You are on page 1of 8

JOURNAL OF BABYLONIAN JEWRY

SCRIBE
PUBLISHED BY T H E E X I L A R C H ' S F O U N D A T I O N

APRIL 1988 No. 26

40 YEARS O N veyard of the Jewish people?


Arab populations in and around
Israel have doubled and redoubled in
No Cause fur Ce ebrafie one generation. Israel's demographic
standstill can be seen as the bankrupt-
The trauma of Israel ever since its To make the confrontation equal cy of the Zionist philosophy.
inception in 1948 can be seen as a the Arabs have to be at risk to lose as Moreover, Israel refuses to make
continuation of the suffering of the much as Israel in an armed conflict. use of a powerful argument, namely
Jewish people this century, which Therefore Israel's overall aim should that 4(I years ago there was an ex-
culminated in the extermination of the be to create a Middle East confedera- change of refugees. To carry this
six millions at the hands of the Nazis. tion not dominated by the Arabs. argument to its logical conclusion the
The Holocaust lasted four years, but :Israel's occupation of Lebanon raised PaIestinian refugees, who have been
Israel's ordeal has been going on for our hopes in that direction, but that kept in camps by the Arabs for
forty years, and no relief is in sight. golden opportunity was bungled. political reasons, should be thrown
Those forty years included 5 wars, Likewise, Israelis who came from into the laps of their Arab brethren,
thousands of victims, endless acts of Arab countries have important econo- firstly by not offering them any em-
terrorism and crippling defence ex- mic and territorial claims on their ployment in Israel, and secondly, by
penditure that has s t y m i e d Israel's countries of origin. These claims have taxing the land in Judea, Samaria and
growth. This of course is in line with become vested in the State of Israel Gaza. The Arabs took our Iands by
the long term objectives of Israel's but the government does not want to conquest, we can recover it by taxa-
enemies. By slowly eroding the gains make capital out of this in case it will tion, in accordance with the Torah
of the six-day war the Arabs hope to prejudice the dominant position of commandment that every Jubilee all
put Israel in an impossible situation Ashkenazim viz-a-viz the Orientals land has to revert to the State.
that would eventually Iead to the and Sephardim. In any case, it is not usual to
destruction of the Jewish State. And Israel must increase its population celebrate 40 years of a happy event.. It
General Rabin, the architect of that from within and not by more aliyah. is either 25 years or 50 years - a silver
brilliant war is now reduced to chasing By swallowing the communities of the of golden jubilee. Forty years also
the teenage rabble of Gaza. Diaspora one after another, is Israel reminds us of Israelite wanderings in
Since Israel joined the United Na- destined to be, God forbid, the gra- the wilderness.®
tions over 100 new countries have 1

been admitted to that body without 40 years ago


problems or controversy. But Israel
has become increasingly isolated in the
world communitygaining new enemies
El Dangoor Refuses to Surrender
every day and losing old friends all the from
time. Israel cannot count even on full
American support. Slowly, the anti-
Israel international lobby has develo-
THE TIMES
ped into anti-Zionism and has now L O N D O N M A Y 17, 1948 Cairo, May T6
become open anti-semitism.
What is the remedy? A Communique by the Ministry of National Defence gave news of the progress of the
From the beginning Israel was man- Egyptian Army. It said:
oeuvered into ptaying Russian roulette "Egyptian forces crossed the eastern frontier at dawn on May 15. Our artillery went
with the Arabs. Heads they win, tails into action against the heavily fortified settlement of EL DANGOOR. The remainder of
our forces continued m advance, passing Khan Ycmnes. EL DANGOOR was wiped out
she loses. In other words, to survive, and set ablaze after the defenders refused to surrender. Our forces arc advancing towards
Israel has to win every confrontation Gaza which was entered at 6.45pm by our vanguard."
with her enemies. This unequal situa- E1 Dangoor was the site of kibbutz Nifim started in 1946 in the Western Negev, near
tion encouraged the Arabs not to the Egyptian frontier, in the neighbourhood of Nir Yitzhaq of today.
come to the negotiating table. Egypt The name derives from Rabbi Shalom Dangoor who was born in 1832 and studied
made peace only to recover Sinai and under Hakham Abdulla Somekh. He served for a short time as Dayyan. In 1897 he was
save its ailing economy from mounting appointed Rabbi in Egypt and stayed there for seven years. In t907 he was appointed
war expenditure; but it did not bring Chief Rabbi of Suez and stayed in this position till his death in 1916. He visited the Holy
an overall settlement any nearer. The Land five times between 1899 and 1914 and bought land there. When his sons asked him
threat remains from the "Eastern why he was buying land in the desert he replied: All of Erctz Israel is holy and our job is
to redeem it; so instead of buying a small piece in Jerusa[ern I bought enough land to
Front" where Syria's gas missiles pose contain two large cities.
as much a menace as atom bombs, and In 1962 his children left Egypt for USA.
Islamic fundamentalism has added a We salute the memory of the heroic defenders of El Dangoor and suggcst that the
new dimension to the equation. Israeli Government should revive the name there®

Page I
The Jews of Iraq between 1920 and 1970
Selections f r o m the p a p e r b y S i m h a Horesh Part 4
The 1958 Revolution [inpr[soncd. With this, the movement for " U n i t y countries were brought Jn to ill[ the vacancies
When Syria and Egypt formed the United n o w " was dealt a sharp blow. Brigadier A h m e d ensuing. T h e composition of the C o m m a n d
A r a b Republic, Ihis led to pro-Egyptian dis- Mohammed Y a h y a replaced him as minister of Council remained secret; most of its members
orders in Lebanon; lraq a n d Jordan soon interior. were reputed to be very young a n d inexperi-
afterwards, ht February i958, constituted the A provisional constitution was announced on enced in public affairs, a n d ahnost all came from
A r a b Federal:ion. King Husayn of Jordan, 271h July cancelling the 1925 organic law a n d its poor classes. T h e party militia, now called the
feaffut of the consequences of the Lebanese amendments. With that, all special regulations National G u a r d , was entrusted with the task of
disturbances on Jordan, requested the Iraqi regarding minorities were abolished. T h e consti- pursuing Communists a n d their sympathiscrs
government to send an armed force to be tution specified Islam as the religion of the state and in the process cumin{tied severe excesses.
stationed at the Syrian-Jordanian frontier. Bri- a n d guaranteed equality before the taw, free- There was a lack of co-ordination among the
gadier Abdul Kalim Oasseln took advantage of dora of thought a n d religion. T h e constitution Ba'ath party members a n d this considerably
the passage of the forces through Baghdad to regarded the Kurds as partners, with the Arabs, weakened them a n d eventually ted to their fall in
stage the i'evotution of the 14th July 1958. in the homehand a n d their national rights November t 963.
Qassem was a member of the Iraqi Free Officers (qawml~vya)within Iraqi unity were recognised. News of the Ba'ath c o o p i n [raq was received
movement, established in Jraq along the Egyp- Qassem's attitude to ini'norities was determined with feat" by the Iraqi Jews w h o hoped that
tian cxalnptc around 1952, a n d he rose to its through the concept of 'national unity through somehow Qassem would be able to put it down.
leadership. T h e Free Officers movement kept in revolutionary rebirth'. H e offered minorities Thch" hopes were dashed when Qassem was
touch with the opposition political parties o1: the complete equality of rights with the ultimate aim caught a n d executed. T h e early proclamations of
United National Front. T h e plan a n d details of of getting them completely assimilated. Indeed, the new regime h a d nothing in them to calm
the revolution were worked out by Oassem during his period in power, despite their initial Jewish fears. It is interesting to note that only in
himself. fears, the Jews h a d nothing to complain about. the version printed in the Official Gazette, was
T h e first notice of the revolution was broad- Jews w h o were serving sentences on charges of there a clause assuring the government's respect
cast on the radio carry in the inol'ning inviting Zionism and Communism were liberated a n d of minority rights a n d its intention of letting
the people to go a n d watch 'edifices of tyranny expelled from h'aq. At the beginning of 1961 an minorities take part in the 'National' life (this
ertnnblc'. Proclalnatkm No. 1 called on the amendment was published in the Official Gazet- was not in the broadcast version). Another
people to support the army a n d its rising against te to the law of 195I regarding supervision of the clause promised action with a view to achieve
the rnya] palace a n d the palace of Nurl a]-Sa'id. property of Jews (who left Iraq a n d did not A r a b unity a n d to recover 'occupied Palestine',
It demanded of the people to inform the return within a specified period a n d consequent- a n d these did not exactly alleviate the anxiety or
authorities about any corrupters ~to extract' ly lost their nationality). T h e law was stated as the Jews. Nevertheless, despite all the atrocities
them and destroy them. There was also the 'incompatible' with the principles of the revolu- it committed, the Ba'ath regime paid tittle
pledge of the formation of a 'popular' republic tion which promised equality for all. More than attention to the Jews, T h e only anti-Jewish
to uphold 'Iraqi unity' (a point very much 45(1 Jews expelled by Nuri al-Sa*id were provision was m a d e in April 1963, when a new
emphasised in the proclamation), to maintain attthorised to return to Iraq (though it is not taw ta replace the one abolished by Qassem was
bonds of fraternity with A r a b a n d Musliln known how many, if any, took advantage of this enacted, through whleh a Jew leaving lraq a n d
countries and to adhere to the United Nations taw). Nevertheless, the law was enthusiastically not returning within a specified period would
principles a n d honour pledges a n d treaties in received by the Jews as a sign of the positive lose his nationality a n d his property would be
accordance with the inlerests of the homeland. attitude of the government towards them. All confiscated. Otherwise, they were free to
The proclamation specified that a C~uneil of through Qassem's regime the Jews enjoyed full conduct their business a n d to travel.
Sovereignty h a d been appointed to serve tem- freedom in conducting their business and could T h e 18th November coup h a d followed a
porarily until such time its the people eIecte6 a leave lraq freely. troubled week in the Ba'ath leadership when
president.
rival factions struggled for control. T h e y were
T h e response to the revolution was over-
Arab Socialist Regimes out-manoeuvered fly the army officers led by
whclming, for a mob of hundreds of thousands
T h e Ba'ath party had, during the last two Aref and ousted from power. T h e National
came ~mt into the streets, wild a n d frenzied Guard was proclaimed d i s ~ l v e d a n d its mem-
'screaming its joy and its thirst for vengeance'. years of Qassem's regime, organised itself a n d
hers were ordered to hand in their arms. There
T h e mob attacked the British embassy, the royal trained a party of militia of thousands. T h e
was street fighting as some of them resisted, but
palaces, statues of King Faysat 1 a n d General militia came into good use when the Ba'ath
party staged its coup on Friday, 8th February the army was soon in control. A declaration
Maude (who led the 1917 British occupation of
signed by Aref was then broadcast explaining
Baghdad), Ioodng a n d destroying everything 1963, in cooperation with A r e f a n d some army
officers, when they took control of the streets the reasons for the coup a n d concentrating vast
until curfew was imposed attd quiet eventually
and fought the Communists who came out in powers in Aref's hands; h e was appointed
prevailed. In the meantime the whole royal
President of the (new) National Revolutionary
family was massacred a n d the body of Crown Qassem's support. Proclamation No. 1, broad-
cast on the morning of the 8th, declared that the C o m m a n d Council, C o m m a n d e r in Chief of the
Prince A b d u l llah was dragged in the streets a n d
'revolutlon h a d come to destroy those who h a d Armed Forces a n d he was vested with special
mutilated by the mob. T h e Jews were petrified powers to be renewed automatically if neces-
with teat', for the hysterical moh shouted slogans deviated the course of the I4th July revolution
a n d to restore its glorious march' a n d that sary. T h e declaration spoke of the formation of
calling for their deaths. T h e old regime, for all an advisory council from citizens of good
its evils, was at [cast known to them; now it h a d Qassem had been killed (Oassem was only killed
the next d a y in the afternoon). T h e broadcast reputation, qualifications a n d experience. This
all been destroyed a n d they feared whatever the was in line with Aref's known attachment to
new one would bring. A sickening lear surged text was without plan a n d barely coherent a n d
concentrated on inciting people against Qassom. traditional Islam, for a n 'advisor), council' was
through the Jews - a relic of the.days of June reminiscent of early Islam. Aref was pious,
1941 - of a n anti-Jewish attack b y the mob. A 'National Council for Revolutionary Com-
m a n d ' was set up to replace Qassem's govern- conservative in the extreme a n d this was
Proclamation No. 3, broadcast in the after-
ment; Aref was nominated President of the strongly felt in the cabinet programme
noon, declared martial law throughout lraq.
Republic to replace the Council of Sovereignty. announced on 24th December 1963. T h e lSth
Further proclamations were m a d e about the Novelnber revolution h a d come to correct the
Council of Sovereignty and its composition a n d Arel' h a d not played a prominent part in the
planning of the revolution; his relationship with 'again deviated" course of the 14th July revolu-
the appointment of Qassem as commander-in-
the Ba'ath party started with the conflict that tion, a n d added " W e h a v e in out" A r a b legacy
chief of the armed forces, prime minister a n d
broke immediately after the 1958 revolution and Islamic Shari'a, all that is needed to give our
acting minister of detcnce; A b d u l Salam Aref,
when hc espoused the Ba'athist d e m a n d for system meaning a n d content, without recourse
his active partner m the revolution, was to imported principles. Aref's piousness was said
appointed deputy commander-in-chief, deputy A r a b union, but tiffs was only temporary, for
Aref himself was not attracted to Ba'ath by some to h a v e been coupled with aversion to
prime minister amt acting minister of interior. In people of other faiths, a n d thal this was behind
the cabinet were represented all the political principles. T h e Ba'ath needed him as a figure-
the anti-Jewish measures taken immediately
groupings in the country except the Communist head to enhance the prestige of the party since
none of their leaders were known to the public. upon his coming to power.
party, but even so, it had sympath[sers in the
govermncnt. Aref was a ~crvent supporter of A n uneasy partnership was therefore m a d e T a h e r Y a h y a , a former member of the Free
President Nasser of Egypt a n d the champion of between the two for the purpose of the coup. Officers movement, was nominated prime
forces advocating "-Uni~y now'" ( w k h the United A purge of government institutions was minister in a cabinet composed of arm), officers
A r a b Republic). Soon Aref broke out with immediately embarked upon, especially in the a n d completely controlled b y the army.
Qassem a n d was relieved of his posts. He was ministry of education, to rid them of t h e i r Early in 1964 the Jews could no longer obtain
iater on accused of plotting against Qassem a n d 'Communist cells" a n d teachers from A r a b permission to travel. It was not declared

Page 2
officially; Jewish applications for passports [ was r e c e n t l y s h o w n a copy of The
simply did not receive any replies and the Jews Scribe w h i c h I f o u n d h~teresting a n d .
soon got the hint and stopped applying for
passports. Soon afterwards, the Land Registry d e l i g h t f u l . M y p a r e n t s w e r e b o r n in
office stopped registering transactions for Jews From Haham Dr. Solomon Gaon B a g h d a d a n d m i g r a t e d to A u s t r a l i a in
which meant that the Jews could no longer bay, I h a v e j u s t r e c e i v e d y o u r copies of 191t. •Mother's name: Khatena,
sell or mortgage property. When in July 1964 The Scribe, for w h i c h 1 t t i a n k y o u a n d F a t h e r ' s n a m e : C o h e n . Q u i t e possibly
there was a nat[onallsation of banks, industries which, as a l w a y s , 1 f o u n d m o s t in- I h a v e r e l a t i v e s , of w h o m 1 do n o t
and insurance companies, aE] faciIities at b~nks t e r e s t i n g , M o s t of t h e copies a r e s e n t
given to Jews were cancelled and I[ccnces for know,
Jewish insurance agents withheld. Jewish em- to t h e I r a q i c o m m u n i t y h e r c t h r o u g h I w o u l d b e pIeased to r e c e i v e y o u r
ployees in nationalised companies and industry the Spanish and Portuguese Congrega- publication.
were expelled from their jobs. Ivlost Jews being t i o n a n d I h a v e also d i s t r i b u t e d s o m e Sydney, Australia Rachel Share
engaged in free business enterprise, soc{alist of t h e copies a m o n g t h e s t u d e n t s of
ineasurcs were a severe Mow to them and indeed
it became increasingly difficult for Jews to Y e s h i v a U n i v e r s i t y w h o a r e , as y o u I a m a n x i o u s to a d d a c o m p l e t e file
continue working. know, very interested in what happens of y o u r j o u r n a l , r r o m its i n c e p t i o n , to
Again, [he Jews were required to gel new in t h e w o r l d of o u r i r a q i b r e t h r e n , o u r r e s e a r c h collection o f m a t e r i a l s
certificates to prove that they still had their Iraqi I must tell yon that I found very about Jewish communities throughout
nationality; the new certificates were given to i n t e r s t i n g t h e little p o e m s of E m i l t h e world. T h u s , I w o u l d be v e r y
them in the autumn of t964. However, with the
increasing number of Jews out of work and their M u r a d a n d I h a v e a s k e d t h e l i b r a r y to i n t e r e s t e d in r e c e i v i n g all a v a i l a b l e
despair of getting jobs or being able to leave o r d e r his novels f r o m Israel. I w a s issues a n d to h a v e t h e n a m e of o u r
Iraq legally, they started escaping across the e s p e c i a l l y i n t e r e s t e d to see t h e p h o t o - l i b r a r y a d d e d to y o u r p e r m a n e n t m a i l -
Iraqi border into Persia en inasse. The [and graphs of t h e y o u n g I r a q i J e w s w h o m I i n g list. I w o u l d , at t h e s a m e t i m e , t i k e
registry office still did not register transactions
for Jews and those escaping were forced to h a d k n o w n w h e n i b e g a n to m i n i s t e r to to l e a r n of a n y m o n o g r a p h s a n d
relinquish their property when they left it L a u d e r d a l e R o a d . I a m v e r y g l a d to pamphlets dealing with Babylonian
behind. The escapes were obviously with the h a v e t h e s e p h o t o g r a p h s a n d to b e Jewry that may be available through
government's knowledge, for an operation or r e m i n d e d of t h e s e y o u n g m e n . L e t u s the Exilarch's Foundation.
such dimensions could not go unnoticed. h o p e t h a t y o u n g H a y i m will soon bc B e s t wishes for t h e c o n t i n u e d suc-
However, the government turned a blind eye to
it alh well. cess of y o u r f i n e w o r k in E n g l a n d a n d
Dr AbduI-Rahman at-Bazzaz, an intimate Yeshiva University New York abroad,
friend of Aref and Iraq's ambassador to Britain, Price L i b r a r y o f J u d a i c a
was appointed deputy prime minister in a " Y o u n g " H a y i m c e l e b r a t e d in J a n u -
a r y , a m i d a n a v a l a n c h e of f l o w e r s a n d U n i v e r s i t y of F l o r i d a
government formed by Brigadier Arcf Abdul
Razzaq on 6th September 1965. Razzaq, a cards f r o m w e l l w i s h e r s , his 5 0 t h b i r t h - A few years ago I endowed a chair
~Nassarite', and some el' his supporters in the d a y a t t h e h o s p i t a l , by s t a n d i n g o n his
army, frastl'ated by the fact that unit}, with at P r i n c e t o n U n i v e r s i t y i n t h e n a m e of
Egypt had not materialiscd, planned to over- f e e t for 2 m i n u t e s for t h c first t i m e my father entitled "The Khedouri
throw Aref and demand imlnediate unity with since h e w a s t a k e n ill. [The Scribe] Z i l k h a Professorship for J e w i s h Civil-
Egypt, but Aref's brother Abdul Rahman isation in t h e N e a r E a s t " . Professor
succeeded in thwarting the attempted coup. I am delighted that you published
Bazzaz was appointed prime minister with the the abridged version of my article in A v r o m U d o v i t c h c u r r e n t l y holds t h e
aim of establishing a civil government that could t h e Masorti Journal I a d m i r e y o u r chair.
effect[very tackle internal problems and improve skill in p r o v i d i n g a n e x a c t precis of t h e M y p u r p o s e in h a v i n g d o n e t h a t w a s
conditions in the country. One highlight of t h a t P r i n c e t o n is t r a n s l a t i n g t h e papers
Bazzaz's shorl period in power was his gov- text.
I l o o k f o r w a r d to r e c e i v i n g f u t u r e f o u n d at t h e C a i r o G e n i z a . t b e c a m e
ernment's twelve-point programme for a settle-
ment of the Kurdish question which had been copies of yo/itr v e r y e l e g a n t , i n f o r m a - v e r y conscious of t h e fact t h a t t h e r e
one of iraq's worst problems. However, with t i v e a n d r e a d a b l e m a g a z i n e - if, as a w e r e , i n fact, v e r y f e w A r a b i c -
Bazzaz's replacement, this came to nothing and C a s t i l l i a n , I a m e i i g i b I e to r e c e i v e it. s p e a k i n g J e w s in t h e N e a r E a s t , a n d I
for all their ambitious plans•and programmes the w a n t e d a pIace to p r e s e r v e t h i s cul-
government under the Aref brothers accom- Gonville College,
plished very I[tfie. Cambridge (Dr) David Abulafia t u r e . It also h a p p e n e d t h a t b o t h m y
The appointment of Bazzaz had been received ( O f course y o u a r e - Ed} d a u g h t e r s h a d b e e n to P r i n c e t o n .
with a measure o[ relief by the Jews; for atong If y o u w o u l d l i k e to b e i n t o u c h w i t h
with his being a fervent proponent of Arab R e c e n t l y I c a m e across issue N o , 2 4 Professor U d o v i t c h to ask h i m a b o u t
nationalism, he was known to be balanced and of The Scribe, I w a s v e r y t h r i l l e d to his findings, his address is as follows:
moderate, and they hoped that their lot would
improve with him. When Aref was killed in a read the opening phrase describing the Professor A L U d o v i t c h , C h a i r m a n ,
plane crash in April 1966, he was succeeded by p u b I i c a f i o n as t h e J o u r n a l o f B a b y l o - N e a r E a s t e r n Studies D e p a r t m e n t ,
his brother Abdul Rahman who asked Bazzaz to nian Jewry. The phrase Babylonian P r i n c e t o n U n i v e r s i t y , 111 J o n e s H a l I ,
remain as prime minister. Baz.zaz became aIso J e w r y stirred a v e r y d e e p e m o t i o n P r i n c e t o n , N e w J e r s e y 08544.
minister of interior and in this capacity he had i n s i d e m c a n d b r o u g h t to m i n d s o m e
more centre[ of internal affairs. Eventually, an New York Ezra K Zilkha
improvement d~d come about I:or the Jews, for w o n d e r f u l m e m o r i e s f r o m t h e old
the Iand registry office was once again open to c o u n t r y a n d t h e old city of m y child- B e i n g o f I r a q i origin I f i n d 7 h e
them. Four Jews were granted passports and hood - Baghdad. I would like very Scribe h i g h l y i n t e r e s t i n g a n d w o u l d
allowed to leave Iraq (after leavinga deposit of a m u c h to r e c e i v e The Scribe in o r d e r to
thousand dinars, to be confiscated if they failed a p p r e c i a t e b e i n g i n c l u d e d in y o u r
to return wiflfin a specific period). This was very k e e p i n t o u c h w i t h m e m b e r s of t h e m a i l i n g list.
important for the Jews for the thing that B a b y l o n i a n J e w i s h c o m m u n i t y , a n d in T h e a r t i c l e " T h e J e w s of I r a q
bothered them most at the time was their d u e course I w o u l d b e m o r e t h a n b e t w e e n 192(I a n d t970'" m a k e s in-
inability to leave iraq legaIly_ When Bazzaz left h a p p y to p r o v i d e y o u w i t h n e w s a b o u t
for Moscow in August, the Jews awaited his t e r e s t i n g r e a d i n g . M y c o m p l i m e n t s to
m e m b e r s of t h e s m a l l I r a q i c o m m u n i t y Simha Horesh.
return with anticipation for the), believed lhat he
would continue with the trend he started and h e r e in b e a u t i f u l P e r t h , t h e c a p i t a l o f London, NW8 Abe Chitayat
that once again they would be free to travel. Western Australia.
However, here again they were disappointed for I w o u l d l i k e to c o n g r a t u l a t e y o u on T h e a r r i v a l o f 7 h e Scribe a t m y
he was replaced immediately upon his return. y o u r e x c e l l e n t service in p u b l i s h i n g h o m e is a t r e a t - j u s t l i k e t h e a r r i v a l o f
(The four Jews who left were tile last to leave
Iraq legally tip to 1971). In the meantime, up to this j o u r n a l . a n old f r i e n d a n d his views, a m u s i n g
April 1967 Jews continued escaping across the U n i v e r s i t y of (Prof) R o n y G a b b a y a n d welI i n f o r m e d a t t h e s a m e t i m e .
bordclt| Western Australia London, W 6 (Mrs) Violette S h a m a s h O

Page 3
• ' . :... . ..~':
Heskell, the Minister of Finance,
....
BOOKS
.:.
insisted that the royalties be paid in
gold. Britain, after much procrastina-
tion, had to yield. When it left the gold
Economic Policy in Iraq 1932-1950 standard, Iraq benefitted greatly from
by Joseph Sassoon this proviso. The first substantial pro-
Published by Frank Cass, London, duct and export of oil took place in
296 pp., price not stated. 1.934 and the revenues were ear-
(Some Iraqi Jews with "Sasson" m marked to implement major develop-
their names choose to spell it as ment schemes much needed by the
"Sassoon" in imitation of the famous country. Other oil wells have been
Sassoon family. But our author is a subsequently tapped in Mosul and
direct male descendant of the original Basrab.
Sheikh Sasson who was from 1781 to Trade was free until the Second
1817 Nasi of Baghdad as weI1 as World War years. However, in 1937,
Treasurer to the Turkish governor. In owing to the large influx of cheap
Arabic script the name reads as "Sa- Japanese goods and their successful
soon" and in view of his long connec- competition with British imports,
tion with the authorities this name Japanese goods were subjected to a
stuck and was kept by his son David ratio import/export system. This policy
Sassoo~ .) was then extended to goods from other
Review by Meer S Basri origins, e.g. Germany, Poland,
Iraq was the first mandated country Czechoslovakia, U.S.S.R., Italy and
in the Middle East to gain its inde- Switzerland. The ratio was raised to 25
pendence after World War I and was per cent. During the war a licensing
admitted to the League of Nations in system was introduced.
1932. Mr Sassoon discussed the various
When the British wrested Mesopo- aspects of economic conditions and
tamia, later known as Iraq, from the policies prevailing during the period
Turks they found a•shattered economy under review: Anglo-Iraqi relations,
and disrupted agriculture. They spent capital development works, finance
millions of pounds on their army of and banking, agriculture, foreign tra-
occupation and civil administration de, industry, oil and labour. His book
and, consequently, the country pros- will remain a source of valuable
pered and resumed its trade links with information for students and resear-
the outside world. chers of Iraq's economyO
This book is a welcome addition to Comment by N.E.D.
the literature on the economy of that Sir Sasson Heskell (or Eskell as he
country during the firs* years of its used to render it) is always remember-
independence and the crucial Second ed for stating the oil royalty in gold,
World War era. The author is well which was of great benefit to Iraq. But
placed to tackle his subject as he left he was not so mindful or successful
Baghdad aged twenty and came to concerning the welfare of our com-
England to grduate from St Antony's munity. In March 1921, at the Cairo
College, Oxford. His Arabic bibliogra- conference, he was readily persuaded
phy is extensive and includes my own by Winston Churchill, Col. Lawrence
book "Studies in Iraq's Economy" and Miss Bell to accept an Arab king
published nearly forty years ago, as for Iraq, which had been recognised as
well as the reports of the Baghdad not a predominantly Arab country.
Chamber of Commerce of which 1 was Heskelt put too much
director.
Iraq suffered enormously from the
world recession of 1929-30. However,
the year 1932 was important, not only
in political terms, but also in the
economic and financial fields. It saw
the introduction of the new Iraqi
currency, the dinar, which replaced
the Indian rupee. The Iraqi govern-
ment participated in the World Econo-
mic Conference held in London in
June 1932 and reaped the first benefits
of an independent state.
Oil, which was to become the prop
of Iraq's national economy, was disco-
vered before the First World War. In
1925 negotiations began with the Tur-
kish (later lraq) Petroleum Company
for the exploitation of this natural
resource. The Iraqi negotiator, Sasson
Page 4
by Alice Shashou
(Her own special recipes)
Cheese Baklawa
Grate 1 packet Haloumi cheese,
plus 1 packet Fetta cheese,
plus 1 packet Mozarella cheese.
Mix well. Butter a rectangular pyrex.
Use 1 packet of filo pastry. Divide in
two. Cut each foil in two. Put one
layer of pastry and brush lightly on one
side only with melted butter or melted
margarine. Continue arranging the
half packet of filo. Add the mixed
cheeses and make it even. Add the
other half of the pastry sheets after
buttering them. Cut in diamonds
(same as baklawa, only slightly big-
ger). Sprinkle with sesame seeds and
caraway seeds. You can freeze it. Naim Dangoor congratulating the Chief Rabbi on his elevation to the Peerage,
Before putting in the oven, beat 4 eggs
that billions were spent on settling
and 3A pint milk, mix and add on top
of the baklawa.
WOJAC Conference Jewish refugees and that therefore no
Bake in preheated hot oven for The Third International conference individual claims will be entertained!
about 10 minutes; lower and bake of W O I A C (World Organisation of This may apply to Jews who settled in
another 20 minutes or until set and Jews from Arab Countries) opened in Israel. What about Jews who settled in
cotoured. Washingtn on 26 October 1987 amid a Europe and America and whose
Take it out of the oven, cut it again spate of publicity and fanfare. But the wealth, which they left behind, was
deeply. Put the pyrex back in the oven quite substantial? The WOJAC execu-
most important resolution concerning
till crispy and well baked. Jews from Arab countries was passed tive decided years ago that the claims
Serve immediately. that day not in Washington but in the of these Jews should be vested in the
Knesset in Jerusalem, where it was State of Israel. Thus everybody will
A Variation of Kahi adopted by 100 members out of 120. It end up empty-handed.
Melt some butter and margarine. Take contained, inter alia, the following: This means that WOJAC is merely a
half a foil of pastry (for baklawa). propaganda platform for Israel, and a
Israel, far its part, has made it known that,
Butter it on both sides with a brush. within the framework of a peace settlement, i t
crude one at that; for the Israeli
Sprinkle with a filling made of: will be prepared to compensate the Arabs who establishment has consistently and
Ground walnut and a little sugar and ]eft Israel. I n the talks concerning this compensa- mysteriously refused to make capital
rose water. Fold it in two. Then fold it tion, the rights o f the Jews who were compelled out of the most important fact that 40
again in two. Put in preheated hot to leave the Arab states and abandon t h e i r years ago there was an exchange of
property w i l l be taken Into accoont.
oven and then reduce till golden in refugees, and that Jewish material,
coiour.'When nearly cold, pour on top If this indeed is t h e stance Israel is political and territorial rights in their
a syrup which was prepared one day or determined to take towards the issue countries of origin, far exceed Palesti-
two in advance. of compensation then it is logical and nian claims. To follow this reasoning
Syrup:4 cups sugar; 2 cups water; fair to require the government of to its logical conclusion, the process of
2 tablespoons of rose water; Israel to use part of the frozen assets of exchange of refugees should be com-
llA tablespoons of lemon juice. Palestinian Arabs to pay Jewish re- pleted by deporting the remaining
Dissolve the sugar in water on low fugees, say 50% of their claims. For Patestinian refugees into the lap of
fire; add the lemon juice and simmer this purpose it would be most useful their Arab brethren in order that they
until the syrup thickens and coats the and practical to invite Jews from Arab too carry out their part of the bargain
back of a spoon. countries to register their individual by absorbing and integrating the Pales-
Before you serve, arrange in a plate claims while they are still alive. tinian refugees just as Israel did with
and sprinkle with cinnamon powder. However, it is argued that in a peace the Jewish refugees.
Especially good when served with settlement, which Jerusalem badly A step in this direction would be to
clotted creamO wants, Israel may agree to pay the cease the employment of non-Israeli
Palestinians full compensation even Arabs in Israel. President Herzog
though Arab states will not reeognise informed us, during his visit to Lon-
Heritage Shop Jewish claims. This is what happened
at the peace negotiations with Egypt.
don, that 10l),000 such Arabs come to
Israel every day to work. These think
Home based charities are enthusias- But that would mean that the peace nothing of withdrawing their labour
tically taking advantage of the "all settlement is carried out at the expense when they feel they can harm the
aboard" charity shop at 255 Finchley of Jews from Arab countries. Having Israel economy. They should all be
Road, London NW3. The idea for the linked the claims of both sides in a set- sacked in one go and their places
shop arose as the result of numerous off calculation, the government of taken, not by imported labour from
telephone calls to the Board of De- Israel cannot escape assuming the Portugal or Vietnam, but by members
puties' Central Enquiry Desk. In order liability of making some payment to of the Israeli Defence Forces who
to assist with volunteers or goods the Jewish claimants. volunteer to fill the gap by doing
please phone 01-387 40440 Against this logic Israel has argued community workO
Page 5
"My grandfather went to Rangoon in
the I870s at about the same time as
Isaac Sofaer. My father and the rest of
the family joined him in 1894. In that
Abraham year H aham Ezra Dangoor arrived
with his family to become the Rabbi of
Rangoon but they returned to Bagh-
Sofaer dad a year later. In Rangoon Eliahou
Heskel Dangoor m et and married my
aunt. My father returned to Baghdad
Abraham Sofaer, who died in Los in 1915 where he opened a branch of
Angeles recently aged 91, was a BGSS. My uncle stayed in Rangoon
seasoned classical actor whose career and died there.
spanned over 60 years on the stage, in Isaac Sofaer became a wealthy prop-
films and on television and radio. erty owner and one of his buildings
He was born 1 October 1896 in was officially opened by the Governor-
Rangoon, the eldest child of R ahm a General of Burma with a
Solomon and Isaac Sofaer, a mer-
chant, who had emigrated to Burma
from Baghdad in 1877. He started as a
teacher in Rangoon where he met
Psyche Angela, a fellow teacher,
whose grandfather, Isaac Cohen, was
a famous Victorian figure who ran the
Pavilion Theatre in Whiteehapel when
it was the home of English melodra-
ma.
Abraham emigrated to England in
1920 and married Psyche in 1922. It is
interesting to recall that one of
Cohen's daughters (Psyche Sofaer's
aunt) married the man who was doing
the catering in Cohen's theatre - his
name was Joseph Lyons, who later
founded the famous restuarant chain
of J. Lyons.
Abraham's first appearance on stage
was a walk-in in 1921 in The Merchant
of Venice at the Palace Theatre,
Newark-on-Trent. In the twenties he
played over 100 classical roles on tour
and he pretty well made the part of
Shylock his own, a mouthpiece for all
the persecuted people in the world.
His performance as Othello in 1934
was recalled later in a leading article in
The Times as one of the four outstand-
ing renderings of that part in living
memory. He was regarded, in his
prime, as one of the best verse
speakers on the English stage.
Perhaps Sofaer's greatest successes
were his "Jewish" roles of Isaac Cohen
in The Matriarch and Benjamin Dis-
raeli in Victoria Regina which he
played more than 750 times in the late
thirties.
He entered films with Dreyfus and
The Wandering Jew in the thirties and
appeared in the following 40 years, in
over 40 films such as Qua Vadis (in
which he played the Apostle Paul). He
played opposite Elizabeth Taylor in
Elephant Walk which was recently
shown on Channel 4.
A m o n g Abraham's large clan is his
cousin's son Judge Abraham Sofaer,
legal adviser to the State Department
in Washington.
Mr Elias M. Sofaer writes,
Page 6
T h e M i s h n a h lists t e n social g r o u p s
S p o t an A n c e s t o r that returned from Babylonia with
Ezra about 430 B.C.E, Among these
A F U R T H E R S E L E C T I O N f r o m t h e R e g i s t e r "of m i l i t a r y t a x p a y e r s o f t h e categories t h e r e w e r e c o m p l e x r u l e s
B a g h d a d C o m m u n i t y of 1892, r e g a r d i n g w h o c o u l d m a r r y w h o m , for
Nessim Shmuel Nawi Heskel Moshe Settouna the g r o u p s c o n s t i t u t e d a distinct sociat
Heskel Reuben Nawi Heskel Ezra Salama p e c k i n g o r d e r , as follows, s t a r t i n g a t
Heskel Ezra Reuben Nawi Abraham "Yacoub Sopher t h e top:
Saleh Sleman Nawi Yosef Yacoub Sopher 1. K o h a n i m (priests) - M a l e dc~
Abdulla Dawid Heskel Nawi Heskel E1]ahou Sopher
Shlomo Reuben Nawi Yacoub Eliahou Sopher s e e n d a n t s of A a r o n , w h o w a s a
Moshe Kbdher Nawi Abraham Eliahou Sopher b r o t h e r of M o s e s a n d a descen-
t-[eskel Dawid Nawi Aharon Etiahou Sopher d a n t of L e v i .
Abraham Khdher Nawi Moshc Eliahou Sopher
Abdul Ezair Khdher Nawi Shlomo E]iahou Sopher 2. L e v i l c s - t h e o t h e r m a l e descen-
Shaul Saleh Khdher Nawi Aharon Eliahou Sopher d a n t s of L e v i , w h o s e r v e d as
Meir Selman Nawi Ezra Aharon Elia Sopher assistants to t h e K o h a n i m .
Eliahu Reubetl Nawi Abraham Ella Sopher 3. H a l a l i m - of N p r i n g of s o m e
Heskel Yosef Nawi Abraham Shuwa F.lia Sopher
Hcsket Ezra Yaconb Neqqash Yacoub Shuwa Etia Sopher forbiddcn marriages entered into
Eliahu Yacoub Neqqash Yishaq Eiia Sopher by priests.
Hesket Rahamin Neqqasb Heskel Abraham Ella Sopher 4. i s r a e l i t e s - all o t h e r J e w s of
HeskeI Yasef Neqqash Ella Yacoub Sopher u n b l e m i s h e d h e r i t a g e ( t h a t is,
Maatuq Yacoub Neqqash Elishaa' Sasson Sopher
Nessim Moshe Nessim Moshe Yishaq Sopher d e s c e n d a n t s of J a c o b w h o h a d
Abondi Yuosef Nessim and sons Moshe Dawid Sopher not i n t e r - m a r r i e d w i t h n o n -
Abraham Dawid Yacoub Nessim Yishaq Ahraham Yacoub Sopher Jews).
Nessim Shimeon Yosef Ness[m and son Abdulla Dawid Sopher
Yaeoub Sasson Nessim Ella Aharon Sopher 5, G c r i m - c o n v e r t s to J u d a i s m .
Yacoub Yosef Nessim Heskel Ezra Sasson Sopher 6. H a r u r i m - f r e e d slaves.
Yosef Yacoub Nessim Menashe Aharon Shlomo Sopher 7. iVIamzerim - b a s t a r d s . C h i l d r e n
Abraham Shalom Hakham Nessim Elishaa' Abdulla Dawid Sopher o f a m a r r i e d w o m a n n o t by h e r
Yosef Shalom Hakham Nessim Menashe Abdulla Dawid Sopher
Abraham Yishaq Hakham Nessim Ella Abraham Sopher husband,
Nessim Shimeon Muallem Nessim Yoscf Hcskcl Sopher 8. N e t i n i m - d e s c e n d a n t s of t h e
Moshe Yishaq Namerdi Saleh Aharon Shlomo Sopher G i b b e o n i t e s , w h o w e r e circum-
Mordechai Saleh Najma Abraham Ella Sopher
Heskel Ezra Saleh Najma Sasson Ezra Sehayeq cised at t h e t i m e of J o s h u a (1200
Sa]ch Bcnyamin Naftali Yosef Ella Sehayeq B.C.E.) and were not regarded
Yehuda Heskel Naftali Aboudi Rahamim Sehayeq as full J e w s b e c a u s e t h e i r conver-
Dawid Ezra Nurael Sasson Hayyu Sehayeq sion w a s n o t v o l u n t a r y .
Nessim Yacoub Naba'a Yehuda Y[shaq Sehayeq
Aboudi Moshe Darwish Saalehi Sh]omo Ezra Sehayeq 9. S h e t u k i m - p e r s o n s u n a b l e to
Dawid Nathan Saatchi Hougui Dawid Sehayeq identify their father.
Khdheri Muallem Sleman ¥oscf Rahamim Benvamin Sehayeq. 10. P e r s o n s u n a b l e to i d e n t i f y e i t h e r
So]man Hakham Sleman Sctman Rahamim Eshayeq
Yosef Sasson Hakham Sleman Ezra Heskel tIayim Eshayeq t h e i r f a t h e r or t h e i r m o t h e r .
Mordechai Abraham Asher Salem Ezra Eshayeq N o t i n c l u d e d in t h i s list w e r e g e n t i -
Rahmin Asher Salem Moshe Abraham Saleh Eshayeq les a n d slaves, w h o h a d n o l e g a l status
Ezra Asher Salem Ezra Sasson Sehayeq a t all i n J e w i s h l a w a t t h e t i m e , since
Salem Asher Salem Yosef Sasson Sehayeq
Eliahu Moshe Salem Yona Shimeon Eliahou Sehayeq J e w i s h law a p p l i e d o n l y to J e w s . It is
Yishaq Moshe Salem Eliahou Hayyu Sehayeq also i n t e r e s t i n g to n o t e t h a t t h i s social
Mual[em Mordecha[ Saleh Smaira Sasson Rahamim Sehayeq o r d e r a p p l i e s o n l y to J e w s w h o re-
Ne~sim Abraham Smaira Hougui Benyamin Sehayeq
Abrahamm Nessim Smaira Saleh Rahamim Schayueq t u r n e d to Israel f r o m t h e B a b y l o n i a n
Abraham Ezra Meir Smaira Eliahou Yishaq Somekh exile. A s l a t e as t h e t h i r d c e n t u r y C . E .
Eliahou Hcskel Shua Smaira Saleh Abdulla Somekh t h e J e w s still in B a b y l o n i a c o n t i n u e d
Eliahu Meir Smaira Ezra Abdulla Somekh to c l a i m t h a t t h e i r l i n e a g e w a s s u p e r i o r
Moshe Me[r Smaira tleskel Ezra Shlomo Somekh
I Ieskel Shua Samra Yosef Ezra ShIomo Somekh to t h a t of t h e P a l e s t i n i a n J e w s , o n t h e
Shaul Heskel Havim Shua Saturn Yacoub Shlomo Somekh theory that the only Jews who had
Abraham Shun Sam]'a Abrtaham tIayim Shlomo Somekh r e t u r n e d to Israel w i t h E z r a w e r e
Dawid Heskel Hayim Shua Samra Meir Abraham Somekh
Mena~he Abraham IIayim Yishaq Sleman Abraham Ezra Somekh those of l o w e r social g r o u p s w h o d i d n ' t
Heskel Shimeon Sleman Abdulla Saleh Somekh l i k e b e i n g t r e a t e d as second-class
Ezra Abraham Hayim Yishaq Sleman Abraham Yosef Somekh citizens i n B a b y l o n i a .
Yosef Selman Shimeon Sleman Eliahou Dawid Somekh (From "Finding our Fathers")@
Yacoub Selman Shimeon Selman Dawid Yehuda Yishaq Somekh
Eliahou Selman Shimeon Selman Yehuda Dawid Somekh
Mordechai Selman Shimeon Selman Abraham Meir Somekh
Yosef Yishaq Sleman Yosef Reuben Somekh The Mormon Genealogical Society
Saleh Reuben Yishaq Selrnan Meir Heskel Reuben Somekh has r e q u e s t e d t o f i l m aH o u r g e n e a l o g i -
Meir Yacoub Smouha Yacoub Reuben Somekh
Menashe Heskel Smouha Shmuel Shemtob Shmuel Somekh caf r e c o r d s o f t h e c o m m u n i t y f o r
Sbmuel Yosef Smouha Aharon Shmuel Somekh s a f e k e e p i 1 N in Utah, U S A , f o r the
Ezra Meir Yishaq Smmlh Menashe Yosef Somekh b e n e f i t o f researchers'. Howei~er, o n
Sclman Shmue] Smouha Shaul ¥osef Somekh
Heskel Yosef Smouha Sasson Yosef Somekh careful considerable& i t was d e c i d e d
Heskel Ezra SIoumi Yehuda Moshe Somekh t o d e c l i n e the o f f e r ~
P.S. The name "Sopher" is now spelled in It is idle to believe that the Hillelsof today are descended from Hitlel the Elder who, anyhow, had
various other forms: SOFAER, SOFAIR, atready [eft Babylon 2,000 years ago. Or that Mani's are descended from Jesse, father of King David;
SOFFAIR, SOFER, SOFFER, SAFIRO that the Sassoons' ancestor was Ibn Shoshan, prince of the community in Spain; that Shlomo-Dawid
I s there a colonel in the honse? indicates descent from King Solomom
It is said that Israel cannot keep the Territories In any case, in 10 generations the genes of an ancestor become diluted to I in a thousand; in 20
and remain a dcmocracy. generations to I in a million; in 30 generations to 1 in a billion, and so on. (Marrying first cousins
So, why not give up democracy!O •only halves this process). And here we are talking of 60, 70 and 80 generations!®
Page 7
Mr. Shlomo Hillel, Speaker o / t h e Knesset, aulographing his new b o o k at the special reception held in London.

material that can be useful to discus-


Operation Board of Deputies sion and study groups. Among recent
The triennial elections of deputies articles: On Darwin's Theory of Evo-
Babylon for the Board of Deputies of British
Jews are due to take place in April/
lution, The Hebrew Element in Every-
day English, Noah and the Ark Reex-
by Shlomo Hillel May 1988. amined. The Development of Biblical
published by Collins - £15 All members of the Iraqi Jewish Prayer, The Story of Creation, etc.
Shlomo Hillel, Speaker of the Knes- Comunity are invited to a Special Annual subscription is $12 or
set, and leading son of Babylonian General Meeting which will be held at equivalent, to be sent to the Society at
Jewry~ was in London in February to 14 Russell Road, London WI4, on 29A Keren Hayesod Street, Jerusa-
Tuesday, 10th May 1988, at 6.30pm lem, Israel 941881}
launch his book, being the English
version of his Hebrew bestseller on the for the election of Deputies to hold
Jewish Aliyah from Iraq. office until April 1991.
Candidates must be nominated by at
Nabucco
Shlomo was the prime mover of this
historic operation in which he was least five members. Nominations for Verdi's grand opera N a b u c c o will be
involved from the age of 24. During the three places allocated to our performed outside the ancient walls of
his daring exploits in the emigration of Congregation must be in writing and Jerusalem in the second half of May. It
130,000 Iraqi Jews he was given the accompanied by the written accept- deals with the first Exile to Babylon by
code name of Richard Armstrong. ance of the candidate and should be Nebuchadnezzar and includes the
During his week in London Mr. posted not later than 29th April. famous "Va, pensiero" aria sung by
Hitlel was acclaimed at various func- The elections will be carried out by the Hebrew captives.
tions and he gave several interesting those present at the Meeting: The N a b u c c o will be produced by Vittor-
talks on Israel's problems, past and Board of Deputies does not' allow io Rossi who has established an inter-
present. David Dangoor made the postal ballots or voting by proxyO national reputation for his out-door
observation, of which Mr. Hillel was productions and will include two choirs,
not aware, that just as the Israelites
were rescued from Pharaoh's Egypt
Dor-Le-Dor the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra and
an array of famous singers.
with a Strong Arm, the Jews of Iraq The World Jewish Bible Society in It is the international operatic event
were rescued by Armstrong! The book Jerusalem publishes an English- of the yearO
is pervaded by typical Hillel wit and language quarterly called Dor-Le-Dor
humour. directed especially to the lay reader
who wishes to further his understand-
Baghdadian Hagadah
Full reviews of this important addi-
tion to the history of Babylonian Jewry ing of Jewish Scripture, and to gain in Hebrew, Arabic
will appear in the next issue. Readers deeper appreciation of the various and English
are invited to send in their comments aspects of Biblical research.
Dor-Le-Dor contains a wealth of £3.75 + 25p. p&p
on the b o o k s
stimulating and thought-provoking 01-584 8778
Published by The Exitarch's Foundation, 20 Queen's Gate Terrace, London SW7 5PF. Editorial Adviser: Percy S. Gourgey, MBE.
Printed by Freedman Bros. (Printers) Ltd. London NWl 1. 01-458 3220

You might also like