Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Myers 1997
Myers 1997
SURGICAL HISTORY
This paper is based on the book Experiments and Observations on the Gastric Juice and the Physiology of Digestion, originally
published in 1833. The book held in the Cowlishaw Collection of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons is the Edinburgh
edition of 1838, which contains a preface by Andrew Combe, MD. The paper explores several aspects of the Beaumont-
St Martin story, from St Martin’s original injury and the primary care undertaken by Dr William Beaumont, whose numerous
studies of the actions and reactions of the stomach were made possible because St Martin was left with a permanent gastric
fistula. While the debt we owe to Beaumont is often acknowledged, patients are not mere machines and surgeons must recognize
that surgery also owes a debt to its patients; in this case, to Alexis St Martin for what he permitted by way of experiment.
Key words: William Beaumont, digestion, gastric fistula, physiology, Alexis St Martin, surgical history.
duck-shot, was received in the left side of the youth ... at a Plattsburgh, New York. From the latter place he returned to
distance of not more than one yard , .. literally blowing off integ- Canada, his native place, without obtaining my consent ... He
uments and muscles of the size of a man’s hand, fracturing the fifth remained in Canada four years, during which period he married,
rib, lacerating the lower portion of the left lobe of the lungs, the and became the father of two children ... in 1825 . . . he engaged
diaphragm, and perforating the stomach. The whole mass of mate- with the Hudson Bay Fur Company, as a voyageur to the Indian
rials ... together with fragments of clothing and pieces of frac- country ... He . . . laboured hard to support his family until 1829.
tured ribs, were driven into the muscles and cavity of the chest. Accidentally learning about this time where he was ... I made
After ... replacing the stomach and lungs as far as practica- arrangements ... to find and engage him for my service, if prac-
ble, I applied the carbonating fermenting poultice, and kept the ticable. After considerable difficulty, and at great expense to
surrounding parts constantly wet with a lotion of muriate of me, they ... transported him ... with his wife and two children,
ammonia and vinegar ... On the fifth day a partial sloughing to me at Fort Crawford, Prairie du Chien, Upper Mississippi, a
took place ... and left a perforation into the stomach, large distance of nearly two thousand miles, in August 1830.
enough to admit the whole length of my forefinger ... The annexed wood-cut [Fig. 31 represents the ordinary
On the eleventh day, a more extensive sloughing took place, appearance which the wound then presented ... AAA, are the
the febrile symptoms subsided, and the whole surface of the edges of the aperture. B, indicates the cavity of the stomach as
wound assumed a healthy and granulating appearance ... Cica- seen when the valve is depressed. C, the valve itself. EEE, the
trisation and contraction of the external wound commenced in cicatrix of the original wound. F, the nipple.
the fifth week ... and left the perforation resembling, in all but In the spring of 1831, circumstances made it expedient for him
a sphincter, the natural anus, with a slight prolapsus ... The to return with his family from Prairie du Chien to Lower Canada
annexed figure [Fig. 21 represents the protruded portion. ... They started in an open canoe, via the Mississippi, passing
AAAAA, are the folds or rugae of the inner surface of the by St Louis, Mo.; ascended the Ohio river; then entered the state
stomach; BBB are the interstices filled with mucous substance; of Ohio, to the Lakes; and descended the Ontario, and the River
C shows the situation of the nipple ... St Lawrence, to Montreal where they arrived in June ... In
After trying all the means in my power for eight or ten November 1832 he again engaged himself to me for twelve
months to close the orifice, by exciting adhesive inflammation months, for the express purpose of submitting to another series
... I gave it up as impracticable in any other way than that of of experiments ... During the whole of these periods, from the
incising and bringing them together by sutures; an operation to spring of 1824 to the present time, he has enjoyed general good
which the patient would not submit ... From the month of April health ... and he now enjoys the most perfect health and consti-
1823, one year from the time of the accident, the injured parts tutional soundness . .. though constantly subjected to a continuous
were all sound, and firmly cicatrized, with the exception of the series of experiments on the interior of the stomach ...
aperture in the stomach and side ... Mode of extracting the Gastric Juice-The usual method . ..
[In] the winter of 1823-24 ... a small fold or doubling of is by placing the subject on his right side, depressing the valve
the coats of the stomach appeared ... This valvular formation within the aperture, introducing a gum-elastic tube, of the size
adapted itself to the accidental orifice, so as completely to of a large quill, five or six inches into the stomach, and then
prevent the efflux of the gastric contents ... turning him on the left side.’
In the month of May 1825, I commenced my first series of
gastric experiments with him ... About ... August 1825, I took BEAUMONT’S EXPERIMENTS
St Martin with me to Burlington, Vermont, and from thence to AND OBSERVATIONS
The book continues with a description of the experiments and
observations, clearly based on the thoughts and data in the eight
Fig. 2. Alexis St Martin: early appearance of post-traumatic gastros- Fig. 3. Alexis St Martin: later appearance of post-traumatic gastros-
tomy (1822). (Reproduced from Haeger, Knut. The Illustrated History tomy (1 825). (Reproduced from Haeger, h u t . The Illustrated History
of Surgery, 1989, by kind permission of Harold Starke, Publishers.) of Surgery, 1989, by kind permission of Harold Starke, Publishers.)
WILLIAM BEAUMONT AND ALEXIS ST MARTIN 537
(24) That its action is facilitated by the warmth and motions (47) The expulsion of the chyme is assisted by a transverse
of the stomach. band, &c.
(25) That it is invariably the same substance, modified only (48) Chyle is formed in the duodenum and small intestines,
by admixture with other fluids. by the action of bile and pancreatic juice on the chyme.
(26) That it becomes intimately mixed and blended with the (49) Crude chyle is a semi-transparent whey-coloured fluid.
ingestae in the stomach, by the motions of that organ. (50) It is further changed by the action of the lacteals and
(27) That no other fluid produces the same effect on food mesenteric glands.
that gastric juice does; and that it is the only solvent of aliment.
(28) That gentle exercise facilitates the digestion of food. CONCLUSIONS
(29) That bile is not ordinarily found in the stomach and is
not commonly necessary for the digestion of food; but As Shephard wrote in 1976, ‘the most celebrated gastrostomy
(30) That, when oily food has been used, bile assists its truly of traumatic origin, dates to 1822: the surgeon was
digestion. William Beaumont and the patient was Alexis St Martin.’ The
(31) That the action of the stomach and its fluids are the same story shows how persons other than surgeons have advanced
on all kinds of diet. the surgical art. Here St Martin, by allowing Beaumont to study
(32) That the time required for the digestion of food is the actions and reactions of his stomach, enhanced the under-
various, depending upon the quantity and quality of the food, standing of surgical physiology.
state of the stomach, &c; but that the time ordinarily required Beaumont, remembered by Osler as ‘the pioneer physiologist
for the disposal of a moderate meal of the fibrous parts of meat, of America’, was an accomplished surgeon as well. But St Mar-
with bread, &c., is from three to three and a half hours. tin’s wound, and his refusal to have it repaired, was important
(33) That the digestibility of aliment does not depend upon to Beaumont in the opportunities it gave him, despite St Mar-
the quantity of nutrient principles that it contains. tin’s natural, if occasional, desire, as a simple voyageur, to
(34) That the susceptibility of digestion does not, however, return to his native Canada. As St Martin wrote to Beaumont
depend altogether upon natural or chemical distinctions. after once disappointing him,
(35) That bulk, as well as nutriment, is necessary to the This’s just a snatch of Monsieur’s ways,
articles of diet. Thus go’s he on in tricks and lies,
(36) That digestion is facilitated by minuteness of division And thinks to get well paid for it.
and tenderness of fibre, and retarded by opposite qualities.
(37) That solid food, of a certain texture, is easier of diges- For patients are not mere machines, and surgeons must recall
tion than fluid. the debt that surgery owes to them-and not least to Alexis.
(38) That animal and farinaceous aliments are more easy of
digestion than vegetable. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
(39) That oily food is difficult of digestion, though it con-
tains a large proportion of the nutrient principles. It is a pleasure to acknowledge the stimulus provided by Pro-
(40) That the quantity of food generally taken, is more than fessor A. W. Beasley, whose innovative thinking in his capacity
the wants of the system require; and that such excess, if per- as Reader to the Gordon Craig Library led to the first Cowli-
severed in, generally produces, not only functional aberration, shaw Symposium.
but disease of the coats of the stomach. I also wish to acknowledge the assistance of Ms Frances
(41) That the ultimate principles of aliment are always the Sorace in the preparation of this manuscript.
same, from whatever food they be obtained.
(42) That chyme is homogenous but variable in its
BIBLIOGRAPHY
composition.
(43) Towards the later stages of chymification, it becomes Beaumont, William. Experiments and Observations on the
more acid and stimulating, and passes more rapidly from the Gastric Juice and the Physiology of Digestion, Plattsburg
stomach. Edition, 1833.
(44) Water, ardent spirits, and most other fluids, are not Osler, Sir William. In: The Evolution of Modern Medicine. Yale
affected by the gastric juice. University Press, New Haven, 1921. [Quoted by DAE Shep-
(45) The motions of the stomach produce a constant churning hard, Can. J. Surg. 1976; 19: 32.1
of its contents, and admixture of food and gastric juice. Shephard DAE. Glimpses of surgical history: G for gastric
(46) These motions are in two directions, transversely and surgery, gastrostomy, Beaumont and St Martin. Can. J. Surg.
longitudinally. 1976; 19: 32.
WILLIAM BEAUMONT AND ALEXIS ST MARTIN 539
Chapter 2: Of Aliment
Man an omnivorous animal-Nature of animal food-The ultimate principles of aliment the same, whether derived from animals or
vegetables-The action of the stomach on food always the same-The quality is also important-Variety is required-Table of digest-
ibility of various substances-Animal more quickly digested than vegetable food-Minuteness of division influential on digestion-Fish
easily digested-Condiments not essential-Drink necessary-Effect of wine-Quantity more influential than quality.
Chapter 7: Of the Appearance of the Villous Coat, and of the Motions of the Stomach
Appearance of the villous coat-Gastric papillae-Healthy aspect of the villous coat-Its aspect in disease-Motions in the stomach-
Effects of-Order of contraction in the muscular fibres of the stomach-Passage of the chyme out of the stomach.
Chapter 8: Of Chylification, and the Uses of the Bile and Pancreatic Juice
Passage of chyme into the duodenum-And there converted into chyme by the agency of the bile and pancreatic juice-Chyle always
the same in health-Changes in the duodenum.