You are on page 1of 7

The Laryngoscop e

Li ppincott Wil lia ms & Wilkins, Inc., Philadelphia


© 2000 The America n Laryng ological,
Rhinologicsl a nd Otologica l Society, Inc.

Extradural Extranasal Combined


Transmaxillary Transsphenoidal Approach
to the Cavernous Sinus: A Minimally
Invasive Microsurgical Model
Ibrahim Sabit, MD; Steven D. Schaefer, MD; William T. Couldwell, MD, PhD

The authors have previously described an extra- employed to access vascular as well as invasive le-
dural transmaxillary approach to the anterior com· sions of the sellar and infrasellar region. The ap-
partment of the cavernous sinus. In an effort to ex- proach offers excellent visualization of the ipsilateral
pand the surgical access to that area without intracavernous carotid artery with both proximal
n cessitating a craniotomy or wide transfacial dissec· and distal control, a s well as cranial nerves ill, IV, VI,
tion, they present a modification of the transmaxil- V2, the hypophyseal r egion, and the medial a spect of
lary approach to the sellar region and cavernous si- the contralateral cavernous sinus. Key Words: Mini-
nus. Methods: The approach was developed on 12 mally invasive, maxillary sinus, sphenoid sinus, cav-
fresh and 12 embalmed cadaveric specimen, and 2 dry ernous sinus. ·
skulls. The initial sublabial incision is followed by a Laryngoscope, 110:286-291, 2000
maxillotomy to expose the course of the infraorbital
nerve (terminal branch of maxillary branch of the
trigeminal n erve) on the roof of the maxillary sinus. INTRODUCTION
The route of the infraorbital n erve is traced to the Despite the variety of approaches the n eurosurgeon
pterygopalatine fossa a s a guide to the foramen rotun- may employ to expose lesions in the cavernous sinus,
d um. Superomedial drilling of the foramen rotund um surgical access to this a rea remains a formidable task. The
is then p erformed to r eveal the contents of the supe- variations in the basic frontal, frontotemporal , and infra-
rior orbital fissure. After the n erves are safely identi·
fled in the superior orbital fi ssure, m edial enlarge- te mporal appr oaches documented in the liter ature for cav-
m ent of the window into the cavernous sinus is made ernous sinus surgery attest to the complexity of the anat-
possible by drilling the lateral and posterior wall and omy of the area.
septum of the sphenoid sinus. R esults: The combined Advances in microsurgical technique and instrumenta-
transmaxillary transsphenoidal approach offers an tion have offered better access to the skull base through
excellent exposure of the sellar and infrasellar r egion. combined neurosurgical and otolaryngological team ap-
The approach offer s clear visualization of the ipsilat· proaches. This collaboration has yielded advances in ante-
eral loop of the carotid artery, the pituitaryfossa, and rior transfacial approaches to the skull base including the
the cranial n erves of the ipsilateral cavernous sinus. transbasal, transnasal transsphenoidal, lateral rhinotomy,
Mean operative reach is 38 mm from the posterior transmaxillary transnasal, transoral, transcervical, and
wall of the maxillary sinus to the ipsilateral carotid midfacial degloving approaches.1- 10 These anterior ap-
loop and 56 mm to the contralateral loop. The width of
the operative window is 26 mm at the base within the pr oaches are popular because they avoid the need for crani-
cavernous sinus. Conclusion: The model offer s a min- otomy and brain retraction and offer better cosmetic out-
imally invasive approach that avoids the n eed for era· come. However, the variable access to the clivus and
niotomy or violating the nasal cavity. It may be safely infrahypophyseal region that these approaches offer re-
mains limited primarily to exposure of midline structures
From the Departments of Neurological S urgery (1.s., w.r .c.), New with limited lateral access. For more aggressive lesions with
York Medical ollege, Valhall a a nd New York, N ew York, and the Depart- skull base invasion from the middle fossa or the paranasal
ment of Otolaryngology (s.o.s.), New York Eye a nd Ea r Infirmary, New
sinuses, more invasive variations of the Caldwell-Luc
York, New York.
Editor's Note: This Manuscript was accepted for publication November
approach are warranted.s,11-13
18, 1999. The authors have recently described an extradural
Send Correspondenc to WiHia m T. Couldwell, MD , PhD, Professor transmaxillary model for access to lesions limited to the
and Chairma n, Department of Neurological Surgery, New York Medical anterior cavernous sinus.14 However, minimal medial reach
Coll ege, Mun g r Pavill ion, Valhalla, NY 10595, U .S.A. E-mail:
wi lliam_ couldwell@nymc.edu to the subhypophyseal region and insufficient control of the

Laryngoscope 11 O: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus

286
Fig. 2. After stripping of the mucosa, the course of the infraorbital
nerve (ION) and artery within the infraorbital canal is displayed In the
roof of the maxillary antrum. A thin layer of periosteum covers the
nerve inside the maxillary sinus (MS).

terminal branch of the V2, as a guide to the foramen rotundum, and


a cranial stage that begins at the level of the fora.men rotundum.

Extracranial Stage
A sublabial incision is made at the level of the lateral incisors
Fig . 1. A. Bony specimen depicting the osseous landmarks of the and extended posterolaterally to the third molar. Soft tissue eleva-
approach. The right maxilla has been osteomized to open the max-
tion to expose the maxilla is then performed up to the level of the
illary sinus (MS). SOF = superior orbital fissure, OC = optic canal.
B. Right sublabial incision extending beyond the second molar and infraorbital foramen to expose the infraorbital nerve and artery. The
superiorly to the infraorbital foramen (IOF). The lnfraorbital nerve surgical widow is afforded by a 2 X 2-cm osteotomy of the maxilla
and artery are reflected superiorly with the skin. extending to the frontal process of the maxilla, exercising care not to
damage the blood supply of the canine roots at the inferior aspect of
intracavemous carotid artery limit its application for resec- the field (Fig. 1). After the maxillotomy removal of the mucosa of the
maxillary sinus displays the course of the infraorbital nerve and
tion oflarge lesions.15 To facilitate access to the more m.idline
artery encased in the very thin bone of the infraorbital canal within
structures without violating the nasal cavity, we present an the roof of the maxillary antrum (Fig. 2).
extradural modified transmaxillary transsphenoidal ap- After identification of the infraorbital nerve in the sinus, the
proach to the cavernous sinus. posterior maxillary antrum is removed with a high-speed drill. This
allows access to the extracranial course of V2 from its exit in the
MATERIALS AND METIIODS foramen rotundum through the pterygopalatine fossa. With the
The dissections were carried out on 12 fresh an d 12 em- course ofV2 in view, enlargement of the osteotomy in the posterior
balmed cadaveric specimens and two dried bone specimens. Mi- wall of the maxillary sinus is carried out safely to expose the con-
crosurgical techniques and metric measurements were conducted tents of the pterygopalatine fossa (Fig. 3A). The internal maxillary
under a Zeiss OPMI 1 FC (Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) and artery and its terminal branch, the sphenopalatine artery, are iden-
documented using a Nikon FE camera with Kodak Ektachrome tified in their retroantral course. The sphenopalatine artery enters
200 film . A Midae Rex 3 drill was used for all bone drilling (Midas the sphenopalatine foramen to supply the nasopharynx. The supe-
Rex, Fort Worth, TX). rior aspect of the lateral pterygoid plate and V2 exiting the cranial
base from the foramen rotundum are clearly identified (Fig. 3B). The
SURGICAL APPROACH window in the posterior antral space is enlarged superiorly by thin-
The approach is conceptually divided into two stages: an ex- ning the bone of the orbital floor without entering the orbital fat pad.
tracranial stage that utilizes the course of the infraorbital nerve, the Inferior extension of the osteotomy allows for mobilization of the

Laryngoscope 110: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus
287
Fig. 4. A. Magnified view of a bony specimen displaying the trajec-
tory afforded after osteotomy of the lateral wall of the sphenoid
Fig. 3. A. Dissection of a dried bone specimen to reveal the rela- sinus (SS) and enlargement of the medial aspect of the foramen
tionship between the foramen rotundum, the superior orbital fissure rotundum (FR) and superior orbital fissure (SOF) to access the
(SOF), the superior aspect of the lateral pterygoid plate (LPP), and parasellar and infrasellar regions. The posterior limit of the approach
the sphenopalatine foramen (SPF), which emits the sphenopaiatine is the upper third of the ventral surface of th e clivus. B. After the
artery to the nasopharynx. B. Contents of the pterygopalatine fossa osteotomy described in panel A, the thin sellar floor is removed and
are displayed after a 2 x 2-cm osteotomy of the posterior wall of the periosteum removed to facilitate access to the vascular and neural
maxillary sinus. The maxillary division of the trlgeminai nerve (V2) structures of the cavernous sinus and sellar region. The anterior
exits the foramen rotundum, and courses immediately Inferior to the loop of the intracavernous portion of the internal carotid artery (ICA)
orbital floor (OF) in the infraorbltal canal. it gives Its first extracranlal laterally borders the pituitary gland, which is seen in its entirety (pit).
sensory branch, the posterior superior alveolar nerve (PSAN), which The cranial nerves of the right cavernous cavity are visualized in
supplies sensory endings to the molars. Coursing inferior and per- their course toward the superior orbital fiss ure (Ill, IV, VI = oculo-
pendicular to the nerve Is the Internal maxillary artery (IMA) whose motor, trochlear, and abducens nerve, respectively). The abducens
terminal branch is the sphenopalatine artery (SPA). The lateral wall nerve has been reflected laterally to facilitate visualization of IV
of the sphenoid sinus (SS) has been partially opened to reveal the
mucosa. The nasopharynx mucosa (NM) is reflected anteromedially.
mth care not to enter the nasal cavity. The extent of the osteotomy
sphenopalatine artery that otherwise would need to be embolized of the superomedial pterygoid plate (above the attachment of the
before surgery to minimi ze the risk of accidental rupture. However, pterygoid muscles) will be the limiting factor in determining the
the artery is routinely sacrificed in various procedures owing to the medial reach of the approach and is crucial to enabling adequate
extensive a.n astomosis around the nasopharynx and can be safely exposure of the medial cavernous compartment.
ligated during surgery. Furthermore, as the mucosa) branch of the
sph nopalatine artery is a common source of postoperative epistaxis Cranial Stage
when the sphenoid rostrum is opened, it is recommended that the With the foramen rotundum and V2 clearly identified, the
internal maxillary arte1y be ernboli zed before surgery. 1a.11 cranial aspect of the microdissection commences by exposing the
Finally, an osteotomy of the superomedial aspect of the ptery- anterolateral triangle of the cavernous sinus from below. Using a
goid plate is carried out to expand the medial extent of the approach, high-speed drill with a 2-mm diamond burr, the course of V2 in

Laryngoscope 11O: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus

288
th e foram en rotundum is exposed by drilling around the medial
course of the nerve. With adequate mobilization of V2, th e extra-
dural cranial base window is safely enlarged superiorly to trans-
form the foramen rotundum and superior orbital fi ssure into a
single fora men (Fig. 4A). The bone of th e floor of th e middle fossa
inferior to the anterolateral triangle of the cavernous sinus is
thicker on the lower aspect (28 mm for the course of the foramen
rotundum) but thins out markedly below the superior orbital
fi ss ure, which lies only 4 to 5 mm superior to the foram en rotun-
dum. Great care must be exercised during superior enl arge ment
of the window to include the superior orbita l fi ssure in order avoid
injury to the neural structures coursing through it (III, IV, Vl,
and VI).
After th e bone window is enlarged to encompass the superior
orbital fissure, the periosteum of the middle cranial floor is removed
and the contents of the superior orbital fissure are identified. Only
after the vital neura l structures of the superior orbital fissure are
safely visualized can medi al enlargement of the window into the
cavernous sinus be performed to gain access to the medial cavernous
compartment. This is effectuated by fi rst thinning the lateral wall of
the ipsilateral sphenoid sinus with a high-speed drill using a 2-mm
diamond burr, followed by carefully removing the remnant of the
lateral and posterior walls using microdissection tecluuques. The
variation in the anatomic architecture of the sphenoid sinus man-
dates a particular order of bone removal in the lateral sphenoidec-
tomy so as to avoid injury to the anterior loop of the carotid artery.
The artery lies in an impression on the superior part of the postero-
lateral wall of the sinus and,..in 66% of cadaveric specimens the
artery is covered by less than 1 mm of bone and by only the mucosa
of the sphenoid sinus in 4%. 18 Consequently, starting at the thick
bone of the floor of the middle fossa medial to the enlarged foram en
rotundum, the bone is drilled safely and propagated med.ially to-
ward the lateral sphenoid wall. After the anterior aspect of the
lateral wall is removed and the sinus opened, the mucosa is stripped
from the sphenoid sinus and the major septum extracted using
pituitary forceps. With the extent of carotid artery protection as-
sessed, more extensive bone drilling can safely be conducted to
medially extend the superior orbital fissure osteotorriy into the
opened sphenoid sinus. It is crucial to note that the inferior medial
wall of the optic canal protrudes into the superior lateral aspect of
the sphenoid sinus. The osseous shielding of the optic nerve in this
location may be very thin or absent, leaving the nerve vulnerable to
injury from both surgical manipulation and thermal damage. 18· 19
With the i.nfrasellar bone removed using microsurgical dissec-
tion techniques, the dural sac covering the pituitary gland is opened
to access the entire ipsilateral cavernous sinus and infrasellar re-
gion, as well as gain good visualization of the intracavernous carotid Fig. 5. A. With the sellar floor and anterior sphenoid wall removed,
artery (Fig. 4B). Finally, the anterior sphenoid wall is extracted with access to the contralateral cavernous sinus is obtained. The thin
lateral wall of the contralateral sphenoid sinus is removed around
pituitary forceps, and the nasopharyngeal mucosa anterior to the
the carotid impression to reveal the medial aspect of the extradural
sphenoid sinus is refl ected anteriorly to avoid its violation and to intracavernous internal carotid artery (ICA). B. lntradural exposure of
enhance viewing of the cavernous sinus. The lateral wall of the the medial contralateral cavernous sinus. The horizontal portion and
contralateral sphenoid wall is removed exercising the same care anterior loop of the lCA (C4 and CS segments) are seen inferior to
previously mentioned to access the contralateral cavernous sinus the proximal dural ring. The inferior hypophyseal trunk (IHT) arises
(Fig. 5a). The dura covering the medi al aspect of the contralateral from the medial aspect of the intracavernous ICA and supplies the
internal carotid artery OCA) is incised to open the cavernous cavity pituitary gland . The intracavernous course of VI is demonstrated in
and access its vascular and neural structures (Fig. 5B). this dissection , lateral and inferior to the ICA, and Inferior to Ill. A
medial view of trigeminal ganglion (TG) is seen on the lateral wall of
the contralateral cavernous sinus.
DISCUSSION
Traditionally, surgical access to the cavernous sinus
has been gained through some variation of the Dalene
approach, thus necessitating a craniotomy and brain re- base and sellar region in 1897. Modifications of that route
traction. Des pite the variety of permutations of the s tan- were quick to follow but still required extensive facial soft
dard approaches to the cavernous sinus, they all r emain tissue dissection and radical osteotomies. Among these,
highly invasive in nature, ranging from the s tandard fron- Schloffer's approach is the most popular. 2 1 Kanave122 pro-
totemporal to the radical midfacial degloving. Giordano20 posed a less invasive model in 1909 entailing a combined
first described the trans facial approaches to the cranial subnasal lateral rhinotomy approach. Also in 1909,

Laryngoscope 110: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus
289
TABLE I.
Measurements Between Bony Landmarks in the Transmaxillary Transsphenoidal Approach.
Average
Distance
{mm) SD{mm)

Posterior antral wall --> foremen rotundum 9.7 0.87


Foremen rotundum --> pterygoid plate 4.2 0.26
Depth of foramen rotundum (thickness) 23.1 3.17
Foremen rotundum --> superior orbital fissure 4.6 0.34
Foremen rotundum --> lateral wall of sphenold sinus 7.3 0.87
Superior orbital fissure --> lateral wall of sphenoid 3.7 1.09
sinus
Foremen rotundum --> clivus 49 5.88

Hirsch23 refined the technique to a strictly endonasal quires no extensive osteotomies of the facial bones or exter-
route without a need for a lateral rhinotomy. One year nal facial incisions, thus maintaining excellent cosmetic out-
later, Halstead.24 introduced the sublabial transnasal ap- come. The ability of this approach to avoid violation the
proach, which was adopted by Cushing26 in his early pi- nasopharynx and oropharynx is a further demonstration of
tuitary adenoma operations and reported a 5.2% mortality its minimally invasive nature. Closure and reconstruction of
r te. However, the transf: cial route was abandoned owing the base of the skull would be a clear advantage for this
to poor illumination and high incidence of meningitis. approach.
In more r cent years the introduction of the operating The operative reach afforded by this approach allows
microscope and advances in microsurgical instrumentation adequate access to the ipsilateral cavernous sinus, medial
as well as the use of antibiotics have led to the reexamina- aspect of the contralateral cavernous sinus, infrasellar and
tion of transfacial approaches. Anterior approaches to the subdiaphragmatic region, and ventral surface of the upper
skull base have offered various degrees of exposure to pri- third of the clivus (Table II). The adjoining of the foramen
marily midline lesions of the hypophysis, clivus, or poste- rotundum and superior orbital fissure into a single foramen
rior circulating vascular lesions, and include the trans- at the onset of the cranial course of the dissection allows
basal, xtended transfrontal, transseptal transsphenoidal, adequate and prompt visualization of cranial nerves III, IV,
facial translocation, transmaxillary, transmaxillary trans- V2, and VI lying lateral to the intracavernous carotid artery.
nasal, midfacial degloving, transoral, mandible splitting During the approach, venous bleeding encountered from the
transoral, transcervical transclival, and anterior cervi- cavernous sinus is controlled by gentle packing with oxidized
cal.4,5,7,9,10,12,2s-s2 For large or local extensions of the various regenerated cellulose (Surgical, Johnson & Johnson Medical,
lesions to the parasellar region, petrous bone, or cavernous Arlington, TX), a technique routinely used in transcranial
sinus, the limited lateral access and difficulty in attaining cavernous sinus dissection. By identifying the neural and
proximal control of the ICA confines the usefulness of these vascular contents of the cavernous sinus early, more medial
approaches. 8·19·18 exposure can be performed with decreased risk of iatrogenic
The proposed combined transmaxillary transsphenoi- injury to the carotid artery when opening the sphenoid sinus
dal approach offers a safe, minimally invasive extradural
to expose the infrasellar region and contralateral ICA. Renn
extranasal route to the entire cavernous sinus and provides
and Rhotonl8 noted that the distance between the intracav-
adequate lateral-to-medial reach in.to the parasellar region.
ernous carotid arteries ranged from 4 to 18 mm. For large
Owing to the satisfactory medial reach of the approach, an
invasive midline lesions of the cavernous sinus, approaching
important feature of this model is the adequate exposure of
both the ipsilateral and medial contralateral intracavernous
carotid arteries. Visualization of the contralateral cavernous
ICA extends to the entire C4-C5 segments (Fig. 5B). In
TABLE II.
addition, the lack of any contact with vital neural or vascular
Distances Between Key Structures in the Transmaxillary
structures before the opening of the cavernous window offers Transsphenoidal Approach.
a clear advantage for this microsurgical model. The course of
Average
the infraorbital nerve provides a clear and uncomplicated Distance
course to follow, leading into the cranial base and the floor of {mm) SD{mm)
the middle fossa. Furthermore, clear exposure of the fore- Course of V2 in pterygopalatlne fossa 9.7 0.87
men rotundum provides good orientation for the bony land-
Course of V2 in foramen rotundum 23.1 2.17
marks of the inferior skull base and infratemporal fossa.
Foramen rotundum --> anterior loop of 27.7 3.27
(Table I) ICA
Previous authors have noted the direct access and short ICA (ipsllateral) <- --> ICA (contralateral) 12.6 1.21
operative range afforded by transfacial approaches to gain
Foramen rotundum --> contralateral ICA 36.4 4.59
ac ess to the infrasellar region and clivus. 6 •27 •33 However,
unlike most previously published efforts, this approach re- ICA = Internal carotid artery.

Laryngoscope 110: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus

290
the lesions from the inferolateral orientation afforded by this 9. Sekhar LN, Nada A, Sen CN. The extended frontal approach to
procedure offers more lateral exposure than a standard tumors of the anterior, middle, and posterior skull base.
J Neurosurg 1992;76:198-206.
transsphenoidal approach. With a width 26 mm at the base 10. Stevenson GC, Stoney RJ, et al. A transcervical transclival to
of the operative field within the cavernous sinus, adequate the ventral surface of lhe brain stem for removal of clivus
proximal and distal control of the ipsilateral carotid artery is chordoma. J N eurosurg 1966;24:544-551.
easily established by the u se of aneurysm clips, as well as 11. Maira G, Anile C, Dossi GF, et al. Surgical treatment of cranio-
visualization of the medial aspect of the contralateral carotid pharyngiomas: an evaluation of the transsphenoidal and pte-
rional approaches. N eurosurgery 1995;36:715-724.
artery. The approach can be a safe alternative route 12. Price JC. The midfacial degloving approach to the central skull
for gaining access to locally aggressive lesions with signifi- base. Ear Nose Throat J 1986;65:174- 180.
cant lateral extension and involvement of the intra- 13. Wilson CB. Neurosurgical management of large and invasive
cavemous carotid artery: lesions that otherwise would re- pituitary tumors. In: Tindall FT, Collins WF, eds. Clinical
quire both a transsphenoidal and pterional approach for Management of Pituitary Disor<krs. New York, Raven Press,
1979:269- 276.
resection. 11 14. Couldwell WT. Sabit I, Rice D. Transmaxillary approach to the
anterior cavernous sinus: a microanatomic study. N eurosur·
CONCLUSION gery 1997;40(6): 1307- 1311.
The transmaxillary transsphenoidal approach can be 15. Sekhar LN. Comments, Transmaxillary approach to the ante-
u seful to neurosurgical and otolaryngological teams in rior cavernous sinus. N eurosurgery 1997;40(6):1307- 1311.
16. Black PM, Zervanas NT, Candia G. Incidence and management
a ddressing disease of the infrasellar and cavernous region of complications of transphenoidal operation for pituitary ad-
with lateral extension. Potential complications of this ap- enomas. Neurosurgery 1987;20:920 - 924.
proach include delayed postoperative epistaxis from the 17. Ciric I, Mikhael M, Stafford T, Lawson L, Garces R. Transsphe-
mucosa! branches of the sphenopalatine artery, and anes- noidal microsurgery for pituitary adenomas with long-term
follow up results. J Neurosurg 1983;59:395-401.
thesia of the upper lips and anterior maxillary teeth seen
18. Renn WH, Rhoton AL Jr. Microsurgical anatomy of the sellar
with the employment of the sublabial incision and re- region. J Neurosurg 1975;43:288-298.
moval of the maxillary spine.a4 .as The decreased sen sa- 19. Van Alyea OE. Sphenoid sinus: anatomic study, with of consid-
tion, however, is temporary in 90% of cases and delayed eration of the clinical significance of the structural character-
epistaxis can be avoided b preoperative embolization of istics of the sphenoid sinus. Arch Otolaiyngol 1941;34:
225-253.
the maxillary artery.17 •28 In addition, with exposure of the
20. Giordano F. Compendia Chir Oper Ital 1908;2:100.
carotid artery within the cavernous sinus or sphenoid, 21. Schlaffer H. Ergolgrieche Operation eines Hypophysentumors
clos ure of the wound should include fas cia! or muscle aufnasalem Wege. Wein Klin Wochenschur 1907;21:621.
covering to the region to decrease the exposure of the 22. Kanavel AB. The removal of the pituitary body by an intranasal
artery and reduce the risk of erosion. The approach can be route. JAMA 1909;53:1701- 1704.
tailored to provide access to the desired target area and 23. Hirsch 0. Ueber Methoden der operativen Behandlung von Hy-
pophysistumoren auf endonasalun Wage. Arch Laryngol Rhi·
can be attained by a purely extradural extranasal route. nol 1910;24: 129- 177.
This approach minimizes the need for the more invasive 24. Halstead AE. Remarks on operative treatment of tumors of the
trans facial approaches of the mid facial degloving, or use of hypophysis. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1910;10:494-502.
an external facial incision of the lateral rhinotomy opera- 25. Cushing H. The transsphenoidal method of access. In: Cushing
tion . It can be u sed in combination with supratentorial H, ed. The Pituitary Body and Its Disorders. Philadelphia: JB
Lippincott, 1912:296-303.
approaches to provide complete access to disease of the 26. Cloward RB, Passarelli P. Removal of giant clival chordoma by
cavernous sinus. an anterior cervical approach. Surg N eurol 1979;11:129- 134.
27. Fraioli B, Esposito V, Jannetti G, Cantore G: Transmaxillary-
BIBLIOGRAPHY transsphenoidal. approach to tumors invading the medial
1. Allen GW, Seigel GJ. The sublabial for extensive nasal and compartment of the cavernous sinus. J Neurosurgery 1995;
82:63-69.
sinus resection . Laryngoscope 1981;1:1635-1639.
2. Anand VK, Conely JJ. Sublabial surgical approach to the nasal 28. Laws ER Jr. Clivus chordomas. In: Sekhar LN, Janecka IP, eds.
cav ity and par anasal sinuses . Laryngoscope 1883;93 : Surgery of Cranial Base Tumors . New York: Raven Press,
1483-1484. 1993:679 - 685.
3. Conley J , Price JC. Sublabial approach to nasal and nasopha- 29. Dolenc VV. Anatomy aruf. Surgery of the Cavernous S inus. New
ryngeal cavities. Am J Surg 1979;138:615-618. York, Springer-Verlag, 1989
4. DelgadoTE, Garrido E, Harwick RD. Labiomandibular trans- 30. Lee KJ. The sublabial transseptal transsphenoidal approach to
oral approach to chordomas of the clivus and upper cervical the hypophysis. Laryngoscope 1978;88:1- 65.
spine. Neurosurgery 1981;8:675-679. 31. Loyo M, Sanchez JD. The Transnasal Approach to the Cavern-
5. Derome PJ. Transbasal approach to tumors invading the skull ous Sinus. In: Dolenc VV, ed. Anatomy and Surgery of the
base. In: Schmidek HH, Sweet WH, eds. Operative Neurosur- Cavernous Sinus. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989:397- 403.
gical Techniques. vol l. New York: Grune & Stratton, 1988: 32. Wilson CP. Transmaxillary approach to the vertebral artery
619 - 633. aneurysm. Ann R Austr Coll Dent Surg 1991;11:278-283.
6. Inoue T, Rhoton AL Jr, Barry ME. Surgical approaches to the 33. Rabadan A, Contesa H. Transmaxillary transnasal approach to
cavernous sinus: a microsurgical study. Neurosurgery 1990; the anterior clivus: a microsurgical anatomic model. N euro-
26:903- 932. surgery 1992;30:473-482.
7. James D, Crockard AH. Surgical access to the base of the skull 34. Nabe-Neilson J . Nasal complications after transsphenoidal sur-
and upper cervical spine by extended maxillotomy. Neurosur- gery for pituitary pathologies. Acta Neorochir (Wein) 1989;96:
gery 1991;29:411-416. 122-125.
8. Sekhar LN, Moller AR. Operative management of tumors in- 35. Watson SW, Sinn DP, Neuwelt EA. Dental consideration in the
volving the cavernous sinus. J Neurosurgery 1986;64 : transsphenoidal surgical approach to the pituitary gland.
879-889. Neurosurgery 1982;10:236-241.

Laryngoscope 110: February 2000 Sabit et al: Minimally Invasive Approach to the Cavernous Sinus
291

You might also like