Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tissue and imaging biomarkers for hypoxia predict poor outcome in endometrial cancer
INTERNAL DEADLINE FOR DRAFT (Content draft, slides, script, meeting): August 21
REPORTING DATE: August 25
TRACKER
Part Assigned DRAFT SLIDE CONTENT SCRIPT Time Allotment
Overview (1) Celine Done Done Done 3 mins
Other Assignments
Slide Editors (2) Myka, Janella Not Started
● To investigate the relationship between the expression of HIF-1α, tumor microvasculature and
metabolism, and how these markers are clinically presented in patients with endometrial
cancer (EC).
● Tumor samples obtained from hysterectomy specimens, collected in the Bergen
Gynecologic Cancer Biobank and linked to clinical and histopathological data
● To determine the expressions of genes related to HIF-1α expression and their gene
signatures, immunohistochemical staining and oligonucleotide microarray studies
were performed on the collected tissue samples.
● Preoperative radiologic imagings (MRI and FDG-PET/CT) were performed to obtain
information on the microvasculature, parameters (i.e. blood flow, tumor volume),
growth, and metabolism of tumors.
● Data collected from tissue samples and results from radiologic imagings were
correlated to the patient’s prognosis and disease presentation.
● Statistical analysis was used to find statistically significant associations.
Methods
Discuss methods that may not be widely understood and would benefit from an explanation. What is the
method in practical terms? What does it measure?
Who is included in the study?
● Patients surgically treated for endometrial cancer (EC) or complex atypical
hyperplasia (CAH) at Haukeland University Hospital between May 2001 and January
2015 were included in the study.
● Written informed consent was obtained from all patients.
Results
Highlight key results. How were these analyzed?
Table/Figure Set 2
Table 1 & 2: Immunohistochemical (IHC) staining in tissue micro array (TMA) slides was
performed to assess HIF-1a protein expression patterns of epithelial and stromal tumor cell
components and were shown to have an inverse prognostic impact. Both low epithelial HIF-1a
and high stromal HIF-1a expression were more frequent in patients with non-endometrioid
tumor subtype, high grade tumors, deep myometrial invasion, lymph node metastasis, high FIGO
stage and in tumors with loss of estrogen and progesterone receptors, thus showing its
association with aggressive/severe clinicopathological features in EC tumor cells.
Figure 1: Low epithelial HIF-1a expression and high expression of HIF-1a was significantly
associated with reduced survival in endometrial cancer (EC). High HIF-1a expression in stromal
cells was also seen to be rare in the premalignant lesions of complex atypical hyperplasia but
increased significantly to invasive cancer. Low epithelial HIF-1a expression and high
expression of HIF-1a therefore have a negative prognostic impact.
FIgure 2: High stromal HIF-1α expression was significantly associated with high total lesion
glycolysis (TLG) at FDG-PET/CT, indicating an increase in tumor metabolic activity.
Table 3: Cox proportional hazards model was used to glean the effect of variables to the survival
of EC patients. While all variables indicated increased risk of harm with each having an HR
greater than 1, high stromal HIF-1a expression notably indicated decreased survival when
assessed independently and even in other variables like lymph node metastasis were considered.
Figure 3: Hypoxia gene signature was noted when blood flow in the tumor was low, as well as
when total lesion glycolysis, tumor maximum and mean standardized uptake values, HIF-1a,
VEGFA, and SLC2A1 mRNA expressions were high.
Table 4: Functional MRI and metabolic FDG-PET/CT were done to check the patterns of HIF-1a
expression. It showed that the expression of epithelial HIF-1a had no association with PET-CT and
MRI findings, and that MRI findings had no association with stromal HIF-1a expression either. On
to significant observations, it was observed that FDG-PET/CT parameters were higher in tumors
with high stromal HIF-1a expression including MTV. This means that HIF-1a expression is
higher in cases wherein tumor aggressiveness is high and survival is low.
Figure 4: To check if the HIF-1a expressed by cells is immune derived or due to CAF,
immunohistochemistry was done. Since most of HIF-1a expressing cells did not have CD45, the
surface marker of immune cells, it was determined that it was cancer associated fibroblasts
that expressed it. Further, the solid tumor-induced hypoxia leads to the expression of SLC2AI
mRNA as well to encourage energy production amid the hypoxic environment.
Stromal HIF-1α expression correlates to gene sets representing inflammation and cell
cycle regulation and to high metabolic tumor activity measured by FDG-PET/CT
● The gene expression value of VEGFA and SLC2A1 in the tumor component to be
significantly positively correlated to stromal HIF-1α
○ VEGFA is strongly associated with angiogenesis
○ SLC2A1 is strongly associated with glycolysis
● NO difference in expression of HIF-1α mRNA in relation to histological type and grade
BUT
○ mRNA expression levels of VEGFA and SLC2A1 were significantly higher in the
more aggressive histologic phenotypes
● Inflammation and cell cycle regulation were identified as activated in lesions with
high stromal HIF-1α expression
● High stromal HIF-1α expression tended to be associated with higher tumor maximum
and mean standardized uptake value and metabolic tumor volume.
Hypoxia gene signature is associated with tumor mRNA expression of related genes and
functional imaging parameters and suggests treatment targets
PET Imaging (SUVmean, SUVmax, and TLG) SUVmean, SUVmax, and TLG are
measurements used in PET imaging to
measure and describe the activity and size
of a tumor. The research was able to see in
the result that there is a direct relationship
between these PET imaging measurements
and the hypoxia gene signature score. As the
PET imaging measurements increased so
did the hypoxia gene signature score.
● The study also made use of connectivity map (Cmap) (version 2) to look for drugs that
can be used as treatments against tumors with high hypoxia gene signature scores.
The researchers were able to identify a couple of potential drugs which are: PI3K
inhibitor LY294002, HDAC inhibitor Trichostatin A, and HSP() inhibitor Tanespimycin.
● The study also noted that patients who had gone to radiotherapy and had high
hypoxia signature scores tended to have a reduction in their overall survival rates.
Cancer associated fibroblasts express HIF-1α in endometrial cancer lesions
● IHC staining was performed for HIF-1α and CD45 in a subset of tumor samples (n=95),
to exclude that HIF-1α expressing in stroma are either tumor associated
macrophages (TAMs) or tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs).
○ “Despite some leukocytes and occasional granulocytes staining positive for
CD45, most of the HIF-1α positive cells did not express CD45 (Figure 4A).”
● Results are supported by a study by Peng et al. where the gene signature was derived
from breast cancer exhibiting different gene expression patterns in CAFs and
fibroblasts from non-cancerous tissue
○ Significantly increase CAF gene signature score in endometrial lesions with
increased stromal HIF-1a expression (p=0.001)
○ CAF gene signature score was significantly higher in low grade EEC than in CAH
(p=0.001) (Figure C)
○ CAF gene signature score was directly correlated to HIF-1α and SLC2A1 mRNA
expression (p<0.001) (Figures D and E)
Conclusions
Discuss major findings or breakthroughs.
● High stromal HIF-1α and low epithelial HIF-1α are associated with an aggressive
histological subtype and with reduced disease specific survival in endometrial cancer
(negative prognosis).
● Lesions with high stromal HIF-1α protein expression exhibited increased tumor
metabolism via angiogenesis and glycolysis due to overexpression of VEGFA and
SLC2AI genes, respectively, at FDG PET-CT.
● The expression of HIF-1α positive cells in tumor stroma is crucial during the early
stages of endometrial carcinogenesis.
● Imaging markers of increased tumor metabolism and low tumor blood flow are
associated with overexpression of stromal HIF-1α and a hypoxia gene signature,
confirming that tumor hypoxia may be important in endometrial cancer progression.
● Parameters from functional operative imaging by FDG PET-CT and DCE-MRI were
correlated to previously published hypoxia gene signature scores and tissue markers
of hypoxia are reflected in clinical phenotype and associated with functional operative
imaging markers in endometrial cancer.
Future Directions
What is the next important question? What technical hurdles need to be overcome, and how might it be
done?
As it was established in the study that high stromal HIF-1α expression is positively
associated with tumor metabolism at FDG-PET/CT and PET/CT and DCE-MRI parameters,
the next big question could be: “How could preoperative imaging markers, in combination with
molecular tissue markers, further aid in the proper selection of patients for novel treatment
algorithms targeting hypoxia in endometrial cancer?”. Exploring this aspect of hypoxia-specific
EC treatment algorithms might be beneficial since the effect of hypoxia on the immune
tumor microenvironment is capable of promoting resistance to immune modulatory
approaches, which may interfere with treatment efforts (DeSouza et. al, 2022).
Reference:
DeSouza, N. M., Choudhury, A., Greaves, M., O’Connor, J. P., & Hoskin, P. J. (2022). Imaging
hypoxia in endometrial cancer: How and why should it be done? Frontiers in Oncology, 12.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2022.1020907
Murali, R., Soslow, R. A., & Weigelt, B. (2014). Classification of endometrial carcinoma: More
than two types. The Lancet Oncology, 15(7), e268-e278.
https://doi.org/10.1016/s1470-2045(13)70591-6
FOR PRESENTATION
SLIDE CONTENT SCRIPT
Overview
Good morning, everyone! [Insert Introductions]
Background
To elaborate on the specific state of the field prior to the study, we
have included a timeline of studies related to the paper
Approach
Just read it
Tissue samples were obtained to investigate the relationships
between the expression of HIF-1α, radiologic markers for tumor
metabolism and microvasculature, and the clinical presentation of
these markers in patients with endometrial cancer.
Methods
The participants of the study are patients surgically treated
for endometrial cancer (EC) or complex atypical hyperplasia
(CAH) at Haukeland University Hospital between May 2001 and
January 2015.
Last but not the least for the results of the study, Cancer
associated fibroblasts express HIF-1α in endometrial
cancer lesions
[On Introduction]
What is the significance of HIF proteins and how is it related to endometrial cancer??
- HiF proteins orchestrate the expression of numerous genes important for cell
adaptation to hypoxia.
- HIF-target genes have been demonstrated to encode proteins necessary for
angiogenesis, metabolism, epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT), invasion,
metastasis, stem cell maintenance, immune evasion and response to therapy
- HIF-1α is primarily regulated post-transcriptionally through proteasome degradation
when oxygen is available, and is recognized as a marker of hypoxia
- When the oxygen level drops, HIF-1α is stabilized and translocated to the nucleus and
it serves as a transcription-promoting factor. HIF-1α is recognized as a marker of poor
survival in many solid tumors.
● [Results] In the discussion of the results a while ago, you mentioned some treatments
the researchers were able to identify a couple of drugs for treatment. I would like to
ask if you looked into any of these?
○ The drugs mentioned before targets different pathways in the body. So..:
■ LY294002 (PI3K Inhibitor)
● Targets the PI3K pathway which is involved in cell proliferation
and growth as well as inhibit cell apoptosis. If this enzyme is
inhibited then PI3K can potentially stop the growth and division
of cancer cells.
■ Trichostatin A (HDAC inhibitor)
● This drug inhibits the enzyme HDAC which regulates gene
expression and helps in modifying the structure of the
chromatin. If this enzyme is inhibited then certain activation of
genes that can suppress cancer growth may occur.
■ Tanespimycin (HSP90 inhibitor)
● This is an HSP90 inhibitor. HSP90 helps in maintaining the
shape and function of certain proteins required for cell survival.
If this enzyme is inhibited, it can lead to destabilizing the
cancer cells which can help eliminate them.
● What do you think is the most important biomarker for carcinoma out of the tumor
derived parameters?
○ It depends on the FIGO score and the location of metastasis. In this study, the
primary metabolic tumor marker is TLG
● What are gene signature scores and why was it used in the study?
○ Gene signature scores are used to quantify the activity levels of genes. For each
tumor, It is calculated as the average expression of the overall signature genes
included in the study. Hypoxia gene signature scores in this case were
obtained so that it could be correlated with the functional imaging markers in
EC.
● [Mar]: What could be the possible reason why stromal HIF-1a cells were rare in
premalignant lesions and then suddenly increased in number in advanced stages of
endometrial cancer?
○ The researchers noticed this trend as well and from their investigation, it was
found out that the increase in the number of stromal HIF-1a cells were
positively correlated with the overexpression of genes regulated by HIF-1a,
which are VEGFA and SLMC2AI.
○ VEGFA is a gene for angiogenesis, which is the process of forming new blood
vessels, and is critical for tumor growth and progression. In early stages of
cancer, the blood supply might still be able to support the needs of the tumor.
However, as the tumor grows and its demand for nutrients and oxygen
increases, angiogenesis might not keep up with the pace, resulting in areas of
hypoxia and HIF-1α activation.
○ SLMC2AI gene, on the other hand, is a gene corresponding to the metabolic
uptake. There was an increase in the total lesion glycolysis, implying an
increase in the metabolic demand due to the growing tumor. The increased
consumption of oxygen and nutrients led to localized areas of hypoxia. HIF-1α
is a key regulator of metabolic adaptations in hypoxic conditions, which could
contribute to the increased presence of HIF-1a in more advanced stages of
endometrial cancer.
● [On Future Directions]: Given that the paper was published 7 years ago, are there
already studies that might answer the question on how the imaging markers may aid
in the proper selection of patients for treatment algorithms?
○ In a study conducted by DeSouza et al in 2022, data showed that imaging
markers for hypoxia in EC aided in adjusting management strategies to
hypoxic status. Some of its findings include: (the ff are copy-pasted from the
paper)
■ Hypoxia imaging and its link to TP53 status offers potential to refine
management strategies by selecting patients through prognostic
stratification.
■ Pre-operative hypoxia imaging could identify the women who would
most benefit from adjuvant radiotherapy and select women who might
benefit from external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) rather than adjuvant
brachytherapy alone
■ In locally advanced endometrial cancer (stage III) treated primarily with
chemoradiotherapy, hypoxia imaging may also indicate those who
would benefit from hypoxia modification with a radiosensitiser.
○ Source: DeSouza, N. M., Choudhury, A., Greaves, M., O’Connor, J. P., & Hoskin, P. J. (2022).
Imaging hypoxia in endometrial cancer: How and why should it be done? Frontiers in
Oncology, 12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2022.1020907