You are on page 1of 10

1

ADOPTION ( RA 11642 )

Adoption refers to the socio-legal process of providing a permanent family to


DOMESTIC ADOPTION UNDER RA 11642
a child whose parents had voluntarily or involuntarily given up their parental
rights, permanently transferring all rights and responsibilities, along with
filiation, making the child a legitimate child of the adoptive parents:
Provided, That adult adoption shall be covered by the benefits of this Act; In Domestic adoption refers to an administrative adoption proceeding where the
the interest of clarity, adoption shall cease to be part of alternative child care Order of Adoption is issued within the Philippines and is undertaken between a
and becomes parental care as soon as the process is completed (Sec. 3[d], RA Filipino child and eligible adoptive parents (Sec. 3[p], Art. I, RA No. 11642).
No. 11642).

2023 NOTES: Rule 99 on Adoption and Rule 100 on Rescission and Policy behind RA No. 11642
Revocation of Adoption had been expressly repealed by the new Rules on
Adoption effective August 22, 2002. The said New Rule on Adoption was It is hereby declared the policy of the State to ensure that every child remains
promulgated by the Supreme Court in accordance with RA No. 8552 or the under the care and custody of the parents and be provided with love, care,
Domestic Adoption Act of 1995 and RA 8043 or Inter-Country Adoption Act understanding, and security towards the full and harmonious development of the
of 1995. Later, the Congress passed RA No. 11642 thereby establishing the child’ personality. Only when such efforts prove insufficient and no appropriate
rules on Administrative Adoption. This new law effectively repealed the New placement or adoption by an unrelated person be considered.
Rule on Adoption, RA No. 8552, and RA No. 8043.

4BLUE 95: The best interest of the child shall be the paramount consideration in
PRIOR TO RA 11642 the enactment of alternative care, custody, and adoption policies. It shall be in
accordance with the tenets set forth in all the rights of the child enumerated under
Article 3 of Presidential Decree No. 603, otherwise known as the “Child and
It is defined as a juridical act, a proceeding in rem, which creates between
Youth Welfare Code”; the “United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child
two persons a relationship similar to that which results from legitimate
(UNCRC)”; the “United Nations Guidelines on Alternative Care of Children”; the
paternity and filiation. However, note that our courts do not take judicial
“United Nations Declaration on Social and Legal Principles Relating to the
notice of the fact of judicial adoption. It must be proven by competent
Protection and Welfare of Children with Special Internationally’; and the “Hague
evidence. Failure on the part of a person claiming to be an adopted child of a
Convention on the Protection of Children and Cooperation in Respect of Inter-
person is fatal for the said claim. However, as of the moment, under RA No.
Country Adoption. Toward this end, the State shall:
11642, adoption is now considered as administrative in nature.

(a) Ensure that a child without parental care, or at risk of losing it, is
SSS vs. Aguas, et al., G.R. No. 165546, February 27, 2006
provided with alternative care options such as adoption and foster care;
Held: Under Section 8(e) of Republic Act No. 1161, as amended, only
"legally adopted" children are considered dependent children. Absent any
(b) Establish alternative care standards to ensure that the quality of life and
proof that the family has legally adopted Janet, the Court cannot consider her
living conditions set are conducive to the child’s development;
a dependent child of Pablo, hence, not a primary beneficiary. Here, the
witnesses were unanimous in saying that Janet was not the real child but
(c) Safeguard the biological parents from making hasty decisions to
merely adopted by Rosanna and Pablo. Leticia also testified that Janet’s
relinquish parental authority over the child;
adoption did not undergo any legal proceedings; hence, there were no papers
to prove it. Under Section 8(e) of Republic Act No. 1161, as amended, only
(d) Prevent unnecessary separation of the child from the biological parents;
"legally adopted" children are considered dependent children. Absent any
proof that the family has legally adopted Janet, the Court cannot consider her
(e) Protect the adoptive parents from attempts to disturb their parental
a dependent child of Pablo, hence, not a primary beneficiary.
authority and custody over the adopted child;
Exception to traditional concept of adoption
(f) Conduct public information and educational campaign to promote a
positive environment for adoption;
Lazatin vs. Campos, 92 SCRA 250
Held: Only an adoption made through the court is valid in this jurisdiction. It
(g) Ensure that sufficient capacity exists within government and private
is not a natural law at all, but is wholly and entirely artificial. To establish the
sector agencies to handle adoption inquiries, process domestic adoption
relation, the statutory requirements must be strictly carried out, otherwise the
petitions, and offer adoption-related services, including pre-adoption and
adoption is an absolute nullity. The fact of adoption is never presumed but
post-adoption services, for the biological parents, children, and adoptive
must be affirmatively proved by the person claiming its existence, such as by
parents;
the decreed of adoption issued by the court.
(h) Encourage domestic adoption so as to preserve the child’s identity and
culture in the child’s native land, and only when this is not feasible shall
4BLUE 95: Before the effectivity of RA No. 11642, administrative adoption is
inter-country adoption be considered; and
already recognized in cases of inter-country adoption. It must be noted that
(i) Establish a system of cooperation with the Inter-Agency Council Against
Inter-Country Adoption takes the form of extrajudicial process. As such, it
Trafficking (IACAT), to prevent the sale, trafficking, and abduction of
could be said that Domestic Adoption under RA 8552 partakes of judicial
children and to protect Filipino children abandoned overseas who are made
character as mentioned in the case of Lazatin, and extrajudicial in nature for
vulnerable by their irregular status.
Inter-Country Adoption under RA 8043. Ultimately, by enactment of RA No.
11642, it appears that both domestic adoption and inter-country adoption are
No child shall be a subject of administrative adoption unless the status of the
administrative/extra-judicial in character.
child has been declared legally available for adoption except in cases of
relative or step-parent adoption where such declaration is not required.
Independent placement cases, or the entrustment of a child by the
OBJECTIVE OF RA 11642
birthparents to a relative or another person without seeking intervention from
government, nongovernment, or any social worker, will be covered by the
This Act shall provide for and allow simpler and inexpensive domestic provisions of this Act if the child is already in the custody of their custodian
administrative adoption proceedings and shall streamline services for alternative before the effectivity of this Act.
child care. Pursuant to this, it shall create the National Authority for Child Care It is hereby recognized that the administrative adoption processes for the
(NACC), which shall exercise all powers and functions relating to alternative child cases of legally-available children, relative, stepchild, and adult adoptees are
care including, declaring a child legally available for both domestic, administrative the most expeditious proceedings that will redound to their best interest.
adoption and intercountry adoption, foster care, kinship care, family-like care, or (Sec. 2, Art. I, RA No. 11642).
residential care (Sec. 3, Art. I, RA No. 11642).
2

WHO MAY ADOPT CONSENT NEEDED IN ADOPTION

After being properly counseled and informed of the right to give or withhold
The following may adopt: approval of the adoption, the written consent of the following to the adoption are
hereby required:
(a) Any Filipino citizen at least twenty-five (25) years of age, who is in possession
of full civil capacity and legal rights; has not been convicted of any crime (a) The adoptee, if ten (10) years of age or over;
involving moral turpitude; is of good moral character and can model the same; is
emotionally and psychologically capable of caring for children; at least sixteen (b) The biological parents of the child, if known, or the legal guardian, or the
(16) years older than the adoptee; and who is in a position to support and care for proper government instrumentality which has legal custody of the child,
adopted children in keeping with the means of the family: Provided, That the except in the case of a Filipino of legal age if, prior to the adoption, said
requirement of sixteen (16)-years difference between the age of the adopter and person has been consistently considered and treated as their own child by the
the adoptee may be waived when the adopter is the biological parent of the adopters for at least three (3) years;
adoptee, or is the spouse of the adoptee’s parent;
(c) The legitimate and adopted children, ten (10) years of age or over, of the
(b) The legal guardian with respect to the ward after the termination of the adopters, if any;
guardianship and clearance of financial accountabilities;
(d) The illegitimate children, ten (10) years of age or over, of the adopter if
(c) The legal guardians with respect to the foster child; living with said adopter or over whom the adopter exercises parental
authority and the latter’s spouse, if any; and
(d) Philippine government officials and employees deployed or stationed abroad:
Provided, That they are able to bring the child with them; and (e) The spouse, if any, of the person adopting or to be adopted. Provided,
That children under ten (10) years of age shall be counseled and consulted,
(e) Foreign nationals who are permanent or habitual residents of the Philippines but shall not be required to execute within consent (Sec. 23, Art. III, RA No.
for at least five (5) years possessing the same qualifications as above stated for 11642).
Filipino nationals prior to filing of the petition: Provided, That they come from a
country with diplomatic relations with the Republic of the Philippines and that the
laws of the adopter’s country will acknowledge the Certificate of Adoption as
valid, acknowledge the child as a legal child of the adopters, and allow entry of the
child into such country as an adoptee: Provided, further, That requirements of
residency may be waived for the following: NATIONAL AUTHORITY FOR CHILD CARE ( NACC )

(1) A former Filipino citizen, habitually residing in the Philippines, who


seeks to adopt a relative within fourth (4th) civil degree of consanguinity or
affinity; or The creation of National Authority for Child Care (NACC)

(2) One who seeks to adopt the legitimate child of the Filipino spouse; or The Inter-Country Adoption Board (ICAB) is hereby reorganized to a one-
step quasi-judicial agency on alternative child care, known as the National
(3) One who is married to a Filipino citizen and seeks to adopt jointly with Authority for Child Care (NACC), attached to the DSWD All duties,
the spouse a relative within the fourth (4th) degree of consanguinity or functions, and responsibilities of the ICAB, the DSWD, and those of other
affinity of the Filipino spouse. Spouses shall jointly adopt, except in the government agencies relating to alternative child care and adoption are
following cases: hereby transferred to the NACC.

(a) If one spouse seeks to adopt the legitimate child of the other; or 4BLUE 95: The Department of Budget and Management (DBM), in
coordination with the ICAB and the DSWD, shall formulate a cohesive
(b) If one spouse seeks to adopt own illegitimate child: Provided, That organizational structure with corresponding plantilla positions responsive to
fulfill the functions and divisions of the NACC as stipulated under this Act
(c) the other spouse has signified consent thereto; or (d) If the spouses are (Sec. 5, Art. II, RA No. 11642).
legally separated from each other. (Sec. 21, Art. III, RA No. 11642)

Paramount consideration in adoption proceedings

WHO MAY BE ADOPTED Adoption statues, being human and statutory, hold the interests and welfare
of the child to be of paramount consideration.
The following may be adopted:
4BLUE 95: They are designed to provide homes, parental care and education
(a) Any child who has been issued a CDCLAA; for unfortunate, needy or orphaned children and give them the protection of
society and family, as well as to allow childless couples or persons to
(b) The legitimate child of one spouse by the other spouse; experience the joys of parenthood and give them legally a child in the person
of the adopted for the manifestation of their natural parental instincts. Every
(c) An illegitimate child by a qualified adopter to improve status of reasonable intendment should be sustained to promote and fulfill these noble
legitimacy; and compassionate objectives of the law.

(d) A Filipino of legal age if, prior to the adoption, said person has been
consistently considered and treated by the adopters as their own child for a
period of at least three (3) years;

(e) A foster child;

(f) A child whose adoption has been previously rescinded;

(g) A child whose biological or adoptive parents have died: Provided, That
no proceedings shall be initiated within six (6) months from the time of death
of said parents; or
(h) A relative of the adopter (Sec. 22, Art. III, RA No. 11642).
3

DOCUMENTS NEEDED FOR ADOPTION EFFECTS OF ADOPTION

The PAPs shall attach the following to the Petition for Adoption and shall The following are the effects of domestic adoption, to wit:
submit the same to the RACCO:

(a) Home study report and child case study report duly prepared pursuant to the 1) The adoptive parents shall enjoy all the benefits entitled to biological
provisions of this Act, which requires a uniform and standardized format of the parents, including benefits that can be availed through the Social Security
report; System (SSS), Government Service Insurance System (GSIS), Department of
Labor and Employment (DOLE), Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR),
(b) Authenticated or security paper copies of birth record of the PAPs and the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth), Health Maintenance
child; Organization (HMO) providers, among others, or through other existing laws
from the date of the Order of Adoption was issued to the adoptive parent.
(c) (Authenticated or security paper copies of Marriage Certificate, if the PAPs are Adoptive parents may avail of paid maternity and paternity leaves as
married; or Court Decision or Certificate of Finality, if annulled, divorced or provided under existing laws for biological parents: Provided, That the leave
legally separated; benefits in this paragraph shall only be availed if by the adoptive parents
within one (1) year from the issuance of the Order of Adoption: Provided,
(d) National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) or Police Clearance; If foreign further, That the leave benefits in this paragraph shall not apply in cases of
national, clearance from police authorities where he or she lived for more than adult adoptions, and in all cases where the adoptive child has been in the care
twelve (12) months any time in the past fifteen (15) years; and custody of the adoptive parent for at least three (3) years before the
issuance of the Order of Adoption by the NACC (Sec. 36, Art. IV, RA No.
(e) Written consent to the adoption by the biological parent(s) or the person(s) 11642);
exercising substitute parental authority over the child and the written consent of
the child if at least ten (10) years old, signed in the presence of an adoption social 2) The adoptee shall be considered the legitimate child of the adopter for all
worker of the NACC or child-caring agency, or of the child-placing agency for intents and purposes and as such in entitled to all the rights and obligations
cases where the child is from a foster home, after proper counseling as prescribed provided by law to legitimate children born to them without discrimination of
in this Act; any kind. To this end, the adoptee is entitled to love, guidance, and support in
keeping with the means of the family. The legitimate filiation that is created
(f) (Authenticated or security paper copies of the Death Certificate of biological between the adopter and adoptee shall be extended to the adopter’s parents,
parents, as applicable; adopter’s legitimate siblings, and legitimate descendants. The adopter is also
given the right to choose the name by which the child is to be known,
(g) Original copy of CDCLAA, as applicable; consistent with the best interest of the child (Sec. 41, Art. V, RA No. 11642);

(h) Result of the recent medical evaluation of the child and the PAPs; 3) Upon issuances of the Order of Adoption, adoption shall cease as
alternative care and becomes parental care. Adoptive parents shall now have
(i) Mandatory result of the psychological evaluation of the PAPs; full parental authority over the child. Except in cases where the biological
parent is the spouse of the adopter, all legal ties between the biological
(j) Mandatory result of the psychological evaluation of the child, for children five parents and the adoptee shall be severed and the same shall then be vested on
(5) years old and above; the adopters. In case spouses jointly adopt or one spouse adopts the
legitimate child of the other, joint parental authority shall be exercised by the
(k) Child care plan with a list of at least three (3) temporary custodian of the child spouses (Sec. 42, Art. V, RA No. 11642);
in order of preference in case of death, absence or incapacity of the PAPs;
4) In testate and intestate succession, the adopters and the adoptee shall have
(l) Letter attesting to the character and general reputation of the PAPs from at least reciprocal rights of succession without distinction from legitimate filiations.
three (3) non-related character references, of whom one must preferably come However, if the adoptees and their biological parents have left a will, the law
from an employer or supervisor or with who the PAPs have business dealings. The on testamentary succession shall govern (Sec. 43, Art. V, RA No. 11642);
contact details of the person attesting must be so indicated in the letter;

(m) Recent close-up and whole-body pictures of the child and the PAPs taken
within the last six (6) months; and

(n) Documents showing the financial capacity of the PAPs. The NACC shall
formulate and produce official, uniform, and standard forms of the foregoing
documentary requirements that will be easily used and submitted by the PAPs for
their Petition for Domestic Adoption.

The documentary requirements previously submitted to the NACC for other child
care services may be considered and admitted for domestic administrative
adoption, if applicable: Provided, That the adoption social worker of the NACC,
LGU, and childcaring or child-placing agencies are nor precluded from asking for
additional documents as may be necessary as proof of the facts alleged in the
petition or to establish a factual claim (Sec. 24, Art. III, RA No. 11642).

OBJECTION IN PETITION FOR ADMIN.ADOPTION

4BLUE 95: Any person who has personal knowledge of any information, which
by ordinary diligence could not be discovered, and which when introduced and
admitted, would result in the denial of the petition and protect the child from
possible harm or abuse may, at any time during the STC or before the issuance of
the Order of Adoption, interpose an objection to the petition and file a complaint
supported by evidence to that effect, with the NACC, through the RACCO where
the petition was filed. The complaint will be subjected to verification and further
investigation (Sec. 33, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).
4

ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION PROCESS

The New Rules on Adoption or AM No. 02-6-02-SC provides the procedural In all proceedings for adoption, the NACC shall decide on the basis of all the
aspect for petition for adoption under Domestic Adoption Act RA 8552 and Inter- documents presented to it, as well as the evidence gathered during the personal
Country Adoption Act RA 8043. Later, RA No. 11642 amended and modified the interviews conducted by the RACCO with the handling adoption social worker,
entire rule for domestic adoption in the sense that domestic adoption, as it now PAPs, and the adoptee. There shall be no adversarial proceedings and all domestic
stands, is administrative in nature. adoption cases shall be decided within sixty (60) calendar days from the receipt of
the Deputy Director for Services of the recommendation of the RACCO on the
4BLUE 95 As already mentioned, by reason of RA No. 11642, domestic adoption petition.
is no longer covered by the New Rule on Adoption. Nevertheless, although RA
No. 11642 is properly termed as “Domestic Adoption Act”, per clarification from The NACC, in the exercise of its quasi-judicial powers, shall observe and comply
the Supreme Court, it is apparent that the rule on Inter-Country Adoption under with the following administrative domestic adoption process:
Part “B” of the New Rule on Adoption which are based on RA No. 8043 is
rendered ineffective as it was ruled that all pending petitions for inter-country (a) Within fifteen (15) working days from the filing of the Petition for
adoptions are automatically considered “dismissed”. This means that inter-country Adoption by the PAPs, the RACCO shall determine whether the PAPs have
adoption is no longer allowed. In fact, all petitions for adoption, either by a complied with the substantive and procedural requirements for domestic
foreigner living abroad or otherwise, or by a Filipino, living abroad or otherwise, adoption by extensively reviewing and examining the petition and its
are governed by RA No. supporting documents, as well as conducting personal interviews with the
11642 handling adoption social worker, the PAPs, and the adoptee: Provided, That
should the ROCCO require the PAPs to submit additional information or
Following the enactment of RA 11642, or the Domestic Administrative Adoption documents, the said fifteen (15)-day period shall be suspended;
and Alternative Child Care Act, the Supreme Court has issued guidelines on the
implications of the law on the Rule on Adoption. (b) Should the RACCO find that the PAPs sufficiently complied with the
requirements under this Act, it shall issue a certification attesting to the same,
4BLUE 95: In an En Banc Resolution, the Court adopted the recommendations of render a recommendation on whether to grant or deny the Petition for
the Committee on Family Courts and Juvenile Concerns, led by then Senior Adoption, and forward the same to the Deputy Director for Services within
Associate Justice Estela M. Perlas-Bernabe, as follows: the said fifteen (15)-day period, excluding the periods of suspension;

(c) The Deputy Director for Services, who may consult the CPC consultants,
1) Upon effectivity of RA 11642, courts may no longer receive or accept as may be necessary, shall review the recommendation of the RACCO within
petitions for domestic adoption. Jurisdiction over domestic adoption cases fifteen (15) working days from receipt thereof and either; (1) return it to the
shall now be with the newly created National Authority for Child Care ROCCO for further examination with a written explanation of its
(NACC), a quasi-judicial agency attached to the Department of Social insufficiency, or (2) forward the Petition for Adoption to the Executive
Welfare and Development. Director for final approval;

(d) In case the petition is returned by the Deputy Director for Services to the
2) Adoptions proceedings are now administrative. RACCO, the latter shall address the concerns raised by the Deputy Director
for Services within fifteen (15) working days from receipt thereof;
3) Petitioners have the option to immediately withdraw judicial petitions for
domestic adoption pending in court, regardless of the stage of the (e) When the petition is forwarded by the Deputy Director for Services to the
proceedings. Otherwise, the courts shall continue to hear and decide such Executive Director, the latter shall act and decide on the recommendation
petitions. within fifteen (15) working days from receipt thereof. However, if within the
fifteen (15)-day period, the Executive Director finds that there is a need to
4) The courts shall give petitioners time to manifest their intent to withdraw. return the petition to the RACCO for submission of additional information
If petitioners fail to notify the court within the set period, they are considered and documents or conduct of further investigation, as may be necessary, the
to have waived the option to withdraw their petitions. action of the RACCO on the returned petition and finally deciding on
whether to grant or deny the petition by the Executive Director should be
5) Petitioners, and their respective counsels, who avail of the benefits of RA settled within fifteen (15) workings days from the day the Executive Director
11642 without first withdrawing their pending petitions before the courts returns the same to the RACCO, except when the information and documents
shall be sanctioned under the Rules of Court. needed are of such nature that cannot be easily obtained by the PAPs.

6) Domestic adoption provisions in the Rule on Adoption are now rendered (f) In cases when there is no decision on the petition within sixty (60)
ineffective except for pending domestic cases before the courts not calendar days from the receipt of the Deputy Director for Services of the
withdrawn by petitioners. recommendation of the RACCO on the petition, through no fault or
negligence on the part of the PAPs, the latter may apply for PAPA, if none
7) Rescission of adoption under Section 47 of RA 11642 covers judicial has been issued yet, with the Executive Director, through the RACCO, for
adoptions. Inter-country adoption petitions pending before the courts the temporary placement of the child;
pursuant to Part B of the Rule on Adoption shall be dismissed.
(g) If the Executive Director returns the petition or documents for further
8) All courts are required to submit to the Office of the Court Administrator a investigation to the RACCO, during the period that the child is under the
list and status report of all pending adoption cases, including archived cases. custody of the PAPs, the child will remain the PAPs, taking into
consideration the child’s best interests: Provided, That if the Executive
9) RA 11642 took effect on January 28, 2022 with the goal of making Director issues a denial on the petition, the child will be immediately
domestic adoption proceedings simpler and less costly. The law also seeks to removed by the RACCO from its temporary placement with the PAPs (Sec.
streamline alternative child care services 32, Art. IV, RA No. 11652).
Phases of administrative adoption under RA No. 11642
5

PHASES OF ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION

1) DECLARATION OF CHILD AS AVAILABLE FOR ADOPTION


3) CASE STUDY
A. Who May File a Petition for CDCLAA?
The Head or Executive Director of a licensed or accredited child-caring or
child placing agency or institution managed by the government, PGU, NGO, A. Requirement of case study of the adoptee, the biological parents and
or provincial, city, or municipal social welfare development officer (SWDO) adopters
who has actual custody of the minor may file a petition before the NACC,
through the RACCO, for the issuance of a CDCLAA. No Petition for Adoption shall be processed by the NACC or its RACCs
If the child is under the custody of any other individual, the child-caring or unless an adoption social worker of the NACC, the social service office of
child-placing agency or institution shall do so with the consent of the child’s the LGU, or any childplacing or child-caring agency, has made a case study
custodian (Sec. 12, Art. III, RA No. 11642). of the adoptee, the biological parents as well as the adopters, and has
submitted the report and recommendations on the matter to the respective
B. Procedure for the Filing of the Petition for CDCLAA T RACCO as among the supporting documents of the petition, and the NACC
he petition shall be filed in the RACCO where the child was found, for the issuance of the Certificate of Adoption. At the time of preparation of
abandoned, voluntarily committed, or discovered. The RACCO shall the prospective adoptive child’s case study, the concerned adoption social
immediately examine the petition and its supporting documents, if sufficient worker shall confirm with the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) the real
in form and substance, and shall authorize the posting of the notice of the identity and registered name of the prospective adoptee. If the birth of a
petition in a conspicuous place for five (5) consecutive days in the locality prospective adoptee was not registered with the PSA, it shall be the
where the child was found, abandoned, voluntarily committed, or discovered, responsibility of the said social worker to ensure that said prospective
and in social media platforms or other online platforms of the NACC and the adoptee is registered (Sec. 25, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).
concerned LGU.
If the RACCO finds that the petition is insufficient, the case shall be put on B. Coverage of case study
hold and the petition shall be returned to the petitioner for compliance with
the additional information or documents requested by the RACCO. 4BLUE 95: The case study on the prospective adoptive child shall establish
Within fifteen (15) working days after the completion of its posting, the that said child is legally available for adoption and that the documents to
RACCO shall render a recommendation and transmit a copy of such support this fact are valid and authentic. Further, the case study of the
recommendation, together with the records, to the Executive Director (Sec. prospective adopters shall ascertain their genuine intentions and that the
14, Art. III, RA No. 11642). adoption is in the best interest of the child. If the adoption social worker
determines that the adoption shall redound to the best interests of the child, a
C. Opposition to the Petition for CDCLAA recommendation shall be made to the RACCO or the NACC for the petition
In cases of abandoned, neglected children, and foundlings, if the biological to be granted; otherwise, a denial thereof shall be recommended. Upon
parents, relatives or legal guardian of the child appear and oppose the discovery of new information that would warrant denial of the petition to
issuance of the CDCLAA, prior to its issuance, the case shall be put on hold protect the best interest of the child, the said social worker is duty bound to
and the RACCO, Deputy Director for Services, or Executive Director, report the same to the RACCO or the NACC (supra).
depending on where the case is pending for review at the time the petition is
opposed, shall direct the handling adoption social worker to immediately
investigate and request for a Parenting Capability Assessment Report
(PCAR) from the LGU where the biological parents, relatives, or legal
guardian reside. Within fifteen (15) working days after the issuance of the
PCAR, the handling adoption social worker shall render a recommendation 4) MATCHING PROCESS
on whether to grant or deny the opposition of the biological parents,
relatives, or legal guardian of the child. Within fifteen (15) working days There shall be a matching process for case of legally available children thirty
after the receipt of the handling adoption social worker’s recommendation, (30) calendar days after the issuance of the CDCLAA or the next matching
the RACCO, Deputy Director for Services, or Executive Director shall conference, whichever is applicable. The matching of the child to approved
decide on the merits of the petition (Sec. 16, Art. III, RA No. 11642). PAPs shall be carried out during the regular matching conference by the
Matching Committee in the regional level, the RCPC under the RACCOs:
D. Finding in favor of issuance of CDCLAA Provided, That interregional matching, which shall be monitored and
supervised by the Deputy Director for Services, may be conducted upon
Upon finding merit in the petition, the Executive Director shall issue a recommendation of the Executive Director, at any time, depending on the
CDCLAA within seven (7) working days from receipt of the number of children declared legally available for adoption and the number of
recommendation, unless further investigation or additional information or approved PAPs. Subject to the approval of the NACC, the RCPC shall fix its
documents are needed to determine the merits of the petition. A copy of the own internal rules and procedures. However, the records of the children and
CDCLAA shall be transmitted to the petitioner and all interested parties the approved PAPs not matched after two (2) presentations in the regional
known to the Executive Director (Sec. 15, Art. III, RA No. 11642). level shall be forwarded to the NACC for inclusion in the interregional
matching presentation: Provided, That children with special needs shall be
E. Remedy in case of denial or grant of issuance of CDCLAA immediately forwarded if not matched in the first meeting, except under
special circumstance. The matching proposal made by the RCPC shall be
The decision of the NACC shall be appealable to the Court of Appeals within approved by the NACC, through the Executive Director.
ten (10) days from receipt of the Order by the interested party, otherwise the
same shall be final and executory (Sec. 17, Art. III, RA No. 11642). 4BLUE 95: Cases of step-parent adoption, relative adoption, and adult
adoption, shall not undergo the matching process: Provided, That the child
and the PAPs have been living in one household for not less than two (2)
years (Sec. 26, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).
2) BIOLOGICAL PARENT SEARCH

It shall be the duty of the NACC, LGU, or the child-placing or the child-caring
agency, which has custody of a child to exert all efforts using tri-media and any Personal appearance of PAPs in matching process
other possible means to locate the biological parents of the child and seek their
consent. If such effort fail, the child shall, if applicable, be registered as a To further ascertain fitness, qualifications, good intentions, and
foundling and subsequently be the subject of administrative proceedings where sincerity of PAPs, the handling RACCO shall require PAPs to
said child shall be declared abandoned: Provided, That if the adoptee is an adult, personally appear before it at least twice during the application
the biological parent search is at the discretion of the adoptee (Sec. 20, Art. III, RA period and on specific dates to be determined by the same (Sec. 27,
No. 11642). Art. IV, RA No. 11642)
6

5) ISSUANCE OF PRE-ADOPTION PLACEMENT AUTHORITY (PAPA) 8) ISSUANCE OF ORDER OF ADOPTION WHEN THE ADOPTION IS
GRANTED
Once a child is matched to an approved PAPs and was subsequently accepted, the NACC
through the RACCO shall authorize the pre-adoption placement of the child to the PAPs
if recommended by the appropriate social worker that there is a need for supervised trial If the STC, as may be applicable, is satisfactory to the parties and the NACC is convinced
custody prior to the filing of Petition for Adoption, and in cases when there is no decision that, from the trial custody report, the petition and its supporting documents including the
on the Petition for Adoption within sixty (6)) calendar days from the receipt of the STC report if applicable, that the adoption shall redound to the best interest of the child or
Deputy Director for Services of the positive recommendation of the RACCO on the prospective adoptee, the NACC through the Executive Director, shall issue an Order of
petition, through no fault or negligence on the part of the PAPs. In cases of adult or Adoption which is a registrable civil registry document stating the name by which the
relative adoption, the PAPs shall automatically be issued a PAPA without undergoing the child shall be known and shall likewise direct the following to perform the actions as
matching process (Sec. 28, Art. IV, RA No. 11642). stated:

(a) The adopter to submit a certified true copy of the Order of Adoption to the
Civil Registrar where the child was originally registered within thirty (30) calendar
days from receipt of the Order of Adoption; and
6) SUPERVISED TRIAL CUSTODY (STC)
(b) The Civil Registrar of the place where the adoptee was registered:
Upon the recommendation of the adoption social worker of the need for STC, and after
(1) To seal the original birth record in the civil registry records which can be
the matching process and issuance of the PAPA, the NACC through the RACCO shall
opened only upon order of the NACC; and
give the adopters an STC over the adoptee for a period of not more than six (6) months
within which the parties are expected to adjust psychologically and emotionally to each
(2) To submit to the NACC proof of compliance with all the foregoing within
other and establish a bonding relationship.
thirty (30) calendar days from receipt of the Order of Adoption. An Order of
The STC shall be supervised and monitored monthly by the adoption social worker who
Adoption obtained under this Act shall have the same effect as a Decree of
prepared the child case study and home study report, and who shall submit a report
Adoption issued pursuant to the Domestic Adoption Act of 1998. A motion
regarding the placement. The PAPs shall assume all the responsibilities, rights, and duties
for reconsideration may be filed before the NACC, through the Executive
to which the biological parents are entitled from the date the adoptee is placed with the
Director, within fifteen (15) calendar days from an Order denying the
prospective adopters.
adoption (Sec. 34, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).
4BLUE95: The STC may be waived in all cases of stepchild, relative, infant, or adult
adoptions, as assessed and recommended by the adoption social worker. Further, for
regular cases, the STC may be reduced or waived depending on the assessment and
recommendation of the adoption social worker, and the express consent of the PAPs. For
independently placed cases, the adoption social worker shall prepare one postplacement
report recommending the qualified adoptive parents to continue their parental obligations
towards the child or adoptee (Sec. 29, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).

7) FILING OF PETITION FOR ADOPTION

The thriving parent-child relationship during the said STC, if recommended, as


substantiated by the monthly monitoring report of the adoption social worker, shall give
rise to the filling of a Petition for Adoption. In all cases, the Petition for Adoption shall be
prepared and signed by the petitioner or PAPs. The said petition shall state the facts
necessary to establish the merits of the petition.
The petitioners must specifically allege that they are at least twenty-five (25) years of
age, in possession of full civil capacity and legal rights; of good moral character; have not
been convicted of any crime involving moral turpitude; are emotionally and
psychologically capable of caring for children; are at least sixteen (16) years older than
the adoptee, unless the adopter is the biological parent of the adoptee or is the spouse of
the adoptee’s parent; and are in a position to support and care for their children in keeping
with the means of the family and have undergone pre-adoption services.

The petition should also indicate the new name the petitioner wishes the child to have, if
any. The petition shall be in the form of an affidavit and shall be subscribed and sworn to
by the petitioners before any person authorized by law to administer affirmation and
oaths. No subsequent petition involving the same PAPs shall be entertained unless the
prior petition has attained finality (Sec. 30, Art. IV, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).

Competent court in administrative adoption proceedings

Section 31 of Art. IV of RA No. 11642 provides that the petition for adoption shall be
filed with the RACCO of the city or municipality where the prospective adoptive parents
reside. Said provision states: “Section 31.

The petition together with complete and original supporting documents shall be filed by
the petitioners with the RACCO of the city or municipality where the PAPs reside. Upon
receipt by the RACCO of the petition and its supporting documents, a copy of the petition
shall be punished once a week for three (3) successive weeks in a newspaper of general
circulation.” Publication of the petition for administrative adoption Upon receipt by the
RACCO of the petition and its supporting documents, a copy of the petition shall be
published once a week for three (3) successive weeks in a newspaper of general
circulation (Sec. 31, Art. IV, RA No. 11642).

(ON THIS PHASE, FOLLOW THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS EXPLAINED


ON PAGE 4 )
7

HUSBAND & WIFE ADOPT JOINTLY


Use of middle name upon decree of adoption

In re: Petition for Adoption of Michelle P. Lim, G.R. Nos. 168992-93, May In the matter of the adoption of Stephanie Nathy Garcia vs. Catindig, G.R. No.
21, 2009. 148311, March 31, 2005
Held: The law is clear. There is no room for ambiguity. Petitioner, having
remarried at the time the petitions for adoption were filed, must jointly adopt. Held: However, as correctly pointed out by the OSG, the members of the Civil
Since the petitions for adoption were filed only by petitioner herself, without Code and Family Law Committees that drafted the Family Code recognized the
joining her husband, Olario, the trial court was correct in denying the petitions for Filipino custom of adding the surname of the child’s mother as his middle name.
adoption on this ground. Nota bene:
In the Minutes of the Joint Meeting of the Civil Code and Family Law
As provided under Sec. 21 of Art. III of RA No. 11642, husband and wife are still Committees, the members approved the suggestion that the initial or surname of
required to adopt jointly, subject to certain exemptions. the mother should immediately precede the surname of the father, thus "Justice
Caguioa commented that there is a difference between the use by the wife of the
surname and that of the child because the father’s surname indicates the family to
which he belongs, for which reason he would insist on the use of the father’s
Qualification in adoption is personal, it could not be based on some other surname by the child but that, if he wants to, the child may also use the surname of
person, although relative of the adoptive parent. the mother. Justice Puno posed the question:

Landingan vs. Republic of the Philippines, G.R. No. 162928, June 27, 2006 If the child chooses to use the surname of the mother, how will his name be
Held: Since the primary consideration in adoption is the best interest of the child, written? Justice Caguioa replied that it is up to him but that his point is that it
it follows that the financial capacity of prospective parents should also be carefully should be mandatory that the child uses the surname of the father and permissive
evaluated and considered. Certainly, the adopter should be in position to support in the case of the surname of the mother. Being a legitimate child by virtue of her
the would-be adopted child or children, in keeping with the means of the family. . . adoption, it follows that Stephanie is entitled to all the rights provided by law to a
legitimate child without discrimination of any kind, including the right to bear the
4BLUE 95: At the time of the filing of the petition, petitioner was 57 years old, surname of her father and her mother, as discussed above.
employed on a part-time basis as a waitress, earning 5.15 US Dollars an hour and
tips around 1, 000 US Dollars a month. Petitioner knows that the limited income This is consistent with the intention of the members of the Civil Code and Family
might be a hindrance to the adoption proceedings. Law Committees as earlier discussed. In fact, it is a Filipino custom that the initial
or surname of the mother should immediately precede the surname of the father.
Additionally, as aptly stated by both parties, Stephanie’s continued use of her
mother’s surname (Garcia) as her middle name will maintain her maternal lineage.
RA 9255 allows the adopted child to use the surname of their father. Similar
application in adoption. It is to be noted that Article 189(3) of the Family Code and Section 18, Article V
of RA 8552 (law on adoption) provide that the adoptee remains an intestate heir of
Note that under RA 9255, other wise known as Revilla Law, illegitimate children his/her biological parent. Hence, Stephanie can well assert or claim her hereditary
are allowed to use the surname of their father. rights from her natural mother in the future
On the other hand, same application is also observed in adoption decree in which
the adopted child is allowed to use the surname of the adopter. Note that in this instant case, the adopted person here is the illegitimate child of
the adopter. Here, the SC allowed the adopted child to bear the surname of her
One of the effects of decree of adoption, according to Article 189 of the Family is: mother as her middle name. The “mother” that is being referred to here is the
"(1) For civil purposes, the adopted shall be deemed to be a legitimate child of the biological mother of the adopted child. To put it differently, the adopted child shall
adopters and both shall acquire the reciprocal rights and obligations arising from use the surname of the adopted father as her or his surname, and the surname of
the relationship of parent and child, including the right of the adopted to use the the biological mother, may be used as her or his middle name. The rule enunciated
surname of the adopters; in this case clearly demonstrates the beneficial view of our courts in relation to
adoption proceedings.

4BLUE 95: paano kung ang adopters ay mag-asawa, hindi ba’t they are required to
adopt jointly? Ano ang pwedeng gamitin na middle name ng adopted child? Yong
apilyedo ng natural mother niya? Yung apilyedo ng adoptive mother niya?
To put it simply, as it now stands, in case a child will be adopted by spouses Commentary/Suggested answer: In my humble opinion, the answer is provided to
who are required to adopt jointly, the adopted child has the following options us by Article 189 of the Family Code. This provision of Family Code provides for
with regard to the use of middle name: the rule on effects of adoption. Now, the rule provided under Art. 189 of the
Family Code was incorporated under RA No. 8552 or the Domestic Adoption Act.
1. Use the surname of the adoptive mother as the adopted’s middle name in In the same vein, the said rule was also made part of RA No. 11642, particularly,
accordance with Article 189 of the Family Code and Sec. 41 of RA No. under Sec. 41 of the said Act. Second paragraph of Sec. 41, Art. IV of RA No.
11642; or 11642 provides: “Section 41. Legitimacy. – the adoptee shall be considered the
legitimate child of the adopter for all intents and purposes and as such in entitled
2. Use the surname of the biological mother, if known, as mentioned in the to all the rights and obligations provided by law to legitimate children born to
case of In re: Stephanie Nathy vs. Catindig, G.R. No. 148311, March 31, them without discrimination of any kind.
2005. To this end, the adoptee is entitled to love, guidance, and support in keeping with
the means of the family. The legitimate filiation that is created between the adopter
and adoptee shall be extended to the adopter’s parents, adopter’s legitimate
siblings, and legitimate descendants.

The adopter is also given the right to choose the name by which the child is to be
known, consistent with the best interest of the child.” Note that under Article 189,
the adopted child has “the right to use the surname of the adopters”. This should
mean to say surname of the adoptive father as the surname of the adopted child,
and surname of the adoptive mother as his or her middle name. In the same vein,
the child may also use the surname of her biological mother, if known, in view of
the pronouncement of the Supreme Court in the case of In re: Stephanie Nathy vs.
Catindig, G.R. No. 148311, March 31, 2005.
8

POST ADOPTION SERVICES

DECISION IN PETITION FOR RESCISSION OF ADMINISTRATIVE


A. PRELIMINARIES TO ADOPTION TELLING.
ADOPTION
The adoption social worker handling the adopted child’s case shall assist the
If the NACC finds that the allegations of the petition for rescission are true, it shall render
adoptive parents in disclosing to the child the story about the adoption at an age
a decision ordering the rescission of administrative adoption, with or without costs, as
deemed proper by psychosocial standards: Provided, That the actual disclosure
justice requires. The NACC shall:
regarding the adoption shall be the duty of the adoptive parents (Section 44. Art.VI,
RA No. 11642).
(a) Order that the parental authority of the biological parent of the adoptee be
restored, upon petition of the biological parents and if in the best interest of the
B. SEARCH OR TRACING OF BIOLOGICAL FAMILY.
child, if the adoptee is still a minor or incapacitated, and declare that the reciprocal
rights and obligations of the adopter and the adoptee to each other shall be
Upon reaching the age of majority, the assistance of the NACC, LGU, or the
extinguished. If the biological parent of the adoptee has not filed a petition for
concerned child-caring or child-placing agency may be sought to trace the
restoration of parental authority, or is not known, or if restoring the parental
adoptee’s biological family and eventually have a face-toface meet-up. The right of
authority over the adoptee is not the latter’s best interest, the NACC shall take legal
the adoptee to identity shall take precedence over any other considerations:
custody over the adoptee if still a child;
Provided, That the adoptee, adoptive parents, and biological parents received
adequate preparation from an adoption social worker regarding the said meet up
(b) Declare that successional rights shall revert to its status prior to adoption, as of
(Section 45, Art. VI, RA No. 11642).
the date of decision. Vested rights acquired prior to administrative rescission shall
be respected;
C. AFTER-CARE MONITORING AND SUBMISSION OF REPORT.

(c) Order the adoptee to use the name stated in the original birth or foundling
Upon finalization of the adoption and the receipt of the amended birth certificate of
certificate; and
the child, the NACC shall monitor the parent-child relationship to ensure that the
adoption has redounded to the best interest of the child. A Closing Summary Report
(d) Order the Civil Registrar where the adoption order was registered to cancel the
shall be prepared by the handling adoption social worker and submitted to the
new birth certificate of the adoptee and reinstate the original birth or foundling
NACC after completing the after-care monitoring to the adopters and adoptees after
certificate (Sec. 51, Art. VI, RA No. 11642).
one (1)-year period. Depending on the age and circumstances of the child, the
NACC may require additional visits or reporting after the one (1)-year period
(Section 46, Art. VI, RA No. 11642)

D. RESCISSION OF ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION (SECTION 47, ART. VI, EFFECTS OF RESCISSION OF ADMINISTRATIVE ADOPTION
RA NO. 11642).
If the petition for rescission of adoption is granted, the legal custody of the NACC shall
Right to rescind the adoption decree, vested to the adopted child; grounds thereof be restored if the adoptee is still a child. The reciprocal right and obligations of the
The adoption may be rescinded only upon the petition of the adoptee with the adopters and the adoptee to each other shall be extinguished.
NACC, or with the assistance of the SWDO if the adoptee is a minor, or if the
adoptee is eighteen (18) years of age or over but who is incapacitated or by his or In cases when the petition for rescission of adoption is granted and the biological parents
her guardian on any of the following grounds committed by the adopter(s): can prove that they are in a position to support and care for the child and it is in the
child’s best interest, the biological parents may petition the NACC for the restoration of
(a) Repeated physical or verbal maltreatment by the adopter despite having their parental authority over the child.
undergone counseling;
(b) Attempt on the life of the adoptee; The NACC shall order the Civil Registrar General to cancel the amended birth certificate
(c) Abandonment and failure to comply with parental obligations. and restore the original birth certificate of the adoptee. Succession rights shall revert to its
status prior to adoption, but only as of the date of the approval of the petition for
Adoption, being in the best interest of the child, shall bot be subject to rescission by rescission of adoption. Vested rights acquired prior to rescission shall be respected. All
the adopter. However, the adopter may disinherit the adoptee for causes provided in the foregoing effects of rescissions of adoption shall be without prejudice to the penalties
Article 919 of the Civil Code of the Philippines (Sec. 47, Art. VI, RA No. 11642). imposed under the Revised Penal Code if the criminal acts are properly proven (Sec. 53,
Art. VI, RA No. 11642).

Where to file petition for rescission of administrative adoption? Lahom vs. Sibulo, G.R. No. 143989, July 14, 2003
Held: The concept of "vested right" is a consequence of the constitutional guaranty of due
The petition shall be filed with the RACCO where the adoptee resides (Sec. process that expresses a present fixed interest which in right reason and natural justice is
48, Art. VI, RA No. 11642). protected against arbitrary state action; it includes not only legal or equitable title to the
enforcement of a demand but also exemptions from new obligations created after the
When to file petition for rescission of administrative adoption? right has become vested.

Upon existence of any ground or grounds mentioned in Section 47 of RA No. Rights are considered vested when the right to enjoyment is a present interest, absolute,
11642, the adoptee or the adoption social worker must file the petition for unconditional, and perfect or fixed and irrefutable. The Philippines, a State Party to the
rescission of adoption before the NACC (Sec. 49, Art. VI, RA No. 11642). Convention, accepted the principle that adoption was impressed with social and moral
responsibility, and that its underlying intent was geared to favor the adopted child. R.A.
Right to object petition for rescission of administrative adoption No. 8552 secured these rights and privileges for the adopted. Most importantly, it
affirmed the legitimate status of the adopted child, not only in his new family but also in
The NACC shall issue an order requiring the adverse party to answer the the society as well. The new law withdrew the right of an adopter to rescind the adoption
petition for rescission within fifteen (15) days from receipt of a copy thereof. decree and gave to the adopted child the sole right to sever the legal ties created by
The order and copy of the petition shall be served on the adverse party in such adoption.
manner as the NACC may direct (Sec. 50, Art. VI, RA No. 11642).
Remedy of the aggrieved adopter for the ungratefulness of the adopted child

While R.A. No. 8552 (this rule is also retained under RA No. 11642) has unqualifiedly
withdrawn from an adopter a consequential right to rescind the adoption decree even in
cases where the adoption might clearly turn out to be undesirable, it remains,
nevertheless, the bounden duty of the Court to apply the law.
Dura lex sed lex would be the hackneyed truism that those caught in the law have to live
with. It is still noteworthy, however, that an adopter, while barred from severing the legal
ties of adoption, can always for valid reasons cause the forfeiture of certain benefits
otherwise accruing to an undeserving child. For instance, upon the grounds recognized by
law, an adopter may deny to an adopted child his legitime and, by a will and testament,
may freely exclude him from having a share in the disposable portion of his estate.
(Lahom vs. Sibuo, Supra.)
9

RULE 103:CHANGE OF NAME

Notify the Solicitor General.


change of name under rule 103 is a judicial proceedings.

PROCEDURE FOR CHANGE OF NAME

Order for Hearing

If the verified petition is sufficient in substance and form, the court shall fix a date
and place for a HEARING by way of an order.

The ORDER shall be published for three (3) successive weeks in some newspaper
of general circulation published in the province. (Rule 103, Sec. 3)

Hearing

The date of the hearing shall NOT be within thirty (30) days prior to an election
nor within four (4) months after the LAST publication of notice. (Rule 103, Sec. 3)

Opposition

ANY interested person may oppose. The Solicitor General or the proper fiscal
SHALL appear on behalf of the Government. (Rule 103, Sec. 4)

Judgment

Upon satisfactory proof of compliance with the publication requirement and that
the allegations of the petition are true, the court shall adjudge that the name be
changed. (Rule 103, Sec. 5)

A procedure for correction of entries can be availed of to change the status from
married to single. Rule 108 cannot be availed of to determine the validity of
marriage, but the court cannot nullify the proceedings before the trial court where
all the parties had been given the opportunity to contest the allegations of
respondent; the procedures were followed, and all the evidence of the parties had
already been admitted and examined.

If applicant indeed sought, not the nullification of marriage as there was no


marriage to speak of, but the correction of the record of such marriage to reflect
the truth as set forth by the evidence. Otherwise stated, in allowing the correction
of the subject certificate of marriage by cancelling the wife portion thereof, the
trial court did not, in any way, declare the marriage void as there was no marriage
to speak of. (Republic v. Olaybar, G.R. No. 189538, 2014)
10

RULE 108: CANCELLATION OR CORRECTION OF ENTRIES IN THE Q: Drylvik, a German national, married Dara, a Filipina, in Dusseldorf, Germany. When
CIVIL REGISTRY the marriage collapsed, Dara filed a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage before
the RTC of Manila. Drylvik, on the other hand, was able to obtain a divorce decree from
According to 4blue95, there must be notification to the Civil Registrar. the German Family Court. The decree, in essence, states: The marriage of the Parties
contracted on xxx before the Civil Registrar of Dusseldorf is hereby dissolved. The
Who and Where to file petition parental custody of the children Diktor and Daus is granted to the father. Drylvik filed a
 Any person interested in any act, event, order or decree concerning the motion to dismiss in the RTC of Manila on the ground that the court no longer had
civil status of persons. jurisdiction over the matter as a decree of divorce had already been promulgated
 RTC of the province where the corresponding civil registrar is located dissolving his marriage to Dara. Dara objected, saying that while she was not challenging
the divorce decree, the case in the RTC still had to proceed for the purpose of
determining the issue of the children’s custody. Drylvik counters that the issue had been
Significance of R.A. No. 9048 disposed of in the divorce decree, thus constituting res judicata.

With the passage of RA 9048, an entry in a civil register may now be changed or a. Should Drylvik’s motion to dismiss be granted?
corrected when it involves clerical or typographical errors and change of first name, the A: No. The motion to dismiss cannot be granted. In Roehr v. Rodriguez (G.R. No.
day and month in the date of birth or sex of a person where it is patently clear that there 142820, 20 June 2003),the Supreme Court ruled that divorce decrees obtained by
was a clerical or typographical error or mistake in the entry, which can be corrected or foreigners in other countries are recognizable in our jurisdiction, but the legal effects
changed by the concerned city or municipal civil registrar or consul general (Republic thereof, e.g. on custody, care and support of the children, must still be determined by our
Act No. 9048, Sec. 1) courts. Before our courts can give the effect of res judicata to a foreign judgment, such as
the award of custody of the children, it must be shown that the parties opposed to the
Clerical or typographical errors in entries of the civil register are now to be corrected and judgment had been given ample opportunity to do so on grounds allowed under Section
changed without need of a judicial order and by the city or municipal civil registrar or 50, Rule 39. Rule 39, Section 50 states that “in case of a judgment against a person, the
consul general (Lee v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 118387, 2001) judgment is presumptive evidence of a right as between the parties and their successors in
interest by a subsequent title; but the judgment may be repelled by evidence of a want of
Coverage of R.A. No. 9048 Changes in entries in a civil register under R.A. No. 9048 are jurisdiction, want of notice to the party, collusion, fraud, or clear mistake of law or fact.”
limited only to clerical or typographical errors. These are errors that are “harmless and Thus, in actions in personam, a foreign judgment merely constitutes prima facie evidence
innocuous…which are visible to the eyes or obvious to the understanding and can be of the justness of the claim of a party and, as such, is subject to proof to the contrary. In
corrected or changed only by reference ot other existing record or records (Republic Act. this case, the divorce decree issued by the German Family Court merely constitutes prima
No. 9048, Sec. 2 (3)) facie evidence and it must be proven that Dara was given the opportunity to challenge the
judgment of the German court so that there is basis for declaring that judgment as res
The following entries may now be changed through administrative proceedings: judicata with regard to the rights of REMEDIAL Law 68 petitioner to have parental
custody of their two children.
1. First name
2. Nickname b. Is a foreign divorce decree between a foreign spouse and a Filipino spouse,
3. Day and month in the date of birth; and uncontested by both parties, sufficient by itself to cancel the entry in the civil registry
4. Sex pertaining to the spouses’ marriage? (2018 Bar)
A: No. A foreign divorce decree between a foreign spouse and a Filipino spouse,
uncontested by both parties is insufficient by itself to cancel the entry in the civil registry.
ENTRIES SUBJECT TO CANCELLATION OR CORRECTION UNDER RULE Before a foreign divorce decree can be recognized by our courts, the party pleading it
108, IN RELATION TO R.A. 9408 must prove the divorce as a fact and demonstrate its conformity to the foreign law
allowing it. (Republic v. Manalo, G.R. No. 221029, 24 April 2018)
Upon Good and Valid grounds, the Following Entries in the Civil register May be
Cancelled or Corrected:
Q: Ms. N initiated a special proceeding for the correction of entries in the civil registry
1. Births under Rule 108 of the Rules of Court before the Regional Trial Court (RTC), impleading
2. Marriage; only the Local Civil Registrar therein. In her petition, Ms. N sought to change the entry in
3. Deaths; her birth certificate with respect to the date of her parents' marriage from "May 22, 1992"
4. Legal separations; to "not married." The Office of the Solicitor General opposed the petition, arguing that
5. Judgments of annulments of marriage; Ms. N's parents should have been impleaded in the proceeding. In response, Ms. N
6. Judgments declaring marriages void from the beginning; argued that this was not necessary since it was an entry in her own birth certificate which
7. Legitimations; she intended to change. Hence, it was a matter personal to her, and as such, the
8. Adoptions; participation of her parents in the case could be dispensed with. Is Ms. N's position
9. Acknowledgments of natural children; correct? Explain. (2019 Bar)
10. Naturalization; A: No. Ms. N’s parents should be impleaded. The Civil Registrar, as well as all other
11. Election, loss or recovery of citizenship; persons who have or claim to have any interest that would be affected thereby, shall be
12. Civil interdiction; made respondents for the reason that they are indispensable parties. In Republic v. Uy
13. Judicial determination of filiation; (G.R. No. 198010, August 10, 2010), the Supreme Court nullified the trial court’s order
14. Voluntary emancipation of a minor; and to correct respondent’s entry for the latter’s failure to implead and notify not only the
15. Changes of name. (Rule 108, Sec. 2) Local Civil Registrar, but also her parents and siblings as the persons who have interest
and are affected by the changes or corrections sought.

PROCEDURE FOR CANCELLATION OR CORRECTION OF ENTRIES


IN THE CIVIL REGISTRY

Parties to the Proceeding

The Civil Registrar AND all interested persons shall be made parties to the
proceeding. (Rule 108, Sec. 3)

Notice and Publication

Persons named in the petition must be given NOTICE of the time and place set for
hearing the petition. Such order must also be PUBLISHED once a week for three
(3) consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the province. (Rule
108, Sec. 4)

General Rule: Notice and publication is mandatory.

Exception: There is substantial compliance when there is publication. It may be


deemed sufficient notice that vests jurisdiction with the court because an action to
correct and cancel entries is an action in rem. (Republic v. Kho G.R. No. 170340,
2007)

Opposition

The Civil Registrar AND any interested person MAY file his opposition within
fifteen (15) days.

You might also like