the main reason of using Atatürk Park responded to the needs ecological and social benefits
to exist. The idea of symbiosis was based in the fact
-the percentage of people who indicate that visit that the urban park movement was cerated as a solu-
the park for the greenery and natural view, tion environmental problems, which was represented
-the percentage of people who consider the parks as “calm”, “open space”, “beautification”, “cleanliness”,
to be an urban oasis of greenery, where they are able “safety”, “life “, largeness” “and the “free”.
to escape for a while from the burdens of life in the Urban parks provide great opportunities for contact
concrete urban desert, with nature for residents. “Parks can be an awe-inspir-
-the percentage of people who indicate that Shade ing contrast to the every day technological word. They
and Seclusion are the main reason of using The Ata- can give urban dwellers contact with the plant and
türk Park, animal world, which is missed in towns, but is deeply
satisfying” (Turner, 1992, p. 369).
-the decrease in the number of people suffering
from mental health problems, The principal formation of the Project is the tree
roots represent the cycling network, trails and walk-
This survey aimed to discover respondent’s imagi-
ways. Purpose of the structures was also to give access
nation, favourite, least favourite things and their as-
and to connect the functional areas like the construct-
sociations of urban parks. According to the survey re-
ed elements and vegetation.
sults, respondents indicate that The Atatürk Park was
identified relate to naturalness and recreation activity; The development of this approach was based the
was appreciated urban parks not only for passive and fact that if a design is not based social and environ-
active pursuits such as “walking “Children’s play area, mental ideals and if designers do not have substantial
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 7
Figure 8. The Park Barrier-Free Life- green areas and circulation.
efforts what problems they are solving and what goals ronment and acting as an important educational tool.
they intent to achieve, sustainable program and form They are also seen as vital to enhancing the quality of
become extremely banal. It was based in this idea that urban environments and the quality of life in urban
the design team started to develop long-range plans area (Dunnett, Swanwick, Woolley, 2002, p. 29). The
for the delivery of recreation and parks services. objective was to establish functional connections with
Although the analysis phrase was developed mutu- the surroundinf area in away to facilitiate access to the
ally, in order to develop leisure participation, citizen park by different means (foot or bicycle) and connect
expectations, recreation as a promoter of community it in a coherent mode to the city. In this way the strat-
and individual health, and trends in park design and egy allowed the creation of the best design possible to
development. each one of the three systems that include concerns
about ease of moving around safely within them, in-
In this sense, the development plan of Ataturk park cluding design of surfaces.
was based in three different system, developed inde-
pendent, which after designed were superimposed: In terms of structure and form we opted to use
(1) circulation; (2) green structure, and; (3) functional naturalized lines. New formal and aesthetic qualities
areas. including organic forms both in terms of landscape and
architectural forms are proven to be more connected
This idea applied to development plan was the first with the natural environment than rectilinear ones in
step in realising the long-term vision for the park. terms of their relationship to city around them. The
Well-managed public open spaces are linked to im- objective was to integrate the proposed landscape in
proving the attractiveness of urban areas, promoting the existing one, reason why organic forms were the
healthier lifestyles, benefiting wildlife and the envi- most appropriate ones.
8 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
The circulation plan constitutes the principal struc- the means to create these spaces as well. Parks have
ture which systematizes the whole park and “creating since become a representation of equality, where ev-
its skeleton”(Fig. 9). eryone is allowed to share and enjoy the same space.
There are three main forms of circulation within Balikesir city center’s residential population is approxi-
parks: mately 300 thousand. Green area per capita is less
than 2 m2. There isn’t a significant recreation area in
1. Vehicular city center except of The Atatürk Park. This percentage
2. Pedestrian is similar in many provinces.
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 9
Figure 10. Circulation form.
tions of spaces many of which equipped for urban Another objective was to preserve the natural en-
dwellers such as area for active and passive recre- vironment enhance biodiversity and protect ecosys-
ations, social communications, and contact for natu- tems. Urban parks can play an important role in the
ral environments. The different functional areas were conservation of biodiversity, especially in a strongly
strategically located to obtain a symbiosis between urbanised region.
form and function. Existing constrains, the proposed
To determine habitat diversity in a time-efficient
objectives and, other design components were locat-
way, we developed a plant list with 6 possible plant
ed tpgether to enable superimposition strategy.
units that can be found in suburbanparks in The
Urban parks are defined as active green public Atatürk Park for example coniferous tree, leaved trees
spaces which provide opportunities for recreations, and shrubs, bushes, groundcovers, aquatic plants and
and family gathering. Public spaces in The Atatürk Park ivy plants.
can be considered as multi-purpose areas. In addi-
The plant species, densities and diversity created
tion, park is regarded as an important venue to fulfill
different experiences inside the park, enhancing and
resident’s leisure times they are known as important
celebrating the merge between ecology, leisure and
destinations for residents. For this reason, to create
recreation.
a multifunctional space we intruduced three distinct
typologies for functional areas: leisure, education and For the green structure, leaved trees and shrubs
ecology. Each one these were carafully located to con- was chosen because they are well adapted to the re-
nect people with natural environments, and to en- gion and provide a continental and Mediterranean
hance mental and physical health both according to image to the space which permits better adjustment
the community needs and desires as it is the case of with the surrounding landscape. Furthermore with
pleasent vistas. the objective to create promoting diversity, activity an
10 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
Figure 11. This walk provides main access to many shops and buildings.
Figure 13. This path is less formal than a walk, yet it still provides access to main areas.
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 11
Figure 14. Functional areas.
deven casual walks in the park green space played an ers have different motives to visit the park and differ-
important role. ent activities they are going to undertake. Therefore,
Finally, the vision was to create vibrant, diverse and should take into account recreational requirements of
multi-functional community such as leisure, living, all target groups.
communication, sport, recreation. This study was held to identify the users’ preferenc-
es for park usability in urban park in Balikesir, Turkey.
Conclusions The results declared that park’s visitors highly prefer
In the context of this study, the role of urban parks to involve with natural settingsFor example, they favor
as provider of social services and their importance for observing landscape views, and being close to trees
city sustainability has been addressed. Some results and shaded areas. Urban dwellers in Balikesir face with
have been presented of a survey aimed at exploring wide range of mental and physical pressures. Physi-
the motives and perceptions of visitors of a Balikesir cal planning of park creates positive impact on users’
urban park. mental and physical restoration. Compared with other
Although the results do not reflect universal, some parks in Balıkesir, such as The Şehitler Park, The En-
conclusive remarks can be made, due to the small size vironmental Education Park and The Park Barrier-Free
of the sample analysed and the limited statistics per- Life, The Atatürk Park is more conceptual and multi-
formed. functional, and it tries to struggle the fact that work is
still the dominant fact of human life.
First of all, urban nature fulfils many social func-
tions and psychological needs of citizens, which make In term of environmental education aspect, Environ-
urban nature a valuable municipal resource, and a key mental Education Park should include learning com-
ingredient for city sustainability. Secondly, different us- munity in which student life and learning processes
12 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1
Asımgil B, Sustainable Planning df Urban Parks-The Case of Balıkesir, Turkey
beyond leisure and different activities. As the strategy, a balanced system that includes places for physical
park should be progressively a centre for education activity to improve health, active recreation, passive
and training, receiving students from all schools and recreation, and wilderness areas. Ataturk Park should
universities of the region. For example, park amenity be re-considered as taking into more comprehensive
planners can increase people’s knowledge about natu- ecological principles. This study discussed about park’s
ral plants. contribution to improve social and environmental as-
pects of the city. However, parks’ role should be re-
They should provide biographic information on
considered ecologically to improve quality of life and
signboards for different species. In addition, park de-
finally city sustainability, such as habitat diversity.
signers should allocate some place in the park for exhi-
bition of outdoor and indoor plants. Municipalities can Furthermore, park should include more compre-
occasionally provide free plants for visitors. Moreover, hensive plants which provide great shade. Landscape
park amenity planners can consider another particular architects should suggest plants which can mitigate
space for visitors to engage with gardening and plant- intensity of sounds. Therefore, urban parks can bring
ing which gives direct involvement with nature. Land- back tranquility and calmness to the dwellers’ life and
scape designers should re-consider role of The Envi- this phenomenon augment spontaneously sustainabil-
ronmental Education Park. ity of environment and city.
The Urban Park of Ataturk is planned at the city References
and neighbourhood levels in order to reduce tensions, Kurucu, Y., Chiristina, N.K., (2008), “Monitoring the impacts
stress, and pressure among the residents, but also of urbanization and industrialization on the agricultural
the needs of people for green space and recreation. land and environment of the Torbali, Izmir region, Tur-
Park serves the diverse interests of different users in key”, Environment Assess, 136:289-297 DOI 10.1007/
CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1 13
s10661-007-9684-4, p. 289-97. the evaluation of visual absorption capacity of the land-
Flint, R., (1985), Encouraging Wildlife in Urban Parks: Guide- scape”, Journal of Environmental Management, 30:3,
lines to Management, The London Wildlife Trust, Lon- 251-63.
don, Gordon Press. Panagopulos, T., and Vargues, P.,(2006), Visual impact as-
Emery, M., (1986), Promoting Nature in Cities and Towns: A sesment of a golf course in a Mediterranean forest land-
Practical Guide Croom Helm, London. scape. In Lafortortezza, Patterns and Processes in Forest
Goode, D.A., (1986), “Smart Designing for Wildlife”, Ecology Landscapes, Consequences of Human Management”,
and Design in Landscape, Proceedings of the 24th Sym- Academia Italiana di Scienze Florestali, Firenze, Italy, p.
posium of the British Ecological Society, Blackwell Scien- 279-85.
tific Publisher, Oxford, p. 859-73. Hacıoğlu, N., Bozok, D., (1997), “Balıkesir: Bir Kentin Kimliği”,
Kendle, A.D., and Forbes, S.J., (1997), “Urban Nature Con- Balıkesir Rotary Kulübü, Balıkesir, s. 10-11.
servation: Landscape Management in the Urban Coun- Akşit, N., Sanır, F., (1981), “A’dan Z’ye Genel Bilgi Ansiklope-
tryside”, London, E & FN Spon. disi”, İstanbul.
Dunnet, N., and Hitchmough, J., (2004), “The Dynamic Galofaro,L., (2007), Land&ScapeSeries: Artscapes, Art as an
Landscape: The Ecology and Design of Urban Landscape aprroach to contemporary landscape, Barcelona, Gus-
Plantings”, London, E & FN Spon. tavo Gili.
MacHarg, I. L., (1964), Design with Nature, New York, Natu- Schulz, N., (1997), Genius Loci.Paysage, Ambiance, Architec-
ral History Press for the American Museum of Natural ture.Buxelles, Pierre Mardaga (edt).
History. Spirn, A., (1998), The language of landscape, New Haven
Hough, M., (1984), City Form and Natural Process: Towards and London, Yale University Press.
a New Urban Vernacular” London, Croom Helm. Tilley, C., (2002), Urban open space in the 21st century”,
Laurie, I.C., (1979), Nature in Cities: The Natural Environ- Landscape Urban Planning, 60:4, 59-72.
ment in the Design and the Development of Urban Green Turner, T., (1992), “Open space planning in London:From
Space, Newyork, and Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Standards per 1000 to Green Strategy”, Town and plan-
Dağdaş, S., Kırış, R., Ateş, M., (2006), “ Kızıldağ Millî Parkı ning review, 63: 365-86.
Orman Amenajman Planı Uygulamaları Örneğinde Ko- Dunnett, N., Swanwick, C., Woolley, H., (2002), “Improving
runan Alan Yaklaşımına Dönük Değerlendirmeler”, I. Urban Parks, Play Areas and Green Spaces”, Urban Re-
Uluslararası Beyşehir ve Yöresi Sempozyumu, 11-13 search Report, Department of Landscape, University of
Mayıs 2006,- Konya, s. 437-55. Sheffield, Department for Transport, Local Government
Beer, A.R., (1994), “Urban greenspace and sustainability. In: and the Regions, The London, p. 9-32.
van der Vegt”, et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of a PRO/ECE- http://www.tuik.gov.tr/PreTablo.do?tb_id=39&ust_id=11
Workshop on Sustainable Urban Development, Research http://www.360cities.net/image/turkey-istanbul-gulhane-
and Experiments, November 1993, Dordrecht, The Neth- park#317.80,-18.00,77.5
erlands, p. 129-38. http://dergi.ormuh.org.tr/dergi2007/dergi2007_2.pdf -
Thompson, C., (1994), A Phenomenology of Landscape. http://dergi.ormuh.org.tr/dergi2007/dergi2007_3.pdf
Places, Paths and Monuments. USA: Berg Publishers. http://www.spo.org.tr/resimler/ekler/de7e2b6d13a41dd_
Amir, S., Gidalizon, E, (1990), ”Expert-based method for ek.pdf
This paper was selected from the papers presented at the CAUMME 2012 International
Symposium that was held at Yıldız Technical University, Faculty of Architecture in 21-23
November 2012.
Bu yazı 21-23 Kasım 2012 tarihlerinde Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi Mimarlık Fakültesi’nde
düzenlenen CAUMME 2012 Uluslararası Sempozyumu’nda sunulan bildiriler arasından
seçilmiştir.
14 CiLT VOL. 7 - EK 1