You are on page 1of 36

SUPPLEMENT TO

Consistent Results
The full MS portfolio from Agilent

With a full portfolio of leading Mass


Spectrometry products, Agilent helps
businesses worldwide optimize their
assets and uptime. Just what you’d
expect from a company with over 35
5973 inert GC/MSD years of analytical testing expertise.

Our entire line of MS systems offer newly


developed technologies – they are more
7500 Series ICP-MS reliable, efficient, and produce higher
quality data than ever before. Each is
developed and tested to meet the individ-
ual needs of labs worldwide. Plus, our
global services and support network will
1100 Series LC/MS Quad,
Ion Trap, and TOF systems help you maximize the value, longevity,
and performance of your systems.

u.s. and canada 1-800-227-9770 Contact your Agilent representative or


www.agilent.com/chem/ms visit our web site for more information.

©Agilent Technologies. 2005 MC5307C


FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 3

Fast, Faster, Ultrafast: Optimization of


Cycle Times in Liquid Chromatography
for Optimum Speed and Resolution

T
he demand for greater sample tion but up to 20 higher throughput.
throughput and faster results in ● The combination with high speed LC
urgent situations has driven the equipment enables cycle times  60 s.
creation of fast or ultrafast analytical liquid ● When combined with automated and
chromatography (LC) methods. Today, sophisticated data evaluation, rapid
new and enhanced LC column and instru- data review of huge numbers of chro-
ment technologies are available to maxi- matograms and results is possible with-
mize sample throughput and provide sub- out compromising data quality.
stantial productivity improvements in the ● Furthermore, the needs regarding data
analytical laboratory. acquisition, chromatogram integration,
These new technologies are used to cre- reporting, data storage, and data trans-
ate solutions to reduce cycle time (the time fer to a laboratory information manage-
between injections) and can be adapted to ment system (LIMS) are discussed.
any specific application needs. These range
from high-throughput screening using Introduction
ultrafast LC–mass spectrometry (MS) The demands of high sample throughput
methods to any other applications where in condensed timeframes have given rise to
high resolution and shortened analysis high efficiency, fast LC. From the process-
times are desired. In this primer, we will ing of hundreds of samples in overnight
present and discuss different approaches to runs, to efficient and timely screening of
reducing cycle time for a variety of differ- metabolic studies, to rapid method devel-
ent application needs. We will consider opment, and to reducing solvent disposal
both improvements in column technology costs, fast chromatography has become a
and LC instrument design. necessity in the chromatography lab.
Several practical examples are presented, Using this new methodology, results can
which include recommendations on how be reported in a few hours, rather than a
to optimize standard LC equipment for day or even more. Complete validated
fast and ultrafast applications by utilizing results in such a short time mean that
current available replacement parts for manufactured goods can be released the
better performance. same day that they are produced. The end
These examples demonstrate that: result is greater productivity for customers
● New column technology enables ultra- and greater cost efficiency
fast analysis with runtimes  40 s.
● New column technology enables fast What Is Fast?
and ultrafast LC without loss in resolu- Fast is a relative term that is dependent
4 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

Eclipse XDB-C8 Rapid Resolution Eclipse XDB-C8


150 mm x 4.6 mm, 5 m 75 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
N = 12,000 N = 10,500

1 Analysis Solvent 1 Analysis Solvent


time waste 2 time waste
2 3 5
3 5 27 min 27 mL 14 min 14 mL
4 4
6 6
7 7

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 5 10 15
Time (min) Time (min)

Figure 1: Mobile phase: 35% 20 mM Na2HPO4, ph 7: 65% Methanol Temperature: 35 C.


Sample: 1. Uracil, 2. Butyl Paraben, 3. Propranolol, 4. Napthalene, 5. Dipropyl Phthalate,
6. Acenaphthene, 7. Amitriptyline.

upon each user’s requirement for speed and To provide a simple structure for this
resolution. If a 20-min separation can be discussion, we have categorized fast LC
completed in less than 5 min without res- into the following areas:
olution loss, the analyst clearly will tell you ● Ultrafast LC means cycle times
that is fast LC.  1 min.
An analyst with a 5-min run per sample ● Fast LC means cycle times  5 min.
would tell you that fast LC should be 1 ● Conventional LC means cycle times
min or less. Therefore, “fast” LC is a rela-  5 min.
tive term and is defined by the user as the We will examine applications in these
reduction in total analysis time or cycle areas and determine the columns and
time while maintaining the needed instrumentation needed to achieve these
resolution. cycle times.

A:B 70:30 2 80:20 1 2 90:10


3
1 3
5 6 Equilibration volume: 7.5 mL
4
4 5
6

0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Time (min) Time (min) Time (min)

Figure 2: Mobile Phase: A: 50 mM Na2HPO4/ 10 mM TBA (pH 7) B: Acetonitrile / 10 mM TBA


Flow Rate: 1.0 mL/min Temperature: 35 °C, Detection: UV 254 nm, Sample: 1. NAD, 2. GMP,
3. AMP, 4. NADH, 5. ADP, 6. ATP.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 5

● short column of 100 mm or less


● Columns packed with stationary phases
N = 20,441
3
250 mm x 4.6 mm, 5 m
of small particles of 3–3.5 m or
1
2 N = 20,078
4
 2 m.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
3
N = 12,133 150 mm x 4.6 mm, 5 m
1
2 N = 12,351
Columns Packed with Polymeric
4

0 5 10 15 20 25 30
or Silica-Based Monolithic
3 N = 11,468 Stationary Phases
N = 11,615 100 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
1
2
4 The second step is to select the appropriate
0
3
5 10 15 20 25 30 instrumentation. Recently, for fast and
N = 10,258 75 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
1 N = 10,148
ultrafast LC, three approaches have been
2
4
used:
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
3
N = 6037 ● High-speed, high-capacity LC systems
50 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
N = 6532
12
4 (commercially available instrumenta-
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
tion)
Time (min)
● High-speed, high-pressure LC systems
Figure 3: Influence of column length on run (research instrumentation like that pro-
time and plate numbers. Columns: ZORBAX posed in the literature [1])
SB-C18, Mobile Phase: A: 50% 20 mM
NaH2PO4, pH 2.8, B: 50% ACN, Flow Rate: ● High-speed, high-temperature LC sys-
1 mL/min, Temperature: 25 °C, Sample: tems (modified standard LC instru-
1. Estradiol, 2. Ethynylestradiol, 3. Dienestrol, mentation like that proposed in the lit-
4. Norethindrone. erature [2,3])
What Makes HPLC Fast? Data evaluation is the third important
To reduce analysis times in chromatogra- aspect that needs to be optimized. The
phy, a user first must select an appropriate needs here are:
column configuration. Several excellent ● Reliable and correct automated
column choices currently are available: integration

Time
36 s for drawing sample (26 s), 42 s for injection and analysis Equilibration time 24 s
Needle wash (10 s) for first run from second run on

Figure 4: Fast analysis of drugs with cycle time of 1 min 6 s with overlapped injection
(31 runs/h), without overlapped injection cycle time of 1 min 54 s (54 runs/h) are possible. Short
column, 4.6  30 mm Zorbax SB C-18, High flow rate, 3 ml/min, Gradient: from 40 to 55%
organic phase in 0.3 min, Detector sampling rate, peak width  0.1 min, Injection volume: 1 l
in overlapped injection mode. Compounds: Hydrocortisone, Beclomethasone, Hydrocortisone
acetate.
6 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

HPLC Column and Instrument


Technology Advancements
Recent developments in column
technology: The column is the heart of
chromatography; everything else is built
around it. To improve the speed of analy-
sis, the column length can be reduced or
the flow rate can be increased. But without
changing any other parameters, these
approaches can compromise results and
increase analysis costs. Thus, the ideal
approach improves analysis speed without
compromising the quality of results. Let’s
first review some advancements in column
Wellplate Automation 1100 HT technology, which are designed to improve
handler interface system
sample throughput.
Figure 5: Agilent 1100 Sample Capacity Recently, new column-packing materials
Extension. have been developed, which can be utilized
for fast and ultrafast applications. In addi-
● Automated and fast customized report tion, these materials offer enhanced effi-
generation ciencies and can be used for conventional,
● Automated data storage and archiving fast, and ultrafast applications.
of raw data and results We have categorized fast LC columns
● Automated transfer of data to other into two technology areas.
data-handling or evaluation devices.
The objective of this primer is to use
examples with complete instrument and
column recommendations that will permit
users to perform conventional methods 50 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
50 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m

faster or to perform fast and ultrafast appli- 2


Plates (N)
1. 3476
with twice the efficiency

2. 4585
cations successfully. This will be done with 3. 5673
4. 6180
2 Plates (N)
1. 6560
3
examples that: 4
3
2. 8958
3. 11,508
4. 12,266

● Present the latest developments in 1


4

packed column technology for fast 1

analysis (for example, 1.8-m particle


size columns).
● Provide recommendations for optimiz- 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.5 1.0

ing instrumentation for fast and ultra- Time (min) Time (min)

fast analysis (for example, achieving the


lowest delay volume). Figure 6: Influence of particle size on reso-
● Provide recommendations for improved lution. Columns: ZORBAX SB-C18, 50  4.6
mm, Mobile Phase: 25% Water: 75% MeOH,
data evaluation software including
Flow Rate: 1.5 mL/min, Temperature: RT,
automated report generation with rele- Detection: UV 254 nm, Sample: QC: 1. Uracil,
vant results. 2. Phenol, 3. 4-Cl-Nitrobenzene, 4. Toluene.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 7

1
RS(1,2) = 4.8 2 250 mm x 4.6 mm, 5 m
3 29.65
N = 21,848 4 N = 22,680

1 2
3
RS(1,2) = 3.5 12.71 100 mm x 4.6 mm, 3.5 m
4 N = 11,691

1 2
N = 6568
RS(1,2) = 2.9 30 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m
3 4.15
4 N = 6104 1 mL/min

N = 6463
RS(1,2) = 2.9 30 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m
2.09
2 mL/min
N = 6460

0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Time (min)

Figure 7: Columns: 50  4.4 mm ZORBAX SB-C18, 1.8 m, Mobile Phase: 50% 20 mM
NaH2PO4, pH 2.8: 50% ACN, Flow Rate: 1 mL/min, Temperature: RT, Detection: UV 230 nm.
Sample: 1. Estradiol, 2. Ethinylestradiol, 3. Dienestrol, 4. Norethindrone.

Columns packed with silica-based Columns packed with polymeric or


particles smaller than 2 m: silica-based monolithic stationary
Advantages phases:
● Columns of different length and inter- Advantages
nal diameter are available. ● Fast and ultrafast LC at high flow rates
● Short columns packed with 1.8-m and low back pressures.
particles show excellent resolution and ● Long columns ( 100 mm) can be
high plate numbers even for ultrafast used due to lower back pressure.
separations. ● Comparable efficiency, resolution, and
● A wide variety of available bonded precision are achieved, as with conven-
phases to meet a range of application tional columns packed with 3-m par-
needs. ticles or greater (4–7).
● Available column internal diameters Disadvantages
and chemistries make them compatibile ● Conventional LC equipment often is
with LC–MS. not designed for optimal performance
Disadvantages at flow rates greater than 3 mL/min.
● Higher back pressure at increased flow For example, this can be due to flow
rates. An appropriate particle size distri- cell design, low detector response times,
bution can contribute to reducing this and scan rates of the mass spectrometer.
effect. ● If a mass spectrometer is used, a splitter
8 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

might be required in front of the MS standard methods as well as new optimized


system to prevent sensitivity loss for ultrafast separations.
flow rates greater than 1 mL/min. For fast and ultrafast high-resolution
● Very high flow rates increase solvent HPLC, three instrument approaches are
costs and disposal costs significantly. currently in use:
● Limited choice of stationary phases and ● State-of-the-art HPLC equipment
suppliers. designed for reliability, high speed, and
Monolithic columns are a promising high capacity.
alternative to packed columns in the ● High-temperature instrumentation
future. Due to the extensive use of packed designed for temperatures above
columns, we will focus in this primer on 100 °C.
packed columns with smaller particle sizes ● High-pressure instrumentation
(1.8 m and 3–3.5 m) for conventional designed for back pressure  1000 bar.
analyses with shorter analysis times as well
as fast and ultrafast HPLC. High Speed, High Capacity HPLC
Recent developments in instrument Instruments
technology: The major factors qualifying Conventional HPLC instruments can be
an HPLC instrument for fast or ultrafast configured for use with almost every typi-
HPLC are a low delay volume minimizing cal column type with good results. Many
extracolumn effects and the availability of conventional methods with reduced analy-
an extended temperature or pressure range sis times also can be done successfully with
are. Some state-of-the-art LC equipment these instruments. However, as columns
already has been developed for high speed get smaller in length, internal diameter,
and throughput and can be tuned for opti- and particle size, high-speed, high-capacity
mum results. These current choices pro- instrumentation is needed to take full
vide the flexibility to be adapted for a wide advantage of these new columns (8). Extra
range of applications — well established delay volume for best mixing performance

Set PW <0.01 min


1.086
Flow rate: 3.5 mL/min
Set PW = 0.1 min
Absorbance (mAU)

200 DAD cell = 1.7 L 0.762 200


150 150
0.306 0.944
100 100
0.614 0.761 1.086
0.305
50 50 0.612 0.943
0 0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

Figure 8: Influence of data rate settings. Column: 30  4.6 mm Zorbax, Mixer: Upchurch
mixer (Oak Harbor, Washington), Mobile phase: Water/ ACN  90/10, 3.5 ml/min, Gradient: at
0.3 min 10% ACN, at 1 min 95%ACN, at 1.18 min 95% ACN, at 1.19 min; 10% ACN, Injection
volume: 1 l with overlapped injection, Column Temperature: 60 C, DAD: 1.7 l cell,
wl 210/8 nm, ref wl 360/100nm, PW  0.01 or PW  0.1, slit width 4 nm.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 9

USP L1 columm: ZORBAX Eclipse XDB-C18, 250 mm x 4.6 mm, 5 m Peak tR N RS 2


Injection: 8 L 1
1 6.63 12,737 0
2 11.19 18,552 15.8

0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Time (min)
2
1 Rapid Resolution HT column (L1) Peak tR N RS
ZORBAX Eclipse XDB-C18, 50 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m
Injection: 2 L 1 1.40 11,421 0
2 2.33 12,909 12.3

0 1 2 3
Time (min)

1 2 Rapid Resolution HT column (L1) Peak tR N RS


ZORBAX Eclipse XDB-C18, 30 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m
Injection: 2 L 1 0.85 5855 0
2 1.43 7300 8.6

0 1 2 Minimum resolution exceeded with the shortest column


Time (min)

Figure 9: Short column length choices to improve throughput - USP analysis of guaifenesin.
Sample: 1. Guaifenesin: 0.04 mg/mL, 2. Benzoic Acid: 0.10 mg/mL; Minimum Resolution
Required  3.0 Eluent: 40% Methanol: 60% Water:1.5% Glacial Acetic Acid, Flow: 1.0 mL/min
Temp: 25 C.

or a complex autosampler design can cause development or enable more rapid and
a longer run time. The dwell volume (the automated sample preparation. With these
volume between gradient mixing point options available, a high-speed, high-
and head of the column) and system delay capacity LC system will enable fast results
volume (extracolumn volume from the and high-throughput without compromis-
pump to the detector) are optimized to ing resolution.
minimize instrument contributions to High-temperature instrumentation:
peak dispersion. Originally, column thermostatting was
During the past few years, high-speed introduced to ensure optimum repro-
autosamplers have been introduced that ducibility of retention times. The tech-
are able to inject a sample within 15 to nique of increasing temperature to
30 s. This enhanced speed of injection now decrease analysis time currently is used at
is ideal for use in gradient runs that take temperatures as high as about 80 °C with
less than a few minutes to complete. At the state-of-the-art LC instruments. This
same time, sample capacity was increased approach has been expanded to increase
to permit several hundred or thousands of the column temperature above 100 °C to
samples, which allowed 24  7 operation further increase the number of theoretical
and high sample throughput with short plates for the same column length. This
cycle times. Valve systems were developed has allowed run times to be decreased to
to increase sample throughput doing sam- less than 1 min. Columns with internal
ple wash steps and column regeneration in diameters of 2.1 or 4.6 mm with particle
parallel to the separation. Special configu- sizes of about 3 m were used. Impressive
rations with solvent- and column-switch- results were obtained (3). Standard instru-
ing valves decrease the time for method mentation was used with modifications to
10 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

heat the LC modules in the sample flow as high as 7000 bar. The speed and effi-
path, which must be kept at elevated tem- ciency of this system have been demon-
peratures. Special column ovens are avail- strated in several publications (1).
able commercially to test this approach. Unfortunately, there is no commercial
Recommendations in the literature are LC system on the market that would allow
given on how to modify a state-of-the-art pumping pressures of 7000 bar. These
LC system accordingly. high pressures would compromise current
However, some stationary phases can technology used in commercial units to
show degradation at elevated temperature, shorten equipment life significantly.
either with respect to retention of com- Some systems and components are avail-
pounds or separation efficiency. The ana- able to allow pressures as high as 1000 bar.
lytes themselves can be unstable at these These systems have limited flow rates and
elevated temperatures. This has been therefore do not permit use with all com-
shown with recent investigations (9). monly used column internal diameters,
High-pressure instrumentation: The especially more desirable and commonly
group of J.W. Jorgenson demonstrated that used 4.6-mm i.d. columns.
small particles have a tremendous positive We will focus on examples that use state-
effect on column efficiency. Excellent reso- of-the-art instrumentation because this is
lution for tryptic digests and for other either available in most labs or can be
applications have been achieved, and the updated inexpensively (compared with the
lowest run times were obtained using cost of purchasing a complete new system)
columns with particle sizes of about 1 m. for fast and ultrafast analytical LC meth-
Jorgensen and his team have developed ods. If required, this instrumentation still
instruments that allow pumping pressures can be used for validated conventional

4
600 3
2
Flow cell with 6 8
Absorbance (mAU)

500 5 7 9
400 500-nL cell volume
300 1
200
100
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

4
500 2 3
8
6
Standard flow cell with
Absorbance (mAU)

5 7
400 9
300
13-L cell volume 1
200
100
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

Time (min)

Figure 10: Influence of additional dispersion volume on run time and resolution, conditions
see Figure 15, except flow rate  2.3 ml/min and column temperature  32 ºC.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 11

High-pressure Standard assembly without standard mixer


gradient pump and 80-L filter

400 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

High-speed well
plate sampler

200 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

3-L Thermostated
heat exchanger column
compartment
105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary
Rapid resolution
HT column
105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary
Union

220 mm x 0.125 mm capillary

Diode-array
DAD equipped with a 50-nL flow cell
detector

80 mm x 0.125 mm capillary

Waste

Figure 11: Agilent 1100 System configuration for ultrafast LC without automated alternat-
ing column regeneration.

methods. High-temperature and high- tional analyses as well as fast and ultrafast
pressure instrumentation can require a HPLC. Column parameters as well as
higher degree of maintenance as operating instrument settings must be reviewed and
conditions add more stress. optimized carefully, and recommendations
We will focus on examples that use high are provided for each type of analysis: con-
performance standard instrumentation ventional, fast, and ultrafast HPLC.
because this is readily available in most labs Faster conventional analyses — switch
and can be inexpensively updated (in com- to smaller particle size and shorter column:
parison to purchasing a complete new sys- A typical analytical LC method might be a
tem) for high-throughput analytical LC simple isocratic separation of as many as
methods. As we review these examples, we 10 components. This type of separation on
will provide additional detail on all of the conventional 150 or 250 mm  4.6 mm,
components of the LC system, including 5-m dp columns often will take 30 min
data handling and data storage. or more. The first step in reducing the
cycle time for a method such as this is to
Practical Examples of Faster replace a traditional column with one that
Analysis: Column and Instrument provides the same efficiency in a shorter
Recommendations length. This can be done with a column
This chapter provides examples that illus- packed with 3–3.5 m particles.
trate the practical use of faster conven- Figure 1 shows an example where analy-
12 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

sis time was reduced by 50% for an iso- In the previous two examples, we saw
cratic separation of seven components. column length reduced to speed up analy-
The analysis on the 150-mm long, 5-m sis. This is the first key step to decreasing
column took 27 min. When the column run time. In Figure 3, an example is given
length was cut in half and the particle size showing the influence of column length on
reduced to 3.5 m, the analysis time was run time, and includes short columns (10).
reduced by 50% with no loss in resolution. Run time has been shortened from
Using the long column, only 18 runs can about 30 min to 7 min; a 77% reduction
be performed within an 8-h day, while 34 in analysis time. All peaks remain baseline
runs can be completed in the same time separated, and proper quantitation is
using the short column. To do this analysis possible.
required conventional LC instrumentation These methods improved dramatically
with no changes and is the simplest way to on analysis time but are still considered
decrease analysis time. conventional LC methods with cycle times
The same approach can be used during of approximately 5 min or more.
method development, as in Figure 2. The Recommended instrumentation for
shorter column with the 3.5-m particle faster conventional analyses: Standard
size was used for method development. HPLC equipment can be used for these
The demands of the method were for base- faster conventional methods with excellent
line separation for all six peaks. The iso- results.
cratic conditions were changed after each Recommended column choices for
run using a sequence. The method devel- faster conventional analyses: Standard
opment was performed within half an 4.6- or 2.1-mm i.d. columns with lengths
hour. of 75–150 mm and 3.5-m particles are a

1.08
1 2 Pressure
Ambient 245 bar
temperature T = 50 °C
Flow rate = 1.0 mL/min

1 2 0.93
T = 50 °C
35 °C 225 bar
Flow rate = 1.5 mL/min

1 2 0.78
50 °C 200 bar
Can increase flow rate to decrease
analysis time even further
Increasing temperature reduces analysis
2 0.65 time by 40% or more and pressure by 25%
1
60 °C 189 bar

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5


Time (min)

Figure 12: Influence of column temperature on run time. Column: rapid resolution HT SB-C18
30  4.6 mm, 1.8 mm, Mobile Phase: 40% water: 60% methanol, Flow Rate: 1 mL/min, Detec-
tion: UV 254 nm, Temperature: as noted, Sample: 1. Triamcinolone , 2. Hydrocortisone.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 13

1100 HT
4
Flow rate 2.6 mL/min
2 3
8 Temperature 32 °C
5 6 7 Pressure 346 bar
9
Absorbance (mAU)

400 1
Cycle time 1.5 min
Run time 1.2 min
200
Analysis 0.912 min
time
0 RS (4,5) 2.76

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 RT% RSD <0.2%

Time (min)

Figure 13: Ultrafast gradient analysis of nine Alkylphenones. System configuration without
automated alternating column regeneration. Chromatographic conditions: Column: 50 
4.6 mm Zorbax StableBond-C18, 1.8 m, Injection: 1 L, Separation: Mobile phase: A: water
 0.1% HCOOH; B: acetonitrile  0.1% HCOOH. Gradient: from 50% B to 100% B in 0.65 min,
hold over 0.2 min. Stop time  1.2 min. Sample: alkylphenones and acetanilide (100 ng/L
each) consisting of: 1. acetanilide, 2. acetophenone, 3. propiophenone, 4. butyrophenone,
5. benzophenone, 6. valerophenone, 7. hexanophenone, 8. heptanophenone, 9. octanophe-
none Temperature: 32 °C, DAD detection: UV signal  245 nm, 10 nm Reference  360 nm, 80
nm Slit: 8 nm, Peak width (response time)  0.01 min (0.1 s), that is, 20 Hz data acquisition rate.

great choice for faster analyses. They pro- time (the time between two injections)
vide improved efficiency in shorter column even more.
lengths with shorter analysis times, while To improve the speed of an analysis, the
delivering excellent quantitative results. cycle time must be minimized. Typically,
cycle time is influenced by the run time,
Fast Analysis ( 5 min cycle time) the equilibration time of the column, time
The previous examples demonstrated needed for the detector to balance or equil-
improved speed and greater throughput ibrate, the time needed for the injection,
but still utilized conventional analysis and the overall response time of both the
times of greater than 5 min. The next goal data acquisition and the data evaluation
is to achieve fast analysis with run times of work station.
less than 5 min. This time is necessary Fast analysis with short 4.6-mm i.d.
when there is a very high number of sam- columns with 3.5-m particles: This
ples or when demand for results is required example (Figure 4) is a gradient example
quickly. This can be a typical need in and uses a very short column (30-mm
process control or drug-screening long), a high-pressure pump, and high-
applications. speed autosampler technology to achieve
Therefore, the next step is to choose an very short cycle times.
even shorter column and use higher flow Influence of high-pressure mixing pumps:
rates to reduce analysis time further. If the The influence of a pump on speed for an
goal is to achieve the highest throughput isocratic analysis is relatively low. For gra-
on the shortest columns, then we must also dient analysis, the importance of low dwell
take advantage of the improvements in volume is significant. The faster gradient
instrument technology to reduce the cycle changes can reach the top of the column,
14 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

the faster the peaks can be eluted and time is needed. In Figure 4, we illustrate
shorter run times will result. High-pressure the separation of drugs using an over-
mixing gradient pumps typically have lapped injection mode and fast gradient
lower dwell volumes than low-pressure gra- application on the 30-mm-long column
dient pumps and are the best choice for (11).
shortening run times and equilibration This graph shows that cycle times can be
times. However, some solvents might reduced significantly using overlapped
require a minimum mixing volume to injections, and sample throughput can be
ensure a stable detector baseline. increased from 31 samples/h to 54 sam-
Influence of autosampler speed and sample ples/h, an increase in speed of 57%.
capacity: Some high-speed autosamplers Autosampler sample capacity is another
can inject 1 L within 15 to 30 s. This is a very important issue in fast and ultrafast
substantial improvement over previous sys- LC. An autosampler that is fast, but which
tems with injection times of 1 min or can handle only 100 samples is not a suffi-
more. Some systems permit overlapped cient high-throughput solution for large
injections in which the next sample can be sample loads or 24  7 h operation in a
drawn up during the runtime of the cur- service lab.
rent sample and kept in the sample loop A typical autosampler that can have
until the current run has ended. As soon as extended capacity if needed is recom-
the LC system is ready, the “parked” sam- mended for high sample throughput. This
ple is injected immediately. Ideally, type of system is shown in Figure 5, with
autosampler wash steps occur while the an additional module that enhances the
sample is analyzed already and no extra basic system. The extra module enables the

Gradient Equilibration
Standard assembly without standard mixer High-pressure High-pressure Standard assembly
and with 80-L filter gradient pump 1 gradient pump 2 without standard mixer

400 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

High-speed well
plate sampler 0.17-mm i.d. capillary

208 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

Thermostated
2PS/10PT valve
column compartment
105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary
220 x 0.125 mm

105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

Column 1 Column 2

105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary 105 mm x 0.17 mm capillary

DAD equipped with a 500-nL flow cell Diode-array


detector 0.508-mm i.d capillary
80 mm x 0.125 mm capillary

Waste

Figure 14: Agilent 1100 System configuration for ultra-fast LC with automated alternating
column regeneration.
No false starts
with the power of a single solution
ZORBAX Eclipse XDB HPLC columns provide
the power to eliminate false starts. From
Eclipse XDB-C18 the first injection resolve your most diffi-
Nearest Competitor A cult separations through Eclipse XDB
Nearest Competitor B columns’ wide selection of bonded phases
and dimensions.

Eclipse columns come in four phases to


meet any application need: Cyano, C18, C8
and Phenyl. Unique eXtra Densely Bonded
Column: Eclipse XDB-C18
phases provide stable separations in a pH
4.6 x 150 mm, 5µm range of 2.0 to 9.0. From 1.8µm to 7µm and
(p/n 993967-902) from fast LC to preparative separations,
Mobile phase: 90% 25mM Na2HP04 , pH 7.0:10% ACN Eclipse columns ensure productive results.
Flow rate: 1.5 mL/min
Temperature: 40 oC No other column affords you the power to
Sample: Procainamide
get the results you need. Eclipse XDB
columns provide a single solution approach
through excellent peak symmetry and wide
Visit our Web site to get your free pH compatibility. Our exclusive double end-
Eclipse technical brochure brief and/or capping provides extended column life and
Column Selection Guide. eliminates undesirable surface interactions.

Combine Eclipse XDB with the Agilent


u.s. and canada 1-800-227-9770 (Option 1) 1100 HPLC for the most powerful, single
www.agilent.com/chem/13eclipse solution to your separation needs.

© Agilent Technologies, Inc. 2005 MC10286


16 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

storage of as many as 80 shallow-well pounds on the same column type with


plates (14.4-mm height) for a total sample identical length and internal diameter. The
capacity of more than 7800 samples. Sam- only difference is the particle size. The res-
ple tracking via barcode can be an appro- olution for the 1.8-m particle size col-
priate complementary step to ensure umn is significantly better. This is due to
rugged operation. the high efficiency possible with these
Instrument recommendations for fast small particles.
analysis: Gradient pumps with high-pres- In Table I, a comparison is made
sure mixing as well as high-speed autosam- between column efficiency, expressed in
plers are a prerequisite to enable fast gradi- plate numbers, and particle sizes for differ-
ents with cycle times less than 5 min. ent column lengths.
Sample capacity extensions with sample For example, comparing a 150-mm-
tracking capabilities enable robust opera- long column with a particle size of 5 m to
tion in a routine lab. a 50-mm-long column with a 1.8-m par-
Column recommendations for fast ticle size, nearly the same efficiency can be
analysis: For a simple, fast analysis, a short expected. For the 1.8-m particle size, a
column (50 mm or shorter) with 3.5-m reduction in run time of 67% can be
particles can be used. These columns pro- achieved with no observable loss in effi-
vide a fast analysis with good results. ciency and resolution.
High-efficiency, fast analysis with 4.6- Figure 7 shows the capability of short
mm i.d. columns with 1.8-m particles: columns with 1.8-m particles to main-
The next change in the column technology tain resolution with very short analysis
is to use even smaller particles than in the times. This is the same separation of estro-
previous examples (that is, 1.8-m parti- gen-related compounds shown on
cles). These particles provide extremely columns with 3.5-m particles, now sepa-
high resolution with very short column rated on columns with 1.8-m particles.
lengths (10). In Figure 6, the two chro- The bonded phase remains the same, only
matograms show the analysis of four com- the particle size changes to the smaller

1100 HT
Flow rate 2.6 mL/min
Temperature 32 °C
3 4 Pressure 350 bar
600 2
6 8
Absorbance (mAU)

500 7 Cycle time 1.3 min


5 9
400 1 Run time 1.2 min
300 Analysis time 0.92 min
200 RT 0.66
100 Avg4_PW 0.79 s
0
RS (4,5) 2.62
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 % RSD n.d.

Time (min)

Figure 15: Ultrafast gradient analysis of nine alkylphenones. System configuration with auto-
mated alternating column regeneration. Conditions, see Figure 13.
From workhorse to racehorse
A scaleable HPLC for ultimate reliability at every turn

Agilent Technologies has been setting the


pace in LC technology for over 30 years.
It’s why 50,000 Agilent systems have been
installed worldwide. And why Agilent’s
1100 Series LC and LC/MS Systems are
considered such workhorses. The open
architecture gives seamless integration
Pumping systems Injection systems
and unprecedented scalability to more
than 50 modules. You can mix and match
modules to adapt to the ever-changing
demands of your lab, providing the best
set of features for every application.
Detectors Fraction collectors

The 1100 Series LC Systems are also the


Agilent 1100 Series LC Systems—50,000 systems installed ultimate racehorses. State of the art
• More than 50 modules to build your best LC instrumentation has been combined with
• From isocratic pumps to TOF-MS detectors ®
the latest ZORBAX column technology to
• From precise shallow gradients to 30 sec run time
give optimum speed, resolution and sensi-
• Perfect fit for peak widths shorter than 1 sec
• Stable flows from 100 ml/min down to 10 nl/min tivity. Save up to 95% in analysis time,
• From walk-up to automated 24/7 operation double your efficiency and gain orders of
• Capacity from 100 to 30,000 samples magnitude in sensitivity. Agilent nanoflow,
capillary and standard LC systems will
exceed your expectations at every turn.

u.s. and canada 1-800-227-9770 For the best in reliability, scalability and
www.agilent.com/chem/1100 record-breaking performance, contact Agilent.

©Agilent Technologies, Inc. 2005 MC8408B


18 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

(a) (b) 0.75 mL/min


0.25 mL/min

-
-
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.3

Time (min) Time (min)

Figure 16: Influence of flow rate on run time Columns: ZORBAX Rapid Resolution HT SB-C18,
30  1.6 mm, 1.8 mm, Mobile Phase: A: 20 mM Na2HPO4 pH 2.8, B: ACN, Gradient: A: 30–70%B
in 5 min, hold for 1min. B: 30–80% B in 1.1 min, hold for 0.3 min, Flow Rate: see below, Tem-
perature: Ambient, Autosampler: 1100, Bypass Mode, Detection: UV 230 nm, Sample: 1. Estriol,
2. Estradiol, 3. Ethynylestradiol, 4. Dienestrol, 5. Norethindrone.

1.8-m particles. This results in easy and longer columns with larger particle size
fast scaling of method parameters to obtain packings, it is possible to make dramatic
these high resolution, very fast results. gains in productivity. Figure 9 shows
Detector response time (data rate) and results for the USP assay of guaifenesin
flow-cell considerations: Fast and ultrafast with benzoic acid as the internal standard
peaks like those in Figure 7 require an (12).
appropriate data rate to obtain reliable Both 50 mm  4.6 mm and 30 mm 
results. A high enough data rate enables 4.6 mm, 1.8-m columns were substi-
accurate detection of the faster eluted tuted to evaluate different choices in col-
peaks. To achieve accurate results, enough umn lengths for high throughput applica-
data points must be collected to define the tions. The 50-mm column length
height and shape of the peak correctly; this improves throughput 5, while maintain-
is possible only with a fast data rate. The ing 70% of the efficiency and 78% of the
example in Figure 8 shows the improved resolution of the 250-mm, 5-m column.
peak shape and width when a correct data The 30-mm, 1.8-m provides 8 the
rate setting is used with a UV detector. sample throughput and resolution Rs of
State-of-the-art UV detectors can be 8.6, still nearly 3 the method require-
used even at flow rates above 3 mL/min ments for resolution. These comparisons
without loss of information. A detector cell are all done using the same bonded phase,
with an efficient elution behavior and a cell so the results are due to the changes in col-
volume that is in line with the peak vol- umn length and particle size.
ume plus correct data rate settings ensure Standard configurations provide very
reproducible results and lower limits of good performance for chromatography
detection. with 4–4.6 mm i.d. columns and small,
Assays for active pharmaceutical ingredi- 3.5-m particle packings as long as run
ents are one example in which very short times are above or close to 5 min and flow
1.8-m columns can be used to speed up rates are between 1 and 3 mL/min, as we
assays. By substituting these columns for saw in the earlier examples. But, for special
Charging forward
HPLC technology that’s been leading for more than 30 years
Agilent Technologies has always led the
pack in HPLC innovation. That’s why over
50,000 1100 Series LC and LC/MS Systems
have been installed worldwide—a total of
300,000 modules performing with expert
robustness day in and day out. From routine
testing to leading edge proteomics, you can
charge forward with powerful performance.

These innovations include a patented vari-


able stroke for optimum retention time
precision and minimum composition ripple;
a flow-through injector design for superior
®

Agilent 1100 Series LC Systems—50,000 systems installed


precision; 1.8 µm ZORBAX column tech-
• Patented variable stroke high-pressure gradient mixing nology for ultimate speed and efficiency;
• Flow-through injector design and a Peltier-controlled column compart-
• Ultrafast column technology ment for retention time stability. The
• Active electronic flow control
innovation continues, including purification
• Wireless column identification module
• Patented online and offline diagnostics
solutions, active flow-controlled capillary
• Predictive early maintenance feedback (EMF) and nano LC, and level-4 instrument control.

To lead the field in your research, install


the worldwide leader in HPLC systems. If
u.s. and canada 1-800-227-9770 you’re using anything less, it’s time you
www.agilent.com/chem/1100 left it behind.

©Agilent Technologies, Inc. 2005 MC8409B


20 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

150 mm x 2.1 mm, 5 m 120 peaks


70-min gradient 60 min
0.2 mL/min

15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
50 mm x 2.1 mm, 1.8 m 125 peaks
10-min gradient 10 min
0.5 mL/min

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
50 mm x 2.1 mm, 1.8 m 156 peaks
30-min gradient 25 min
0.5 mL/min

5 10 15 20 25
Time (min)

Figure 17: Conditions: Mobile Phase A: Water w/ 0.1% TFA, B: ACN w/0.1% TFA, Gradient
2%B to 50%B, Temperature: 50 C, Detection: UV 214 nm Sample: HSA Tryptic Digest, injection
8 l (120 pmol total on column).

demands, like fast or ultrafast LC with device with a volume of 320 L, the detec-
optimum resolution, the standard instru- tor cell was minimized to a volume of
ment configuration should be modified as 500 nL, and the detector capillaries were
discussed here. Capillaries or tubings in the changed.
flow path must be exchanged according to Two additional chromatographic
the vendor’s recommendation. An appro- parameters also can be optimized to reduce
priate detector cell should be selected, and analysis time and achieve fast analysis.
the mixing device should also be of the They are flow rate and temperature. Many
lowest possible volume for gradient separa- people increase flow rate to decrease analy-
tions. These options are readily available, sis time. It also is possible to adjust both
and these changes can be made in a mini- parameters at one time. Figure 12 shows an
mal amount of time. example in which temperature was raised
At higher flow rates, the influence of the to decrease run times. At the same time,
correct instrument setup is also significant. due to the decreased viscosity and reduced
In Figure 10, two instrument setups are back pressure of the mobile phases at ele-
compared. The comparison of peak width vated temperatures, higher flow rates can
for both chromatograms shows that mini- be used.
mizing extra peak dispersion (as the result Instrument recommendations for high
of extra column volume) with the properly efficiency, fast analysis: In addition to the
configured instrument enables faster run instrument recommendations for fast
times without loss in resolution (13). analysis with high-pressure mixing —
Figure 11 shows the modifications binary pumps and high capacity, high-
needed for a typical LC system. A mixer speed autosamplers — it is critical to
with an 80-L volume replaced the mixing choose a detector setup with a fast data rate
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 21

to accurately define the narrow peaks in gradient separations can also be done effec-
high-efficiency chromatography. These tively with 1.8-m particle size columns,
will allow accurate detection of the peak with both 4.6-mm and 2.1-mm internal
and permit good, quantitative results. diameters. The combination of the high
Column recommendations for high- resolution of the 1.8-m particle size and
efficiency fast analysis: The isocratic steep gradient analysis results in extremely
examples mentioned earlier demonstrate high peak capacity and the ability to sepa-
the high resolution achievable for fast and rate complex samples in a very short time.
ultrafast LC by simply scaling down with Sequential operation mode: In the
4.6-mm i.d. columns with high resolution next example, the ultrafast analysis of eight
1.8-m particles. This small particle size alkylphenones and acetanilide is presented
provides extremely high efficiency, while (13). The Agilent standard 1100 LC sys-
the4.6-mm internal diameter permits stan- tem was modified to meet the demands of
dard injection and sample sizes and easy extremely short cycle times, as shown
scaling from conventional 4.6-mm i.d., before (Figure 11).
3-m or greater columns with predictable, This system and the principle of “auto-
reliable, and robust results. matic delay volume reduction,” in which
the autosampler delay volume is excluded
Ultrafast Gradient Analysis automatically from the flow path once the
 1-min Cycle Time Using 1.8-m sample has cleared the sample loop,
Particle Size Columns resulted in cycle times of 1.5 min with
Gradient elution is used widely for fast baseline separation for all peaks (Figure
separations of complex samples. Ultrafast 13). The flow rate was set to 2.6 mL/min

600
Absorbance (mAU)

Poor instrument setup


500 W4 = 2.26 s
400 R (4,5) = 1.83
300
200
100
0
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00
Absorbance (mAU)

800
Optimized setup
600 W4 = 1.54 s
R (4,5) = 2.27
400

200

0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00


Time (min)

Figure 18: Influence of instrument setup on performance. Column: 50  2.1 mm Zorbax


StableBond-C18, 1.8 m 50–95%B in 0.95 min, hold over 0.55 min, 0.70 mL/min, 350 bar,
Room Temp.
22 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

and the back pressure was kept around 346 regeneration pump (Figure 14). Depend-
bar, which is below the 400 bar limit on ing upon whether the regeneration pump
some liquid chromatographs. The modifi- is an isocratic or gradient pump, column
cations involved replacement of the stan- equilibration or column wash and equili-
dard mixer in the pump with a low volume bration can be performed while the next
mixer. A 500-nL UV cell replaced the stan- analysis already is in progress. The two-
dard diode-array detector cell, and wider position/10-port valve can be integrated
capillaries were used for the 500-nL cell to into the thermostated column compart-
avoid higher back pressure. Overlapped ment for full temperature control.
injections also are used in this example to For this sample, using a system with a
provide faster sample throughput, as two-position, 10-port valve for alternating
described earlier. More samples are ana- column regeneration, the cycle time was
lyzed during a given period of time when reduced to 1.3 min, using the same chro-
both automatic delay volume reduction matographic conditions (Figure 15). All
and overlapped injections are used. peaks were still baseline separated and 13%
Operation with parallel column cycle time is saved.
regeneration: Because gradient elution Instrument recommendations for
requires the column to regenerate before ultrafast analysis: These examples
subsequent runs, an automated column demonstrate that with only a few modifi-
regeneration system reduces cycle time cations, a currently available HPLC system
dramatically, especially with gradients that is suited perfectly for fast and ultrafast gra-
take less than a minute. A column regener- dient analysis, even of complex mixtures
ation valve (two-position/10-port valve) that require high resolution. With the
allows simultaneous analysis on one col- smallest particle size columns, 1.8 m, the
umn while a second, identical column is only additional instrument changes
flushed and equilibrated by an additional required are to optimize the data rate for

Table I: Efficiency versus column length with different particle sizes


Column Length Particle Size Efficiency Typical Pressure* Analysis Time
Reduction (%)

150 mm 5 mm 12,500 86 bar -


3.5 mm 21,000 157bar -
1.8 mm N.A. - -
50 mm 5 mm 4200 44 bar 67%
3.5 mm 7000 62 bar 67%
1.8 mm 12,000 210 bar 67%
30 mm 5 mm N.A. 20 bar -
3.5 mm 4200 37 bar 80%
1.8 mm 6500 126 bar 80&
15 mm 5 mm N.A. - -
3.5 mm 2100 17 bar 90%
1.8 mm 2600 55 bar 90%
Chromatographic conditions:
Pressure determined with 60:40 MeOH: water, 1 mL/min. 4.6 mm id.
Room Temperature
Column only – optimized HPLC system adds approximately 60 bar to each pressure
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 23

accurate detection of these low-volume, cost is saved due to the very short run
high-efficiency peaks. times. While 4.6-mm i.d. columns provide
Column recommendations for ultrafast ease of use, narrow-bore 2.1-mm
analysis: The high resolution shown here i.d.columns offer substantial advantages in
is possible using high-throughput columns solvent costs and sensitivity. They are oper-
with small, 1.8-m particle sizes. The ated at lower flow rates and thus are com-
superior efficiency provides the resolution patible with many different detector
of much longer columns, but the short col- options, including UV detectors and mass
umn lengths, 50 or 30 mm, permit fast spectrometers. These columns with smaller
analysis. The 4.6-mm i.d. columns are easy internal diameters also can be used for fast
to use and allow scaling down of current and ultrafast analysis with optimized LC
conventional methods. With many systems.
bonded phases available, methods easily UV detection: In Figure 16, a gradient
are matched or adapted as needed. Solvent method with a conventional analysis time

High-pressure Standard assembly


gradient pump without standard mixer

400 mm x 0.12 mm capillary

High-speed well
plate sampler

200 mm x 0.12 mm capillary

Column oven
3-L
heat exchanger

70 mm x 0.12 mm

Column

300 mm x 0.1 mm capillary

Diode-array DAD equipped with a 500-nL flow cell


detector

80 mm x 0.125 mm capillary

600 mm x 0.13 mm PEEK

Mass
spectrometer

Figure 19: Agilent 1100 instrument configuration for 2.1 mm, 1,8 m column with DAD and
MS.
24 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

( 5 min) on a 2.1-mm i.d. short column size, on the analysis of a tryptic digest of
is shown with UV detection. This method human serum albumin. The chro-
was converted easily to a very fast LC matograms in Figure 17 illustrate the
method by increasing the flow rate. With difference.
such a short column length, the flow rate The first trace shows the results
can be increased without exceeding the obtained using a 150 mm  2.1 mm,
pressure limit of the column or the instru- 5-m column and gradient conditions.
mentation. The flow rate was increased by Using a shorter 50-mm column with the
a factor of 3. This resulted in a decrease in same stationary phase but with smaller
run time by a factor of 4.5. Resolution still particles (1.8 m), higher resolution is
is very good, and area and retention time obtained in one-sixth the time, up to
precision are comparable for both 500% faster, due to the combined effects
applications. of using smaller particles and reducing the
Tryptic protein digests typically are pre- column length by a third, increasing the
cious and complex samples that are prefer- flow rate by a factor of 2.5 and reducing
ably separated on a small i.d. column for the gradient time from 70 min to 10 min.
higher sensitivity with the limited sample The resolution can be increased further by
size (14). Resolution of these samples and increasing the gradient time from 10 to 30
other complex biological fluids can be min, while the analysis time still is less than
improved significantly using columns with half that of the original method.
particle sizes less than 2 m. This is For flow rates below 1 mL/min and
demonstrated by a comparison of two 2.1-mm i.d. columns, the optimum setup
columns, differing in length and particle is a little different. To optimize the stan-

1
7.0

6.0
TIC (x 106)

5.0

4.0 2

3.0

2.0

0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

Time (min)

Figure 20: High-throughput LC–MS with rapid resolution HT columns. APCI analysis of Clin-
damycin and Lincomycin Column: ZORBAX Rapid Resolution HT SB-C18 30  2.1 mm, 1.8 m
Mobile Phase: Gradient: 15–50% B in 1 min, hold for 1.5 min, A: 0.2% formic acid pH, 2.8 B:
ACN  0.2% formic acid, Post time: 1.5 min, Flow Rate: 0.5 mL/min, Injection Volume: 1 L,
Temperature: Ambient, HPLC: Agilent 1100 with WPS and ADVR on, Detection: APCI, Positive
ion MS Conditions: Peak width: 0.10 min Scan: 150–600 Da, step 0.1 Fragmentor: 70, Gas
Temp: 350 ºC Vaporizer: 350 ºC Drying gas: 12 L/min, Nebulizer pres. 50 psi, Vcap 3000V,
Corona: 4.0 mA, Sample: 1. Lincomycin 2. Clindamycin.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 25

dard LC configuration, short 0.12-mm i.d. accurate identification of close eluted com-
capillaries replaced the long 0.17-mm i.d. ponents possible, this combination is ideal
flow capillaries. As a mixing device a short to analyze unknowns.
0.12-mm i.d. capillary was used. The The analysis of antibiotics with MS
500-nL UV detector cell with appropriate detection using narrow-bore columns
inlet and outlet capillaries ensures opti- packed with 1.8-m packing material is
mum peak shape. shown in Figure 20 (15).
Figure 18 dramatically shows the influ- The separation of clindamycin and its
ence of the correct configuration on peak precursor product lincomycin was done
width and consequently on resolution with within 1.5 min, and the cycle time was
narrow bore, 2.1-mm i.d. columns. The 3 min. The mobile phase selected and the
required instrument modifications are flow rates of 0.5 mL/min are compatible
shown in Figure 19. with most LC–MS ionization techniques.
LC–MS detection: Narrow-bore Atmospheric pressure chemical ionization
columns are the ideal choice for LC–MS was chosen and provided good sensitivity
work. They provide excellent sensitivity at for these compounds.
lower flow rates. While the mass spectrom- The spectra of the two components
eter is chosen for quick and accurate iden- show predominantly the expected [M+H]+
tification of compounds, the high-resolu- ions for both lincomycin and clindamycin
tion column packing is especially critical to phosphate (Figure 21).
avoid ion suppression. By resolving ana- In fast and ultrafast HPLC, mass spec-
lytes from early eluted matrixes or excipi- trometers with different ionization and
ent components and obtaining the most detection processes can be utilized. Typical

4.0 Lincomycin spectrum 407.1 [M + H]+ Max: 403,456


Abundance (x 106)

1.45 min
3.0

2.0

1.0
160.1 176.1 219.1 391.1 423.0 519.0
355.0 371.1 437.1 577.0
0.0
200 300 400 500 600
1.2
[M + H]+ 505.1 Max: 115,512
Clindamycin phosphate spectrum
1.0
1.84 min
Abundance (x 106)

0.8 507.0

0.6
160.1 506.0
0.4 219.1
407.1
176.1
0.2 156.0
391.0 445.2 521.0
197.0 220.1 279.1 355.0 371.1 425.2 469.1 577.0 583.0
0.0
200 300 400 500 600
m/z

Figure 21: Mass spectra of clindamycin and lincomycin. High-throughput LC–MS with rapid
resolution HT column lincomycin MW  406.5 spectrum 407.1  [M + H]+, clindamycin phos-
phate MW  505 spectrum 505-506 [M+H]+.
26 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

100 100 100


279.1 285.0 311.1
80 80 80

60 60 60

40 1,2 40 3 40 4

20 270.0 20 20
221.0
311.1
0 0 0
200 400 600 200 400 600 200 400 600
m/z m/z m/z

5–95% acetonitrile in 0.5 min


600 1,2 600 Zorbax 15 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m
Absorbance (mAU)

1,2
Absorbance (mAU)

400 400 3
3 4

200 4 200

0 0
0 0.4 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Time (min) Time (min)

Cycle time of 1 min achieved by


• Short small particles column: 15 mm x 4.6 mm, 1.8 m SB-C18
• High flow rate: 4 mL/min
• Steep gradient: 55–95% organic in 0.5 min
• Coelution acceptance: Selected ion monitoring
• Overlapped injection: Save sample-draw and wash time
• Column regeneration: Save column regeneration time

Figure 22: Ultrafast, high-throughput LC–MS analysis of sulfa drugs.

examples are: analysis.


Single Quadrupole: ● High calibration stability
● Sensitive and secure molecular weight Typically, these detectors cannot be used
information for rapid screening pur- at flow rates above 1.5 mL/min without a
poses. loss in sensitivity. Some mass spectrome-
● Fast scanning for scan rates up to ters can suffer even at lower flow rates. If
5250 m/z/s. higher flow rates are used, a splitter must
● For qualitative/quantitative analysis. be installed in front of the mass spectrom-
● Highest sensitivity and accuracy in eter. In Figure 22, an example is given for
selected ion mode. the ultrafast analysis of sulfonamides using
● Special versions allow fast pos/neg a quadrupole mass spectrometer or an ion-
switching. trap mass spectrometer system (16). High
Ion Trap: flow rates were applied and a column-
● Fully automated and manual MSn to switching valve was used to switch between
characterize compounds and elucidate two identical columns. Having finished
structures. the run on the first column, the injection
● Special version for highest sensitivity & valve and the column selection valve were
ultrahigh scan rates up to 26,000 m/z/s. switched such that the next sample was
Time of Flight: injected immediately onto the second col-
● Highest resolution and mass accuracy umn. In the meantime, a second pump,
( 3 ppm) for secure identification providing the starting concentration of the
and characterization. gradient, regenerated the first column.
● Extremely fast duty cycles for ultrafast Applying this setup, the cycle time was as
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 27

low as 1.1 min. accuracy, only the amount of noise can-


In Figure 14, the instrument set up for celling due to summing fewer data points
such fast cycle times is shown. (Figure 23). As a result, TOF is the pre-
Influence of MS data acquisition rate: ferred mass analyzer for high speed
Increasing the acquisition rate for MS chromatography.
detection may have an impact on other Instrument recommendations for fast
performance factors. For example, resolu- and ultrafast analysis with narrow-bore
tion is sacrificed on quadrupoles when columns and UV or MS detection: With an
increasing the scan speed to m/z 5000/s. In optimized flow path (for example, as
TOF detectors, the key performance factor shown in Figure 19 with 0.12-mm i.d.
is mass accuracy. TOF detectors typically capillaries) a state-of-the-art HPLC instru-
acquire one scan or “transient” in 70 – 100 ment can be updated for ultrafast HPLC
s and add as many as possible given the or HPLC–MS using narrow bore columns.
chromatographic peak width. As a result, The minimized system delay volume takes
faster acquisition rates do not impact mass gradient changes right to the column and

TIC: from 20_Hz_hi_lo.wiff


Max. 1.9e5 cps
0.49
1.6 0.37
Intensity (cps x 105)

1.2

0.33 0.41
0.8
0.27
0.4

0.0
0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60
Time (min) Max. 1053.1 counts
108.0450 156.0116
1000

Fragmentor 225 V
Intensity (counts)

800
285.0209
600 307.0026

400

308.9998
200 287.0194
328.9839

100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380
m/z (amu)

Figure 23: Analysis of four sulfa drugs with LC–ESI-TOF instrument at 40 Hz scan rate. A:
Water  0.1% Acetic Acid, B ACN  0.1% Acetic, 25%B to 60% @ 0.4 min, flow 3 ml/min
5 ng/ul each of sulfamethazine, sulfadimethoxine, sulfachloropyridazine and sulfamethizole
4.6  30  1.8 m Zorbax SB-C18 flow split to MS 2:1, Fragmentor 175 (175 & 225), drying gas
13 L/min @ 325 C, nebulizer 60 psi, Transient length 70 usec, scan range m/z 100–1000, 141 tran-
sients/scan, dual fragmenter data, 212 transients/scan.
28 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

Hypersequence

Sequence 1 Sequence 2 ... Sequence x

Run Run Run Run Run Run Run Run Run

Figure 24: Automation model with a "Hypersequence.”

speeds up the analysis. The autosampler packed with the appropriate bonded phase
delay volume must be taken out of the flow material and with small particle size, either
path automatically after the sample has 3–3.5 m or for greater efficiency, 1.8 m
reached the top of the column. This was Choose flow rates as high as appropriate
discussed previously as “automatic delay for optimal resolution. Increase column
volume reduction.” This contributes to temperature to reduce analysis time and
reduced run times and reequilibration back pressure.
times because of the lower volume. MS How to select the optimum instrument
detectors with sufficient scan rates ensure setup: State-of-the-art HPLC equipment
sufficient data to characterize fast-eluted ideally is suited for fast and ultrafast LC
compounds properly. without compromising performance or
Column recommendations for fast flexibility using standard and narrow-bore
and ultrafast analysis with narrow-bore columns, both with monolithic as well as
columns and UV or MS detection: Nar- columns with particles smaller than 2 m.
row-bore, 2.1-mm i.d. columns provide High-pressure mixing gradient pumps, fast
enhanced sensitivity with smaller sample autosamplers with capacity extension, and
sizes. These columns also are operated at fast-responding detectors are recom-
lower flow rates and are compatible with mended. For UV detection, low volume
both UV and MS detectors. When com- flow cells are recommended. For gradient
bined with 1.8-m particles, high effi- operations, the dwell volume should be as
ciency can be achieved for fast analysis low as possible.
with complex samples. Therefore, high- Using 2.1-mm i.d. columns such as
resolution, fast analysis of complex samples those often recommended for LC–MS
is an achievable goal. applications, short 0.12-mm capillaries
How do you select columns and set col- help further reduce the delay volume, yet
umn parameters?: Fast and ultrafast LC still are compatible with the flow rates used
can be done with the highest resolution with ultrafast HPLC.
and highest speed on columns packed with
1.8-m particles. Choose short columns Data System Considerations for
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 29

Fast and Ultrafast Analysis their own sequence table. It is also an


Fast run times and fast cycle times are the advantage if for further transfer of data to
first step to increase sample throughput. A a database, the appropriate study name can
second step, of equal importance, is to be filled in.
ensure that setup of automatic unattended Once a sequence has been set up and
analysis of samples (sequences) and evalua- started, it also is convenient to add more
tion of results do not become the limiting sequences for more sample sets without the
step. These hints are meant to provide need to wait for the end of the started
examples of how intelligent data acquisi- sequence. Using a so-called “hyper-
tion and evaluation software can help to sequence” you can do this (17). A hyper-
increase sample throughput. The topics sequence contains several sequences
discussed are related to sequencing, inte- aligned with their samples and also man-
gration, customized reporting, data stor- ages the correct analysis of all samples. The
age, and archiving and data transfer for sequence itself contains all parameters that
further data evaluation. are needed to perform the single runs. An
Acquisition setup: The setup of add-on of new samples and sequences
sequences of samples typically involves a should be possible at any time. In Figure
set of information like vial number, 24, the schema of such a hyper-sequence is
method name, injection volume, sample shown.
type, data file names, sample names, and The use of integrated barcode readers
more, which are added into the sequence allows safe linking of sample and results
lines. It is convenient for users if they can and automatic selection of sequences based
use names as long as needed and configure upon barcodes. It also is useful and saves

Baseline Example Description

Classical 1. Standard baseline tracking

2. Using timed events


Classical

No penetration 1. Search for penetration


2. Move start–end of peak until
(Classical)
no penetration is left

Advanced 1. Removal of baseline penetrations


2. Improve start–end of a peak
3. Reestablish the baseline for
a cluster of peaks

Figure 25: Improved integration for automatic baseline correction.


30 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

time if a hyper-sequence table can be time, due to extreme workload and more
imported as a CSV file, for example, cre- and more high throughput applications,
ated from Microsoft Excel. manually examining all chromatograms
Data evaluation — chromatogram and results has become a limiting factor for
integration: In the past, most users looked fast applications. Therefore, it is necessary
at the obtained chromatograms, at the for the integrator algorithm to be designed
integration results, and took appropriate such that even with a difficult baseline, the
action if the integration and baseline set- automated integration is appropriate. In
ting were not appropriate. In the mean- Figure 25, a comparison is made between

Table II: Column and instrument recommendations for high-throughput analysis


Module Cycle time Cycle time Cycle time Cycle time
< 1min < 5min > 5min > 10m
Column 15, 30 or 50mm length, 50mm length, 75mm length, > 75mm length,
4.6mm id, 1,8µm 4.6 mm id, 4.6 mm id, 1,8 µm 4.6 mm id
particle size 1.8 µm particle size or 3.5µm 1.8, 3.5 or 5 µm
particle size particle size
Flow As short as possible As short as possible Standard length Standard length
capillaries with internal diameter with internal diameter with internal with internal
of ~0.17µm of ~0.17µm diameter of diameter of
~0.17 µm ~0.17 µm
Pump High pressure gradient High pressure gradient High pressure High pressure
pump with optimized pump with optimized gradient pump gradient pump
delay vol. for fast delay volume for with optimized or low pressure
gradient operation fast gradient operation delay volume for gradient pump
fast gradient
operation
Auto sampler High speed sampler High speed sampler High speed sampler High speed
(ALS) with flow through with flow through with flow through sampler or
design for fast design for fast design for fast vial standard
injection and injection and injection and auto sampler
cleaning cycles cleaning cycles cleaning cycles
ALS ALS should be ALS should be Extension is Extension is
capacity equipped with equipped with typically not a typically not a
extension capacity extension capacity extension must must
Column Thermostat with Thermostat with Thermostat with Thermostat with
compartment Peltier heating Peltier heating Peltier heating Peltier heating
and cooling for fast and cooling for fast and cooling for fast for optimum
method changes and method changes and method changes temperature
highest temperature highest temperature and highest stability
stability stability temperature stability
UV detector UV detectors with UV detectors with UV detectors with UV detectors
fast data rates fast data rates standard cells with standard
(min 20Hz) and (min 20Hz) and and long path flow cells
with low-volume with low-volume length for and long path
flow cells and flow cells and highest sensitivity length for
long path length long path length highest
for lowest peak for lowest peak sensitivity
dispersion and dispersion and
highest sensitivity highest sensitivity
Mass MS with fast scan rates MS with fast scan MS with moderate MS with
spectrometer and typically with flow rates and typically scan rates and moderate scan
splitter, if flow rate is with flow splitter, typically with flow rates and
>1ml/min if flow rate is splitter, if flow rate typically with
> 1ml/min is > 1ml/min flow splitter, if
flow rate is
> 1ml/min
Recommendations for 4.6mm id columns packed with stationary phases of particle size between 1.8 and 5µm. If 2.1 mm
id columns are used for cycle times less than 5 minutes the flow capillaries should be about 0.12mm id to minimize
peak dispersion.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 31

different integration algorithms. penetrations, and the user must spend


A chromatogram is shown in which valuable time to set more integration
automated tracking of a baseline is not events to ensure proper baseline tracking.
easy. Baseline corrections are necessary Modern integrators have new functions
because baseline penetration occurs and or options in which first a standard base-
most peaks are on an upslope of the base- line is found and at the same time, baseline
line. Penetration is where the constructed penetrations are detected and advanced
baseline crosses the real signal and gives baseline tracking occurs.
negative areas, particularly if the user has Most recently, the user can determine
set the “baseline at valley” timed event. whether or not these new options should
Classical integrators cannot handle these be set. When this option is set, the peak

Figure 26: Customized report.


32 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

cluster will be searched for baseline pene- and format.


trations. The start and end of the peak are State-of-the-art data-evaluation software
shifted toward the top of the peak until offers both standard reports and also the
there is no penetration left. possibility to generate customized report
Furthermore, the integrator will try to templates, which are then used for all fol-
improve the start and end location of a lowing applications.
peak and reestablish the baseline for a clus- In Figure 26, an example of a cus-
ter. In many situations, this will give a bet- tomized report, based on an Agilent
ter and more stable (less dependent upon (Wilmington, Delaware) ChemStation
the slope sensitivity setting) baseline. The Plus report generation tool is given.
better the automated integration of chro- Results of all data files of a sequence are
matograms is, the less interaction of the combined. The report includes statistical
user is needed. One can have more trust in and quantitative data for the calibrated
the correctness of automated created base- peaks, names of used study and applied
line, and there is no need to look at any method and data, as well as the chro-
chromatogram. matograms of the single runs (18). To
Data reporting generation, archiving, make data management easier, the
and transfer to a LIMS: For high through- acquired data are transferred to a database
put analysis, hundreds and hundreds of and are stored in studies or other data-
reports must be created. The need here is management tools. This allows tracking of
to get only the amount of information that different sequences with, for example, dif-
is important for judging the results and for ferent applications on different working
making the right decisions. In most cases, days.
report generation must be customized These data-management tools allow a
according to the needed report content central and secure repository for organiza-

Figure 27: Tool bar of the LimsLink CDS worksheet, showing that all six samples have been
retrieved.
FEBRUARY 2005 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST 33

tion, review, approval, and storage of chro- and transferred to the LIMS. Typically, a
matographic data. Safe archiving of raw LIMS toolbar is used to display the current
data, chromatograms, and results is pro- status of the reporting process, showing
vided using these enhanced software tools. information such as the number of
Furthermore, laboratories also are faced approved samples found in CDS, how
with the requirement to accurately and many of those samples have been reported,
efficiently transfer data from the chro- or how much time remains until the LIMS
matography data system (CDS) to a LIMS. will query the CDS again for approved
An example of such a data-handling sys- results (19,20). An example of such a tool
tem is the Agilent Enterprise Content bar is given in Figure 27.
Management (ECM) tool. The Agilent Recommendations for data handling:
ECM is the umbrella system that encom- Ultrafast LC can generate as many as a few
passes all of Agilent’s application-specific hundred chromatograms overnight. This
software solutions. ECM stores all elec- requires considerations of how to handle
tronic records in a central location, regard- the huge amount of data. HPLC systems,
less of their format. ECM transfers key which come as complete solutions, are best
information from proprietary formats to a suited for fast and ultrafast LC in routine
generic format, facilitating review and analysis. This solution should include
management of data through a central sophisticated sequencing and integration
browser interface, independent of the ini- of data as well as customized reporting.
tial acquisition format of the data. ECM is Advanced data management with storage,
the answer to data storage, data organiza- archiving, and data transfer to a LIMS
tion, and compliance needs. must be available.
ECM is fully web-based and scalable
from single laptop solutions to enterprise Conclusions
system implementations for many users. This primer has examined many ways to
Its functionality combines the solution to be more productive using optimized con-
long-term archiving needs with the power ventional, fast, and ultrafast HPLC. All of
of a document management system. It pro- these methods are achievable in every lab,
vides full versioning and audit trails for all and the resulting improvements in produc-
human readable documents and reports, tivity can be realized easily in your day-to-
including the MS Office applications day work. This is accomplished using cur-
Word and Excel. It also provides a special rently available improvements in column
plug-in that enables Excel calculations to technology, HPLC instrumentation, and
run in a compliant fashion with restricted data system technology. This includes:
access and template protection, as well as New 1.8-m particle size column tech-
revision control and audit trails of the cal- nology is available in a variety of column
culation templates. dimensions, including 4.6- and 2.1-mm
Typically, the interface between the i.d. columns, which enable ultrafast analy-
CDS and LIMS automatically queries the sis with run times down to less than 40 s.
CDS at specified time intervals for The combination of advanced, 1.8-m
approved sample results. Any results that particle size columns and high-speed,
have been approved by CDS since the time high-capacity HPLC equipment (such as
of the last query are collected automatically high-pressure mixing pumps, high-speed
34 FAST, FASTER, ULTRAFAST FEBRUARY 2005

s03/Loyd-s03.pdf, University of Alabama,


autosamplers, and optimized detectors) Mobile, Alabama, 2003.
enables cycle times  60 s for ultrafast LC (7) A.M. van Nederkassel, A. Aerts, A. Dierick,
in 24  7 operation. D.L. Massart, and Y. Vander Heyden, J.
The combination of these elements with Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 32(2), 233–249 (2003).
fast, sophisticated data acquisition and reli- (8) R.E. Majors, LCGC 21(12), 1124–1133
able evaluation enables rapid and reliable (2003).
data review of huge amounts of chro- (9) Y. Yang and D.R. Lynch Jr., Recent Develop-
matograms and results. ments in LC Column Technology, Supplement
Table II provides a summary view of the to LCGC, June 2004, pp. 34–39.
(10) A.D. Broske, R.D. Ricker, B.J. Permar, W.
recommendations that have been pre-
Chen, and M. Joseph, Agilent Appl. Note
sented in this primer. In the table, recom-
5988-9251EN, http://www.agilent.com, Agi-
mendations are given as to what instru- lent Technologies, Wilmington, Delaware,
ment combinations will provide best 2003.
results for different cycle times. The table is (11) M. Stahl, Agilent Appl. Note 5988-9914EN,
related to 4.6-mm i.d. columns. If 2.1-mm Agilent Technologies, Wilmington, Delaware,
i.d. columns are used for cycle times  5 2003.
min, the flow capillaries should have an (12) W.E. Barber and M.J. Joseph, Agilent Appl.
internal diameter of 0.12 mm to minimize Note 5989-0540EN, Agilent Technologies,
peak dispersion. Wilmington, Delaware, 2004.
As a result, the methodology enables up (13) A. Fandino and S. Schuette, Agilent Appl.
Note 5989-1603EN, Agilent Technologies,
to 20 higher throughput. The column
Wilmington, Delaware, 2004.
and detector technology plus the mini-
(14) W.E. Barber, Agilent Appl. Note 5989-
mized dispersion are key factors to achieve 0542EN, Agilent Technologies, Wilmington,
in addition up to 2 the resolution and an Delaware, 2004.
increased sensitivity. (15) W.E. Barber and M.J.Joseph, Agilent Appl.
Note 5989-0026EN, Agilent Technologies,
References Wilmington, Delaware, 2003.
(1) A.D. Jerkovich, J.S. Mellors, and J.W. Jorgen- (16) M. Stahl, Agilent Appl. Note 5988-9638EN,
son, Recent developments in LC Column Tech- Agilent Technologies, Wilmington, Delaware,
nology, Supplement to LCGC Eur., June 2003, 2003.
pp. 20–23. (17) M. Stahl, Agilent Appl. Note 5988-9863EN,
(2) B. Yan, J. Zhao, J.S. Brown, J. Blackwell, and Agilent Technologies, Wilmington, Delaware,
P.W. Carr, Anal. Chem. 72, 1253–1262 2003.
(2000). (18) A. Gratzfeld-Huesgen, Agilent Appl. Note
(3) J.D.Thompson and P.W. Carr, Anal. Chem. 5988-9340EN, Agilent Technologies, Wilm-
74, 4150–4159 (2002). ington, Delaware, 2003.
(4) D. Lubda, K. Cabrera, W. Kraas, C. Schaefer, (19) Agilent Brochure 5989-1384EN, Agilent
D. Cunningham, and R.E. Majors, LCGC Technologies, Wilmington, Delaware, 2004.
Eur. 14(12). (20) S. Bolton and U. Bober, Agilent Appl. Note
(5) G. Rozing, Recent Developments in LC Column 5988-8962EN, Agilent Technologies, Wilm-
Technology, Supplement to LCGC, June 2004, ington, Delaware, 2003. 
pp. 12–17.
(6) J.D. Loyd, “Advances in HPLC: Monolithic
Silica Columns,” http://bama.ua.edu/~chem/
seminars/student_seminars/spring03/papers-
Agilent’s HPLC & MS purification
Your first great discovery will be the system itself
Agilent’s 1100 Series Purification Platform
has been enhanced with even more features
for you to discover. This includes signifi-
cant hardware and software innovations
for the highest purity and recovery, rugged
hardware for unattended 24/7 operation,
and a new dual loop autosampler PS for fast
The Agilent 1100 Series Purification Platform
Combines ruggedness, >97% purity, >98% recovery injection of high sample volumes. What’s
and 24/7 operation. This is made possible by: more, the ChemStation Data Browser
• Dedicated systems for lowest peak dispersion provides high-throughput analysis and
• Precise and automated delay volume measurement
• Integrated system intelligence with real time data purification data. It’s all accessible to you
processing with a wide range of software solutions
• ”Smart” fraction collection based on time, peak providing the option to configure a system
and/or mass
specific to your needs. In short, Agilent’s
1100 Series forges an unparalleled union
of reliability, safety and performance.

To learn more, Agilent offers a compre-


hensive, free e-seminar series with topics
u.s. and canada: 1-800-227-9770 for all levels of users. Register now on
www.agilent.com/chem/purification www.agilent.com/chem/education

©Agilent Technologies, Inc. 2005 MC5272


Catalog No.
5989–2108EN

You might also like