Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The presented study proposes a framework for applying smart mobility in contemporary urban contexts.
Received 27 January 2022 It starts with a literature investigation and analysis; subsequently, it synthesizes the main key findings
Revised 8 September 2022 into a framework for applying smart mobility comprising five main dimensions, seven patterns, and 34
Accepted 16 September 2022
attributes. Then it applied a survey to investigate the applicability of 34 smart mobility attributes in
Available online 1 October 2022
two selected districts in Greater Cairo Region. Results of the presented work highlight the degree of exis-
tence of smart mobility attributes in the selected districts, through site visits and community survey.
Keywords:
Also, the five smart mobility dimensions are shown to be important regarding experts’ ratings which ran-
Smart cities
Smart urban mobility
ged from 3.5 to 4.7. In addition to smart mobility objectives which ratings ranged from 3.5 to 4.6. Finally,
Smart systems the study compared experts’ and users’ ratings for travel efficiency attributes. Moreover, it points out the
Transportation potential of smart mobility applications in the Egyptian context.
Sustainable mobility Ó 2022 THE AUTHORS. Published by Elsevier BV on behalf of Faculty of Engineering, Ain Shams Uni-
versity. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/
by-nc-nd/4.0/).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2022.101987
2090-4479/Ó 2022 THE AUTHORS. Published by Elsevier BV on behalf of Faculty of Engineering, Ain Shams University.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
desired travel attributes using smart navigations. Moreover, smart coexistence to develop the proposed framework and the case study
mobility offers higher connectivity, reliability, less time consump- research design (observation and analysis). Moreover, it adopted
tion, and integration [20]. However, many challenges face smart quantitative research tools namely; community survey in the
mobility in contemporary cities, such as; traffic management sys- selected cases, experts’ survey, and the travel attributes ratings.
tems, public transportation, parking systems, and safety of users Regarding keywords coexistence in previous publications; the
[21].Understanding the different aspects of smart mobility helps data collection process targeted relevant papers indexed in Web
overcome these challenges and find solutions to them, which of Science database and Scopus database which is known for its
accordingly enhance its performance and benefits[22,23]. broader coverage. Both databases will provide reasonable coverage
Many smart mobility initiatives took place as a part of the for the required research to build on the framework. The presented
transformation of cities from ordinary to smart ones. However, review covers research publications on smart mobility, sustainable
there is a lack of a standardized or consistent framework to apply mobility, mobility as a service, and intelligent mobility, which are
smart mobility in existing urban settings which will transform selected from papers in SCImago journal rank and indexed in Web
eventually into smart urban contexts [24]. Accordingly, the main of Science and Scopus databases in 2018–2022. A total of 1,668
objective of the research study is to develop a conceptual frame- research articles were retrieved from the selected databases. To
work and identify the main attributes for applying smart urban help in extracting data from previous literature and achieve the
mobility in contemporary cities. Moreover, it aims to assess the mentioned research objective, another round of the search was
applicability of smart mobility attributes in the Egyptian context. performed to reduce the number of articles contributing to the
Moreover, it aims to identify the Egyptian performance towards study. String used for the searching process was ‘smart mobility’
applying smart mobility strategies as an action of contemporary and ‘sustainable mobility’ or ‘smart cities’ or ‘smart city’ and ‘sus-
urban development. The study addresses the different technologi- tainable mobility’. This resulted in reducing the number to 750
cal interventions implemented in the field of urban mobility in research articles, 105 in Web of Science database and 545 in Sco-
contemporary cities [25]. Furthermore, it investigates the main pus database. Topics published in journals related to smart mobil-
definitions, dimensions, and patterns for smart urban mobility ity and smart cities were mapped using SciVal, in March 2022. To
through an integrative literature review. Then it synthesizes the highlight the research gap further reduction for the papers was
key findings of the review to develop a conceptual framework to performed, adopted from [31] which followed a specific criteria
help identify the main attributes of smart urban mobility. In the for papers’ selection. Accordingly, only peer reviewed journal arti-
light of the addressed problem and presented objective and aims, cles that are available online, with direct inclusion of smart mobil-
the study answers two main questions, (RQ1) What are the main ity and smart city as a topic and of high relevance to the research
dimensions and attributes for applying smart urban mobility? aim are selected. Thus 90 articles were included in the literature
(RQ2) What is the feasibility of applying smart mobility solutions analysis. Table 1 illustrates the adopted approach for the presented
and interventions in Egypt as a developing country? The presented study to highlight the research gap. The table covers the aspects
paper comprises five main sections including this introduction, that are required for the research in comparison with the most fea-
illustrated in Fig. 1. Then it is followed by the materials and meth- tured researches in the field.
ods section that describes the collection and analysis of data used According to the highlighted work, no research proposed a
in both the literature investigation and the selected case studies. framework including all the dimensions, objectives, patterns, and
The third section is the results of the review analysis which pre- attributes of smart mobility. To investigate the potentiality and
sents the key findings in the form of a conceptual framework syn- feasibility of applying smart mobility applications in Egypt, a case
thesizing different dimensions of smart urban mobility, its study research design method [30] was adopted in this study. Two
patterns, and accordingly identifying the attributes of applying regions in Greater Cairo Region (GCR) were selected one represent-
smart mobility. Also, this section comprises the main results of ing the old city center and the other representing the new settle-
the survey adopted to investigate smart mobility attributes in ment. Moreover, two surveys were designed as data gathering
the selected case studies in addition to the experts’ survey in addi- tools. A location-based community survey was conducted to inves-
tion to recommendations regarding smart mobility application in tigate mainly the state of awareness of smart mobility in the two
Egypt. Then the conclusion section which highlights the summary selected cases. In addition to a survey targeting experts in different
of the study presented in addition to the considerations and rec- fields of urban design and urban planning and relevant mobility
ommendations for the application of smart mobility in the Egyp- fields, was designed to rate the dimensions and objectives of smart
tian urban context. urban mobility.
The presented study follows a mixed-method data gathering To build a framework for applying smart mobility in contempo-
approach. Both qualitative and quantitative methods were used rary cities and to identify the main attributes for these purpose
for achieving the research’s main objective. First, the methodology four questions need to be answered. These questions are; what are
for the literature review was adopted from[26,27] to highlight the the dimensions needed for applying smart urban mobility? Why is
research gap and to answer the proposed research question (RQ1). the application of smart mobility needed in the selected area?
Collected data were reviewed and analyzed to identify dimensions How it will be applied? Who are the actors responsible for apply-
for smart mobility and related topics like smart cities, mobility dis- ing the selected mobility patterns? [25,38]. Each question presents
advantages, Mobility as a Service, and other connected topics a phase in the proposed framework. Smart mobility dimensions
[28,29]. Second, a case study research design method [30] was fol- (What) [39] are the Environmental dimension; which is related
lowed, to investigate the potential of applying smart mobility in to improving the environmental conditions within the different
Egypt. To answer the proposed research question (RQ2), an inves- challenges [14,37]. The social dimension; is more concerned with
tigation for the deduced attributes from a proposed smart mobility enhancing safety and increasing social interaction [40–42]. The
application framework on two selected districts in Greater Cairo technological dimension; encompasses different aspects like inte-
Region (GCR) was applied. The research adopted qualitative tools grating different types of technology for making services more
namely; literature collection and analysis according to keywords responsive to existing demand [22,40]. The economic dimension;
2
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
Table 1
Comparing previous studies to the current study and highlighting the research gap.
is more concerned with reducing costs and improving the effi- city regions [47]. The actors could be the decision-makers, who
ciency of implemented applications [14,43], and the Urban dimen- are important to be involved for consultancy and support by pro-
sion; is more related to spatial qualities and enhancing service viding information regarding the required actions needed, like
coverage, improving flexibility of services, and reducing travel time urban planners and designers, transport operators’ local and regio-
and congestion [44]. nal administrations. Stakeholders: like different regional and local
The objective of applying smart mobility actions (Why) is to organizations, private companies, and public bodies who are
maintain the achievement of one of the main six pillars of smart potential beneficiaries, they are considered important due to their
cities [45]. Accordingly, four guiding principles were identified to help with their public relations management and funding aspects.
apply the proposed framework. These objectives are Sustainability: Citizens and public transport users are important to be involved to
by enhancing the quality of the environment, providing clean and evaluate the different outcomes of smart mobility attributes and
green technology, and reducing related CO2 emissions. Safety: by actions [48].
enhancing safe, healthy, and equitable mobility for people, though Through the bibliographic research and after reviewing differ-
eliminating road accidents and offering clean mobility solutions. ent approaches and methods to identify smart city indicators,
Management: through optimizing traffic flow and reducing travel and to attain the objective of the current study; the research
times and traffic congestion in city areas with the help of data selected smart city methods that are targeting cities [49], commu-
and effective decision-making processes. Efficiency: reduces con- nities scale with main focus on the development of smart cities
gestion, offering diverse and cheaper solutions and options for strategies and mechanisms namely; CIVITAS II, U4SSC - ITU-T
users using smart navigations and mobility sharing options Y.4903/l.1603, CITYKEYS, and European Smart City Ranking in
[4,14,46]. It is important to identify (Who) should be involved in addition to relevant literature. Accordingly in the light of the pre-
the process of implementing smart mobility actions in different vious literature, a framework illustrating the main dimensions and
3
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
attributes of applying smart mobility could be developed (pre- main dimensions of smart mobility, which helped in better reading
sented in Fig. 2) – highlighting the main contribution to this study and interpretation for the different attributes within the proposed
– It answers the first research question (RQ1) What are the main framework. Patterns and attributes of smart mobility contribute
dimensions and attributes for applying smart urban mobility? mainly to the technological dimension since it mainly depends
Moreover, the study illustrates how implementing smart mobility on different technological applications like ICT, IoT wireless com-
in developing countries could be achieved depending on the four munication and 5G [18,59,65]. This contributes in increasing
main pillars (the dimensions, the objectives, the responsibility (ac- mobility’s efficiency, reliability and accessibility. Contribution to
tors), and the attributes). Fig. 2 illustrates the sequential flow and both urban and social dimensions was also significant; it could
the integration between the main components of the proposed be identified mainly in enhancing service coverage which in turn
framework of achieving smart mobility. increases accessibility. Reducing travel time and traffic congestion
The framework starts by identifying the main dimensions of [34,58], enhancing safety increasing social interaction and
smart mobility and the different objectives that are supposed to be enhances users health due to clean technologies adopted in mobil-
achieved after applying its different solutions in regards to four main ity solutions. Likewise, Environmental dimension and the attri-
points; sustainability, safety, management, and efficiency. Then the butes contribution to it, which could be identified in reducing
main actors responsible for different actions and contributions CO2 and greenhouse gas emissions [50,52,53] and providing eco-
regarding smart mobility are identified as follows: experts/ friendly solutions for the urban environment. This integration
decision-makers, citizens and stakeholders. Accordingly, the patterns between the different patterns, attributes and dimensions provides
and attributes that will help implement the proposed framework are healthy and integrated mixed modal access for modes of urban
identified after identifying their integration with the different dimen- mobility which mainly enhances the quality of urban life, fulfill cit-
sions of smart mobility [4,49–64] in Appendix 2. izens’ needs and promotes contemporary smart living.
Moreover, Fig. 3 shows a correlation chart showing the interre- The presented study aims to test the proposed framework by
lationship between the 34 attributes of smart mobility and the five previewing how it works through its four parts. A sample of 65
4
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
Fig. 3. Correlation chart mapping of smart mobility patterns, attributes and dimensions.
experts was selected to start answering a designed survey for the infrastructure to establish smart mobility systems since lots of
first two sectors (Dimensions and Objectives of smart mobility enhancements were executed in its roads network. It was already
application) since it is more reliable to the practitioners’ field, included in the existing underground metro system to link it to
and normal users are not familiar with the used scientific and tech- other major essential areas [66,67]. The Fifth Settlement: one of
nical aspects used in the presented framework. Nevertheless, a the luxurious districts in New Cairo, Egypt. It encompasses several
sample from the local community was selected to answer a locally private neighborhoods, served by Share‘El Tes‘een or 90 Street, the
based community survey including smart mobility attributes of the central axis of New Cairo. It comprises financial, commercial, and
fourth sector of the framework, as they are the end-users and the administrative centers that serve Greater Cairo as a whole
ones in direct contact with the patterns and attributes of urban [67,68]. The study aims to assess the applicability of smart mobil-
mobility. The third sector of the framework which is selecting ity attributes in the Egyptian context; this was based on data col-
the responsible actor for talking actions could be identified accord- lection from official resources and references, in addition to a
ing to each specific case. community survey conducted by the authors of the presented
study. The two selected case studies only spot more details for a
deeper investigation of smart mobility attributes in the Egyptian
4. Case studies: Smart mobility implementation in Egypt context. Whereas, highlighting smart mobility application in Egypt
shall encompass mentioning four major projects regarding trans-
Two regions in GCR were selected; one in the downtown area forming the transportation system to become smart and environ-
(old urban settlement) and the other in a new urban settlement. mentally friendly [69]. The projects are; the electric Monorail,
Fig. 4 shows the selected case studies in GCR, it also shows the Smart super-jet of the administrative capital, the Electric trains
expected smart mobility mega-projects that are mainly concerned and finally the BRT of the ring road.
with connecting the New Administrative Capital with the heart of The location-based community survey was issued to the users
the city; this was the main reason for selecting both cases. in the two selected areas to help read the potential of applying
Misr El-Gedida (Heliopolis): A suburb that was established to be smart mobility interventions in Egypt. In addition to the transition
outside Cairo in 1905, but with the urban development and growth steps to smart mobility strategies from the residents’ points of
it became in the heart of GCR. It is used to be served by LRT (tram view and the awareness of the smart mobility attributes that are
system) but now it has been eliminated, however, it shows a good applied in selected districts. Participants were calculated according
5
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
Fig. 4. Selected case studies (showing future smart mobility projects by and beyond 2022).
to the population of each one of the selected regions, using the fol- systems which are presented in ‘‘Mwasalat Misr” and ‘‘Green bus”
lowing equation. mobile applications. These apps introduced smart management in
public transportation in Egypt. E-tickets systems allow to access
0:9604 Np public transport through smart cards or mobile e-payment. Smart
Nmin ¼ ; ½10 ð1Þ
0:009 Np þ 0:9604 applications for car sharing like ‘‘Uber”, ‘‘Careem” services, and
smart transportation systems allow real-time responses and
where Nmin is the minimum number of participants in the survey to
adjustments on the road which is very helpful for mobility services.
give 95 % confidence level and 3 % margin of error [10], and Np is the
Using smartphones, people can view their next stops and travel
total population number of the selected areas. Accordingly, a sam-
time for different trips, in addition to receiving notes and recom-
ple of 150 participants in both case studies was selected to give reli-
mendations for best routes or shortcuts during their trips using
able results at this level of the study. Regarding the survey targeting
GPS technologies. Smart applications also allow users to purchase
the experts, a sample of 60 experts was randomly selected to rate
and validate their tickets in case of public transport and pay for
the dimensions and objectives of urban mobility according to their
their trips in case using car-sharing services. All this is controlled
importance. All of the experts were Egyptian, with more than
through real-time data and information management and sharing.
7 years of experience, representing different expertise as follows:
According to the previous assessments of the attributes in both
40 % were urban designers, 32 % were architects, 16 % were urban
selected districts Table 2 shows the intensity of patterns of smart
planners, and 12 % were urban mobility and transportation experts.
mobility according to their existence in both districts.
Moreover, both surveys investigated travel attributes priorities
Regarding the awareness of the concept of smart mobility
according to different preferences. This was also included in the
51.7 % of the respondents appeared to be aware of the concept,
investigation to read the potentiality of applying smart urban
while 31.7 % had no idea about it. Moreover, 92.7 % are aware of
mobility in Egypt.
the Egyptian government projects in smart mobility, and 7.3 %
answered that they are not aware of these projects.
5. Results On the other hand, experts were asked to rate the dimensions
and objectives of smart urban mobility according to their impor-
Regarding investigating the existence of smart mobility attri- tance regarding their application in the Egyptian context. Experts’
butes in the selected districts, 24 attributes only appeared to exist ratings for the dimensions and objectives of smart urban mobility
according to the observation and community survey. The intensity are presented in Table 3. Their responses highlighted the impor-
of existence of each one of the attributes in terms of ‘‘high, med- tance of focusing on technological dimension (MR = 4.7) while
ium, and low” as grading. High: refers to the strong existence adopting smart urban mobility to ensure its users’ safety
and impact of the attribute on the residents. Medium: refers to (MR = 4.6), and enhance their health, increasing the chances of
moderate existence and impact of the attribute. Low: refers to adopting green solutions to guarantee its sustainability
weak existence and impact of the attribute. Some attributes did (MR = 4.3) as an objective and augment both environmental and
not exist at all in both cases; those are referred to as N/A not appli- urban dimension (MR = 4.2).
cable. For more elaboration intensity of the existence of the attri- The survey investigated travel efficiency attributes related to
butes is illustrated in Appendix 3. Moreover, Fig. 5 shows smart their travel journey and destination adopted from [70], to help bet-
mobility attributes in Misr El-Gedida as a sample. Some attributes ter understand the requirements and potentials of applying smart
are noticed through specific applications like; smart transportation mobility in Egypt. Participants were asked to rate according to
6
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
Table 2 6. Discussion
Assessment of smart mobility patterns for both case studies.
Misr El- Fifth According to the previous assessments of the smart urban
Gedida Settlement mobility attributes in both selected districts Table 5 shows the
Patterns (How?) Intensity Intensity intensity of the existence of the 34 patterns of smart mobility in
Parking and Management Low Low the Greater Cairo Region, to highlight its application potentiality
Traffic flow and circulation scheme Medium Medium in Egypt. Evidence of the presented results recommends focusing
Pedestrian and bicycle routes Medium Medium
Car-pooling and car/bike-sharing Medium Medium
on enhancing the low existing attributes and to manage the non-
services existing ones, by developing integrative strategies that adopt
Public transport and on-demand service High High implementing efficient smart mobility actions in GCR. This will
Roads and Infrastructure Low Low help achieve successful implementation of the patterns of urban
Ticket integration Low Low
mobility which will help achieve high efficiency of traffic manage-
ment with high security and safety benefits to the society. More-
over, it will offer a clean solution with a less negative impact on
their personal preferences, the travel attributes on a scale from the the environment and high benefits of reducing travel time index
most important (1) to the least (10). Table 4 shows the ratings for and offering more flexible mobility solutions for society. However,
both users and experts, in addition to their ranking order according the case studies showed some potential for applying smart mobil-
to their importance. Users’ ratings are considered compatible with ity in Egypt, namely: Infrastructure, existing roads network, and
what was presented in [70] while there is slight difference in current mobility development projects, in addition to well-
experts’ ratings. Consequently, applying smart mobility patterns controlled traffic and pedestrian routes.
shall be with consideration of achieving the users travel attributes The application of the proposed framework on the selected case
to ensure the quality of the smart mobility solutions and services studies pointed out its merits and potential as a convenient tool in
offered to citizens. Thus, it will help supporting stronger economy managing the complexities of applying smart urban mobility in
and higher living standard. This could be achieved by applying existing urban contexts. The tool allowed observation, mapping,
smart parking systems, on demand services, digital enhancements and analyzing each of the four main pillars; the dimensions, the
of roads infrastructures and online sharing services to help users objectives, the patterns, and attributes of smart urban mobility
reach their destination smoothly, on time and enjoy their travel altogether. It also highlights the features and interrelations of the
journey while being able to socially interact with each other. key components and attributes of urban mobility in two different
urban contexts. Moreover, applying the proposed framework shall
come from various sources and partnerships. It is recommended
that it shall encompass a team of decision-makers from city gover-
Table 3 nance, members of mobility and transportation programs, and
Experts’ ratings for the dimensions and objectives of smart urban mobility.
external partners. Regarding community awareness and accep-
Mean Ratings (MR) tance of smart mobility and smart transportation solutions, it is
Dimensions (What?) Environmental 4.2 highly recommended to be increased since it offers higher effi-
Social 3.5 ciency, accessibility, and safety for the usage of smart mobility
Technological 4.7 applications in society. For better reading and understanding for
Economic 4.0
the application and existence of smart mobility attributes, and
Urban 4.2
Objectives (Why?) Sustainability 4.3 according to the deduced correlation between the 34 attributes
Safety 4.6 and dimensions of smart mobility; it is possible to map the inten-
Efficiency 3.5 sity of smart mobility attributes’ existence on the proposed corre-
Management 3.5 lation chart as shown in Fig. 6.
7
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
Table 4
Rating of travel attributes.
Travel Attributes Experts Rating Experts Rank Users Rating Users Rank
To reach your destination as smoothly as possible 8.8 2 7.7 1
To reach your destination on time 9.4 1 7.6 2
To reach your destination ASAP 8.6 4 7.4 3
To be able to work on the way 4.7 9 6.5 4
To enjoy your trip and relax 7.7 7 5.9 5
To be able to plan your trip in advance and on the go 8.7 3 5.5 6
To not to be disturbed on the way 7.7 7 5.0 7
To have multiple travel mode options (maximum flexibility) 8.5 5 3.9 8
To be able to interact socially during your trip 6.0 8 3.5 9
To keep as low an environmental footprint as possible 7.9 6 3.1 10
development directives of the proposed framework were further The framework combines simplicity and flexibility of application
covered through experts’ survey and analysis for ratings of the which might be useful for policy and decision-makers to facilitate
dimensions and objectives of smart urban mobility. The applica- implementation of smart mobility and to plan inducements for their
tion of the framework on the selected case studies showed some development. To improve the results of the presented research, it is
implications for applying smart mobility in Egypt, namely: recommended to invite experts from other countries to compare the
similarities and differences of dimensions and objectives ratings.
All the five dimensions of smart urban mobility are important to Another suggestion is to investigate the applicability of the framework
be involved and taken into consideration during applying smart in rural areas to identify the differences from the urban areas in terms
mobility solutions in existing urban contexts, to ensure its of applications and required infrastructure. Findings and conclusions
success. point out suggestions for future research, namely further investigation
Integration between the different dimensions of smart mobility for the four parts of the proposed framework, investigating ratings and
to achieve higher performance is essential however, more opinions of experts and decision-makers regarding smart mobility
emphasis on technology and environmental dimension is essen- attributes, and investigating the adoption of decision-making methods
tial since it has shown a lack in its attributes. as a tool for implementing smart mobility strategies.
Reaching destinations on time in the most efficient and smooth
way is considered a high priority as a travel attribute according
8. Availability of data and materials
to the ratings of both experts and users. This should orient the
objectives of smart mobility implementation in Egypt.
All datasets generated and analysed during the current study
Identifying attributes is very beneficial for the application of
are available in the Mendeley Data repository at https://doi.org/
smart mobility in existing urban contexts as well as its integra-
10.17632/r5289384yd.1.
tion in mobility development projects; it also facilitates the
evaluation process.
Declaration of Competing Interest
There are on-going projects for developing roads network in
Egypt, which highlights the need for integrating smart mobility
The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
solutions as a part of the upgrading process, to guarantee its
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
efficiency and sustainability.
to influence the work reported in this paper.
9
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
10
S. Tarek and T. Ibrahim Nasreldin Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14 (2023) 101987
[56] Yamazato T, Kawagita N, Okada H, Fujii T, Yendo T, Arai S, et al. The uplink [67] Murshed SM, Ouf AM, Zafarany AF. Enabling quality of urban spaces in Cairo’s
visible light communication beacon system for universal traffic management. new suburban settlements: a community character approach for New Cairo,
IEEE Access 2017;5:22282–90. doi: https://doi.org/10.1109/ Egypt. J Eng Appl Sci 2021;68(1):28. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s44147-021-
ACCESS.2017.2759179. 00026-8.
[57] CIVITAS. Policy Advice notes: Smart mobility management measures; 2010. [68] Ghalib H, El-Khorazaty MT, Serag Y. New capital cities as tools of development
[Online]. Available: http://www.civitas.eu. and nation-building: review of Astana and Egypt’s new administrative capital
[58] Errousso H, Malhene N, Benhadou S, Medromi H. Predicting car park city. Ain Shams Eng J 2021;12(3):3405–9. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
availability for a better delivery bay management. Procedia Comput Sci asej.2020.11.014.
2020;170:203–10. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.2020.03.026. [69] Selim T, Eltarabily MG. Impact of COVID-19 lockdown on small-scale farming
[59] CIVITAS Initiative, ‘‘CIVITAS: Cleaner and better transport in cities,” 2013. in Northeastern Nile Delta of Egypt and learned lessons for water conservation
https://civitas.eu/#::text=CIVITAS is a network of,for City VITAlity and potentials. Ain Shams Eng J 2022;13(4):101649. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Sustainability. asej.2021.11.018.
[60] Ho GT, Tsang YP, Wu CH, Wong WH, Choy KL. A computer vision-based [70] Noy K, Givoni M. Is ‘Smart mobility’ sustainable? examining the views and
roadside occupation surveillance system for intelligent transport in smart beliefs of transport’s technological entrepreneurs. Sustainability 2018;10(2).
cities. 2019;19(8), doi: 10.3390/s19081796. doi: 10.3390/su10020422.
[61] E. T. S. I. E. T. S. 103 463, ‘‘Key performance indicators for sustainable digital
multiservice cities:Technical specification.,” 2017. [Online]. Available: https://
www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/103463/01.01.01_60/
ts_103463v010101p.pdf. Tarek Ibrahim Nasreldin is an Associate Professor at the
[62] Groth S. Multimodal divide: Reproduction of transport poverty in smart department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo
mobility trends. Transp Res Part A Policy Pract 2019;125:56–71. doi: https:// University. He received his B.Sc Engineering (Architecture
doi.org/10.1016/j.tra.2019.04.018. engineering) his M.Sc. and his Ph.D degree from Faculty of
[63] Manders TN, Wieczorek AJ, Verbong GPJ. Understanding smart mobility Engineering Cairo University, Egypt in 2000, 2005, and
experiments in the Dutch automobility system: Who is involved and what 2010 respectively. Presently he is a lecturer at the AUC –
do they promise? Futures 2018;96:90–103. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/ interior design diploma- and Associate Professor at the
j.futures.2017.12.003. department of Architecture Nile University, and he is the
[64] Matyas M. Opportunities and barriers to multimodal cities: lessons learned manager of Center of Architectural and Engineering
from in-depth interviews about attitudes towards mobility as a service. Eur Design Support CAEDS- Faculty of Engineering, Cairo
Transp Res Rev 2020;12(1):7. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-020-0395- University since 2020. His area of research includes urban
z.
design, urban technology, and building technology.
[65] Diran D, Fleur VAN VEENSTRA A, Timan T, Testa P, Kirova M. Artificial
Intelligence in smart cities and urban mobility,” 2021. [Online]. Available:
Sara Tarek is Assistant Professor at the department of Architecture, Faculty of Engi-
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2021/662937/
IPOL_BRI(2021)662937_EN.pdf. neering, Cairo University. She holds a Ph.D. in Urban Design and Community Devel-
[66] Hassan P, Ibrahim S. People’s forces alliance for heritage preservation in urban opment, her research entitled ‘‘Urban Media Interventions: Redesigning Urban Spaces for
development projects: the case study of heliopolis (Masr El-Gedida), Egypt; Interactive Experience‘‘. Her research is situated in the field of architecture and urban
2021. p. 235–247. design, with a special focus on urban technology, smart sustainable urbanism and
urban computing.
11