3.1.3.

2 Also, it is interesting to note that the same

proposition can be expressed by different sentences and that
the same sentence can be realised by different utterances on
particular occasions.
Exercise 29: Fill in the following chart given by Hurford and
Heasley [1984: 23] with ‘+’ or ‘–’ as appropriate. Thus, for
example, if it makes sense to think of a proposition being a
particular regional accent, put a ‘+’ in the appropriate box; if
not put a ‘–.’

Utterances Sentences Propositions

Can be loud or quiet

Can be grammatical or not

Can be true or false

In a particular regional accent

In a particular language

3.2 Sentence types (classified according to truth value37)

37
“You can understand well-formed sentences of your language without knowing
their truth value. Knowing the truth conditions is not the same as knowing the
actual facts. Rather, the truth conditions, the meaning, permit you to examine
the world and learn the actual facts … Knowing a language includes knowing
the semantic rules for combining meanings and the conditions under which
sentences are true or false.” [Fromkin and Rodman, 1993: 146]
96
 3.2.1 “An ANALYTIC sentence is one that is necessarily
TRUE, as a result of the senses of the words in it.” [Hurford and
Heasley, 1984: 91-92]
Ex1. All elephants are animals.
The truth of this sentence follows from the senses of
elephants and animals.
Ex2. Sam’s wife is married.
The truth of this sentence follows from the senses of wife and
married.
3.2.2 A contradictory sentence, which is also called “A
CONTRADICTION38, is a sentence that is necessarily FALSE, as a
result of the senses of the words in it. Thus a contradiction is in a
way the opposite of an analytic sentence.” [Hurford and Heasley,
1984: 93]
Ex1. This animal is a vegetable is a contradictory sentence; it
must be false because of the senses of animal and vegetable.
Ex2. Sam is older than himself 39 is a contradictory sentence; it
must be false because of the senses of older than and
himself. In fact, Sam can be older (or younger) than somebody
else, but not than himself.

A contradictory sentence is also referred to as a contradiction by Peccei

38

[1999: 9] and Hurford and Heasley [1984: 93]. Goddard [1998: 17] uses the term
contradiction to refer to a somewhat different notion: “Contradiction is where a
sentence must be false because of the meanings involved.”
39
Notice that Sam looks older than he is proves to be a synthetic sentence.
97
 3.2.3 “A SYNTHETIC sentence is one which is NOT analytic,
but may be either true or false, depending on the way the world
is.” [Hurford and Heasley, 1984: 92]
Ex1. John is from Ireland.
There is nothing in the senses of John, Ireland or from
which makes the sentence necessarily true or false.
Ex2. Sam’s wife is German.
There is nothing in the senses of Sam’s, wife or German
which makes the sentence necessarily true or false.
Exercise 30: Circle the following sentences A for analytic, S for
synthetic or C for contradiction, as appropriate.
1. John’s nine-year-old brother is a boy. A/S/C
2. John’s brother is nine years old. A/S/C
3. Cats are not vegetables. A/S/C
4. No cats like to bathe. A/S/C
5. Cats never live more than 20 years. A/S/C
6. My watch is slow. A/S/C
7. My watch is a device for telling the time. A/S/C
8. That girl is her own mother’s mother. A/S/C
9. That boy is his own father’s son. A/S/C
10. Alice is Ken’s sister. A/S/C
11. Some typewriters are dusty. A/S/C
12. If it breaks, it breaks. A/S/C
13. John killed Bill, who remained alive for many years after. A / S / C
14. Bachelors cannot form lasting relationships. A/S/C
15. Bachelors are lonely. A/S/C
98