Professional Documents
Culture Documents
#'%$('$#
.?<D8E8><D<EKF=JFC@;N8JK<@J8E@JJL<K?8K:FE:<IEJ<M<IPFE<@EK?<NFIC; FEJLDGK@FE8E;N8JK<
D8E8><D<EK;<:@J@FEJD8;<9P@E;@M@;L8CJ8E;>FM<IED<EKJ?8M<8E@DG8:KFEK?<;8@CP?<8CK? FLKGLK
8E; :C<8EC@E<JJ F= :FDDLE@K@<J +FFI N8JK< D8E8><D<EK 8DFE> FK?<I K?@E>J @J ?8ID@E> 8E@D8CJ K?8K
LEBEFN@E>CP:FEJLD<N8JK< GFCCLK@E>K?<NFIC;JF:<8EJ :CF>>@E>;I8@EJN?@:?@EKLIE:8LJ<=CFF;@E>
JG8NE@E> ;@J<8J< :8IIP@E> M<:KFIJ @E:I<8J@E> I<JG@I8KFIP GIF9C<DJ ;L< KF 8@I9FIE< G8IK@:C<J =IFDN8JK<
@E:@E<I8K@FE ?@E;<I@E> <:FEFD@: ;<M<CFGD<EK K?IFL>? ;<:I<8J<; KFLI@JD 8E; DFI< .?<I< ?8J 9<<E 8
:FE:<IK<; <==FIK KF :FII<:KCP D8E8>< >8I98>< 8E; D@E@D@Q< K?< ;8D8>< :8LJ<; 9P @DGIFG<I N8JK<
D8E8><D<EK ?FN<M<IK?<J<D<K?F;J:8EJK@CC9<@DGIFM<;56
T*G<E 8@I :@KP :<EK<I ;LDGJ 8E @EJL==@:@<EK 8DFLEK F= JKI<<K C@KK<I 9@EJ 8E @DGI8:K@:8C N8JK< I<:P:C@E>
JPJK<D8E;I8DG8EKFM<ILJ<F=GC8JK@:>IF:<IP98>J8I<8CC<M@;<E:<K?8K8E>BFB?8J8?L><N8JK<8E;
N8JK<D8E8><D<EKGIF9C<D ,<:<EKCP K?<FM<I LJ8><8E;GIF;L:K@FEF=GC8JK@:?8M<:8L>?KK?<8KK<EK@FE
F=K?<GL9C@:LE8MF@;89C< :FEJ@;<I@E>K?8K8K:FEM@M<E:<JKFI<J JD8CC@K<DJ:8E9<=FLE;@E;@M@;L8CCP
G8:B<; 8E;K?8KJKI<<K=FF;M<E;FIJLJL8CCPLJ<KNFFIDFI<GC8JK@:98>JKF?8E;FLKK?<@I>FF;J 8E;
@E@K@8K@M<JKFI<;L:<GC8JK@:N8JK<?8M<9<<EJGI<8;KFK?<<EK@I<:8G@K8C:@KPU56 .?<J<@E@K@8K@M<J9<>@E
N@K?K?<JFLI:< JFIK@E>DLE@:@G8CN8JK<56
18JK<:8E9<J<G8I8K<;@EKFD8EP:8K<>FI@<J=FF; G8G<I D<K8C GC8JK@: <K: N?@:?:8E9<><E<I8C@Q<;@EKF
KNF;@==<I<EKJ<:K@FEJ9@F;<>I8;89C<8E;EFE9@F;<>I8;89C<56 !FIK?<J:FG<F=K?@JI<J<8I:? K?<=F:LJ@J
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 1
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
GC8:<;FE:C8JJ@=@:8K@FEF=EFE9@F;<>I8;89C<N8JK< N?@:?D8B<JLGF=K?<>CF98CN8JK<:FDGFJ@K@FE
56 .?< D<K?F; F= JKFI8>< =FI ><E<I8C N8JK< I<D8@E<; K?< J8D< =FI K?< G8JK ;<:8;<J FG<E ;LDG@E>
C8E;=@CCJ 8E;@E:@E<I8KFIJ '@D@K8K@FEJF=N8JK<JFIK@E>K<:?E@HL<JI<D8@EK?<D8AFIC@D@K@E>=8:KFIFEK?<
I<:P:C@E>@E;LJKIP :FDGI@J@E>K?<J:8C<F=K?<N?FC<@E;LJKIP !FI.?8@C8E;JG<:@=@:8CCP FG<E;LDG@E>@J
K?<;<=8LCKJFCLK@FE@ED8EP8I<8J56 C<8I<M@;<E:<?8JC@EB<;8;M<IJ<?<8CK?FLK:FD<JN@K?<==<:KJF=
C8E;=@CCJ @E:@E<I8KFIJ :FDGFJK@E>=8:@C@K@<J <K: .?@JGIFDGKJ8E8K@FE8C8E;>CF98C@E@K@8K@M<KFI<LJ<8E;
I<:P:C< N?@:?=LIK?<I@E:I<8J<JK?<E<<;=FI8E<==@:@<EK8E;8::LI8K<JFIK@E>F=N8JK<56
$EK?<N8JK<@E;LJKIP K?<I<8I<8=<N<O@JK@E>K<:?E@HL<JKFJFIKN8JK< .?<=@IJKK<:?E@HL<@JK?<D8EL8C
8GGIF8:? LJ@E>?LD8EC89FIKFJFIKK?<N8JK<@E;@M@;L8CCP8KKI8EJ=<IJK8K@FEJ5656 .?@JKPG<F=D<K?F;
:8EEFK9<J:8C<;8E;I<HL@I<J8CFE>K@D<KF:C8JJ@=P:FII<:KN8JK<KPG<J FE:<IEJ8I<8CJFI8@J<;89FLKK?@J
K<:?E@HL<;L<KFJ<M<I8C?<8CK?I@JBJKFK?<NFIB<IJ@EMFCM<;56
.?<J<:FE;K<:?E@HL<@JLK@C@Q@E>;@==<I<EKCPC89<CC<;I<:P:C@E>9@EJKF:FCC<:K;@==<I<EKKPG<JF=N8JK< .?@J
D<K?F;I<;L:<JK?<8DFLEKF=?LD8E<==FIKE<<;<;KF:C8JJ@=P8E;JFIK8::FI;@E>CP .?<=@IJKC@D@K8K@FEF=
K?@J 8GGIF8:? @J @KJ ;<G<E;8E:< FE K?< :FCC89FI8K@FE F= :@K@Q<EJ $E .?8@C8E; I<J<8I:? ?8J J?FNE K?8K 8
:FEJ@JK<EK F=K?<GFGLC8K@FEJ<>I<>8K<J8KC<8JKFE<KPG<F=N8JK<5656 !LIK?<I8E8CPJ@JF=K?@J
G<I:<EK8><@JE<:<JJ8IP9<:8LJ<GI@FII<J<8I:??8JJ?FNEK?8KG<FGC<=I<HL<EKCP<O8>><I8K<K?<@II<:P:C@E>
<==FIKJ 56 ::FI;@E> KF K?< I<JLCKJ F= 8E>BFB I<J@;<EKJ :C8@D<; K?8K =@E8E:@8C >8@E N8J K?<
GI@D8IP DFK@M8K@FE =FI JFLI:< J<G8I8K@FE N?@C< ;@; @K =FI <EM@IFED<EK8C I<8JFEJ 56 EFK?<I
@EK<I<JK@E>I<JLCK@J=FIK?FJ<N?FI<GFIK<;?8M@E>EFGI8:K@:<F=JFLI:<J<G8I8K@FE JK8K<;K?8KK?<P
?8; EF @EK<I<JK FI EF K@D< 8E; JK8K<; K?8K K?<P 9<C@<M<; @K N8J D<8E@E>C<JJ 8J K?<P ?8M< J<<E
DLE@:@G8C<DGCFP<<J:FD9@E@E>I<:P:C89C<JN@K?FK?<IKI8J? 56
.?<K?@I;K<:?E@HL<@JK?<@D8>@E>K<:?E@HL<N?@:?:C8JJ@=@<J>8I98><LJ@E>M8I@FLJ8IK@=@:@8C@EK<CC@><E:<
D<K?F;J LKFD8K@E> I<G<K@K@M< K8JBJ GIFM<J KF 9< DFI< <==<:K@M< K?8E ?LD8E C89FI N@K? 8E @E:I<8J@E>
8::LI8:P8JDFI<I<J<8I:?8E;;8K8@J=FLE;56 <<GC<8IE@E>8GGC@:8K@FEJ:8EJG<<;LGC@KK<I;<K<:K@FE
8E;JFIK@E><M<E=LIK?<I 08I@FLJD<K?F;J?8M<9<<ELJ<;N@K?M8IP@E>8::LI8:@<J56
.<:?E@HL<JLJ@E>K?<<D<I>@E>K<:?EFCF>P?8M<EFK9<<ELE@HL<KFKI8J?JFIK@E> 1@K?K?<I<:<EKKI<E;F=
;@>@K8C KI8EJ=FID8K@FE D8:?@E< C<8IE@E> FI ;<<G C<8IE@E> 98J<; M@J@FE @EJG<:K@FE JPJK<DJ 8I< 9<@E>
;<M<CFG<; 8E <O8DGC< F= N?@:? @J 9I@;>< JL9 JKIL:KLI< ;<K<:K@FE @E .?8@C8E; 5656 8J<; FE K?@J
I<J<8I:?LJ@E>))J=FIF9A<:K:C8JJ@=@:8K@FE K?@JI<J<8I:?@DGC<D<EKJ8J@D@C8I))DF;<C=FI>8I98><
JFIK@E>
E<O8DGC<F=K?@JK<:?E@HL<@J;<K8@C<;@EK?@JG8G<I9L@C;@E>8E@D8><:C8JJ@=@<ILJ@E>8:FEMFCLK@FE8C
E<LI8CE<KNFIB)):8CC<;3*'*M3FL*ECP'FFB*E:<8E;G@:KLI<JF=K?<N8JK<56 ))@J8
GFGLC8I8IK@=@:@8CE<LI8CE<KNFIBLJ<;@E8E8CPQ@E>@D8><J ))I<C8K@M<CPD@E@D@Q<JK?<GI< GIF:<JJ@E>
=FI8E@D8><;8K8J<K56 3*'*M@JDFI<<==@:@<EK8K;<K<:K@E>JD8CC@D8><JK?8EFK?<I:FDDFE))
9<:8LJ<3*'*M;<I@M<JK?<9FLE;8IP9FO<J8E;:C8JJGIF989@C@K@<J;@I<:KCP=IFDK?<@D8><G@O<CJ56
.?<I<N8J:FEJ@;<I8K@FEKFLJ<8G8:B8><;JF=KN8I<JL:?8J#'*)=IFD(0.<:-F=KN8I<K?8KGIF;L:<J
GIFD@J@E>I<JLCKJ '@B<3*'*M #'*)@J8))98J<;F9A<:K;<K<:K@FE?FN<M<I 3*'*M@JFG<E
JFLI:<>@M@E>K?<LJ<I<OKI8=C<O@9@C@KPKFDF;@=P8JK?<PJ<<=@K5656
*K?<II<J<8I:?=@E;@E>JLJ@E>3*'*M8E;+PKFI:?;<DFEJKI8K<;?@>?8::LI8:P;LI@E>;<GCFPD<EK N@K?
I<:8CC8E;GI<:@J@FE:CFJ<KF8E;8M<I8><D+8::LI8:PF=DFI<K?8E56 <JG@K<@KJ?FN@E>
GIFD@J@E>I<JLCKJ FECP;IP8E;N<K>8I98><8I<:C8JJ@=@<;8E;EFJL9:C8JJ<J=FID<K8C G8G<IGC8JK@:
2
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
.?<>F8CF=K?@JI<J<8I:?@JKF;<DFEJKI8K<K?<89@C@KPF=8IK@=@:@8C@EK<CC@><E:<:FDGLK<IM@J@FEKFJ<>I<>8K<
>8I98>< N?@:?NFLC;FK?<IN@J<9<8C89FI @EK<EJ@M<8E;<OG<EJ@M<K8JB
'%!&%)%#'$$!$*
(% O8DGC<@D8><JF=>8I98><@D8><J8+8G<I 9+C8JK@: :D<K8C
0$+)#$*
*+(()&)') $E.?8@C8E;G8G<ID8B<LGF=K?<KFK8CDLE@:@G8CJFC@;N8JK<
DFJKG8G<I@JI<:P:C89C<8E;:8E9<;@M<IK<;8N8P=IFDC8E;=@CCJ@K<J56
$*+# )0$#&! .?8@C8E;><E<I8K<J89FLKD@CC@FEKFEJF=GC8JK@:N8JK<8EEL8CCP N@K?
FECP KFEJI<:P:C<;@EF==@:@8CI<:P:C@E>=8:@C@K@<J J<G8I8K@E>GC8JK@:=FII<:P:C@E>@J
M@K8C56
+$)0$#&! CC>I8;<JF=EFE =<IIFLJ8E;=<IIFLJD<K8C:8E9<I<:P:C89C<=FI=LKLI<LJ<
.?@J@J9<:8LJ<D<K8CJ;FEKCFJ<HL8C@KPN?<EI<:P:C<; D<K8C:8E9<I<:P:C<;J<M<I8CK@D<J
FM<I56
,*+# #+#'& ') + '$$+#'& .?< @D8>@E> ;8K8 LJ<; =FI K?@J G8G<I N8J :FCC<:K<; 8E;
C89<CC<;D8EL8CCP9<:8LJ<JL@K89C<GL9C@:CP8M8@C89C<;8K8J<KJ;@;EFK<O@JK .?<;8K8J<K?FC;J
@D8><JF=I<:P:C<;KI8J?JG8EE@E>K?I<<;@==<I<EK:C8JJ<J @D8><JN@K?@E<8:?:C8JJM8I@<JN@K?
8M8@C89@C@KP "@M<EK?8KN8JK<@JG8JJ<;@EKFK?<J8D<:FEK8@E<I K?<8DFLEKF=M8I@8K@FE@E
F9A<:K@JC<JJJ@>E@=@:8EKKFDF;<CVJG<I=FID8E:<N?<E:FDG8I<;KFLJ@E>8GL9C@:GI< C89<CC<;
;8K8J<K
')+#&!"#&).)
"").)*+,(@JJ<G8I8K<;@EKFJ<:K@FEJ8$E9FO 9"I89@E 8E;:-FIK<;@EJ
N?@:?8I<8CCJ?FNE@E=@>LI<8E;;FEKIFCC<I N?@:?@JJ?FNE@E=@>LI<
3
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
(%@8>I8DF=K?<@E9FO8E;K?<JFIK<;9@EJ (% EEFK8K<; @D8>< F= K?< ,8JG9<IIP +@
:FEE<:K<;KFK?<9LKKFE9FO
+#-+#&!+" %).?<$E9FO:FEJ@JKJF=8C@>?K:LIK8@ELKFE@:J9NG 'F>@K<:?
N<9:8DN@K?8I@E>C@>?K 8E;8KI8G;FFIKF;IFGK?<F9A<:KKFK?<"I899@E8JJ?FNE
@E=@>LI< .?<C@>?K:LIK8@E@JLJ<;KF;<K<ID@E<N?<K?<IK?<>8I98><@JG8JJ<;@EKFK?<$E9FO
.?< :8D<I8 :8GKLI<J 8E @D8>< F= K?< >8I98>< @E K?< @E9FO 8E; J8M<J K?< @D8><J @E K?<
,8JG9<IIP+@ .?<:8D<I8@JDFLEK<;G8I8CC<CKFK?<GC8E<F=K?<>8I98><8K8GFJ@K@FE:D
=FFK89FM<K?<KI8G;FFI .?<I@E>C@>?K@JKF<EJLI<GIFG<I@CCLD@E8K@FE .?<:8D<I8@JJ<K
KF8LKF=F:LJN@K?K?<=I8D<8;ALJK<;KF9<N@K?8N@;K?G@O<CJ8E;?<@>?KG@O<CJ
.?<@D8><J8I<J8M<;8J8+)"=@C<+FIK89C<)<KNFIB"I8G?@:J .?<:FCFIF=K?<98:B>IFLE;
@JJ@CM<I.?<:FCFIF=K?<JK8@EC<JJ JK<<C9FO@EK?<@E9FO
(% @I:L@K;@8>I8DF=K?<:FDDLE@:8K@FEF=
K?<,8JG9<IIP+@KFK?<+'+IF>I8DD89C<'F>@:
@I:L@K
4
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
(% $D8><F=9@EJF=JFIK<;>8I98><
" ,++'& '/ !@>LI< :FEK8@EJ I<C8PJ N?@:? :CFJ< K?< JN@K:?<J .?< J:FG< F= K?@J
I<J<8I:?;<G<E;JFEK?<9I8@EF=K?<D8:?@E< K?<,8JG9<IIP+@!@>LI< .?<+@GIF:<JJFI
?8JHL8; :FI< JL==@:@<EKKFILEM@J@FEGI<;@:K@FE@ELE;<I8J<:FE; "+$*"<E<I8C+LIGFJ<
$EGLK*LKGLKG@EJF=K?<+@8I<K?<E:FEE<:K<;KF=FLI MFCKJI<C8PN?@:?N@CC8:K@M8K<K?<
D8:?@E< .?<>I899@E@J:FEKIFCC<;9PK?<+' N?@:?@J8:K@M8K<;9PGI<JJ@E>K?<9LKKFEFE
K?<9LKKFE9FO !@>LI<.?<,8JG9<IIP+@K?<EJ<E;J8?@>?J@>E8CKF K?<I<C8P9F8I;
N?@:?K?<EJ?FIK :@I:L@KJK?<9LKKFEKFJ@DLC8K<8GI<JJ@E>8:K@FE
+"''$'!0
")#&#($' +"')+#&!"#&9<>@EJN@K?K?<C@>?K:LIK8@E N?@:?@JLJ<;KF;<K<:KK?<
<EK<I@E> F= >8I98>< K?< C@>?K :LIK8@E @J KI@>><I<; N@K? K?< F9A<:K F9JKIL:K@E> K?< KNF C@>?K
>8K<J?8E; FI>8I98>< <EK<I@E>K?<@E9FO 8E;JKFGK?<KI@>><IFE:<K?<I<@JEFF9JK8:C<@E
K?<N8PF=K?<:LIK8@E GI<JLD89CP<@K?<IK?<?8E;@JK8B<EFLKF=K?<9FO FIK?<>8I98><@J
GC8:<;@EK?<@E9FO .?<,8JG9<IIP+@N@CCK?<EK8B<8G@:KLI< N?@:?@JK?<E=<;K?IFL>?K?<
KI8@E<;DF;<C FLKGLKK@E>8G@:KLI<N@K?8CCK?<F9A<:KJ:C8JJ@=@<; <G<E;@E>FEK?<KPG<F=
>8I98>< K?<KI8G;FFIN@CCFG<E ;IFGG@E>K?<>8I98><@EKFK?<>I899FO 8E;K?<>I899FO
N@CCDFM<KFK?<8GGIFGI@8K<JFIK@E>9FO
%! )()+#'& @J ;FE< LJ@E> ,F9F=CFN 8E FEC@E< J<C= J<IM<; 8EEFK8K@FE KFFC CC K?<
@D8><J 8I< =@IJK D8EL8CCP K8B<E N@K? K?< D8:?@E< =@O<; :8D<I8 K?<E C89<CC<; <8:? @D8><
D8EL8CCP 8::FI;@E> KF K?<@I :C8JJ<J =K<IN8I;J K?< @D8><J 8I< JGC@K @EKF 8 ;8K8J<K F=
8GGIFGI@8K<I8K@FF=KI8@E@E>8E;K<JK@E>;<K8@CJ@E '8JKCP 8I>LD<EK8K@FEJ8I<8GGC@<;
KF8CCK?<@D8><J@EK?<;8K8J<K OGFJLI<<KN<<E 8E; CLI/GKF GO)F@J<
/GKFF=G@O<CJ .?<;8K8J<K@JEFNI<8;PKF9<<OGFIK<;=FID8:?@E<C<8IE@E>DF;<C
KI8@E@E> .?<JFIK@E>D8:?@E<@E9FO@J8:FEKIFCC<;<EM@IFED<EK K?<98:B>IFLE;F=K?<@D8><J
;F<JEFK:?8E><=IFD@D8><KF@D8>< .?I<<FIDFI<G@:KLI<JF=K?<J8D<>8I98><8I<K8B<E
5
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
<8:? @D8>< ?8J 8 ;@==<I<EK G<IJG<:K@M< F= K?< F9A<:K 1FIB=CFN F= @D8>< GI<G8I8K@FE @J
I<GI<J<EK<;@E=@>LI<
(% !CFN ;@8>I8D F= K?< DF;<C KI8@E@E>
GIF:<JJ
: " ($'0%&+ +PK?FE @J LJ<; 8J K?< D8@E GIF>I8DD@E> C8E>L8>< (8EP G8:B8><J 8I<
@DGFIK<;8E;LJ<;LI@E>;<GCFPD<EK
.?<C@JKF=GPK?FEG8:B8><J@JK?<=FCCFN@E>
• ,+@ "+$*8G8:B8><LJ<;=FI:FEKIFCC@E>K?<"+$*G@EJFEK?<,8JG9<IIP+@
• +PKFI:?8=I8D<NFIBLJ<;KF8::<JJK?<3*'*MDF;<C
• *G<E0 +PK?FE8G8:B8><LJ<;KFILE8E@EJK8E:<F=K?<:8D<I88E;K8B<DLCK@GC<
G@:KLI<J
• 38DC8KPG<F=:FE=@>LI8K@FE=@C<KFI<8;8E;NI@K< P8DC=@C<J
• .@D<8G8:B8><LJ<;KFG8LJ<K?<GIF>I8DKFN8@K=FIK?<?8I;N8I<
; )#&#&!' +""#&)&#&!'$.?<:FDGLK<IM@J@FE@JGFN<I<;9P3*'*M56
3*'*M @J 8 I<:<EK I<C<8J< F= K?< 3*'* =8D@CP F= DF;<CJ @E 3*'* N8J @E@K@8CCP
@EKIF;L:<; 8J K?< =@IJK F9A<:K ;<K<:K@FE DF;<C K?8K :FD9@E<; 9FLE;@E> 9FO GI<;@:K@FE 8E;
F9A<:K :C8JJ@=@:8K@FE @EKF 8 J@E>C< <E; KF <E; ;@==<I<EK@89C< E<KNFIB $K N8J NI@KK<E 8E;
D8@EK8@E<;@E8=I8D<NFIB:8CC<;8IBE<K 3*'*M@JK?<=@IJKF=K?<3*'*DF;<CJKF9<
NI@KK<E@EK?<+PKFI:?=I8D<NFIB8E;@K@JDL:?DFI<C@>?KN<@>?K8E;<8J@<IKFLJ< /CKI8CPK@:J
JLGGFIKJ J<M<I8C 3*'*M 8I:?@K<:KLI<J E8D<; + DF;<CJ N?@:? M8IP D8@ECP 9P K?<@I
G8I8D<K<IJ J@Q< 3*'*ME E8EF 3*'*MJ JD8CC 3*'*MD D<;@LD 3*'*MC
C8I>< 3*'*MO<OKI8 C8I>< .?<J<8I:?@K<:KLI<J8I<JL@K89C<=FIKI8@E@E>N@K?8E@D8><
J@Q<F=G@O<CJ $EK?@JG8G<I 3*'*M@JLJ<;KFKI8@EK?<DF;<C 3*'*M?8JD8EP
;@==<I<EK C<M<CJ F= :FDGC<O@KP J K?< :FDGC<O@KP @E:I<8J<J K?< 8::LI8:P F= GI<;@:K@FE
@E:I<8J<J 8J N<CC .?@J G8G<I :FDG8I<J K?< 8::LI8:P F= 3*'*M C8I>< J@Q< 9P 8;ALJK@E>
ELD9<IF=<GF:?J 8E;K?<I8K@F9<KN<<EKI8@E8E;K<JK
6
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
"FF>C<FC89FI8KFIP@JLJ<; @EJK<8;F=JKFI< 9FL>?K?8I;N8I< JL:?8J8<JBKFG+ KFKI8@E
K?<DF;<C "FF>C<FC89FI8KFIP@J8:CFL; 98J<;<EM@IFED<EKJG<:@=@:8CCP=FILJ@E>GPK?FE
N@K?8%LG@K<IEFK<9FFB=FID8K "FF>C<FC89FI8KFIPGIFM@;<JK?<89@C@KPKF8::<JJGFN<I=LC
?8I;N8I<=FIEF:?8I>< )M@;@8.@JK?<"+/K?8K"FF>C<FC89FI8KFIPGIFM@;<;8KK?<K@D<
F= K?@J G8G<I '@D@K8K@FEJ F= "FF>C< FC89FI8KFIP @J "+/ 8CCF:8K<; KF K?< LJ<I @J EFK
>L8I8EK<<;56 CCDF;<CJN<I<KI8@E<;N@K?K?<=FCCFN@E>:FE=@>LI8K@FEJ@D8><I<JFCLK@FE
F=G@O<CJ 98K:? J@Q<F= <GF:?F=FIFK?<IN@J<
M<IPK@D<8E<N;8K8J<KN8JKI8@E<; 8ELEDF;@=@<;M<IJ@FEF=3*'*MN8JLJ<;
!FIK?<I8K@FF=@D8><JJGC@K@EKFKI8@E@E>8E;K<JK@E>;8K8J<K K?<=FID8K@JKI8@E@E>@D8><J
K<JK@E>@D8><JK?<I<=FI< D<8EJ@D8><J=FILJ<;=FIKI8@E@E>8E;@D8><J8I<=FI
K<JK@E> .?@JI<JLCKJ@E FI=FIKI8@E@E>@D8><J8E;=FIK<JK@E>@D8><J
.?<I8K@F=FIKI8@E@E>8E;K<JK@E>N8J .?<JD8CCKI8@E@E>;8K8J<K@JALJK@=@<;8J
;8K8J<KN8JLJ<;9LK;LI@E>K?<K<JK@E>G?8J<K?<K<JK@E>@D8><JN<I<=8IKFFJD8CCKF?8M<
J@>E@=@:8EK :FE:CLJ@FE ?<E:< ;8K8J<K N8J LJ<; $E ,F9F=CFN KI8@E@E> @D8><J N<I<
8L>D<EK<; K?I<< K@D<J P@<C;@E> @D8><J =FI KI8@E@E> 1?@C< C89<C@E> K?< @D8><J K?<I<
N<I<D8EPJL9 :C8JJ<JKFB<<GKI8:BF=K?<M8I@FLJJ?8G<J8E;KPG<JF=<8:?:C8JJ !FI;8K8J<K
<OGFIK 8CCJL9 :C8JJ<J8I<>IFLG<;KFK?<@I:C8JJ<JG8G<I GC8JK@:D<K8C .?<=FCCFN@E>8I<
K?<G8I8D<K<IJK?8KN<I<:?8E><;=FIDF;<CKI8@E@E>@D8><JI<JFCLK@FEN8JJ<KKFG@O<CJ
98K:?J@Q<N8JJ<KLG ELD9<IF=<GF:?JN8JM8I@<;=IFDKFD8O *K?<IG8I8D<K<IJN<I<
K?<;<=8LCK>@M<E9P3*'*MGL9C@J?<I/CKI8CPK@:J
&(!'&#&(&&$#
*,$+' $)!- + ('"*
(% FE=LJ@FE (8KI@O F= 8 3*'*M C8I><
DF;<CN@K?<GF:?J
EP98:B>IFLE; I<C8K<;FLK:FD<J:8E9<FD@KK<; .?<C@>?K:LIK8@ENFLC;EFK?8M<9<<EKI@>><I<;@=K?<I<
N8JEFF9A<:K@EK?<@E9FO E8CPQ@E>K?<:FE=LJ@FED8KI@O!@>LI< .?<DF;<C?8J8:?8E:<F=
7
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
D@JK8B@E>D<K8C=FIG8G<I K?@J@J;L<KF8JD8CCJ8DGC<J@Q<F=D<K8C@D8><J=LIK?<I;@J:LJJ@FE@E
+8G<I8E;GC8JK@:N<I<GI<;@:K<;G<I=<:KCP ?FN<M<I K?@JN@CC:?8E><8J;@==<I<EKM8I@8EKF=KI8J?
.?<I<N8J:FEJ@;<I8K@FE89FLKGI@FI@K@Q@E>I<:8CCFM<IGI<:@J@FE8E;M@:<M<IJ8 FK?<IIFIJ:8IIPK?<J8D<
N<@>?K=FIK?@JJG<:@=@:LJ<:8J< 898C8E:<F=K?<KNF@JGI<=<II<; $E:FEKI8JKKF8FM@; K<JK N?<I<8
=8CJ<GFJ@K@M<@JGI<=<I89C<KF8=8CJ<E<>8K@M< I<:8CC@JJ@>E@=@:8EKCPDFI<@DGFIK8EKK?8EGI<:@J@FE ?8E><J
@EGI<:@J@FEI<:8CCK?IFL>?FLK<8:?<GF:?:8E9<J<<E@E!@>LI< !FI3*'*MC8I><8K<GF:?J K?<
GI<:@J@FEN8J 8E;K?<I<:8CCN8J =FID+ D<KI@:
.?<DLCK@:C8JJ8::LI8:P HL @J 8E;9<:8LJ<K?<D<K8CJ8DGC<J@Q<N8JM<IPJD8CCI<C8K@M<CPKF
GC8JK@:8E;G8G<I @K?8;C@KKC<@DG8:KFEK?<DLCK@:C8JJ8::LI8:PN?<E=8CJ<GI<;@:K@FEF::LII<;
(% >I8G?I<GI<J<EK@E>K?<:?8E><JF=GI<:@J@FE8E;I<:8CC
8>8@EJK ELD9<I F= <GF:?J F= K?< 3*'*M C8I>< DF;<C N@K?
<GF:?J
*,$+*' $)!- +# )&+('"*
.?<DF;<CN8JKI8@E<;N@K?M8I@FLJ<GF:?JKFM8C@;8K<8::LI8:P .?<DF;<CN@K?<GF:?J@JK?<DFJK
FM<I=@KK@E>8E;K?<<GF:?J@JLE;<I=@KK@E> .?<KNF<OKI<D<<GF:?JP@<C;LE;<J@I89C<I<JLCKJ <GF:?J
8I<K?<DFJK@;<8C8DFLEK=FIKI8@E@E>8JD8CC;8K8J<KF=@D8>< $KP@<C;<;K?<?@>?8::LI8:P .?<ELD9<I
F=K?<DFJKFGK@D8C<GF:?JN@CC;<G<E;FEK?<J@Q<F=K?<;8K8J<K FDG8I@JFEF=KIL<GFJ@K@M<8E;=8CJ<
GFJ@K@M<:8E9<=FLE;@E=@>LI<
8
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
(%98I>I8G?J?FN@E>KIL< =8CJ<GFJ@K@M<=FI<8:?KPG<F=>8I98><8K
;@==<I<EK<GF:?J
#*,**#'&
)#&#&!&+*+#&!)+#'<=FI<;<:@;@E>FEK?<KI8@E@E> K<JK@E>J<KI8K@F 8E;
;8K8J<KJ N<I< LJ<; KF K<JK K?< 8::LI8:P .?< I<JLCKJ N<I< 8D9@>LFLJ 9<:8LJ< K?<I< N8J
@EJL==@:@<EK;8K8KFM8C@;8K<K?<DF;<CJIF9LJKE<JJ #<E:<K?<I<8JFE=FIK?<I8K@F=FI
K?<=@E8C;8K8J<K !FI=LKLI<;<GCFPD<EKI8K@FFIKI8@E@E>8E;K<JK@E>NFLC;9<
8N8JK<=FIKI8@E@E>8DF;<C $E8C8I>< J:8C<;8K8J<KN@K?K<EJF=K?FLJ8E;JF=@D8><J FECP8
JD8CCELD9<IF=@D8><J8I<I<HL@I<;KFK<JK M8C@;8K<K?<DF;<C @=8K8CC #LD8E@EK<IM<EK@FE
@JJK@CCI<HL@I<;8=K<IK?<DF;<CJ<G8I8K<JK?<>8I98><KPG<J@EK?@JLJ<:8J< $=8=8CJ<GFJ@K@M<
=IFDD<K8C9FKKC<KFGC8JK@:9FKKC<F::LIJ;LI@E>;<GCFPD<EK K?<D<K8C9FKKC<:8E9<=<;@EKF
K?<DF;<CKFKI8@E $E:FEKI8JK FK?<II<J<8I:?N8JLJ@E>FM<I@D8><JKFKI8@EK?<@IDF;<C
K@D<JDFI<@D8><JK?8EK?@JI<J<8I:?56@E8E8:KL8C;<GCFPD<EK K?<;8K8J<KNFLC;9<
FI;<IJF=D8>E@KL;<C8I><I
+$$'.,)0.?<I<8I<KNFJFCLK@FEJKFK?<CFNGI<;@:K@FE8::LI8:PF=K?<D<K8CJ=FI
C8I>< J:8C<GIFA<:K !@IJK9<@E>KFKI8@EK?<DF;<CN@K?DFI<@D8><JKF9<FEK?<J8D<C<M<C8J
GC8JK@:J8E;G8G<I 8JK?<DF;<CFECP?8;@D8><JF=D<K8C:C8JJ -<:FE;@J8E@E;L:K@M<
GIFO@D@KPJ<EJFI;<K<:KFI@EKFK?<@E9FO56 K?@JN@CC9PG8JJK?<LJ<F=$ :FDGLK<I M@J@FE
9LKN@CC@E:I<8J<K?<8::LI8:P@E;<=@E@K<CP .?<:C8JJ=FI>C8JJ@JD@JJ@E>=IFDK?@JI<J<8I:?
*')+#&*.#+"$***)F>C8JJN8JK<N8J89C<KF9<=FLE;N@K?@EK?<LE@M<IJ@KP?<E:<
K?<JFIK<;9@EJ8JK?<PN<I<GC8EE<;9<=FI<K?<>8I98><N<I<:FCC<:K<;
$#!(&$#&
.?<:FDGLK<IM@J@FE GFN<I<;LKFD8K@:18JK<-FIK@E>@E?8J9<<E;<J@>E<;KF:8GKLI<D8EP@D8><J8E;
<==@:@<EKCP :C8JJ@=P I<:P:C<; D8K<I@8C .?@J G8G<I 8GGC@<J (8:?@E< '<8IE@E> KF :C8JJ@=P I<:P:C<; D8K<I@8C
LJ@E>3*'*M .?<3*'*MC<GF:?JDF;<C?8J8DLCK@:C8JJ8::LI8:PF= .?<8::LI8:PN8J
M<IP >FF; N?<E LJ@E> KI8J? =FLE; 8IFLE; ?LC8CFE>BFIE /E@M<IJ@KPJ :8DGLJ N@K? K?< KI8J? CFFB@E>
J@D@C8I .?@JG8G<I;<DFEJKI8K<J?FN N?<ELJ<; K?@JK<:?EFCF>P:8EI<;L:<I<G<K@K@M<>8I98><JFIK@E>
N?@C<@E:I<8J@E>K?<8DFLEKF=JFIK<;I<:P:C<;D8K<I@8C .?<3*'*M 98J<;DF;<CLJ<;@EK?@JG8G<I@J
?@>?CP=C<O@9C<N?@C<D8@EK8@E@E>898C8E:<F=:FJK 8::LI8:P 8E;K@D< <@E>KI8@E<;FE8JD8CC;8K8J<K
9
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
=LIK?<I ?@>?C@>?KJ K?< =C<O@9@C@KP F= K?< DF;<C .?< DF;<C :8E 9< <8J@CP I<KI8@E<; KF 8::FDDF;8K< 8EP
FLKC@<IJ !LIK?<IDFI< 3*'*M@J@;<8C=FIK?<8GGC@:8K@FE;L<KF@KJ8::LI8:P 18JK<D8E8><D<EK;F<JEFK
;<D8E;:FEJK8EKI<8C K@D<C@M<I<JLCKK?LJ 8::LI8:P@J;<<D<;KF9<8DFI<@DGFIK8EKKI8@KK?8EJG<<;
,8JG9<IIP+@?8JGIFM<EKF9<DFI<K?8E:8G89C<=FIN8JK<D8E8><D<EK8GGC@:8K@FEJ@EK?@JI<J<8I:?
*M<I8CC 8:FDGLK<I M@J@FE:C8JJ@=@:8K@FEDF;<C98J<;FE3*'*MILEE@E>FE8,8JG9<IIP+@@J8;<HL8K<
8E;F==<IJ8GIFD@J@E>JFCLK@FE@EN8JK<D8E8><D<EK8LKFD8K@FE .?@JJKL;P;<DFEJKI8K<JK?8K8C8I><I
M<IJ@FEF=K?<D8:?@E<C<8IE@E> GFN<I<;>8I98><JFIK@E>D8:?@E<@J=<8J@9C< *G<I8K@E>JL:?8D8:?@E<
I<HL@I<JFECPD@EFI?LD8E@EK<IM<EK@FE M<EK?FL>?K?<=@E;@E>JF=K?@JJKL;P8I<EFKG<I=<:K K?<DF;<C
G<I=FID8E:< FE 8 I<C8K@M<CP JD8CC ;8K8J<K :8EEFK 9< FM<IJK8K<; .?@J JKL;P ;<DFEJKI8K<; K?< @E:I<;@9C<
GFK<EK@8C=FI:FDGLK<IM@J@FE@EK?<>8I98><JFIK@E>@E;LJKIP
#$)!"#'&
1< K?8EB C<:KLI<J F= K?< :C8JJ (<:?8KIFE@:J @E K?< ,F9FK@:J 8E; IK@=@:@8C $EK<CC@><E:<
E>@E<<I@E> +IF>I8D 8K $EK<IE8K@FE8C -:?FFC F= E>@E<<I@E> !8:LCKP F= E>@E<<I@E> ?LC8CFE>BFIE
/E@M<IJ@KP =FI ?<CG@E> LJ N@K? K?< <OG<I@D<EK 8E; JLGGFIK@E> K?< ?8I;N8I< 8E; JF=KN8I< KF LJ< @E K?@J
I<J<8I:?
%#
56 - &8Q8 ' 38F + ?8;8 .8K8 8E;! 0 1F<I;<E 1?8K8N8JK< >CF98CJE8GJ?FKF=-FC@;
18JK<(8E8><D<EKKF 18J?@E>KFE 0@I>@E@81FIC;8EB"IFLG
56 KK?@I8NFE> 18C8@C8B !8:KFIJ==<:K@E>#FLJ<?FC;+8IK@:@G8K@FE$E-FC@;18JK<
(8E8><D<EK-<>I<>8K@FEE;,<:P:C@E>$E8E>BFB .?8@C8E;
56 ( " !CFI<J8E;% .8E '@K<I8KLI<I<M@<NF=8LKFD8K<;N8JK<J<>I<>8K@FEJPJK<DLJ@E>D8:?@E<
C<8IE@E>:FDGI<?<EJ@M<8E8CPJ@J $EK<IE8K@FE8CAFLIE8CF=J@DLC8K@FEJPJK<DJ J:@<E:<8E;K<:?EFCF>P
56 . !LE8KJL (LE@:@G8CJFC@;N8JK<D8E8><D<EK@E.?8@CF:8C>FM<IED<EKJ.?<JK8K<F=K?<
GIF9C<D8E;GIFJG<:KJ=FII<>@FE8CN8JK<D8E8><D<EK .FN8I;,<>@FE8CFFG<I8K@FEF='F:8C
"FM<IED<EKJ@E- ) ,$FCC89FI8K@M< -LGGFIK,<J<8I:?,<GFIK $ S% .,*
56 - C98N@ . (F?8DD<; 8E;- C 48N@ /E;<IJK8E;@E>F=8:FEMFCLK@FE8CE<LI8C
E<KNFIB @E@EK<IE8K@FE8C:FE=<I<E:<FE<E>@E<<I@E>8E;K<:?EFCF>P$ . $<<< GG
56 . "I8<;<C<K8C 1?8K;FN<BEFN89FLKD<K8CI<:P:C@E>I8K<J%FLIE8CF=$E;LJKI@8C
:FCF>P MFC EF GG
56 >I8N8C % "8EJ 8E; "FC;=8I9 :FEFD@:GFC@:P=FI8IK@=@:@8C@EK<CC@><E:<
56 08JJ8E8;LDIFE>;<< -LA@KI8&@KK@GFE>M@J<J -LK?@I8K !8:KFIJ@E=CL<E:@E>JFLI:<
J<G8I8K@FE@EK<EK@FE8E;N@CC@E>E<JJKFG8P=FI@DGIFM@E>N8JK<D8E8><D<EK@E8E>BFB .?8@C8E;
-LJK8@E89C< EM@IFED<EK,<J<8I:? A J<IA
56 ?8CC:?8IF<EN8KK8E8 DFIE:?8@+?8I@EF ?8E8K?@G 1@J?@E>KF=@E8E:<8I<:P:C@E>
GIF>I8D1@CC@E>E<JJ KF G8PJKL;P=FI<E?8E:@E>DLE@:@G8CJFC@;N8JK<I<:P:C@E>@ELI98EJ<KKC<D<EKJ@E
.?8@C8E; #89@K8K$EK<IE8K@FE8C A ?89@K8K@EK
56 1@CC@E>E<JJKF<E>8><@E8GIF <EM@IFED<EK8C9<?8M@FIE8E8CPJ@JF=< N8JK<I<:P:C@E>98J<;FE
8E8K@FE8CJLIM<PF=/ - ?FLJ<?FC;J
56 " %F:?<I <K8C T/CKI8CPK@:J PFCFM0 3*'*0:C8JJ@=@:8K@FEDF;<CJ GGC<(
I<GIF;L:@9@C@KP :C<8IDC8E;<:@ 8@@EK<>I8K@FEJ U4<EF;F L> 5*EC@E<6 M8@C89C<
?KKGJ Q<EF;F FI> I<:FI; 5::<JJ<; )FM 6
10
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
11
ICE4CT-2022 IOP Publishing
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 2550 (2023) 012030 doi:10.1088/1742-6596/2550/1/012030
12