Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/283949335
CITATIONS READS
6 329
1 author:
Thomas Headland
SIL International Dallas Texas USA
95 PUBLICATIONS 2,777 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Thomas Headland on 16 November 2015.
Thomas N.Headland
Summa Institute of Linguistics
Naruli, Bukidnon
The Dumagat method of teeth mutilation (Frazer 1959: 17; see also Van Gennep 1960,
is to saw through the top six incisors and canines Grosvenor 1969, Howitt 1904, and Spencer and
with a file so that they are flat and even with the Gillen 1899 and 1904).
gums and, usually, to keep them dyed black for
a few years afterwards. The operation is done in To my knowledge, only one article has
late puberty, for aesthetic reasons, and is purely appeared on teeth mutilation in the Philippines
voluntary. There is no religious or magical cere- (Galang 1941). However, brief descriptions on
mony attached to the custom. Between 1965 and the subject occur frequently in the literature.
1975 the operation was performed on approxi-
mately 26 percent of the teenage population. In Vietnam, several groups from the south
are reported to practice filing and blackening of
This paper will attempt to describe in full teeth. These are the Bahnar, Bru, Hre, Hroi, Jeh,
this teeth mutilation among the Dumagat, after Katu, Koho, Ma, Pacoh, Rengao, Sedang and
first making a brief survey of the phenomenon Tau-oi (see Maurice 1941, Mole 1970, Pichon
elsewhere in the Philippines, and in other areas 1938 and Schrock 1966). The language of the
of the world. A lengthy bibliography is included Hroi is Malayo-Polynesian; the others are
which should prove useful as a reference tool for Austroasiatic. Several northern groups are said
the researcher interested in a further comparative to practice teeth blackening, but not filing. These
study of the subject. are the Black Tai, Man, Muong, Tho, and White
Tai (see Schrock 1966 and Huard 1953).
The practice of teeth mutilation has been
found to occur in every major area of the world, For mention of the custom in other areas of
and is still practiced among several traditional Southeast Asia, see Alkema and Bezemer 1927,
ethnic groups in Southeast Asia. It is usually Covarrubias 1938, DuBois 1960, Evans 1937,
done for aesthetic reasons, though some groups Grosvenor 1969,Kennedy 1929, Schebesta 1973,
have been known to do it as a sign of mourning Steller and Aebersold 1959, and Wilken 1893. In
- . Africa, see Boulton 1941, Little 1951, Staub
in the Sula Islands, Salayar, Java, Australia and
Polynesia (see Wilkin 1893, Alkema and Bezemer 1936, and Werner 1906. On the American con-
.- 1927, and Spencer and Gillin 1927), and "among
the Australian tribes it was a common practice
tinent, see Conzemius 1932, Hrdlicka 1940,
Marden 1941, Stevens 1926, and Zahl 1959. In
to knock out one or more of a boy's front teeth Polynesia, see Alkema and Bezemer 1927. In
at [ceremonies of initiation into adulthood]" Australia, see Spencer 1927.
The data on Dumagat teeth mutilation wan gathered in and around the municipality of Casiguran from May
to September 1976, under the auspices of the Summa Institute of Linguistics. Other data on the Dumagrt has been
gathered by the author over a period of fourteen yean of intermittent residence among the Dumagat. Thanks are due
bo my ~0lleap8 Len Whalley for taking the photographs reproduced in this paper, and to David Thomas and Kenneth
Watt for mdriag several helpful comments on a preliminary version of the manuscript.
Headland / TEETH MUTILATION AMONG THE CASIGURAN DUMAGAT
A Survey of the methods ing the teeth black (Galang 1941, Conklin 1958).
Illustrations of Filipinos with mutilated teeth
Teeth are mutilated for beautification by appear in Barton 1930, Cole 1913, Cole 1956,
various methods of sawing, filing, chipping or Fox 1952, Galang 1941, Steller and Aebersold
dyeing. In some groups, teeth are knocked out 1959, and Worcester 1906. Also, four human
with a stone as a sign of mourning (see Alkema skulls appear on display in the Ayala hfuseurn in
and Bezemer 1927, and Wilken 1893). Makati, each with different types of mutilated
teeth.
Usually only the incisors and canines are
mutilated, and often just the upper incisors and Where the Custom is found
canines. Throughout Southeast Asia and the in the Philippines
Philippines the operation is done at puberty, The literature records that the practice of
and always for adornment plus peer pressure teeth filing or chipping has been reported to have
("so one won't look like a dog") (see Cole 1945 been practiced in at least the following Philippine
and 1956, Conklin 1958, Finley 1913, Garvan groups: the Bagobo (Cole 1913 and 1945), the
1964, Kennedy 1929, and Reed 1904).
Bisayans (Blair and Robertson, vol. 12), the
Practically everyone to whom I have described
Bukidnon (Cole 1956), the Hanunoo (Conklin
Dumagat teeth filing asks me the question, 1958), the Ilongot (Wilson 1947), the Mamanua
sometimes with a rather ethnocentric tone of Negritos (M. Maceda 1975), the Manobo (Garvan
criticism, "Why do they do it?" The answer is 1931), the Casiguran Dumagat (Turnbull 1929,
very simple: they d o it for beautification. But Vanoverbergh 1937-38, and Headland 1 9 7 9 ,
customs often look strange t o the outsider.
One anthropology textbook even refers t o it the Negritos of Pampanga (Worcester 1906), the
as a "most foolish" custom (Hoebel 1958: Negritos of Zarnbales (Reed 1904, and Fox
251), which of course it is not. I refer the 1952), the Remontados of Rizal (G. Maceda
reader who may still question the reasoning 1937), the Samal (Pallesen 1972), the Sambal
behind such a custom t o Miner (1956:504-05). (Blair and Robertson Vol. 16), the Sangil
Here Miner describes teeth mutilation among
the Nacirema tribe (spell it backwards), a (Maryott ms.), the Subanun (Christie 1909 and
group in which virtually every member Finley 1913), the Sulod Society (Jocano 1968),
submits t o the operation-a custom "which and the Tiruray (ScNegel 1971).
strikes the uninitiated stranger as revolting
because of the almost unbelievable ritual Barton 1931:37 refers t o tooth filing in his
torture of the client" (1956:505). work on the Ifugao, but does not specifically
state that it was an Ifugao custom. I found no
evidence in the literature that any of the
In the Philippines, there are six reported
Ifugao groups, or othergroups in theMountain
methods of teeth mutilation: (1) Filing the front Province, ever practiced teeth filing, and the
teeth down slightly so they are even (Steller and SIL teams presently working among four
Aebersold 1959, Cole 1956, G. Maceda 1937); different Ifugao dialect groups also report
(2) Filing or sawing the front teeth down even negative evidence (though some do blacken
their teeth).
with the gums (Finley 19 13, Headland 1975,
Conklin 1958); (3) Filing or chipping the front Several of my own colleagues with the SIL,
upper teeth to points (Worcester 1906, Garvan presently doing linguistic research in 56 different
1964); (4) Filing concave grooves on the outer cultural communities in the Philippines, re-
surface of the upper front teeth (Steller and ported to me (personal correspondence) that
Aebersold 1959, Galang 1941:426, ScNegel they have observed that tooth filing is still
1971); (5) Putting gold caps on filed teeth, or actively practiced by at least some people in the
gold fillings or brass wire in holes bored in the following groups: in Luzon: Zambales Aeta,
front teeth (Cole 1956, Pallesen 1972); (6) Dye- Casiguran Dumagat (Agta), Ilongot, and Palanan
PHILIPPINE QUARTERLY OF CULTURE AND SOCIETY 56
Dumagat (Agta); in Mindanao: Sangil, Sangi., have appeared on the Casiguran Dumagat (Vano-
llianen Manobo, Maranao, Tigwa Manobo, verbergh 1937-38, Headland and Headland 1974,
Cotabato Manobo, Tagakaulu Kalagan, Mamanua, Headland 1975, Estioko and Griffin 1975, etc.).
Ata Manobo, and T'boli; in Palawan: Kalarnian Forty-six percent of the adult Dumagat
Tagbanwa, Molbog; in the Sulu area: Central have filed teeth (gepgip) (59 adults out of a
Sinama (Samal), Yakan, Tausug and Southern sample of 128). Thirtyeight percent of all men
Samal. (24/63), and 54 percent of all women (35/65),
have filed teeth.
Other colleagues report that tooth filing was
once practiced, but has now ceased among the The statistical data for this section of the
following groups: Western Bukidnon Manobo, paper was drawn from a nonprobability
Mansaka, Binukid (Bukidnon) and Dibabawon sample taken in 1976 of 63 men and 65
Manobo. women, or 29.7 percent o f the adult
population.
Still others report that it has never been
practiced, to their knowledge, in the follow- To answer the question whether the custom
ing groups: in Luzon: Isneg, Ga'dang, Arnganad of teeth filing is dying out, we checked the
Ifugao, Antipolo Ifugao, Central Cagayan Agta, percentages of adults with filed teeth in each age
Urniray Dumagat, Northern Kankanay, Southern bracket. The results are shown in Table 1.
Kahga, Pasil Kahga, Southern Bontoc, Central These results show a definite pattern of slow
Kankanay, Ata Negrito; in Mindanao: Sarangani decrease in the percentage of people who have
Manobo, Chavacano, Bilaan; in Palawan: Batak had their teeth filed since the turn of the century.
(Negrito); in the Visayas: Masbatenyo; in the Whereas only one-fourth of the young adults (age
Batanes: Ivatan. 20-29) have their teeth filed today, approxi-
mately three out of four teenagers were having
The evidence we have been able to gather their teeth filed during the second decade of this
(admittedly still incomplete) indicates that teeth century. Each age group of Dumagat per decade
filing was probably practiced in every indgenous shows an approximately eight to twenty percent
community in Mindanao and Sulu in the past. In decrease in people with filed teeth from the
Luzon, it was practiced by four of the seven 1920's to the present. The evidence definitely
Negrito groups for which we have data, and not establishes, therefore, that the custom of teeth
by the other three, and by only one non-Negrito filing is slowly dying out among the Casiguran
group, the Ilongot. It was apparently never Dumagat.
practiced by any highland groups on Luzon. Our
data for the Visayas and Palawan is too sketchy Table 1. Frequency and Percentage Distribution
to say anything more than that it was practiced of Casiguran Dumagat with filed teeth,
by some groups there, the Hanunoo on Mindoro, by age group
the Sulod on Panay, and the Molbog and Kalarnian
Tagbanua in Palawan.
35.71%
are a Negrito band society living widely scattered 17 out of 30 56.67%
in the sub-province of Aurora on the eastern
coast of Luzon Island. Most of them live within 14 out of 21 66.67%
the municipal area of Casiguran. They number 8 outof 11 72.73%
431 adults and 337 children and teenagers I
(Headland 1977). Brief ethnographic descriptions TOTAL 59 out of 128 =461)9%
57 Headland / TEETH MUTILATION AMONG THE CASIGURAN DUMAGAT
Who does the filing? substantiate that hypothesis. And the fact that
the Palanan Dumagat, far to the north in Isabela,
Morice Vanoverbergh was strongly of the also praetice teeth filing, tends to further weaken
opinion that teeth frling is not indigenous among Vanoverbergh's hypothesis.
the Casiguran Dumagat, but was borrowed from
the neighboring Ilongot (1937-38). To test this Tools used in the operation
hypothesis we questioned a sample of 52 adults,
who had filed teeth, as to who had performed The main tools used in the operation are a
the operation on them. The answers are as threecomered file (kikil), a dull bolo (guho), - .
follows: a block of wood with cotton cloth wrapped
around it (sangal) and a piece of white bark
The person who does the filing is always an cloth (age). The size of the angal is approxi- *
adult male more than forty years old. Twenty- mately 2% by 1 % by % inches. The size of the
nine percent stated that an "uncle" (amoy) had age is about 5 by 6 inches. A small plate of water
performed the operation (we must interpret the and a kettle with a blackened bottom are also
term "uncle" loosely, since amoy can refer to necessary.
any male collateral relative, no matter how
distant, in the first ascending generation from Martines is said to wmetimes perform the
Ego, or even a non-relative). Of the 52 res- operation with the use of a hack saw. Infor-
mants tell me that before files were availabIe
pondents, eight percent had their teeth filed a dull bolo was used. Turnbull states that the
by their own father, six percent by Palanan operations, around 19 15, were "performed. . .
Dumagat (all different men from Palanan), and using an anow head" (1929:131).
six percent by Ilongot.
Thirteen percent had their teeth filed by a
The actual procedure
man named Martines, eight percent by Pedrin, It took a total of seventeen minutes to
and another eight percent by Ayogyog. These perform the operation on the sixteen year old
three men, all Casiguran Dumagat, are the only girl shown on the following plates. Martines was
ones in our data who stood out as having been the filer. Here is the sequence of the operation,
asked to file teeth many times. Pedrin and as my wife and I recorded it in our field notes,
Ayogyog do not have filed teeth themselves. on September 2,1976.
Martines had his teeth filed by his uncle Abundio
(deceased), and is the only Dumagat we know of (8:12) The girl lies down on a mat on the
who had his upper and lower front teeth filed, as sand, and the svlngal is inserted into the mouth
the Ilongot do it. for the girl to bite on, and the age is put over ,
begins sawing with the bolo again. The patient Post-operativeMedicinal Treatment
begins to wince from pain. (8:20) They let her sit
up and spit, and then the procedure is resumed. A day or so after the operation, when the
(8:22) The right medial incisor breaks off, and is teeth and gums become sore, a medicine is pre-
placed -by the fder in the plate of water. (8:23) pared from the vine amulong (Raphidophom
The left medial incisor breaks off, and is placed merrillii). When the pulp cavity (utdk) is sore, the
in the water. (8:24) The left lateral incisor breaks bark of the vine is peeled off, the bark is then
off, (Plate 3), and falls down into the patient's pounded or crushed to a pulp, and placed against
mouth, so they have her sit up and spit it out. the newly fded teeth. This is said to "draw out
The tooth is dropped into the water. (8:25) The the pulp of the tooth". This poultice is changed
right lateral incisor breaks off (Plate 4). A small three or four times a day. This procedure a h
amount of blood oozes out which is wiped off causes a temporary blackening of the teeth.
with a rag. (8:26) The rough edges are being An alternate medicine, used in a similar way,
fded smooth, and the tips only of the two upper is made from the vine dtdmon (species unidenti-
canines are fded flat. (8:28) Soot is scraped off fied). The leaves of this vine are made into a
the bottom of the kettle with the bolo and poultice, and applied to broken teeth to make
smeared with a finger onto the stumps of the the pain and swelling of gums subside.
teeth (Plate S), so that it will fill the now exposed Blackening the teeth
pulp cavities. (8:29) The operation is finished.
The girl stands up and giggles. The stumps of the Young people with fded teeth usually
teeth slant inward at a 45 degree angle when the blacken their teeth-in a custom called mdg-
girl is standing erect (Plate 6). banase-in the following way: A twig is taken
from the t m y a n tree (Stmmbosia philip
Plate 6 was photographed just a few minutes pinensis) and stuck into a fire. When the sap is
afZer the operation was completed. Sub- bubbling out of the end ofthe twig it is made to
sequent checking of the patient on following drip on the blade of a bolo. The finger is then
days ahowed no noticeable swelling, infection
or other complications. This girl, in contrast dipped into the sticky sap on the bolo, and the
to most patients, did not have her caninea sap is smeared on the teeth. This blackening is
l i k d flat down to the gums. usually done by unmarried teenagers, and the
custom is eventually dropped after marriage.
(8:30) The patient's father hands her a gawid Unmarried teenagers are said to do this fre-
leaf (Piper betle). She heats the leaf over the quently, as the black color does not last in-
4 s and begins continually patting her lips with definitely on the teeth. Mdgbanase is not a
it (this is said to prevent swelling). The utensils medical treatment, but is done for beautification.
are gathered and the broken teeth are c d y One Dumagat stated, "If we did not blacken our .
thrown into the grass. teeth, we would be an ugly sight, something
sickening to behold. We would look dirty."
BIBLIOGRAPHY
(In this bibliography,the pages which discuss NederWschdndie. Haarlem: H.D. Tjeenk
teeth mutilation occur in parentheses at the end WillinL en Zoon @. 518-23):
of each reference. Asterisks are found at the end M o p , Roy F .
of those references which are on file at the 1930 The Hav-Way Sun: Life Among the
HRAF at Ateneo de Manila University.) Headhunters of the Philippines. New
Yo*: Brewer and Wamn (pp. 37,40).*
Alkema, B. and TJ. Bezemer Blair, Emma H. and James A. Robertmn
1927 Beknopt Handboek dm Volkenkunde van 1903-1909 The Philipphe Ishnds, 1493-1898.
PHILIPPINE QUARTERLY OF CULTURE AND SOCIETY