Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3, Spring 1999
Felman, 1987; Finkel & Arney, 1995; Frank, 1995; Heinrich, 1995;
Jacobs, 1991; Jay, 1987; Kurpius, Gibson, Lewis, & Corbet, 1991;
McCready, 1985; McGee, 1987; Moi, 1992; Murphy, A., 1989; Murphy,
C., 1989; Penley, 1989; Robertson, 1993; Robertson, 1995; Salzber-
ger-Wittenberg, Henry, & Osborne, 1983; Scheman, 1995; Schleifer,
1987; Simon, 1995; Tobin, 1993). However, unlike Daloz and a few
other authors, most college educators do not recognize transference
nor even understand what it is. When the fire starts, they get
burned. This paper is about the fire, about the intensity, that Daloz
identifies in transference in the teacher/student relationship.
Working from an extensive review of the college teaching and the
transference literatures—an analysis of more than 350 items—as
well as from an experiential base that includes 25 years as a college
and university teacher and 10 years as a faculty developer, in this
article I offer college educators the following: (a) conceptual back-
ground for transference (What is it?), (b) 15 possible indicators of
transference (What does it look like?), and (c) 9 recommended strate-
gies for the effective management of transference (What do you do
about it?). The larger context of this discussion is the conceptualiza-
tion of the educational helping relationship through exploration of
various aspects of the complex, dynamic, intersubjective system that
the teacher/student relationship constitutes—in this case, uncon-
scious displacements called transference.
Finally, I should note that I do not approach the topic of transfer-
ence through the disciplinary lens of psychology or psychoanalysis.
In addressing a problem, I feel most comfortable drawing material
from all relevant disciplines in the belief that the problem or theme
should define the inquiry, not a particular discipline. I am especially
sensitive to the communicational interference caused by jargon, and
I try to eliminate it or translate it whenever possible. These princi-
ples, aspirations, and values guide the discussion that follows, al-
though I may not always have succeeded fully in actualizing them.
Freud's Introduction
Countertransference
Transference Is Transference
ference (if one becomes aware of it) to the person whom one is help-
ing (Gorkin, 1987; Tansey & Burke, 1989). Traditionally, such disclo-
sure is proscribed, although some do advocate it (Maroda, 1991;
Watkins, 1985). Personally, I am not convinced of this disclosure's
benefits, and I recommend against it within a college teaching con-
text. A related question concerns discussing with students their
transference onto the teacher if the teacher begins to suspect it.
Again, within typical college teaching and advising contexts, I rec-
ommend against it. Too much can go wrong, and losing a fix on one's
teaching role is too easy. The first purpose of psychotherapy is to
promote psychological healing; that of teaching is to promote learning
(Robertson, 1998). Except perhaps in special circumstances—e.g.,
where the transference relates to some healing that is required in
order to learn, say in the case of learning blocks, and where the
teacher is sufficiently skilled at handling an overt discussion of trans-
ference—I think that teachers are best advised to recognize trans-
ference in a student—or in themselves—but not to discuss it overtly
with that student.
Conclusion
If professors continue to develop as teachers, I conclude that they
eventually conceive of teaching as facilitating students' learning
(Robertson, in press-a). With the adoption of this perspective, teach-
ers enter into a helping relationship with learners, an educational
helping relationship—a complex, dynamic, intersubjective system to
promote the students' learning. Within this framework, the subjective
experience of both the teacher and the student is important, particu-
larly in interaction. Within these two sets of subjective experience—
the teacher's and the students'—transference (an unconscious
displacement of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors from a previous sig-
nificant relationship onto a current relationship) may play a major
role at times, particularly in those instances when the relationship
between the teacher and a student is intense, whether positively or
negatively, which generally are also occasions when the teacher may
feel most out of control of the situation. I hope that this essay serves
as tool to aid in developing the ability to conceptualize, identify, and
manage transference enactments in teaching and advising. More
broadly, I hope that this discussion continues to develop the college
teaching profession's conceptualization of the educational helping re-
166 INNOVATIVE HIGHER EDUCATION
References
Abney, V. D., Yang, J. A., & Paulson, M. J. (1992). Transference and countertransfer-
ence issues unique to long-term group psychotherapy of adult women molested as
children: Trials and rewards. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 7, 559-569.
Beaman, D. (1994). Black English and the therapeutic relationship. Journal of Mental
Health Counseling, 16, 379-386.
Bird, B. (1972). Notes on transference: Universal phenomenon and hardest part of
analysis. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 20, 267-301.
Britzman, D. P., & Pitt, A. J. (1996). Pedagogy and transference: Casting the past of
learning into the presence of teaching. Theory into Practice, 35, 117-123.
Brockett, D. R., & Gleckman, A. D. (1991). Counter-transference with the older adult:
The importance of mental health counselor awareness and strategies for effective
management. Journal of Mental Health Counseling, 13, 343-355.
Brooke, R. (1987). Lacan, transference, and writing instruction. College English, 49,
679-691.
Brower, I. C. (1980). Counseling Vietnamese, Personnel and Guidance, 58, 646-652.
Campbell, R. J. (1989). Psychiatric dictionary (6th ed.). New York: Oxford University
Press.
Casement, P. (1985). On learning from the patient. London: Tavistock Publications.
Cerney, M. S. (1985). Countertransference revisited. Journal of Counseling and De-
velopment, 63, 362-364.
Culley, M. (1989). The authority of experience: Adult women in the college classroom.
Equity and Excellence, 24, 67-68.
Culley, M., Diamond, A., Edwards, L., Lennox, S., & Portuges, C. (1985). The politics
of nurturance. In M. Culley & C. Portuges (Eds.), Gendered subjects: The dynamics
of feminist teaching (pp. 11-20). Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Daloz, L. A. (1986). Effective teaching and mentoring: Realizing the transformative
power of adult learning experiences. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Davis, R. C. (1987). Pedagogy, Lacan, and the Freudian subject. College English, 49,
749-755.
Dunkel, J., & Hatfield, S. (1986). Countertransference issues in working with persons
with AIDS. Social Work, 31, 114-117.
Felman, S. (1987). Jacques Lacan and the adventure of insight: Psychoanalysis in con-
temporary culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Finkel, D. L, & Arney, W. R. (1995). Educating for freedom: The paradox of pedagogy.
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
Francis, P. C., & Turner, N. R. (1995). Sexual misconduct within the Christian church:
Who are the perpetrators and those they victimize? Counseling and Values, 39,
218-227.
Frank, A. W. (1995). Lecturing and transference: The undercover work of pedagogy.
In J, Gallop (Ed.), Pedagogy: The question of impersonation (pp. 28-35). Bloom-
ington, IN: Indiana University Press.
Freud, A. (1974). Four lectures on psychoanalysis for teachers and parents (1930). In
A. Freud, The writings of Anna Freud (Vol. 1, pp. 71-133). New York: International
Universities Press.
Transference 167
Kurpius, D., Gibson, G., Lewis, J., & Corbet, M. (1991). Ethical issues in supervising
counseling practitioners. Counselor Education and Supervision, 31, 48-57.
Lacan, J. (1977a). Ecrits: A selection (J. Lacan, Ed., & A. Sheridan, Trans.). New York:
W. W. Norton. (Original work published 1966)
Lacan, J. (1977b). The four fundamental concepts of psychoanalysis (J. Miller, Ed., &
A. Sheridan, Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. (Original work published 1973)
Lacan, J. (1988a). The seminar of Jaques Lacan: Book I, Freud's papers on technique
1953-1954 (J. Miller, Ed., & J. Forrester, Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. (Origi-
nal work published 1975)
Lacan, J. (1988b). The seminar of Jacques Lacan: Book II, The ego in Freud's theory
and in the technique of psychoanalysis 1964-1955 (J. Miller, Ed., & S. Tbmaselli,
Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. (Original work published 1978)
Lane, F. M. (1986). Transference and countertransference: Definitions of terms. In H.
C. Meyers (Ed.), Between analyst and patient: New dimensions in countertrans-
ference and transference (pp. 237-256). Hillsdale, NJ: Analytic Press.
Laplanche, J., & Pontalis, J.-B. (1973). The language of psycho-analysis (D. Nichol-
son-Smith, Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. (Original work published 1967)
Maroda, K. J. (1991). The power of countertransference: Innovations in analytic tech-
nique. Chicester, West Sussex, England: John Wiley & Sons.
McCready, K F. (1985). Differentiating of transference versus theme interference in
consultee-centered case consultation. School Psychology Review, 14, 471-478.
McGee, P. (1987). Truth and resistance: Teaching as a form of analysis. College Eng-
lish, 49, 667-678.
McLaughlin, J. T. (1981). Transference, psychic reality, and countertransference. Psy-
choanalytic Quarterly, 50, 639-664.
Mitchell, C., & Melikian, K. (1995). The treatment of male sexual offenders: Counter-
transference reactions. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 4, 87-93.
Moi, T. (1992). Transference/countertransference. In E. Wright (Ed.), Feminism and
psychoanalysis: A critical dictionary (pp. 431-435). Oxford, UK Blackwell.
Morgan, J. P. (1994). Bereavement in older adults. Journal of Mental Health Coun-
seling, 16, 318-326.
Murphy, A. (1989). Transference and resistance in the basic writing classroom: Proble-
matics and praxis. College Composition and Communication, 40, 175-187.
Murphy, C. (1989). Freud in the writing center: The psychoanalyses of tutoring well.
The Writing Center Journal, 10, 13-18.
Muse, J. S. (1992). Faith, hope, and the "urge to merge" in pastoral ministry: Some
countertransference-related distortions of relationships between male pastors and
their female parishioners. Journal of Pastoral Care, 46, 299-308.
Natterson, J. M. (1991). Beyond countertransference: The therapist's subjectivity in the
therapeutic process. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson.
Olinick, S. L. (1969). On empathy, and regression in service of the other. British Jour-
nal of Medical Psychology, 42, 41-49.
Orr, D. W. (1954). Transference and countertransference: A historical survey. Journal
of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 2, 621-670.
Peaslee, D. M. (1995). Countertransference with specific client populations? A comment
on The treatment of male sexual offenders." Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 4,
111-115.
Penley, C. (1989). Teaching in your sleep: Feminism and psychoanalysis. The future
of an illusion: Film, feminism, and psychoanalysis (pp. 165-181). Minneapolis: Uni-
versity of Minnesota Press.
Pollak, J., & Levy, S. (1989). Countertransference and failure to report child abuse
and neglect. Child Abuse & Neglect, 13, 515-522.
Racker, H. (1968). Transference and countertransference. New York: International Uni-
versities Press.
Transference 169