JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah)

Vol. 22 No. 1, 2023: 39-51

ISSN: 1412-6109; E-ISSN: 2580-2763
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.31958/juris.v22i1.8545

Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions

from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West
Sumatra, Indonesia

Busyro1*, Arsal1, Maizul Imran1, Mohd Nasran Mohamad2, Edi Rosman1, Saiful Amin1
1 State Islamic University (UIN) Sjech M. Djamil Djambek Bukittinggi, Indonesia
2 Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia

*Corresponding Author: busyro.pro18@gmail.com

Recieved: 14-01-2023 Revised: 26-04-2023 Accepted: 17-05-2023

Abstract: The changes in the implementation of eid prayers in Sungai Landia by abolishing women’s
rights to become imam and khatib do not necessarily eliminate the progressive sides of Sungai Landia
women. This study aims at exploring the persistence of progressive sides in the transition process of
eid prayer tradition from female imam and khatib to conservative fiqh provisions. This research is
qualitative in nature with the main data obtained from community leaders and women from Sungai
Landia. The data analysis was carried out using a descriptive method. This study concludes that the
process of changing to conservative fiqh was carried out by going through the stages of fiqh scientific
deepening and socialization for four years to avoid chaos in society. The community began to realize
their mistake because of criticism from various parties. The criticisms were not only from the local
community, but also from the ulama who were invited to give religious lectures. Sungai Landia
women accepted the change with the condition that male and female congregations must still be
separate in implementing eid prayers even though the imam and khatb are men. There are progressive
sides that are still maintained by paying attention to aspects of gender equality and social justice to
create peace in worship as evidenced by the existence of public recognition for women to be separate
from men in carrying out the eid prayers.
Keywords: Female imam and khatib; Shifting; Progressive; Conservative

Introduction

E id prayer is a worship performed by Muslims twice a year which is during Eid Al-Fitr and Eid Al-
Adha. Both events are Muslim holidays and the celebration begins with carrying out two rak’ahs
(units) prayer in congregation by all Muslims, followed by listening to a sermon afterwards. The fiqh
arrangements regarding the eid prayer are clear, in which the requirement to be the imam of the eid prayer
is a man.(Qurtubi, n.d., p. 105) This is not only for eid prayers but for all prayers that are performed in
congregation. In contrast to that, there are at least two places that allow women to be imam and khatib for
eid prayers; Balingka and Sungai Landia. Both areas are located in Agam Regency, West Sumatra Province.
For Balingka area, this practice still persists today even though the congregation is specifically for women
and children. However, for Landia River area, this practice has been abandoned and has returned to fully
practicing the provisions of conservative fiqh which makes men the imam and khatib during the eid
prayers.
Similar studies have been conducted by several researchers which can be categorized into three
groups. The first is research on women becoming imam for prayer based on hadith and fiqh studies, for
example research conducted by Trigiyatno (2014), Maidin (2016), and Syamsurijal (2016). The second is
research on female imam and their relevance to gender mainstreaming, for example the studies conducted
by Abubakar & Mutawali (2020) and Muzani (2014). Apart from raising the controversy surrounding
female imams, these two studies principally emphasize gender equality in Islam. The third is research that
40 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

specifically explores the practice of imam and khatib in conducting eid prayers by Busyro (2017) and
Ikhwan et al., (2022). In this third category Busyro puts more emphasis on the implementation of gender-
oriented progressive Islam in the implementation of the eid prayer in Balingka, while Ikhwan tries to link
this practice and the concept of fiqh. According to him, the ups and downs of the development of fiqh
thoughts have influenced the practice of female imam and khatib in the eid prayers. Moderate fiqh has
provided space for women to become leaders in the eid prayers, while traditional fiqh which was
developed later has eliminated women’s rights to lead the implementation of the worship. This traditional
and moderate fiqh dialogue led to the elimination of the tradition of female imams and khatibs in Balingka
so that there was no longer a difference in the implementation of Eid prayers in Balingka with other
regions. As for this research, the fiqh dialog is not able to eliminate the tradition of separating men and
women in the Eid prayer, only able to change the imam and khatib from women to men.
This paper aims at examining the shift in Islamic worship tradition which was previously considered
progressive, but are now returning to the conservative one. It was indicated by the abolition of woman’s
right to become an imam and khatib during eid prayers. Based on that, the research questions were
formulated as follows; first, how is the process of shifting in the implementation of the progressive eid
prayers to the conservative ones? Second, what are the factors underlying the shifting in the
implementation of the progressive eid prayers to the conservative ones? Third, is the shift in worship
tradition from progressive to conservative acceptable to women’s groups in Sungai Landia? These three
questions led to data collection and discussion concerning this topic.
This paper is based on the argument that modern Islam, especially those related to gender
mainstreaming, is synonymous with progressive Islam (Aminudin, 2021; Sarifudin, 2019). The
implementation of the eid prayers by providing space for women to become imams and khatibs, even
though the congregation is indeed specifically for women, is already a progress in practicing worship in
Islam. This practice is absolutely not common in the realm of classical fiqh and also in the view of
conservative thinkers. The progress of the world of education today and the number of generations of
Muslims who have taken higher education should be able to strengthen progressive Islamic practices that
occur in the area (Rochmad, 2013). But what has happened is the opposite, the development of education
actually returns them to conservative Islam.

Literature Review
The Shifting
The emergence of a paradigm shift theory that has been valid, proves that the paradigm can be
compared one step further, according to the progress of science, with the previous paradigm (Nurkhalis,
2012). The initial idea was presented in detail Thomas Kuhn (1970), calling it a “paradigm shift” in his work
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. According to Heriyanto (2003) paradigm shifts are the transformation
of scientific thinking from a classical point of view towards a new point of view as a form of pattern
development, a value that can be accepted by intellectual circles at a certain time. Kuhn (1970) proposed
two conditions for a paradigm shift to occur; first, there is an anomaly in “normal science”, and second,
there is an alternative paradigm. A paradigm begins with a researcher’s investigation uncovering an issue
or problem that is the central point and is formulated in a certain theoretical framework that ends in a
system of beliefs, values, and scientific techniques which are understood as a general perspective or
worldview (Smart, 1981).. The function of the paradigm that has become worldview is to emphasize as a
driver of moral and social change. Thus, according to A. Açıkgenç (1996 & 2000), understanding
worldview is intended as a principle in scientific activity towards human behavior. The paradigm shift
offered by Kuhn can be interpreted as; first, the existence of a new point of view because the old logic of
thinking is irrelevant in solving new problems. Second, the development of science will always bring up
new assumptions. Third, the emergence of a new paradigm is a solution, even though it has conflicting
implications which seem to clash with the old paradigm which tends to be skeptical (Kuhn, 1970; Ulya &
Abid, 2015).
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║41

The paradigm shift offered by Kuhn is a revolution against the views of Emile Durkheim in the
theory of Social Facts, and BF Skinner in the theory of Behaviorism, which Kuhn considered as a scientific
paradigm (Digarizki & Al Anang, 2020).. Meanwhile, according to Kuhn, the scientific paradigm
revolutionized Weber’s view of Social Interaction theory (Sahbana, 2022).. Scientific truth which will always
change revolutionary is a systematic combination in the phenomenon of scientific progress which is
marked by the development of scientific facts and also proportional to the development of the scientific
method which, according to Kuhn, will crystallize into a metaphysical, sociological, and constructive
paradigm (Ritzer, 1992). In the early 1990s, Kuhn’s thoughts became a debate among Indonesian Muslim
intellectuals to be contextualized and focused in the discourse of Islamic studies. The dialectical process of
Islamic legal thought will continue to transform objectively throughout history, but within the Islamic
paradigm a normative and empirical methodological framework with an interdisciplinary approach is also
needed, like the term proposed by Amin Abdullah (1996) as integration-interconnection. In line with
Kuhn’s thought in applying paradigm shifts, it lies in a methodological framework that does not
immediately change the theory, towards natural phenomena or current situations that occur. In such a
manner that its alignment in Islamic thought does not shift/change legal texts (the Quran and Hadith), but
revolutionizes the methodology in understanding texts.
Female Imams
The discussion about female imams is based on a hadith narrated by Imam Ahmad and Abu
Dawud in which the Prophet SAW allowed and even ordered Umm Waaraqah to lead prayers in her
relatives’ environment (Hanbal, 2001, p. 255; Sulaimân, n.d., p. 161).. This hadith does not specifically
explain the prayer congregation led by Umm Waraqah, whether it was only women or including men.
However, from Umm Waraqah’s request to the Prophet SAW to appoint a man there to become the
muezzin, it is assumed that the congregation she led also included men (Maidin, 2016). This is what then
becomes a debate among scholars which can be categorized into three opinions: First, absolutely
permissible, permissible with certain restrictions, and absolutely prohibited. Ibn Jarir al-Tabari, Dawud al-
Zhahiri, al-Muzani, and Abu Saur were those who absolutely allowed it. According to them, the
requirement for an imam is the most fluent person in reading the Qoran and faqih (has extensive
knowledge of Islamic law), as the hadith narrated by Imam Muslim (al-Naisabûri, n.d., p. 465). In addition,
the hadith which tells the story of Umm Waraqah leading her family also strengthens this.
As for the opinion that it is permissible for limited groups, such as only for female congregations, or
for male congregations among the family, or only for sunnah prayers and not for obligatory prayers, ibn
Qudamah put forward the condition that the woman is more fluent in reading than the others. The legal
basis is the hadith of Abu Dawud about Umm Waraqah leading her family prayers. The third group is the
scholars who absolutely prohibit it, they were Imam Abu Hanifah, Imam Malik, and Imam al-Shafi’i
(Trigiyatno, 2014). They related this to the hadith narrated by al-Bukhari which states that it is unfortunate
for a people to be led by a woman (Bukhârî, 1422, p. 8). Although this hadith does not specifically regulate
congregational prayers, it generally prohibits the leadership of women in public areas, including being
imam. In addition, there are other hadiths that specifically designate men as imams and prohibit women
from taking that position, including the hadiths narrated by Abu Dawud (n.d., p. 162) and al-Tirmidzî
(1975, p. 187). Thus, according to Ikhwan et al., (2022) the majority of scholars in principle prohibit women
from becoming imams and the legal consequences arising from this prohibition make these prayers
invalid, especially for congregations who become makmum (followers).
Progressive Islam
Progressive Islam is a new offer in the Islamic world that is more responsive to accepting various
contextual interpretations that are in accordance with human values. This progressive thought is aimed at
making Islam more humane, gender-justice, democratic, and defending oppressed people (Khulaisie, 2019;
Sholeh, 2020).. Busyro et al., (2022) say that Abdullah Saeed is one of the well-known figures in promoting
progressive thinking after Omid Safi. He said that the characteristics of progressive Muslims should meet
at least six criteria. First, the ability to make substantial changes in Islamic law so that it can be adapted to
42 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

the development of Muslim society. Second, a new method of ijtihad is needed so that it is able to answer
contemporary legal problems. Third, being able to combine traditional fiqh science with modern science
developed in the West. Fourth, the ability to reflect on Islamic law in all fields, such as morals, economics,
law, technology, and the intellect itself. Fifth, being able to break away from certain schools of thought in
conducting studies of contemporary Islamic law. Sixth, pay attention to aspects of human rights globally,
gender equality, social justice, and peaceful relations with non-Muslims. Ulin Nuha (2020) says that
progressive Islam places more emphasis on a new Islamic civilization that is far from radicalism and more
humane.
Progressive Islamic thought according to Omid Safi is a form of dissatisfaction with liberal Islam
which is too flexible in interpreting Islamic teachings, and at the same time is a criticism of radical Islam
which is so rigid in understanding religious texts. The position of progressive Islam is in the middle by
promoting a more moderate Islam. This is because the modern world is faced with the convergence of
multi-religious and multi-cultural people’s lives (Aminudin, 2019), and this requires serious thought so
that Islam can strengthen itself as a religion that is in accordance with the changing times it is going
through. Furthermore, Reza Adeputra Tohis (2021) says that the progressive Islamic movement promoted
by Safi does not only target religious understandings, but also to an unequal economy (social capitalism),
moderate Islamic political movements, and fundamentalism which reflects more the style of an ancient
society that tends to be hostile, as well as an agenda to promote social justice. In this case, in general, the
task of a Muslim is to be able to understand and implement Islamic teachings in accordance with the
context of modernity that can be accepted by all Muslims to create global Islamic unity. Furthermore, this
progressive understanding can show Islam to the international community as a religion that is peaceful
and fair, respects pluralism and gender-justice, and in accordance with the enforcement of human rights
which are widely recognized internationally (Arrasyid et al., 2023).
Conservative Islam
Conservative is an effort to maintain or preserve old (ancient) traditions, while limiting changes.
Those changes can come from globalization, information technology, or changes in behavior or lifestyle.
Pratama (2019) says that conservatism is a political philosophy theory that supports traditional values.
According to Maghfuri (2019) conservatism is a religious understanding and practice that is based on literal
texts (Quran and Sunnah) or doctrines, and ancient teachings, it even usually becomes fundamentalist
Islam in order to extremely achieve political goals. Religious behavior that arises from a conservative
understanding is usually also shown by a religious attitude that is full of enthusiasm, obedience, and seems
more Islamic compared to other Muslims. In another language, Zuhdi (2018) says that conservative groups
generally reject modern, progressive, and liberal interpretations of Islam. Furthermore, conservative
understanding hardly provides an opportunity to reinterpret the text so that it seems textual and rigid.
Thus, conservative is an effort to maintain old traditions and does not want to change these traditions even
though the conditions faced and scientific developments already require changes. Whereas, conservatism
is a very strong understanding to reject all forms of interpretation and try to defend and fight for it even
through violent (radical) channels.
According to Van Bruinessen, as quoted by Jubba et al. (2021) and Maghfuri (2019), there are three
reasons for the growth of conservative Islam in Indonesia. First, the reality of Indonesian Islamic society,
which has generally been conservative since the beginning. Second, moderate Islamic groups are more
oriented towards practical politics which causes the development of moderate Islam itself to be weak.
Third, the strong influence of the Middle East in Indonesia, which in general also carries a conservative
ideology. Regarding the number of terms that appear in discussing the meaning of conservative, Maghfuri
(2019) says that conservative, fundamentalist, and salafi have the same meaning which is a form of literal
religious understanding and does not accept reinterpretation, whereas when this understanding is
demonstrated in the form of violence, acts of violence in religion is called radical. This group is not only
growing in Indonesia, but also in various other Islamic countries such as Turkey and Malaysia. In Turkey,
conservative Islamic movements have succeeded in incorporating Islamic education into the country’s
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║43

educational curriculum since 1990 and have gradually phased out the secular curriculum (Guven, 2019).
In Malaysia, conservative Islam has shown its movement in the political field with the victory of the PAS
party (Islamic Party of Malaysia) in the general elections in the state of Trengganu in 1999, as well as
proving the defeat of Islam Hadhari (moderate Islam) promoted by Abdullah Ahmad Badhawi (Fauzi
Abdul Hamid & Ismail, 2014). Thus, conservative Islam does not only focus on the practice of religion in
the form of worship, but has influenced the course of Islamic politics in various Islamic countries and is
always dealing with moderate and progressive Islamic understanding and movements.

Method
This research is qualitative research which was conducted in Sungai Landia, one of the areas in
Agam Regency, West Sumatra, Indonesia. Data sources were from community leaders, scholars, and
women in the research location. The data were collected by conducting interviews and observation (Elfia
et al., 2022). The questions in the interview were well prepared and related to research questions, but if the
informants’ answers led to something the writer had not thought of before, the writer would explore these
answers with adjusted questions. The observations were made to strengthen the interview data which
were done by observing people’s behavior (Wahyuti et al., 2020) regarding the implementation of the Eid
prayer, and observing the research location to obtain additional data which led to a shift in the procedure
for implementing the Eid prayer from progressive to conservative. After collecting the data, the writer
grouped it according to the data group, and then they were arranged systematically. For analyzing the
data, descriptive and inductive methods were used. The descriptive method was used to describe and
explain the data more, while the inductive method is used to draw general conclusions from the subjective
data obtained from each informant. In addition, data analysis was also carried out by linking one event to
another, one tradition to another, to be able to find a relationship between traditions in that area and the
shift in the implementation of the Eid prayer from progressive to conservative.

Results and Discussion

The Practice of Female Imams and Khatib Then and Now
The implementation of the Eid prayer at the Sungai Landia by appointing women as imams and
khatib is something interesting because it has never been practiced anywhere else. Some of the informants
interviewed did not know the history how this practice began. The results of interviews with several
informants are written as follows:
Table 1.
Informant Interview Result
Arnel (65 yo) The female imam and khatib who used to lead the eid prayers at the Sungai Landia was
Tuo Maziar who died in 2018 (Tuo means the old one). She was a Quran recitation
teacher, and in fact all Quran recitation teachers there were women. The implementation
of the eid prayer led by Tuo Maziar had been going on for a very long time until 2016.
She performed as a khatib by reading the text based on the pillars of the sermon which
was previously corrected by one of the male scholars there named Inyiak Haji Mustafa
(Arnel, 2023).
Ali Akbar Tuo Maziar was one of the women who often becomes the imam and khatib of eid
Chaniago (50 prayers, but apart from that there were also other women, they were Tuo Jawaher and
tahun Tuo Nurmailis. These three women always took turns leading the eid prayer
congregation every year, even though the congregation they led was a group of women
and children (Chaniago, 2023).
Anna Fadilla I have ever been the imam and khatib of the eid prayer at Sungai Landia, but only once.
(48 yo) Actually, several women and I were prepared as cadres to replace the old female imams,
but we did not stay in Sungai Landia village (have moved to another place). In my
44 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

opinion, the implementation of the eid prayer is normal, there is no need to debate it. In
fact, this has spurred the enthusiasm of generations of young women in Sungai Landia
to study religion by going to Islamic boarding schools. However, because they do not
stay in Sungai Landia, in the end the female cadres who would continue the religious
tradition were no longer responsive to the development of religious tradition in their
hometown (Fadilla, 2023).
Asrul (44 yo) Geographically the Landia River consists of Ateh Village and Baruah Village (Ateh
means upper and Baruah means lower). There are two mosques there, the Al-Ihsan
Mosque in Ateh Village and the Istiqamah Mosque in Baruah Village. Annually, male
and female congregations take turns in carrying out the eid prayers in both mosques.
The male congregation is led by a man, and the female congregation is led by a woman.
Separation of male and female congregations is due to large population while there are
only two mosques. In addition, this separation also means the unification of the
congregation from Ateh Village and Baruah Village, so that there will always be
friendship among the women there. The solidarity of women is very high regarding any
traditional or religious events held in this village. Even though men and women have
still been separated in the implementation of the eid prayer, but since 2016 the imam is
already male, no longer female (Asrul, 2023).

Based on the excerpts from the interviews above, it can be understood that previously women held
strategic positions in the religious field, especially in teaching recitation and writing of the Quran to
children in Sungai Landia. The imam and khatib for the eid prayer were also entrusted to these women. It
is recorded that there were three female figures who alternately became imams and khatibs, and all of them
were religious teachers in Sungai Landia. The practice of female imams and khatibs had been going on for
a long time in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra and ended in 2016. Initially, this practice was due to the limited
prayer area, thus male and female congregations had to be separated. Even though they were separated,
the separation was also to maintain unity and brotherhood between Ateh Village and Baruah Village. It
seems that this practice was initiated by a male ulama there named Inyiak Haji Taha because he was the
teacher of Tuo Maziar and other female imams. The interview above also illustrates that one of the reasons
the women accepted the change was because there were no more cadres of female imams and preachers
who settled in Sungai Landia after the death of the three women, although there were cadres who were
prepared, but they did not stay there (migrate) and did not respond again to replace the three women.
When there is a demand for a conservative shift, there is certainly no argument that can be presented by
the women's group to maintain the tradition.
The Shifting Process
Based on the practice of the Eid prayer above, it does not mean women lead men, but there are
separate congregations between men and women. The male congregation is led by a male imam and vice
versa. The process of separation between men and women was stated informants as follows:
Table 2.
Informant Interview Result
Arnel (65 yo) Planning to change the practice of women imam and khatibs had been planned since
2012, but could not be implemented at that time. We have to change the old tradition
gradually because we don’t want chaos in society, especially women’s groups. We
started the change by increasing people’s knowledge first. We asked the lecturers we
invited to Sungai Landia to study the provisions of Islamic law regarding the eid prayer
(Arnel, 2023).
Asrul (44 yo) The change in the implementation of the eid prayer was based on several Ateh villagers
who had received higher education and were more familiar with sharia/fiqh. They tried
to straighten out the practice of the eid prayer in accordance with the fiqh provisions
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║45

they had learned. We have also invited lecturers from State Islamic University of
Bukittinggi City who specifically gave lectures to the public about the provisions for the
eid prayer. In his lecture he explained that the practice of the eid prayer that occurs in
Sungai Landia was not commonly carried out by people in other places and was
different from the Sunnah of the Prophet, thus it must be returned to the true sharia,
where the imam and khatib must be men (Asrul, 2023).

The information above illustrates that the process of shifting the form of the implementation of the
Eid prayer on Sungai Landia began with providing sufficient knowledge to the public by bringing in
scholars from outside Sungai Landia to provide religious knowledge, especially the fiqh of prayer. It seems
that the knowledge provided by the scholars who were invited there was very influential in shifting the
way of worship carried out by the community. Moreover, many Sungai Landia’s younger generations had
taken higher religious education which allowed them to understand the Eid prayer procedure better, based
on the sunnah of the Prophet. Therefore, the steps taken to shift to normal prayer practices have been
carried out in earnest to change this tradition. Therefore, there was generally no negative reaction from
society, especially women, when this tradition changed.
Social and Women’s Reaction
Social reactions concerning a change of tradition are common, and Sungai Landia society is no
exception. The object of change was focused on women who used to practice the Eid prayer with female
imam and khatib. Reactions and arguments about the change are illustrated in the following information:
Table 3.
Informant Interview Result
Arnel (65 yo) The plan to change the practice of Eid prayers at Sungai Landia began with an intense
debate held at Al-Ihsan Mosque in 2016. Pros and cons occurred between the groups
who wanted to maintain the tradition and those who wanted to change it. Women’s
groups did seem to have much response to the proposed change concerning reduction
to their rights to be as independent as men in leading prayers. After undergoing quite a
long debate, finally the women’s group was able to accept and agreed on deliberative
decisions (Arnel, 2023).
Ali Akbar There were no more female cadres capable of becoming imams and khatib in Sungai
Chaniago (50 Landia. Even though there were some women who had religious education and were
yo) able to become khatibs, they migrated far away to other places. Therefore, in accordance
with the conditions, the rejection from women’s groups was not supported by strong
arguments, especially when they were faced with the Sunnah of the Prophet
Muhammad concerning the practice of eid prayer. Under these conditions, the women’s
group finally accepted the change (Chaniago, 2023).
Anna Fadilla (48 At first, we objected to this change, because we thought it would break up the unity that
tahun) had long existed among women in Sungai Landia, but because the purpose of this
change was precisely to carry out worship in accordance with the sunnah of the Prophet
Muhammad SAW and had been discussed by the community by involving women, in
the end we agreed. The change is only about male imams and khatibs, in practice it is
still separated between female and male congregations (Fadilla, 2023).

Based on the table above, it can be understood that in principle the women in Sungai Landia did not
object to the shift in the procedure for carrying out the Eid prayer as had been practiced so far. The shift is
only in terms of the imam and khatib who are required to be male, but still separate between male and
female congregations. Moreover, in reality, the are no more cadres of female imams and khatibs, making
it difficult to maintain this tradition. Therefore, the shift went well without any chaos in the community.
46 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

The Support and Tradition That Goes Around

Carrying out a tradition cannot be separated from other traditions that surround it. Removing one
of them will have an impact on the loss of other traditions (Busyro et al., 2023). Therefore, the tradition of
eid prayers with female imams and khatibs did not stand alone, there were traditions that must be carried
out simultaneously. The following are excerpts of interviews with several informants:
Table 4.
Informant Interview Result
Radiah (64 yo) The residents of Ateh Village and Baruah Village are the native. There are no migrants
from outside who build houses and settle in this village. They cannot be separated in
carrying out the holidays. The reason for this is because the two villages have been
linked by marriages between them. Thus, people who are married are still in the same
village. Because of that we are related to each other, marrying each other between
different tribes. When the eid prayers must be separated, we, as women of Ateh Village
and Baruah Village, felt uncomfortable. The Taklim al-Ihsan Council is a combination of
the women of the two villages. We agreed not to join the men in the eid prayer, even
though we are no longer allowed to be imam and khatib because now we consider that
the women’s union in our village is more than arguing about female imam and khatib
(Radiah, 2023).
kArnel (65 yo) The kinship that has existed between Ateh Village and Baruah Village due to marriages
made the women’s union in Sungai Landia very strong. Their only request is to keep the
eid prayers separate from the men, even though we actually want to carry out the eid
prayers like in other places, where men and women pray together. But to maintain the
unity of the women, finally the men agreed to remain separated as before, even though
now the imam and khatib are men (Arnel, 2023).
Ali Akbar Judging from the social conditions of women in Sungai Landia, they prefer to gather
Chaniago (50 with other women, both at traditional events and at other religious events. Gathering
yo) together with men in various activities is not their preference (Chaniago, 2023)

Based on some of the information above, it can be understood that there is one thing that the Sungai
Landia women consider in continuing to separate themselves from the male congregation in carrying out
the eid prayer, it is the women’s union. The Sungai Landia women’s association has been very strongly
intertwined because not only for the reason of living in the same village, but more than that. In general,
they have relatives throughout the village, both marital relations and ethnic kinship. The tradition of
gathering among fellow women does not only occur during eid prayers, but in all traditional and religious
activities. Therefore, there are logical reasons why the Sungai Landia women want to remain separated in
carrying out the Eid prayers with the male congregation.
The Survival of Progressive Aspects in The Shift of Worship to Conservative in Sungai Landia
Sungai Landia is one of the villages in IV Koto District, Agam Regency, West Sumatra Province,
Indonesia, with an area of 16,072 with a population of 2,359 people, consisting of 1,122 men and 1,237
women (Palanta, 2020). Sungai Landia directly borders Balingka Village, which also has a tradition of
making women imams and khatibs, although it has now been abandoned (Busyro, 2017; Ikhwan et al.,
2022). Deputy Governor of West Sumatra, Audy Joinaldy, said that the Landia River would be promoted
as a cultural tourism destination in West Sumatra because it had a special culture and beautiful panorama.
He conveyed this during his working visit to Sungai Landia on February 16th, 2022 (Barat, 2022). This
proves that Sungai Landia is one of the priority villages to be developed as a tourism village in West
Sumatra because it still maintains an interesting local culture, one of which is the tradition of eid prayers
which is different from other regions.
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║47

The interview result did not show any connection between the practice of female imam and khatib
in Sungai Landia and the women’s emancipation movement, because the first perpetrators of this activity
were no longer there. The informants did not know certainly the reason for the separation of men and
women during the eid prayers. However, the author strongly suspects that the origin of this specialization
was due to the desire of women to separate themselves from men during eid prayers and this was also
supported by the charismatic ulama of Sungai Landia, Inyiak Haji Taha. This is because they already have
sufficient knowledge to be equal to men in various matters, including religious knowledge. Apart from
that, it is impossible for the practice of this religious ritual to be different from other Muslims if it is not
started with sufficient knowledge for it. If it were only natural factors, there would be many villages around
Mount Singgalang, with the same topography, which would also do the same thing, but in fact this practice
only happened in Nagari Sungai Landia. According to the author, natural factors and the limited mosques
are only supporting factors for the occurrence of this religious tradition.
The tradition of female imam and khatib at Sungai Landia has ended since 2016 and the Eid prayers
have been led by male imam and khatib just like the sunnah of the Prophet SAW. However, this shift does
not necessarily shift the tradition of women there to continue to gather with other women in all traditional
and religious activities. Changing tradition is not an easy thing, many things need to be done before the
tradition is actually changed to other forms. The desire of community leaders in Sungai Landia to make
changes began in 2012, but sufficient knowledge was needed beforehand to ensure these changes occur.
This is justified Salceda et al., (2020), according to him, without socialization and an adequate knowledge
base, it will be vulnerable to rejection. According to Chigbu (2019) regarding the rights that women have
had thus far, negotiating is necessary to change them because there are different interests between men
and women in these changes. In a different theme, says that in making a change to an established religious
tradition, it is necessary to carry out intensive and massive outreach to the community in order to avoid
misunderstanding and public chaos.
Negotiations carried out by the women of Sungai Landia resulted in a policy to continue to give
them their rights to carry out the eid prayer as was the previous tradition on which the female congregation
was separated from the male congregation during the eid prayer. They take turns occupying different
mosques, even though the imam and khatib are already men. There is a progressive part that is still being
maintained amidst the strong currents of the transition to conservatives. The progressive part is the
recognition of the existence of women to be equal to men in carrying out their religious activities.
Dzuhayatin (2020) says that in the study of gender equality, women’s position in this matter has received
recognition in the public sphere by not opposing religious theological concepts, especially in carrying out
the eid prayer. This acknowledgment at the same time generates benefits for the people of Sungai Landia
because the decision to make a shift has taken into account the sociological values and traditions of the
community (Reskiani et al., 2022). Thus, the shift theory put forward by Kuhn et al., (2012) to make changes
in accordance with normal knowledge and provide alternatives that can be accepted by all people has been
realized in Sungai Landia. The wisdom of the entire Sungai Landia community is also in accordance with
the rule that in making changes to tradition one must continue to maintain good old traditions, not
eliminate them altogether.

Conclusion
The shifting in the implementation of the eid prayers in Sungai Landia initiated by the village head
together with local clerics and traditional leaders, by abolishing women’s rights to become imam and
khatib do not necessarily eliminate the progressive sides of Sungai Landia women. The process of changing
to a conservative Islamic practice, by returning to the rules based on the Sunnah of the Prophet SAW, was
carried out carefully by the policy holders there. Religious studies that specifically discuss fiqh provisions
regarding eid prayers were carried out before these changes occurred, besides always socializing that the
old tradition was not fully in accordance with fiqh provisions. The community began to realize their
mistake because of the criticism from the younger generations in Sungai Landia who had received higher
48 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

religious education, seperti Asrul, alumni Madarah Sumatra Tawalib dan Anna Fadilla, and they tried to
rectify this practice so that it complies with the provisions of fiqh. These criticisms were not only from the
local younger generation, but also from lecturers who were invited to give religious lectures. After the
knowledge given to the community was sufficient, the shift was carried out by returning to conservative
fiqh which was marked by the abolition of women’s rights to become imams and khatibs of the eid prayer.
In general, the reaction of the Sungai Landia women did not show significant resistance, they accepted on
condition that the implementation of the eid prayer must still be separated between male and female
worshipers even at different mosques in the village, though the imam and khatib are men. Progressive
sides are still being maintained by public recognition of women being separated from men in the
implementation of the eid prayer.
This paper has been able to show a different side from previous studies regarding female imam and
khatib in the eid prayers. This paper also has limitations in terms of the number of informants who do not
involve the views of scholars outside Sungai Landia and because there are no more initial figures in the
history of this tradition. Research with the same theme is still widely open for other researchers with more
number of informants and with different research objectives and questions

Acknowledgement
This research is inseparable from the help of various parties, especially research informants who are
willing to answer questions related to the theme of this research. Thanks also go to the rektor of the State
Islamic University (UIN) Bukittinggi, who previously facilitated the authors by disbursing funds to learn
to write articles. Thanks are also conveyed to the author's supervisor in writing articles, Irwan Abdullah, I
hope that the knowledge that has been taught will always motivate writers to always write scientific
articles.

Conflict of Interest
There is no conflict of interest.

References
Abdullah, M. A. (1996). Studi agama: normativitas atau historisitas? Pustaka Pelajar.
Abubakar, S., & Mutawali, M. (2020). Pandangan Amina Wadud Terhadap Perempuan Menjadi
Imam Sholat Laki-Laki (Suatu Pendekatan Tafsir Hemeneutik). Schemata: Jurnal Pascasarjana
IAIN Mataram, 9(1), 15–32. https://doi.org/10.20414/schemata.v9i1.1021
Açikgenç, A. (1996). The Framework for a history of Islamic Philosophy. Al-Shajarah: Journal of the
International Institute of Islamic Thought and Civilization (ISTAC), 1(1&2).
https://journals.iium.edu.my/shajarah/index.php/shaj/article/view/177.
Açıkgenç, A. (2000). Scientific thought and its burdens: An essay in the history and philosophy of science.
Fatih University Publications.
al-Naisabûri, M. ibn H. A. Y. al-Q. (n.d.). al-Musnad al-Shahîh al-Mukhtashar bi Naql al-‘Adl ilâ
Rasûlillâh SAW. Dâr al-Ihyâ` al-Turâts al-‘Arabi.
Al-Tirmidzî, M. ibn ‘Îsâ. (1975). Sunan al-Tirmidzî 2. Musthafâ al-Bâbî al-Halabî.
Aminudin, A. (2019). Islam Progresif: Telaah atas Pemikiran Omid Safi. Farabi, 16(2), 147–160.
https://doi.org/10.30603/jf.v16i2.1085
Aminudin, A. (2021). Pemikiran Abdullah Saeed Tentang Muslim Progresif Sebagai Jalan Alternatif
Tantangan Era Modern. RUSYDIAH: Jurnal Pemikiran Islam, 2(1), 40–52.
https://doi.org/10.35961/rsd.v2i1.267
Arnel. (2023). Interview. Sungai Landia.
Arrasyid, F., Pagar, Tanjung, D., & Nor, M. R. M. (2023). The Progressivity of Umar Ibn Al-Khattab’s
Ijtihad in Responding to Community Social Changes. Al-Istinbath: Jurnal Hukum Islam, 8(1), 21–
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║49

36. https://doi.org/10.29240/jhi.v8i1.4872
Asrul. (2023). Interview. Sungai Landia.
Barat, M. P. S. (2022, February). Wagub Sumbar Kunjungi Nagari Budaya Sungai Landia.
InfoPublik.Id.
Blum, A., Gavroglu, K., Joas, C., & Renn, J. (Eds.). (2012). Shifting Paradigms: Thomas S. Kuhn and
the History of Science. In Proceedings of the conference “50 Years Since Structure: Towards a History
of the History of Science. Max Planck Institute for the History of Science.
Bukhârî, M. ibn I. A. ‘Abdillâh al. (1422). 3al-Jâmi’ al-Musnad al-Ṣ ahîh al-Mukhtaṣ ar min Umûr
Rasûlillâh SAW wa Sunanuh wa Ayyâmuh 3. Dâr al-Ṭ awwâf al-Najâh.
Busyro. (2017). Female imam and khatib: The progressive tradition of gender-responsive practices
in Balingka, West Sumatera. Journal of Indonesian Islam, 11(2).
https://doi.org/10.15642/JIIS.2017.11.2.531-550
Busyro, B., Alwana, H. A., Arsal, A., Shafra, S., & Basir, G. (2022). Implementasi Islam Progresif pada
Permendikbud Ristek No. 30 Tahun 2021 dalam Kajian Filsafat Hukum Islam. Al-Manahij:
Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam, 16(1), 153–168. https://doi.org/10.24090/mnh.v16i1.6321
Busyro, Burhanuddin, N., Muassomah, M., Saka, P. A., & Wafa, M. A. (2023). The Reinforcement of
the ‘Dowry for Groom’ Tradition in Customary Marriages of West Sumatra’s Pariaman Society.
Samarah, 7(1), 555–578. https://doi.org/10.22373/sjhk.v7i1.15872
Chaniago, A. A. (2023). Interview. Sungai Landia.
Chigbu, U. E. (2019). Masculinity, men and patriarchal issues aside: How do women’s actions
impede women’s access to land? Matters arising from a peri-rural community in Nigeria. Land
Use Policy, 81, 39–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2018.10.033
Digarizki, I., & Al Anang, A. (2020). Epistemologi Thomas S. Kuhn: Kajian Teori Pergeseran
Paradigma dan Revolusi Ilmiah. Jurnal Humanitas, 7(1), 23–34.
https://doi.org/10.29408/jhm.v7i1.3285
Dzuhayatin, S. R. (2020). Gender glass ceiling in Indonesia: Manifestation, roots and theological
breakthrough. Al-Jami’ah, 58(1), 209–240. https://doi.org/10.14421/AJIS.2020.581.209-240
Elfia, Sari, S. M. R., Ikhwan, Bahar, M., & Shalihin, N. (2022). Patterns for Settlement of Punah
Inheritance Disputes In the Community of Nagari Salareh Aia from the Perspective of Islamic
Law. Al-Ihkam: Jurnal Hukum Dan Pranata Sosial, 17(2), 480–505. https://doi.org/10.19105/al-
Ihkam.v17i2.6246
Fadilla, A. (2023). Interview. Sungai Landia.
Fauzi Abdul Hamid, A., & Ismail, M. T. (2014). Islamist Conservatism and the Demise of Islam
Hadhari in Malaysia. Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations, 25(2), 159–180.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09596410.2014.880549
Guven, I. (2019). Neo-Conservative Islam and Trasition of Secular Education in Tukey. Journal for
The Study of Religions and Ideologies, 18(53), 37–59.
http://jsri.ro/ojs/index.php/jsri/article/view/1075
Hanbal, A. A. A. ibn M. ibn. (2001). Musnad al-Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal. Muassasah al-Risalah.
Heriyanto, H. (2003). Paradigma Holistik: Dialog Filsafat, Sains, dan Kehidupan Menurut Shadra dan
Whitehead. Khazanah Pustaka Ilmu.
Ikhwan, Fatia, A., Suratman, J., Ramadhan, M. N., & Alfaiz. (2022). The dialectic of fiqh
understanding and the female Imam-Khatib tradition in Balingka, West Sumatra, Indonesia.
Indonesian Journal of Islam and Muslim Societies, 12(2), 313–339.
https://doi.org/10.18326/ijims.v12i2.
Jubba, H., Awang, J., & Sungkilang, S. A. (2021). The Challenges of Islamic Organizations in
Promoting Moderation in Indonesia. Wawasan: Jurnal Ilmiah Agama Dan Sosial Budaya, 6(1), 43–
54. https://doi.org/10.15575/jw.v6i1.12948
Khulaisie, R. N. (2019). Islam Progresif dan Kesetaraan Gender Menurut Pemikiran Abdullah Saeed.
50 ║ JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 00 (00), 2023: 000-000

Muwazah Jurnal Kajian Gender, 11(1), 65–82. https://doi.org/10.28918/muwazah.v11i1.1976

Kuhn, T. S. (1970). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (Vol. 111). Chicago University of Chicago
Press.
Maghfuri, A. (2019). Countering Conservative-Radical Understanding By Mainstreaming Moderat
Islam and the Role of Educational Institution in Indonesia. Sunan Kalijaga International Journal
on Islamic Educational Research, 3(1), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.14421/skijier.2019.2019.31.01
Maidin, M. N. (2016). Perempuan Menjadi Imam Shalat (Kajian Hukum dalam Perspektif Hadis).
Al-Maiyyah, 9(1), 139–150. https://doi.org/10.35905/almaiyyah.v9i1.341
Muzani, A. (2014). Wanita Menjadi Imam Shalat, Diskursus dalam Perspektif Kesetaraan Gender.
Sawwa: Jurnal Studi Gender, 10(1), 33–46. https://doi.org/10.21580/sa.v10i1.628
Nuha, U. (2020). Studi Tentang Pluralisme Dalam Islam Progresif di Indonesia. Dewantara, 10(2),
160–172. https://ejournal.iqrometro.co.id/index.php/pendidikan/article/view/148
Nurkhalis, N. (2012). Konstruksi Teori Paradigma Thomas S. Kuhn. Jurnal Ilmiah Islam Futura, 11(2),
79–99. https://doi.org/10.22373/jiif.v11i2.55
Palanta, A. (2020, March). Nagari Sungai Landia, IV Koto, Kabupaten Agam. Langgam.Id.
Pratama, A. I. (2019). Inovatif dan Konservatif dalam Menghadapi Era 4.0. Tantangan Guru
Menyikapi Generasi Digital-Milineal. Annual Conference on Islamic Education and Social Sains
(ACIEDSS), 1(1), 23–33. https://pkm.uika-
bogor.ac.id/index.php/ACIEDSS/article/view/485
Qurtubi, A. ibn R. al. (n.d.). Bidayah al-Mujtahid wa Nihayah al-Muqtashid 1. al-Haramain.
Radiah. (2023). Interview. Sungai Landia.
Reskiani, A., Tenrilawa, D. F., Aminuddin, & Subha, R. (2022). Reform Methods of Islamic
Inheritance Law in Indonesia in Jurisprudence. Juris: Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah, 21(1), 39–51.
https://doi.org/10.31958/juris.v21i1.5564
Ritzer, G. (1992). Sociology: A Multiple Paradigm Science (Sosiologi Ilmu Pengetahuan Berparadigma
Ganda) (Alimandan (Ed.)). Rajawali Pers.
Rochmad, A. (2013). Gagasan Hukum Progresif Perspektif Teori Maslahah. Al-Manahij: Jurnal Kajian
Hukum Islam, 7(1), 1–14. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.24090/mnh.v7i1.572
Sahbana, M. D. R. (2022). Epistimologi paradigma dan revolusi ilmu pengetahuan Thomas Kuhn.
Kanz Philosophia A Journal for Islamic Philosophy and Mysticism, 8(1), 31–48.
https://doi.org/10.20871/kpjipm.v8i1.188
Salceda, M., Vidu, A., Aubert, A., & Roca, E. (2020). Dialogic Feminist Gatherings: Impact of the
preventive socialization of gender-based violence on adolescent girls in out-of-home care. Social
Sciences, 9(8), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.3390/SOCSCI9080138
Sarifudin, S. (2019). Hukum Islam Progresif: Tawaran Teori Maslahat At-Thufi sebagai Epistemologi
untuk Pembangunan Hukum Nasional di Indonesia. Jurnal Wawasan Yuridika, 3(2), 135–154.
https://doi.org/10.25072/jwy.v3i2.269
Sholeh, M. A. N. (2020). Towards a Progressive Fatwa: MUI’s Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic.
Ahkam: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah, 20(2), 281–298. https://doi.org/10.15408/ajis.v20i2.17391
Smart, N. (1981). The Philosophy of Worldviews - That is, the Philosophy of Religion Transformed.
Neue Zeitschrift Fur Systema Tische Theologie Und Religion Philosophie, 23(1), 212–224.
https://doi.org/10.1515/nzst.1981.23.1.212
Sulaimân, A. D. (n.d.). Sunan Abî Dâwûd 1. Maktabah al-‘Ashriyah.
Syamsurijal. (2016). Kontroversi Imam Perempuan; Study Maudhu’iy Terhadap Hadist-Hadist
Imam Perempuan dalam Shalat. Al-Fikr, 20(2), 234–255.
https://doi.org/10.24252/jumdpi.v20i2.2319
Tohis, R. A. (2021). Islam Progresif dan Tan Malaka (Reposisi MADILOG Sebagai Metode Pemikiran
Islam Progresif). Aqlam: Journal of Islam and Plurality, 6(2), 84–105.
https://doi.org/10.30984/ajip.v6i2.1586
 Female Imam and Khatib: The Shifting in Worship Traditions from Progressive to Conservative in Sungai Landia, West Sumatra, Indonesia ║51

Trigiyatno, A. (2014). Kontroversi Perempuan Menjadi Imam Salat Di Kalangan Fukaha. Jurnal
Hukum Islam, 12(1), 49–61. https://doi.org/10.28918/jhi.v12i1.527
Ulya, I., & Abid, N. (2015). Pemikiran Thomas Kuhn dan Relevansinya terhadap Keilmuan Islam.
Fikrah, 3(2), 249–276. https://doi.org/10.21043/fikrah.v3i2.1797
Wahyuti, Salman, D., Bastiana, Agustang, A., Arwan, & Yani, A. (2020). Why Do People Fail to
Comply with the Smoking Ban in Public Places?(The Case of Jayapura City, Indonesia).
Systematic Reviews in Pharmacy, 11(10), 732–736. https://www.sysrevpharm.org/articles/why-
do-people-fail-to-comply-with-the-smoking-ban-in-public-places-the-case-of-jayapura-city-
indonesia.pdf
Zuhdi, M. (2018). Challenging Moderate Muslims: Indonesia’s Muslim Schools in the Midst of
Religious Conservatism. Religions, 9(310), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel9100310