Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The end justify the means : Navigating the Experience of Learners Engaged in Cheating
A Research Paper
Practical Research I
ACOSTA,Mac Jonell
AMADEO,John Rey
ALIDO,Rowena
DEPDEPEN,JANREY
DOMINGO,Earlyn Jane
NUÑEZ,Chaezerine Kate
OLBINADO,Angel Gabriel
ORFIANO,Norelle
RAMOS,Wilmar kent
VALDEZ,Krisha Mae
———————————
Research Adviser
APPROVAL SHEET
Navidad
Practical Research I.
study would not have been possible without the help and support of
their warmest gratitude to the following people who made a great help
First and for most, the researchers would like to thank the
courage, blessings and good health. All things are made possible
because of Him.
Nomer Pacilan Jr., for her continuous and tireless guidance and
research.
to Mrs. Yolanda A. Zabala and to all their other subject teachers for
the knowledge they have shared in their study and to the members of
stayed there to support them in their works and for giving ideas which
DEDICATION
They are the one who provide the resources that needed in the
making of this study. It also dedicated the teachers who are behind in
complete this study. The researchers would also like to dedicate this
shift. Also, this study is also dedicated to the school who gives
Cheating is a behavior that involves breaking the rules or principles that govern a
particular activity. It can be seen in various contexts such as academia, sports, and
relationships. Cheating has become prevalent due to the pressure to succeed,
competition, and the allure of rewards. This study aims to explore the motivation and
justification for cheating by analyzing previous research on the topic.
A study by McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield (2001) found that students' motivation to
cheat was influenced by their desire to achieve high grades. The study found that
students who believed in the importance of grades were more likely to cheat, as they
saw cheating as a means of achieving academic success. Additionally, students who had
a fear of failure were more likely to cheat as a way to avoid negative consequences and
maintain their self-esteem.
Another study by Starnes and Tapp (2018) discovered that students perceived cheating
as a means of leveling the playing field, especially when they believed that the teachers
were not fair in their evaluations. Thus, students who felt that they were not receiving
the same opportunities as their peers were more likely to cheat.
The justification for cheating can be seen as a form of cognitive dissonance, where
individuals attempt to align their behavior with their beliefs and values. A study by Chari
and Chang (2016) found that students who had a high level of moral reasoning and a
strong belief in academic integrity were less likely to cheat. In contrast, students who
had a low level of moral reasoning and a weak belief in academic integrity were more
likely to cheat.
Another study by Schurr and Ritov (2019) found that people justify their cheating
behavior by focusing on external factors that influenced their behavior. For example,
individuals might blame the pressure to succeed or the lack of time to study as reasons
for cheating.
In conclusion, motivations and justifications for cheating are influenced by various
factors such as the desire for success, perceived unfairness, fear of failure, beliefs, and
values. Understanding these factors can help educators and policymakers develop
strategies to prevent and deter cheating behavior.
The teachers - They will be able to understand better why students engage in. This
study to develop educational programs and interventions that foster a culture of
academic honesty and integrity among students.
The school - it will enjoy a higher prestige as an educational institution with students
who struggle to learn and acquire knowledge and skills in honest ways and serious
study.
The Researcher - The researcher also can benefit in this study to get more crucial
knowledge and improve their self-learning.
E.Definition of terms:
A.Research Design
The researchers make use of case study research design which is appropriate to
provide clarity,and validity. According to creswell (2022) A case study is an in-depth
study of one person, group, or event. In a case study, nearly every aspect of the
subject's life and history is analyzed to seek patterns and causes of behavior. Case
studies can be used in various fields, including psychology, medicine, education,
anthropology, political science, and social work.
The purpose of a case study is to learn as much as possible about an individual or
group so that the information can be generalized to many others. Unfortunately, case
studies tend to be highly subjective, and it is sometimes difficult to generalize results
to a larger population. While case studies focus on a single individual or group, they
follow a format similar to other types of psychology writing. A case study is a detailed
study of a specific subject, such as a person, group, place, event, organization, or
phenomenon. Case studies are commonly used in social, educational, clinical, and
business research.
The qualitative research utilized an interpretative case study.Case studies are good for
describing, comparing, evaluating and understanding different aspects of a research
problem. A case study is an appropriate research design when you want to gain
concrete, contextual, in-depth knowledge about a specific real-world subject. It allows
you to explore the key characteristics, meanings, and implications of the case.
Case studies are often a good choice in a thesis or dissertation. They keep your project
focused and manageable when you don’t have the time or resources to do large-scale
research. You might use just one complex case study where you explore a single
subject in depth, or conduct multiple case studies to compare and illuminate different
aspects of your research problem. (Denzin and Lincoln ,2019)
E. Ethical Consideration
Research were opted to further provide truthful information and guaranteed that
the information they were contributed were remained confidential and private as well
as the participants' identity. The names of participants were optionally specified and
they were not forced to answer any of the questions prepared. Moreover, veracity was
also considered in the sense that all data is truthful and reliable. The researchers chose
to conduct the interview where the participants can feel and answer comfortably. Some
technological devices were used as a tool for data gathering and serves as a proof;
however it was mot used to disrepute one's decency. As a tool to gather data and serve
as proof, certain technical instruments have been used; however they were not used for
discharging one's decency.
F. Data Analysis
In data analysis, processes involved were the reaffirmation, evaluation and
interpretation of the experienced by the Grade 11 students on their navigating. The data
analysis procedure in this study will include a qualitative analysis of the participants'
responses to the interview questions. The thematic analysis will be used to analyze the
transcribed interview data. Thematic analysis is a qualitative research method for
analyzing data derived from interviews, focus groups, or other types of qualitative data.
The primary objective of thematic analysis is to find patterns, themes, and categories in
data and then interpret and comprehend their meaning. The researcher will start by
reviewing the data and getting acquainted with the content. The data analysis
procedure will include drawing conclusions based on the answers of the respondents.
The researcher will use these findings to answer the research questions to investigate
the implications for social media advertising.
Chapter III
Results and Discussion
This chapter presented the analyses and interpretation of the topic The End does not
Justify the Means. Navigating the Experience of Learners Engaged in Cheating.
Themes of the topic The End does not Justify the Means. Navigating the Experience
of Learners Engaged in Cheating
Themes:
1. Emotional Rollercoaster
2. Hunting Dilemmas
3. Driving Force
4. Emotional Response
5. Action Taken
6. Coping Mechanism
7. Philosophical Connections
8. Academic Integrity
9. Moral Learning
10. Improved Actions
Emotional Rollercoaster
Emotional Rollercoaster can arise from various circumstances and events in life,
such as relationship dynamics, significant life changes, personal achievements or
failures, unexpected news, or intense experiences. For example, falling in love, going
through a breakup, dealing with a major loss, or facing a challenging situation can all
contribute to experiencing an emotional rollercoater.
The common reason why I sometimes cheat in our class is because I didn’t get a
time to review the lesson that my teachers discuss.
One of the reason why I sometimes do this is that I can’t prepare for summative
and quizzes.
Hunting Dilemmas
I thought about the consequences of cheating, some being caught by the teacher
which could end up in suspension from our school. And if my parents find out that I’m
cheating in class they might scold me.
Yes I know that cheating has a different consequences including the following ;
1. Your teacher might give you a zero score if ever they caught you cheating.
2. Your teacher might send you to the principal’s office so that you can receive your
warning.
3. You might be dropped out in the entire school.
Yes, I think about the consequences if I cheat, maybe my teacher will tear up my
paper.
Yes I think about the consequences if I cheat. Cheating has various consequences,
such us losing trust,damaging relationships, negatively affecting academic or career
opportunities, or resulting in legal consequences in certain contexts.
Driving Force
It’s important to know that driving forces can vary depending on the context and the
individuals or systems involved. Different people may have different driving forces base
on their unique perspectives, experiences, and goals. Understanding the driving forces
behind behaviors and actions can provide insights into human motivation and the
factors that shape individual and collective behavior.
I always wanted to get a high score to satisfy myself so I think my own self is the one
who’s forcing me to cheat.
There was a time when I only got a small score because I cheated, of course I’m
guilty.
The external factors that contributed to my decision to cheat in class include fear of
failure or full performance, poor time management and study skills.
Emotional response
It plays a crucial role in human functioning as they provide valuable information about
one’s needs, preferences, and overall well-being. They can influence decision-making,
behavior, interpersonal relationships, and overall emotional well-being. Understanding
and managing emotional responses is an important aspect of emotional intelligence and
can contribute to psychological resilience and overall emotional health.
Yes, I feel negative consequences after I cheat sometimes, I feel guilty because my
classmates spend time revising, and I just cheat on our exams. I feel ashamed of my self
sometimes.
There was a time when I only got a small score because I cheated, of course I’m guilty.
The negative consequences that I encountered when I tried to cheat once our the other
answer is not correct, and I feel guilty because I just copied it and didn’t read it. I wish I
could taken to higher.
Action taken
An action given in a particular situation, problem or goal. It represents the actual
physical or strategic activities carried out to address a specific issue or achieve a desired
outcome. Action taken can carry across different contexts. In a personal or individual
scenarios, it may refer to the steps an individual takes to resolve a personal issue, such
as seeking advice, making a decision, or implementing a plan or action.
I avoid cheating by my first making sure that I am well prepared and have studied the
material thoroughly. I actively participate in class.
Strawberry stated that,
I started to always review my notes and I will not let my self be infuenced with my
friends.
I always think that cheating is not good and of course every time I take a test or quizzes
I’m always making sure that I reviewed all the lesson that we tackled.
Coping Mechanism
Refers to the psychological strategies and behaviors that individuals employ to manage
or adapt to challenging or stressful situations. Coping mechanisms can be conscious or
unconscious responses to external or internal stressors, and they are aimed at reducing
or alleviating the emotional, psychological, or physical distress associated with those
stressors.
Some effective strategies to avoid cheating in class include developing good study
habits, asking teachers or classmates for help when needed, and reviewing my notes
before a quiz or test.
I akways think that cheating is not good and of course every time I take a test or quizzes
I’m always making sure that I reviewed all the lessons that we tackled.
Review everyday.
The technique that I use to avoid cheating is that I prepare early and or I repeat
everything we studied, and I have to review it immediately so I don’t miss it.
Philosophical connections
Refers to the relationship or association between different philosophical ideas,
concepts, theories, or thinkers. It involves identifying and exploring the links,
similarities, or shared themes that exist within the broad scope of philosophy.
Apple stated that,
Yes, cheating undermines the principle of honestly, integrity and fairness that are
essential to personal growth and development. It also affects my confidence of
classmates or teachers in my ability as a student.
Yes, it affects my moral well-being. It affects the popular quotation “Honesty is the best
policy”. It also tests my guiltiness in cheating.
Yes, cheating is generally considered morally wrong as it involved betraying the trust of
others and violate principles of honesty and fairness. Cheating is also negatively impact
a persons character and self-esteem as it create feelings of guilt, shame and low self-
worth.
Academic Integrity
Refers to ethical principles and values that govern scholarly and educational activities. It
encompasses the honesty, trustworthiness, and responsible conduct expected of
students, researchers, and academic professionals in their pursuit of knowledge,
research, and learning.
Cheating severely damages the academic integrity of my school and negatively affects
my fellow students. When individuals engage in cheating, it creates an unfair advantage
and negates the effort of people who have worked really hard.
Strawberry stated that,
Of course, it affects everything including the academic integrity and also my fellow
students. Because cheating was an evidence that every students have no discipline.
It get really unfair for those who are hardly reviewed there test and its unfair because
cheater didn’t make an efforts to get a high grades.
This has a big impact because many students will not learn if they always cheat.
When students cheats, they undermine the principle of honesty and fairness that
academic institutions are built on. This can lead to a culture of dishonesty and
deception, which can ultimately erode the reputation of the school and the value of the
degrees it confers.
Moral learning
Refers to the process through which individuals acquire moral values, ethical principles,
and develop their understanding of right and wrong. It involves the acquisition,
internalization, and application of moral knowledge, belief and behavior.
I have learned that cheating ultimately undermines my own learning and growth.
Cheating erodes settings, tarnishing my reputations and potentially leading to serve
consequences.
I learned that cheating can affect your conscience and as well as it test your guiltiness.
That is why we need to avoid cheating to all classes we take. And also do not forget that
cheating has heavy consequences.
The lessons that I have learned about cheating is to not trust any word that it takes but
instead read it critically before copying it so you can define what is wrong and what is
correct. It can’t really avoided in all activities, but it’s still wrong because there
consequences that you must experience if you get caught, but in my experience, I have
never experienced severe punishment, we all just retook because my other classmates
cheated and feel guilty.
Improved Action
Refers to the act of enhancing or optimizing ones actions or behaviors in order to
achieve better outcomes and results. It involves making adjustments, modifications, or
refinements to ones actions based on feedback, experience, or new information in order
to improve efficiency, effectiveness, or overall performance.
If I were given a second chance, I would participate on our discussion, and review our
lesson each time.
If I were given a second chance before I do cheating. I will think practically, in that way I
can avoid cheating. And also I will think about the consequences firstly before doing
cheating, because as we all know every bad actions have punishment.
I would encourage everyone not only myself to stop cheating and just do their best to
study well.
We al deserve a second chance even some of us made some wrong choices. And remind
that don’t do it again and make your mistakes right as soon a possible.
Chapter IV
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
A. Summary
The study The End does not Justify the Means. Navigating the Experience of Learners
Engaged in Cheating in Senior High School Students was conducted and resulted from
the exploration of the experiences of senior high school students on their cheating
experience.
The participants were the Grade 11 Senior High School Students of Castor Z. Concepcion
Memorial National High School who have experience cheating in their classroom. The
study was conducted at Brgy. Antonino, Balaoan, La Union, particularly in Castor Z.
Concepcion Memorial National High School.
School Year 2022-2023. The participants were the grade 11 Senior High School students
who have experienced on cheating during the examination and were chosen through
purposive sampling in which set of criteria was utilized.
From the analysis and interpretation of data, the following themes were identified:
2. Thetheme entitled “Hunting Dilemmas” refers to the challenges and dilemmas that
entitled individuals encounter in the context of hunting.
3. The
theme entitled “Driving Force” serves as the primary motivation or impetus
behind an individual’s actions or decisions.
5. Thetheme entitled “Action Taken” refers to the steps, decisions, or behaviors that an
individual engages in response to a situation or circumstance.
8. Thetheme entitled “Academic Integrity” refers to the ethical principles and values that
guide honest and responsible behavior in academic settings.
9. Thetheme entitled “Moral Learning” refers to the process through which individuals
acquire and develop their moral values, principles, and ethical understanding.
10. The
theme entitled “Improved Actions” refers to behaviors or actions that have been
enhanced or developed in a positive way.
C. Conclusions
5. While
cheating may seem to offer short-term benefits, it undermines the core values
of education and has long-term consequences for individuals and the educational
system.By addressing cheating through a combination of disciplinary measures,
educational initiatives, and a supportive environment, we can promote a culture of
academic integrity and foster genuine learning experiences for all learners.
D. Recommendation
Based on the results of the study, the researchers presented the following
recommendations:
2. Foster
of safe learning environment: In order to reduce the temptation to cheat, it is
important to promote a safe learning environment where students feel comfortable
seeking help, sharing ideas, and expressing their concerns. This can be done by creating
supportive classrooms policies and by implementing fair grading practices that reduce
the pressure to cheat.
Mazar, N., Amir, O., & Ariely, D. (2008). The Dishonesty of Honest People: A Theory of
Self-Concept Maintenance. Journal of Marketing Research, 45(6), 633_644
https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkr.45.6.633
Kerkvliet, J., Sigmund, C., & Arthur, W. (2004). The End Does Not Justify the Means:
Adapting Training to the Values of the Learner. International Journal of Training and
Development, 8(3), 155- 165.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1360-3736.2004.00211.x
Stromberg, P. (2016). Cheating in the Digital Age: Do Students Cheat More in Online
Courses? Online Learning, 20(3), 1-11.
https://doi.org/10.24059/olj.v20i3.939
Singh, G., & Jain, D. (2013). Cheating in Online Examinations: A Preliminary Study.
Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 16(1),499_510.
Campbell, M. A., & Cox, D. B. (2013). The Challenge of Cheating in Online Courses: A
Student Perspective. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 17(1), 27_44.
https://doi.org/10.24059/olj.v20i3.939
Kerkvliet, J., & Sigmund, C. (2006). Can We Train Character? An Aristotelian Answer.
Academy of Management Learning & Education, 5(1), 68_81.
https://doi.org/10.5465/amle.2006.20390405
APPENDICES
Appendix A
Appendix B
Appendix C
Appendix D
Appendix E
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE
CURRICULUM VITAE