You are on page 1of 70

CAPITAL BUDGETING &

TRANSFER PRICING
A Review Presentation
CAPITAL
Definition & Importance
Criteria/Methods

BUDGETING Problem-Solving
Techniques & Shortcuts
DefinitionOInvest
& Importance

Long-term Asset Invested Funds Future Benefits


CRITERIA/Methods
OInvest

Non-Discounting Discounting

Payback Period Discounted Payback Period


Accounting Rate of Return Net Present Value
Profitability Index
Internal Rate of Return
Payback
OInvest Period

Ilang taon bago mabalik


puhunan ko?

LOTS Formula

L = Lower year
O–T
L+
O = Outlay

S
T = Total inflows until lower year
S = Subsequent inflow
Payback
OInvest Period

Ilang taon bago mabalik


puhunan ko?
Year
Steps
1. Get total cumulative inflows per year ≤ outlay.
2. Identify LOTS.
a. LOWER year
b. OUTLAY
c. TOTAL inflows until lower year
d. SUBSEQUENT inflow after lower year
3. Use formula.
Payback
OInvest Period

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱250,000 on a long-term 0 (250,000)
asset.
1 40,000

The expected cash benefits 2 60,000

are given on the right. 3 70,000

4 56,000
What is the payback period?
5 64,000
Payback
OInvest Period
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow Cumulative
₱250,000 on a long-term 0 (250,000) (250,000)
asset.
1 40,000 40,000

The expected cash benefits 2 60,000 100,000

are given on the right. 3 70,000 170,000

4 56,000 226,000
What is the payback period?
5 64,000 290,000
Payback
OInvest Period
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Cumulative
Outlay 0 (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 40,000
Total inflows
until lower year 2 60,000 100,000

3 70,000 170,000

Lower year 4 56,000 226,000

Subsequent inflow 5 64,000 -


Payback
OInvest Period
StepOInvest
3
Varying annual inflows
LOTS Formula
Year Cash Flow Cumulative

O–T 0 (250,000) (250,000)

L+
S
1 40,000 40,000

2 60,000 100,000

3 70,000 170,000

4 56,000 226,000
250k – 226k
4+ 5 64,000 –
64k

PP = 4.375 years
Bailout
OInvestPeriod

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow Salvage Value
₱250,000 on a long-term asset.
0 (250,000) (250,000)

The expected cash benefits are 1 40,000 100,000


given on the right. The salvage
2 60,000 80,000
value is ₱100,000 and
decreases by ₱20,000 annually. 3 70,000 60,000

4 56,000 40,000
What is the bailout period?
5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 100,000

2 60,000 80,000

3 70,000 60,000

4 56,000 40,000

5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000

3 70,000 60,000

4 56,000 40,000

5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000 180,000

3 70,000 60,000

4 56,000 40,000

5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000 180,000

3 70,000 60,000 230,000

4 56,000 40,000

5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000)

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000 180,000

3 70,000 60,000 230,000

4 56,000 40,000 266,000

5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000) Outlay

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000 180,000

Lower year 3 70,000 60,000 230,000 Total inflows


until lower year
Subsequent 4 56,000 40,000 266,000
inflow
5 64,000 20,000
Bailout
OInvestPeriod
StepOInvest
3
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow Salvage Value Cumulative
0 (250,000) (250,000) (250,000) Outlay

1 40,000 100,000 140,000

2 60,000 80,000 180,000

Lower year 3 70,000 60,000 230,000 Total inflows


until lower year
Subsequent 4 56,000 40,000 266,000
inflow
5 64,000 20,000

250k – 230k
3+ = 3.357
56k
DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period

Just add
Year one step!
Steps
1. Get the present value for each year.
2. Get total cumulative inflows per year ≤ outlay.
3. Identify LOTS.
a. LOWER year
b. OUTLAY
c. TOTAL inflows until lower year
d. SUBSEQUENT inflow after lower year
4. Use formula.
DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱250,000 on a long-term 0 (250,000)
asset.
1 40,000

The expected cash benefits 2 60,000

are given on the right. 3 70,000

4 56,000
The firm's cost of capital is
5 64,000
4%. What is the discounted
payback period?
DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period
StepOInvest
1
Discounted annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow PV
₱250,000 on a long-term 0 (250,000) (250,000)
asset.
1 40,000 38,462

The expected cash benefits 2 60,000 55,473

are given on the right. 3 70,000 62,230

4 56,000 47,689
The firm's cost of capital is
5 64,000 52,603
4%. What is the discounted
payback period?
DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period
StepOInvest
2
Discounted annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year PV Cumulative
₱250,000 on a long-term 0 (250,000) (250,000)
asset.
1 38,462 38,462

The expected cash benefits 2 55,473 93,935

are given on the right. 3 62,230 156,165

4 47,689 203,854
The firm's cost of capital is
5 52,603 –
4%. What is the discounted
payback period?
DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period
StepOInvest
3
Discounted annual inflows
Year PV Cumulative
Outlay 0 (250,000) (250,000)

1 38,462 38,462
Total inflows
until lower year 2 55,473 93,935

3 62,230 156,165

Lower year 4 47,689 203,854

Subsequent inflow 5 52,603 –


DISCOUNTEDOInvest
Payback Period
StepOInvest
4
LOTS Formula Discounted annual inflows
Year PV Cumulative

O–T 0 (250,000) (250,000)

L+
S
1 38,462 38,462

2 55,473 93,935

3 62,230 156,165

4 47,869 204,033
250,000 –
204,033
4+ 5 52,603 –
52,603

PP = 4.874 years
Payback
OInvest Period

Constant annual inflows Varying annual inflows 4% Discounted annual inflows

Year Cash Flow Year Cash Flow Year Cash Flow

0 (250,000) 0 (250,000) 0 (250,000)

1 58,000 1 40,000 1 38,462

2 58,000 2 60,000 2 55,473

3 58,000 3 70,000 3 62,230

4 58,000 4 56,000 4 47,869

5 58,000 5 64,000 5 52,603

PP = 4.310 years PP = 4.375 years PP = 4.874 years


Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

Sa puhunan ko, ilang % ang


magiging profit ko?

Initial Average
investment investment

APAT APAT APAT = Average profit after tax

AFAM AFAM + TV AFAM = Average fixed assets maintained


2 TV = Terminal value
Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

How good will this investment


be based on accounting profit?

Year
Steps
1. Calculate:
a. Average profit after tax
b. Average fixed assets maintained
2. Use formula.
Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

After-tax profit & fixed assets


The annual profit after tax Year APAT AFAM
and fixed assets maintained 1 20,000 90,000
from a specific investment is
2 22,000 80,000
shown on the right.
3 24,000 70,000

What is the investment's 4 26,000 60,000


average rate of return? 5 28,000 50,000
Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

StepOInvest
1
After-tax profit & fixed assets
The annual profit after tax Year APAT AFAM
and fixed assets maintained 1 20,000 90,000
from a specific investment is
2 22,000 80,000
shown on the right.
3 24,000 70,000

What is the investment's 4 26,000 60,000


simple rate of return? 5 28,000 50,000

Average 24,000 70,000


Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

StepOInvest
2
APAT–AFAM Formula After-tax profit & fixed assets
Year APAT AFAM

APAT 1 20,000 90,000

AFAM 2 22,000 80,000

3 24,000 70,000

4 26,000 60,000
Based o
n
INITIAL i
24,000 nvestm 5 28,000 50,000
ent
70,000 Average 24,000 70,000

ARR = 34.29%
Accounting Rate of Return
OInvest

StepOInvest
2
APAT–AFAM Formula After-tax profit & fixed assets
Year APAT AFAM

APAT 1 20,000 90,000

AFAM 2 22,000 80,000

3 24,000 70,000

4 26,000 60,000
Based o
n
24,000 AVERAG
E inves
5 28,000 50,000
70,000 + 0 tment
Average 24,000 70,000
2

ARR = 68.58%
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
Magkano 'yung kita ko
pagkatapos ng investment?

NINO Formula (RATS–OWO)

Net Inflows (PV) – Inflows Outflows


Net Outflows (PV) Return of working capital Outlay
Annual after-tax inflows Working capital
Tax benefit from Overhaul
depreciation
Salvage value
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
Magkano 'yung kita ko
pagkatapos ng investment?

PV of 1 PV of OA

(1 + i)ᵗ 1 – (1 + i)ᵗ
i

nly for
Used o STANT
i = interest rate
t = number of years CON WS
L IN FLO
ANNU A
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
Magkano 'yung kita ko
pagkatapos ng investment?
Year
Steps
1. For each figure:
a. Which is it—inflow or outflow?
b. When did it occur?
c. What is the PV factor?
2. Calculate and sum up present values.
3. Use formula.
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest in hi-tech equipment
Year Cash Flow
requiring extensive training and testing.
0 (550,000)

It will be sold at the start of the 6th year for 1 (500,000)


₱50,000 when its book value is zeroed out.
2 450,000

Internal hurdle rate is 14%, and effective tax 3 350,000


rate is 40%.
4 350,000

Its projected after-tax cash flows per year are 5 350,000

on the right. What is the NPV?


NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest in hi-tech equipment
Year Cash Flow
requiring extensive training and testing.
0 (550,000)

It will be sold at the start of the 6th year for 1 (500,000)


₱50,000 when its book value is zeroed out.
2 450,000

Internal hurdle rate is 14%, and effective tax 3 350,000


rate is 40%.
4 350,000

Its projected after-tax cash flows per year are 5 350,000

on the right. What is the NPV? 5 30,000


NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow +/– When PVF
0 (550,000)

1 (500,000)

2 450,000

3 350,000

4 350,000

5 350,000

5 30,000
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow +/– When PVF
0 (550,000) –

1 (500,000) –

2 450,000 +

3 350,000 +

4 350,000 +

5 350,000 +

5 30,000 +
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow +/– When PVF
0 (550,000) – 0

1 (500,000) – 1

2 450,000 + 2

3 350,000 + 3

4 350,000 + 4

5 350,000 + 5

5 30,000 + 5
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow +/– When PVF
0 (550,000) – 0 1

1 (500,000) – 1 0.877

2 450,000 + 2 0.769

3 350,000 + 3 0.675

4 350,000 + 4 0.592

5 350,000 + 5 0.519

5 30,000 + 5 0.519
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
+/– Cash Flow PVF PV Sum
– (550,000) 1

– (500,000) 0.877

+ 450,000 0.769

+ 350,000 0.675

+ 350,000 0.592

+ 350,000 0.519

+ 30,000 0.519
NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
+/– Cash Flow PVF PV Sum
– (550,000) 1 (550,000)

– (500,000) 0.877 (438,500)

+ 450,000 0.769 346,050

+ 350,000 0.675 236,250

+ 350,000 0.592 207,200

+ 350,000 0.519 181,650

+ 30,000 0.519 15,570


NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
+/– Cash Flow PVF PV Sum
– (550,000) 1 (550,000)

– (500,000) 0.877 (438,500) (988,500)

+ 450,000 0.769 346,050

+ 350,000 0.675 236,250

+ 350,000 0.592 207,200

+ 350,000 0.519 181,650

+ 30,000 0.519 15,570 986,720


NET PRESENT
OInvest VALUE
StepOInvest
3
Varying annual inflows
+/– Cash Flow PVF PV Sum
– (550,000) 1 (550,000)

– (500,000) 0.877 (438,500) (988,500)

+ 450,000 0.769 346,050

+ 350,000 0.675 236,250

+ 350,000 0.592 207,200

+ 350,000 0.519 181,650

+ 30,000 0.519 15,570 986,720

NPV (1,780)
Profitability
OInvest Index
Ilang % 'yung kita ko
pagkatapos ng investment?

NINO (÷) Formula

Net Inflows (PV) Inflows Outflows


Net Outflows (PV) Return of working capital Outlay
Annual after-tax inflows Working capital
Tax benefit from Overhaul
depreciation
Salvage value
Profitability
OInvest Index
Ilang % 'yung kita ko
pagkatapos ng investment?
Year
Steps
1. For each figure:
a. Which is it—inflow or outflow?
b. When did it occur?
c. What is the PV factor?
2. Calculate and sum up present values.
3. Use formula.
Profitability
OInvest Index

Investment Projects
The firm is selecting from 3
Criteria A B C
possible projects shown on
the right. NPV 23,370 29,827 27,333

IRR 18.7% 17.6% 17.2%


Which is the best investment
Initial cost 200,000 235,000 190,000
in terms of profitability?
Profitability
OInvest Index

Investment Projects
The firm is selecting from 3
Criteria A B C
possible projects shown on
the right. NPV 23,370 29,827 27,333

IRR 18.7% 17.6% 17.2%


Which is the best investment
Initial cost 200,000 235,000 190,000
in terms of profitability?
Net inflows 223,370 264,287 217,333
Profitability
OInvest Index
StepOInvest
3
Investment Projects
The firm is selecting from 3
Criteria A B C
possible projects shown on
the right. NPV 23,370 29,827 27,333

IRR 18.7% 17.6% 17.2%


Which is the best investment
Initial cost 200,000 235,000 190,000
in terms of profitability?
PI 1.1169 1.1269 1.1439
Profitability
OInvest Index
StepOInvest
3
Investment Projects
The firm is selecting from 3
Criteria A B C
possible projects shown on
the right. NPV 23,370 29,827 27,333

IRR 18.7% 17.6% 17.2%


Which is the best investment
Initial cost 200,000 235,000 190,000
in terms of profitability?
PI 1.1169 1.1269 1.1439
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
Anong discount rate gagamitin
para maging 0 NPV?

NONIY Formula
Notes
Net Outflows Present values are not used.
Net Inflows
The formula will yield the PV factor
Years which you will use to find the IRR.
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
Anong discount rate gagamitin
para maging 0 NPV?

Year

Steps Lazy Steps


1. Use formula. 1. For each IRR in the choices:
2. Trace PV factor to table. a. If constant inflows, get PVF of OA.
3. Use trial and error or b. If uneven inflows, get PV of 1 for
interpolation. each year.
2. Calculate total NPV for each choice.
3. Pick the choice that would make NPV
closest to 0.
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return

Even annual inflows


A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 50,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 50,000

What is the IRR?


A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% D. 20%
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
1
Even annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 50,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 50,000

What is the IRR?


A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% D. 20%
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
1
Even annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 50,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 50,000

What is the IRR?


A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% – 2.0422 D. 20%
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
2
Even annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 50,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 50,000

What is the IRR? Choice PV of inflows NPV


A 100,565 565
A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% – 2.0422 D. 20% B 102,110 2,110
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
3
Even annual inflows
A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 50,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 50,000

What is the IRR? Choice PV of inflows NPV


A 100,565 565
A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% – 2.0422 D. 20% B 102,110 2,110
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return

Varying annual inflows


A firm would like to invest Year Cash Flow
₱100,000 on a long-term 1 40,000
asset. The expected cash
2 50,000
benefits are given on the
right. 3 60,000

What is the IRR?


A. 23% – 2.0113 C. 21%
B. 22% D. 20%
Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
1
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow 22% PVF 22% PV 21% PVF 21% PV
1 40,000 0.8197 32,788 0.8264 33,056

2 50,000 0.6719 33,595 0.6830 34,150

3 60,000 0.5507 33,042 0.5645 33,870

Sum 99,425 101,076


Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
2
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow 22% PVF 22% PV 21% PVF 21% PV
1 40,000 0.8197 32,788 0.8264 33,056

2 50,000 0.6719 33,595 0.6830 34,150

3 60,000 0.5507 33,042 0.5645 33,870

Sum 99,425 101,076

NPV (575) 1,076


Internal Rate
OInvest of Return
StepOInvest
3
Varying annual inflows
Year Cash Flow 22% PVF 22% PV 21% PVF 21% PV
1 40,000 0.8197 32,788 0.8264 33,056

2 50,000 0.6719 33,595 0.6830 34,150

3 60,000 0.5507 33,042 0.5645 33,870

Sum 99,425 101,076

NPV (575) 1,076

B
PP Formula ARR ARR
Initial Average

O–T APAT APAT


L+
S AFAM AFAM + TV
2

NPV Formula PI Formula IRR Formula


(RATS–OWO)
Net Inflows (PV)
Net Outflows
Net Inflows (PV) – Net Outflows (PV) Net Inflows
Net Outflows (PV) Years
TRANSFER
Definition & Importance
General Rule

PRICING Problem-Solving
Techniques & Shortcuts
DefinitionOInvest
& Importance

Proper signals Capacity Internal matter


General
OInvest Rule
Ano ba mawawala sa akin
kapag nagbenta ako sa amin?

Is there idle capacity?


Yes – Differential cost only
No – Differential cost + Opportunity cost

Minimum transfer price

Lost CM
VC +
# Units transferred
Excess Capacity
OInvest

Division A can produce 2,000 units and expects to sell 1,500


units. Division B desires to purchase 100 units from Division A.

Division A sells each unit at ₱100 per unit. Its variable cost is ₱25,
and fixed costs total ₱30,000.

What is the minimum transfer price?


Excess Capacity
OInvest

Division A can produce 2,000 units and expects to sell 1,500 units. Division B desires to
purchase 100 units from Division A.

Division A sells each unit at ₱100 per unit. Its variable cost is ₱25, and fixed costs total
₱30,000.

What is the minimum transfer price?

Lost CM
VC +
# Units transferred
Excess Capacity
OInvest

Division A can produce 2,000 units and expects to sell 1,500 units. Division B desires to
purchase 100 units from Division A.

Division A sells each unit at ₱100 per unit. Its variable cost is ₱25, and fixed costs total
₱30,000.

What is the minimum transfer price?

0
25 + = 25
100
At Capacity
OInvest

Division B is currently purchasing a part from an outside supplier.


Division A has no excess capacity and produces and sells this part
for ₱19 and ₱31, respectively.

If Division B buys from Division A, the latter can reduce its variable
cost on internal transfers by ₱3.

What transfer price would Division A establish?


At Capacity
OInvest

Division B is currently purchasing a part from an outside supplier. Division A has no


excess capacity and produces and sells this part for ₱19 and ₱31, respectively.

If Division B buys from Division A, the latter can reduce its variable cost on internal
transfers by ₱3.

What transfer price would Division A establish?

12
19 + = 31
1

You might also like