You are on page 1of 169

Radiologic Physics Taught Through Cases

Jonathon A. Nye, PhD


Associate Professor
Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences
Emory University School of Medicine
Atlanta, Georgia

231 illustrations

Thieme
New York • Stuttgart • Delhi • Rio de Janeiro
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Important note: Medicine is an ever-changing science
is available with the publisher undergoing continual development. Research and clinical
experience are continually expanding our knowledge, in
particular our knowledge of proper treatment and drug
therapy. Insofar as this book mentions any dosage or appli-
cation, readers may rest assured that the authors, editors,
and publishers have made every effort to ensure that such
references are in accordance with the state of knowledge at
the time of production of the book.
Nevertheless, this does not involve, imply, or express any
guarantee or responsibility on the part of the publishers in
respect to any dosage instructions and forms of applications
stated in the book. Every user is requested to examine
carefully the manufacturers’ leaflets accompanying each
drug and to check, if necessary in consultation with a phy-
sician or specialist, whether the dosage schedules mentioned
therein or the contraindications stated by the manufacturers
differ from the statements made in the present book. Such
examination is particularly important with drugs that are
either rarely used or have been newly released on the market.
Every dosage schedule or every form of application used is
entirely at the user’s own risk and responsibility. The authors
and publishers request every user to report to the publishers
any discrepancies or inaccuracies noticed. If errors in this
work are found after publication, errata will be posted at
www.thieme.com on the product description page.
Some of the product names, patents, and registered
designs referred to in this book are in fact registered trade-
© 2020. Thieme. All rights reserved. marks or proprietary names even though specific reference
Thieme Publishers New York to this fact is not always made in the text. Therefore, the
333 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10001 USA appearance of a name without designation as proprietary is
+1 800 782 3488, customerservice@thieme.com not to be construed as a representation by the publisher that
it is in the public domain.
Georg Thieme Verlag KG
Rüdigerstrasse 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany
+49 [0]711 8931 421, customerservice@thieme.de

Thieme Publishers Delhi


A-12, Second Floor, Sector-2, Noida-201301
Uttar Pradesh, India
+91 120 45 566 00, customerservice@thieme.in

Thieme Publishers Rio de Janeiro,


Thieme Publicações Ltda.
Edifício Rodolpho de Paoli, 25º andar
Av. Nilo Peçanha, 50 – Sala 2508
Rio de Janeiro 20020-906 Brasil
+55 21 3172 2297

Cover design: Thieme Publishing Group


This book, including all parts thereof, is legally protected by
Typesetting by DiTech Process Solutions, India
copyright. Any use, exploitation, or commercialization out-
side the narrow limits set by copyright legislation without the
Printed in USA by King Printing Company, Inc. 54321
publisher’s consent is illegal and liable to prosecution. This
ISBN 978-1-62623-967-8 applies in particular to photostat reproduction, copying,
mimeographing or duplication of any kind, translating, prep-
Also available as an e-book: aration of microfilms, and electronic data processing and
eISBN 978-1-626-23971-5 storage.
Contents

Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix

Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . x

1. Fluoroscopy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Rebecca Milman Marsh and Michael Silosky

1.1 Case 1: SID, ABC, and Radiation 1.7 Case 7: Digital Subtraction
Output . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Angiography and Motion
Artifacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
1.2 Case 2: Reference Air Kerma and
1.8 Case 8: Fluoroscopy Modes and
Skin Dose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Dose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
1.3 Case 3: Collimation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
1.9 Case 9: Equalization Filters . . . . . . . . . . 18

1.4 Case 4: Anti-scatter Grids . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 1.10 Case 10: Cone Beam Computed
Tomography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
1.5 Case 5: Patient Shielding . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
1.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
1.6 Case 6: CT Fluoroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

2. Mammography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Ingrid S. Reiser

2.1 Case 1: Magnification Imaging. . . . . . 26 2.7 Case 7: Microcalcification-like


Appearance Caused by a Detector
2.2 Case 2: Focal Spot Size Selection Artifact . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36
in Magnification Views . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
2.8 Case 8: Artifact due to Imperfection
2.3 Case 3: X-ray Acquisition Technique in Compression Paddle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
Factors in Mammography . . . . . . . . . . . 29
2.9 Case 9: Patient Motion Causing
2.4 Case 4: Digital Breast Tomosynthesis: Blurred Parenchymal Structure
Artifacts due to High-Contrast in a Mammogram. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Objects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 2.10 Case 10: EMI Artifact due to LVAD
2.5 Case 5: Effect of Image Device . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
Post-Processing on the Appearance 2.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
of a Mammogram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32

2.6 Case 6: Artifact due to Detector


Row Dropout . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
Contents

3. Computed Tomography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
Karen L. Brown and Jason R. Gold

3.1 Case 1: Ring Artifact . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 3.6 Case 6: Displayed Volume CT Dose


Index and Patient Size . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51
3.2 Case 2: Effect of Patient Size
3.7 Case 7: Beam Hardening Artifact . . . 52
on CT Number Accuracy . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45
3.8 Case 8: Partial Volume Artifact . . . . . 53
3.3 Case 3: Effect of kV Selection
3.9 Case 9: Metal Artifact . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54
on Image Quality and Dose . . . . . . . . . 46
3.10 Case 10: Motion Artifact . . . . . . . . . . . . 55
3.4 Case 4: Image Quality Variation
with Reconstructed Slice 3.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56
Thickness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47

3.5 Case 5: Image Quality Variation


with Reconstruction Filter . . . . . . . . . . 49

4. Magnetic Resonance Imaging . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59


Puneet Sharma

4.1 Case 1: Appearance of Discrete 4.6 Case 6: Application of Fat-Suppressed


Image Ghosts on Abdominal Sequences in the Pelvis did not
Imaging . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 Reveal the Expected Contrast . . . . . . . . 71

4.2 Case 2: A Well-Defined Area of 4.7 Case 7: T1-Weighted Gradient


Signal Hyperintensity Appears Echo of the Abdomen Shows
Bilaterally at the Level of the Marked Artifact Medially on Both
Internal Auditory Canal on Coronal and Axial FOV, Obscuring
Diffusion-Weighted MRI, Affecting Visualization of Soft Tissues . . . . . . . . 74
Visualization of Surrounding
4.8 Case 8: Abnormal Dark Fluid Seen
Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62
in the Bladder of an Axial Single-Shot
T2-Weighted Sequence, but not on
4.3 Case 3: Appearance of Extra
Location-Matched 3D T2
Field-of-view Anatomy on the
Acquisition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76
Inferior Portion of Sagittal 3D
T2-Weighted Acquisition of the 4.9 Case 9: Postcontrast T1-Weighted
Spine. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Gradient Echo Reveals Patchy
Enhancement in the Anterior
4.4 Case 4: Precontrast, Axial 3D
Septal Wall . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79
T1-Weighted Gradient Echo with
Fat Suppression Shows Adequate 4.10 Case 10: Significant Signal-to-Noise
Anatomical Detail, but Minor Edge Variation Across the FOV, Creating
Ripple and Blur that is Presumed Nondiagnostic Image Quality . . . . . . . 82
to be Motion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
4.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85
4.5 Case 5: Dark Etching Appears
at the Boundary of Fat and
Soft-Tissue Layers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69

vi
Contents

5. Nuclear Medicine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90
Jonathon A. Nye, James R. Galt, and John N. Aarsvold

5.1 Case 1: Degraded Resolution of a 5.6 Case 6: The Effects of Image


Whole-Body Planar 99mTc Methylene Di- Smoothing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104
phosphonate Image . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91
5.7 Case 7: Choosing the Correct
5.2 Case 2: Effect of Positron Range Acquisition Image Matrix Size . . . . . 106
on Image Quality and Resolution . . . 94
5.8 Case 8: Assessing Patient Motion
in Myocardial Perfusion Imaging . . 108
5.3 Case 3: Standardized Uptake
Value in Positron Emission 5.9 Case 9: Bremsstrahlung Imaging
Tomography (Noise Bias) . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 of 90Y Microspheres Liver
Embolization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110
5.4 Case 4: The Impact of Attenuation
Correction in PET . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 5.10 Case 10: Degraded Image
Quality from an Improper
5.5 Case 5: Iterative Reconstruction
Collimator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112
and Choosing the Number of
Iterations and Subsets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 5.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114

6. Ultrasound Imaging . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117


Zheng Feng Lu

6.1 Case 1: Pulse-Echo Imaging 6.6 Case 6: Range Ambiguity in


Principle and Speed of Sound B-Mode . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129
Propagation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118
6.7 Case 7: Shadowing and
6.2 Case 2: Array Transducers Enhancement (Increased Through
and Sound Frequency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 Transmission) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130

6.8 Case 8: Harmonic Imaging . . . . . . . . . 132


6.3 Case 3: Nonuniformity
(Array Transducer Element
6.9 Case 9: Ultrasound Image
Dropouts) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122
Display on Scanners and
6.4 Case 4: Pulse-Echo Imaging in Reading Rooms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133
Acquisition Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124
6.10 Case 10: Doppler Ultrasound
6.5 Case 5: Reflection (Boundary Aliasing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135
Conditions)—Reverberation
6.11 Review Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138
Artifacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127

vii
Contents

7. Image Processing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143


Jonathon A. Nye and Randahl C. Palmer

7.1 Case 1: Filtering and Edge 7.3 Case 3: Fused Image Display
Enhancement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 144 of Multiple Modalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148

7.2 Case 2: Maximum Intensity 7.4 Case 4: Multimodality Image


Projection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146 Registration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150

Answer Key . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152

Index. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155

viii
Preface
Radiology residents gather their medical physics their clinical workstation. Although the breadth of
knowledge from multiple sources, often beginning this topic area is large, the goal of this text is to provide
with their first encounter with a radiologic image. examples relevant to diagnostic radiology training,
Although many educational approaches start with thereby proving to be of high value to the learner.
fundamental physical concepts and work toward Chapters are divided according to modality, each
image generation, they are likely to require an having 10 topics presented in a case format that is
extended period of time to build a conceptual frame- meant to quickly convey information with an image
work. Arguably, the clinical demands of residency followed by a brief explanation. Some important
training do not always allow for a traditional class- topics, such as radiation safety, do not lend them-
room approach, as it can be much more efficient to selves to teaching from images but are part of impor-
learn about radiologic imaging principles during the tant encounters like occupational or patient hazards
course of a clinical rotation. Therefore, a hybrid during a fluoroscopic-guided procedure. In these
approach may be more amenable, which begins with cases, schematics are provided to assist in teaching.
a study of images commonly encountered during The reader is encouraged to consult the chapter refer-
diagnostic radiology training and provides a straight- ences for further discussion. Review questions are
forward and compact explanation of the physical provided at the end of each chapter to reinforce the
factors underlying the creation and displayed con- case concepts.
trast of these images. To that end, this book presents a
number of common physical concepts in diagnostic Jonathon A. Nye, PhD
radiology, which may be encountered by a resident at

ix
Contributors
John N. Aarsvold, PhD Jonathon A. Nye, PhD
Associate Professor Associate Professor
Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences
Emory University School of Medicine Emory University School of Medicine
Atlanta, Georgia Atlanta, Georgia

Karen L. Brown, MHP, CHP, DABR Randahl C. Palmer, MS


Diagnostic Imaging Physicist Resident,
Department of Radiology Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences
Penn State College of Medicine Emory University School of Medicine
Hershey, Pennsylvania Atlanta, Georgia

James R. Galt, PhD Ingrid S. Reiser, PhD


Professor Associate Professor
Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences Department of Radiology
Emory University School of Medicine The University of Chicago
Atlanta, Georgia Chicago, Illinois

Jason R. Gold, DO Puneet Sharma, PhD


Resident Assistant Professor
Department of Radiology Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences
Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center Emory University School of Medicine
Hershey, Pennsylvania Atlanta, Georgia

Zheng Feng Lu, PhD Michael Silosky, MS


Professor Assistant Professor
Department of Radiology Department of Radiology
The University of Chicago University of Colorado School of Medicine
Chicago, Illinois Aurora, Colorado

Rebecca Milman Marsh, PhD


Associate Professor
Department of Radiology
University of Colorado School of Medicine
Aurora, Colorado

x
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1 Fluoroscopy
Rebecca Milman Marsh and Michael Silosky

Introduction ensuring that image quality is adequate to achieve


the clinical task being performed, the operator is
Shortly after the discovery of X-rays in the late responsible for dose management throughout the
nineteenth century, fluoroscopy was developed to exam, not only for the safety of the patient but also
enable visualization of moving anatomy. Today, for all staff members present. Understanding fluo-
fluoroscopy is used for diagnosis and guidance of roscopy imaging parameters and their effect on
clinical procedures. Applications of fluoroscopy both image quality and dose is essential for anyone
are found throughout medicine, including radi- operating or supervising the operation of a fluoro-
ology, cardiology, urology, and speech pathology. scopy system.
Fluoroscopy has the same tradeoffs between An essential function of modern fluoroscopy
image quality and radiation exposure as other systems is the continuous adjustment of X-ray
X-ray-based modalities. During a fluoroscopy tube output to maintain adequate image quality
exam, multiple factors affect radiation dose to throughout the procedure. This feedback loop
patients and staff. Some may be directly controlled between the detection system and the X-ray tube
by the fluoroscopy operator while others are is commonly referred to as automatic brightness
dictated by patient habitus and the procedure control (ABC), referring to the goal of maintaining
being performed. Some interventional procedures a constant brightness on the output phosphor of
can be very complex, requiring long fluoroscopy the image intensifier.1 With the advent of digital
times to accomplish the clinical task. detectors, this same concept is sometimes
Fluoroscopy differs from most other imaging referred to as automatic dose control (ADC).
modalities in that the physician is often directly Throughout this chapter, we will use the tradi-
involved in image acquisition. In addition to tional term ABC.

1
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.1 Case 1: SID, ABC, and Table 1.1 Acquisition parameters, reference air kerma
rates, and estimates of skin dose are shown for a range
Radiation Output of source-to-image receptor distances
Reference Skin dose
1.1.1 Background SID AKR rate
kV mA
● A patient undergoes a fluoroscopy-guided L1 (cm) (mGy/ (mGy/
minute) minute)
kyphoplasty procedure to treat vertebral body
119 65 5.1 3.03 5.6
compression.
110 65 4.4 2.62 4.79
● At the start of the procedure, the operator places
100 66 3.3 2.07 3.89
the image detector 10 cm above the patient.
90 67 2.6 1.65 3.18
● In order to properly insert the cannula into the
Abbreviations: AKR, air kerma rate; SID, source-to-image
vertebral body, the operator has to raise the receptor distance.
detector to 30 cm above the patient.
In addition, the distance between the X-ray source
1.1.2 Findings and the patient’s skin (known as the source-to-
skin distance [SSD]) directly impacts
Increasing the distance between the X-ray source patient dose. Dictated by the inverse square law,
and the image detector increased the reported air doubling the distance between the radiation
kerma rate (AKR) by a factor of approximately 1.5. source and an object will result in a reduction
in exposure to that object by 75%. In the case
1.1.3 Discussion described here, the increase in X-ray tube
output can be calculated using the equation:
Patient dose is dependent on the source-to-image
receptor distance (SID) which is the distance 1
between the source of X-rays (the focal spot of the ðr2 =r1 Þ2
X-ray tube) and the image receptor. As SID
changes, the fluoroscopy system adjusts acquisi- Thus, where r1 = 50 cm and r2 = 100 cm.
tion parameters, directly affecting the radiation 1 1
¼
output. As discussed in the beginning of this ð100=50Þ2 4
chapter, the ABC algorithms used by fluoroscopy
systems adjust tube output to maintain image or 25%.
appearance. For a fixed X-ray output, as the When determining how the patient and equip-
distance to the image receptor increases, the ment should be positioned for an exam, one
amount of radiation that reaches the image should consider the location(s) where the operator
receptor decreases. For example, at an SID of needs to directly access the patient, how much
100 cm, only 25% as many X-ray photons will working space is needed between the patient and
intercept the detector compared to an SID of the detector, any special positioning needs of the
50 cm. To compensate for fewer photons reaching patient, and operator ergonomic factors such as
the receptor at larger SIDs, ABC algorithms table height. While some of these factors are
increase X-ray tube output. Typically, this is done dictated by the needs of the specific exam and
by changing one or more of the following parame- operator, ensuring that SID is as small as practical
ters: kV, mA, pulse width, or beam filtration. This can help to reduce patient dose.
will result in an increase in reference air kerma
(AK) and, assuming a constant distance between
the X-ray source and the patient’s skin, an increase
1.1.4 Resolution
in patient dose. This is illustrated in ▶ Table 1.1 The following steps can help reduce patient dose
where entrance dose to a phantom was measured while maintaining affecting image quality. First,
under conditions of variable SID. for fluoroscopic systems with fixed SID, as is the

2
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.1 Case 1: SID, ABC, and Radiation Output

case with many mobile C-arms, the patient should patient positioning may be primarily dictated by
be positioned as close to the image receptor (as far the procedure being performed. Once the patient
from the source) as is practical, given the needs of has been positioned and the fluoroscopy system is
the procedure. Second, for fluoroscopic systems oriented as desired, the SID should be reduced as
with variable SID, such as those used in interven- much as is practical by moving the image receptor
tional radiology or cardiac catheterization labs, toward the source.

3
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.2 Case 2: Reference Air Kerma It is notable that in this case, the estimated PSD is
substantially greater than the AK reported by the
and Skin Dose machine. Patient skin dose is affected by several
factors including table attenuation, backscatter,
1.2.1 Background differences in how dose is deposited in various
● A patient undergoes a superior mesenteric arte- materials, and patient positioning. None of these
riogram for embolization of a pseudoaneurysm factors are considered when the system calculates
the displayed AK. While a thorough discussion is
in the transverse colon.
beyond the scope of this text, special attention
● At the end of the exam, the total reference AK is should be paid to the effects of patient positioning,
5100 mGy. specifically SSD.
● The case is referred to Radiation Safety so that a The most common reason for large differences
peak skin dose (PSD) estimate can be performed. between the displayed AK and the actual skin dose
is patient size. In the case described here, the pa-
tient was morbidly obese, and the location where
1.2.2 Findings the X-ray beam entered the patient’s skin was much
The estimated PSD is 7000 mGy, approximately closer to the X-ray source than the location where
1.5 times the reference AK displayed by the fluoro- the fluoroscopy system calculated the AK. As a
scopy system. consequence, the AK at the patient’s skin was
greater than the reference AK. As the AK at the
patient’s skin increases, skin dose will also increase.
1.2.3 Discussion These concepts are illustrated in ▶ Fig. 1.1. The
Fluoroscopy operators can monitor the use of radia- X-ray tube is under the patient table with the X-ray
tion during procedures by paying attention to focal spot (the source of the X-ray beam) indicated
machine-reported dose metrics. All modern fluoro- by a white “x.” The AK reference point (located
scopy systems are required to display the reference 65 cm from the focal spot) is indicated by a black
AK and reference AKR, where the reference AK is “x.” In ▶ Fig. 1.1a, the patient is closer to the X-ray
equivalent to the dose to air at a specific reference tube than the AK reference point is. Here the
point. (The exact location of the reference point entrance AK at the patient’s skin will be greater than
varies based on equipment vendor and model.) the reference AK. The opposite happens in
These values provide the operator with real-time ▶ Fig. 1.1b, where the patient is farther from the
dosimetry information throughout a case. Conse- source than the reference point. In this case,
quently, it is important to know how these values entrance AK will be lower than the reference AK. It
are measured and how they relate to patient expo- should be noted that variation between the
sure and patient skin dose, specifically. displayed AK and the entrance AK is governed
For fluoroscopy procedures, the primary radia- by the inverse square law—as an object moves
tion safety concern for patients is the PSD, which farther away from the source of radiation, the expo-
is the maximum dose to any single area of the skin. sure decreases as a factor of the square of the

Fig. 1.1 The relationship between


the X-ray focal spot (white “x”), the air
kerma reference point (black “x, and
the entrance point of the patient’s skin
are shown. (a) In this image the
patient’s skin is closer to the X-ray
source than is the air kerma reference
point, meaning that the reference air
kerma displayed by the system will
underestimate the patient’s skin dose.
(b) Here the patient’s skin is further
from the X-ray source. Consequently,
the air kerma displayed by the system
will overestimate the patient’s skin
dose.

4
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.2 Case 2: Reference Air Kerma and Skin Dose

distance. Consequently, entrance AK and actual diverge will allow the fluoroscopy operator to
patient skin dose may be larger or smaller than the manage radiation dose during a procedure.
reference AK.
The patient’s position relative to the AK refer-
ence point is not the only factor that affects the
1.2.4 Resolution
PSD. If, for example, the C-arm is rotated during If the AK reference point is at 65 cm from the focal
the fluoroscopy exam, the dose will be “spread spot, then the AK at 53 cm from the focal spot is
out” over different areas of the patient’s skin. (65/53)2 or 1.5. This means that if the displayed AK
Similarly, if the table or C-arm is translated so is 5100 mGy, then the patient entrance AK will be
that the imaging field of view moves from the approximately 7700 mGy. Other factors, such as
groin to the chest, the total AK displayed by the attenuation of the X-ray beam by the table, back-
system will include radiation delivered to scatter generated by the patient, and a conversion of
different portions of the skin. While any detailed entrance skin exposure to absorbed skin dose must
PSD estimate should be performed by a qualified be considered to determine the PSD. However,
medical physicist, understanding the relationship entrance AK can be used as a reasonable surrogate
between the displayed AK and patient skin dose for PSD when considering radiation management
and recognizing when these values are likely to during a fluoroscopy procedure.

5
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.3 Case 3: Collimation Table 1.2 The collimated field size and dose metrics for
the uncollimated and collimated images shown in
1.3.1 Background ▶ Fig. 1.2
Uncollimated Collimated
● Patient underwent a fluoroscopy-guided (left) (right)
exchange of a retrograde left nephroureteral tube.
Collimated field 21.9 × 28.4 cm 16.5 × 19.9 cm
● Two digital spot images were acquired during size (620 cm2) (328 cm2)
the procedure with different amounts of physical DAP (mGycm2) 446 278
collimation. AK (mGy) 1.3 1.3

Changes in collimation will not substantially affect


1.3.2 Findings AK. However, collimation will affect DAP (some-
● Collimation was used to reduce the field of view times called Kerma Area Product, or KAP) which is
another dose metric that is commonly displayed on
(from 21.9 × 28.4 cm to 16.5 × 19.9 cm; ▶ Table 1.2).
fluoroscopy systems. DAP is the product of AK and
● Dose area product (DAP) was reduced by 47%. field size, so even if AK remains constant, DAP will
change proportionally to the change in X-ray field
size. For procedures using single fields (i.e., the
1.3.3 Discussion position of the X-ray tube remains constant relative
This case illustrates that collimation (also some- to the patient throughout the exam), this will not
times referred to as “coning in”) can reduce radia- reduce the PSD substantially but will reduce the
tion exposure to both patients and staff and effective dose to the patient. For procedures with
improve image quality. Collimation uses lead shut- multiple fields, proper collimation can reduce the
ters inside the X-ray tube housing to reduce the likelihood of having overlapping radiation fields
imaging field of view. This enables one to image and potentially reduce PSD. In addition, collimation
(and irradiate) only the patient anatomy essential can greatly reduce staff exposure since a smaller
for performing the procedure. imaging field will produce less scatter radiation.

Fig. 1.2 Digital spot images acquired without collimation (a) and with collimation (b).

6
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.3 Case 3: Collimation

Finally, proper collimation has the additional 1.3.4 Resolution


benefit of enhanced image quality. Collimated fields
can be used to exclude very high- or low-attenu- In the example shown in ▶ Fig. 1.2, the field of
ating tissues, reducing the variation in signal inten- view was reduced from 21.9 × 28.4 cm (620 cm2)
sity across the field of view, which may improve in ▶ Fig. 1.2a to 16.5 × 19.9 cm (329 cm2) in
image contrast. Moreover, since proper collimation ▶ Fig. 1.2b; a reduction of 47%. DAP also decreased
reduces the amount of scatter created by patient 47%, i.e., from 807 mGycm2 (▶ Fig. 1.2a) to 428
tissue, images will appear with improved contrast mGycm2 (▶ Fig. 1.2a). AK was the same for both
(Table 1.2). images (1.3 mGy).

7
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.4 Case 4: Anti-scatter Grids Image quality is greatly influenced by the


scatter-to-primary ratio (SPR) or the ratio of the
1.4.1 Background amount of energy deposited in the detector by
scattered versus primary photons. If a fluoro-
● A 5-year-old patient undergoes a fluoroscopy- scopy system has an SPR of 3, this indicates that
guided cardiac procedure. 75% of the energy deposited in the detector is
● The patient had a similar procedure 6 months from scattered photons while the remaining 25%
prior where the total AK was 450 mGy. is from primary photons.
As the SPR increases, low-contrast objects are
● With a similar amount of fluoroscopy time and
more difficult to distinguish. Image quality can be
the same number of exposures, the AK for the improved by using an anti-scatter grid. The grids
current procedure was 1200 mGy. are made up of a series of septa made of lead or
other X-ray-attenuating material, and these septa
1.4.2 Findings preferentially absorb scattered photons while
allowing more of the primary photons to pass
● The same fluoroscopy system and imaging through. The grid is placed just in front of the
protocol were used for both procedures. image receptor, decreasing the SPR, and improving
image quality. Since the grid also absorbs some of
● The images for the prior procedure (▶ Fig. 1.3a)
the primary photons, the X-ray system must
have poorer image quality than the images from compensate by producing more photons (i.e.,
the later procedure (▶ Fig. 1.3b). increasing mAs), which increases patient dose. A
main determinant of how much scatter is
1.4.3 Discussion produced in a specific patient is patient habitus. As
the X-ray beam passes through additional tissue,
X-ray photons that reach the image detector are the number of scatter events increases. In other
either primary or scattered photons. Primary words, thicker anatomy and larger patients will
photons travel along a straight path through the produce more scatter than smaller patients.
patient until they are absorbed by the detector. Consequently, the anti-scatter grid has a substan-
Scattered photons are those that have interacted tial effect on image quality when imaging adult
with the patient’s tissue (or other objects) and patients, but it has little effect when imaging
have changed direction from their original path. extremities or small patients.

Fig. 1.3 Fluoroscopy images of an anthropomorphic chest phantom without (a) and with (b) an anti-scatter grid.

8
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.4 Case 4: Anti-scatter Grids

1.4.4 Resolution scatter photons, causing the ABC system to


increase both kV and mA. As a result, the AKR
▶ Fig. 1.3 shows an image of an anthropomorphic increased by a factor of almost 3.
chest phantom. The image on the left (▶ Fig. 1.3a)
Removing the anti-scatter grid is a common way
was obtained without an anti-scatter grid whereas
to reduce patient dose in fluoroscopy exams of
the image on the right (▶ Fig. 1.3b) was obtained
pediatric patients, where image quality is not
with the grid in place. The effect on image quality
substantially affected. However, in most adult (or
is apparent by looking at the increase in detail
visible in the image on the right (obtained using adult-sized) patients, the grid is required to
the grid.) However, for some clinical indications achieve adequate image quality. It should be noted
the image quality in ▶ Fig. 1.3 may be sufficient. that while many fixed fluoroscopy systems have
The acquisition parameters for the two images are removable grids, most mobile C-arms have fixed
also shown. The grid attenuates both primary and grids that cannot be removed.

9
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.5 Case 5: Patient Shielding affects both image quality and dose. First, as
shown in ▶ Fig. 1.4, the presence of the lead apron
1.5.1 Background substantially reduces contrast throughout the
image. Second, since lead is highly attenuating, it
● A patient who is 30 weeks pregnant undergoes significantly affects the function of the ABC algo-
a fluoroscopy-guided intervention to treat iliofe- rithm increasing the X-ray tube output and radia-
moral deep venous thrombosis. tion dose to the patient, fluoroscopy operator, and
● The patient is positioned prone on the table. other staff present during the case.2
Fetal radiation exposure during an exam of the
● A lead apron is placed under the patient’s
mother varies substantially based on whether
abdomen and pelvis (between the patient and
the fetus is in or outside the imaging field of
X-ray tube). view. If the fetus is in the imaging field of view, it
is exposed to the primary X-ray beam and radia-
1.5.2 Findings tion dose could exceed 100 mGy, above which
there is an increased the risk of congenital
● The lead apron covers most of the imaging field malformation, stillbirth, miscarriage, or mental
of view. disability.3 If the fetus is outside of the imaging
● Image quality is diminished as contrast is field of view, the majority of radiation exposure
reduced for important anatomical structures. is from scatter generated within the mother and
the fetal dose is typically below 1 mGy.4 At such
● The fluoroscopy system’s ABC algorithm
low dose levels, there is no demonstrated
increases tube output to compensate for increased risk to the fetus. For a more detailed
additional attenuation caused by the presence discussion of management of pregnant patient
of the lead. during fluoroscopy procedures, we refer the
reader to multisocietal guideline published by
Dauer et al.4
1.5.3 Discussion The use of patient shielding outside of the
Shielding materials (typically lead aprons) are imaging field of view has been advocated as a way
sometimes placed on or around patients with the to reduce radiation dose to staff. However, it is
goal of reducing radiation exposure to staff. This important to keep in mind that the vast majority
technique is also used with pregnant patients to of operator exposure comes from scatter created
reduce fetal exposure to radiation. However, by interactions of the primary beam with patient
placing lead under the patient may adversely tissue. In other words, the radiation to which an

Fig. 1.4 A digital spot image of


a pregnant patient who had lead
apron placed between her skin and the
X-ray tube in an attempt to provide
additional protection to the fetus.

10
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.5 Case 5: Patient Shielding

operator (and other staff) is exposed originates view. This carries the same risks as shielding
from the patient. Consequently, shielding placed placed directly in the beam for patient protection,
on the patient can only provide a protective i.e., reduced image quality and increased radiation
benefit when an operator is standing in a few exposure to both the patient and staff.
specific locations. In addition, it has been demon-
strated that even under these conditions, the
1.5.4 Resolution
protective benefit is negligible compared to that of
the operator’s own protective garments (i.e., lead In summary, shielding materials should not be
apron and glasses).5 placed on a patient. The benefit to the patient or
Finally, due to the dynamic nature of fluoro- operator is negligible, but the risk of compromising
scopically guided interventions, there is a risk that image quality is substantial. Furthermore, using
shielding initially positioned outside of the patient shielding may increase radiation dose to
primary beam might end up in the imaging field of everyone involved.

11
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.6 Case 6: CT Fluoroscopy


1.6.1 Background
● An obese patient with diabetes and a history of
colon cancer presents with an enlarging right
lower lobe nodule with metabolic activity on a
recent positron emission tomography (PET)/
computed tomography (CT) scan.
● The patient undergoes a CT-guided right lung
mass biopsy (▶ Fig. 1.5).
● A total of 30 scans are performed. The total
CT dose index (CTDIvol) for the procedure is
1200 mGy. The dose length product (DLP) is
12,600 mGy-cm.
Fig. 1.5 A CT image obtained during the biopsy
procedure. The arrow indicates where the biopsy
1.6.2 Findings needle is visible on the image.

The patient was referred to radiation safety for


an estimate of PSD to determine if follow-up X-ray tube will be closer to the patient’s skin if the
evaluation for radiation-induced skin injury was patient is obese, compared with the SSD for a
appropriate. smaller patient. Consequently, if a patient is obese,
the ratio of PSD to CTDIvol may be even higher than
it would be for a smaller patient.
1.6.3 Discussion
While traditional fluoroscopy is based on planar
imaging techniques, CT fluoroscopy can be used
1.6.4 Resolution
to create “real-time” cross-sectional images to In the case presented, the total CTDIvol is 1200
guide interventional procedures. Studies have mGy and the DLP is 12,600 mGy-cm. These dose
demonstrated that CT-guided biopsy is a low-risk metrics are considerably higher than those from a
method of obtaining tissue samples of media- typical diagnostic CT scan of the adult abdomen,
stinal masses.6 Dose metrics used in CT differ which has a CTDIvol of approximately 20 mGy and
from those used in fluoroscopy. A basic under- a DLP of approximately 1000 mGy-cm.8 Using the
standing of CT dose metrics is a fundamental relationship cited above, where the PSD is approx-
component of dose management in CT-guided imately 65% of the reported CTDIvol, PSD can be
interventional procedures. conservatively approximated as 780 mGy. This is
The radiation output of a CT scanner is well below the point at which radiation-induced
commonly characterized by the CTDIvol and DLP. skin damage is expected.9 Of note, the patient in
CTDIvol is an estimate of dose, in mGy, to a the case presented here has diabetes, which, due
standard acrylic phantom. DLP is the product of to the associated decrease in tissue perfusion, may
CTDIvol and the scan length and is reported in units increase skin radiosensitivity. For a discussion of
of mGy-cm. While these values can be used to other factors that can increase radiosensitivity,
estimate patient effective dose, neither corre- please see the article by Balter et al.9
sponds well with skin dose, making the assess- DLP is commonly used to calculate effective
ment of risk for radiation-induced skin injuries dose.10 However, effective dose is not correlated
difficult. Studies have shown that skin dose can with PSD. While CTDIvol is a better indicator of
range from approximately 49 to 65% of the PSD, it suffers from some of the same limitations
scanner-reported CTDIvol for scans performed as cumulative AK reported on a fluoroscopy
without table movement (as is often the scenario system, i.e., neither cumulative AK nor CTDIvol give
during CT-guided interventional procedures).7 For any indication of how the radiation exposure was
a CT scanner, the X-ray tube cannot be moved distributed across the patient’s skin. Although one
closer or farther from the patient, meaning the can generally assume that the radiation from a

12
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.6 Case 6: CT Fluoroscopy

CT-guided interventional procedure is evenly hand, staff radiation exposure usually comes from
distributed around the circumference of the scatter created within the patient. Consequently,
patient, when evaluating PSD, one should consider when possible, staff should stand to the side of the
whether all imaging was performed over a single CT gantry, where the gantry provides a shielding
“slice” along the z-axis of the patient, or if the barrier between the patient and the staff member.
patient was moved superiorly or inferiorly during Alternatively, the operator can leave the room and
the procedure. perform a single-slice CT scan. This can result in a
Another consideration when performing slightly higher radiation dose to the patient, but
CT-guided procedures is staff radiation exposure. the cumulative occupational dose savings to an
Similar to traditional fluoroscopy, staff will only be operator may be significant while the small
exposed to the primary radiation beam if their increase in radiation exposure may not pose any
body enters the imaging field of view. On the other additional risk to the patient.

13
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.7 Case 7: Digital Subtraction 1.7.3 Discussion


Angiography and Motion DSA is an imaging technique used to visualize
blood vessels while minimizing the appearance
Artifacts of bone and soft tissues. It is performed by
1.7.1 Background acquiring a “mask” image of the anatomy of
interest before the administration of a contrast
● A patient undergoes a preoperative embolization medium (typically iodine-based), followed by a
of renal cell carcinoma metastasis in the left hand. series of postcontrast images. The mask image is
● Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) is used to subtracted from each image in the postcontrast
demonstrate reduced blood flow to the tumor series, reducing the visibility of overlapping
tissues. When properly utilized, the resulting
following embolization.
images provide a map of the vasculature of
interest and have several uses in identifying
1.7.2 Findings stenosis, embolism, and aneurysm.
● During the DSA run, the patient repositions her Proper application of this technique requires
that the anatomy being imaged is stationary in
hand, leading to significant artifacts.
the imaging field of view. ▶ Fig. 1.6a shows the
● DSA was repeated to obtain adequate image patient’s hand at the beginning of the DSA run
quality. before contrast has been administered. The hand

Fig. 1.6 Individual frames from the


beginning (a), middle (b), and end
(c) of a DSA run where patient motion
caused significant artifacts are
shown. (d) The ability to visualize
the vasculature of the hand was
compromised leading to a repeated
acquisition.

14
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.7 Case 7: Digital Subtraction Angiography and Motion Artifacts

is well aligned with the previously acquired mask 1.7.4 Resolution


image. Consequently, the subtraction image
masks the appearance of soft tissue and bone. The example in ▶ Fig. 1.6 highlights the effects of
▶ Fig. 1.6b shows an image near the beginning of motion in an exam of the hand. Extremities may
contrast administration. The radial artery is be more prone to these artifacts since there is
easily visualized as a result of contrast injection. higher possibility of movement. However, any
However, as contrast is administered, the changes in patient position between acquisition of
patient’s hand begins to move. This is most the mask image and the subsequent images will
readily observed at the fingers where the result in these effects. This can be caused by the
misalignment between the current acquisition operator moving the patient, table, or X-ray tube,
and the mask image is greatest. Finally, ▶ Fig. 1.6c or by involuntary patient motion (cardiac and res-
shows an image that occurs near the end of the piratory). It should be noted that, in this case, the
DSA run where the hand is now substantially DSA run was repeated with reduced patient
mispositioned relative to the mask image. At this motion and image quality was greatly improved
point in the run, the vasculature of the hand (▶ Fig. 1.6d).
should be clearly visible but artifacts obscure the While extremities are not typically exposed to
anatomy of interest. large amounts of radiation during fluoroscopy
The initial position of the hand during the exams, procedures that are complex or require
acquisition of the mask image can be readily iden- imaging through larger portions of the body
tified in ▶ Fig. 1.6c by the lighter, almost white require higher doses and have the potential to
fingers and outer portion of the hand. Since the result in radiation injuries. These risks are more
position of the hand has changed, the mask image likely during DSA acquisitions compared to
is being subtracted from an area that no longer conventional fluoroscopy since the dose rate
contains the anatomy. Consequently, this portion during DSA is substantially higher (even 20 times
of the image is even brighter than the background. higher). Good practice is to limit the use of DSA
As a corollary, a darker image of the thumb and to portions of the exam where it provides a clear
fingers is apparent, indicating the final position of clinical benefit over fluoroscopy and avoid
the hand. repeating DSA acquisitions when possible.

15
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.8 Case 8: Fluoroscopy Modes higher than that used for an individual fluoroscopy
frame producing a higher-quality image but with
and Dose an associated increase in dose. While the dose per
image is substantially higher in digital spot mode,
1.8.1 Background the total exposure to the patient may be less than
● A patient with unstable angina received a cardiac an individual fluoroscopy run which may contain
catheterization procedure under fluoroscopic dozens of images.
Finally, cine mode creates an “X-ray movie”
guidance.
similar to fluoroscopy but the image quality of
● Standard fluoroscopy, digital spot images, and each individual frame is roughly equivalent to that
cine mode fluoroscopy were used. of a digital spot image. This improved image
quality for the entire cine run comes at the
1.8.2 Findings expense of greatly increased dose rates. It should
be noted that the dose rate in cine mode is not
The reference AKR during cine angiography was limited by regulation. This case illustrates the
28.5 times higher than during standard fluoroscopy. difference in dose between standard fluoroscopy
and cine mode fluoroscopy.
▶ Fig. 1.7 shows two single-frame images of the
1.8.3 Discussion same anatomic location. Collimation, X-ray tube
Modern fluoroscopic systems have multiple oper- and detector positions, and frame rate remained
ating modes, including standard fluoroscopy, high- the same for both images. ▶ Fig. 1.7a was acquired
dose-rate (HDR) fluoroscopy, digital spot imaging, as part of a fluoroscopy run, while ▶ Fig. 1.7b was
and cine (sometimes referred to as cinefluorog- part of cine run. The cine image (▶ Fig. 1.7b)
raphy). The selection of an imaging mode during a clearly provides better image contrast as well
procedure requires consideration of the image as improved detail of high spatial frequency struc-
quality needs of the individual case as well as the tures (edges). During the fluoroscopy run, the
relative radiation exposure rate for each mode. reference AKR was 20 mGy/minute. In contrast,
For all fluoroscopy systems, the maximum dose the reference AKR during the cine run was 570
rate that can be physically produced by the system mGy/minute (more than 28 times the AKR during
is limited by regulation for standard fluoroscopy standard fluoroscopy).
and HDR modes.11 The location along the X-ray
beam at which this is measured varies for different
types of fluoroscopy systems. (For under-table
1.8.4 Resolution
systems, the maximum dose rate is measured at It is important for fluoroscopy operators to care-
1 cm above the patient table, while for C-arm type fully consider whether the imaging task requires
systems used in interventional radiology and the quality provided by cine and HDR fluoroscopy
cardiac catheterization labs, the maximum dose modes. Commonly, positioning of the imaging field
rate is measured at 30 cm from the image of view relative to the patient can be performed
receptor.) When used in standard fluoroscopy using standard fluoroscopy with higher-dose-rate
mode, the maximum allowable dose rate is 88 modes reserved for the anatomy of interest during
mGy/minute.11 In HDR mode the limit doubles to select portions of the procedures. Positioning can
176 mGy/minute. While standard fluoroscopy also be aided by use of virtual collimators and
produces adequate image quality for many positioning tools.
patients, HDR may be required to maintain image Similarly, digital spot imaging yields a higher
quality in larger, more attenuating patients. dose per image than fluoroscopy. All modern fluo-
In digital spot mode, the fluoroscopy system roscopy devices are equipped with a “last image
functions as a general radiography device hold” function that presents the final image from
producing a single image. The technique (kV, mAs) any fluoroscopy run to the operator, providing a
used to produce a digital spot image is generally lower quality (and lower dose) static image. Digital

16
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.8 Case 8: Fluoroscopy Modes and Dose

Fig. 1.7 (a) A single frame from a fluoroscopy run performed during a cardiac catheterization procedure. (b) A cine
image from the same procedure using the same positioning and collimation. While image quality is improved on the
cine image, it comes at the expense of a substantial increase in dose rate. This image is similar to what would be seen
from a digital spot.

spot images may then be reserved for situations AKR in standard fluoroscopy mode was well
where the improved image quality is necessary. As below the regulated maximum of 88 mGy/minute
is the case with other dose reduction practices, (176 mGy/minute when operated in high-dose-
imaging modes that result in lower patient dose rate fluoroscopy mode), the dose rate in cine
also reduce staff dose. mode was considerably higher. Interestingly, the
It should be noted that while the Food and reference point at which the maximum AK
Drug Administration (FDA) places limits on the is regulated by the FDA is often different from the
maximum AKR that a system can produce while location of where the displayed reference AK
operating in fluoroscopy mode,11 no such limit is calculated. Consequently, the maximum dis-
exists when the system is used in other modes played AKR may be higher than the regulated
(cine, DSA, or single-shot acquisitions). While the maximum AKR.

17
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.9 Case 9: Equalization Filters ● The left portion of the image contains “open
space,” where there is no anatomy to attenuate
1.9.1 Background the X-ray beam.
● A patient with a history of primary sclerosing ● Contrast is poor inferior to the lungs.
cholangitis, coagulopathy, and chronic
portal vein thrombosis undergoes an 1.9.3 Discussion
intrahepatic portosystemic shunt creation Section 1.4, Case 3: Collimation, discussed the use of
procedure. collimators to limit the X-ray field to the anatomy of
● Much of the procedure requires imaging over clinical interest. These collimators are made of lead
an area that includes the lungs, liver, and bony and are thick enough to fully attenuate the X-ray
beam. In addition to collimators, many fluoroscopy
structures of the vertebral bodies.
systems have equalization filters. These filters are
sometimes known as wedges or contour filters. As
1.9.2 Findings the name implies, wedge filters have varying thick-
ness and are typically made of lead-impregnated
● The lung appears hyperintense, obscuring acrylic sheets. They are less absorptive than collima-
any anatomical contrast in the lungs tors and provide more attenuation through the
(▶ Fig. 1.8). “heel” portion of the wedge than through the “toe.”
The filters can be moved in and out of the imaging
field view over structures that are less attenuating.
To understand the effect that equalization
filters have on image quality, one must consider
how digital images are displayed. The ultimate
purpose of these physical filters is to equalize the
signal intensity across the image. Since a finite
number of grayscale levels are available to
display a digital image, having a wide range of
signal intensities across the field of view results
in having fewer grayscale values available to
display less-attenuating anatomy, thus degrading
image contrast in these areas. Proper use of
wedge filters can help to maintain image contrast
for exams where the attenuation properties of
objects in the imaging field of view vary
substantially.
The case presented here highlights the effect of
not using equalization filters. The lungs
are less attenuating relative to other anatomic
structures in the image, that is, the diaphragm
and vertebral bodies. Without equalization
filters, the lungs appear extremely bright and
washed out.
Fig. 1.8 The lung in this image appears extremely
bright. The image also contains space to the patient’s 1.9.4 Resolution
left which also appears hyperintense. The image
contrast in other regions of the image is poor. Proper use of wedge filters can improve image
quality, especially in cardiac and thoracic imaging,

18
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.9 Case 9: Equalization Filters

where an image often contains portions of the


heart, lungs, and bone, all of which have vastly
different X-ray attenuation properties. ▶ Fig. 1.9
provides an example of the benefits of using wedge
filters to equalize the signal intensity across the
image. The wedge filters are placed over portions of
the right and left lungs, improving image quality
across the entire image. An added benefit of using
equalization filters is a reduction in radiation dose
to areas covered by the filters.
Another way to achieve equalization of attenua-
tion properties across the image is to place a bolus
material next to the patient. In the case shown in
▶ Fig. 1.8, a bolus placed next to the patient’s chest
would decrease the brightness on the left side of the Fig. 1.9 An image showing wedge filters positioned
image. However, bolus materials increase scatter, over the left and right portions of the image.
By partially covering the radiotransparent lungs,
degrading image quality and increasing patient and
image quality is improved across the entire field
operator dose. For this reason, wedge filters are of view.
typically preferred to achieve image equalization.12

19
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.10 Case 10: Cone Beam has been demonstrated to be superior to DSA for
visualization of liver tumors.13 CBCT images can
Computed Tomography also be compared with images obtained prior to
the procedure using either MDCT or magnetic
1.10.1 Background resonance imaging.
● A patient has a history of massive hemoptysis Similar to standard multidetector CT (MDCT),
and blood visualized in the right bronchus CBCT utilizes projections taken at multiple angles
around the anatomy of interest to reconstruct
during bronchoscopy.
axial, sagittal, and coronal slices. As with other
● An embolization procedure is performed, tomographic techniques, anatomic visualization is
including a right bronchial artery angiogram. improved by removing overlapping tissue. Since
● Cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) imaging the principles of CBCT are similar to those for
is used to provide axial and coronal images of the MDCT, CBCT is susceptible to similar image arti-
facts. However, the clinical implementation of
liver and localize the tumor for therapy.
CBCT may result in unique manifestations of these
artifacts.
1.10.2 Findings ▶ Fig. 1.10 shows axial (▶ Fig. 1.10a) and coronal
(▶ Fig. 1.10b) images using CBCT during a liver
Streaking and motion artifacts are clearly visible embolization procedure. In the axial image,
on both the axial (▶ Fig. 1.10a) and coronal streaking artifacts result from interactions
(▶ Fig. 1.10b) images reconstructed from the CBCT between the primary X-ray beam and the metal
acquisition. catheter placed as part of the procedure. Incident
X-rays are highly absorbed by the catheter,
resulting in fewer X-ray photons reaching the
1.10.3 Discussion detector. The star pattern is due to this effect
CBCT is used in the interventional environment to occurring in multiple X-ray projections. In addi-
produce cross-sectional and 3D reconstructions. tion, in the coronal image, a possible beam
This intraprocedural imaging technique is used to hardening artifact is shown inferior to a region of
visualize anatomy and guide intervention. In some hyperintensity.
procedures, such as transarterial chemoemboliza- The images in ▶ Fig. 1.10 also suffer from blurri-
tion (TACE) for treatment of liver cancer, CBCT ness, especially visible in the lungs which is caused

Fig. 1.10 Axial (a) and coronal (b) images using cone beam computed tomography are shown. Both have noticeable
streaking and motion artifacts.

20
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.10 Case 10: Cone Beam Computed Tomography

by breathing motion. While motion artifacts also level of sedation during CBCT, so the amount of
occur during MDCT, the acquisition times of CBCT sedation should be considered in evaluating breath
tend to be longer, leaving more time for motion to hold options and limitations.
occur. (On modern systems, CBCT acquisition times Compared with MDCT, CBCT suffers from low
are generally around 6–10 seconds. Rotation times contrast-to-noise ratio. However, this limitation
in MDCT are often below 1 second.) is not generally clinically significant because the
use of iodinated contrast greatly increases the
visibility of the relevant anatomy. CBCT tends to
1.10.4 Resolution have better inherent spatial resolution, since the
Adequate patient breath holds, starting a couple of pixel pitch of the flat panel detectors on inter-
seconds prior to initiation of imaging, are essential ventional angiography systems is smaller than
during CBCT. ▶ Fig. 1.11 shows axial and coronal the detectors used in MDCT. (A modern flat panel
images obtained using a patient breath hold. detector has a pixel pitch of approximately
Compared with the images shown in ▶ Fig. 1.10, 0.15 mm; a MDCT detector is often around
motion artifacts are markedly reduced. As with 0.6 mm.) Finally, studies have found that CBCT
MDCT, the ability to achieve an adequate breath results in lower patient skin dose compared with
hold may be limited by the patient and procedure DSA.13 CBCT also often results in shorter overall
being performed. An additional consideration is imaging times, further reducing radiation dose to
that patients are more likely to be under some both patients and staff.

Fig. 1.11 Axial (a) and coronal (b) images using cone beam computed tomography with breath hold are shown.
These images have fewer motion artifacts than those shown in ▶ Fig. 1.10.

21
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.11 Review Questions 4. If the patient table is raised from a height


of 50 cm above the X-ray source to 60 cm
1.11.1 Case 1: SID, ABC, and above the X-ray source, and all other imaging
Radiation Output parameters remain the same, how much will
1. During a fluoroscopy-guided interventional the displayed AK change?
procedure, the operator increases the SID from a) The displayed AK will be 1.4 times the
90 to 120 cm without changing SSD. What effect AK displayed at 50 cm.
will this change have on entrance skin dose? b) The displayed AK will be 1.2 times the AK
a) Entrance skin dose will increase by greater displayed at 50 cm.
than 50%. c) The displayed AK will remain the same.
b) Entrance skin dose will increase by less than d) The displayed AK will be 0.8 times the
50%. AK displayed at 50 cm.
c) Entrance skin dose will be unaffected. e) The displayed AK will be 0.7 times the AK
d) Entrance skin dose will be reduced by less displayed at 50 cm.
than 50%.
e) Entrance skin dose will be reduced by
1.11.3 Case 3: Collimation
greater than 50%.
5. For a procedure performed using a single field
2. When moving from imaging a patient’s torso (i.e., without any tube rotation), collimating the
to imaging the abdomen, the ABC algorithm imaging field of view from 600 to 400 cm2 will
used by the fluoroscopy system will likely have what effect on PSD?
compensate by doing which of the following? a) PSD will decrease approximately by 33%.
a) Lowering kV b) PSD will not change.
b) Increasing mA c) PSD will increase approximately by 33%.
c) Adding filtration
6. For a procedure performed using a single field,
d) Decreasing magnification
collimating the imaging field of view from 600
to 400 cm2 will have what effect on scatter dose
1.11.2 Case 2: Reference Air to the operator?
Kerma and Skin Dose a) Operator dose will decrease by 33%
3. During a pain management procedure using b) Operator dose will not change.
a C-arm with a fixed SID, the operator raises c) Operator dose will increase by 33%.
the patient table such that the SSD changes
from 50 to 75 cm. What effect will this change
1.11.4 Case 4: Anti-scatter Grids
have on entrance skin dose?
a) Entrance skin dose will increase by greater 7. For what clinical exam would it be appropriate
than 50%. to remove the anti-scatter grid?
b) Entrance skin dose will increase by less than a) Sacroiliac joint injection
50%. b) Endoscopic retrograde
c) Entrance skin dose will be unaffected. cholangiopancreatogram
d) Entrance skin dose will be reduced by less c) Inferior vena cava filter placement
than 50%. d) Upper extremity arteriovenous fistulagram
e) Entrance skin dose will be reduced by
greater than 50%.

22
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

1.11 Review Questions

8. What is the primary consequence of removing c) 3000 mGy


the anti-scatter grid for an adult abdomen d) 6000 mGy
protocol?
a) Decreased image quality 1.11.7 Case 7: Digital Subtraction
b) Increased patient skin dose Angiography and Motion Artifacts
c) Decreased visualization of iodine contrast
13. In DSA, why are blood vessels readily visible
d) Increased DAP
while the appearance of other tissues is
minimized?
1.11.5 Case 5: Patient Shielding a) The kV of the mask and second acquisitions
9. What is one of the most effective ways to are adjusted to specifically remove certain
decrease radiation exposure to a fluoroscopy tissues types following subtraction.
operator? b) The addition of contrast agents to the blood
a) Wear appropriate lead garments vessels between the mask and the second
(e.g., apron, glasses). acquisition highlights the vessels.
b) Position a lead drape on the patient. c) The attenuation properties of blood vessels
c) Increase the SID. are significantly different than those of other
soft tissue, making them more visible.
10. When performing a cardiac fluoroscopy-guided
procedure on a pregnant patient, what is the 14. During DSA, an X-ray attenuating object is
primary source of radiation exposure to the removed from the imaging field of view after
fetus? the mask image is acquired but before the
a) Primary X-ray beam second acquisition. What effect will it have on
b) Internal scatter the images resulting from subtraction?
c) Backscatter a) The object will leave a dark shadow relative
to background.
1.11.6 Case 6: CT Fluoroscopy b) The object will have no effect on the
subtraction image since it is removed before
11. What is the primary reason the DLP for a
the second acquisition.
CT-guided fluoroscopy-guided procedure is
c) The object will leave a light shadow relative
typically higher than for a diagnostic CT scan?
to background.
a) The total CTDIvol is typically higher for
a CT fluoroscopy-guided procedure.
b) The scan length is typically higher for
1.11.8 Case 8: Fluoroscopy Modes
a CT fluoroscopy-guided procedure. and Dose
c) A higher kV is typically used for a CT 15. The patient dose from a digital spot image is
fluoroscopy-guided procedure. roughly equivalent to which of the following
d) A higher effective mAs is typically used for images?
a CT fluoroscopy-guided procedure. a) The dose from a single fluoroscopy frame
b) The dose from an HDR fluoroscopy frame
12. Radiation-induced skin injuries may occur at c) The dose from a single cine frame
PSDs as low as 2000 mGy. For an average-sized 16. For what imaging mode is the maximum AKR
adult patient, what CTDIvol would be associated limited to 176 mGy/minute?
with a PSD of 2000 mGy? a) Standard fluoroscopy
a) 1300 mGy b) HDR fluoroscopy
b) 2000 mGy c) Cine mode fluoroscopy

23
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Fluoroscopy

1.11.9 Case 9: Equalization Filters References


17. During a cardiac imaging procedure, the lungs [1] AAPM Report 125. Functionality and operation of fluoro-
scopic automatic brightness control/automatic dose rate
appear so bright on the images that the cardiac control logic in modern cardiovascular and interventional
structures are poorly visualized. What is the angiography systems (2012)
[2] Marsh RM. What considerations should be made when
most appropriate method for improving image
performing fluoroscopy-guided interventions on pregnant
quality? patients? AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017; 209(3):W195–W196
[3] International Commission on Radiation Protection. Biological
a) Positioning a bolus material under the
effects after prenatal irradiation (embryo and fetus). ICRP
patient Publication 90. Ann ICRP. 2003; 33:1–206
b) Using equalization filters over the lungs [4] Dauer LT, Thornton RH, Miller DL, et al. Society of Interven-
tional Radiology Safety and Health Committee, Cardiovascu-
c) Decreasing the amount of copper filtration lar and Interventional Radiology Society of Europe Standards
d) Increasing the collimated field of view of Practice Committee. Radiation management for interven-
tions using fluoroscopic or computed tomographic guidance
during pregnancy: a joint guideline of the Society of Inter-
18. What is the primary benefit of using equaliza- ventional Radiology and the Cardiovascular and Interven-
tional Radiological Society of Europe with Endorsement by
tion filters?
the Canadian Interventional Radiology Association. J Vasc
a) Improved image contrast Interv Radiol. 2012; 23(1):19–32
b) Increased patient dose [5] Smith JR, Marsh RM, Silosky MS. Is lead shielding of patients
necessary during fluoroscopic procedures? A study based on
c) Improved spatial resolution kyphoplasty. Skeletal Radiol. 2018; 47(1):37–43
d) Increased temporal resolution [6] Petranovic M, Gilman MD, Muniappan A, et al. Diagnostic
yield of CT-guided percutaneous transthoracic needle biopsy
for diagnosis of anterior mediastinal masses. AJR Am J Roent-
1.11.10 Case 10: Cone Beam genol. 2015; 205(4):774–779
[7] Leng S, Christner JA, Carlson SK, et al. Radiation dose levels
Computed Tomography for interventional CT procedures. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2011;
197(1):W97–103
19. What is the primary advantage of using CBCT [8] Kanal KM, Butler PF, Sengupta D, Bhargavan-Chatfield M,
instead of DSA to view liver tumors during Coombs LP, Morin RL. U.S. diagnostic reference levels and
achievable doses for 10 adult CT examinations. Radiology.
interventional procedures? 2017; 284(1):120–133
a) Decreased patient skin dose [9] Balter S, Hopewell JW, Miller DL, Wagner LK, Zelefsky MJ.
Fluoroscopically guided interventional procedures: a review
b) Decreased motion artifacts of radiation effects on patients’ skin and hair. Radiology.
c) Improved spatial resolution 2010; 254(2):326–341
[10] AAPM Report 96. The measurement, reporting, and manage-
d) Improved visualization of lesions ment of radiation dose in CT (2008)
[11] Performance standards for ionizing radiation emitting prod-
20. What is the primary limitation of CBCT ucts, 21 C.F.R. §1020.32 (2018)
[12] Schueler BA. The AAPM/RSNA physics tutorial for residents:
compared with MDCT? general overview of fluoroscopic imaging. Radiographics.
a) Poor spatial resolution 2000; 20(4):1115–1126
[13] Tacher V, Radaelli A, Lin M, Geschwind JF. How I do it: cone-
b) Increased patient dose beam CT during transarterial chemoembolization for liver
c) Limited imaging field of view cancer. Radiology. 2015; 274(2):320–334

d) Introduction of streaking artifacts

24
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2 Mammography
Ingrid S. Reiser

Introduction X-ray absorption, and resolution of the detector


are optimized for the detection of low-contrast
Mammography uses X-ray projection imaging to tumors and microcalcifications in the breast. X-ray
acquire images of the breast. Mammography has energies impact radiographic contrast and patient
been the gold standard for breast cancer scree- dose, and are optimized to produce images with
ning since the 1990s. In addition to breast cancer the best tumor signal-to-noise ratio at the lowest
screening, mammography is used for diagnostic dose. Over- or underexposure of the mammogram
breast imaging. Conventional mammography due to incorrect X-ray technique is less common in
produces 2D projection images of the breast. The digital detectors than film because of their wide
complex anatomical background of structures can dynamic range. However, there are a number of
hinder tumor detectability. With the advent of detector artifacts in digital mammography that
digital full-field detectors for mammography, can potentially mimic or obscure suspicious find-
digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) became ings that must be recognized. In DBT, a quasi-3D
feasible. DBT produces quasi-3D images of the image volume is synthesized from a series of low-
breast that provide some depth resolution to dose projection images acquired with the X-ray
overcome limitations of geometric superposi- tube moving across an arc of 15 to 50 degrees
tioning in conventional 2D projection images. (depending on vendor implementation). The
DBT has helped reduce callback rates from scree- limited angle acquisition provides some depth
ning mammography and potentially helps resolution, but also causes artifacts in the tomo-
increase cancer detection rates. synthesis image volume.
Mammography utilizes ionizing radiation to As in radiography, the most common problem
detect breast cancers. Since ionizing radiation also affecting image quality is patient positioning and
induces cancer (albeit at a much lower rate), it is patient motion. Further, image quality can be
important to limit and monitor the average dose affected by artifacts that mimic or obscure relevant
to glandular breast tissues during mammography. anatomy. Speck-like artifacts can potentially
mimic microcalcifications. There are multiple
causes for these artifacts as described below. Arti-
Common Image Quality facts caused by the image receptor include row
dropout and electromagnetic interference (EMI).
Problems Mammography utilizes a grid in contact mode.
Mammography is a unique imaging modality in Artifacts due to grid positioning, such as grid
the sense that it is dedicated to and optimized for cutoff, do not occur because the grid and X-ray
a single anatomy. The energy of the X-ray beam, source are in a fixed geometry.

25
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

2.1 Case 1: Magnification gained from the magnification setup that


includes use of a smaller focal spot compared to
Imaging contact mode to minimize focal spot blurring.1

2.1.1 Background
2.1.3 Discussion
Magnification views are acquired when visualiza-
tion of fine detail is required. Magnification views In magnification mode, the breast is positioned
are often used in the diagnosis of microcalcifica- on a magnification stand and is thus located
tions. ▶ Fig. 2.1 demonstrates this effect. A micro- closer to the X-ray source (▶ Fig. 2.1d). As a
calcification cluster is imaged in magnification result, structures within the breast are magnified
mode (▶ Fig. 2.1a), which is shown enlarged in by a factor M, depending on the distance between
▶ Fig. 2.1b. ▶ Fig. 2.1c shows the microcalcification the X-ray focal spot and the breast on the magni-
cluster imaged in contact mode. The resolution in fication stand (dmag), and the distance between
▶ Fig. 2.1c is markedly lower and as a result less the X-ray focal spot and the detector (ddet). The
detail is perceived. magnification factor M is given by the ratio of
these distances as M = ddet/dmag.

2.1.2 Findings
The images shown in ▶ Fig. 2.1a, b were acquired
2.1.4 Resolution
with the breast placed on the magnification The height of the magnification stand deter-
stand at a height of 31 cm, resulting in a magnifi- mines the magnification factor. Most mammog-
cation factor of 1.8 for a source-to-detector raphy systems allow for several heights of the
distance of 70 cm. An increase in resolution is magnification stand.

Fig. 2.1 Magnification views improve visualization of fine detail. Microcalcification cluster magnification imaging
(a, b) and in contact imaging (c). The magnification factor in this example was 1.8. Geometry of magnification imaging:
object magnification (d).

26
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.2 Case 2: Focal Spot Size Selection in Magnification Views

2.2 Case 2: Focal Spot Size focal spot. When the phantom is placed on the
breast support (▶ Fig. 2.2a), the images acquired
Selection in Magnification with a large or small focal spot exhibit similar
Views sharpness. When the test phantom is placed on the
magnification stand, the image acquired with the
2.2.1 Background large focal spot is less sharp due to focal spot blur.
● Magnification views can help visualize small
structures, such as microcalcification clusters, 2.2.3 Discussion
with greater detail. In contact imaging, when the The focal spot of an X-ray tube is not a single
breast is placed directly on the breast support, the point, but a small area from where X-rays are
system uses a large focal spot (typically 0.3 mm). emitted. In mammography, the size of the focal
spots are 0.3 mm (large) and 0.1 mm (small). The
● When the breast is positioned on the magnifi-
finite size of the focal spot results in blurring of
cation stand and magnification mode is used, the image.1 This is demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 2.2a, b
the system switches to a small focal spot and depends on the distance between the focal
(typically 0.1 mm). spot, the breast, and the detector. When the
object (i.e., breast) is located in close contact with
the detector and the focal spot is far away, focal
2.2.2 Findings spot blur is negligible for both the large and the
▶ Fig. 2.2a, b shows a comparison of a test phantom small focal spot. Therefore, the images shown in
imaged with a large (0.3 mm) and a small (0.1 mm) ▶ Fig. 2.2a are equally sharp. In magnification

Fig. 2.2 (a) Phantom images acquired in contact mode with different focal spot sizes (FS). (b) Phantom images
acquired in magnification mode with different focal spot sizes (FS). (c) Focal spot blur in contact mode and
magnification mode.

27
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

mode, the breast is half-way between X-ray focal blur. Focal spot blur can be computed from the
spot and the detector. In this configuration, the imaging distances as:
size of the projected focal spot is equal to the  
ddet  dmag
actual focal spot size and blurs the image accord- wblur ¼ w 
dmag
ingly. This is shown in ▶ Fig. 2.2b.
The differences in blur become visible when where w is the size of the focal spot, and wblur is
focal spot blur is the dominant factor that limits the width of focal spot blur.
image resolution. In contact imaging, shown in
▶ Fig. 2.2a, image sharpness is limited by
detector resolution, and therefore no difference 2.2.4 Resolution
in image sharpness is observed when the focal
spot sizes are changed. The small focal spot needs to be selected when
▶ Fig. 2.2c shows how the distance of the object performing imaging in magnification mode to
from the X-ray focal spot, dmag, affects focal spot optimize resolution of the system.

28
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.3 Case 3: X-ray Acquisition Technique Factors in Mammography

2.3 Case 3: X-ray Acquisition ● The system selected higher mAs, kV, and a
different filter to image the 82-mm breast,
Technique Factors in
resulting in a greater HVL and AGD.
Mammography ● The ACR digital mammography accreditation
2.3.1 Background phantom was imaged at equal average glandular
dose but different kV and target/filtration
In mammography, technique factors, such as mAs,
kVp, filtration, are chosen depending on settings, and image quality was compared
compressed breast thickness and composition (▶ Fig. 2.3c, d).
(fatty/heterogeneous/dense). Higher kV is chosen
for larger breast thicknesses. 2.3.3 Discussion
As the X-ray tube potential (i.e., kV) increases,
2.3.2 Findings subject contrast is reduced. This is demonstrated
in ▶ Fig. 2.3c, where the contrast of all masses is
● Mammograms of two different patients are
greater for the 28 kV W/Rh image, compared to
shown in ▶ Fig. 2.3a, b. The compressed breast
37 kV W/Ag. As the X-ray tube potential (i.e., kV)
thicknesses are 35 and 82 mm. The patients were increases, contrast-to-noise ratio reduces, as
imaged on the same mammography system shown in ▶ Fig. 2.3d. The display window width
using automated exposure control. is set to achieve equal displayed contrast of the
● X-ray technique factors (mAs, kV, filter) for the largest mass, compared to the background. The
37-kV image is noisier, and it is more difficult to
acquisition of these two images are shown in
see the smaller masses and fibers. Technique
the figure, along with half-value layer (HVL) factors are set so as to optimize the contrast-
and average glandular dose (AGD). to-noise ratio per average glandular dose. For

Fig. 2.3 (a, b) Mammographic


technique for different breast sizes.
(c, d) Signal insert of the full-field
digital mammography accreditation
phantom imaged at equal average
glandular dose (AGD), but different
filtration and kV settings. In (c), the
display window width is equal for both
images. In (d), the display window is
different for both kV settings and was
chosen to produce equal contrast of
the largest mass in both images.

29
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

the phantom images, the optimum X-ray tech- Structure in a Mammogram), and it can also
nique is 28 kV compared to 37 kV, because it potentially cause X-ray tube heat overloading. In
gives better image quality in terms of higher addition, increasing mAs increases dose. Average
contrast and contrast-to-noise ratio. When glandular dose is linearly proportional to mAs, i.
imaging a thicker breast, generally a higher kV is e., doubling mAs produces twice the AGD.
used to achieve a more penetrating beam. This is
manifested in the increased HVL of the X-ray
beam. Improved image quality could also be 2.3.4 Resolution
achieved by increasing mAs to maintain subject kV should be increased with breast thickness and
contrast, but prolonged exposure times can lead breast density to produce a more penetrating
to artifacts from patient motion (see Case 9, Pa- X-ray beam that optimizes subject contrast.
tient Motion Causing Blurred Parenchymal

30
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.4 Case 4

2.4 Case 4: Digital Breast seen as it fans out as the distance to the focus
slice increases. The angle of the fan is that of the
Tomosynthesis: Artifacts due
tomosynthesis scan.
to High-Contrast Objects
2.4.1 Background 2.4.3 Discussion
Tomosynthesis imaging is a quasi-3D imaging In tomosynthesis, depth resolution is achieved by
modality of the breast. The X-ray source travels blurring structures below and above the in-focus
along an arc of 15 to 50 degrees, depending plane, and enhancing structures that are truely
on vendor implementation, and a series of low- located at that depth. High-contrast structures
dose projections are acquired. The tomosyn- often persist throughout all tomosynthesis images
thesis images are reconstructed from these and present themselves as repeat “copies” of the
projections. object, as is the case for the microcalcification
shown in ▶ Fig. 2.4a. Sometimes, a calcified vessel
2.4.2 Findings appears as ripples in slices above or below the slice
of focus. Other high-contrast objects that can
● ▶ Fig. 2.4a shows a large calcification as it produce such artifacts include biopsy markers.
appears in the focus plane, i.e., in the tomosyn-
thesis image at the actual depth of the object.
The insets show slices displaying the calcifica-
2.4.4 Resolution
tion at different depths. The calcification is The limited angle scan geometry of tomosynthesis
causes artifacts from high-contrast objects, such as
clearly seen at other depths, but it becomes more
large calcifications. Depending on the image
distorted as the tomosynthesis image is further
reconstruction and image processing used by the
away from the in-focus depth. equipment manufacturer, conspicuity of these
● ▶ Fig. 2.4b shows a perpendicular slice through artifacts can vary. It is important to understand
the breast volume. The calcification is clearly the origin of these artifacts.

Fig. 2.4 (a) Artifact due to a high-contrast calcification in tomosynthesis volume. Regions centered on the calcification
are shown at different depths. Repeated ghosts of the calcification can be observed at depths far from its in-focus plane.
(b) Perpendicular slice through the tomosynthesis volume at the level of the high-contrast calcification. The X-ray tube
moves along the X-direction during the tomosynthesis scan.

31
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

2.5 Case 5: Effect of Image in the image falls off toward the skin line because
breast thickness decreases.
Post-Processing on the ● ▶ Fig. 2.5b shows a mammogram of the same
Appearance of a Mammogram patient but acquired on full-field digital
2.5.1 Background mammography (FFDM). The breast is visual-
ized up to the skin line, which was achieved
● Digital mammography uses image processing
through a uniformity correction. As a result,
to enhance contrast.2,3
structures close to the skin line are still clearly
● Processed mammograms are overall more
visible.
uniform in comparison to a screen-film
● ▶ Fig. 2.5c shows a mammogram acquired
mammogram, which virtually eliminate the
on a FFDM unit of a different vendor. As in
need to adjust display window width and
▶ Fig. 2.5b, the breast is visualized up to the
level.
skin line. However, the image is processed
● Mammograms obtained from different vendor
to show greater contrast compared to that
systems can have a significantly different “look”
shown in ▶ Fig. 2.5b. ▶ Fig. 2.5d shows a
due to proprietary choices in image processing
synthetic 2D image generated from tomosyn-
and presentation.
thesis volume images for the same patient as
in ▶ Fig. 2.5c. The synthetic mammogram is
2.5.2 Findings similar but not equal to a conventional 2D
● ▶ Fig. 2.5a–d shows images from a patient mammogram. In the example shown, the calci-
acquired on different vendor systems. ▶ Fig. 2.5a fication exhibits dark overshoots above and
shows a screen-film mammogram. The intensity below it, which is an artifact of tomosynthesis

Fig. 2.5 (a–d) Image processing affects the appearance of mammograms. A patient was imaged with different systems:
screen-film mammography (a), full-field digital mammography (FFDM) vendor A (b), FFDM vendor B (c), 2D
mammogram synthesized from tomosynthesis (d). Note the difference in the calcification (arrows) shown in the inset in
(c) and (d). (Continued)

32
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.5 Case 5: Effect of Image Post-Processing on the Appearance of a Mammogram

Fig. 2.5 (Continued) (e) Fourier-domain


filters can enhance large or small detail
in an image.

Fig. 2.5 (Continued) (f–h) Original mammogram (f) processed with different unsharp masking parameters (g, h). The
image uniformity is improved, which allows display of the image at a higher display contrast in (h), while maintaining
visibility of the skin line.

33
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

that is not seen in the conventional 2D enhances edges. The effect of these filters is
mammogram (▶ Fig. 2.5c). demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 2.5e.
In unsharp masking, a low-pass filtered copy
of the original image is subtracted from the image,
2.5.3 Discussion producing a sharper and more uniform image
In digital mammography as in digital radiog- ▶ Fig. 2.5f-h. Digital mammograms are processed
raphy, the image consists of an array of numeric to achieve greater uniformity, eliminating the
values. Image processing is achieved through intensity drop-off near the skin line that
mathematical operations on these numbers (i.e., is observed in screen-film mammograms. In addi-
pixel values). Two basic image processing opera- tion, images might be processed to produce a
tions, by use of the Fourier transform and by greater displayed contrast.2
histogram processing, are demonstrated below.
The Fourier transform is a basic element of image
processing that takes advantage of the spatial fre-
2.5.4 Resolution
quency. Low spatial frequencies represent large Image processing algorithms are proprietary and
structures and image contrast, while high spatial can differ between mammography equipment
frequencies represent image detail such as fine vendors. Differences in image appearance between
structures and edges, and image noise. A low- vendors are more likely caused by different image
pass filter selects large structures in an image, post-processing algorithms than differences in
while a high-pass filter selects image detail and acquisition technique or dose.

34
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.6 Case 6: Artifact due to Detector Row Dropout

2.6 Case 6: Artifact due to dropout forms a band corresponding to the line
dropout visualized in the tomosynthesis
Detector Row Dropout
images at different depths.
2.6.1 Background
Detector artifacts can be caused by individual pixel 2.6.3 Discussion
dropout or by an entire detector row dropout.4,5
This case describes the appearance of detector row The appearance of the dropout artifact differs
dropout in conventional 2D mammography and 3D in the conventional 2D mammogram and the
tomosynthesis and associated synthetic 2D view. simulated 2D image. This underlines the fact that
the synthetic 2D image is created from the 3D
tomosynthesis volume. Depending on vendor
2.6.2 Findings implementation, the synthetic 2D image may not
● In this example, dropout is observed for two be intended to mimic a 2D mammogram, but
instead enhances potentially suspicious features
detector rows. ▶ Fig. 2.6a shows the appearance
that are seen in the tomosynthesis image, such as
of the artifact in the conventional mammogram. edges. In this case, edge post-processing likely
As expected, two lines are seen. enhanced the line artifacts and caused the banding
● ▶ Fig. 2.6b shows the appearance of the artifact in the synthetic 2D image.
in 3D tomosynthesis. In this particular case,
row dropout occurred at two locations in one
2.6.4 Resolution
single projection view. In the tomosynthesis
images, two lines can be observed and the loca- The dropout signal observed in these images
represents a failure in the readout hardware of the
tion of the lines changes in different depths. In
digital detector and could not be remediated by
the simulated 2D image, which incorporates recalibrating the detector. In this case, the detector
information from the 3D volume, the row panel needed to be replaced.

Fig. 2.6 (a) Line artifacts due to detector row dropouts in a conventional mammogram. In this case, two lines are seen.
(b) Line artifacts due to detector row dropout in tomosynthesis. In this example, row dropout occurred in a single
projection view. In the tomosynthesis images, two lines are seen. The lines sweep across the tomosynthesis images
while scrolling through different depths. In the corresponding synthetic 2D image, the lines appear as bands.

35
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

2.7 Case 7: Microcalcification-like 2.7.3 Discussion


Appearance Caused by a Detector Small speck-like artifacts can be observed in
mammograms. Their cause can be multiple (also see
Artifact Case 8, Artifact due to Imperfection in Compression
2.7.1 Background Paddle). An artifact in the detector manifests itself in
the same location in different images. This artifact
● An unexpected microcalcification-like object can be distinguished from dust or scratches by
was observed during ACR phantom image wiping all surfaces and rotating the test phantom.
quality review. An artifact in the detector will always remain at the
● Prior patient images were reviewed. An same location. Multiple quality control tests might
reveal this artifact, including a weekly artifact test
artifact was found at the identical pixel
during which an image of a uniform phantom is
locations. inspected, as well as the phantom image quality test.

2.7.2 Findings 2.7.4 Resolution


● The defect is seen in prior patient images at the Detector artifacts can be resolved by updating
the dead pixel map, which is used to mask out
same pixel location.
bad pixels. If there are too many bad pixels
● In the clinical example shown below, the artifact or the region of bad pixels is too large, the manu-
appears dark, while it appears white in the facturer might choose to replace the detector
phantom image. (▶ Fig. 2.7).

Fig. 2.7 Dead pixel artifact in the detector in (a) patient image and (b) ACR mammography accreditation phantom
image. Artifacts in the detector occur at the same location in the patient image, and they might appear as dark or
bright, or mixed (see insets).

36
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

2.8 Case 8: Artifact due to Imperfection in Compression Paddle

2.8 Case 8: Artifact due to ● A small speck (< 1 mm in diameter) can be seen
with use of the new compression paddle.
Imperfection in Compression
Paddle 2.8.3 Discussion
2.8.1 Background The artifact is only seen in the patient images for
which this particular compression paddle was
● The radiologists noticed a small speck-like
used. The artifact does not appear in the same
artifact within the mammogram, with location because its projection shifts across the
microcalcification-like appearance, that detector as the compression paddle height is
was seen in most images from a particular adjusted according to breast thickness
unit. (▶ Fig. 2.8b).
● A compression paddle had a crack and was
replaced with a new paddle a few days prior.
2.8.4 Resolution
An imperfection on the compression paddle mani-
2.8.2 Findings
fests as a high-contrast microcalcification-like
● A small artifact is seen (▶ Fig. 2.8a). It is visible appearance in patient images. If cleaning the
in most but not all patient images, and at paddle does not remedy the artifact, the compres-
different locations. sion paddle should be replaced.

Fig. 2.8 (a) Location of the artifact in two mammograms with different compressed breast thicknesses. The red line
indicates the location of the same detector row in both images. (b) The projected location of the artifact changes with
compression paddle height.

37
| 09.11.19 - 01:52

Mammography

2.9 Case 9: Patient Motion ● Original image: compressed breast thickness


was 72 cm, with 14 lb compression force. Repeat
Causing Blurred Parenchymal
image: compressed breast thickness was 60 cm,
Structure in a Mammogram with 23 lb compression force.
2.9.1 Background
● This left-medial lateral oblique (LMLO) 2.9.3 Discussion
mammogram is part of a screening exam Mammography requires high spatial resolution
of an asymptomatic patient. in order to depict clusters of microcalcifications.
● Breast cancer screening exams are rated using Individual microcalcifications of clinical
relevance have diameters ranging from 100 to
the BI-RADS scale. This exam resulted in a
500 μm. In mammography, X-ray images are
BI-RADS score of 0 (recall) for technical reasons.
acquired with the breast under compression
● The patient returned to the clinic and a technical with typical compression forces between 25 and
repeat of this view was performed. 45 lb. The technologist has to balance patient
comfort and image quality. Too much compres-
2.9.2 Findings sion force leads to patient discomfort. Too little
compression force reduces breast immobiliza-
● The parenchymal structure of the breast appears tion and can result in patient motion, as seen in
blurred due to patient motion. this case.
● Microcalcification clusters, which represent an
important early indicator of breast cancer, might
be missed due to insufficient spatial resolution
2.9.4 Resolution
of this image. A repeat mammogram was obtained (▶ Fig. 2.9b).
● Exposure times in mammography are relatively The technologist applied a higher compression
force, resulting in better breast immobilization
long. This image was acquired with a 1.5-second
and the absence of motion artifacts.
X-ray exposure.

Fig. 2.9 (a) Left-medial lateral oblique mammogram with signs of patient motion. The image appears unsharp.
Fine detail of the parenchymal structure is blurred due to motion. (b) Repeated image with increased compression.
Fine linear details in the parenchymal structure are visible in this image.

38
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

2.10 Case 10: EMI Artifact due to LVAD Device

2.10 Case 10: EMI Artifact due 2.10.3 Discussion


to LVAD Device This EMI artifact occurs when electromagnetic
fields emitted by the LVAD motor interfere with
2.10.1 Background the detector readout electronics.
A patient received a routine mammogram. Due other
health reasons, the patient has a left-ventricular 2.10.4 Resolution
assist device (LVAD).
The radiologist needs to be aware that the pres-
ence of the LVAD devices in patients can cause
such artifacts. Unless the mammography equip-
2.10.2 Findings ment manufacturer has implemented solutions
The mammogram (▶ Fig. 2.10) exhibits high- into their imaging system to prevent such inter-
frequency striping near the chest wall edge. ference through shielding or image processing
Visually, this artifact has similarity with grid designed to remove these structures, these
artifacts that can be observed in radiography. artifacts need to be tolerated.

Fig. 2.10 (a) Mammogram with the left-ventricular assist device (LVAD) device partially visible. When zoomed into
a region near the chest wall (b), horizontal lines can be seen that are caused by the electromagnetic interference
between the LVAD motor and the detector readout electronics.

39
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Mammography

2.11 Review Questions 2.11.3 Case 3: X-ray Acquisition


2.11.1 Case 1: Magnification Technique Factors in
Imaging Mammography
5. What is the most likely range of X-ray tube
1. A small microcalcification (diameter = 100 μm)
potentials used in mammography?
is imaged in contact mode. What is the approx-
a) 15–25 kV
imate diameter of the microcalcification in the
b) 25–35 kV
image? Assume dmag = 67.5 cm and ddet = 70 cm.
c) 35–45 kV
a) 100 µm
d) 45–50 kV
b) 200 µm
c) 400 µm
6. Subject contrast in a mammogram is most
d) 500 µm
affected by which of these parameters?
2. A small microcalcification (diameter = 100 μm) is a) Milliampere-time product (mAs)
imaged in magnification mode. The detector b) X-ray tube kilovoltage (kV)
pixel size is 90 μm. What magnification is c) Exposure time
required so that diameter of the microcalcifica- d) Focal spot size
tion in the image is twice the pixel size of the
detector?
2.11.4 Case 4: Digital Breast
a) 1
Tomosynthesis: Artifacts due
b) 1.8
c) 2
to High-Contrast Objects
d) 2.3 7. The resolution in digital breast tomosynthesis
images is isotropic, similar to computed
2.11.2 Case 2: Focal Spot Size tomography images.
a) True
Selection in Magnification Views
b) False
3. In magnification imaging, a small focal spot is
used to eliminate which of the following? 8. The origin of the artifacts from high-contrast
a) Scattered radiation objects in digital breast tomosynthesis is most
b) Patient motion similar to:
c) Focal spot blur a) Detector pixel dropout artifact in conven-
d) Geometric distortion tional mammography and radiography
b) Artifacts from metal implants in
4. How wide is the blur from a 0.3-mm focal spot
radiography
when the magnification factor is 2?
c) Streaking artifacts from metal implants in
a) 0.15 mm
computed tomography
b) 0.3 mm
c) 0.6 mm
d) 0.8 mm

40
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

2.11 Review Questions

2.11.5 Case 5: Effect of Image 14. If a small speck-like artifact is observed in the
artifact image during weekly quality control
Post-Processing on the
testing, which actions should be taken?
Appearance of a Mammogram
a) Clean all surfaces
9. The effect of a high-pass filter is to: b) Rotate phantom
a) Increase image resolution c) Gain calibration
b) Emphasize large detail in the image d) Dead pixel mapping
c) Reduce noise e) Replace detector
d) Emphasize small detail in the image

2.11.7 Case 7: Microcalcification-


10. Unsharp masking is a post-processing algo-
rithm that can improve:
like Appearance Caused by a
a) Spatial resolution
Detector Artifact
b) Displayed contrast resolution 15. Which of the following is correct concerning
c) Image noise artifacts from dead pixels in the detector?
d) Geometric distortion a) Dead pixels always appear as black spots.
b) Dead pixels artifacts are always located at
2.11.6 Case 6: Artifact due to identical image coordinates.
Detector Row Dropout c) The detector is free of dead pixels if a
uniform test image does not show any arti-
11. What is a likely cause for a partial detector row
facts.
dropout?
d) An artifact in a uniform test image always
a) Dead pixels are lined up perfectly along
requires the detector to be replaced.
a detector row.
b) The image receptor consists of multiple tiled 16. Which remedial actions should be considered
flat-panel detector elements. when a detector artifact has been identified?
c) The detector electronic readout process is a) Detector replacement
being interrupted. b) Gain calibration
d) The detector panel has been physically c) Dead pixel mapping
damaged. d) All of the above

12. In tomosynthesis, a detector row dropout


artifact looks the same in the synthetic 2D
2.11.8 Case 8: Artifact due to
mammogram as it would in a conventional
Imperfection in Compression
FFDM mammogram. Paddle
a) True 17. What is the most likely cause of a high-contrast
b) False small speck-like image artifact at a fixed loca-
tion, which persists while imaging patients?
13. Prior to replacing the detector, which steps can a) Bad pixels in detector
be taken to resolve a small speck-like image arti- b) Dust during gain calibration
fact? c) Imperfection in the compression paddle
a) None d) Dust on breast support
b) Clean all surfaces
c) Gain calibration 18. Compression force is applied
d) Dead pixel mapping a) To reduce breast thickness
e) All of the above except choice a b) To reduce the potential for patient motion

41
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Mammography

c) To reduce average glandular dose c) Connection to external battery pack


d) All of the above d) Abandoned cardiac leads

2.11.9 Case 9: Patient Motion Equations


Causing Blurred Parenchymal Object magnification factor M, for an object posi-
Structure in a Mammogram tioned at a distance of dmag from the focal spot, and
19. What is the maximum allowable compression a distance ddet between the focal spot and the
force in mammography? detector:

a) 25 pounds
M ¼ d det =d mag
b) 35 pounds
c) 45 pounds Diameter of the image of an object (xmag), imaged
d) 55 pounds with magnification factor M, when the actual size
of the object is x:
20. Which of the factors below is generally not a
x mag ¼ M  x
cause for patient motion?
a) Breast compression force too low Width of focal spot blur (wblur) for a focal spot of
b) Long exposure time size w:
c) Magnification imaging
d) Use of an X-ray grid w blur ¼ w  ðddet  dmag Þ=dmag
¼ w  M  1Þ

2.11.10 Case 10: EMI Artifact due


to LVAD Device References
21. Which of the following statements is correct? [1] Villafana T. Generators, X-ray tubes, and exposure geometry
in mammography. Radiographics. 1990; 10(3):539–554
a) EMI artifacts can occur in computed
[2] Pisano ED, Cole EB, Hemminger BM, et al. Image processing
radiography. algorithms for digital mammography: a pictorial essay.
Radiographics. 2000; 20(5):1479–1491
b) EMI artifacts only occur in digital
[3] Seeram E, Seeram D. Image postprocessing in digital radiolo-
mammography detectors because of the gy—a primer for technologists. J Med Imaging Radiat Sci.
high resolution. 2008; 39(1):23–41
[4] Yaffe MJ, Rowlands JA. X-ray detectors for digital radiography.
c) The appearance of an EMI artifact is similar Phys Med Biol. 1997; 42(1):1–39
to a grid artifact. [5] Ayyala RS, Chorlton M, Behrman RH, Kornguth PJ, Slanetz PJ.
Digital mammographic artifacts on full-field systems: what
d) An EMI artifact is a permanent detector are they and how do I fix them? Radiographics. 2008; 28(7):
artifact. 1999–2008

22. EMI artifacts occur due to the


a) Presence of metal in the LVAD
b) Spinning motor in the LVAD

42
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3 Computed Tomography
Karen L. Brown and Jason R. Gold

Introduction defined to be zero in value. As such, tissues that


are more attenuating than water will have posi-
In computed tomography (CT) imaging, the tive values in a CT image, and tissues that are less
X-ray tube and detector array rotate around the attenuating than water will have negative values.
patient in a fixed geometry generating thou- Each type of tissue in a CT image has a specific
sands of attenuation measurements through the Hounsfield unit range which may be used quan-
patient volume of interest. The attenuation titatively to characterize tissues or pathology.
measurements are reconstructed into axial Image quality in CT is affected by many parame-
images which can then be reformatted into ters, some of which are selected by the operator
sagittal and coronal planes. The grayscale value prior to the acquisition, while others are selected
displayed in each pixel represents the CT number prior to reconstruction of the data into tomo-
in Hounsfield units of the corresponding voxel graphic planes. The same acquisition data can,
volume. CT number is a normalized measure- therefore, be reconstructed in multiple ways to
ment of the linear attenuation coefficient meas- achieve different image quality end points
ured in the voxel relative to that of water, dependent upon the clinical goals of the study.

43
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

3.1 Case 1: Ring Artifact other detectors, or fails completely, artifacts will
appear in the reconstructed images. In helical
3.1.1 Background acquisitions, the artifact will appear as a partial
ring (▶ Fig. 3.1a) and appear to rotate around
● Patient with a history of nephrolithiasis isocenter throughout the imaging volume. Full
presented for CT of abdomen and pelvis ring artifacts will be present in axial scan
examination. acquisitions (▶ Fig. 3.1c). The artifact will be
● A helical acquisition was acquired using a limited to the images corresponding to the
affected detector channel. For example, if a 16-
detector configuration of 24 × 1.2 mm channels.
channel system has a defective detector in
● Axial images of 3.0 mm thickness were
channel 1, a full ring artifact will appear in the
reconstructed using a soft-tissue filter. first reconstructed image and then again in
image 17 but will not appear in images 2 to 16,
assuming the width of the reconstructed slice is
3.1.2 Findings equal to the width of the detector channel.
A partial ring artifact is centrally located in all axial
reconstructions.
3.1.4 Resolution
Axial acquisitions of a uniform water phantom,
3.1.3 Discussion reconstructed at the thinnest possible slice thick-
The X-ray tube and detector array rotate around ness, should be acquired and evaluated for ring
the CT gantry in a fixed geometry. The detector artifacts by the CT technologist on a daily basis.2
array consists of multiple detector channels in When ring artifacts are identified, some CT
the z-direction, each containing many hundreds systems will provide the user a method to recali-
of individual detector elements in the x/y direc- brate the detectors (often called an air calibration
tion (▶ Fig. 3.1b).1 Each detector within the array scan). If the air calibration scan is not available, or
measures the residual X-ray signal through the does not resolve the ring artifact, service
patient. If an individual detector within the array personnel should be contacted and corrective
is not properly calibrated with respect to the maintenance be performed.

Fig. 3.1 (a) Partial ring artifact on helically acquired abdomen–pelvis computed tomography examination.
(b) Multichannel CT detector array. (c) Full ring artifact on axially acquired phantom image.

44
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.2 Case 2: Effect of Patient Size on CT Number Accuracy

3.2 Case 2: Effect of Patient typically sized patient, this beam hardening effect
is corrected for by the scanner. In bariatric
Size on CT Number Accuracy patients, the beam hardening effect is more
significant and can affect the accuracy of
3.2.1 Background displayed CT numbers. When the patient’s tissues
● Bariatric patient with a history of renal calculi fall outside of the scan field of view (FOV), the
presents with abdominal pain. system overestimates the attenuation provided
by the tissues within the FOV. This is often
● A helical abdomen/pelvis CT is performed.
referred to as a truncation artifact and appears as
● Incidental finding in the adrenal gland with bright areas in the image (▶ Fig. 3.2a). Truncation
elevated CT number measurement. artifact can also affect the accuracy of CT numbers
used for quantitative analysis.3
3.2.2 Findings
Use of CT number for quantitative analysis can be 3.2.4 Resolution
compromised in bariatric patients due to beam
hardening and truncation artifact. Some systems may offer an extended FOV recon-
struction option as shown in ▶ Fig. 3.2b. In this
case, the visual appearance of the truncation arti-
3.2.3 Discussion fact was reduced by reconstructing using an
The X-ray tube used in CT produces a polyener- extended FOV; however, little effect on measured
getic X-ray beam. Filters are placed at the exit CT number in the adrenal gland was realized.
port of the beam to remove low-energy X-rays Patient positioning can also have a significant
increasing the average energy of the X-ray beam. impact on beam hardening and truncation arti-
A process called beam hardening. As the X-ray facts in bariatric patients. The patient in this case,
beam enters the patient, beam hardening presented for another scan 2 weeks later
continues as the lower-energy X-rays in the beam (▶ Fig. 3.2). Note the difference in the patient’s
are attenuated with higher probability. The apparent shape and diameter. This was due to
displayed CT number is a relative measure of more effective wrapping of extraneous tissues by
attenuation as compared to the attenuation of the technologist prior to scanning and is not
water. As the beam becomes more energetic related to patient weight loss. No truncation arti-
(hardened), less attenuation occurs in a given fact is present and the change in measured Houns-
tissue which changes the CT number. In a field units is significant.

Fig. 3.2 (a) Abdomen-pelvis computed tomography showing truncation artifact (arrows) and artificial elevation of
measured CT numbers. Acquisition parameters: 120 kV, 557 mAs. (b) Extended field-of-view reconstruction of image
shown in (a). (c) Follow-up abdomen-pelvis CT of patient. Acquisition parameters: 120 kV, 414 mAs. All other technique
and reconstruction parameters were consistent with image shown in (a).

45
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

3.3 Case 3: Effect of kV contrast of the seminal vesicle structure shown in


▶ Fig. 3.3a which was acquired at 100 kV as
Selection on Image Quality and compared to the same structure in ▶ Fig. 3.3b
Dose acquired at 120 kV.
Tube voltage (kV) also affects the efficiency of
3.3.1 Background X-ray production in the X-ray tube. At a lower kV
setting, the number of X-rays produced is reduced
● Patient with a history of cecal and appendiceal
by the ratio of the change in kV squared to cubed
adenocarcinoma with multiple prior CT exami- (ΔkV2–3). Quantum noise increases when fewer
nations presents for chest/abdomen/pelvis CT X-rays are used to make the image, which
with contrast post resection with peroneal will have a negative effect on the visibility of
nodules for evaluation of treatment. low-contrast structures. To compensate, a decrease
in kV is often accompanied by an increase in tube
● A helical acquisition is acquired at reduced kV
current (mA). As shown in ▶ Fig. 3.3a, b, an appro-
compared to prior studies. priate increase in mA to achieve an acceptable level
of quantum noise levels can be achieved at a signifi-
3.3.2 Findings cant dose reduction.
Contrast is improved at the lower kV setting at
a dose savings of approximately 17%. 3.3.4 Resolution
Tube voltage and current settings should be
3.3.3 Discussion adjusted to optimize image quality and dose. The
Lowering tube voltage (kV) produces an X-ray usefulness of this technique will depend on
beam with lower average and maximum energy. patient size and the anatomy/pathology of
Lower X-ray energies will be attenuated in a given interest. A lower kV setting can often be used on
tissue more than higher-energy X-rays. This is smaller patients. In very large patients, the mA
primarily governed by differences in attenuation limitations of the X-ray tube may result in
that occurs due to photoelectric absorption which increased photon starvation artifacts. Beam hard-
is approximately proportional to the atomic ening artifacts will also be enhanced at low
number (Z) cubed of the tissue, and inversely kV settings. Lower-energy beams are also effec-
proportional to the energy (E) cubed of the X-ray tive when using iodinated contrast agents as the
beam. As such, the relative attenuation between average beam energy more closely aligns with
two tissues increases at lower kV settings. On a the k-edge absorption peak of iodine. Care should
CT image, this results in a greater difference in be taken when using CT numbers for quantitative
Hounsfield units between the two tissues, and analysis as the CT number is affected by the
therefore, greater contrast. Note the increased kV setting.

Fig. 3.3 (a) Image acquired at 100 kV and 200 mAs with a displayed volume CT dose index (CTDIVOL) of 8.37 mGy.
(b) Image acquired at 120 kV and 140 mAs with a displayed CTDIVOL of 10.06 mGy.

46
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.4 Case 4: Image Quality Variation with Reconstructed Slice Thickness

3.4 Case 4: Image Quality represents the average attenuation measurement


of all the tissues within the voxel. This principle is
Variation with Reconstructed called partial volume averaging and is inherent to
Slice Thickness the CT image reconstruction process. As the tissue
voxel becomes larger and there is more signal
3.4.1 Background averaging, there is less spatial differentiation of
the signal in a given direction and the image
● Patient presents to the emergency department
appears more blurred, with lower spatial resolu-
following a motor vehicle collision. tion. ▶ Fig. 3.4a is reconstructed with a 1.5 mm
● CT thorax, CT abdomen, and pelvis examinations slice thickness and ▶ Fig. 3.4b is reconstructed
following the administration of contrast were with a 3.0 mm slice thickness. The thinner recon-
acquired. structions are sharper (better spatial resolution)
and have less partial volume averaging. Note the
● Axial images of 3.0 and 1.5 mm slice thickness
subtle clavicle fracture seen on the 1.5-mm recon-
were reconstructed. structions which is not visible on the 3.0-mm
reconstructions. Quantum noise is also affected by
3.4.2 Findings the size of the reconstructed voxel. The amount of
signal (number of X-rays) interacting within a
Small fracture of the clavicle is not visible with given voxel is directly proportional to voxel size.
3.0 mm reconstructed slices. Quantum noise changes inversely with the square
root of the change in signal.

3.4.3 Discussion
Reconstructed slice thickness affects the level of
3.4.4 Resolution
quantum noise, spatial resolution, and partial Voxel size is a function of the pixel size and the
volume averaging present in CT images. Slice reconstructed slice thickness selected by the oper-
thickness affects the size of the reconstructed ator. When reconstructed slice thickness is
tissue voxel. Each voxel of tissue is displayed as increased, more partial volume averaging occurs in
one shade of gray in the corresponding image the slice thickness direction. When a thinner
pixel. When the voxel contains more than one type reconstructed slice thickness is selected, there is
of tissue or pathology, the CT number displayed better differentiation of tissues along the slice

Fig. 3.4 (a) Computed tomography (CT) image reconstructed with 1.5 mm slice thickness. (b) CT image reconstructed
with 3.0 mm slice thickness.

47
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

thickness direction resulting in better spatial reso- The only other parameter that affects the size
lution and less partial volume averaging. CT proto- of the reconstructed voxel in CT is the FOV
cols often include multiple reconstructions of the selected by the operator prior to reconstruction.
same acquisition at different reconstructed slice FOV is often selected to encompass the anatomy
thicknesses to provide the clinician with high of interest and determines the size of the tissue
spatial resolution image series as well as low noise voxel and corresponding image pixel in the x and
image series for evaluation. y dimension.

48
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.5 Case 5: Image Quality Variation with Reconstruction Filter

3.5 Case 5: Image Quality signal intensity. The tube current (mA) used during
the acquisition of the exam affects the total number
Variation with Reconstruction of X-rays produced. If the mA is reduced by one
Filter half, signal intensity is reduced by one half. They
are directly proportional. The level of quantum
3.5.1 Background noise in the image will increase as 1/√ (change in
signal) or 1/√1/2 (approximately 40%). In this case,
● Patient with a history of bacterial meningitis and
the images reconstructed using filtered back
multiple brain abscesses presents for follow-up projection (▶ Fig. 3.5a) are very noisy. The radiol-
CT to evaluate the response to treatment with ogist is concerned that important findings may be
IV antibiotics. missed as increased levels of quantum noise
diminish visibility of low-contrast structures. The
● Helical CT of the head is acquired with contrast
advantage of reduced mA techniques is lower
and reconstructed using filtered back projection. patient dose. Patient dose is directly proportional to
● A reduced mA technique is implemented in an the mA setting selected by the technologist.
effort to reduce patient radiation dose.

3.5.4 Resolution
3.5.2 Findings There are several acquisition and reconstruction
The reconstructed images have elevated quantum parameters that affect the level of quantum noise
noise due to the use of a reduced mA technique. in an image. One of the reconstruction parameters
selectable by the operator is the reconstruction
filter or kernel. The reconstruction filter will affect
3.5.3 Discussion how much smoothing out of the noise occurs in
The level of quantum noise in a CT image is related the image. A soft tissue or standard filter will have
to 1/√N, where N is equal to the number of X-ray lower image noise compared to a sharp filter, such
photons used to generate the image, also called the as a bone or lung filter, at the expense of lower

Fig. 3.5 (a) Filtered back projection


reconstruction using a smooth filter
with a window width/window level
setting of 100/40. (b) Filtered back
projection reconstruction using
a sharp filter with a window width/
window level setting of 100/40.
(c) Filtered back projection recon-
struction using a sharp filter with a
window width/window level setting of
2500/500. (d) Iterative reconstruction
using a smooth filter with a window
width/window level setting of 100/40.

49
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

spatial resolution. The image in ▶ Fig. 3.5a was Iterative reconstruction techniques are available on
reconstructed using a soft-tissue (smooth) recon- all modern CT scanners and produce images with
struction filter. At the same window/level setting, lower noise than filtered back projection techni-
the same data reconstructed with a sharp filter ques.4 ▶ Fig. 3.5d shows the same image recon-
(▶ Fig. 3.5b) has much higher noise but spatial structed using an iterative technique. Note the
resolution has improved. Sharp reconstructions significant reduction in quantum noise compared
are often viewed on a different window/level to ▶ Fig. 3.5a. Spatial resolution in the iterative
setting to emphasize the spatial information in the reconstruction is also maintained which is another
structures of interest (▶ Fig. 3.5c). advantage of this technique. Iterative reconstruc-
The type of reconstruction algorithm selected by tion is often used with reduced mA or kV techni-
the operator will also have an effect on image noise. ques to overcome increases in quantum noise.

50
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.6 Case 6: Displayed Volume CT Dose Index and Patient Size

3.6 Case 6: Displayed Volume CT mGy-cm. DLP provides an estimate of the total
energy imparted to the scan volume.5 Any error in
Dose Index and Patient Size estimating patient dose using CTDIVOL is propa-
gated in the calculation of DLP.
3.6.1 Background The use of dose values displayed on the
● A 6-year-old patient with medulloblastoma CT scanner to estimate patient dose can be particu-
presents for CT of the thorax with contrast for larly problematic for chest, abdomen, and pelvic
examinations of pediatric patients. The displayed
evaluation of possible pulmonary embolus.
dose for body scans is typically estimated using the
● Patient has received multiple CT examinations large 32-cm phantom (although some older systems
over the past year. may use the 16-cm phantom) which may underesti-
mate dose in pediatric patients by a factor of 2 or 3.
3.6.2 Findings For this reason, care must be taken when using
displayed dose metrics for benchmarking and
Volume CT dose index (CTDIVOL) and dose length protocol optimization.
product (DLP) displayed on the dose summary
page underestimate dose to the patient.
3.6.4 Resolution
3.6.3 Discussion When it is necessary to estimate patient dose
from a CT examination, the clinician should be
Patient dose is dependent on the radiation
output of the CT scanner and patient size. The aware of the limitations of displayed or reported
CTDIVOL (in units of mGy) displayed on the CT CT dose metrics on the scanner. The American As-
scanner is a measure of the radiation output as sociation of Physicists in Medicine has developed
estimated to one of two-sized polymethyl metha- a method to provide a better estimate of patient
crylate phantoms, a small 16-cm-diameter dose.6 The size-specific dose estimate (SSDE) is
phantom or a large 32-cm-diameter phantom.5 calculated by multiplying the displayed CTDIVOL
When patient size varies from the size of the by a correction factor that accounts for the diam-
phantom used, the CTDIVOL displayed on the CT eter of the patient as compared to the diameter of
scanner may over- or underestimate patient the phantom used to estimate CTDIVOL. SSDE is
dose. In the case presented, the dose summary not currently displayed on CT scanners or on the
report (▶ Fig. 3.6a) estimates 2.08 mGy as the dose summary page. Some third-party dose ma-
CTDIVOL to the large 32-cm phantom from the nagement software programs do provide SSDE
chest scan. The actual diameter of the patient, as calculations that can be compared to national
shown in ▶ Fig. 3.6b is significantly less than benchmarks such as the American College of
32 cm. In this case, the CTDIVOL underestimates Radiology Dose Index Registry. If these tools are
the dose to the patient which would be higher not readily available to the clinician, a medical
than the value displayed on the dose summary physicist should be consulted to provide a patient
page. When patient size is larger than the dose estimate. As a general rule of thumb, if the
phantom indicated on the dose summary page, large (32 cm) phantom is used by the scanner to
patient dose is overestimated and would be estimate CTDIVOL, the dose to a 16-cm-diameter
lower than the displayed CTDIVOL value. patient will be approximately two times the value
The DLP is calculated by multiplying the esti- displayed on the scanner. The estimated SSDE for
mated CTDIVOL by the scan length and has units of the patient presented in this case is 3.6 mGy.

Fig. 3.6 (a) Computed tomography dose summary page. (b) Axial CT scan used to estimate patient diameter.

51
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

3.7 Case 7: Beam Hardening X-ray beam through these dense objects. Note the
presence of beam hardening around the bone
Artifact structures in the noncontrast image (▶ Fig. 3.7b).
In the contrast image, beam hardening artifact is
3.7.1 Background more noticeable when the beam passes through
Patient with suspected subdural hematoma all three contrast-filled structures but is not
presents for head and neck CTA with and without apparent at other angular pathways where the
contrast. beam passes through a shorter axis of each indi-
vidual contrast-filled structure.

3.7.2 Findings
Beam hardening artifacts are observed in contrast-
3.7.4 Resolution
enhanced images. Beam hardening artifacts can be minimized with
the use of higher-energy X-ray beams. Increasing
the tube voltage (kV) produces a higher-energy
3.7.3 Discussion X-ray beam but this will also affect image contrast
Beam hardening occurs when the polyenergetic and patient dose. Dual energy CT acquisitions
X-ray beam passes through material.7 Higher acquire data at two separate beam energies. A low
density and higher atomic number materials such kV setting, such as 80 kV, and a high kV setting, such
as metal, bone, and contrast agents preferentially as 140 kV, are typical. The attenuation difference
attenuate lower-energy X-rays resulting in a between tissues will be different at the low kV
higher average energy X-ray beam exiting the setting compared to the high kV setting. This infor-
material. Because, the higher-energy beam has mation can be used to reconstruct virtual monoe-
greater penetrating ability, tissues that lie nergetic images at higher energy, eliminating the
between, or are adjacent to these structures effect of low-energy X-rays on beam hardening.8,9
appear to be less attenuating. In the reconstruc- Angulation of the gantry to avoid passage of the
tion, lower CT numbers than what actually repre- beam through the long axis of known, high-density
sent the tissue are calculated and displayed. This structures will help mitigate the artifact. This
results in shadowing or dark bands as shown in option is not available on all CT scanners. Iterative
▶ Fig. 3.7a. The magnitude of beam hardening reconstruction techniques can also be used to mini-
that occurs will depend on the path length of the mize the appearance of beam hardening artifacts.

Fig. 3.7 (a) Contrast scan showing


shading artifact from beam hardening
when the angular orientation of the
beam passes through multiple
contrast-filled structures. (b) Noncon-
trast scan shows less significant beam
hardening artifact when the beam
passes through the long axis of bone
structures.

52
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.8 Case 8: Partial Volume Artifact

3.8 Case 8: Partial Volume the arrow. The increased signal is due to the
averaging of skull and brain matter attenuation
Artifact within the voxel (▶ Fig. 3.8b) resulting in
elevated CT number and brighter shade of gray
3.8.1 Background presentation in the image. Follow-up CT
● ICU patient presents with history of right thalamic (▶ Fig. 3.8c) shows no hyperdensity due to
hemorrhage and right frontal contusion. contusion and that the elevated CT numbers are
likely due to partial volume averaging.
● Portable axial CT scan of the head without
contrast with a reconstructed slice thickness
of 5 mm is performed. 3.8.4 Resolution
The magnitude of partial volume artifact is
primarily affected by reconstructed slice thickness.
3.8.2 Findings
Slice thickness controls the z-dimension of a tissue
Hyperdensity in right frontal lobe due to partial voxel. It is common for most CT examinations to
volume averaging is not indicative of contusion be reconstructed using thick and thin reconstruc-
per history. tions. Partial volume averaging will be diminished
in thinner slice images compared to thick image
reconstructions. The x–y dimension of the voxel is
3.8.3 Discussion
equal to the size of the image pixel which is deter-
Each pixel in a CT image displays a single shade mined by the FOV divided by the size of the image
of gray representing the calculated CT number matrix. For most modern CT scanners, the matrix
for the associated voxel of tissue. When more size is fixed at 512 × 512 pixels. Adjusting the FOV
than one type of tissue is contained within a is, therefore, the single parameter adjustment that
given voxel, the average attenuation value of the can affect pixel size. The size of each pixel in CT is
tissues within the voxel is used to calculate the typically much smaller than the slice thickness, so
CT number and corresponding displayed gray- changing FOV has less effect on partial volume
scale value. Head CT scans are commonly recon- averaging than slice thickness. Reconstructing and
structed with a 5 mm slice thickness, resulting in viewing images in different reconstruction planes
relatively large voxels in the z-direction (through may also affect partial volume averaging as the
the scanner bore). ▶ Fig. 3.8a shows a hyperden- tissue types within a given voxel may vary along
sity in the right frontal lobe region indicated by the direction of reconstruction.

Fig. 3.8 (a) Axial computed tomography of the brain reconstructed with 5 mm slices shows hyperdensity in the right
frontal lobe. (b) Scout image showing location of adjacent axial slices (white lines) and voxel encompassing both skull
and brain matter. Note: for illustrative purposes only, voxel size and position are not accurately depicted. (c) Axial follow-
up CT shows no hyperdensity in the right frontal lobe indicating the effect on prior image was likely due to partial
volume averaging.

53
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

3.9 Case 9: Metal Artifact 3.9.4 Resolution


3.9.1 Background There are several techniques to minimize the
appearance of metal artifacts.11 Thin acquisition
● Patient with possible leg cellulitis and fluid collec- sections are recommended to reduce partial
tion in the anterolateral leg is referred for CT. volume averaging; however, larger reconstructed
● Helical CT scan of the lower leg with 1.0- and slice thickness averages the noise over larger
voxels and mitigates the appearance of streaking.
3.0-mm reconstructions is acquired.
▶ Fig. 3.9a was reconstructed with 3.0 mm slice
thickness and shows mild reduction in streak
3.9.2 Findings artifact compared to ▶ Fig. 3.9b which was
reconstructed with 1.0 mm slice thickness.
Metal artifact precludes visualization of possible Higher tube voltage (kV) increases the pene-
soft tissue fluid collection. trating ability of the X-ray beam through metal
structures and also increases the number of
X-ray photons in the beam helping to overcome
3.9.3 Discussion both beam hardening and photon starvation
The presence of metal within the CT scan FOV effects. Note significant reduction in metal
causes severe streaking artifact. There are streak artifact seen in ▶ Fig. 3.9c acquired at
several phenomenon contributing to the appear- 140 kV. Dual energy CT can be used to generate
ance of streaking including beam hardening and virtual monoenergetic images.89 Using this tech-
photon starvation effects. In addition, the meas- nique, low-energy X-rays in the beam that
ured linear attenuation values of metal struc- contribute significantly to beam hardening are
tures may be beyond the dynamic range of the removed, minimizing their contribution to
CT system. Visualization of anatomy and path- streak artifacts. Metal artifact reduction soft-
ology in the vicinity of metal material may be ware is available from equipment and third party
significantly compromised as a result. In this vendors. The use of iterative reconstruction
case, the radiologist was unable to make a defin- techniques reduces noise, minimizing artifact
itive diagnosis due to the severe streaking arti- intensity. These techniques can be used sepa-
fact (▶ Fig. 3.9a, b) in proximity to the structures rately or in combination to reduce the appear-
of interest. ance of metal streak artifacts.

Fig. 3.9 (a) Metal artifact reconstructed with 3.0 mm slice thickness showed mild improvement of streak artifact
compared to 1.0 mm reconstruction as shown in (b). (b) Image reconstructed with 1.0 mm slice thickness shows slightly
enhanced streaking from metal artifact compared to 3.0 mm reconstruction as shown in (a). (c) Image acquired at
140 kV shows significant reduction in metal streak artifact.

54
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.10 Case 10: Motion Artifact

3.10 Case 10: Motion Artifact


3.10.1 Background
● Patient presents with left-sided weakness.
● Noncontrast helical CT is performed with sagittal
and coronal reformats.

3.10.2 Findings
Evaluation of the study was compromised due
to motion artifact, requiring the technologist to
repeat the scan.

3.10.3 Discussion
The appearance of motion artifacts can be quite
varied depending on the source of motion (patient,
respiratory, cardiac, etc.) and severity. Respiratory Fig. 3.10 Image presentation of significant patient
motion may appear as a generalized loss of resolu- motion during computed tomography acquisition.
tion in the anterior chest cavity with little effect in
other areas of the image. As shown in ▶ Fig. 3.10,
significant patient motion can cause streaking, incorporate longer gantry rotation times (0.8–2.0
shading, ghosting, and incongruence of anatomical seconds) as compared to abdominal scans (0.25–0.5
features. In some cases, the degradation in image seconds) during which respiratory motion is more
quality caused by motion requires the scan to be likely to occur. For patients with a high probability
repeated resulting in increased radiation dose to of motion, either due to their condition or age, seda-
the patient. tion may be appropriate. Systems with larger beam
widths and dual source technology also provide
opportunities for faster scanning, minimizing the
3.10.4 Resolution potential for motion artifacts.
Patient motion can be mitigated with adequate Cardiac motion creates a significant challenge
exam preparations to include careful patient posi- when imaging heart structures and vasculature.
tioning and appropriate use of immobilization Artifacts related to cardiac motion can manifest in
devices, explanation of the examination process to a variety of forms including blurring, ghosting, and
the patient prior to the scan, and provision of clear misregistration.12 Prospective or retrospective
instructions throughout the scanning process. Opti- cardiac gating techniques are often employed to
mization of scan parameters is also essential, when essentially “freeze” heart motion during the
imaging anatomical features with higher probability selected portion of the cardiac cycle. The effective-
of involuntary motion, gantry rotation time and ness of these techniques is dependent on patient
helical pitch are adjusted accordingly to optimize heart rate and stability. Beta blockers may be
scan acquisition time. Shorter gantry rotation times administered to the patient to decrease patient
and higher helical pitch result in shorter scan heart rate and extend the period of diastole when
acquisition times. For example, head scans typically using cardiac gating techniques.

55
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

3.11 Review Questions b) Bone


c) Fat
3.11.1 Case 1: Ring Artifact d) Iodine
1. What reconstructed slice thickness will provide
the greatest visibility of detector malfunctions 6. What CT acquisition parameter has the largest
in a CT scanner? effect on quantum noise in the image?
a) 0.6 mm a) mA
b) 1.2 mm b) kV
c) 3.0 mm c) Rotation time
d) 5.0 mm d) Collimation

2. What is the purpose of the daily air calibration 3.11.4 Case 4: Image Quality
scan recommended by some CT scanner manu- Variation with Reconstructed Slice
facturers? Thickness
a) Assess the CT number accuracy of water and
7. By what factor does quantum noise in the
air
image change when slice thickness is decreased
b) Adjust the gain settings of individual
from 3.0 to 1.5 mm?
detector elements
a) 0.75
c) Measure noise standard deviation of the
b) 1.0
system
c) 1.4
d) Disable malfunctioning detector channels
d) 2.0

3.11.2 Case 2: Effect of Patient


8. What is the primary advantage of thicker
Size on CT Number Accuracy reconstructed slice thickness in CT?
3. What factor affects the measured CT number a) Improved spatial resolution
for a given tissue? b) Faster acquisition times
a) Beam energy c) Lower patient dose
b) Tube current modulation d) Increased low-contrast visibility
c) Gantry rotation speed
d) Window level/width 3.11.5 Case 5: Image Quality
Variation with Reconstruction
4. What affect does increasing the FOV have on
Filter
image spatial resolution?
a) Decreases 9. An increase in what parameter will reduce
b) Increases quantum noise in a CT image with no direct
c) Stays the same effect on patient dose?
a) Pitch
b) Slice thickness
3.11.3 Case 3: Effect of kV
c) Rotation time
Selection on Image Quality
d) kV
and Dose
5. For a given X-ray beam energy, what material 10. What is the primary advantage of iterative
has the highest probability of attenuating an reconstruction techniques as compared to
X-ray photon? filtered back projection?
a) Air a) Lower noise images

56
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

3.11 Review Questions

b) Faster reconstruction time 3.11.8 Case 8: Partial Volume


c) Reduced image storage requirements
Artifact
d) Minimal partial volume averaging
15. What effect will decreasing FOV have on
quantum noise when using fixed acquisition
3.11.6 Case 6: Displayed Volume
parameters?
CT Dose Index and Patient Size a) Increase
11. How is the displayed CTDIVOL related to the tube b) Decrease
current setting during a CT acquisition? c) No effect
a) Directly
b) Inversely 16. What effect will decreasing reconstructed slice
c) Exponentially thickness have on spatial resolution?
d) One over the square root a) Increase
b) Decrease
12. What is a typical CTDIVOL reported for a routine c) No effect
adult abdomen/pelvis CT examination of
average-sized patient?
3.11.9 Case 9: Metal Artifact
a) 1–5 mGy
b) 10–15 mGy 17. What is the dominant interaction of 80 kV
c) 25–30 mGy X-rays in metal?
d) 45–50 mGy a) Coherent scattering
b) Compton scattering
c) Pair production
3.11.7 Case 7: Beam Hardening
d) Photoelectric absorption
Artifact
13. What component of CT imaging system 18. What quantity is used to calculate CT number
corrects for variations in X-ray beam intensity (Hounsfield unit)?
due to different X-ray path lengths through a) Linear attenuation coefficient
the patient? b) Mass attenuation coefficient
a) Anode c) Tissue atomic number
b) Bow-tie filter d) Tissue density
c) Collimator
d) Grid
3.11.10 Case 10: Motion Artifact
14. An increase in what parameter will reduce the 19. What is the effect of using a shorter gantry
difference in grayscale values between adjacent rotation time, assuming all other protocol
tissues in a CT image. parameters remain unchanged?
a) mA a) Decreased spatial resolution
b) kV b) Longer scan acquisition time
c) Rotation time c) Increased quantum noise
d) Pitch d) Higher patient dose

57
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Computed Tomography

20. What is the effect of increasing helical pitch [3] Fursevich DM, LiMarzi GM, O’Dell MC, Hernandez MA, Sensa-
kovic WF. Bariatric CT imaging: challenges and solutions.
assuming all other protocol parameters remain Radiographics. 2016; 36(4):1076–1086
unchanged? [4] Padole A, Ali Khawaja RD, Kalra MK, Singh S. CT radiation
dose and iterative reconstruction techniques. AJR Am J
a) Improved visibility of low-contrast struc-
Roentgenol. 2015; 204(4):W384–92
tures [5] Report No AAPM. 96, The Measurement, Reporting, and
Management of CT Dose, The American Association of Physi-
b) Lower patient dose
cists in Medicine, 2008
c) Higher spatial resolution [6] Report No AAPM. 204, Size Specific Dose Estimates (SSDE) in
d) Decreased quantum noise Pediatric and Adult Body CT Examinations, The American
Association of Physicists in Medicine, 2011
[7] Barrett JF, Keat N. Artifacts in CT: recognition and avoidance.

Equations Radiographics. 2004; 24(6):1679–1691


[8] McCollough CH, Leng S, Yu L, Fletcher JG. Dual- and multi-en-
ergy CT: principles, technical approaches, and clinical appli-
FOV
Pixel size ¼ cations. Radiology. 2015; 276(3):637–653
Matrix Size [9] Grajo JR, Patino M, Prochowski A, Sahani D. Dual energy
CT in practice: basic principles and applications. Appl Radiol.
Voxel size ¼ pixel size  slice thickness 2016; 45(7):6–12
[10] Katsura M, Sato J, Akahane M, Kunimatsu A, Abe O. Current
 t  w and novel techniques for metal artifact reduction at CT:
CT # ðHUÞ ¼  1000
w practical guide for radiologists. Radiographics. 2018; 38(2):
450–461
μt is the average linear attenuation coefficient of [11] Lee MJ, Kim S, Lee SA, et al. Overcoming artifacts from
metallic orthopedic implants at high-field-strength MR
the tissues within a voxel. imaging and multi-detector CT. Radiographics. 2007; 27(3):
μw is the linear attenuation coefficient of water 791–803
[12] Kalisz K, Buethe J, Saboo SS, Abbara S, Halliburton S, Rajiah P.
Artifacts at cardiac CT: physics and solutions. Radiographics.
2016; 36(7):2064–2083
References
[1] Bushberg JT, Seibert JA, Leidholdt E, Boone J. The Essential
Physics of Medical Imaging. 3rd ed. Philadelphia: Wolters
Kluwer Health/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2012
[2] The American College of Radiology. Computed Tomography:
Quality Control Manual, 2017

58
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4 Magnetic Resonance Imaging


Puneet Sharma

Introduction which is subsequently stored. A multitude of addi-


tional signals are generated, encoded, and stored
From its inception in the 1970s, and through that are eventually combined and decoded
humble beginnings in the early 1980s, magnetic through a process called Fourier analysis to
resonance imaging (MRI) has experienced over- produce a final image. Though some MR acquisi-
whelming growth in utility and innovation across tions are on the order of 500 miliseconds for one
virtually all diagnostic applications. The power of slice, most scan times are on the order of minutes
MRI lies in image contrast, exploiting the inherent due to the repeated process of excitation,
magnetic properties of protons predominantly encoding, timing, and signal reception. Many
found in tissue water, but also in other biochemical significant innovations in MRI over the past two
species. The essential tool for an MRI experiment decades have focused on reducing acquisition
is a large main magnetic field (> 0.5 Tesla), which times, mostly by limiting the required data needed
creates an observable net magnetization in biolog- for image reconstruction.
ical samples that can be subsequently manipulated In actuality, only a tiny percentage of protons
for image formation. A carefully designed collec- make up the observable net magnetization for
tion of radiofrequencies (RF) and time-varying MRI. This places significant importance on coil
gradient pulses work in conjunction with the main reception sensitivity to optimize signal-to-noise
magnetic field to produce image contrast “maps” ratio (SNR). Moreover, these SNR constraints
from received signals that are “weighted” toward may place practical limits on image resolution,
specific tissue properties, such as T1, T2, T2*, especially in comparison to computed tomog-
proton density (PD), and, if desired, diffusion and raphy (CT). Although SNR can be improved
flow. This image contrast versatility is akin to through signal averaging, this prolongs scan
histopathological tissue staining, wherein specific times significantly.
tissue substructures are highlighted by altering the
chemical fixation. Anatomical visualization in MRI
can be prescribed in any orientation using multi- Common Image Quality
planar 2D or 3D slices; however, gating and repeti-
Problems
tion can be employed to manifest a temporal
dimension, allowing cine or 4D visualization. ● Motion (bulk tissue movement and flow)
Since MRI acquisitions depend on tissue relaxa- ● Susceptibility
tion properties (i.e., T1 and T2), adequate time is ● Aliasing
needed to impart appropriate weighting to the
● Truncation
encoded MR signal. In its basic sense, the received
signal represents information pertaining to tissue ● Field inhomogeneity
properties, pulse timing, and signal location, ● Coil use and placement

59
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.1 Case 1: Appearance of 4.1.3 Discussion


Discrete Image Ghosts on The essence of MR signal acquisition and recon-
struction relies on data consistency in k-space over
Abdominal Imaging the complete duration of the scan (seconds to
4.1.1 Background minutes). A positional change of an object during
acquisition will induce an amplitude or phase mo-
● Subject underwent routine abdominal MRI, dulation of the expected k-space encoding step,
using multislice gradient echo imaging. especially in relation to previous (and future)
● This type of gradient echo data acquisition inter- encoding steps. This modulation in k-space will
leaves collection of phase-encoded data signals manifest as a replication of the object in the resul-
tant image due to properties of the discrete Fourier
from all slices over the course of one repetition
transform. The nature of the replication depends on
time (TR) period (~ 170 miliseconds). the nature of the object motion, and how it
Subsequent phase-encode steps are repeated
every TR period, until k-space is filled.
● Most abdominal MRI acquisitions, such as this,
require the subject to suspend breathing for the
duration of the scan. Typically, the breath-hold
duration is < 20 seconds.

4.1.2 Findings
● Subject was not able to suspend breathing
during the acquisition.
● Upon reconstruction, distinct image “copies”
(ghosts) are seen propagating in the anterior-
posterior direction (▶ Fig. 4.1, ▶ Fig. 4.2, and
▶ Fig. 4.3).
Fig. 4.1 Axial T1 gradient echo of the abdomen
showing gross appearance of image ghosts,
propagating in the anterior-posterior direction.

Fig. 4.2 (a–c) Three abdominal cases, showing acquisition during (a) heavy breathing (period motion); (b) incomplete or
irregular breath holding, and (c) perfect breath holding. Variation of phase encode data collection accompanies each case.

60
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.1 Case 1: Appearance of Discrete Image Ghosts on Abdominal Imaging

Flow due to moving spins also may induce


image ghosts. Like respiratory motion, flow pulsa-
tility coupled with signal amplitude changes from
unsaturated spins moving through the imaging
plane and can cause modulation of k-space across
phase-encode steps (▶ Fig. 4.3).

4.1.4 Resolution
The simplest tactic to remedy the clinical signifi-
cance of image ghosts is to exchange phase and
frequency directions in order to redirect ghosts
into a perpendicular direction, and better reveal
Fig. 4.3 Discrete ghosts from pulsatile flow in the aorta tissue under examination. However, any strategy
propagate in the anterior-posterior direction. to reduce or entirely eliminate image ghosts
involves ensuring k-space consistency over the
duration of the data acquisition. As seen in
synchronizes with data acquisition: periodic ▶ Fig. 4.2, eliminating ghosts ultimately requires
motion, such as respiration, will usually result in synchronizing phase-encode data collection with
discrete ghosts, while random motion, such as eye known object motion. This synchronization, as
movement and swallowing, will result in faint, employed with navigator or respiratory gating,
unstructured ghosts. collects data only from particular motional states
Since the effective sampling rate is slower in the (e.g., expiration) and disregards others. Depending
phase encode direction (1/TR, for single-echo on the complexity of motion, data synchronization
imaging; 1/echo-spacing, for echo train imaging) may result in long scan times or even insignificant
compared to the frequency encode direction motion compensation. Alternatively, if one is able
(1/Δt = bandwidth (BW), Δt = sampling interval), the to reduce TR such that the phase encode sampling
sensitivity of k-space modulation and inconsistency rate is high relative to the object motional rate,
is commonly seen along the phase encode direc- ghosts may become indistinguishable from edge
tion. This is depicted in ▶ Fig. 4.2 which plots the blurring. Reducing TR and echo spacing may also
degree of (normalized) k-space modulation as a allow breath holding. This latter strategy is the
function of three types of motional behaviors: deep most robust compensation method and is
periodic breathing, shallow breathing, and perfect becoming increasingly more applicable due to
breath holding. As seen, the change in amplitude advancements in parallel imaging and compressed
among phase-encode steps are much greater than sensing.
individual frequency-encode steps.

61
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.2 Case 2: A Well-Defined Area common outcomes: (1) image distortion (or
warping), and (2) susceptibility related signal loss.
of Signal Hyperintensity Appears When adjacent tissues have very different magnetic
Bilaterally at the Level of the susceptibility, image distortion is likely since the
local magnetic field is altered from its expected
Internal Auditory Canal on value. This inhomogeneous environment may
Diffusion-Weighted MRI, disrupt the applied spatial encoding gradients
during an MRI acquisition, which are assumed to be
Affecting Visualization of linear. In the frequency-encoding direction, a
Surrounding Structures nonlinear gradient will change the overall fre-
quency distribution of encoded spins, where some
4.2.1 Background spatial locations may now be “mapped” with more
● Routine brain MRI exam without specific than one spatial frequency (▶ Fig. 4.5), resulting in
image distortion or signal “pile-up.” The more
pathologic indication. Diffusion-weighted imaging
shallow the applied gradient (low encoding BW),
(DWI) is a standard-of-care acquisition for
the more significant the spatial mismapping and
describing cellular integrity of various tissue types. distortion. Even though this effect occurs predomi-
● DWI is an echo-planar imaging (EPI) technique, nantly in the frequency-encoding direction, single-
utilizing large directionally sensitive gradients to shot EPI shows susceptibility-related distortion in
encode movements related to diffusion. the phase-encode direction (▶ Fig. 4.4) due to the
relatively low sampling rate in this direction. Accel-
● EPI is a rapid gradient echo method that collects
erated signal loss is another result of high magnetic
all k-space data following one RF excitation susceptibility environments. The large local field
(“single-shot”). This typically involves fast
gradient reversals, interleaved with incremental
phase-encoding steps.

4.2.2 Findings
● The high signal intensity is an artifact evolving
from constructive signal “pile-up” related to
susceptibility (arrows, ▶ Fig. 4.4).
● The internal auditory canal (IAC) region is an
air-filled region with changing geometry that
represents a sharp transition of magnetic suscept-
ibility compared to the rest of the brain structure.

4.2.3 Discussion
Tissues and other substances in the body will alter
the applied magnetic field based on their tissue
properties and chemical composition. “Magnetic
susceptibility” is a term that describes the degree to
which a substance is able to disrupt the local
magnetic field in terms of its strengthening (para-
magnetic) or weakening (diamagnetic). Some
substances, such as iron, are ferromagnetic which Fig. 4.4 Diffusion EPI brain acquisition showing hyper-
cause significant disruption of the local magnetic intense signal at the level of the internal auditory canal
caused by susceptibility.
field. Significant magnetic susceptibility has two

62
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.2 Case 2

Fig. 4.5 (a,b) Frequency encoding


gradient showing gradient warping
due to susceptibility.

Fig. 4.6 Comparison of signal loss and distortion due to the presence of metal in three types of imaging techniques:
(a) turbo spin echo, (b) gradient echo, and (c) echo-planar imaging.

alterations induce additional spin dephasing in the bility to characterize tissue properties and is espe-
transverse plane causing signal loss. Even though cially useful for looking at iron content and hemor-
the additional field inhomogeneities are mitigated rhages in the brain.
by RF rephasing in spin echo techniques, accelerated
T2 decay will still occur. This is not the case for
gradient echo techniques, where T2*-related signal
4.2.4 Resolution
loss is the predominant result in high magnetic Complete elimination of image distortion and
susceptibility environments (▶ Fig. 4.6). It is impor- signal loss due to large magnetic susceptibility
tant to note that exploiting susceptibility effects to may not be attainable, especially for metal
enhance tissue characterization has recently implants or other ferromagnetic substances.
become an active area of research. Susceptibility- However, there are several tactics to reduce the
weight imaging (SWI) uses the effect of suscepti- impact on surrounding anatomy. Susceptibility

63
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

artifacts are most prevalent on gradient echo addressed by increasing the imaging BW, which
sequences and high field strengths (3T), so allows for more encoding frequencies and lessens
switching (if possible) to spin echo alternatives the degree of spatial misregistration. This also
and lower field strengths (1.5T) are the primary allows for shorter TEs. While other strategies
options. Also, one should address the key parame- exist (such as reducing voxel size), new MR inno-
ters that affect signal loss and image distortion. vations have been developed to incorporate
The former can best be impacted by using lower specific susceptibility-reducing attributes, espe-
times to echo (TEs), while still maintaining the cially for imaging in the presence of metal
desired image contrast. Distortion can be implants for orthopedic applications.

64
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.3 Case 3: Appearance of Extra Field-of-view Anatomy

4.3 Case 3: Appearance of 4.3.3 Discussion


Extra Field-of-view Anatomy The example shows clear evidence of anatomical
wrap-around artifact, also known as “aliasing,” in
on the Inferior Portion of the superior-inferior direction with a section of the
Sagittal 3D T2-Weighted head superimposed onto the lower thoracic spine.
Acquisition of the Spine This is also apparent on an axial reformatted slice
(▶ Fig. 4.7a). Aliasing occurs in the phase-encoding
4.3.1 Background direction for both 2D and 3D acquisitions when
employing Cartesian k-space trajectories. The possi-
● 3D MR acquisitions are subject to phase bility of aliasing in any imaging scenario depends on
encoding in two directions. three main situations: (1) whether tissue is within
● Isotropic resolution allows high-resolution the sensitivity region of an activated RF receiver coil;
reconstructions in secondary directions. (2) whether the prescribed FOV is smaller than the
● Additional image quality issues exist for 3D anatomical extent in the (2D or 3D) phase-encoding
direction; and (3) the excitation region of the RF
acquisitions.
transmission pulse. In ▶ Fig. 4.7, the top of the head
is within a region that has both been excited by an
4.3.2 Findings RF pulse and observable by the activated head coil.
Since the in-plane phase-encode direction is
● Large superior-inferior FOV requires activation
superior-inferior and the FOV is smaller than this
of both multichannel head coil and cervical/ “activated” anatomy, the portion of the head outside
thoracic spine coil elements. Lumbar spine coil the FOV is superimposed, or “wrapped,” onto the
elements are deactivated. other side. This is another form of spatial mismap-
● Ghost-like artifact resembling the head ping due to the MR signal encoding process. To
understand the phenomena, note that the tissue
appears superimposed on the lower part of
outside of the prescribed 2D FOV has still been
the image and on the resultant axial
excited by an RF pulse and thus still subject to
reconstruction. applied field encoding gradients. The phase
● No other abnormal artifacts appear on the upper encoding process imparts phase shifts between −180
half of the sagittal image, nor in the left-right and + 180 degrees within the FOV. However, tissues
direction of the axial series. outside of the FOV still experience phase encoding,
but with shifts outside this range (> + 180, or < −180).
● 3D T2 TSE sequence was applied using volume
For example, due to the cyclical nature (i.e., sine
selective RF excitation, but with minimal over- wave) of MR signals, a phase shift of + 185 degrees is
sampling of data in the in-plane phase-encoding equivalent to −175 degrees and is “wrapped” onto
direction (superior-inferior direction) to save other encoded steps of −175 degrees as illustrated
imaging time. in ▶ Fig. 4.8. Aliasing can also occur in the slice

Fig. 4.7 (a) 3D sagittal T2, and


(b) a corresponding axial reformatted
slice of the spine showing faint signs
of head anatomy, indicative of signal
aliasing.

65
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fig. 4.8 Graphical representation of


phase-encode wrap around. Excited
anatomy outside the field of view
“acquires” the same phase-encoding
step as corresponding tissue within the
FOV.

Fig. 4.9 (a, b) Slice encode aliasing


shown on axial 3D T2 imaging. Spins
excited outside the prescribed imaging
volume are encoded similarly as those
within the imaging volume. In some
cases, 3D aliasing may be mistaken for
pathology.

direction in 3D imaging. However, the case in entire coil-sensitivity region may be needed for
▶ Fig. 4.7 employed slab-selective RF, so that little to particular 3D acquisitions. Mostly, users are
no tissue outside the intended volume (FOV in the resigned to “oversample” the tissue outside the
slice direction) is excited. Even with slab-selective FOV, especially if one does not want to increase
excitation, some residual aliasing may occur, as FOV or coverage for resolution or data limit
shown in ▶ Fig. 4.9, since no selective RF pulses have purposes, respectively. While this strategy is liber-
a perfect slice profile. ally applied in the 2D phase-encode direction, a
lesser amount is generally applied in the slice-
encoding direction, particularly if slab-selective
4.3.4 Resolution
excitation is used. Phase encode oversampling
The straightforward remedy for aliasing is to be costs time, but adds SNR, and therefore, should be
conscious of the three criteria mentioned above. balanced against other imaging criteria for specific
One must first observe what tissue resides outside applications. It should be noted, finally, that some
the imaging FOV, but within the RF excitation and aliasing is tolerable: if aliased anatomy does not
activated coil sensitivity region. If possible, specific impinge on the diagnostic region of interest,
coil elements should be deactivated to avoid significant time-savings or optimized resolution
encoding this residual signal. However, no receive can be achieved. Two applications that exploit this
coils have sharp sensitivity cut-offs. Moreover, the are cardiac and phase-contrast imaging.

66
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.4 Case 4

4.4 Case 4: Precontrast, Axial undersampled in both the phase- and slice-
encoding direction to achieve appropriate scan
3D T1-Weighted Gradient Echo durations. This amounts to a reduced phase reso-
with Fat Suppression Shows lution and increased slice thickness, respectively.
When resolution is too low in a certain direction,
Adequate Anatomical Detail, truncation (or Gibbs) artifact may occur. Trunca-
but Minor Edge Ripple and Blur tion artifact is identified by periodic low- and
high-signal intensity ripples emanating from
that is Presumed to be Motion high-contrast edges. While this appearance may
4.4.1 Background closely mimic motion artifact, truncation effects
are exclusive to sharp, high-contrast edges, and
● 3D gradient echo imaging of the abdomen is fade thereafter; there is no replicating of anatomy.
a breath-hold technique that will be subject This phenomenon is due to the inability of the
to motion artifacts if the patient cannot comply. acquisition to accurately define sharp edges, using
the available frequency encoding range, particu-
● Imaging resolution is 1.4 × 1.7 mm in-plane,
larly high-frequency data. The consequence is an
with 3 mm (interpolated) slice thickness. overestimation and underestimation of the high-
● The subject appeared cooperative with breath contrast structure, which decays with distance
holding instructions, judging from other (▶ Fig. 4.11). The propagation distance of ripples is
longer if more high-frequency data points are
acquisitions (not shown).
absent from the acquisition.
In-plane truncation artifacts affect both 2D
4.4.2 Findings and 3D acquisitions. However, truncation in the
slice direction is unique to 3D imaging.
● There are several areas of edge ripple and blur in ▶ Fig. 4.12 shows a coronal reconstruction of the
the image, including the liver capsule and portal original data set, given in ▶ Fig. 4.12. The recon-
vein. structed data makes the truncation artifact more
● There is also some signal fluctuation in the
visceral fat in the retroperitoneum.
● While most ripples emanate in the anterior-
posterior direction, some extend in lateral
directions as well.
● Incomplete breath holding is a source of minor
blur in the phase-encode direction; however,
the external abdominal wall appears fairly sharp,
without indication of signal propagation
(▶ Fig. 4.10).

4.4.3 Discussion Fig. 4.10 Breath-hold 3D T1 spoiled-gradient echo with


fat suppression, showing adequate breath holding, but
Given the requirements of breath-hold imaging in subtle ringing and edge enhancements (arrows).
the abdomen, 3D acquisitions are significantly

Fig. 4.11 Gibbs ripple resulting from


a limited frequency-encoding range.

67
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

conspicuous, especially realizing that the axial 4.4.4 Resolution


3D volume was acquired with 6 mm (3 mm inter-
polated) slice thickness. The ripples, which are The 3D truncation artifact seen in ▶ Fig. 4.10 can
best seen in the spleen and against the fat- be improved by reducing the slice thickness, or
suppressed retroperitoneum, are large due to the rather, improving the slice resolution. Similarly, a
low resolution in the slice direction. The signifi- fully sampled in-plane data set, such as
cance of this artifact is not appreciated when 288 × 288, will also reduce edge ripple in 2D.
viewed in the standard axial orientation. However, it is important to note that a complete
elimination of edge ringing is not possible. This is
due to the discrete nature of digitized data
sampling in MRI and subsequent Fourier recon-
struction. In practice, an infinite frequency range
would be necessary to describe a sharp step
change in signal intensity between two objects,
which is not possible in MRI experiments.
However, when high enough resolution imaging
is employed, a greater frequency range is avail-
able to approximate edge information, with high-
contrast features being more well defined
(▶ Fig. 4.13). Even though ringing may still be
present, both intensity and ripple distance from
the edge location will be progressively reduced,
which makes them less conspicuous. If increasing
Fig. 4.12 Coronal reconstruction of 3D data set from the resolution is not practical due to SNR and
▶ Fig. 4.1, showing more prominent truncation artifact time constraints, applying a filter to smooth the
due to large slice thickness. image helps to reduce much of the ringing, at the
expense of some edge blurring.

Fig. 4.13 Comparison of low- and


high-resolution imaging of a grid
phantom. The degree of truncation
ripple is less in the high-resolution
scan.

68
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.5 Case 5: Dark Etching Appears at the Boundary of Fat and Soft-Tissue Layer

4.5 Case 5: Dark Etching mismapping: when two neighboring tissue


proton species have different resonant frequen-
Appears at the Boundary of Fat cies, they may be spatially misinterpreted during
and Soft-Tissue Layers frequency encoding, and therefore spatially offset
from one another (or superimpose) during image
4.5.1 Background formation. This is the case for fat and water
protons, where the frequency offset is 3.5 ppm,
● Routine Ax T1 TSE for neck soft tissues with
or 224 Hz at 1.5 T. The degree of water–fat shift
phase encoding left-to-right. (WFS) is inversely proportional to the frequency-
● Subject is cooperative, and slight blur around the encoding bandwidth, as with susceptibility. The
tongue is considered normal. prevalence of type 1 artifact to the frequency-
encode direction (for non-EPI sequences) is due
4.5.2 Findings to the relatively low readout BW of these
sequences, as well as the fact that transverse
● While some dark signal is attributable to signal magnetization is either refocused or spoiled for
loss, specific etching in the locations indicated each echo measurement. This effectively negates
seems abnormal (▶ Fig. 4.14). the accumulation of precession-related offsets in
the phase-encode direction. Since EPI utilizes a
● Parameters are typical for T1 imaging
very high BW, it is a special case where type 1
(TR ~ 500 milliseconds; TE ~ 11 milliseconds),
artifact typically occurs in the phase-encode
with a matrix of 256 and bandwidth less than direction.
200 Hz/pixel.
4.5.4 Resolution
4.5.3 Discussion Type 1 artifact does not degrade image quality to the
The appearance of dark etching, also known as extent of motion or susceptibility artifact. However,
“India ink,” between soft tissues and fat is indica- it may have impact on diagnosis if water–fat misre-
tive of type 1 chemical shift artifact. Type 1 arti- gistration obscures pathology such as cartilage thick-
fact, which is considered a misregistration arti- ness. As alluded, chemical shift is greatest when the
fact between fat and water spins, affects all frequency-encode BW is low. But it also becomes
conventional imaging techniques such as spin more significant when image resolution is also low
echo, TSE, and gradient echo. Chemical shift is (large FOV or small matrix). Since the resonant offset
somewhat similar to susceptibility-induced between water and fat is well defined (224 Hz at

Fig. 4.14 (a, b) Axial T1 turbo spin


echo of the soft tissues of the neck
reveal subtle black etching around
tissue boundaries (arrows).

69
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fig. 4.15 Axial T1 turbo spin echo of


the neck at two different bandwidths:
200 Hz/px (left), and 425 Hz/px (right).
Note that the frequency-encoding
direction is left-right in (a) and ante-
rior-posterior in (b). There is noticeable
reduction in chemical shift signal loss
along boundaries with higher
bandwidth.

1.5 T and 448 Hz at 3 T, etc.), one can easily calculate aliasing and motion, are not adversely affected. One
the expected WFS in terms of image pixel offset, if must also be wary of chemical shift at high field
the FOV, matrix, and BW are known (see appendix). strengths, since one-to-one transfer of imaging
Since FOV and matrix are often fixed due to applica- parameters will not be optimal; a proportional
tion criteria, increasing BW directly remedies the increase in BW is necessary to achieve the same
artifact (▶ Fig. 4.15). This tactic also has less SNR WFS as lower field strength. Another solution to
penalty than increases in image resolution, which is eliminate the appearance of fat shifts is to employ fat
another remedy. Alternatively, frequency and phase saturation. Though effective, this clearly alters the
directions can be swapped, in lieu of any parameter purpose of the sequence, and may not be warranted
adjustment, as long as other artifacts, such as in particular clinical applications.

70
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.6 Case 6: Application of Fat-Suppressed Sequences

4.6 Case 6: Application of Fat- 4.6.3 Discussion


Suppressed Sequences Fat suppression has many applications, including
making edema and inflammation more conspic-
in the Pelvis did not
uous on T2-weighted imaging and eliminating
Reveal the Expected Contrast confounding high signal from postcontrast
T1-weighted imaging. One important advantage of
4.6.1 Background a resonant frequency difference between water
● Fat-suppressed T1 and T2 sequences are univer- and fat protons is the ability to selectively saturate
sally employed in body MR applications, such as the magnetization of fat in MR images. This can be
done in a variety of ways, but the most common is
female pelvic imaging for fibroids.
to center an additional RF saturation pulse over
● The most common fat saturation technique is
the resonant frequency of fat. In actuality, fat has
chemically selective RF excitation, whereby only up to six different resonant frequencies, with the
fat resonant frequency is specifically targeted most significant occurring at 1.3, 2.1, and 0.9 ppm
with a saturation pulse. (▶ Fig. 4.17). For this reason, spectrally selective RF
pulses must also have a prescribed BW, but must
4.6.2 Findings be limited to prevent intruding water resonance at
4.7 ppm. In some areas of the body where complex
● Chemical fat saturation is incomplete in both or abnormal tissue geometry affects the local
T1- and T2-weighted imaging (▶ Fig. 4.16). magnetic field, the prescribed fat-centered RF
● It is likely that the MR system erroneously tuned pulse and BW may partially “miss” the true
the center frequency to be the dominant species susceptibility-induced resonant frequency of fat
in the FOV, in this case fat. causing incomplete tissue saturation on images.
Moreover, this scenario may even lead to erro-
● Alternatively, strong inhomogeneous fields or
neous saturation of water signal (▶ Fig. 4.18a).
poor shimming within the FOV may alter the
Another root cause for poor or erroneous fat
expected off-resonance position of fat species saturation is the inefficiency of RF pulses them-
relative to water. selves; sharp frequency cutoffs are difficult to
● Chemical fat saturation RF pulses are automati- achieve, especially over a small spectral range.
cally applied at 440 Hz (at 3T) down field from Consequently, the bell-shaped profile may cause
some varying excitation of resonances inside and
the tuned center frequency, which no longer
outside the frequency bounds.
effectively excite fat resonances.
Separate from local susceptibility changes, large
● Partial or incomplete fat saturation typically FOV imaging also causes regions of poor fat sup-
appears as regional bands of dark fat tissue. pression, primarily along the periphery of the FOV.

Fig. 4.16 Fat-suppressed axial (a) T2 single-shot, and (b) T1 3D gradient echo acquisitions did not produce hypointense
fat signal as expected. Some regional fat uppression is evident.

71
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fat-containing voxels located along the periphery longitudinal magnetization of fat protons prior to
are significantly far from isocenter, where field image acquisition, based on the its short T1 value
inhomogeneity also predominates. This also (~ 250 millisecond at 1.5T). Since the IR prepulse
pertains to multislice axial imaging; poor fat sup- affects both fat and water proton resonant
pression is often seen on first and last slices of frequencies, all tissue will undergo longitudinal
axial data sets with large number of slices. T1 recovery. Most tissues relax slower than fat,
and will not be suppressed at the selected inver-
sion time (TI); however, they will incur reduced
4.6.4 Resolution available magnetization, which translates to
An immediate solution to poor fat suppression is reduced image SNR.
improving the fat suppression pulses themselves. With chemically selective fat suppression
Using adiabatic RF excitation helps improve the methods, it is always useful to observe the spectral
spectrum of targeted fat protons. Alternatively, peaks of fat and water following any shimming
spectral excitation can be performed on water procedure when fat suppression uniformity is
protons only, whose spectral amplitude and line desired. Even though broad line widths may still
width are usually more well defined than fat. persist, manual frequency adjustments help to
Another strategy is to convert the acquisition to a resolve significant fat frequency shifts caused by
short-tau inversion recovery (STIR) technique off-resonance. This strategy can be further opti-
which offers increased suppression uniformity mized by using smaller FOVs, or fewer slices,
over broad FOVs and field inhomogeneity thereby limiting the effective volume of shimming.
(▶ Fig. 4.18b). STIR utilizes a nonselective 180- More systems are now equipped with sophisti-
degree inversion (IR) prepulse timed to null the cated fat-water separation techniques, which

Fig. 4.17 Sample spectrum of fat and


water resonant peaks from a voxel
obtained in fatty liver tissue. Note the
broad lipid peak, suggesting the pres-
ence of other lipid resonances. Arbitrary
units are used along the x-axis.

Fig. 4.18 Comparison of (a) spectrally


selective fat suppression, and
(b) nonselective inversion-recovery-
based fat suppression (STIR) in the
cervical spine. Local field homogeneity
impacts the uniformity of fat suppres-
sion in (a) to the extent that water
signal may also be partially affected.

72
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.6 Case 6: Application of Fat-Suppressed Sequences

Fig. 4.19 Comparison of (a) spectrally


selective fat suppression, and (b) two-
point Dixon water-only images of the
neck in two different subjects. While
some expected inhomogeneous is
expected in (a), more robust suppres-
sion is achieved by separating fat and
water images with the Dixon tech-
nique (b).

evolved from the well-known two-point Dixon pulses, which reduce SNR of all tissues. However,
method (▶ Fig. 4.19). Modern versions of the the overall efficacy of the reconstruction is highly
method still incur a scan time penalty, but are very dependent on producing a suitable domain
efficient for creating robust fat-suppressed (water- magnetic field map. Nonetheless, unfavorable fat/
only) images. These techniques do not rely on water swapping can persist in regions of signifi-
spectrally selective pulses, or nonselective IR cant Bo field inhomogeneity.

73
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.7 Case 7: T1-Weighted 4.7.3 Discussion


Gradient Echo of the Abdomen The availability of parallel imaging methods has
tremendously improved the utility of MR in a
Shows Marked Artifact Medially variety of applications. Parallel imaging involves
on Both Coronal and Axial FOV, utilizing multiarray receive coils over the
Obscuring Visualization of Soft imaged region, and using their individually
specific coil sensitivity to reconstruct under-
Tissues sampled k-space data. Scan times can be drasti-
cally reduced by 2 × or more with parallel
4.7.1 Background imaging but the side effect is reduced SNR and
● Most T1-weighted 2D and 3D acquisitions of the some associated artifacts. Often significant
chest, abdomen, and/or pelvis require subject amplification of noise is seen with parallel
imaging when reduction factors exceed 3 × .
breath hold and some method of scan acceleration.
Furthermore, if multiarray coils are not properly
● In addition to reducing the phase-encode resolu-
placed around the region of interest, more noise
tion, utilizing parallel imaging acceleration with amplification is observed. One parallel imaging
multichannel receive coils is another common method reconstructs undersampled k-space
strategy. data using multiple coil sensitivity images in
image space (e.g., SENSE). Artifacts with this
4.7.2 Findings method appear similar to image foldover,
although the aliased regions typically appear in
● Both examples in ▶ Fig. 4.20 utilize parallel the center of the FOV and are sometimes
imaging approaches. mistaken as signal “hotspots.” Another common
● Relatively small FOV was prescribed in the parallel imaging technique estimates missing
imaging information in k-space (e.g., GRAPPA).
respective phase-encode directions to further
If missing k-space data is not effectively recov-
reduce acquisition time.
ered, unwanted phase shifts may develop,
● Both images suffer from unwanted signal artifact resulting in ghost-like artifacts in the phase-
in relevant soft tissue. encode direction (▶ Fig. 4.21).

Fig. 4.20 (a) T1-weighted 3D gradient echo (GRE) of the abdomen shows marked artifact through the middle
of the field of view, obscuring visualization of soft tissues. (b) A nonspecific high-signal line also appears on
an axial 2D GRE.

74
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.7 Case 7

Fig. 4.21 Subtle ghost-like artifact


appears in liver across the center of the
field of view (arrows). This artifact is
not indicative of motion, but rather
results from parallel imaging effects.

4.7.4 Resolution In k-space-based methods, parallel imaging


ghosts are usually rare since autocalibration
Parallel imaging artifacts may mimic physiological steps are built into the acquisition. However, the
or other technical artifacts; therefore, one must
technique is more sensitive to patient motion or
first identify the true origin of poor SNR, ghosts, or
inadequate reference coil sensitivities. Often,
aliasing. For image-based parallel imaging, some
more autocalibration reference lines are needed,
extended phase FOV (oversampling) will alleviate
the subtle unfolding reconstruction artifact. which reduces the scan acceleration. Increased
Furthermore, effort should be made to match the reference lines also alleviate central noise
anatomic positioning between coil calibration banding, which is common with parallel imaging.
scans and pulse sequences using parallel imaging. Finally, routine system and coil maintenance is
This may require calibration scans to be performed vital for optimal performance of sequences using
using similar breath hold instructions. parallel imaging.

75
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.8 Case 8: Abnormal Dark 4.8.2 Findings


Fluid Seen in the Bladder ● While each slice in HASTE imaging is acquired
of an Axial Single-Shot T2- individually in less than a half second, an entire

Weighted Sequence, but volume of tissue is excited and combined every


TR period for the 3D T2 technique.
not on Location-Matched ● Static fluid in the bladder will be T2-bright by
3D T2 Acquisition definition on both sequences, but some focused
4.8.1 Background regions of hypointense signal indicate some flow
on HASTE (▶ Fig. 4.22a).
● All soft-tissue pelvic imaging involve either large
● The ultrafast acquisition of HASTE will be
FOV axial T2 for gross anatomy, or small FOV
sensitive to some flow turbulence entering the
(high resolution) T2 for evaluating specific
slice during the acquisition. This fluid was not
diseases, such as rectal and prostate cancer.
originally excited, but replaces some fluid in this
● Often, half-Fourier-acquired single-shot turbo
course of time.
spin echo (HASTE) is performed for overall
● 3D T2 is not sensitive to this subtle fluid motion
anatomical assessment since it is able to quickly
since its influence is effectively averaged out
acquire large superior-to-inferior coverage with
over the multiple TR periods.
minimal motion artifacts.
● HASTE acquires just over half of its k-space data
in one TR period, with the rest being interpo- 4.8.3 Discussion
lated. This enables ultra-fast single-slice The case above exemplifies the ever-present
acquisition, without T1-weighting. concept of flow-related contrast in MRI. In many
cases, such as in angiographic applications, flow-
● High resolution 3D T2 acquires k-space data in
related contrast is expected with sequences espe-
multiple TR periods, depending on the amount
cially configured to be sensitive to the phenomena.
of total phase-encode data and the acquisition However, many essential sequences intended for
echo train length. soft tissue analysis may be prone to unexpected

Fig. 4.22 Abnormal dark fluid seen in the bladder of an axial single-shot T2-weighted sequence (a). The appearance is
absent from a location-matched 3D T2 acquisition (b).

76
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.8 Case 8: Abnormal Dark Fluid Seen in the Bladder

hyper- or hypointensities related to flow. It was (at TE), leaving a “flow void.” As flow becomes
previously discussed (Case 1) that fluctuating signal restricted or stationary (as in veins or certain parts
intensity due to periodic flow will lead to ghosting of the cardiac cycle), blood will appear diffusely
if not properly compensated or synchronized with hyperintense, similar to fluid, since it also has rela-
the acquisition. While this is particularly true for tively high T2. This is apparent in ▶ Fig. 4.23c, d, in
TSE sequences, flow-related contrast may also a patient with metastatic neuroendocrine disease,
appear as a static indication of a particular flow where HASTE shows some hyperintense blood
state and possibly even point to disease abnormal- signal representative of slow or restricted flow. In
ities. In the case of ▶ Fig. 4.22a, the fluid in the this case, it is important to examine all slices to
bladder is mostly stationary, and predictably determine whether the signal is due to sensitivity
appears bright due to its high T2 value. The dark to the cardiac cycle or related to disease (such as
areas represent subtle flow from fluid entering the hypertension or thrombosis). Flow-related contrast
slice between excitation and TE. In contrast, also affects gradient echo MR sequences. Since TE
consider ▶ Fig. 4.23a, b, where blood in the aorta and TR are typically shorter than spin echo type
and portal vein are both dark on axial and coronal sequences, unperturbed blood flowing into the slice
HASTE, respectively. In rapid flowing vessels, blood is both excited and measured in close tandem,
that is slice-excited quickly travels out of the slice producing a bright blood phenomenon. A well-
before the signal is both refocused and measured known example is 3D time-of-flight (TOF) imaging.

Fig. 4.23 (a) Axial and (b) coronal T2 single-shot in a healthy subject reveals hypointense signal in the aorta and portal
vein. Similar acquisitions obtained in a patient with metastatic disease (c and d) show some hyperintense blood signal in
the corresponding vessels, suggesting slow or restricted flow.

77
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fig. 4.24 Examples of entry-flow phenomena on gradient echo (GRE) images. (a) 2D axial GRE, with bright blood in liver
vessels; (b) a reconstructed coronal-oblique 3D GRE with hyperintense blood signal, which slowly fades in the direction
of flow.

In this sequence, blood entering the imaging Lack of flow voids on spin echo type imaging,
volume is excited and measured at TE, but escapes especially HASTE, are indicative of slow-moving
the volume before the next excitation. This “entry- blood remaining in the imaging slice. These
flow” enhancement effect can be contrasted with diastolic hyperintensities can be lessened with
stationary tissue that remains dark due to repeated cardiac gating, with or without the addition of a
exposure to RF excitation. In some cases, bright “black blood” pulse. These additional pulses come
blood on gradient echo is unwanted or unexpected, in a variety of methods (both gradient and RF
as shown in ▶ Fig. 4.24, since it may be mistaken for forms), and help to further eliminate residual
the presence of gadolinium contrast agent. blood signal though flow cancellation and
dephasing. Conversely, flow voids are unwanted in
angiographic 3D gradient echo. It is important
4.8.4 Resolution
to prescribe sufficient volumetric coverage to
As stated, flow-related contrast is desirable in maximize inflow enhancement, while being
many applications. In addition, it aids in many conscious that in-plane flow from tortuous vessels
diagnostic instances. In practice, it is important to may result in some signal loss. For nonangio-
understand how flow from generally static fluid or graphic gradient echo, shortened TR and opti-
from fat flowing blood may affect the signal prop- mized TE, especially for 3D imaging, ensures dark
erties of specific spin or gradient echo sequences. vessel lumen.

78
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.9 Case 9: Postcontrast T1-Weighted Gradient Echo Reveals Patchy Enhancement

4.9 Case 9: Postcontrast T1- from the pharmacokinetics of most gadolinium


contrast agents, which provide significant T1 en-
Weighted Gradient Echo hancement in regions of high vascularity and
Reveals Patchy Enhancement in extracellular space. In the case of infarcted
myocardium, the scarred region experiences
the Anterior Septal Wall delayed contrast distribution due to poor vascu-
4.9.1 Background larity followed by prolonged clearance. This is in
stark contradiction to the more predictable
● Corresponding cine and postcontrast T1 is kinetic behavior in both remote myocardium and
essential for demonstrating areas of scar due blood pool. While fast T1-weighted imaging can
to myocardial infarction. exploit the T1 differences between normal and
infarcted myocardium, image contrast can be
● Postcontrast T1 is commonly performed with
significantly improved by implementing IR prepa-
inversion recovery fast gradient echo sequences, ration pulses. These 180-degree RF pulses, which
which is intended to enhance the contrast invert the polarity of all available longitudinal
between healthy and infarcted myocardium. magnetization, are performed at a designated
● T1 image contrast is controlled by the time time prior to normal data acquisition. In other
words, this process “prepares” the longitudinal
delay between the inversion pulse and data
magnetization for subsequent data collection.
acquisition.
Since all tissues including normal and infarcted
myocardium have unique T1 values, IR pulses
4.9.2 Findings have the ability to further enhance the dynamic
range and contrast if the time of inversion (TI) is
● Area of scar enhancement not clearly defined
selected appropriately. Maximum apparent
relative to healthy myocardium. contrast in the case of delayed myocardial
● Corresponding short-axis cine shows thin imaging is achieved when TI is selected to cancel
myocardium in the same region. (or “null”) the longitudinal recovery of normal
myocardium (▶ Fig. 4.26). The TI null point
implies tissue signal suppression (in terms of its
4.9.3 Discussion T1 value), since no longitudinal magnetization
Delayed contrast enhancement (DCE) is a exists as imaging data collection commences.
powerful cardiac MRI technique for distinguishing ▶ Fig. 4.27 shows another example of how
areas in the myocardium with increased extracel- changing the TI value significantly alters the
lular distribution volume due to cell necrosis, ability to distinguish infarcted from normal
fibrosis, or scarring (▶ Fig. 4.25). This extends myocardium.

Fig. 4.25 (a) Postcontrast T1-weighted gradient echo reveals patchy enhancement in the anterior septal wall.
(b) Corresponding short-axis cine shows thin myocardium in the same region.

79
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fig. 4.26 Plot of the relative longitudinal T1 recovery of contrast-enhanced normal and infarcted myocardium following
application of an inversion (180 degrees) RF pulse. The concept is to commence image acquisition after an inversion
time (TI) set to suppress the signal of normal myocardium. This occurs at the point when recovery crosses the x-axis.

Fig. 4.27 Comparison of contrast-enhanced short-axis inversion recovery in a subject with subendocardial infarction.
A TI of 600 milliseconds (a) does not reveal the extent of infarct region, while adapting to TI = 300 milliseconds (b) shows
the enhancement sufficiently (arrow) by virtue of suppressing signal from normal myocardium.

80
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.9 Case 9: Postcontrast T1-Weighted Gradient Echo Reveals Patchy Enhancement

There are a host of applications that utilize IR. same application. In this case, image contrast
Each carefully prescribes TI to null a particular between subendocardial infarct and normal
tissue’s (known) T1, or enhance contrast between myocardium is optimized with TI = 250 milli-
two T1 s. Both STIR- and fluid-attenuated inversion second (▶ Fig. 4.27b) compared to TI = 600 milli-
recovery (FLAIR)-type sequences employ IR to null second (▶ Fig. 4.27a). However, since contrast
fat and fluid, respectively. Some other applications, agent concentration changes dynamically
such as postcontrast brain imaging (e.g., MPRAGE), following administration, simply applying TI = 250
utilize an optimized TI to enhance grey and white millisecond to the case in ▶ Fig. 4.25 may not
matter differences, in contrast to enhancing always null normal myocardium. Often, a “TI-
lesions. It can be shown that T1 image contrast scout” acquisition must be performed, which
improves with the use of IR prepulses at the quickly samples images at multiple TI values. The
expense of some increased imaging time. user then selects the optimal null point TI to
subsequently optimize IR delayed enhancement
imaging. Similar TI optimization is needed in other
4.9.4 Resolution sequences, as well, such as FLAIR. In this sequence,
In general, if T1 is known (e.g., T1fat = 250 milli- CSF fluid suppression is desired. Since CSF fluid
second; T1csf = 3500 millisecond), optimal null has a lengthy T1 (~ 3500 millisecond), which is on
point TI is calculated from a modified monoexpo- the order (or greater than) most spin echo TRs, one
nential recovery equation (TI = 0.693 × T1). An must consider the effect of incomplete T1 relaxa-
analytical solution can also be made to estimate tion when choosing an optimal TI value. In this
the expected image contrast of any chosen TI, case, the optimal TI is less than the predicted TI,
given multiple T1 values and scales exponentially with TR. For complete-
ness, it is often important to consider other
S ¼ 1  2eTI=T1
parameters, such as TR, flip angle, and echo train
▶ Fig. 4.27 shows the important image contrast length, when determining optimal TI, especially
differences when different TIs are chosen for the for long T1 tissues.

81
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.10 Case 10: Significant integrity in any part of these two elements
dramatically reduces the upper threshold of
Signal-to-Noise Variation achievable SNR and, hence, image quality. For
Across the FOV, this reason, it is important to have a routine
quality assurance program in place, whereby RF
Creating Nondiagnostic coils are tested for proper functionality. An
Image Quality important distinction must be made when inter-
rogating errors and artifacts related to either RF
4.10.1 Background transmission or RF reception. Particularly, RF
transmission field mostly originates from the
● MR signal originates from net magnetization
main magnetic coil located within the bore (even
aligned along the main magnetic field.
though local transmit/receive and dual transmit
● Above all, the imaging process requires spin coils also exist). This transmission is pretuned
excitation and signal reception by RF coils. based on desired flip angles and emits across a
● The homogeneity of the prescribed transmission broad volume within the bore. It is clear that the
and receiving RF fields are proportional to the integrity of the RF transmission field is only
entirely uniform over a smaller finite volume
resulting image SNR.
(~ 30–40 cm) around the isocenter, and falls off
thereafter due to inhomogeneity (▶ Fig. 4.30).
4.10.2 Findings The result is variation in the expected flip angle
distribution, which in turn affects transverse
● Significant noise is apparent in the middle of
magnetization. Another dramatic effect of RF
FOV, and anterior to the spinal anatomy transmit field inhomogeneity is dielectric effect
(▶ Fig. 4.28). (▶ Fig. 4.31). In this situation, which mostly
● Underlying T2 image contrast is sufficient, occurs at high field strengths (> 1.5T), image
despite poor SNR. signal variation is caused by the RF field’s inter-
action with various tissue conductivities, particu-
● Brain anatomy is spared from poor image quality.
larly increased water content.
RF receive coil integrity is equally (if not more)
4.10.3 Discussion important for optimal SNR MRI. It is entirely
possible (and common) that a well-functioning
Upon closer inspection, one finds that a partic- receive coil can produce low SNR images, if care
ular receive coil element surrounding the neck
was mistakenly deactivated during the scan.
Fortunately, recognizing this error allows a
simple remedy to ensure all necessary coils are
activated over the region of interest, thus recov-
ering the underlying signal (▶ Fig. 4.29). The
persistently lower SNR anterior to spinal
anatomy points to the use of primarily posterior
receiver coil elements. While this scenario and
remedy seems trivial, other more significant root
causes may lead to SNR variation across the FOV,
such as malfunctioning receiver coils. The
common theme, therefore, is to recognize the
unequivocal importance of both receive and
transmission RF fields in MR image quality. As
stated in the background, these RF fields buttress
the entire MR image formation process; RF trans-
mission begins the experiment by exciting
proton spins, while RF receiver coils (or Fig. 4.28 Significant signal-to-noise variation across the
“antennas”) capture the encoded signal. Loss of field of view, creating nondiagnostic image quality.

82
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.10 Case 10: Significant Signal-to-Noise Variation Across the FOV,

Fig. 4.29 Comparison of the original


acquisition (a), with a second acquis-
ition with the appropriate coils
activated (b).

Fig. 4.30 (a) An initial localizer


acquisition uses a large field of view
(FOV) to routinely locate and identify
the anatomy in question. It also reveals
the effective region coil sensitivity and
signal fall-off. (b) A smaller, more
focused FOV is subsequently used for
higher-quality anatomic visualization,
while being conscious to limit
including areas outside the effective
sensitivity region.

Fig. 4.31 (a) The increased abdominal


fluid affects the RF transmit
uniformity. The fluid acts as dampener
due to the change transmit conduc-
tivity, thereby modifying the effective
flip angle. (b) The dielectric effect is
absent in patients with minimal to no
interabdominal fluid.

is not paid to its proper positioning. This is actuality, the coil was placed suboptimally. The
exemplified in ▶ Fig. 4.32, where there may be skill developed in coil use and placement is often
legitimate question about the significant drop in understated and presumed.
SNR across a multislice acquisition, when in

83
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Fig. 4.32 (a) Sagittal T2 image of the pelvis does not extend through the pelvic floor due to poor coil coverage in
the region. (b) and (c) show corresponding axial acquisitions from two locations. Note the significant drop in SNR
in (c) relative to (b) toward the pelvic floor due to poor coil sensitivity.

4.10.4 Resolution FOV < 30 cm to preserve optimal quality. Initial


survey scans also reveal whether receive coils are
Many image quality issues stem from poor coil positioned too high or low (▶ Fig. 4.32). This
placement or not recognizing the optimum extent should be adjusted based on the extent of
of the RF transmit uniformity. Quality MR would anatomic coverage. Positioning and activation of
not be possible without careful attention to both coils and coil elements should also play a role
items. If an imaging practice intends to perform when diagnosing other artifacts, such as parallel
large FOV exams (e.g., abdomen-pelvis, thoracic imaging (Case 7, T1-Weighted Gradient Echo
spine, long bones, etc.), it is wise to acquire large (GRE) of the Abdomen Shows Marked Artifact
(> 40 cm FOV) survey acquisitions, and measure Medially on Both Coronal and Axial FOV,
the region of optimal signal homogeneity avail- Obscuring Visualization of Soft Tissues) and
able. This can be appreciated in ▶ Fig. 4.31, where aliasing (Case 3, Appearance of Extra Field-of-
a FOV of 40 cm shows signal drop out beyond a View Anatomy on the Inferior Portion of Sagittal
30 cm radius; subsequent scans are limited to 3D T2-Weighted Acquisition of the Spine).

84
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.11 Review Questions

4.11 Review Questions 4.11.2 Case 2: A Well-Defined


4.11.1 Case 1: Appearance of Area of Signal Hyperintensity
Discrete Image Ghosts on Appears Bilaterally at the Level
Abdominal Imaging of the Internal Auditory Canal on
Diffusion-Weighted MRI, Affecting
1. The acquisition of phase-encode steps at both
Visualization of Surrounding
inspiration and expiration states during the
Structures
course of free-breathing abdominal MRI will
most likely result in what appearance in the 4. Which of the following strategies will help
image? reduce metal susceptibility artifact?
a) Image blurring a) Increase BW, and switch to fast gradient
b) Discrete image ghosts echo
c) Ringing in the frequency direction b) Increase BW, and lower TE
d) Pulsation artifacts c) Switch to fast gradient echo, and increase
resolution and signal averaging
2. Which of the following methods is NOT an d) Swap phase-encode direction, and increase
effective strategy for reducing motion resolution and slice thickness
artifacts?
a) Breath holding 4.11.3 Case 3: Appearance of
b) Respiratory gating Extra Field-of-view Anatomy on
c) Shallow breathing
the Inferior Portion of Sagittal 3D
d) Ultrashort TR sequences
T2-Weighted Acquisition of the
3. “Single-shot” MR abdominal acquisitions, such
Spine
as half-Fourier turbo spin echo (TSE), collect all 5. To image small anatomy, such as the pituitary,
phase-encode steps from one slice in one TR without aliasing artifact using an FOV smaller
period, with very short echo spacing. Regarding than the brain, which of the following tactics
motion artifacts due to free breathing, which of should NOT be employed?
the following is NOT true about single-shot a) Sagittal 2D imaging with maximum phase
methods? oversampling
a) Multislice images may be misregistered with b) Axial 3D imaging with nonselective RF
one another pulses and maximum phase oversampling
b) Subtle ghosts will be apparent along the c) Coronal slab-selective 3D imaging some slice
phase-encode direction oversampling
c) Image blurring may occur d) Axial 2D imaging using a rectangular FOV in
d) Cross-talk and signal saturation may occur the left-right direction, such that the ears
between sequentially acquired slices are truncated

85
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

4.11.4 Case 4: Precontrast, Axial 4.11.6 Case 6: Application of


3D T1-Weighted Gradient Echo Fat-Suppressed Sequences in the
with Fat Suppression Shows Pelvis did not Reveal the Expected
Adequate Anatomical Detail, but Contrast
Minor Edge Ripple and Blur that is 10. All of the following strategies will help to
Presumed to be Motion improve fat suppression, except:
6. In 3D imaging, how can one better distinguish a) Repositioning the subject at the magnet
truncation from motion artifact? isocenter
a) Reconstruct data in another dimension b) Switching to STIR acquisitions
b) If ringing occurs in all directions, it is due to c) Switching receiver coils
motion d) Shimming and manually adjusting the
c) Signal intensity is much higher with center frequency
truncation
d) There is no way to distinguish them 11. Frequency-selective fat saturation is usually
most uniform in which of the following
7. Truncation artifact may occur in the frequency- scenarios?
encode direction when: a) Anatomy that allows small FOV, such as the
a) Resolution is very high knee
b) BW is large b) Anatomy with irregular geometry, such as
c) There are very high-contrast boundaries the neck
along that direction c) Off-center FOV, such as the elbow at one’s
d) A smoothing filter is applied side
d) Large FOV, such as bilateral femurs and hips

4.11.5 Case 5: Dark Etching


4.11.7 Case 7: T1-Weighted
Appears at the Boundary of Fat
Gradient Echo of the Abdomen
and Soft-Tissue Layers
Shows Marked Artifact Medially
8. A water-fat shift (WFS) of two pixels at 1.5 T
on Both Coronal and Axial FOV,
implies:
Obscuring Visualization of Soft
a) Water and fat are off-resonant by 2 times
224 Hz (448 Hz)
Tissues
b) Water and fat will be misregistered by two 12. Given that SNR decreases with the use of parallel
pixels in the phase-encode direction imaging, what can be done to improve relative
c) The BW in Hz/pixel must be half of 224 Hz SNR and lessen parallel imaging artifacts?
(112 Hz) a) Oversample in the phase-encode direction
d) FOV must be too large b) Reduce resolution
c) Increase slice thickness
9. Which imaging scenario would reduce the d) Use more slices
conspicuity of type 1 chemical shift?
a) Removing fat sat from EPI 13. In spine MRI, typically only posterior receive
b) Swapping phase- and frequency-encode coils are used. In terms of using parallel
directions imaging, this implies:
c) Switching from spin echo to gradient echo a) Parallel imaging can be used in any direction
sequences b) For sagittal imaging, it is best to use parallel
d) Increasing the imaging resolution imaging in the superior-inferior direction

86
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.11 Review Questions

c) For axial imaging, parallel imaging in the b) SNR is too low


anterior-posterior direction is preferred c) The short TI may inadvertently suppress
d) Parallel imaging should not be used contrast agent effects
d) Too many flow artifacts

4.11.8 Case 8: Abnormal Dark 17. The null point TI is modified from 225 to 300
Fluid Seen in the Bladder of an millisecond during two DCE scans 5 minutes
Axial Single-Shot T2-Weighted apart. This implies:
Sequence, but not on Location- a) Contrast agent is mostly in the blood pool
Matched 3D T2 Acquisition b) Fat tissue needs to be suppressed for optimal
contrast
14. Low signal intensity of cerebrospinal fluid
c) TR is also short
(CSF) on T2-weighted cervical spine imaging is
d) Contrast agent is slowly being cleared from
likely due to:
normal myocardium
a) Flow ghosting
b) Use of saturation bands
c) Spin dephasing due to pulsatile flow
4.11.10 Case 10: Significant
d) Flow compensation Signal-to-Noise Variation Across
the FOV, Creating Nondiagnostic
15. T2-weighted TSE sequences are more sensitive Image Quality
to flow voids than T1-weighted TSE because: 18. Another possible cause for signal loss in the
a) T2 values of blood are short following image is:
b) TE is higher, giving more time for flowing
protons to “escape” the imaging slice
c) The multitude of 180 refocusing pulses
associated with T2 TSE continually saturates
flow
d) T1 TSE sequences allow more complete
recovery of flow signal each TR period

4.11.9 Case 9: Postcontrast T1-


Weighted Gradient Echo Reveals
Patchy Enhancement in the
Anterior Septal Wall
16. STIR acquisitions are typically not used for
postcontrast imaging because:
a) Spectrally selective fat saturation is good
enough

87
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Magnetic Resonance Imaging

a) Cardiac motion and flow Glossary


b) Metal artifact
B0: main magnetic field strength
c) A long MR bore
TR: repetition time
d) Having too many coil elements activated
TE: time to echo
Ny: pixels in the phase (y) direction
19. One remedy for dielectric effect seen in the
Nx: pixels in the frequency (x) direction
following image is:
Nz: pixels in the slice (z) direction
NSA: number of signal averages
Δx: resolution (mm) in the frequency direction
Δy: resolution (mm) in the phase direction
Δz: resolution (or slice thickness) in the slice
direction
BWread: bandwidth in the frequency readout
direction
WFS: water–fat shift (in pixels)
FOV: field-of-view
Δf: relative frequency offset between two proton
types (e.g., fat and water)
Δχ: susceptibility difference between two tissues
g: geometric factor related to coil configuration
and placement
R: parallel imaging acceleration factor

a) Position the patient prone Suggested Reading


b) Omit T2 imaging from the protocol Bernstein MA. Signal acquisition and k-space
c) Reposition the receive coil sampling. In: Bernstein MA, 1st ed. Handbook of
d) Attempt the exam at lower field strength, MRI Pulse Sequences. Burlington, US: Elsevier
if possible Academic Press; 2004:367–442
Brown MA, Semelka RC. MRI: Basic Principles and
Application. 2nd ed. New York, NY: John Wiley &
Equations Sons, Inc; 1999
Brown RW, Cheng YC, Haacke EM, Thompson MR,
Scan time ¼ TR  Ny  Nz  NSA
Venkatesan R. Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Phys-
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi! ical Principles and Sequence Design. 2nd ed.
NSA  Nx  Ny  Nz Hoboken: Wiley; 2014:944
SNR / K ðΔx  Δy  ΔzÞ
BWread
Graves MJ, Mitchell DG. Body MRI artifacts in clin-
ical practice: a physicist’s and radiologist’s
FOV  Δf
WFS ¼ perspective. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2013; 38(2):
Nx  BW
269–287
Susceptibility artifact size e ðΔxÞ  TE  B0 =BWread Griswold MA, Jakob PM, Heidemann RM, et al.
Generalized autocalibrating partially parallel
1 acquisitions (GRAPPA). Magn Reson Med. 2002; 47
SNR e pffiffiffi
g R (6):1202–1210

88
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

4.11 Review Questions

Hargreaves BA, Worters PW, Pauly KB, Pauly JM, loading in the brains of patients with β-thalas-
Koch KM, Gold GE. Metal-induced artifacts in MRI. semia major. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2014; 35(6):
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2011; 197(3):547–555 1085–1090
Hamilton J, Franson D, Seiberlich N. Recent Reeder SB, Atalar E, Bolster BD, Jr, McVeigh ER.
advances in parallel imaging for MRI. Prog Nucl Quantification and reduction of ghosting artifacts
Magn Reson Spectrosc. 2017; 101:71–95 in interleaved echo-planar imaging. Magn Reson
Huang SY, Seethamraju RT, Patel P, Hahn PF, Kirsch Med. 1997; 38(3):429–439
JE, Guimaraes AR. Body MR imaging: artifacts, k- Simonetti OP, Kim RJ, Fieno DS, et al. An improved
space, and solutions. Radiographics. 2015; 35(5): MR imaging technique for the visualization of
1439–1460 myocardial infarction. Radiology. 2001; 218(1):
Lee VS. Cardiovascular MRI: Physical Principles to 215
Practical Protocols. Philadelphia: Lippincott Wang J, He L, Zheng H, Lu ZL. Optimizing the
Williams & Wilkins, 2006 magnetization-prepared rapid gradient-echo (MP-
Mugler JP, III. Optimized three-dimensional fast- RAGE) sequence. PLoS One. 2014; 9(5):e96899
spin-echo MRI. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2014; 39 Wheaton AJ, Miyazaki M. Non-contrast enhanced
(4):745–767 MR angiography: physical principles. J Magn Reson
Pruessmann KP, Weiger M, Scheidegger MB, Imaging. 2012; 36(2):286–304
Boesiger P. SENSE: sensitivity encoding for fast Zaitsev M, Maclaren J, Herbst M. Motion artifacts
MRI. Magn Reson Med. 1999; 42(5):952–962 in MRI: a complex problem with many partial
Qiu D, Chan GC, Chu J, et al. MR quantitative solutions. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2015; 42(4):
susceptibility imaging for the evaluation of iron 887–901

89
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5 Nuclear Medicine
Jonathon A. Nye, James R. Galt, and John N. Aarsvold

Introduction Common Image Quality


Nuclear medicine imaging comprises planar projec- Problems
tion and tomographic image acquisition techniques
● Patient motion: degrades spatial resolution due
to capture the distribution of radiolabeled
substances. Acquisitions includes single time point to object motion blurring.
imaging, gated and time-series imaging to map ● Improper attenuation correction: leads to
radiotracer biodistributions for evaluation of hypo- or hyperintense regions due to misalign-
normal/abnormal function. Data collection is a
ment between the transmission and emission
photon starved process, that is, the total number of
photons collected is substantially lower than any data in the reconstruction process.
other X-ray-based modality leading to images of ● High-Z materials: oral/intravenous contrast
high noise. Moreover, attenuation and scatter within and implanted metallic devices are opaque
the patient and detector coupled with an imperfect
to X-rays used in positron emission tomog-
photon detection process (detector energy resolu-
tion, collimation, and event processing) degrade the raphy/computed tomography (PET/CT)
image contrast and spatial resolution. Evaluation of systems to collect transmission data leading
these factors, and improvements when possible, is to artifacts that propagate to the emission
key to the pursuit of improved image quality. image.
Elements of good image quality in nuclear medicine
include absence of image distortion and a noise
● Truncation: tissue lying outside the camera field
distribution that is consistent with the expected of view (FOV) that is not incorporated properly
radiotracer uptake. into the reconstruction process.

90
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.1 Case 1

5.1 Case 1: Degraded 5.1.2 Findings


Resolution of a Whole-Body ● Counts are sufficient in each view (▶ Fig. 5.1).
Planar 99mTc Methylene ● A large visual difference in image resolution is

Diphosphonate Image observed between the anterior and posterior


planar images.
5.1.1 Background ● The anterior image is of unacceptable diagnostic
● Patient suspected of having neoplastic disease. quality.
● Delayed phase skeletal images obtained approxi-
5.1.3 Discussion
mately 2 hours post injection.
Review of the acquisition setup showed that the
● Anterior/posterior planar contiguous bone
anterior camera head was positioned further from
imaging protocol with low-energy high-
the patient than the posterior camera head. The
resolution (LEHR) collimators. consequence was a sharp degradation in image
● Counts from the first images starting at the head quality observed in the anterior camera due to the
totaled approximately 2.3 million. strong dependence of resolution on the collimator

Fig. 5.1 Anterior (left) and posterior


(right) whole-body 99mTc methylene
diphosphonate images.

91
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

distance from the source. The loss of resolution with


collimator distance is a linear relationship with
distance from the camera as shown in ▶ Fig. 5.2.
Although the distance has a large effect on
resolution, count rate is not strongly dependent

Source-to-collimator distance
on the source distance from the collimator. The
counts collected at a single point decrease by
1/(source-to-collimator distance)2; however, the
number of collimator holes that permit passage
of photons is proportional to (source-to-
collimator distance)2.1-3 Therefore, the total
number of counts, represented by the area under
the curves in ▶ Fig. 5.2 is essentially the same
at all source distances with a parallel-hole
collimator. This relationship applies to point, line,
and uniformly distributed sources.

5.1.4 Resolution
Proper placement of the gamma camera heads
relative to the patient is the responsibility of the
camera operator. There are no software correc-
tions to sharpen a blurred image, therefore the
operator should rescan the patient with the
Fig. 5.2 Resolution of a point source (e.g., point spread
gamma camera heads placed at the proper function) versus distance from the face of a parallel-
distances from the patient. A satisfactory bone hole collimator. The total counts are the same for all
scan is shown in ▶ Fig. 5.3 with the anterior distributions.
camera closer to the patient.

92
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.1 Case 1

Fig. 5.3 99mTc methylene diphospho-


nate anterior and posterior images
after adjustment of camera head
position.

93
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.2 Case 2: Effect of Positron parameters, the difference in image quality can
be attributed entirely to the position range effect
Range on Image Quality and (▶ Fig. 5.4). Note that some differences in image
Resolution contrast exist due to the biochemical processes
that govern the uptake and distribution of [82Rb]
5.2.1 Background CI and [18F]FDG.
▶ Fig. 5.5 details three main factors that affect
● A rubidium-82 (82Rb) chloride PET study is
image resolution in PET imaging: detector size,
performed to assess myocardial perfusion. noncollinearity of the annihilation photons and
● Following the resting exam, an fluorodeoxyglu- position range.4,5 Briefly, resolution is approxi-
cose ([18F]FDG) viability study is performed to mately proportional to half the detector size for
assess myocardial metabolism. annihilation events originating in the center of
the FOV and approximately equal to the detector
● Both studies are performed in the resting state
size at the periphery. Noncollinearity in the anni-
on the same scanner with the same reconstruc- hilation photons occurs because of a small
tion parameters. amount of residual momentum remaining at the
time of positron annihilation. Since the PET
system assumes collinear photons, the line along
5.2.2 Findings which the system assigned the coincidence event
● The resting [82Rb]CI and [18F]FDG viability is in error compared to the true annihilation loca-
studies are of excellent quality exhibited by the tion. This error in positioning increases with FOV
diameter. Lastly, the energy of positrons from
high contrast (> 2:1) between the myocardium
beta decay have a continuous spectrum from zero
and blood pool.
to a maximum energy. As a result of this energy
● There is a marked difference in resolution distribution, the range of a position in tissue can
between the [18F]FDG and [82Rb]CI images, be described by an exponential function. The
where the [82Rb]CI image appears to be blurred higher the maximum energy, the larger the posi-
relative to the [18F]FDG study. tron range and distance of the annihilation event
from the decay origin. This disparity between
location of the radiotracer and annihilation event
contributes to resolution loss independently of
5.2.3 Discussion the detector design. Rb-82 has maximum positron
A resting/viability protocol is a good example of energy of 3,400 keV compared to F-18 at 635 keV.
how positron range affects image quality. Therefore, all things the same, the resolution
Because both images were collected on the same achieved with Rb-82 will be inferior to that of F-
instrument using the same reconstruction 18-labeled compounds.

94
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.2 Case 2: Effect of Positron Range on Image Quality and Resolution

Fig. 5.4 Resting [82Rb]RbCl and [18F]FDG positron emission tomography images oriented along the short, vertical, and
horizontal axis.

95
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

Fig. 5.5 Illustration of resolution degrading factors is the positron emission tomography detection process.
The three main factors are noncollinearity of the annihilation photons, detector size, and position range.

5.2.4 Resolution algorithms now model the positron physics


(among other resolution degrading factors) in
The resolution difference between [82Rb]CI and the iterative reconstruction process, which can
[18F]FDG in this example is normal and attrib- compensate for some of this effect.
uted to positron range. Newer reconstruction

96
| 09.11.19 - 02:54

5.3 Case 3: Standardized Uptake Value in Positron Emission Tomography

5.3 Case 3: Standardized 5.3.2 Findings


Uptake Value in Positron ● Although the ROIs are drawn in the same
Emission Tomography location for each reconstruction, extracted

(Noise Bias) information differs.


● ▶ Fig. 5.6 reports the SUV mean and max
5.3.1 Background results.
● Three difference whole-body [18F]FDG PET
reconstructions are presented. 5.3.3 Discussion
● Regions of interest (ROIs) are drawn in the liver, The SUV is calculated by normalizing the activity
which is assumed to be uniform. concentration in the reconstructed image to the ratio
● Standardized uptake value (SUV) mean of the of the administered activity and body weight.6,7
h i
liver is a semiquantitative indicator of scanner Bq
image mL
calibration and may be checked periodically to SUV ¼
body weight ½g  administered activity ½Bq
ensure correct SUV calculation.
It has meaning similar to the pharmacological
● The three images are reconstructed with the
concept of distribution volume. That is, if the
same iterative algorithm but with bed times of
administered activity is uniformly distributed
30, 60, and 90 seconds. throughout the body, the SUV would be 1.0 g/mL

Fig. 5.6 A whole-body [18F]FDG coronal slices reconstructed with imaging durations of 30, 60, and 90 seconds per
bed position. The max and mean standardized update value are reported for a region of interest placed in the liver
(red circles).

97
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

everywhere. This concept is independent of the maintaining all other variables constant. As the
amount of FDG administered and is a method for scan duration per bed is reduced, the noise in the
removing variation between patients of [18F]FDG reconstructed images increases. Noise is a high-
distribution that are related to administered frequency component in the image; therefore,
amount and body weight. Assessment of the mean SUVmax will always increase when noise
SUV in a large uniform area, such as the liver, can increases. This can be thought of as a noise bias,
be a good marker for detecting potential imaging where the mean value is less sensitive. Although
problems. In uniform normal liver, the mean SUV the SUV mean is robust in the liver, it is less
has been shown to vary with camera manufacturer reproducible than SUV max in smaller features
but have an expected value ranging between 1.8 such as lesions.
and 2.3 g/mL.
Clinically, the maximum SUV, not the mean, is
5.3.4 Resolution
used in the reporting and staging of cancer with
[18F]FDG. SUVmax is the brightest (or highest) Image quality is largely subjective and based on
voxel in the ROI and has been shown to be a the preference of the interpreting radiologist or
better predictor of outcomes. A number of factors nuclear medicine physician. It is critical that the
affect the accuracy of SUV including presence of patient preparation and PET camera used to collect
body fat, patient diet/fasting, reconstruction data be kept the same for each scan in a patient's
parameters, scan duration, partial volume effects, cancer assessment. Therefore, any bias related to
and others. In this case, we illustrate the change the instrument hardware or reconstruction is
in SUV on scan duration by reducing the number largely kept constant throughout a patient’s initial
of counts used in each reconstruction while staging and clinical follow-up.

98
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.4 Case 4: The Impact of Attenuation Correction in PET

5.4 Case 4: The Impact of height of the liver in the attenuation-corrected


images and CT are the same suggesting that the
Attenuation Correction in PET attenuation correction was not accurate in that
interface region. This attenuation-related artifact
5.4.1 Background is common in whole-body [18F]FDG PET and is
● An [18F]FDG PET/CT image is collected as part of caused by a difference in temporal resolution
cancer staging. between the acquisition of the PET and CT data.8
The result is that the PET represents a time-aver-
● The overall image is unremarkable and consid-
aged position of all structures that move during
ered of good technical quality. the respiratory cycle while the CT captures a snap-
shot at a specific phase of the respiratory cycle.
This leads to a mismatch in position of structures
5.4.2 Findings
within the thoracic cavity, more easily observed
● A photopenic area is observed at the interface where the motion extent is the greatest, near the
between the lung and liver in the attenuation- lung and liver boundary.
Attenuation correction is the largest data correc-
corrected [18F]FDG PET (▶ Fig. 5.7a).
tion step in the image reconstruction process. For a
● The height of the liver in the PET scan does not
set of annihilation photons that originate at center of
match to that in the CT scan (▶ Fig. 5.7a–c). the body and travel to opposing detectors in the
● The nonattenuation-corrected (NAC) scan shows coronal plane of ▶ Fig. 5.4, the correction factor can
liver activity in areas that the attenuation- be as large as 18 × for a total of 30 cm tissue. If the
corrected scan does not, suggesting these photo- amount of tissue traversed by these photons were
underrepresented by 40%, such as the presence of
penic areas are not physiological (▶ Fig. 5.7d).
lung instead of liver tissues, then attenuation correc-
tion factor applied would be 5.5 or 3 times
lower. An undercorrection in attenuation of this
5.4.3 Discussion
magnitude will alter image contrast leading to
The photopenic area observed in ▶ Fig. 5.7a is not photopenic regions similar that described in
present in the NAC images in ▶ Fig. 5.4b. Also, the ▶ Fig. 5.7.

Fig. 5.7 (a) Attenuation corrected coronal [18F]FDG positron emission tomography (FDG PET) slices showing
a photopenic area at the interface between the liver and lungs. (b) Nonattenuation-corrected coronal slice
with no photopenic regions. (c) Corresponding coronal CT used for attenuation correction of (a). (d) Attenuation-
corrected coronal FDG PET using an average CT protocol that better accounts for the liver position in the PET
data.

99
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.4.4 Resolution practice. Attenuation-related artifacts also lead to


scatter correction problems because this also relies
Methods have been proposed to correct for the on an accurate CT. The common approach is to
motion of the diaphragm in attenuation correction “read around” the artifact but take caution if a
but these techniques usually add to the CT radia- lesion were present in the photopenic area.
tion dose and are not widely available in clinical

100
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.5 Case 5: Iterative Reconstruction and Choosing the Number of Iterations

5.5 Case 5: Iterative is repeated several times until the simulated


guess image best approximates the measured
Reconstruction and Choosing projection data. Each pass through the scan
the Number of Iterations simulation process and update of the guess is
called an iteration. Note that each iteration
and Subsets increases the resolution and contrast of the final
5.5.1 Background image but also the noise. The primary advantage
of iterative reconstruction is the ability to model
● A new single-photon emission computed tomog- aspects of the scanning process, such as attenua-
raphy (SPECT) system is being installed and this tion, scatter, collimation, and other features that
camera will perform, among other studies, 99mTc affect the image appearance. A disadvantage of
iterative reconstruction is the lengthy computa-
hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime (HMPAO)
tional time needed to run these simulations.
studies for assessment of cerebral blood flow. The iterative reconstruction process can be sped
● The imaging center has collected its first patient up by dividing the projection space into subsets,
and is evaluating the iterative reconstruction for example, simulation of 16 projections (1 of 8
parameters to determine suitable iterations subsets) out of a 128-projection acquisition.
Although only a few projections are simulated, the
and subsets.
scan simulation process occurs much faster and
the entire image is updated. The result is that the
5.5.2 Findings guess converges to the measure projection data
faster than simulation of the entire projection
● A series of image reconstructions were made space at once. Two iterations with six subsets
with varying iterations and subsets (▶ Fig. 5.8). result in roughly the same image contrast as six
● Attenuation correction was performed with the iterations with two subsets, and this is computa-
Chang method and mu-value of 0.125/cm. tionally faster (▶ Fig. 5.9).
● A Butterworth smoothing kernel was applied
with a power 10 and cutoff of 0.7 cycles/mm. 5.5.4 Resolution
Iterative reconstruction provides many advan-
tages such as modeling the physical properties of
5.5.3 Discussion the acquisition system that can lead to more
Iterative reconstruction begins with a guess accurate images.9 Each iteration drives the guess
image, typically a uniform image as not to bias image closer to convergence but at the cost of
the result, followed by a simulation of the scan- increasing noise. It is common to add a filter to
ning process. The scan simulation process control for the increase in noise. The most
includes a comparison in projection space of the appropriate clinical reconstruction will depend
guess data with the measured projection data. A on the physician preferences and the exercise
correction image is made from this comparison shown in ▶ Fig. 5.5a is commonly done to make
and used to update the guess image. This process those decisions.

101
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

Fig. 5.8 99mTc hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime images created by varying the number of iterations and subsets. Note
that the resulting contrast is similar when the iterations × subset product is the same (images along the diagonal). At
high iterations and subsets, the Butterworth filter dominates the image noise and contrast.

102
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.5 Case 5: Iterative Reconstruction and Choosing the Number of Iterations

Fig. 5.9 Illustration of an ordered subset iterative reconstruction process. The initial guess image is projected by the
scan simulation process. The simulated guess projections are then compared to the measured projections. A correction
image is created and used to update the guess. The process is repeated (an iteration) until the simulated scan
projections of the guess are a good approximation of the measured projections.

103
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.6 Case 6: The Effects of Image 5.6.3 Discussion


Smoothing All nuclear medicine imaging systems employ
image smoothing to improve contrast through
5.6.1 Background the reduction of statistical noise or to enhance
edges to detect boundaries. Filtering can be
● A myocardial perfusion imaging study was
performed in either the frequency domain,
performed with 99mTc sestamibi.
commonly integrated into the reconstruction
● The reconstructed transaxial images show a high process, or the spatial domain post reconstruc-
amount of noise than typically observed tion. An image can be described in terms of
(▶ Fig. 5.10). summation of different frequencies, where high-
frequency components contain edge information
5.6.2 Findings (e.g., air–tissue boundary) and low-frequency
components describe slow varying features
● The counts per projection and the number of within structures. The application of a filter
projection samples are consistent with either removes or modifies the frequency
published guidelines. components that are a part of an image, thereby
changing its appearance.
● Review of the reconstruction protocol shows
A common filter in general nuclear medicine is
that iterative reconstruction was performed with the Butterworth filter, applied in frequency space,
8 iterations and 10 subsets (▶ Fig. 5.11). used to remove high-frequency components but
● Images were not corrected for attenuation. preserve low-frequency components. Two parame-

Fig. 5.10 99mTc sestimibi myocardial perfusion images in the transaxial plane.

Fig. 5.11 A representative transaxial from a 99mTc sestamibi myocardial perfusion exam processed without filtration and
with Butterworth filters of 0.4/cm cutoff and power of 2, 5, and 20.

104
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.6 Case 6: The Effects of Image Smoothing

ters specify the filter behavior: the cutoff fre- 5.6.4 Resolution
quency and power. The maximum cutoff frequency
is 0.5 pixels/cycle (e.g., Nyquist criterion) and The addition of a Butterworth filter to remove high-
lowering the cutoff frequency will remove high- frequency components from the image substantially
frequency components improving low-contrast improves the image contrast. The trade-off is loss of
features. The power describes how fast the filter edge information and blurring of boundaries but, if
reaches the cutoff value and higher power not overdone, this is acceptable given the improve-
preserves more edge information.10 ment in low-contrast resolution.

105
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.7 Case 7: Choosing the 5.7.3 Discussion


Correct Acquisition Image A number of variables can cause degraded resolu-
tion of the reconstructed images including the
Matrix Size
choice of collimator, camera positioning relative to
5.7.1 Background the patient, and reconstruction parameters.1 For a
typical SPECT system, the expected resolution with
● Three-hour delayed 99mTc methylene diphospho- a LEHR collimator is approximately 6 to 8 mm at a
nate (MDP) SPECT data were acquired to better distance of 10 cm from the collimator surface. Of
evaluate location and extend of disease. critical importance is to appropriately sample the
● Single anterior-posterior projection and sagittal/ imaging space in order to utilize the capable reso-
transaxial SPECT are evaluated. lution of the camera. The planar projections used
to reconstruct a SPECT image consist of discrete
samples (pixels) covering the useful FOV. Choice of
5.7.2 Findings acquired projection matrix will affect the resolu-
● The images are of poorer diagnostic quality than tion of the downstream processes, such as SPECT
typical (▶ Fig. 5.12). reconstruction. The rule of thumb is to set the
sampling distance (pixel size) to one-third of the
● The administered activity and counts per projec-
camera resolution. For example, a camera with an
tion were normal.
extrinsic resolution of 8 mm and square FOV of
● The acquisition settings were: low-energy high- 350 × 350 mm should have 131 samples (pixels) in
resolution (LEHR) collimator, 180-degree orbit, each direction. SPECT instruments offer matrix
elliptical orbit, 120 stops of 20 second each, sizes scaled in powers of 2 (64, 128, 256, 1024)
64 × 64 acquired projection matrix. and choosing 128 × 128 would provide adequate
● The SPECT data was reconstructed with sampling in this example. It should be noted that
angular sampling must also be set correctly and
an ordered-subset expectation maximization
can be estimated from relationships given in the
(OSEM) algorithm with 6 iterations and references.
16 subsets that incorporates modeling of In ▶ Fig. 5.12, the FOV is 300 mm and a matrix size
the collimator resolution. to 64 × 64 is not enough pixels to satisfy the

Fig. 5.12 Anterior-posterior projection and single-photon emission computed tomography sagittal and transaxial slices
from a 99mTc methylene diphosphonate bone study.

106
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.7 Case 7: Choosing the Correct Acquisition Image Matrix Size

sampling rule. This undersampling in the projection 5.7.4 Resolution


space leads to loss of resolution observed in
▶ Fig. 5.13 when comparing the 64 and 128 matrix Increasing the matrix size of the planar projections
projections and SPECT reconstructions. Note that the from 64 × 64 to 128 × 128 fully utilizes the available
noise is increased in the 128 × 128 matrix as there system resolution resulting in improved spatial
are fewer counts per pixel for the same total counts. resolution and image quality. Applying a Butter-
Increasing the matrix size to 256 × 256 or higher worth filter with a high power may improve the
makes no improvements on the system’s ability to noise texture of data collected with the 128 × 128
resolve structures and further increases noise. matrix with limited loss is spatial resolution.

Fig. 5.13 Anterior-posterior projection and single-photon emission computed tomography slices in the sagittal and
transaxial plan from projection data acquired with a 64 × 64 matrix (top) and 128 × 128 matrix (bottom). Each acquisition
has the same total counts.

107
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.8 Case 8: Assessing Patient good technologist instructions or using light


restraints. The step-wise collection of projection
Motion in Myocardial Perfusion data provides another means to assess motion by
Imaging playing them back in a loop to view changes in
the heart’s position. Up and down shifts indicate
5.8.1 Background motion along the superior/inferior direction (e.g.,
table direction), whereas lateral/medial shifts are
● Myocardial perfusion imaging with 99mTc
more difficult to assess due the angular sampling
sestamibi. of the SPECT acquisition.
● The short axis images are of poor in quality Tools are available from several manufacturers
(▶ Fig. 5.14). to minimize patient motion artifacts. These tools
permit manual (or automatic) shifts of the
projection data. For example, in ▶ Fig. 5.15,
5.8.2 Findings shifting projections 17 and 23 approximately two
pixels would correctly align the heart with the
● There is some distortion in the short axis heart
neighboring projections. ▶ Fig. 5.16 shows the
size, particularly along the septal and inferior same data in ▶ Fig. 5.14 after the projection data
wall. was motion corrected for the superior/inferior
● Inspection of the planar images shows axial movement. Note the improved image quality and
motion in the table direction in some but not remediation of structural distortion compared to
the motion-corrupted reconstruction. A note of
all projections (▶ Fig. 5.15).
caution is that shifting projections can do more
harm than good and automated routines should
5.8.3 Discussion be reviewed for accuracy before sent to recon-
struction.
The lengthy imaging time of myocardial perfu-
sion SPECT makes this data acquisition process
particularly susceptible to patient motion.11 5.8.4 Resolution
Patient motion such as contractile cardiac, respi-
ratory action or movement on the table can Myocardial perfusion imaging performed with
degrade image resolution and introduce artifacts SPECT should be examined for possible motion
that often appear as structural distortions. corruption. This can be easily assessed by viewing
Cardiac and respiratory action can be addressed playback of the planar projection data for changes
using gating techniques but patient body motion in the heart position. Tools that correct for volun-
on the table cannot be addressed using these tary motion work well but should be reviewed for
tools. Patient motion can be minimized through accuracy if used in an automated state.

Fig. 5.14 Reoriented short axis slices of a 99mTc sestamibi myocardial perfusion study. Note the distortion in the superior
and septal walls.

108
| 09.11.19 - 02:56

5.8 Case 8: Assessing Patient Motion in Myocardial Perfusion Imaging

Fig. 5.15 A sample of planar projections used in the reconstruction of ▶ Fig. 5.8 (original panel). The red arrows show a
dip in the heart position indicating the patient moved down in the direction of the table. Following motion correction
(motion corrected panel), the heart is aligned in all projections.

Fig. 5.16 Reoriented reconstructed short axis slices of a 99mTc sestamibi myocardial perfusion study following motion
correction of the planar projections.

109
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.9 Case 9: Bremsstrahlung interactions in soft tissue as it slows down


resulting in a wide spectrum of photons with a
Imaging of 90Y Microspheres maximum energy of approximately 2.3 MeV. Since
Liver Embolization there is no distinct photopeak, as typical for
gamma camera imaging, placement of an energy
5.9.1 Background window is not trivial (▶ Fig. 5.17). The placement
and width of the imaging window have been
● A patient workup for intra-arterial resin micro-
suggested to be around 108 keV with a 35 keV
sphere radioembolization of a hepatic lesion. width when using a medium-energy collimator.
● They have received a 99mTc microaggregated Conventional energy discrimination is not possible
albumin (MAA) pretreatment planning scan. with a continuous photon spectrum; therefore, the
● Post radioembolization SPECT/CT data collection contribution of scatter is difficult to quantify in the
image. In addition, since the incident photons
of 90Y bremsstrahlung photons was performed.
range in energy well above 108 keV, there is
● Data are fused with contrast enhance MRI to considerable septal penetration and scatter within
confirm the distribution of trapped micro- the collimator as well as the camera housing that
spheres is in the tumor vasculature. further contribute to degraded image quality. With
all of these effects, it is still possible to obtain good
quality images of 90Y biodistribution post emboli-
5.9.2 Findings zation with SPECT as shown in ▶ Fig. 5.18. Further
● Setup of the 90Y SPECT camera includes use of a advancements in SPECT quantification have
medium-energy collimator. worked toward verifying the fraction of adminis-
tered activity in the liver but the physical
● There is no photopeak to window, as with 99mTc
complexity increases as corrections for both
imaging. A 35-keV energy window centered on attenuation and scatter in soft tissue depend on
108 keV was selected. photon energy.
● Data were collected with 128 × 128 matrix and
reconstructed with OSEM and no attenuation
5.9.4 Resolution
correction.
Imaging of bremsstrahlung photons can be
performed with good image quality but careful
5.9.3 Discussion consideration is needed when selecting an energy
90Yemits a high-energy beta particle (2.28 MeV window and collimator as these factors affect
maximum) that undergoes bremsstrahlung image quality.

Fig. 5.17 Photon energy spectrums from unshielded 99mTc (a) and 90Y (b). The photopeak energy at 72–88 keV is a Pb
characteristic X-ray from photoelectric interactions with the lead collimator.

110
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.9 Case 9: Bremsstrahlung Imaging of 90Y Microspheres Liver Emboliza

Fig. 5.18 99mTc microaggregated albumin (MAA) planning (middle panel) and 90Y bremsstrahlung (bottom panel) single-
photon emission computed tomography images fused with MR. Patient is a 71-year-old male. 4 mCi 99mTc MAA and
28.6 mCi 90 SIR-Sphere administrations.

111
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.10 Case 10: Degraded Image peaks: 171 keV, 245 keV) and medium-energy
collimators. LEHR collimators are most
Quality from an Improper commonly used with 99mTc-labeled radiophar-
Collimator maceuticals and are specifically designed to opti-
mize resolution and sensitivity of 140 keV
5.10.1 Background photons from 99mTc. Compared to Low energy
high resolution (LEHR), medium-energy collima-
● Patient screened for bone metastases with
tors typically have larger holes and thicker septa
known cancer. in order to maintain sensitivity and prevent
● 25 mCi of 99mTc MDP was administered. resolution degradation from septal penetration
● Whole-body planar imaging was performed when imaging with photon energies above
about 45 minute after MDP administration approximately 200 keV.
The consequence of using medium-energy
(▶ Fig. 5.19).
collimators with 99mTc is a loss of resolution due to
the larger collimator hole aperture as illustrated in
▶ Fig. 5.21. The wider angle of acceptance allows
5.10.2 Findings
more photons to reach the detector crystal from
● Images are of inferior quality compared to oblique angles. This leads to a degraded contrast
previous patient images (▶ Fig. 5.20). and spatial resolution for objects located at the
same distance compared to imaging with a LEHR
● The image resolution appears worse than typical,
collimator.
which is more evident in the posterior planar
view.
5.10.4 Resolution
Loss of resolution from this technical error
5.10.3 Discussion
cannot be resolved with post-processing. The
Review of the protocol and patient setup technologist should switch from medium-energy
revealed a technical error where the medium- collimators to low-energy collimators and
energy collimators were used during imaging. reimage the patient. A satisfactory bone scan
The technologist operating the camera had with the proper collimators is shown in
previously performed imaging with 111In (photo- ▶ Fig. 5.10.

Fig. 5.19 Repeat bone scan collected


for evaluation of bone metastases
(right). Prior bone scan on the same
camera from a different patient (left).
There is a degradation in image reso-
lution from left to right that is also
visible in the anterior view (not shown).

Fig. 5.20 Medium-energy collimators


(left) and a repeat scan with low-
energy high-resolution collimators
(right).

112
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.10 Case 10: Degraded Image Quality from an Improper Collimator

Fig. 5.21 Illustration of the effect of


resolution for a medium- and low-
energy collimator for a source at the
same distance from the collimator. The
measure of point spread function of a
point source at the same distance is
wider for the medium-energy colli-
mator compared to the low-energy
collimator. Widening of the point
spread function results in degraded
resolution and contrast.

113
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.11 Review Questions c) Detector size


d) Depth of interaction
5.11.1 Case 1: Degraded
Resolution of a Whole-Body Planar 5.11.3 Case 3: Standardized Uptake
99mTc Methylene Diphosphonate
Value in Positron Emission
Image Tomography (Resolution and Noise)
1. A quality control source of Technetium-99 m
5. Calculate the standardized update value
(99mTc) yielding 1200 cps is placed 10 cm from
for patient weighing 80 kg who is administered
the face of a gamma camera with a parallel-
10 mCi of [18F]FDG with a decay corrected
hole collimator. If the source is move to 20 cm
measured lesion concentration of 300 nCi/mL.
from the face of the gamma camera, what is
a) 2.4
the expected count rate?
b) 3.2
a) 1800 cps
c) 4.1
b) 1200 cps
d) 5.3
c) 800 cps
d) 600 cps
6. The mean liver SUV from an [18F]FDG oncology
2. The parallel-hole collimator having 1 cm length PET/CT study was measured to be 1.6. It was
holes is replaced with another parallel-hole later discovered that the patient weight was
collimator of 1.5 cm length holes of the same incorrectly documented during the exam as 180
septal thickness. This change will result in a lb and should have been recorded as 230 lb.
reduction of what performance characteristic? What is the mean liver SUV with this revised
a) Sensitivity weight?
b) Resolution a) 1.6
c) Magnification b) 1.8
d) Energy resolution c) 2.0
d) 2.2

5.11.2 Case 2: Effect of Positron


Range on Image Quality and 5.11.4 Case 4: The Impact of
Resolution Attenuation Correction in PET
3. The system response function, including all 7. Including attenuation correction, which other
resolution-degrading factors of detector size, data correction process in PET relies on accu-
noncollinearity, and positron range, is meas- rate measurement of the attenuation map?
ured by imaging what type of object? a) Normalization
a) Point source b) Scatter
b) Rotating rod source c) Randoms
c) Large uniform phantom d) Well-counter calibration
d) An anthropomorphic phantom
8. What is the primary interaction process of
4. Which resolution-degrading aspect of the PET 511 keV annihilation photons in the body?
image does not depend on the instrument’s a) Coherent scattering
construction? b) Compton scattering
a) Noncollinearity c) Photoelectric absorption
b) Positron range d) Pair production

114
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

5.11 Review Questions

5.11.5 Case 5: Iterative 5.11.7 Case 7: Choosing the


Reconstruction and Choosing the Correct Acquisition Image
Number of Iterations and Subsets Matrix Size
9. Which reconstruction approach is not based 13. What is the pixel size of a planar gamma
on an iterative algorithm? acquisition with a 25-cm FOV collected with a
a) Maximum likelihood expectation 128 × 128 pixel matrix?
maximization a) 1.20 mm
b) Conjugate gradient minimization b) 1.95 mm
c) Algebraic reconstruction technique c) 2.32 mm
d) Filtered backprojection d) 3.21 mm

10. What is an advantage of using filtered backpro- 14. When switching from a 64 × 64 to a 128 × 128
jection over iterative reconstruction routines? matrix, how many more counts are need
a) Increased speed to maintain the same noise properties
b) Reduced noise (× = times)?
c) Improved spatial resolution a) 1 ×
d) Resolution modeling b) 2 ×
c) 3 ×
5.11.6 Case 6: The Effects of d) 4 ×

Image Smoothing
5.11.8 Case 8: Assessing Patient
11. Which image filtering type is commonly
applied in the image space domain after
Motion in Myocardial Perfusion
reconstruction?
Imaging
a) Gaussian 15. When projection data are organized into a
b) Butterworth sinogram, patient motion along the table direc-
c) Shepp–Logan tion leads to as what appearance in the sinus-
d) Ramp oidal information?
a) Area of high counts
12. Increasing the Butterworth cutoff frequency b) Data discontinuities
toward the Nyquist limit changes which c) Complete loss of data
characteristic of image quality? d) No change can be observed
a) Reduces noise
b) Improves low contrast 16. How does patient motion change image
c) Increases resolution resolution?
d) Introduces aliasing a) Degrades
b) No change
c) Improves

115
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Nuclear Medicine

5.11.9 Case 9: Bremsstrahlung References


Imaging of 90Y Microspheres Liver [1] Naddaf SY, Collier BD, Elgazzar AH, Khalil MM. Technical er-

Embolization rors in planar bone scanning. J Nucl Med Technol. 2004; 32


(3):148–153
[2] Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps ME. The gamma camera: basic
17. What photon interaction process produces the
principles. In: Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps ME, eds. Physics
Pb characteristic X-rays commonly observed in in Nuclear Medicine 4th ed. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders;
a gamma camera energy spectrum? 2012:195–208
[3] Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps ME. The gamma camera: per-
a) Photoelectric formance characteristics. In: Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps
b) Compton ME, eds. Physics in Nuclear Medicine. 4th ed. Philadelphia,
PA: W.B. Saunders; 2012:209–31
c) Coherent [4] Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps ME. Positron emission tomog-
d) Pair production raphy. In: Cherry SR, Sorenson JA, Phelps ME, eds. Physics in
Nuclear Medicine. 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders;
2012:307–43
18. What is a common energy window width used [5] Votaw JR. The AAPM/RSNA physics tutorial for residents.
in 99mTc radiopharmaceutical imaging? Physics of PET. Radiographics. 1995; 15(5):1179–1190
[6] Kinahan PE, Fletcher JW. Positron emission tomography-
a) 10–15% computed tomography standardized uptake values in clinical
b) 15–20% practice and assessing response to therapy. Semin Ultrasound
CT MR. 2010; 31(6):496–505
c) 20–25%
[7] Thie JA. Understanding the standardized uptake value, its
d) 25–30% methods, and implications for usage. J Nucl Med. 2004; 45
(9):1431–1434
[8] Blodgett TM, Mehta AS, Mehta AS, Laymon CM, Carney J,
5.11.10 Case 10 Degraded Image Townsend DW. PET/CT artifacts. Clin Imaging. 2011; 35(1):
49–63
Quality from an Improper [9] Tong S, Alessio AM, Kinahan PE. Image reconstruction for
Collimator PET/CT scanners: past achievements and future challenges.
Imaging Med. 2010; 2(5):529–545
19. What collimator is appropriate for performing [10] Galt JR, Hise HL, Garcia EV, Nowak DJ. Filtering in frequency
space. J Nucl Med Technol. 1986; 14(3):152–160
a planar gallium-67 (Ga-67) citrate study? [11] Burrell S, MacDonald A. Artifacts and pitfalls in myocardial
(Ga-67 has a photopeak at 93 keV (37%), 187 perfusion imaging. J Nucl Med Technol. 2006; 34(4):193–
211, quiz 212–214
keV (20.4%), and 300 keV (16.6%)).
a) Low-energy high-resolution
b) Low-energy general-purpose
c) Medium-energy
d) High-energy

20. Increasing the collimator hole length has what


effect on image quality?
a) Reduction in noise
b) Improved resolution
c) Increased sensitivity
d) Decreased scatter rejection

116
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6 Ultrasound Imaging
Zheng Feng Lu

Introduction Common Image Quality


An ultrasound image is formed using sound. Ultra- Problems
sound has been widely used because it is portable,
● Speed of sound propagation: it affects spatial
low cost, and does not involve ionizing radiation;
thus, it is safe even for scanning a fetus. B-mode resolution and the accuracy of the distance
ultrasound image formation is based upon three measurements.
basic assumptions:1 ● Frequency: it affects spatial resolution and the
1. The sound travels in a straight and narrow maximum depth of penetration.
line called an acoustic beam. A transducer is ● Array transducer dropouts: the deficiency most
used both as a pulse emitter and as an echo commonly found during routine quality control
receiver. The transducer emits a short pulse (QC) testing.
and then receives echo signals which are ● Presets in image protocols: optimize the image
generated by the emitted pulse propagating acquisition controls and maintain the consis-
and interacting with tissue within the tency by managing the “presets” in image
acoustic beam. protocols.
2. The speed of the sound propagation is assumed ● Acoustic window: it affects the coupling of the
to be constant at 1,540 m/s, an average speed transducer and patient body. A poor acoustic
for soft tissues. Therefore, on the image, the window prevents the sound from being trans-
sources for echo signals are localized by the mitted to the region of interest.
so-called range equation: ● Reverberation artifacts such as comet-tail and
ct ring-down can provide diagnostic information.

2 ● Range ambiguity occurs when the pulse repeti-
Where t is the time delay between the pulse tion frequency (PRF) is too high with the result
emission and the echo reception, c represents that echoes from the prior beam line are mispo-
the speed of sound (i.e., 1,540 m/s is assumed sitioned in the current beam line.
for soft tissue), and D is the depth of the echo ● Enhancement and shadowing can provide
where it is generated. The time delay t includes
diagnostic information.
both the time it takes for the pulse to travel
down to the reflector and the time it takes for ● Harmonic imaging is advantageous over conven-
the echo to return. Therefore, it accounts for the tional B-mode imaging in generating superior
factor of 2. image quality, especially in the case of a “techni-
3. The received echo signals are amplified to cally difficult” patient with a thick body wall.
compensate for the attenuation. The strength ● The performance evaluation of the ultrasound
of the echo signals is represented by varying scanner display and the reading room worksta-
brightness levels on a B-mode image. tion displays is crucial in maintaining consis-
tency of image perception.
Ultrasound images are formed using the ideal-
● Doppler aliasing occurs when the PRF is too low,
ized model described above. Ultrasound artifacts
occur when any or all of the assumptions are a control that is linked to the PRF. To reduce
violated. aliasing, one should increase the velocity scale.

117
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.1 Case 1: Pulse-Echo Imaging The misestimated speed of sound propagation


affects the image quality as demonstrated by the
Principle and Speed of Sound group of pins in ▶ Fig. 6.2.
Propagation
6.1.1 Background 6.1.3 Discussion
Size measurement is a routine clinical application The speed of sound propagation is dependent
in ultrasound imaging. The range equation is upon the tissue properties such as density and
implicitly built into pulse-echo imaging instru- compressibility. For any particular material, the
ments to localize the received echo signals. If the higher its density and the harder it is to
sound propagation speed in the body tissue is compress, the faster its sound speed will be. For
indeed 1540 m/s, the measured size will be accu- example, the sound speed is faster in bone than
rate. However, if the sound propagation speed is that in soft tissue because bone is more dense
less than 1540 m/s, then the longer delay in echo and harder to compress than soft tissue.
return time is interpreted by longer distance; in ▶ Table 6.1 shows the typical speed of sound
this case the distance in the axial direction is over- propagation in a variety of materials. In diag-
estimated. On the other hand, if the speed is nostic ultrasound, a sound speed of 1,540 m/s is
greater than 1540 m/s, then the distance in the assumed. This value represents the average speed
axial direction is underestimated. of sound propagation in soft tissues. Any devia-
The misestimated sound propagation speed not tion from the assumed speed causes errors in size
only affects the distance measurement, but also measurements, known as speed artifacts. As the
contributes to the reduction of the spatial resolu- acoustic beam focusing relies on the assumption
tion; thus, it worsens the image quality. of the sound speed, image quality is affected by
any deviation in the actual sound speed and the
assumed sound speed by the ultrasound system
6.1.2 Findings in setting up the beam former. As demonstrated
In the following clinical case, the discontinuity seen in ▶ Fig. 6.2, the beam focuses the best when the
in the diaphragm pointed by the arrow in ▶ Fig. 6.1a assumed sound speed matches the actual sound
is caused by the different sound speed in the lesion. speed at 1460 m/s.
The sound speed reduces in a fatty lesion. Therefore,
the portion of the diaphragm (pointed by the arrow)
below the lesion is shown in a deeper position in the
6.1.4 Resolution
image. In another clinical case shown in ▶ Fig. 6.1b, It is important to recognize potential speed
an irregular liver/diaphragm interface is seen in the artifacts by examining the acoustic pathway
image caused by heterogeneous liver parenchyma and identifying regions that are suspected
with fatty infiltration. to have different values for sound speed. Typically,

Fig. 6.1 Speed artifacts shown as the discontinuity at the liver/diaphragm interface (pointed by the arrow) caused by a
lesion (a). An irregular liver/diaphragm interface shown in the image caused by heterogeneous liver parenchyma with
fatty infiltration (b).

118
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.1 Case 1: Pulse-Echo Imaging Principle and Speed of Sound Propagation

Fig. 6.2 (a–d) A set of images of a group of pins in a urethane phantom under different settings of speed of sound
propagation. The actual speed of sound in urethane is 1,450 m/s as per manufacturer’s specification. The spatial
resolution is at its best when the speed is set at 1,460 m/s that is the closest to the actual speed in urethane material.

Table 6.1 Sound propagation speed in selected materials with 1,540 m/s as the average speed for soft tissue2
Media Lung Fat Water Liver Blood Kidney Muscle Skull bone
Speed 600 1,460 1,498 at 1,555 1,560 1,565 1,600 4,080
(m/s) 25 °C

nothing is done to correct for speed artifacts.


However, some modern ultrasound systems allow-
manual adjustment to correct for deviations in the
speed of sound in order to improve image quality. As
demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 6.2, the actual speed of sound
of the urethane-based phantom is approximately 6%
lower than 1,540 m/s.3 When the machine-assumed
speed of sound does not match the actual speed of
sound in the urethane-based phantom, the lateral
resolution deteriorates. This feature has been used
Fig. 6.3 A breast image with the speed of sound
for breast imaging. As shown in ▶ Fig. 6.3, the image
propagation set at 1,500 m/s to match the actual
quality is improved by an adjustment from the
speed of sound in breast tissue to improve image
typical sound speed, i.e., 1,540 m/s to the actual quality.
sound speed in breast tissue at 1,500 m/s.

119
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.2 Case 2: Array Transducers Linear Array


and Sound Frequency ● A subgroup of elements is fired to form one

6.2.1 Background acoustic beam perpendicular to the face of the


array.
Sound frequency is the number of oscillations per
● Subgroups of elements are fired sequentially to
unit time, determined by the source—ultrasound
transducer. For human ears, the audible sound fre- form parallel acoustic beams to scan across a
quency ranges from 20 Hz to 20 kHz. Sound with region of interest (ROI).
frequencies above 20 kHz is called ultrasound. The ● Rectangular shape of the image format.
higher the frequency, the better the spatial resolu- ● Clinical applications include small parts, vascular,
tion in ultrasound images. On the other hand, the
and obstetric exams (▶ Fig. 6.4a).
lower the frequency, the deeper the ultrasound
penetrates because the ultrasound attenuation is
proportional to frequency. In medical ultrasound Curvilinear or Curved Array
imaging, the frequency typically ranges from 2 to 15
● Same as linear arrays except that the elements
MHz with low frequency used for imaging deep
targets but with compromised spatial resolution, are aligned in a curve instead of a straight line.
and high frequency used for imaging superficial ● Each acoustic beam is perpendicular to the face of
targets with better spatial resolution. High frequen- the array. Since the array of elements is curved, the
cies, around 50 MHz or even higher, are used for acoustic beams diverge with depth which allows
certain specialized imaging applications, such as in
for a broader coverage as the depth increases.
ophthalmology or in small animal imaging, with
superb spatial resolution.
● Clinical applications include general abdominal,
An ultrasound system typically has multiple obstetric, and transabdominal pelvic exams. In
transducers of various frequencies, each trans- addition, transvaginal and transrectal probes are
ducer having a different contact surface size (foot- curved arrays (▶ Fig. 6.4b).
print) designed for specific clinical applications.
Modern ultrasound systems often allow the oper-
ator to choose the frequency within a range on the
Phased Array
same transducer, which allows for adjustment ● All the elements are fired to form one acoustic
between penetration and spatial resolution.
beam.
● The acoustic beam is electronically steered
6.2.2 Findings across the ROI.
Different types of array transducers and their corre- ● The footprint is typically very small to allow for
sponding image examples are shown in ▶ Fig. 6.4. a small acoustic window (e.g., between the ribs)

Fig. 6.4 Various types of array transducers and their corresponding image examples. (a) An image example of a linear
array transducer. (b) An image example of a curvilinear array transducer. (c) An image example of a phased array
transducer.

120
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.2 Case 2: Array Transducers and Sound Frequency

but the sector image format allows for a broad 6.2.4 Resolution
field of view.
It is possible to improve penetration at high fre-
● Clinical applications include intercostal scanning
quency with advanced technology such as coded
for heart, liver, or spleen (▶ Fig. 6.4c). excitation technology. This technology plants a
code in the transmitted pulses. In return, the
received echo signals are carrying the same code;
6.2.3 Discussion thus, raising the ability to differentiate between
On modern ultrasound systems, frequency can be echo signals and noises. Through appropriate
selected within a certain range on the same trans- coding on transmitted pulses and decoding on
ducer. While making the frequency selection, one received echo signals, one can improve the signal-
must consider the fundamental trade-off between to-noise ratio and can, therefore, mitigate the
spatial resolution and penetration, and strike an trade-off between better spatial resolution, which
optimal balance between these two factors is associated with higher frequency, and less
(▶ Fig. 6.5). penetration, also associated with higher frequency.

Fig. 6.5 A phantom is scanned by


the same transducer with different
frequency selections.

121
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.3 Case 3: Nonuniformity the wires inside the cable and cause element
dropouts. Handling transducers with care is crit-
(Array Transducer Element ical to ensuring the longevity of these array
Dropouts) transducers.

6.3.1 Background
6.3.2 Findings
An ultrasound array transducer contains an array
(or arrays) of composite ceramic piezoelectric Sometimes the nonuniformities are minor,
elements connected by wires enclosed in a cable appearing as streaks along the axial direction
that runs to the ultrasound system via a of the transducer, whereas some are more
connector. An ultrasound transducer is vulner- prominent. ▶ Fig. 6.7 shows the images generated
able to damage because it is handled frequently by the same transducer. Nonuniformities can be
during ultrasound imaging operation and may seen on the clinical image and the phantom image,
easily be dropped or bumped against hard as well as on the in-air scan image.
surfaces, or its cable may be rolled underneath
the scanner wheels during transportation for
6.3.3 Discussion
portable studies. An ultrasound transducer is
prone to image nonuniformity problems due to Image nonuniformity is considered the most
any of the following defects: (1) failed crystal commonly found deficiency during routine QC
elements; (2) delamination of the lens/coupling testing.4 As shown in the example in ▶ Fig. 6.8, the
layers on the transducer face; (3) broken wires transducer cable was accidentally rolled under-
in the transducer cable; and (4) disruptions in neath the scanner wheel and five wires in the
the connector. A picture of transducers with cable were broken causing minor dark streaks near
tangled cables connected to an ultrasound the face of the transducer. The broken wires were
system is shown in ▶ Fig. 6.6a. Transducers are detected by an electronic transducer testing
often hung on walls, as shown in ▶ Fig. 6.6b, c. device.5 The nonuniformity was much less perceiv-
Too much stress on a transducer cable may tear able on clinical images.

Fig. 6.6 Ultrasound transducers are handled frequently during ultrasound imaging operation. Education on careful
handling of the transducers can reduce transducer failure rate. (a) Transducers should be hung properly on the system
to avoid tangles or being trapped under the wheels of the system. (b) While it is neat to hang up transducers, too much
stress on transducer cable may tear the wires inside the cable and cause element dropouts. (c) Various transducer
hanging boxes such as this one are designed to handle transducers with care by minimizing the stress on transducer
probe, its connector and cable.

122
| 09.11.19 - 02:58

6.3 Case 3: Nonuniformity (Array Transducer Element Dropouts)

Fig. 6.7 (a–c) Nonuniformities are seen in the images of this transducer (pointed by arrows) on a patient, a phantom,
and just in-air.

Fig. 6.8 Both images were obtained by the same transducer. (a) The streaks observed near the face of the transducer in
the phantom image are hard to see in the (b) clinical image.

6.3.4 Resolution before clinical applications are impacted. The image


uniformity test is a required QC test by American
It is important to perform periodic QC testing using College of Radiology (ACR) Ultrasound Accredita-
an ultrasound QC phantom to detect the presence tion Program for all transducers used for clinical
of any nonuniformities as early as possible in order applications.6
to monitor the condition and address the problem

123
| 09.11.19 - 02:58

Ultrasound Imaging

6.4 Case 4: Pulse-Echo Imaging 6.4.3 Discussion


Acquisition Controls Four ultrasound pulse-echo imaging acquisition
parameters are explained below.
6.4.1 Background ● Transmit power: This determines the amplitude
The pulse-echo imaging controls on an ultrasound of the pulse emitted from the transducer. Higher
system affect both image data acquisition and transmit power will yield stronger returned
image display. The proper setting of these controls
echoes, thus deeper penetration depth as demon-
is crucial for optimizing the image performance to
strated in ▶ Fig. 6.9. This control affects the acoustic
fulfill the clinical task.
dosimetry that is typically indicated by the
mechanical index (MI) and the thermal index (TI).
6.4.2 Findings ● Gain (overall gain): This amplifies the echo signals
We will discuss the following four main controls: of all depths. It is often used to adjust the overall
● Transmit power (▶ Fig. 6.9) image brightness. Unlike transmit power control,
● Overall gain (▶ Fig. 6.10 and ▶ Fig. 6.11) this control does not affect the penetration depth,
● Time gain compensation (TGC) (▶ Fig. 6.12) as demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 6.10 and ▶ Fig. 6.11.
● Dynamic range (▶ Fig. 6.13) Neither does it affect the acoustic dosimetry.

Fig. 6.9 The ultrasound phantom images were acquired under identical instrumentation settings except the transmit
power setting at maximum in (a), − 6 dB in (b) and − 12 dB in (c). As the transmit power reduces, the image becomes
dimmer and with less penetration.

Fig. 6.10 The ultrasound phantom images were acquired under identical instrumentation settings except the overall
gain setting at 100% in (a), 70% in (b), and 60% in (c). As the overall gain reduces, the image becomes dimmer but the
penetration remains the same.

124
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.4 Case 4: Pulse-Echo Imaging Acquisition Controls

Fig. 6.11 The ultrasound phantom images were acquired under identical instrumentation settings except that the
overall gain setting is increased by 5 dB at each increment from 30 dB at the upper left panel to 70 dB at the lower
right panel.

Fig. 6.12 The two ultrasound


phantom images were acquired under
identical instrumentation settings
except that the time gain compensa-
tion (TGC) setting is set at the center
position in the upper panel and one of
the TGC knobs was set at its minimum
position in the lower panel.

125
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

Fig. 6.13 (a) The ultrasound images were acquired under identical instrumentation settings except the dynamic range
setting at 36 dB, (b) 60 dB, and (c) 96 dB. As the dynamic range increases, the image becomes smoother but with less
contrast.

● TGC: Due to ultrasound attenuation, echoes dynamic range indicates the range from the
returning to the transducer get weaker from the smallest to the largest echo signals to which the
distance traveled. The longer distance it travels, system can properly respond. It is described in
the weaker the echo signal becomes. Amplifica- decibels. A smaller dynamic range setting
tion in the receiver, called TGC, is needed to offset means a steeper gradient that provides more
the loss due to attenuation as the depth increases. contrast on the image display, increasing the
By increasing amplification along with the depth, conspicuity of a low-contrast lesion. However,
TGC offers a more uniform display of the bright- the image will appear coarse. Conversely, a
ness level throughout the field of view (FOV). TGC larger dynamic range setting has a lower
can be altered by a group of sliding knobs, each of contrast gradient, but the image will appear
which amplifies the echo signals from a specific smoother. This is demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 6.13.
depth range. The TGC knobs are calibrated in such
a way that when all the knobs are aligned in the 6.4.4 Resolution
center position, the image of an organ, for
The ultrasound image acquisition controls,
example, a liver, appears with uniform brightness discussed here, are user adjustable. Typically,
at all depths as demonstrated in ▶ Fig. 6.12. optimization of these controls is conducted
● Dynamic range: In ultrasound imaging, echo through “presets” on the system protocol and
signals are logarithmically compressed and may vary per transducer and per body part, even
for an ultrasound system of the same vendor and
transformed by decibel notation, defined as
same model. Therefore, understanding and
10 times the log10 of the ratio of echo signal
managing these controls helps maintain the
intensity compared to reference intensity. The consistency of the imaging performance.

126
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.5 Case 5: Reflection (Boundary Conditions)—Reverberation Artifacts

6.5 Case 5: Reflection result in multiple reflections back and forth


between the two interfaces. The first received
(Boundary Conditions)— echo will appear at the proper depth on the
Reverberation Artifacts image, but the subsequent echo signals received
from the multiple reflections between the two
6.5.1 Background interfaces will appear at deeper depths; the extra
time delays caused by multiple reflections are
A sound beam is reflected when it is incident on an
interpreted by the system as representing longer
interface formed by two tissues of different acoustic
distances traveled by the sound. These additional
impedance. The magnitude of the reflection
echo signals appear equally spaced on the image
depends on the acoustic impedance difference at
but with decreasing intensity, as each reflection
the interface. The smaller the acoustic impedance
is weaker than the prior.
difference, the less the reflected beam energy, and
Comet-tail artifact as shown in ▶ Fig. 6.15 is a
the better the transmission of the sound beam will
special subtype of reverberation artifact which
be. Acoustic impedance is a property of the tissue
occurs when the two highly reflective interfaces
that equals to the product of tissue density and the
are too close to each other to be resolvable on the
sound propagation speed. Therefore, the acoustic
image. As implied by its name, comet-tail artifact
impedance of soft tissue is very different from the
looks like a comet tail with a tapering echogenic
acoustic impedance of bone or gas. A good acoustic
triangle-shaped tail. It often appears in response to
window is a body location that allows minimal
a highly reflective object such as cholesterol crys-
sound reflection and optimal sound transmission,
tals in adenomyomatosis of the gallbladder or a
for example, region with no bone or gas to compro-
bullet fragment.
mise sound transmission.
Ring-down artifact as shown in ▶ Fig. 6.16 is
often included as another special subtype of rever-
6.5.2 Findings beration artifacts. Although it may resemble a
comet-tail artifact, the ring-down artifact is
Ultrasound imaging assumes that an echo returns
different. Caused by resonant vibrations within the
to the transducer after a single reflection. Rever-
center of a cluster of air bubbles, a ring-down arti-
beration artifacts occur when this assumption
fact appears as a long solid streak or series of steaks
fails, as shown in ▶ Fig. 6.14.
along the sound propagation axis. In a 1985 publica-
tion,7 Avruch et al demonstrated that ring-down
never occurred with only one layer of air bubbles.
6.5.3 Discussion
Rather, it only resonated from a fluid center trapped
When two highly reflective interfaces run within a cluster or tetrahedron of air bubbles: three
parallel in the beam propagation path, it may air bubbles on top and one air bubble nestled
beneath.

Fig. 6.14 Reverberation artifacts occur due to parallel Fig. 6.15 Breast imaging with surgical clips showing
reflective interfaces in the body wall. comet-tail artifacts.

127
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.5.4 Resolution
The reverberation artifacts are easy to identify, as
shown in ▶ Fig. 6.14, ▶ Fig. 6.15, and ▶ Fig. 6.16.
Typically, nothing is done about it. Sometimes, a
different acoustic window is chosen to avoid severe
reverberation artifacts. Comet-tail artifacts are clini-
cally useful because small objects, such as surgical
clips, can be identified through the occurrence of
comet-tail artifacts, as shown in ▶ Fig. 6.15. Ring-
down artifact can be useful in providing diagnostic
information, for example, in case of emphysematous
Fig. 6.16 Ring-down artifact caused by air bubbles in
(gas-forming) infections and abscesses that often
the bowel.
produce ring-down artifacts.

128
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.6 Case 6: Range Ambiguity in B-Mode

6.6 Case 6: Range Ambiguity in the above mentioned assumption fails. This is
called the range ambiguity artifact.
B-Mode
6.6.1 Background 6.6.3 Discussion
The conventional B-mode image is formed by If an echo from a distant structure is received after
ultrasound beam line, one after another. For each the next pulse is transmitted, i.e., beyond the PRP,
ultrasound beam line, a very short ultrasound the time delay will be counted from the second
pulse (< 1 μs) is emitted from the transducer and pulse emission instead of the first pulse emission.
then echo signals are received along the beam Consequently, the distance will be mispositioned
line. The next pulse will not be emitted until after to be closer to the transducer than it actually is.
the echo signal from the deepest range of the Any scanner parameter setting that shortens the
FOV from the prior line is received. The time time interval between pulse emissions, for
between successive individual pulse emissions is example, setting up multiple focal zones, is
called the pulse repetition period (PRP). As a susceptible to range ambiguity artifacts.
result, the deeper the range of the FOV, the
longer the PRP is needed.
6.6.4 Resolution
The name “range ambiguity” refers to uncertainties
6.6.2 Findings in the actual range from where the echo signal
Pulse-echo image formation assumes that occurs. When it occurs, it is likely visible in large
returning echo signals are all generated by the fluid-filled structure, misleading to mimic debris in
latest pulse emission. As shown in ▶ Fig. 6.17, a the structure. Range ambiguity artifact can be mini-
horizontal line formed by reflection echoes from mized by allowing more time for echoes from deeper
the bottom of the phantom is mispositioned when structures to arrive before firing the next pulse.

Fig. 6.17 Range ambiguity artifact


is shown in this phantom image
(pointed by the arrow). The horizontal
line formed by reflection echoes from
the bottom of the phantom is mispo-
sitioned. This occurred when the
reflection echo from the bottom of the
phantom was received after the next
pulse was transmitted; and was thus
counted as echo for the next beam
line.

129
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.7 Case 7: Shadowing and 6.7.3 Discussion


Enhancement (Increased Reduced echo intensity appears as “shadowing”
distal to a highly attenuating or reflective object
Through Transmission) such as a tumor (▶ Fig. 6.18). On the other hand,
6.7.1 Background increased echo intensity appears as “enhance-
ment” distal to an object with lower attenuation
As an ultrasound wave propagates through tissue, such as a fluid-filled gallbladder (▶ Fig. 6.19).
its intensity is reduced over distance due to
absorption, scattering, and reflection. The ultra-
sound attenuation coefficient is given in decibels 6.7.4 Resolution
per centimeter (dB/cm). Shadowing and enhancement are considered
useful image artifacts because these artifacts
indicate the attenuation properties of the object
6.7.2 Findings that causes the occurrence of shadowing or en-
hancement. For example, enhancement is often
Ultrasound attenuation coefficient is an important
used to differentiate cystic structures from solid
characteristic property of a material. For example,
structures and shadowing is used to detect
a fatty infiltrated liver tissue has a higher attenua-
stones, calcified objects, and air. One must be
tion coefficient than a healthy liver tissue. For a careful that spatial compounding, an advanced
focal lesion with higher attenuation coefficient in imaging feature, may affect the appearance of
comparison to that of its surrounding tissue, shad- shadowing or enhancement. When spatial
owing occurs (▶ Fig. 6.18). Otherwise, enhance- compounding is activated, each ultrasound beam
ment occurs (▶ Fig. 6.19). is steered into different angles and multiple

Fig. 6.18 Shadowing is shown behind


the breast mass due to higher attenu-
ation in the mass in comparison
to the surrounding tissue.

Fig. 6.19 Enhancement (increased


through transmission) is shown behind
the gallbladder due to lower attenu-
ation in the gallbladder in comparison
to the surrounding tissue.

130
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.7 Case 7: Shadowing and Enhancement (Increased Through Transmission)

steered frames are rendered to create an image image protocol, its effect on shadowing and en-
with less speckle and better signal-to-noise hancement needs to be understood, especially
ratio. However, as the spatial compounding when the object in question is small. For
steers the ultrasound beam, the shadowing or example, to see the shadowing associated with a
enhancement diverges and loses its intensity, kidney stone, the operator should deactivate the
thus becoming less noticeable. Since spatial spatial compounding feature.
compounding is typically activated in the preset

131
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.8 Case 8: Harmonic Imaging fundamental, or in this case, 7 MHz. When a trans-
ducer transmits a burst of ultrasound at a funda-
6.8.1 Background mental frequency, the sound wave gradually distorts
as it propagates due to the fact that the compres-
Harmonic imaging was originally developed on the
sional part of the wave travels slightly faster than
basis of nonlinear properties of sound propagation
the rarefactional part. Consequently, this distortion
in ultrasound contrast agents. Later, it was revealed
is accompanied by the generation of harmonics that
that the nonlinear effect was also present in tissues.
can be used to form images. This process is called
Tissue harmonic imaging (THI) was developed based
harmonic imaging.
upon the nonlinear effect present in tissue.8
The benefits of using the harmonic imaging
include improved contrast resolution, reduced
6.8.2 Findings
clutter, improved spatial resolution, and reduced
Harmonic imaging is superior in image quality. A section thickness.8 As shown in ▶ Fig. 6.20, THI has
comparison of harmonic image and conventional superior border and tissue definition with reduced
B-mode image is shown in ▶ Fig. 6.20. speckles.

6.8.3 Discussion 6.8.4 Resolution


The term “harmonic” refers to those frequencies that Many ultrasound imaging protocols have
are integral multiples of the transmitted frequency. “harmonic imaging” in the preset as the default
The transmitted frequency is called the fundamental imaging mode instead of conventional B-mode.
frequency or the first harmonic frequency. For This is particularly helpful in imaging “technically
example, for a 3.5-MHz transmitted pulse, its funda- challenging” patients who have thick body walls
mental frequency, or the first harmonic frequency, is or other complicated structures that give rise to
3.5 MHz. Its second harmonic frequency is twice the artifacts and clutters.

Fig. 6.20 (a) A comparison of a liver


image acquired in B-mode (left) and
the same patient scanned in tissue
harmonic imaging mode (THI; right) is
shown. Superior image quality is
demonstrated with THI. (b) This panel
shows a comparison of a phantom
image acquired in B-mode (left) and
the same phantom scanned in THI
(right). Mirror artifact (pointed by
arrows) is more prominent in the
B-mode image.

132
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.9 Case 9: Ultrasound Image Display on Scanners and in Reading Rooms

6.9 Case 9: Ultrasound Image scanner monitor display and the reading room
workstation monitor display must be verified.
Display on Scanners and in
Reading Rooms 6.9.2 Findings
6.9.1 Background Matching the presentation on the ultrasound
scanner display and the reading room worksta-
For diagnostic ultrasound imaging, the display
tion displays can be challenging as shown in
characteristics must be optimal in order to convey
▶ Fig. 6.21.
all details and features of ultrasound images to the
human interpretter. In practice, if the operator of
the ultrasound scanner cannot visualize a path- 6.9.3 Discussion
ology on the scanner display, then the image
When a brand new ultrasound scanner is
cannot be properly acquired, and thus will not be
installed, image presentation consistency
sent to the picture archiving and communication
between the scanner monitor display and the
system (PACS) and interpreted on reading room
reading room workstation monitor display must
displays. Therefore, an ultrasound scanner display be verified. The ultrasound system, of which the
belongs to the category of diagnostic displays, just images are shown in ▶ Fig. 6.21, may have many
like the reading room displays. Ultrasound scanner different curves to export ultrasound images
display performance testing is required by the ACR from the scanner to PACS. The pixel values of the
Ultrasound Accreditation Program.6 In addition, image can be altered in order to match the ultra-
consistency in image presentation between the sound image presentation on the PACS display.

Fig. 6.21 For an ultrasound scanner, the setting of the system configuration can export the same ultrasound image to
reading room in multiple different ways, resulting different appearances on reading room workstation display as shown
here. LUT, look-up-table.

133
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

The limitation of this approach is that it is tail- 6.9.4 Resolution


ored to a specific characteristic display during
the matching process but not generalizable to Standardized display systems are needed to map
other displays with different characteristic the presentation values to monitor luminance
curves. regardless of the display monitor or vendor soft-
What makes establishing presentation consis- ware. Such a standardized display system, called
tency between the scanner display and the PACS the grayscale standard display function (GSDF),9
display even more challenging is the fact that some has already been developed by the digital
ultrasound manufacturers have created special imaging and communication (DICOM). As long as
display look-up-tables (LUT) on their scanner both the ultrasound scanner monitor and the
display devices to enhance the ultrasound images. reading room monitor follow GSDF and all the
Such image enhancement cannot be replicated image enhancement is done in the presentation
downstream on the PACS display because it is only values, there is a good chance of preserving
available on the scanner display. presentation consistency.

134
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.10 Case 10: Doppler Ultrasound Aliasing

6.10 Case 10: Doppler 6.10.2 Findings


Ultrasound Aliasing Doppler aliasing in spectral Doppler is shown in
▶ Fig. 6.23. The aliasing is manifested as "wraps
6.10.1 Background around" from the bottom to the top in spectrum.
The capability to quickly image and quantify blood Similarly, aliasing can also occur in color
flow is unique to diagnostic ultrasound imaging. Doppler, showing the reversed color at the peak
The physics principle is straightforward. When- flow speed as if the flow direction is reversed
ever there is a relative motion between a sound (see ▶ Fig. 6.24).
source and a listener, the frequency received by
the listener is shifted from the frequency emitted
6.10.3 Discussion
by the source. The perceived frequency shift is
called the Doppler shift. We experience the The Doppler shift is detected based upon “sampled”
Doppler shift in routine life. For example, the horn echo signals. Each time a pulse is emitted and echo
of a train is shifted to a higher pitch when the train signals are collected along the beam line, the echo
is approaching the platform and shifted to a lower signals are sampled for Doppler shift analysis. There-
pitch when the train is leaving the platform. Math- fore, the sampling rate of a pulsed Doppler instru-
ematically, the Doppler shift fD, the difference mentation is equal to the pulse repetition frequency
between the received sound frequency fr and the (PRF). The greater the PRF, the better the rendition
emitted sound frequency fo, is expressed as of the Doppler shift signals will be. If the PRF is less
following for a blood flow (▶ Fig. 6.22) with than twice the frequency of the maximum Doppler
Doppler angle : signal frequency, then aliasing will occur. The condi-
tion of two times the maximum Doppler shift is
2vcosðÞf 0
fD ¼fr  fo ≅ known as the Nyquist criteria. On a pulsed Doppler
c instrument, the PRF needs to be more than or equal
The Doppler angle  is the angle between the to the Nyquist criteria frequency to prevent aliasing
sound beam and the flow direction. The Doppler from happening.
angle affects the detected Doppler shift. When
the Doppler angle is at 90 degrees, no Doppler
shift can be detected. The rule of thumb in clin-
6.10.4 Resolution
ical applications is to keep the Doppler angle To eliminate aliasing, the operator can take the
below 60 degrees. following steps:

Fig. 6.22 Illustration of detecting the


Doppler shift from a flow with a flow
velocity of V, sound speed c, emitting
frequency f0 and receiving frequency fr.

135
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

Fig. 6.23 Aliasing on a spectral Doppler display and aliasing elimination steps.

136
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.10 Case 10: Doppler Ultrasound Aliasing

Fig. 6.24 Aliasing on a color Doppler


display. The color at the peak speed of
the flow is changed from blue to yellow
as if the flow direction is reversed
(arrow).

● Adjust the scale. The PRF is linked to the scale ● If none of the above steps are successful, increase
setting. As the scale increases, the PRF increases. the Doppler angle. Increasing the Doppler angle
● Adjust the baseline if the scale has reached its will lower the Doppler shift, thus lowering the
maximum and the flow is mainly in a single Nyquist criteria. However, raising the Doppler
direction. angle increases the uncertainty in the accuracy
● If neither of the above two steps are effective in of Doppler shift measurement and is thus not
eliminating aliasing, lower the transducer desirable.
frequency. Lowering the transducer frequency
Having a proper Doppler scale is crucial for good
will lower the Doppler shift, thus lowering the practices using Doppler ultrasound.
Nyquist criteria as well.

137
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.11 Review Questions a) Linear array


b) Curved array
6.11.1 Case 1: Pulse-Echo Imaging c) Phased array
Principle and Speed of Sound d) Mechanical sector
Propagation
4. With identical instrumentation settings except
1. If the liver speed of sound is slower than
the frequency selection by the same trans-
1,540 m/s, the size measured by the calipers in
ducer, which image was generated at the
the following image would:
highest frequency?
a) Panel A

a) Be overestimated
b) Be underestimated
c) Be the same

b) Panel B
2. The speed of the sound propagation is
largely determined by which of the following
factor?
a) The transducer frequency
b) The transmission power
c) The medium stiffness
d) The medium attenuation

6.11.2 Case 2: Array Transducers


and Sound Frequency
3. What transducer was used for the
c) Panel C
following image?

138
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.11 Review Questions

d) Panel D 6. What QC test should be done to investigate the


cause of the dark streak in the following image
if the streak at the same transducer face loca-
tion appears on many clinical images?

6.11.3 Case 3: Nonuniformity


(Array Transducer Element
Dropouts)
a) Maximum depth of penetration
5. The hypoechoic streak indicated by the arrow b) Distance accuracy
in the following image is most likely caused c) Image uniformity
by? d) Low contrast detectability

6.11.4 Case 4: Pulse-Echo Imaging


Acquisition Controls
7. What acquisition control should be increased if
more depth of penetration is needed?
a) Transducer frequency
b) Dynamic range
c) Overall gain
d) Transmit power

8. What acquisition control should be adjusted if


a horizontal band of darkness is seen?
a) Improper gain setting a) TGC
b) Compound imaging b) Dynamic range
c) Dead transducer elements c) Overall gain
d) Inappropriate transducer pressure d) Transmit power

139
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

6.11.5 Case 5: Reflection c) Reduce transmit power


d) Reduce transducer frequency
(Boundary Conditions)—
Reverberation Artifacts
6.11.7 Case 7: Shadowing and
9. What is the name of the artifact indicated by
Enhancement (Increased Through
the following image?
Transmission)
13. What is the name of the artifact indicated by
the arrow in the following image?

a) Enhancement
b) Comet tail
c) Beam width
d) Range ambiguity

10. What is the cause for the artifact indicated by


the arrow the image from the previous
question? a) Shadowing
a) Multiple refractions b) Comet-tail
b) Multiple reflections c) Beam width
c) Beam steering d) Ring-down
d) Beam diverging
14. How is the attenuation of the thyroid nodule
compared with the attenuation of the
6.11.6 Case 6: Range Ambiguity in
B-Mode
11. Which of the following is most likely to occur
when pulse repetition period is too short and
an echo signal from the prior beam line is
mispositioned in the current beam line?
a) Speed artifact
b) Aliasing
c) Mirror artifact
d) Range ambiguity
surrounding tissue in the following image?
a) The nodule is more attenuating
12. What can be done to minimize range
b) The nodule is less attenuating
ambiguity artifacts?
c) the same
a) Reduce overall gain
b) Reduce number of focal zones

140
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

6.11 Review Questions

6.11.8 Case 8: Harmonic Imaging b) Scanner display performance


c) Primary interpretation display performance
15. Which of the following is a benefit using the
d) Contrast resolution
THI instead of conventional B-mode imaging?
a) Improved depth of penetration
b) Reduced clutter
6.11.10 Case 10: Doppler
c) Increased temporal resolution Ultrasound Aliasing
d) Reduced sound frequency 19. What is of the artifact indicated by the arrow in
the following image?
16. Which ultrasound imaging technology
was effective to improve image quality and
reduce artifact in abdominal ultrasound
imaging of a patient with a very thick body
wall?
a) Spatial compounding
b) Ultrafast imaging
c) Harmonic imaging
d) Coded excitation

6.11.9 Case 9: Ultrasound Image


Display on Scanners and in
Reading Rooms
a) Aliasing
17. Advantages of enabling the GSDF on ultrasound b) Spectral broadening
scanner display include all of the following c) Twinkle
except: d) Flash
a) Image enhancement performed by the ultra-
sound scanner display 20. What can be done to minimize aliasing?
b) No custom matching needed on the reading a) Reduce wall filter
room workstation displays b) Reduce gain
c) Presentation consistency among various c) Increase scale
displays in the imaging chain d) Increase frequency
d) More streamlined performance evaluation
and quality control
References
18. Which of the following is a required QC test by [1] Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound instrumentation.
Essentials of Ultrasound Physics. St. Louis: Mosby,
the ACR Ultrasound Accreditation Program? 1996:46–47
a) Distance accuracy

141
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Ultrasound Imaging

[2] Zagzebski JA. Physics of diagnostic ultrasound. Essentials of org/~/media/ACRAccreditation/Documents/Ultrasound/


Ultrasound Physics. St. Louis: Mosby, 1996:6 Requirements.pdf?la=en (accessed 12/26/2018)
[3] Dudley NJ, Gibson NM, Fleckney MJ, Clark PD. The effect of [7] Avruch L, Cooperberg PL. The ring-down artifact. J Ultrasound
speed of sound in ultrasound test objects on lateral resolu- Med. 1985; 4(1):21–28
tion. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2002; 28(11–12):1561–1564 [8] Anvari A, Forsberg F, Samir AE. A primer on the physical prin-
[4] Hangiandreou NJ, Stekel SF, Tradup DJ, Gorny KR, King DM. ciples of tissue harmonic imaging. Radiographics. 2015; 35
Four-year experience with a clinical ultrasound quality con- (7):1955–1964
trol program. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2011; 37(8):1350–1357 [9] DICOM PS3. 14 2018e – Grayscale Standard Display Function,
[5] Powis RL, Moore GW. The silent revolution: catching up with NEMA. http://dicom.nema.org/medical/dicom/current/out-
the contemporary composite transducer. J Diagn Med Sonogr. put/html/part14.html (accessed 12/31/2018)
2004; 20:395–405
[6] American College of Radiology (ACR). Ultrasound accredita-
tion program requirements: http://www.acraccreditation.

142
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

7 Image Processing
Jonathon A. Nye and Randahl C. Palmer

Introduction interpretation. In addition, the combination of infor-


mation from two or more modalities can increase
Image processing and display are critical components both sensitivity and specificity compared to a single
in the imaging workflow chain. They have tremen- exam. This chapter presents basic image processing
dous diagnostic utility for disease detectability and concepts that are used in medical imaging.

143
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Image Processing

7.1 Case 1: Filtering and Edge a new image. A common kernel is a Gaussian
function, which is a low-pass operation that
Enhancement reduces noise (e.g., quantum mottle) and
improves visibility of low-contrast features.
7.1.1 Background High-contrast features can be enhanced by
Presentation of an anteroposterior (AP) chest adding negative lobes to the kernel. This process
radiograph. improves high-contrast resolution but also
increases noise since both of these features are
high-frequency components of an image. Kernels
7.1.2 Findings are normalized to preserve the scale of the orig-
● Presentation of post image filtering by convolu- inal image. The convolution process is described
tion with kernels designed to extract features of in ▶ Fig. 7.11 where discrete kernel values are
multiplied by the pixel values that fall under-
different frequencies.
neath the function and the sum of these products
● Kernels are commonly used to lower noise or is placed in a new image. The kernel is then
enhance edge information. shifted and the process is repeated. ▶ Fig. 7.2
demonstrates the change in contrast of a chest
radiograph following Gaussian smoothing and
7.1.3 Discussion Gaussian–Laplacian edge enhancement.
Filtering is one of the most basic imaging proc-
essing steps to enhance image contrast. It can be
applied either in frequency space through use of
7.1.4 Resolution
the Fourier transform or in image space through Convolution using kernels designed to lower
use of the convolution process.1 In image space, noise or enhance edge information alters
filtering involves construction of a kernel that is contrast and can improve the detectability of
moved across the image. All pixels within the anatomical features such as soft-tissue masses or
kernel are averaged and that average is placed in bone fractures.

Fig. 7.1 1D example of a convolution of an edge (open circles) with a Gaussian kernel. Data are rounded to the nearest
whole number for easier display. The plot shows the original data including the same information following a Gaussian
smoothing operation (solid line) and a hybrid Gaussian–Laplacian edge enhancement operation (dashed line).

144
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

7.1 Case 1: Filtering and Edge Enhancement

Fig. 7.2 (a) Chest X-ray without application of a postprocessing convolution filter. (b) Convolved with a 10-pixel full-
width-at-half-maximum Gaussian filter. (c) Convolved with a 10-pixel full-width-at-half-maximum Gaussian–Laplacian
edge-enhancement filter.

145
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Image Processing

7.2 Case 2: Maximum Intensity viewing plane (▶ Fig. 7.4). The volume can be
oriented in any direction or rotated incremen-
Projection tally after each ray tracing to produce many 2D
projections that can be played back as a movie.
7.2.1 Background The MIP process gives the perception of looking
● Whole-body [18F] fluorodeoxyglucose ([18F] through a volume as opposed to the conven-
FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) of a tional methods of paging through slices. It is
used extensively in nuclear medicine tomog-
patient with extensive disease.
raphy (e.g., PET/SPECT) to quickly identify hot
● The image volume is processed with a ray- spots in a large 3D volume. Two hot areas of
tracing technique called maximum intensity interest that lie along the same ray path can
projection (MIP), to highlight hyper-metabolic mask one another, therefore rotating the volume
activity throughout the volume (▶ Fig. 7.3). can reveal these superimposed areas.

7.2.2 Findings 7.2.4 Resolution


● Compared to a standard coronal slice, the MIP MIP is a simple yet powerful visual rendering
image permits visualization at depth within a 3D method that gives information about an entire 3D
volume on a 2D display. volume without the need to scroll through slices.
● The MIP volume can be rotated to improve visu- The method is completely automated, commonly
displayed in the coronal orientation, and may be
alization of hot lesions that lie along the same
oriented in any direction. More sophisticated
ray path but in different planes. implementations can be performed where pixels
along the visualization vector are weighted by or
limited to a certain depth within the 3D volume.
7.2.3 Discussion
This process is used, in combination with other
MIP is a simple but powerful processing tool processing techniques, to construct synthetic 2D
used to visualize a 3D volumetric dataset. The mammograms from breast tomosynthesis data.
most straightforward implementation of the Other common uses of MIP include visualization of
method involves using a ray-tracing technique vascular structures in computed tomography
that projects the maximum pixel value along angiography and magnetic resonance (MR) time-
parallel paths within a 3D volume on to a 2D of-flight.2,3,4

Fig. 7.3 (a) Coronal slice of a [18F] FDG


whole-body PET/CT showing extensive
disease. (b) Maximum intensity
projection processed volume in the
coronal orientation along the anterior-
posterior direction. Note the visual-
ization of lesions at deeper slices that
are out of plane in (a).

146
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

7.2 Case 2: Maximum Intensity Projection

Fig. 7.4 (a) Illustration of the


maximum intensity projection (MIP)
process of ray tracing a 3D volume to
create a 2D MIP image. (b) A ray path
through pixels finds the maximum
value and displays that value on the
workstation.

147
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Image Processing

7.3 Case 3: Fused Image Display ● Data fusion allows for better identification of
anatomical boundaries of disease and visual
of Multiple Modalities
correlation with changes in metabolism.
7.3.1 Background
● Independently collected MR and PET images 7.3.3 Discussion
were acquired, registered, and displayed as a Display fusion, or color blending, of two or more
single image (▶ Fig. 7.5). images is a widely employed technique for
displaying and interpreting functional imaging
● The T2-weighted fluid-attenuation inversion
data.5,6 Commonly, the underlying image is a
recovery (FLAIR) MRI, presented in grayscale,
structural modality (e.g., MRI, CT) displayed in
provides structural details that can be visually grayscale and the overlying image is a functional
correlated with functional metabolic informa- modality (e.g., PET, SPECT, MRS) displayed in a
tion provided by the [18F] FDG brain PET false color scale. The fusion process is commonly
image. called alpha blending, where images are
converted to a 24-bit color image (e.g., red,
green, and blue channels) and a transparency
7.3.2 Findings value (alpha) is assigned to the blended image.
Monitors shipped with common desktop
● Limited or poor anatomical detail in PET can be computers are 24-bit, having 3 channels each
augmented by coregistering and fusing these with 256 shades of color. The displayed image is
data with a high-resolution anatomical image. then a combination of two color scales, grayscale

Fig. 7.5 An example of the alpha blending technique using an magnetic resonance image in grayscale and positron
emission tomography image in rainbow color.

148
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

7.3 Case 3: Fused Image Display of Multiple Modalities

and false color, that gives the perception of More sophisticated blending techniques are avail-
transparency depending on the choice of the able that can preserve certain features, for
alpha value. example, thresholding the PET image to display
only standardized uptake values above a prede-
fined value. Image fusion has enabled hybrid
7.3.4 Resolution
imaging to grow into a powerful diagnostic tool
The example in ▶ Fig. 7.5 demonstrates the alpha increasing both sensitivity and specificity of inter-
blending image fusion technique using a linear pretation compared to viewing one of the two
combination of display scales from two images. modalities alone.7

149
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Image Processing

7.4 Case 4: Multimodality ● Spatial coregistration can be accomplished using


automated routines based on similarity metrics
Image Registration
including entropy and mutual information.
7.4.1 Background
● [18F] FDG and T2-weighted FLAIR brain images 7.4.3 Background
were acquired in a patient with epilepsy. Patient data collected from different scanners can
● Images were collected on different instruments, be coregistered to correlate voxel intensities of
therefore there is a need to spatially align them function (e.g., PET, SPECT) with areas of
to the same reference orientation. morphology (CT, MRI). For imaging data collected
on stand-alone systems (nonhybrid), a software
solution is needed. There are a large number of
7.4.2 Findings coregistration similarity metrics for determining
whether two images are aligned well. Two
● Fused display of the images show misalignment
common approaches include use of external
because these data were acquired on stand- surface landmarks and correlation of voxel inten-
alone systems (▶ Fig. 7.6a). sity but these methods are either cumbersome to

Fig. 7.6 Examples of misregistered (a, c) and registered (b, d) images of positron emission tomography with magnetic
resonance imaging (a, b) and computed tomography (c, d). The second column are the joint histograms of pixel
intensities between the respective images. The third column lists the calculated joint entropy and mutual information of
the images in their orientation as displayed in the first column. Note that lower joint entropy and higher mutual
information indicate better spatial alignment.

150
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

7.4 Case 4: Multimodality Image Registration

implement or present difficulties when voxels of by maximizing a similarity measure. Similarity


two different modalities are weakly correlated, measures based on entropy have prevailed, as they
respectively. A popular similarity metric for inter- are highly reliable when aligning two images from
modality image registration is the one based on different modalities.
entropy.8,9 Entropy is a measure of dispersion in
the probability distribution. The probably distribu-
tion between two images can be represented by References
plotting a 2D histogram. The joint histogram [1] Brody WR. In: Bankman IN, ed. Handbook of Medical Image
counts how many times a grayscale value corre- Processing and Analysis. 2nd ed. Burlington: Academic Press;
spondence occurs; the brighter the pixel in the 2009
[2] Prokop M, Shin HO, Schanz A, Schaefer-Prokop CM. Use of
joint histogram, the larger the correspondence fre-
maximum intensity projections in CT angiography: a basic
quency. Entropy can be thought of as a measure of review. Radiographics. 1997; 17(2):433–451
the histogram dispersion. Minimizing the disper- [3] Saloner D. The AAPM/RSNA physics tutorial for residents. An
sion of the joint histogram occurs when the joint introduction to MR angiography. Radiographics. 1995; 15(2):
453–465
entropy between two image modalities is mini-
[4] Hofman MS, Hicks RJ. How we read oncologic FDG PET/CT.
mized. A common implementation of entropy is Cancer Imaging. 2016; 16(1):35
maximization of mutual information (MI) given as [5] Bican J, Janeba D, Táborská K, Veselý J. Image overlay using
alpha-blending technique. Nucl Med Rev Cent East Eur. 2002;
Entropy ðMRIÞ þ Entropy ðPETÞ − Entropy ðMRI þ PETÞ 5(1):53
MI is the most commonly used similarity metric [6] Watson CC, Townsend DW, Bendriem B. PET/CT systems. In:
and is considered highly robust and reliable. Wernick MN, Aarsvold JN, eds. Emission Tomography. San
Diego: Academic Press; 2004:195–212
▶ Fig. 7.6 demonstrates the differences in sensi-
[7] Hany TF, Steinert HC, Goerres GW, Buck A, von Schulthess
tivity between entropy and MI when comparing GK. PET diagnostic accuracy: improvement with in-line PET-
misregistered and registered PET images with CT system: initial results. Radiology. 2002; 225(2):575–581
either CT or MRI. [8] Viergever MA, Maintz JBA, Klein S, Murphy K, Staring M,
Pluim JPW. A survey of medical image registration—under
review. Med Image Anal. 2016; 33:140–144
[9] Oliveira FP, Tavares JM. Medical image registration: a review.
7.4.4 Resolution Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin. 2014; 17(2):73–93
Image registration is an optimization problem
where the goal is to match corresponding features

151
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Answer Key
Chapter 1 Fluoroscopy Chapter 3 Computed
1. a Tomography
2. b 1. a
3. e 2. b
4. c 3. a
5. b 4. a
6. a 5. d
7. d 6. b
8. a 7. c
9. a 8. d
10. b
9. b
11. a
10. a
12. c
11. a
13. b
12. b
14. c
13. b
15. c
14. b
16. b
15. a
17. b
16. a
18. a
17. d
19. d
18. a
20. c
19. c
20. b
Chapter 2 Mammography
1. a Chapter 4 Magnetic Resonance
2. b
Imaging
3. c
4. b 1. b
5. b 2. c
6. b 3. b
7. b 4. b
Due to the limited angle scan, depth resolu- 5. b
tion in digital tomosynthesis is much lower 6. a
than the in-plane resolution. 7. c
8. c 8. c
9. d 9. d
10. b 10. c
11. b 11. a
12. b 12. a
13. e 13. b
14. e 14. c
15. b 15. b
16. d 16. c
17. b 17. d
18. d 18. b
19. c 19. d
20. d
21. c
22. b

152
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Answer Key

Chapter 5 Nuclear Medicine [Zagzebski JA. Physics of diagnostic ultra-


sound. Essentials of Ultrasound Physics. St.
1. b Louis: Mosby; 1996:26-27]
2. a 5. c
3. a The nonuniformity near surface is typically
4. b due to dead transducer elements.
5. a [ACR technical standard for diagnostic
6. c medical physics performance monitoring of
real time ultrasound equipment, Revised
7. b
2016]
8. b
6. c
9. d
Image uniformity is an effective phantom
10. a
test for revealing transducer element drop-
11. a
outs.
12. c
[Hangiandreou NJ, Stekel SF, Tradup DJ,
13. b
Gorny KR, King DM. Four-year experience
14. d
with a clinical ultrasound quality control
15. b
program. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2011; 37
16. a
(8):1350-1357]
17. a
7. d
18. b
Only the increase of the transmit power
19. c
will increase the depth of penetration. The
20. b
increase of the dynamic range or the
overall gain will not affect the maximum
Chapter 6 Ultrasound Imaging depth of penetration. Increasing the trans-
ducer frequency will reduce penetration.
1. a [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
If the true speed of sound propagation is instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
slower than 1,540 m/s, it takes longer time Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]
to travel; thus the distance will be overesti- 8. a
mated. The horizontal band of darkness may be
[Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound caused by insufficient amplification at the
instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound specific depth and can be adjusted by
Physics. St. Louis: Mosby, 1996:46-47] sliding the TGC knob that controls the
2. c amplification at the corresponding depth.
The speed of sound is dependent on the [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
properties of the medium such as its instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
density and compressibility. Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]
[Zagzebski JA. Physics of diagnostic ultra- 9. b
sound. Essentials of Ultrasound Physics. St. [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
Louis: Mosby, 1996:6] instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
3. b Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]
Curved array produces acoustic beams 10. b
diverging as the depth increases and its [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
transducer surface has a wide footprint. instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
[Zagzebski JA. Physics of diagnostic ultra- Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]
sound. Essentials of Ultrasound Physics. St. 11. d
Louis: Mosby; 1996:34-3] [Hangiandreou NJ, O'Brien RT, Zagzebski JA,
4. a Delaney FA. Ultrasound corner: range
This image has the lowest depth of penetra- ambiguity artifact. Vet Radiol Ultrasound.
tion due to high attenuation at high fre- 2001; 42(6):542-545]
quency. 12. b

153
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Answer Key

[Hangiandreou NJ, O'Brien RT, Zagzebski JA, 17. a


Delaney FA. Ultrasound corner: range [On-Line Report No AAPM. 03, Assessment
ambiguity artifact. Vet Radiol Ultrasound. of Display Performance for Medical Imaging
2001; 42(6):542-545] Systems, American Association of Physicists
13. a in Medicine, 2005. https://www.aapm.org/
[Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound pubs/reports/OR_03.pdf (accessed on 12/
instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound 31/2018)]
Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996] 18. b
14. b [American College of Radiology (ACR).
[Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound Ultrasound accreditation program require-
instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound ments: http://www.acraccreditation.org/
Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996] ~/media/ACRAccreditation/Documents/
15. b Ultrasound/Requirements.pdf?la=en
[Anvari A, Forsberg F, Samir AE. A primer (accessed 12/26/2018)]
on the physical principles of tissue 19. a
harmonic imaging. Radiographics. 2015; 35 [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
(7):1955-1964] instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
16. c Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]
[Anvari A, Forsberg F, Samir AE. A primer 20. c
on the physical principles of tissue [Zagzebski JA. Pulse-echo ultrasound
harmonic imaging. Radiographics. 2015; 35 instrumentation. Essentials of Ultrasound
(7):1955-1964] Physics. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996]

154
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Index
A
abnormal dark fluid seen in bladder of an – displayed volume CT dose index CT fluoroscopy
axial single-Shot T2-weighted sequence –– background 51 – background 12
– background 76 –– discussion 51 – discussion 12
– discussion 76 –– findings 51 – findings 12
– findings 76 –– resolution 51 – resolution 12
– resolution 78 – image quality variation with recon-
antiscatter grids structed slice thickness
– background 8 –– background 47 D
– discussion 8 –– discussion 47
–– findings 47 dark etching appears at boundary of fat
– findings 8
–– resolution 47 and soft-tissue layers
– resolution 9
– image quality variation with recon- – background 69
array transducers and sound frequency
struction filter – discussion 69
– background 120
–– background 49 – findings 69
– discussion 121
–– discussion 49 – resolution 69
– findings 120
–– findings 49 degraded image quality from improper
artifact due to detector row dropout
–– resolution 49 collimator
– background 35
– kV selection on image quality and dose, – background 112
– discussion 35
effect of – discussion 112
– findings 35
–– background 46 – findings 112
– resolution 35
–– discussion 46 – resolution 112
artifact due to imperfection in compression
–– findings 46 degraded resolution of whole-body planar
paddle
99mTc methylene diphosphonate image
– background 37 –– resolution 46
– metal artifact – background 91
– discussion 37
–– background 54 – discussion 91
– findings 37
–– discussion 54 – findings 91
– resolution 37
–– findings 54 – resolution 91
attenuation correction in PET
–– resolution 54 digital breast tomosynthesis
– background 99
– motion artifact – background 30
– discussion 99
–– background 55 – discussion 30
– findings 99
–– discussion 55 – findings 31
– resolution 100
–– findings 55 – resolution 31
–– resolution 55 digital subtraction angiography and mo-
B – partial volume artifact tion artifacts
–– background 53 – background 14
beam hardening artifact – discussion 14
–– discussion 53
– background 52 – findings 14
–– findings 53
– discussion 52 – resolution 15
–– resolution 53
– findings 52 discrete image ghosts on abdominal imag-
– patient size on CT number accuracy, ef-
– resolution 52 ing, appearance of
fect of
bremsstrahlung imaging of 90Y micro- – background 60
–– background 45
spheres liver embolization – discussion 60
–– discussion 45
– background 110 – findings 60
–– findings 45
– discussion 110 – resolution 61
–– resolution 45
– findings 110 displayed volume CT dose index
– ring artifact
– resolution 110 – background 51
–– background 44
–– discussion 44 – discussion 51
–– findings 44 – findings 51
C – resolution 51
–– resolution 44
collimation cone beam computed tomography doppler ultrasound aliasing
– background 6 – background 20 – background 135
– discussion 6 – discussion 20 – discussion 135
– findings 6 – findings 20 – findings 135
– resolution 6 – resolution 20 – resolution 135
computed tomography correct acquisition image matrix size
– beam hardening artifact – background 106
–– background 52 – discussion 106
E
–– discussion 52 – findings 106 EMI artifact due to LVAD device
–– findings 52 – resolution 107 – background 39
–– resolution 52 – discussion 39

155
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Index

– findings 39 –– background 10 –– resolution 146


– resolution 39 –– discussion 10 – multimodality image registration
equalization filters –– findings 10 –– background 150
– background 18 –– resolution 11 –– discussion 150
– discussion 18 – reference air kerma and skin dose –– findings 150
– findings 18 –– background 4 –– resolution 151
– resolution 18 –– discussion 4 image quality variation with reconstructed
extra field-of-view anatomy on inferior –– findings 4 slice thickness
portion of sagittal 3D T2-weighted ac- –– resolution 5 – background 47
quisition of spine, appearance of – SID, ABC, and radiation output 12 – discussion 47
– background 65 –– background 2 – findings 47
– discussion 65 –– discussion 2 – resolution 47
– finding 65 –– findings 2 image quality variation with reconstruc-
– resolution 66 –– resolution 2 tion filter
focal spot size selection in magnification – background 49
views – discussion 49
F – background 27 – findings 49
– discussion 27 – resolution 49
fat-suppressed sequences, application of
– findings 27 image smoothing
– background 71
– resolution 28 – background 104
– discussion 71
fused image display of multiple modalities – discussion 104
– findings 71
– background 148 – findings 104
– resolution 72
– discussion 148 – resolution 105
filtering and edge enhancement
– findings 148 iterative reconstruction and choosing the
– background 144
– resolution 149 number of iterations and subsets
– discussion 144
– background 101
– findings 144
– discussion 101
– resolution 144
fluoroscopy
H – findings 101
– resolution 101
– antiscatter grids harmonic imaging
–– background 8 – background 132
–– discussion 8 – discussion 132
–– findings 8 – findings 132
K
–– resolution 8 – resolution 132 kV selection on image quality and dose,
– collimation hyperintensity appears bilaterally at the effect of
–– background 6 level of the internal auditory canal on – background 46
–– discussion 6 diffusion-weighted MRI, affecting visu- – discussion 46
–– findings 6 alization of surrounding structures – findings 46
–– resolution 7 – background 62 – resolution 46
– cone beam computed tomography – discussion 62
–– background 20 – findings 62
–– discussion 20 – resolution 63 M
–– findings 20
magnetic resonance imaging
–– resolution 21
– abnormal dark fluid seen in bladder of
– CT fluoroscopy I an axial single-Shot T2-weighted
–– background 12
image post-processing on appearance sequence, but not on location-matched
–– discussion 12
– background 32 3D T2 acquistion
–– findings 12
– discussion 32 –– background 76
–– resolution 12
– findings 34 –– discussion 76
– digital subtraction angiography and
– resolution 34 –– findings 76
motion artifacts
image processing –– resolution 78
–– background 14
– filtering and edge enhancement – dark etching appears at boundary of fat
–– discussion 14
–– background 144 and soft-tissue layers 67
–– findings 14
–– discussion 144 –– background 69
–– resolution 15
–– findings 144 –– discussion 69
– equalization filters
–– resolution 144 –– findings 69
–– background 18
– fused image display of multiple modal- –– resolution 69
–– discussion 18
ities – appearance of discrete image ghosts on
–– findings 18
–– background 148 abdominal imaging 60
–– resolution 18
–– discussion 148 –– background 60
– modes and dose
–– findings 148 –– discussion 60
–– background 16
–– resolution 149 –– findings 60
–– discussion 16
– maximum intensity projection –– resolution 61
–– findings 16
–– background 146 – extra field-of-view anatomy on inferior
–– resolution 16
–– discussion 146 portion of sagittal 3D T2-weighted ac-
– patient shielding
–– findings 146 quisition of spine, appearance of 65

156
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Index

–– background 65 –– resolution 39
–– discussion 65 – equations 42
N
–– finding 65 – focal spot size selection in magnifica- nonuniformity (array transducer element
–– resolution 66 tion views 27 dropouts)
– fat-suppressed sequences, application –– background 27 – background 122
of 71 –– discussion 27 – discussion 122
–– background 71 –– findings 27 – findings 122
–– discussion 71 –– resolution 28 – resolution 122
–– findings 71 – image post-processing on appear- nuclear medicine
–– resolution 72 ance 32 – attenuation correction in PET
– hyperintensity appears bilaterally at –– background 32 –– background 99
level of internal auditory canal on –– discussion 32 –– discussion 99
diffusion-weighted MRI, affecting visu- –– findings 34 –– findings 99
alization of surrounding structures –– resolution 34 –– resolution 99
–– background 62 – magnification imaging – bremsstrahlung imaging of 90Y micro-
–– discussion 62 –– background 26 spheres liver embolization
–– findings 62 –– discussion 26 –– background 110
–– resolution 63 –– findings 26 –– discussion 110
– post contrast T1-weighted gradient –– resolution 26 –– findings 110
echo reveals patchy enhancement in an- – microcalcification-like appearance –– resolution 110
terior septal wall 79 caused by detector artifact – correct acquisition image matrix size
–– background 79 –– background 36 –– background 106
–– discussion 79 –– discussion 36 –– discussion 106
–– findings 79 –– findings 36 –– findings 106
–– resolution 81 –– resolution 36 –– resolution 107
– precontrast, axial 3D T1-weighted gra- – patient motion causing blurred paren- – degraded image quality from improper
dient echo with fat suppressions 67 chymal structure collimator
–– background 67 –– background 38 –– background 112
–– discussion 67 –– discussion 38 –– discussion 112
–– findings 67 –– findings 38 –– findings 112
–– resolution 68 –– resolution 38 –– resolution 112
– signal-to-noise variation across FOV, – x-ray acquisition technique factors – degraded resolution of whole-body pla-
creating nondiagnostic image quality –– background 29 nar 99mTc methylene diphosphonate
–– background 82 –– discussion 29 image
–– discussion 82 –– findings 29 –– background 91
–– findings 82 –– resolution 30 –– discussion 91
–– resolution 84 maximum intensity projection –– findings 91
– T1-weighted gradient echo of abdomen – background 146 –– resolution 92
shows marked artifact medially on both – discussion 146 – image smoothing
coronal and axial FOV, obscuring visual- – findings 146 –– background 104
ization of soft tissues – resolution 146 –– discussion 104
–– discussion 74 metal artifact –– findings 104
–– Fbackground 74 – background 54 –– resolution 105
–– findings 74 – discussion 54 – iterative reconstruction and choosing
–– resolution 75 – findings 54 the number of iterations and subsets
magnification imaging – resolution 54 –– background 101
– background 26 microcalcification-like appearance caused –– discussion 101
– discussion 26 by detector artifact –– findings 101
– findings 26 – background 36 –– resolution 101
– resolution 26 – discussion 36 – patient motion in myocardial perfusion
mammography – findings 36 imaging
– artifact due to detector row dropout 35 – resolution 36 –– background 108
–– background 35 modes and dose –– discussion 108
–– discussion 35 – background 16 –– findings 108
–– findings 35 – discussion 16 –– resolution 108
–– resolution 35 – findings 16 – positron range on image quality and
– artifact due to imperfection in compres- – resolution 16 resolution
sion paddle 37 motion artifact –– background 94
–– background 37 – background 55 –– findings 94
–– discussion 37 – discussion 55 –– discussion 94
–– findings 37 – findings 55 –– resolution 96
–– resolution 37 – resolution 55 – standardized uptake value in positron
– EMI artifact due to LVAD device multimodality image registration emission tomography
–– background 39 – background 150 –– background 97
–– discussion 39 – findings 150 –– discussion 97
–– findings 39 – resolution 151

157
| 09.11.19 - 01:53

Index

–– findings 97 – findings 133


–– resolution 98
R – discussion 133
range ambiguity in B-mode – resolution 134
– background 129 ultrasound imaging
P – findings 129 – array transducers and sound frequency
– discussion 129 –– background 120
partial volume artifact
– resolution 129 –– discussion 121
– background 53
reference air kerma and skin dose –– findings 120
– discussion 53
– background 4 –– resolution 121
– findings 53
– discussion 4 – doppler ultrasound aliasing
– resolution 53
– findings 4 –– background 135
patient motion causing blurred parenchy-
– resolution 5 –– discussion 135
mal structure
reflection (boundary conditions)-reverber- –– findings 135
– background 38
ation artifacts –– resolution 135
– discussion 38
– background 127 – harmonic imaging
– findings 38
– discussion 127 –– background 132
– resolution 38
– findings 127 –– findings 132
patient motion in myocardial perfusion
– resolution 128 –– discussion 132
imaging
ring artifact –– resolution 132
– background 108
– background 44 – nonuniformity (array transducer ele-
– discussion 108
– discussion 44 ment dropouts)
– findings 108
– findings 44 –– background 122
– resolution 108
– resolution 44 –– discussion 122
patient shielding
–– findings 122
– background 10
–– resolution 123
– discussion 10
– findings 10
S – pulse-echo imaging acquisition
–– background 124
– resolution 11 shadowing and enhancement
–– findings 124
patient size on CT number accuracy, effect – background 130
–– discussion 124
of – findings 130
–– resolution 126
– background 45 – discussion 130
– pulse-echo imaging principle and speed
– discussion 45 – resolution 130
of sound propagation
– findings 45 SID, ABC, and radiation output
–– background 118
– resolution 45 – background 2
–– discussion 118
positron range on image quality and reso- – discussion 2
–– findings 118
lution – findings 2
–– resolution 118
– background 94 – resolution 2
– range ambiguity in B-mode
– findings 94 signal-to-noise variation across FOV, creat-
–– background 129
– discussion 94 ing nondiagnostic image quality
–– findings 129
– resolution 96 – background 82
–– discussion 129
post contrast T1-weighted gradient echo – discussion 82
–– resolution 129
reveals patchy enhancement in anterior – findings 82
– reflection (boundary conditions)-rever-
septal wall – resolution 84
beration artifacts
– background 79 standardized uptake value in positron
–– background 127
– discussion 79 emission tomography
–– discussion 127
– findings 79 – background 97
–– findings 127
– resolution 81 – discussion 97
–– resolution 128
precontrast, axial 3D T1-weighted gradient – findings 97
– shadowing and enhancement
echo with fat suppressions – resolution 98
–– background 130
– background 67
–– findings 130
– discussion 67
– findings 67 T –– discussion 130
–– resolution 130
– resolution 68
T1-weighted gradient echo of abdomen – ultrasound image display on scanners
pulse-echo imaging acquisition
shows marked artifact medially on both and in reading rooms
– background 124
coronal and axial FOV, obscuring visual- –– background 133
– findings 124
ization of soft tissues –– findings 133
– discussion 124
– background 74 –– discussion 133
– resolution 126
– discussion 74 –– resolution 134
pulse-echo imaging principle and speed of
– findings 74
sound propagation
– resolution 75
– background 118
– discussion 118
X
– findings 118 U X -ray acquisition technique factors
– resolution 118 – background 29
ultrasound image display on scanners and – discussion 29
in reading rooms – findings 29
– background 133 – resolution 30

158

You might also like