Republic of the Philippines

CAPIZ STATE UNIVERSITY

Fuentes Drive, Roxas City, Capiz, Philippines
Tel. No. (036) 6214-578 Fax No. (036) 6214-578
website: www.capsu.edu.ph email address: roxas@capsu.edu.ph

College of Engineering, Architecture and Technology

Title Defense Evaluation Form
Date : ______________________
Name of Presenter : ____________________________________________
Proposed Title : _____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________

Exceeds Expectations Meets Expectations Needs Improvement

Criteria
(10 points)
Clearly outlines a
significant problem to
Problem
be addressed with
Identification
strong supporting
evidence
Solution is highly
innovative, feasible,
Proposed Solution
and clearly addresses
the identified problem
Demonstrates critical
Background review of related work;
Research insightful connections
to proposed solution
Goals are Specific,
Measurable,
Project Goals
Achievable, Relevant
and Timed
Potential impact and
Impact and
outcomes are
Outcomes
significant and realistic
Engaging delivery with
smooth transitions;
Communication
visuals enhance
presentation
Proposal is Approved
(7-9 points)
Identifies a relevant
problem backed by
some evidence
Proposed solution is
reasonably innovative
and could solve the
problem
Sufficient preliminary
research presented to
inform proposed
solution
Goals are reasonably
well-defined in
SMART criteria
Outcomes have clear
value and are
achievable
Clear, organized
communication; easy to
follow with some
visual aids
TOTAL
Proposal is Rejected
Inadequate (1-3 points) Score
(4-6 points)
Problem is loosely Fails to identify a
described and lacks problem or justify
sufficient evidence importance
Solution has some
weaknesses in Lacks an innovative or
originality or appropriate solution
feasibility
Limited references to No evidence of
previous work related background research
to the problem provided
Goals lack some
Proposed goals are vague
specificity or are not
or poorly defined
fully SMART
Impact and outcomes Impact and expected
are uncertain or lack outcomes are unrealistic
substance or exaggerated
Delivery and
structure need more Disorganized; poor
polish; visuals are visuals or lack thereof
weak
Needs Revision

Evaluator’s Comment(s):
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________
Name and Signature of Evaluator
Accredited: Accrediting Agency of Chartered Colleges and Universities of the Philippines (AACCUP)
Member: Philippine Association of State Universities and Colleges (PASUC)
Agricultural Colleges Association of the Philippines (ACAP)