You are on page 1of 5

Key takeaways This transition will likely need an Key actions that India could take

The power generation sector investment of $2.5 trillion until 2050 to enable the transition would be
accounts for 35 percent of India’s in the LoS scenario and an additional a) increase RE and storage capacity
total emissions, which have grown at a $1.3 trillion in the Accelerated scenario. additions; b) initiate market reforms,
CAGR of two percent in the last decade, Importantly, most of this investment leverage innovative flexibility sources
in line with the demand growth of is NPV positive and could get India’s for RE-integration to ensure grid
electricity. While India has taken steps power-generation cost from its current reliability; c) improve the financial
toward decarbonising the sector by INR 4/kWh to INR 3/kWh by 2050. health of power distribution
accelerating build-out of RE capacity The total average system cost of supply companies (DISCOMs); and d) localise
over the past decade, challenges which was 6.15 INR/kWh in 2020 can manufacturing in key technology
remain. also come down by 0.7–0.9 INR/kWh areas such as solar, storage and
as increases in per unit transmission hydrogen electrolysers. Besides the
India could get to net-zero emissions and distribution cost could be offset transition, decarbonisation could
by 2070 in our LoS scenario, by decreases in generation cost and also help accelerate job creation and
supported by favourable economics aggregate, technical and commercial provide India with an opportunity to
(of RE and RE-storage hybrids vis-à- (AT&C) loss reduction.61 However, become a global leader of energy
vis coal), industry action, conducive India would have to be mindful not to transition and a possible exporter
policies and increasing investment compromise on energy security through of green technologies. However,
(including from major global investors). import localisation and power-mix India will have to be mindful not to
We do not envisage accelerated diversification. compromise on energy security through
retirement of coal-fired power plants in import localisation and power-mix
our scenarios—incremental demand for Critical challenges that India would
diversification.
power would largely be met with non- face to achieve net-zero in the
fossil sources of generation while the power sector are a) 5x and 9x RE
existing fleet of hyphenate plants would capacity addition in 2030 and 2040,
continue to operate (depending on their respectively relative to its current
position in the merit order curve) until 10–12 GW per year RE addition; b)
the end of their economic life. RE supply chain and raw material
manufacturing given 80–90 percent of
India’s power sector could achieve solar modules are currently imported; c)
net zero by 2050 in the Accelerated land availability and grid connectivity;
scenario by accelerating investment d) integration of intermittent RE while
and undertaking market reforms. This ensuring grid stability and avoiding
will require around 1000 GW additional power outages.
renewable capacity by 2050 and
can result in avoiding a cumulative 16
GtCO₂e of emissions by 2070. Sector
emissions would peak by the mid- to
late-2020s in this scenario.

61
Full system cost of power including costs (factoring reasonable returns and system losses) for generation, transmission and distribution. The corresponding cost of
power generation Is INR 3.9/KwH.

Decarbonising India: Charting a pathway for sustainable growth 51


The power sector today Renewables are increasingly wind power have led to the RE annual
competitive against coal: Most of capacity addition outpacing coal since
The power sector currently accounts
the emissions in the sector are from 2017.68 Government initiatives over
for around 35 percent of India’s total
coal-based thermal power plants, the past decade—such as holding
carbon emissions. Between 2011
which currently meet three-quarters reverse auctions, creating solar
and 2019, emissions increased from
of India’s power demand.65 However, parks and de-risking evacuation and
930 MtCO₂e to 1100 MtCO₂e—a
the share of coal generation in the offtake—have also attracted significant
CAGR of two percent,62 roughly half
power generation mix peaked in 2015 investment and enabled this shift.
the electricity demand growth in the
at 78 percent and has been declining
period.63 Demand for power is set to
since. 66 This decline is driven primarily
rise further as industry and transport
by exponential capacity growth in
electrify, increasing per capita
RE and its cost competitiveness
consumption from the current relatively
(Exhibit 10). India is a global leader in
low levels of around 1,200 kWh, just
RE development. In 2021, it had the
one-seventh of the Organisation
world’s fifth-highest global solar-power
for Economic Co-operation and
capacity and fourth-largest global
Development (OECD) average.64
solar and wind capacity.67 Rapid cost
declines in solar photovoltaic (PV) and

62
Historical emissions—UNFCCC
63
Climate action tracker (India); “Third biennial update report to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change,” Ministry of Environment, Forest and
Climate Change, Government of India, 2021.
64
“Per capita electricity generation,” Our World in Data.
65
India’s current capacity mix, Ministry of Power annual report, 2021–22
66
“India energy outlook,” IEA, 2021.
67
Country rankings, International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA).
68
Ministry of Power and Ministry of New and Renewable energy annual reports

Exhibit 10

The share of coal generation in the power mix has been declining due to capacity growth
in renewable energy.
Coal Other fossil1 Solar and wind Other non-fossil1 Wind Solar

Annual capacity addition for coal, solar & wind Generation Mix
GW %

16
15

3 5 6 7 8 9 9
11 11

9
8 8
7
7
78 77 77 77 75 74 75
4 4
4
3
1

FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 FY22 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 FY22

Source: India RE Navigator, Ministry of Power annual reports; Ministry of new and renewable energy; Government of India

52 Decarbonising India: Charting a pathway for sustainable growth


Solar tariffs in the range of INR 2–2.5/ Net zero is possible, but challenges
kWh are cheaper than the marginal remain: Reaching net zero is possible
cost of 60–70 percent of coal power in India only if the power sector builds
plants.69 Solar-wind-storage hybrid on and accelerates its energy-transition
plants that provide 85 percent round- momentum. We examine two scenarios
the-clock power on an annual basis—a for getting to net zero in the sector:
common definition of baseload RE in the LoS scenario and the Accelerated
India—have ex-bus bar tariffs between scenario (Exhibit 12). Both are realistic
INR 4–5/kWh. These RE-storage and would bring great benefits.
hybrids have reached parity with new- However, both scenarios would require
build coal plants, and it is expected that substantial investment, and major
they will be cheaper on a marginal cost challenges remain to be addressed—
basis than 30–50 percent of operating primarily through market and
coal plants by 2030 and 60–75 percent policy reform.
by 2040 (Exhibit 11).70

69
Ex-bus bar tariff excludes the cost of transmission and distribution. Analysis based on the unit-level coal plant variable cost; Data from RE navigator and Merit India
70
Analysis based on unit-level coal plant variable cost.

Exhibit 11

Cost of power from solar-wind-storage hybrids has reached parity with the full-cost of
new-build coal plants.
Comparison of coal plant variable cost curve LCOE comparison of baseload RE and coal
with RE tariffs in 2021, INR/kWh based generation, INR/kWh

Price
6.3 6.3
7 Full cost of
5.3 5.4 5.4 new build coal
6 5.0 plant
Solar-wind-storage hybrid 4.5 4.6
5
4.0–5.0 Coal plant
4.0 3.7 3.6 3.6
4 variable cost
3.9
3.1
Solar-wind hybrid1
3.4 3.4 RE-storage
3
2.7
2.9 hybrid LCOE2
Coal variable cost 2.5
2 2.4 2.5
Solar 2.1 2.2
1

0
0 40 80 120 160 200 240 2022 2030 2040 2050

1. Adani Hybrid Energy Jaisalmer commissioned a 390 MW solar-wind hybrid plant. The plant has a PPA with SECI at a tariff of ₹2.69/kWh.
2. The upper limit is hybrid levelised cost of energy (LCOE) with average capex and opex costs for solar, wind and storage; lower limit is hybrid LCOE with best-in-class
85% fulfilment.

Source: India RE Navigator, Merit India, McKinsey Power Model

Decarbonising India: Charting a pathway for sustainable growth 53


Exhibit 12

Both the LoS and the Accelerated scenarios are realistic—but would likely require
substantial investment.
Transmission & distribution Coal Other fossil1 Solar and wind Other non-fossil Storage2

LoS scenario

Non-fossil capacity at 400 GW by 2030 Coal reaches net zero by 2070


Capacity evolution until 2050, GW Generation mix, %

2,675 5 12 1 1 6
16 11
9 27
1,325 60 79
415
673 74 55
28 14
2022 2030 2040 2050 2022 2030 2040 2050

Emission peaks in the early 2030s $2.5 trillion investment required by 2050
CO2e emissions until 2050, Mt Investments in RE and storage until 2050, $ billions

1,268 1,273 1,288 2,502


1,125
931
793
783
431

2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2020–30 2030–40 2040–50 Total

Capacities by 2050: Solar – 1372 GW; Wind onshore – 364 GW; Hydro – 51 GW; Nuclear – 22 GW, Capacities by 2030: Solar – 204 GW; Wind onshore – 86 GW;
Hydro – 69 GW; Nuclear – 16 GW.

Accelerated scenario
Non-fossil capacity at 600 GW by 2030 Coal reaches net zero by 2050
Capacity evolution until 2050, GW Generation mix, %

5 12 4 14 1
11 6 1
4,019 9
44 74
1,939 94
872 74
415 38 14
2022 2030 2040 2050 2022 2030 2040 2050

Emission peaks in mid-2020s $3.8 trillion investment required by 2050


CO2e emissions until 2050, Mt Investments in RE and storage until 2050, $ billions

1,330 2,000 3,793


1,125
955
616 1,202
591
0
2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2020–30 2030–40 2040–50 Total

Capacities by 2030: Solar – 376 GW; Wind onshore – 102 GW; Hydro – 71 GW; Nuclear – 24 GW; Capacities by 2050: Solar – 2172 GW; Wind onshore – 536 GW;
Hydro – 54 GW; Nuclear – 22 GW.

1. Other fossil includes gas and oil; other non-fossil includes hydro, biomass and nuclear.
2. Storage includes battery, pumped hydro, LDES 8–24h, LDES 24h+ and hydrogen.

Source: McKinsey Power Model

54 Decarbonising India: Charting a pathway for sustainable growth


These challenges include but are not inter-state transmission charges and — Coal capacity: This is estimated to
limited to the poor financial health ambitious decarbonisation targets; a increase from its current 210 GW
of DISCOMs, power infrastructure well-developed, mature power and RE to peak at 240 GW by 2030, driven
upgrades to deal with infirm power, industry; the presence of large global by the completion of major projects
constraints in the RE supply chain and investors; and a growing trend among currently under construction or in
barriers to RE access for industrial industrial consumers to decarbonise advanced planning (Exhibit 14).72
consumers. The absence of ancillary their power. The LoS scenario assumes that
and capacity markets in India shows there would be minimal to nil coal
In this scenario, emissions may rise for
that India’s market structures are still capacity addition after 2030—but
another decade, as coal generation
not ready to integrate large amounts of also no forced plant retirements,
is expected to increase modestly to
RE.71 The fact of a relatively young coal as cheaper coal capacity could be
provide continuous power and balance
fleet (the average age of coal-powered maintained at an average plant load
the grid till RE-storage hybrid ramps
plants is 14 years) will need to be kept in factor (PLF) of 60 percent.
up. Correspondingly, emissions would
mind while developing India’s road map
peak in the early 2030s at 1.3 GtCO₂e. — Solar and wind capacity: This
to net-zero emissions.
Emission intensity would, however, is expected to increase from the
gradually decrease from 0.77 kgCO₂e/ current 95 GW in 2021 to 300
The LoS scenario kWh in 2020 to 0.52 kgCO₂e/kWh by GW by 2030, with 20–25 GW
It is feasible for India to achieve net- 2030. This transition would be built annually. This is achievable,
zero emissions by 2070 in an LoS enabled by: considering India has succeeded
scenario. Several factors put India’s in adding 10–12 GW per year over
power sector on a strong footing the past five years (excluding some
to reach its decarbonisation goals: periods affected by the COVID-19
favourable economics; strong policy pandemic) 73 and is further scaling its
backing, including the waiver of renewable capacity.

71
90 percent of power in India is still provided via long-term power purchase agreements (PPAs), the majority of which are for baseload. The share of wholesale or
traded power, peak PPAs and shaped PPAs is very low. Time-of-day pricing, which is needed to achieve demand-side flexibility, is also not dynamic or adequate in
many places.
72
Based on the McKinsey power model (detailed in the Box 1). Currently, 29 GW of coal power plant capacity is under construction and 20 GW of capacity is planned.
By 2030, it is expected that 18 GW of coal power plants will be retired, which entails a net increase of 30 GW by 2030.
73
Solar energy, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, Government of India.

Exhibit 13

Key assumptions made in the LoS and Accelerated scenarios for power sector analysis.

LoS scenario Accelerated scenario

• Demand growth of 5% till 2050 (including hydrogen • Higher demand growth rate of 6% till 2050 due
demand); without hydrogen demand growth at 4% till to faster electrification of industry and transport
2050
• No new coal plants built other than plants
• Coal capacity increases from 210 GW currently to already under construction. Coal capacity peaks
peak at 240 GW by 2030 driven by completion of in mid-2020s, and is 190 GW in 2030
plants which are under-construction and in advanced
• Most coal plants become uneconomical by mid-
planning stage
2040s and are retired. End of life for coal plants
• No accelerated decommissioning of coal plants, coal assumed to be 10 years less (30-40 years)
plants are retired when they reach their end of life
• Wind and solar capacity addition assumed not to
(40-50 years)
be constrained by land availability, equipment
• Wind and solar capacity addition assumed not to be and other factors
constrained by land availability, equipment and other
• Nuclear capacity is assumed to increase from
factors
7 GW in 2021 to minimum 15 GW by 2030 and
• Nuclear capacity is assumed to increase from 7 GW in 20 GW by 2040. Wind Offshore is assumed to
2021 to minimum 15 GW by 2030 and 20 GW by reach 5 GW by 2030, 15 GW by 2040 and 30
2040. Wind Offshore is assumed to reach 5 GW by GW by 2050
2030, 15 GW by 2040 and 30 GW by 2050

Decarbonising India: Charting a pathway for sustainable growth 55

You might also like