You are on page 1of 7

Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology

ISSN No:-2456-2165

The Impact of Digital Resources on Government


and Private School Education Systems
Pardip Kaur1; Dr. Payare Lal2
Research Scholar1; Professor2
Department of Library & Information Science
Desh Bhagat University, Mandi Gobindgarh (Punjab)

Abstract:- The integration of digital resources into I. INTRODUCTION


educational systems has transformed the landscape of
teaching and learning. This research paper explores the In the 21st century, the pervasive influence of
impact of digital resources on both government and technology has dynamically altered the landscape of
private school education systems. The study employs a education, with digital resources emerging as transformative
mixed-methods approach, combining surveys, tools in the teaching and learning process. This research
interviews, and case studies to comprehensively assess delves into the consequential impact of digital resources on
the implications of digital integration. education systems, specifically exploring the divergent
trajectories within government and private schools. As
The literature review provides a historical context educational paradigms continue to evolve, understanding
of digital integration in education, highlighting the how these institutions harness digital tools becomes
evolution of technology in both government and private imperative for shaping effective policies and practices.
school settings. A comparative analysis reveals  Background and Context: The historical trajectory of
distinctions in the adoption rates, challenges faced, and education has been marked by periods of innovation, and
existing studies on the effectiveness of digital resources the current era is no exception. The advent of digital
in these two educational spheres. resources - encompassing interactive smart boards,
online platforms, e-books, and diverse applications - has
The methodology section outlines the research ushered in an era where traditional teaching methods are
design, sampling strategy, and data collection methods augmented or, in some cases, revolutionized. This
employed to gather insights from educators, research situates itself within this context, seeking to
administrators, and students. Digital resources, comprehend how the integration of digital resources
including smartboards, online platforms, and e-books, shapes the educational experience in government and
are categorized and examined, shedding light on the private schools.
varied approaches taken by government and private  Overview of Education Systems: Government and
schools in their adoption. private schools represent distinct spheres within the
educational landscape, each governed by unique
The impact on teaching and learning is explored,
structures, funding mechanisms, and administrative
elucidating changes in pedagogical methods, student
frameworks. This study acknowledges the diversity
engagement, and academic performance. Infrastructure
inherent in these systems and aims to dissect the nuanced
and access disparities between government and private
ways in which digital resources impact teaching,
schools are discussed, along with initiatives aimed at
learning, and overall educational outcomes.
mitigating the digital divide. The role of professional
development for educators in acquiring digital skills is  Statement of the Research Problem: As digital
emphasized, highlighting its importance in successful resources permeate classrooms, a critical examination is
integration. required to discern their implications for both
government and private schools. While literature
The paper delves into the policy and governance highlights the potential benefits, it also underscores
frameworks that support or hinder the implementation challenges related to equity, infrastructure, and
of digital resources. Case studies offer specific examples pedagogical adaptation. This research aims to contribute
of successful integration in government and private to the existing body of knowledge by offering a
schools, showcasing innovative approaches and lessons comprehensive analysis of the impact of digital
learned. The study also identifies ongoing challenges and resources in the context of diverse educational settings.
proposes potential solutions, concluding with  Significance of the Study: The importance of this
recommendations for future research directions and the research lies in its potential to inform educational
continued enhancement of digital education in policies, guide decision-makers, and inspire educators to
government and private school systems. adapt to the evolving educational landscape. By
understanding the differential impact on government and
Keywords:- Education, Resources, Digital. private schools, stakeholders can tailor interventions that
cater to the unique needs and challenges of each setting,
fostering a more equitable and effective educational
environment.

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 1
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
II. FUNCTIONS G. Addressing Learning Diversity:
 Inclusive Education: Digital tools can be customized to
The functions of digital resources in government and cater to diverse learning needs, including those of
private school education systems are multifaceted, students with special needs. This inclusivity is crucial for
encompassing various aspects of teaching, learning, creating an equitable educational environment.
administration, and overall educational efficacy. Here are
key functions associated with the integration of digital H. Preparation for the Digital Age:
resources in these educational settings:  Digital Literacy: Integrating digital resources prepares
A. Enhanced Teaching Methods: students for the demands of the digital age, equipping
 Interactive Learning: Digital resources enable teachers to them with essential digital literacy skills that are
engage students interactively, fostering a more increasingly vital in the modern workforce.
participatory learning environment through tools like
smartboards, multimedia presentations, and educational I. Global Collaboration:
software.  Virtual Learning Environments: Digital resources
 Personalized Instruction: Adaptive digital platforms facilitate global collaboration by connecting students
allow for tailored learning experiences, addressing with peers and educators from around the world,
individual student needs and pacing, which is fostering cross-cultural understanding and collaboration
particularly beneficial in diverse classrooms. on projects and initiatives.

B. Accessible Learning Materials: J. Continuous Assessment and Feedback:


 E-books and Online Resources: Digital resources  Online Assessment Tools: Digital resources enable
facilitate easy access to a wealth of educational continuous assessment through online quizzes, tests, and
materials, including e-books, articles, and online interactive assignments, providing real-time feedback to
resources, reducing the dependence on traditional both students and teachers.
textbooks and broadening the scope of learning materials
available to students. III. SCOPE

C. Student Engagement and Motivation: Understanding and harnessing these functions


 Gamification: Educational games and interactive effectively can contribute to the successful integration of
simulations can be integrated into the curriculum, digital resources in government and private school education
enhancing student engagement and motivation by systems, ultimately enhancing the quality and relevance of
making learning more enjoyable and relevant. education in the digital era.
Multimedia Content: The use of multimedia elements, The scope of digital resources in government and
such as videos and animations, can make complex private school education systems is expansive,
concepts more accessible and engaging for students. encompassing various dimensions that influence teaching,
D. Administrative Efficiency: learning, administration, and overall educational outcomes.
Here are key aspects that define the scope of digital
 Data Management: Digital resources streamline
resources in these educational settings:
administrative tasks, including student records,
attendance tracking, and grading, promoting efficient A. Teaching and Learning:
data management and reducing paperwork for educators.  Curriculum Enhancement: Digital resources offer
 Communication Platforms: Digital tools facilitate opportunities to enrich the curriculum with multimedia
communication between teachers, students, and parents, content, interactive simulations, and online learning
creating a more transparent and collaborative educational modules, providing students with a more dynamic and
environment. engaging learning experience.
E. Professional Development for Educators:  Adaptive Learning Platforms: The scope extends to
adaptive learning platforms that cater to individual
 Training Programs: Digital resources provide
student needs, allowing for personalized learning
opportunities for teachers to enhance their digital literacy
experiences and addressing diverse learning styles.
and teaching skills through training programs, ensuring
that educators are well-equipped to integrate technology B. Professional Development:
effectively into their classrooms.  Teacher Training: Digital resources provide a platform
F. Infrastructure Development: for ongoing professional development, offering teachers
opportunities to enhance their digital literacy skills and
 Technological Infrastructure: The adoption of digital
incorporate innovative teaching methodologies into their
resources often necessitates the development of robust
practices.
technological infrastructure in schools, including high-
speed internet, computer labs, and other facilities,
contributing to the overall modernization of educational
institutions.

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 2
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
C. Accessibility and Inclusivity: reliance on traditional textbooks and expanding access to
 Addressing Learning Diversity: Digital resources play a wide array of learning materials.
a crucial role in creating inclusive learning
environments, allowing for customization to meet the Understanding the comprehensive scope of digital
diverse needs of students, including those with varying resources in government and private school education
learning abilities. systems is essential for educators, administrators,
policymakers, and other stakeholders as they navigate the
D. Administrative Efficiency: integration of technology to enhance the quality and
 Data Management: The scope includes the streamlining effectiveness of education.
of administrative tasks through digital tools, such as
electronic record-keeping systems, attendance tracking, IV. DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN DIGITAL
and automated grading, reducing the administrative RESOURCES ON GOVERNMENT AND
burden on educators. PRIVATE SCHOOL EDUCATION SYSTEMS
 Communication Platforms: Digital resources facilitate The integration of digital resources in government and
efficient communication among teachers, students, and private school education systems can exhibit differences in
parents, fostering a collaborative and transparent various aspects, including access to technology, funding,
educational ecosystem. administrative structures, and policy frameworks. Here are
E. Infrastructure Development: the key differences between digital resources in government
and private school education systems:
 Technological Infrastructure: The scope extends to the
development of robust technological infrastructure A. Funding and Resources:
within schools, including high-speed internet, computer  Government Schools: Government schools may face
labs, and devices, to support the seamless integration of budget constraints, impacting their ability to invest in
digital resources. advanced technological infrastructure and a wide range
F. Global Connectivity: of digital resources. They often rely on government
funding, which may be limited compared to the financial
 Virtual Learning Environments: Digital resources
enable schools to connect globally, fostering resources available to private institutions.
collaboration between students and educators from  Private Schools: Private schools typically have more
different regions. Virtual exchanges and collaborative financial autonomy and can allocate larger budgets for
projects become feasible, promoting cross-cultural technology integration. This allows them to invest in
understanding. state-of-the-art digital resources, such as interactive
whiteboards, cutting-edge software, and a variety of
G. Assessment and Feedback: educational technologies.
 Continuous Assessment: Digital resources allow for
continuous assessment through online quizzes, tests, and B. Technological Infrastructure:
interactive assignments, providing timely feedback to  Government Schools: In some cases, government
both students and educators. schools may lack the necessary technological
infrastructure, including high-speed internet, computer
 Data-Driven Decision-Making: The scope includes the
labs, and devices, which can impact the seamless
use of data analytics to inform educational decision-
integration of digital resources.
making, allowing institutions to identify trends, assess
student performance, and implement targeted  Private Schools: Private schools are generally better
interventions. positioned to invest in and maintain robust technological
infrastructure, facilitating smoother integration of digital
H. Parental Involvement: resources into daily educational practices.
 Parent-Teacher Communication: Digital resources
C. Access to Devices:
facilitate communication between teachers and parents
through online platforms, keeping parents informed  Government Schools: Students in government schools
about their child's progress, assignments, and overall may face challenges in terms of personal access to
school activities. digital devices outside of the classroom. Limited access
to computers or tablets can influence the extent to which
I. Preparation for the Future: digital resources are utilized for homework or individual
 Digital Literacy Skills: The scope extends to equipping study.
students with essential digital literacy skills, preparing  Private Schools: Private schools may provide students
them for the demands of a digitally-driven future with greater access to personal digital devices, ensuring
workforce. that they can fully engage with digital resources both
inside and outside the classroom.
J. Resource Management:
 E-Books and Online Libraries: Digital resources D. Policy and Regulation:
encompass the creation and utilization of e-books, online  Government Schools: Integration of digital resources in
libraries, and educational repositories, reducing the government schools is often influenced by broader
educational policies and regulations set by government

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 3
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
bodies. These policies may vary across regions and A. Enhanced Teaching Methods:
impact the flexibility of implementation.  Government Schools: Digital resources empower
 Private Schools: Private schools have more autonomy educators in government schools to adopt innovative
in setting their educational policies and can often adapt teaching methods, incorporating multimedia
more quickly to emerging trends and technologies presentations, interactive simulations, and online
without waiting for government mandates. educational platforms to make lessons more engaging
and effective.
E. Teacher Training and Support:  Private Schools: In private schools, the availability of
 Government Schools: Teachers in government schools more extensive financial resources often allows for the
may face challenges in terms of receiving adequate adoption of cutting-edge digital tools and technologies,
training and support for the effective integration of further enhancing the diversity and depth of teaching
digital resources. Limited professional development methods.
opportunities can hinder the implementation of
technology in the classroom. B. Student Engagement and Motivation:
 Private Schools: Private schools may have more  Government Schools: Digital resources play a crucial
resources to invest in teacher training programs, ensuring role in capturing the attention of students in government
that educators are well-equipped to leverage digital schools, making lessons more interactive and enjoyable,
resources effectively for instructional purposes. thereby increasing student engagement and motivation.
 Private Schools: Private schools can leverage a wider
F. Curriculum Customization: array of digital tools to create immersive learning
 Government Schools: Curriculum customization may experiences, catering to diverse learning preferences and
be more constrained in government schools due to sustaining high levels of student motivation.
standardized testing and curricular requirements
mandated by educational authorities. C. Accessibility to Learning Materials:
 Private Schools: Private schools often have more  Government Schools: Digital resources provide
flexibility in designing and customizing their curriculum, government schools with the ability to offer a more
allowing for a more tailored integration of digital extensive range of learning materials, including e-books,
resources aligned with specific educational goals. online articles, and educational videos, reducing reliance
on traditional textbooks and broadening access to
G. Socioeconomic Factors: resources.
 Government Schools: Students in government schools  Private Schools: Private schools, often having more
may come from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds, financial flexibility, can invest in comprehensive digital
impacting their access to digital devices and the internet libraries, ensuring students have access to a wealth of
outside of school. educational content beyond the traditional curriculum.
 Private Schools: Private school students may, on
average, come from higher socioeconomic backgrounds, D. Personalized Learning:
potentially having more resources for personal digital  Government Schools: Digital resources enable
devices and a conducive home environment for utilizing government schools to implement personalized learning
digital resources. approaches, catering to individual student needs,
adapting content based on learning styles, and offering
While these differences exist, it's essential to note that additional support where required.
the digital divide is a complex issue, and efforts are being  Private Schools: Private schools, with their greater
made globally to bridge these gaps and ensure equitable resources, can invest in advanced adaptive learning
access to digital resources in education. Both government platforms that provide highly personalized learning
and private schools can benefit from strategic planning and experiences, further tailoring education to individual
collaboration to maximize the positive impact of digital student abilities and preferences.
resources on student learning outcomes.
E. Administrative Efficiency:
V. ROLE OF DIGITAL RESOURCES IN  Government Schools: Digital resources streamline
GOVERNMENT AND PRIVATE SCHOOL administrative tasks in government schools, such as
EDUCATION SYSTEMS attendance tracking, grade management, and
communication with parents, improving overall
The role of digital resources in government and private
administrative efficiency.
school education systems is instrumental in shaping modern
education, enhancing teaching and learning practices, and  Private Schools: Private schools, often equipped with
preparing students for the demands of the digital age. Here more advanced management systems, can benefit from
are the key roles that digital resources play in both enhanced administrative tools, contributing to smoother
government and private school settings: operational processes.

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 4
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
F. Professional Development for Educators:
 Government Schools: Digital resources facilitate A. Digital Divide:
ongoing professional development for educators in  Issue: One of the most significant criticisms is the
government schools, ensuring they stay updated on digital divide, where students in economically
technological advancements and effective integration disadvantaged areas may lack access to the necessary
strategies. devices and high-speed internet required for effective
 Private Schools: Private schools, with potentially more digital learning.
resources, can invest in comprehensive training  Impact: This disparity exacerbates educational
programs, empowering educators to maximize the inequalities, hindering the ability of some students to
impact of digital resources on teaching and learning. benefit fully from digital resources and participate
equally in the digital learning environment.
G. Infrastructure Development:
 Government Schools: The integration of digital B. Inequitable Access:
resources in government schools often involves the  Issue: In some cases, even if devices are provided, there
development of necessary technological infrastructure, might be insufficient training or support for educators
including the provision of computer labs, internet and students to use digital resources effectively, leading
connectivity, and devices. to inequitable access and utilization.
 Private Schools: Private schools, with greater financial  Impact: This can result in a situation where the potential
capabilities, can invest in state-of-the-art technological benefits of digital resources are not fully realized across
infrastructure, ensuring a seamless and robust all demographic groups, contributing to educational
environment for the effective use of digital resources. disparities.

H. Global Connectivity: C. Overemphasis on Technology:


 Government Schools: Digital resources enable  Issue: Critics argue that an overemphasis on digital
government schools to connect globally, fostering resources may lead to a neglect of other crucial aspects
collaboration with schools and students from different of education, such as interpersonal skills, critical
regions, and promoting cultural exchange and global thinking, and creativity, which are not always addressed
awareness. adequately by digital tools.
 Private Schools: Private schools, with potentially more  Impact: Focusing too much on technology might
extensive networks, can facilitate advanced global diminish the importance of holistic education and
connectivity initiatives, expanding opportunities for overlook the development of essential non-digital skills.
international collaborations and learning experiences.
D. Pedagogical Concerns:
I. Assessment and Feedback:  Issue: Some critics express concerns that digital
 Government Schools: Digital resources enable resources might promote passive learning or over-
continuous assessment in government schools, allowing reliance on pre-packaged content, potentially limiting
for online quizzes, tests, and interactive assignments that opportunities for active student engagement and critical
provide timely feedback to both students and educators. thinking.
 Private Schools: Private schools, with potentially more  Impact: If not used thoughtfully, digital resources might
sophisticated assessment tools, can implement advanced contribute to a more traditional, teacher-centric approach
data analytics to derive insights, further enhancing the to education rather than facilitating student-centered,
quality of feedback provided. inquiry-based learning.

J. Preparation for the Digital Age: E. Cost Implications:


 Government Schools: The integration of digital  Issue: The initial costs of implementing digital
resources in government schools prepares students for resources, including purchasing devices, software
the digital age by imparting essential digital literacy licenses, and providing training, can be a significant
skills, enhancing their readiness for the technologically financial burden for both government and private
driven workforce. schools.
 Private Schools: Private schools, with greater resources,  Impact: Schools with limited budgets may struggle to
can often provide more comprehensive programs that go afford the necessary infrastructure and may divert
beyond basic digital literacy, preparing students for resources from other essential educational needs.
advanced technological challenges and opportunities.
F. Security and Privacy Concerns:
VI. CRITICISM  Issue: The use of digital resources raises concerns about
data security and student privacy. Inadequate safeguards
While digital resources have significantly transformed may expose sensitive student information to
education, there are criticisms and challenges associated unauthorized access or compromise.
with their integration into both government and private  Impact: The fear of data breaches and privacy violations
school education systems. It's important to acknowledge can erode trust among parents, educators, and students,
these criticisms to inform ongoing discussions and potentially hindering the adoption of digital resources.
improvements. Some of the common criticisms include:

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 5
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
G. Teacher Resistance: C. Innovative Administrative Practices:
 Issue: Some educators may resist the integration of Digital resources have streamlined administrative tasks,
digital resources due to a lack of training, fear of enhancing efficiency in both government and private
technology replacing their role, or skepticism about the schools. From attendance tracking to communication with
effectiveness of digital tools. parents, these tools contribute to a more effective and
 Impact: Teacher resistance can hinder the successful transparent educational administration.
implementation of digital resources, as educator buy-in
is crucial for their effective integration into the teaching D. Challenges in Implementation:
and learning process. The implementation of digital resources is not without
challenges. Issues such as the digital divide, inadequate
H. Dependence on Internet Connectivity: teacher training, and privacy concerns pose significant
 Issue: Reliance on internet connectivity for accessing hurdles that demand attention and strategic solutions to
digital resources can be problematic in areas with ensure effective integration.
inconsistent or unreliable internet access.
E. Balancing Technology and Pedagogy:
 Impact: Students and educators may face disruptions in
Striking a balance between leveraging technology and
learning, and instructional continuity may be
preserving effective pedagogical practices is crucial. Critics
compromised when internet connectivity is unreliable.
argue against an overemphasis on digital tools at the
I. Rapid Technological Obsolescence: expense of holistic education, emphasizing the importance
 Issue: The rapid pace of technological advancements of cultivating critical thinking and interpersonal skills.
may lead to the obsolescence of digital resources,
F. Financial Considerations:
requiring frequent updates and replacements.
Financial considerations play a pivotal role in the
 Impact: This can strain budgets and create challenges in successful integration of digital resources. Private schools,
maintaining compatibility with evolving technological
with more extensive financial resources, often have a
standards.
competitive advantage in adopting cutting-edge
J. Standardization Concerns: technologies, while government schools face budgetary
 Issue: Some argue that the standardization of digital constraints that may limit their capabilities.
resources may lead to a one-size-fits-all approach, G. Data Security and Privacy:
neglecting the diverse learning needs and preferences of The use of digital resources raises legitimate concerns
students. about data security and student privacy. Both government
 Impact: A lack of customization and personalization in and private schools must prioritize robust safeguards to
digital resources may limit their effectiveness in protect sensitive information and build trust among
addressing the unique requirements of individual stakeholders.
learners.
H. Teacher Professional Development:
VII. CONCLUSION Effective integration of digital resources hinges on
comprehensive teacher professional development. Ensuring
In conclusion, the integration of digital resources in
that educators are well-equipped with the skills to leverage
government and private school education systems has
technology is crucial for maximizing the benefits of digital
ushered in a transformative era, shaping the landscape of
tools in the classroom.
teaching and learning. While these technologies have
brought about numerous benefits, it is essential to recognize I. Adapting to Evolving Technologies:
the challenges and complexities associated with their The rapid pace of technological evolution poses
implementation. The following key points summarize the challenges related to the potential obsolescence of digital
overarching implications of digital resources in education: resources. Schools must adapt to emerging technologies and
commit to continuous updates to ensure relevance and
A. Transformation of Teaching and Learning: effectiveness.
Digital resources have redefined pedagogical
approaches, offering interactive and engaging methods that J. Customization and Inclusivity:
cater to diverse learning styles. Both government and private Striving for customization in digital resources is
schools have witnessed a paradigm shift toward more essential to address the diverse learning needs of students.
dynamic and student-centered educational practices. The one-size-fits-all approach may neglect individual
differences, emphasizing the need for personalized,
B. Addressing Educational Inequalities
inclusive educational experiences.
The digital divide remains a pressing concern,
particularly in government schools where access to In navigating these complexities, it is evident that both
technology may be limited. Bridging this gap requires government and private schools have critical roles to play in
concerted efforts to ensure equitable access to digital shaping the future of education. Collaboration, thoughtful
resources for all students, irrespective of socio-economic policies, and a commitment to addressing disparities are
background. essential for realizing the full potential of digital resources
in fostering a dynamic and inclusive educational

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 6
Volume 9, Issue 1, January 2024 International Journal of Innovative Science and Research Technology
ISSN No:-2456-2165
environment. By acknowledging the challenges and building ki/Sustained_Blended_Professional_Development_in_t
on the successes, educational stakeholders can work he_21st_Century
together to create a balanced, technology-enhanced [15]. Attwell, G. (2007). Personal learning environments—
educational landscape that prepares students for the The future of e-learning? eLearning Papers,2(1), 1–8.
complexities of the digital era. [16]. Barnett, H. (2002). How to guarantee a learning return
on your technology investment. eSchool News, 1–5.
REFERENCES [17]. Bauer, J., & Kenton, J. (2005). Toward technology
integration in the schools: Why it isn’t happening.
[1]. Alberta Education. (2013). Learning and Technology Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 13(4),
Policy Framework 2013. Edmonton, AB, Canada: 519–546.
Alberta Education, School Technology Branch. [18]. OFFICE OF Educational Technology 93
Retrieved from [19]. Bolam, R., McMahon, A., Stoll, L., Thomas, S., &
http://www.education.alberta.ca/media/7792655/learni Wallace, M. (2005). Creating and sustaining effective
ng-and-technology-policy-framework-web.pdf professional learning communities (Research Report
[2]. Alliance for Excellent Education. (2012). The digital No. 637). Bristol, England: University of Bristol.
learning imperative: How technology and teaching Retrieved from http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/5622/1/RR637.pdf
meet today’s education challenges. Retrieved from
http://all4ed.org/wp-
content/uploads/2012/01/DigitalLearningImperative.pd
f
[3]. American Association of School Administrators.
(2010). 2011 District Excellence Award for
digitallearning.
[4]. Retrievedfromhttp://www.aasa.org/uploadedFiles/Prog
rams_and_Events/Awards_and_Scholarships/Technolo
gy_Award/2011_Technology_Award/2011_Technolog
y_Award2011
[5]. AASA_LS_App_procedure_082410.pdf
[6]. Amirian, S. (2007). Digital backpacks: Facilitating
faculty implementation of technologies for teaching
and learning. Computers in the Schools, 24(1/2), 5–14.
[7]. Anderson, R. E., & Dexter, S. L. (2000). School
technology leadership: Incidence and impact.
[8]. Irvine: University of California, Center for Research
on Information Technology and
[9]. Organizations. Retrieved from
http://escholarship.org/uc/item/76s142fc#page-7
[10]. Anderson, R. E., & Dexter, S. L. (2005). School
technology leadership: An empirical investigation of
prevalence and effect. Educational Administration
Quarterly, 41(1), 49–82.
[11]. Anderson, T., & Elloumi, F. (Eds.). (2004). The theory
and practice of online learning. Athabasca, AB,
Canada: Athabasca University Press.
[12]. Annenberg Institute for School Reform. (2004).
Professional learning communities: Professional
development strategies that improve instruction.
Providence, RI: Author. Retrieved from http://
www.annenberginstitute.org/pdf/proflearning.pdf
[13]. Argueta, R., Huff, J., Tingen, J., & Corn, J. O. (2011).
Laptop initiatives: Summary of research across seven
states (Friday Institute White Paper No. 4). Raleigh:
North Carolina State University, the William & Ida
Friday Institute for Educational Innovation. Retrieved
from https://www.fi.ncsu.edu/wp-
content/uploads/2013/05/laptop-initiatives-summary-
of-research-across-seven-states.pdf
[14]. Armstrong, M., & Earle, L. (2012). Sustained blended
professional development in the
21stcentury.Retrievedfromhttp://etec.ctlt.ubc.ca/510wi

IJISRT24JAN020 www.ijisrt.com 7

You might also like