You are on page 1of 17

Sistema de Educación Media Superior

Escuela Preparatoria 9

The assessment process for the Teamwork is composed of two parts. The first will be peer evaluation where every member in a
team will evaluate his peers in the same team. The second will be done by the course instructor or the assessment committee which will depend
mainly on the final report and log book submitted by each group. These rubrics are designed for evaluating the role of individuals in acquiring this
skill.

Peer Evaluation Rubrics:

CO-EVALUATION

Category 2 1.5 1 0.5

Contributions Routinely provides useful Usually provides useful ideas Sometimes provides useful ideas Rarely provides useful ideas
ideas when participating in when participating in the when participating in the group when participating in the
the group and in classroom group and in classroom and in classroom discussion. A group and in classroom
discussion. A leader who discussion. A strong group satisfactory group member who discussion. May refuse to
contributes a lot of effort. member who tries hard! does what is required. participate.

Problem-solving Actively looks for and Refines solutions suggested Does not suggest or refine Does not try to solve problems
suggests solutions to by others. solutions, but is willing to try out or help others solve problems.
problems. solutions suggested by others.
Lets others do the work.

Attitude Is never publicly critical of Is rarely publicly critical of Is occasionally publicly critical of Is often publicly critical of the
the project or the work of the project or the work of the project or the work of other project or the work of other
others. Always has a positive others. Often has a positive members of the group. Usually members of the group. Is often
attitude about the task(s). attitude about the task(s). has a positive attitude about the negative about the task(s).
task(s).
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

Focus on the Consistently stays focused on Focuses on the task and Focuses on the task and what Rarely focuses on the task and
the task and what needs to what needs to be done most needs to be done some of the what needs to be done. Lets
task be done. Very self-directed. of the time. Other group time. Other group members must others do the work.
members can count on this sometimes nag, prod, and remind
person. to keep this person on task.

Working with Almost always listens to, Usually listens to, shares, Often listens to, shares with, and Rarely listens to, shares with,
shares with, and supports with, and supports the supports the efforts of others, and supports the efforts of
Others the efforts of others. Tries to efforts of others. Does not but sometimes is not a good others. Often is not a good
keep people working well cause "waves" in the group. team member. team player.
together.
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

Self-Evaluation

Learn Unit:_______________________________________________________________________________

Grade:_____ Group:_____ Turn:_________ Date:____________________________

Student’s name:__________________________________________________________________________________

Teacher’s name: _________________________________________________________________________________


The performance of the students. The generic competences are valued by them within their learning space (classroom), their activities and interactions with other
partners, it is considered: A = very good, B = good, C = bad, D = very bad or insufficient and E = you do not have the relevant competence.
Assessment
areas to evaluate activities A B C D E

1. I clearly understood the objectives, purposes and competences to achieve in each of the Units of
Competence of the course.
2. I participated in debates and discussions among my classmates and in the Online Forum.
Communication 3. I listened to the points of view and participated in the free exhibition of ideas and opinions.
4. I participated actively in class, and contributed ideas and points of view in feedback activities, as well as
in plenary sessions.
5. Resolved doubts about my interventions in class.
6. I participated in class activities and extraclass that the teacher promoted.
1. I acquired new knowledge through individual and collaborative work.
2. I used different learning strategies, and built my own knowledge through various information sources.

3. I completed assignments, assignments and exams in a timely manner.


Educational
processes 4. Develop self-reflection promoted by the teacher and build from it, ideas and concepts.
5. I used technological resources to facilitate the understanding and learning of the topics.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

6.- I researched, analyzed and applied information from different printed or digital bibliographic sources of
the topics that were discussed in the course.

7. I used the information discussed in class at different times in my daily life.


8. I used the educational materials available to carry out the activities in class (Guides, manuals, readings,
etc.).
1. I respected the diversity of beliefs, values, ideas and social practices among my classmates and the
teacher.

2. I used dialogue as a mechanism to resolve differences or discrepancies between my colleagues and the
teacher.
Attitudes and Values 3. I complied with the rules of work and coexistence that were agreed upon in class.
4. I developed a civic, ethical and ecological awareness, as well as an interest in my school, my community
and my global environment.
5. I expressed my opinions in a framework of respect and tolerance.
6.- My performance in class contributed to a better learning.

Comments and recommendations:

Very good class and excelent teacher

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

RUBRIC FOR PORTFOLIO

Portfolio OPTIMUM SUFFICIENT ADVANCED BASIC INSUFFICIENT


Evaluative
Criteria
Students Expectations Portfolio gives Portfolio gives Portfolio gives Portfolio gives Portfolio lacks all knowledge
knowledge and knowledge and knowledge and knowledge and of the 5 or more Students
personal examples personal examples of personal examples of personal Expectations
of all Students all Students at least 5 of the examples of at
Expectations Expectations Students least 3 of the
Expectations Students
Expectations
Shows knowledge of The use of The use of readings The use of readings There is very There is no use of course
readings and course readings and and course materials and course materials little use of materials through each
material course materials are evident through are somewhat course materials assignment
are evident each assignment evident through each through each
through each assignment assignment a
assignment
Communication All assignments All assignments are Most assignments Some None of the assignments are
are well written well written and are well written and assignments are well written and
and communicate communicate communicate well written and communicate information
information and information and ideas information and communicate and ideas clearly
ideas clearly clearly ideas clearly information and
ideas clearly
Critical Thinking Assignments Assignments Assignments Assignments Assignments demonstrate
demonstrate demonstrate demonstrate show some limited critical thinking
considerable considerable critical considerable critical critical thinking
critical thinking thinking and provide thinking skills skills
and provide links links to resources /
to resources / examples that extend
examples that beyond scope of
extend beyond course.
scope of course.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

RUBRIC FOR PORTFOLIO


Spelling and Grammar Portfolio has no Portfolio has no Portfolio has few Portfolio has Portfolio has multiple
spelling or spelling or spelling or several spelling spelling or grammatical
grammatical errors grammatical errors grammatical errors or grammatical errors
errors
I Integrity Portfolio Portfolio responses Portfolio responses Portfolio Portfolio responses are
responses accept accept all points of are considerate of responses show disrespectful towards others
all points of views. views. The portfolio differing viewpoints. some and their points of view.
The portfolio demonstrates the Portfolio highlights consideration of Portfolio does not exemplify
demonstrates the integrity and sense of the integrity and and differing the integrity and sense of
integrity and sense community through sense of community, viewpoints community.
of community personal examples. with or without Portfolio begins
through personal personal examples. to touch upon
examples. the integrity and
sense of
community.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Speech Rubric
Criterion Rating Rating Rating Rating Score
Excellent Good Satisfactory Needs Improvement
Points 10-9 Points 9-8 Points 8-7 Points 7-6
Introductio (1) Gets attention Meets any three of the Meets any two of the four Meets only one of the four
n (2) Clearly identifies topic four criteria criteria criteria
(3) Establishes credibility
(4) Previews the main points
Body Main points are clear, Main points are Main points Main points
well supported, and somewhat clear, need clarity are not clear
sources are documented some support, and and support and have no support
some documentation lack of and no sources or
sources and documentation
documentation
Conclusion (1) Reviews main points Reviews main points , Brings closure Does not bring closure; the
(2) Brings closure brings audience is left hanging
(3) Memorable closure
Use of Use of language contributes to Use of language does not Use of language causes Use of language is
Language effectiveness of the speech, have negative impact, and potential confusion, inappropriate
and vocalized pauses vocalized pauses and/or vocalized pauses
(um uh er etc.) (um uh er etc.) (um uh er etc.)
not distracting not distracting are distracting

Body Body language, gestures, and Body language, Body language, Body language, gestures, and
language facial expressions gestures, and facial facial expressions and facial expressions are lacking or
adds greatly to the message expressions compliment gestures inappropriate
message lack variety and
spontaneity

Clarity Speaks clearly and distinctly all Speaks clearly and Speaks clearly and Often mumbles or can not be
the time with no distinctly nearly all the distinctly most of the time understood with more than
mispronounced words time with no more than with no more than two three mispronounced words
one mispronounced word mispronounced words
Topic is Topic is specific, Topic is clear appropriate Topic lacks clarity No specific
specific, appropriate and and and focus purpose--inappropriate for
adapted somewhat adapted needs adapting to audience or
Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
http://moodleprepa9.sems.udg.mx, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg. mx
follows audience occasion
assignment
Adapted to
audience
Visual Aids Visual aids well chosen and Minor problems with Significant problems with No visual aids
presented visual aids visual aids
Time Within allotted time Within 10% of allotted Within 20% of allotted Not within 20% of allotted time
time time

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
http://moodleprepa9.sems.udg.mx, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg. mx
Points Score Points Score Points Score
90 15 59 9.83 28 4.67
89 14.8 58 9.67 27 4.5
88 14.67 57 9.5 26 4.33
87 14.5 56 9.33 25 4.17
86 14.33 55 9.17 24 4
85 14.17 54 9 23 3.83
84 14 53 8.83 22 3.67
83 13.83 52 8.67 21 3.5
82 13.67 51 8.5 20 3.33
81 13.5 50 8.33 19 3.17
80 13.33 49 8.17 18 3
79 13.17 48 8 17 2.83
78 13 47 7.83 16 2.67
77 12.83 46 7.67 15 2.5
76 12.67 45 7.5 14 2.33
75 12.5 44 7.33 13 2.17
74 12.33 43 7.17 12 2
73 12.17 42 7 11 1.83
72 12 41 6.83 10 1.67
71 11.83 40 6.67 9 1.5
70 11.67 39 6.5 8 1.33
69 11.5 38 6.33 7 1.17
68 11.33 37 6.17 6 1
67 11.17 36 6 5 0.83
66 11 35 5.83 4 0.67
65 10.83 34 5.67 3 0.5
64 10.67 33 5.5 2 0.33
Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
http://moodleprepa9.sems.udg.mx, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg. mx
63 10.5 32 5.33 1 0.17
62 10.33 31 5.17 0 0
61 10.17 30 5
60 10 29 4.83

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
http://moodleprepa9.sems.udg.mx, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg. mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

RUBRIC FOR VIDEO

VIDEO 20 10 5 1
EVALUATIVE EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR WEAK
CRITERIA NEED IMPROVEMENT LOW PERFORMANCE
CONTENT It covers all the topics in It includes basic It includes essential The content includes
depth with details and knowledge about the information about the minor details and has
examples. The knowledge topic. The content seems topic, but I has 1- 2 several mistakes in the
of the topic is excellent. to be good. mistakes in the facts. fact.
ORIGINALITY The product shows great The product shows Uses ideas from other He/ she uses ideas from
originality. The ideas are certain originality. It people (quoting them), but other people without
creative and witty. shows of new ideas and there is little evidence of quoting them.
shrewdness. original ideas.
USE OF LANGUAGE There are not any mistakes Three or fewer spelling Four spelling of grammar More than four spelling or
in spelling or grammar. mistakes or punctuation mistakes. grammar mistakes.
mistakes.
VIDEOGRAPHY INTEREST A lot of different shots, Several (2-4) and One or two different Little efforts have been
different scenography and different shoots, shoots, little use of made.
costumes, and adecuate different scenography scenography and costumes
use of creativity and and costumes, and use (1-2) little of creativity and
originallity. of creativity and originallity
originallity.
VIDEOGRAPHY CLARITY The ocerall quality of the Most of the quality of The quality of the video is The quality and the focus
video and the focus were the video and the focus not very good but overall are not very good.
excellent were good, but still some focus was excellent.
things missing.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

SCHOOL YEARBOOK
15 10 5 1
CRITERIA EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR WEAK
PHYSICAL FEATURES All features in the yearbook Most features in the Many features in the Many features in the
1. School background are drawn correctly. There is yearbook are correct. yearbook are NOT correct. yearbook are NOT correct.
2. Student’s stages (Past, 3 different stages per There is 2 different stages There is 1 stage per There are not any stages per
present, future)** student (past, present and per student (past, present student (past, present or student.
future) or future) future)
3. Group Memories
4. Goodbye
ACCURATE DEFINITIONS All physical features are Most physical features are Many physical features are Many physical features are
AND LABELS defined correctly. All physical defined correctly. All NOT defined correctly or NOT defined correctly or
features are correctly physical features are NOT labeled correctly. NOT labeled correctly.
labeled. correctly labeled. Information is missing. Information is missing.
Information is missing.
NEATNESS AND COLOR There are at least 30 There are less than 30 There are at least 10 There are no pictures of the
AND IMAGES different pictures of the different pictures of the different pictures of the whole group during the six
whole group during the six whole group during the six whole group during the six semesters.
semesters. All the work is semesters. semesters. Work is sloppy or lacks
neat and colorful. Pictures Most work is neat and Most work is not neat and pictures and captions are
and captions are easy to colorful. Pictures and colorful. Pictures and not understandable or
read. captions are easy to read. captions are difficult to readable.
read.
SPELLING / GRAMMAR All physical features are Most physical features are Most physical features are Many physical features are
written correctly. The written correctly. The NOT written correctly. The NOT written correctly. The
grammar and information grammar and information grammar and information grammar and information
are well written. are quite well written. are NOT well written. are NOT well written.
CREATIVITY Very creative and time Quite creative and Not that creative and not Not creative and not
organized. organized. that organized. organized.

**2.1 (Name, age, hobbies, tastes, likes and dislikes, where were you born, a memory from your past, favorite subjects, favorite song or movie at the moment…)
**2.2 (What do you like about school, friends, family, how do you spend time now, what High School has meant to you…) **2.3 (What are you planning to do after
High School, projects, dreams, resolutions, etc)

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl,
Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

Didactic Game // Rally Rubric


Student: _______________________________ Date: _________

Excellent Good Fear Weak


Criteria

1. Team work Each one contributed to his/her Student contributes to the team Good job individually, however, Student only works individually.
team; he/she always helped individually; however, he/she he/she collaborated little with
his/her teammates. didn´t always collaborate. his/her group.

2. Diagrams, Very clear and detailed, they Very detailed, but students Diagram, drawing or element The diagram, drawing or game
drawings and help a lot so that the student need a little more organization for the game meet the element have very little
elements for understands what must be and clarity. objectives but needs to be information and is not easy to
the game. done. improved. understand.

3. Use of The student and his/her team Some details were missing Some steps present errors Many errors in procedure and
language perform correctly explaining the regarding the use of the English during the procedure and the order of use of the English
procedure in English. language during the use of the English language. language.
proceedings.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

4. Creativity The procedure was very Quite creative but some details Not that creative and some Nothing creative and has many
creative in terms of order and were missing in terms of order steps have errors in the order errors in order and execution.
execution. and execution. and execution.

5. Use of The student and his/her team Some details were missing They lacked many details Lots of mistakes in English
English correctly use English grammar regarding the correct use of regarding the correct use of grammar and vocabulary in
grammar and and vocabulary in their game English grammar and English grammar and their game and they don't invite
vocabulary and invite their classmates to vocabulary in their game, and vocabulary in their game and their classmates to practice it.
practice it. they invite their classmates to they do not invite their
practice it. classmates to practice it.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52] [33-3684-4174], Web:
www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9
ATTITUDES AND VALUES RUBRIC

Attitudes / Optimal Sufficient Advanced Basic Deficient


Values

Hands in tasks Hands in tasks Hands in tasks Hands in tasks Hands in tasks
on time and on time and on time and on time and on time and
completes 100% completes 90% completes 75% completes 60% completes 50%
of the activities in of the activities in of the activities in of the activities in of the activities
a neat and a neat and a neat and a neat and Lacks neatness
Attitudes organized organized organized organized and organization.
towards manner. manner. manner. manner.
Classwork
Participates in Participates in Participates in
Participates in
events related to events related to events related to
Participates in events related to
the subject. the subject. the subject.
events related to the subject.
the subject.

Attends to 100% Attends to 90% Attends to 75% Attends to 60% Attends to less
of clases in a of clases in a of clases in a of clases in a than 60% of
Punctuality
punctual way. punctual way. punctual way. punctual way. clases in a
punctual way.

100% of clases: 90% of clases: 75% of clases: 50% of clases: Less than 50% of
the classes:
Maintains a Maintains a Maintains a Maintains a
positive attitude, positive attitude, positive attitude, negative attitude, Maintains a
Cooperative and collaborates with collaborates with collaborates with does not negative attitude,
Collaborative responsibility. responsibility. responsibility. collaborates with does not
learning responsibility. collaborates with
Works very well Works well in Works partially responsibility.
in teams. teams. well in teams. Works partially
well in teams. Does not work in
teams.

Promotes a Promotes a Promotes a Promotes a Promotes a


respectful respectful respectful respectful disrespectful
atmosphere atmosphere atmosphere atmosphere atmosphere
among team among team among team among team among team
Respect
mates, teacher mates, teacher mates, teacher mates, teacher mates, teacher
and classmates and classmates and classmates and classmates and classmates
in all the tasks. in the majority of in most in rare ocassions. in most
tasks. ocassions. ocassions.

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax [52]
[33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
Sistema de Educación Media Superior
Escuela Preparatoria 9

RUBRIC FOR BOOK


ADVANCED
OPTIMUM SUFFICIENT BASIC INSUFFICIENT

Use Vocabulary The sentences and All sentences are Most are Many fragments
correctly are complete, complete with well-constructed are poorly made.
The sentences and are built well and built well (There sentences.
complete, built well and good structure isn’t fragments Exercises need
good structure from sentences, some work.
it’s not written
fastly.) The
exercises are
made correctly-
The student does the student The student The student
Orthographically well not make commits ONE OR commits THREE commits four or
The student does not grammatical TWO grammatical OR FOUR more grammatical
make grammatical errors errors grammatical errors
errors errors.

Develops activities of Performs all Not perform two Not perform FOUR Not perform FIVE
HIS/HER choice activities of the activities of the activities of the or more activities
Performs all activities of unit. unit. unit of the unit.
the unit.

Underline or circle the Underline Underline or circle Underline or circle Just underline or
most important important almost the most some Outstanding circle or he/she
Underline important concepts or ideas. important. concept or idea. uses it too much.
concepts or ideas

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax
[52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx
RUBRIC FOR
BOOK
OPTIMUM SUFFICENT ADVANCED BASIC INSUFFICIENT

Use Vocabulary The sentences and All sentences are Most are Many fragments
correctly are complete, complete with well-constructed are poorly made.
The sentences and are built well and built well (There sentences.
complete, built well and good structure isn’t fragments Exercises need
good structure from sentences, some work.
it’s not written
fastly.) The
exercises are
made correctly-

The student does the student The student The student


Orthographically well not make commits ONE OR commits THREE commits four or
The student does not grammatical TWO grammatical OR FOUR more grammatical
make grammatical errors errors grammatical errors
errors errors.

Develops activities of Performs all Not perform two Not perform FOUR Not perform FIVE
HIS/HER choice activities of the activities of the activities of the or more activities
Performs all activities of unit. unit. unit of the unit.
the unit.

Underline or circle the Underline Underline or circle Underline or circle Just underline or
most important important almost the most some Outstanding circle or he/she
Underline important concepts or ideas. important. concept or idea. uses it too much.
concepts or ideas

Av. Mateo del Regíl y Tlalpan s/n, Col. El Briseño, C.P. 45236, Zapopan, Jalisco, México. Teléfonos [52] [33-3686-9113] Fax
[52] [33-3684-4174], Web: www.prepa9.sems.udg.mx/p9_mdl, Facebook: Prepa9/UDG, E-mail:prepa9@sems.udg.mx

You might also like