Professional Documents
Culture Documents
learning zone
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Page 57 Page 66 Page 67 Page 68
The benefits of honey in Tissue viability multiple Read Paul Endean’s Guidelines on how to
wound management choice questionnaire practice profile on write a practice profile
wound healing
in wound management
NS318 White R (2005) The benefits of honey in wound management. Nursing Standard. 20, 10, 57-64.
Date of acceptance: October 10 2005.
(Aminu et al 2000). This aspect of skin care is (SSD)-impregnated gauze (n=52 patients in each
supported by reports of the beneficial effects of group), 87 per cent of the wounds treated with
honey on paediatric (napkin/diaper) dermatitis honey healed within 15 days, compared with 10
(Al-Waili 2005), and on atopic eczema and per cent of those treated with SSD (P<0.001)
psoriasis (Al-Waili 2003). Validity was (Subrahmanyam 1991). In this study a
established by reproducibility, evidence level IIa. statistically significant difference (P<0.001) was
An outline of the wound types suitable for found in the clearance of bacteria from the burns.
honey treatment is given in Box 1. The key areas In the 43 out of 52 cases that presented positive
with regard to wound assessment are highlighted swab cultures on admission in the group treated
in Box 2. with honey, 39 (91 per cent) became sterile within
seven days. In the comparison (SSD) group, only
Time out 2 three (7 per cent) of 41 wounds with positive
BOX 3
Selection of the most appropriate
honey-based dressing
healing with the many systemic antibiotics and retraction or the lysis of fibrin. It is an enzyme
modern dressing materials previously used over a that is able to break down fibrin clots which
long period. attach slough and eschar to the wound bed
Good infection control was reported in a (Esmon 2004).
crossover study of nine infants with large infected Honey, through its strong osmotic action, may
surgical wounds (Vardi et al 1998). Honey was create a moist environment by drawing out lymph
used on the wounds after they failed to heal fluid from the wound tissues. This osmotic action
following at least 14 days of treatment with provides a constantly replenished supply of
intravenous antibiotics – a combination of proteases at the interface of the wound bed and
vancomycin and cefotaxime, subsequently the overlying necrotic tissue, which may in part
changed according to bacterial sensitivity – fusidic explain the rapid debridement brought about by
acid ointment, and wound cleaning with aqueous honey (Stephen-Haynes 2005). It also ‘washes’
0.05% chlorhexidine solution. Marked clinical the surface of the wound bed from beneath,
improvement was seen in all cases after five days which explains the frequent observation of honey
of treatment. All wounds were closed, clean and dressings removing debris, for example, foreign
sterile after 21 days of honey application. It is of bodies such as dirt and grit (Molan 2002). The
interest that in-vitro (in the experimental action also helps to explain the painless lifting off
laboratory situation of the test tube or culture of slough and necrotic tissue that is observed
dish) studies have shown a synergy between honey (Efem 1988, 1993, Hejase et al 1996,
and common antibiotics in multidrug-resistant Subrahmanyam 1993, 1998). In black necrotic
Pseudomonas spp. (Karayil et al 1998). This heels, the steady softening/debriding action of
would, therefore, appear to justify the honey allows granulation to begin before the
combination of systemic antibiotics with use of eschar is removed (Gray and White 2005).
topical antibacterials, such as honey, in wounds
where poor perfusion and drug resistance might Anti-inflammatory action
compromise healing.
Clinical observations of reduced inflammation
Wound malodour and deodorising following application of honey to a wound are
substantiated by the results of in-vivo studies that
Malodour is a common feature of chronic have shown that honey, when compared to
wounds and is attributed to the presence of various controls, reduces inflammation.
anaerobic bacterial species such as Bacteroides Histological evidence of reduced numbers of
spp., Peptostreptococcus spp. and Prevotella inflammatory cells present in wounds dressed
spp. (Bowler et al 1999, Cooper and Gray 2005). with honey exists from studies of deep and
It is reasonable to interpret the reduction in superficial burns as well as full-thickness wounds
malodour when treating wounds with honey as (Postmes et al 1997). These effects were the result
an antibacterial action in vivo; honey has also of components other than the sugar in honey
been demonstrated to be active against (Postmes et al 1997). Evidence also has come
anaerobes in vitro (Elbagoury and Rasmy 1993). from findings in biopsy samples from burn
However, the rapid deodorising of wounds wound tissue of hospital patients
observed when honey dressings are used is (Subrahmanyam 1998).
probably the result of more than just the Although it is a vital part of the normal
antibacterial action of honey against these response to infection or injury, excessive or
anaerobes. The malodorous substances prolonged inflammation can prevent healing or
produced by bacteria are short-chain fatty acids, cause further damage to tissues (Agren et al
ammonia, amines, and sulphur compounds. 2000). Suppressing inflammation, as well as
These are formed by the metabolism of amino reducing pain for the patient, also reduces the
acids from decomposed serum and tissue opening of blood vessels, thus lessening oedema
proteins. Honey provides a copious quantity of and exudate (Molan 2005). Pressure in tissues
glucose, a substrate metabolised by bacteria in secondary to oedema restricts the flow of blood
preference to amino acids (Molan 2005). through the capillaries, starving the tissues of the
oxygen and the nutrients that are vital for
Wound debridement leucocytes to fight infection and for fibroblasts to
multiply for wound healing.
Like any other moist wound dressings, honey
facilitates the debridement of wounds by Stimulation of tissue growth
autolysis. Honey promotes conversion of inactive
plasminogen in the wound matrix to the active With regard to the stimulation of tissue growth,
form, plasmin (Molan 2005), which is the major the evidence provided supports the following
proteolytic enzyme involved in blood clot statements:
TABLE 1
Reported pain sensation on the application of a honey-based wound ointment in a study of
89 patients
Wound type No pain Mild pain Severe pain
Venous ulcers 31 4 1
Burns 5 2 0
Diabetic foot ulcers 5 1 0
Mixed wounds 9 2 3
Pressure ulcers 15 3 0
Skin tears 8 0 0
Note: not all medical honey dressings are advocated for the treatment of full-thickness burns; always
read the manufacturer’s instructions before use
(Vandeputte and Van Waeyenberge 2003)
References
Agren MS, Eaglstein WH, Bloomfield E (1976) Old remedies. Dunford C, Cooper R, Molan P Harris S (1994) Honey for the
Ferguson MW et al (2000) Causes Journal of the Royal College of (2000a) Using honey as a dressing treatment of superficial wounds: a
and effects of the chronic General Practitioners. 26, 576. for infected skin lesions. Nursing case report and review. Primary
inflammation in venous leg ulcers. Times. 96, 14 Suppl, 7-9. Intention. 2, 4, 18-23.
Bolton LL, Monte K, Pirone LA
Acta Dermato-Venereologica. 210,
(2000) Moisture and healing: Dunford C, Cooper R, Molan P, Hejase MJ, Simonin JE, Bihrle R,
3-17.
beyond the jargon. Ostomy Wound White R (2000b) The use of honey Coogan CL (1996) Genital
Ahmed AK, Hoekstra MJ, Hage J, Management. 46, 1A Suppl, in wound management. Nursing Fournier’s gangrene: experience with
Karim RB (2003) Honey-medicated 51S-62S. Standard. 15, 11, 63-68. 38 patients. Urology. 47, 5, 734-739.
dressing: transformation of an
Bowler PG, Davies BJ, Jones SA Eddy JJ, Gideonsen MD (2005) Johnson DW, van Eps C,
ancient remedy into modern
(1999) Microbial involvement in Topical honey for diabetic foot Mudge DW et al (2005)
therapy. Annals of Plastic Surgery. ulcers. Journal of Family Practice. Randomized, controlled trial of
chronic wound malodour. Journal of
50, 2, 143-148. 54, 6, 533-535. topical exit-site application of honey
Wound Care. 8, 5, 216-218.
Al-Waili NS (2003) Topical (Medihoney) versus mupirocin for
Cooper RA (2005) The Efem SE (1988) Clinical
application of natural honey, the prevention of
antimicrobial activity of honey. In observations on the wound healing
beeswax and olive oil mixture for catheter-associated infections in
White RJ, Cooper RA, Molan P properties of honey. British Journal
atopic dermatitis or psoriasis: hemodialysis patients. Journal of
(Eds) Honey: A Modern Wound of Surgery. 75, 7, 679-681.
partially controlled single-blinded the American Society of
study. Complementary Therapies in Management Product. Wounds UK, Efem SE (1993) Recent advances in Nephrology. 16, 5, 1456-1462.
Medicine. 11, 4, 226-234. Aberdeen, 24-32. the management of Fournier’s
Karayil S, Deshpande SD,
gangrene: preliminary observations.
Al-Waili NS (2005) Clinical and Cooper RA, Gray D (2005) The Koppikar GV (1998) Effect of
Surgery. 113, 2, 200-204.
mycological benefits of topical control of wound malodour with honey on multidrug resistant
application of honey, olive oil and honey-based wound dressings and Elbagoury EFA, Rasmy S (1993) organisms and its synergistic action
beeswax in diaper dermatitis. ointments. Wounds UK. 1, 3, Suppl Antibacterial action of natural with three common antibiotics.
Clinical Microbiology and Infection. part II, 26-32. honey on anaerobic bacteroides. Journal of Postgraduate Medicine.
11, 2, 160-163. Egyptian Dental Journal. 39, 1, 44, 4, 93-96.
Cooper RA, Molan PC,
381-386.
Al-Waili NS, Saloom KY (1999) Krishnamoorthy L, Harding KG Keast-Butler J (1980) Honey for
Effects of topical honey on (2001) Manuka honey used to heal Esmon CT (2004) Crosstalk necrotic malignant breast ulcers.
post-operative wound infections due a recalcitrant surgical wound. between inflammation and The Lancet. 2, 8198, 809.
to Gram positive and Gram negative European Journal of Clinical thrombosis. Maturitas. 47, 4,
Kingsley A (2001) The use of
bacteria following Caesarean Microbiology & Infectious Diseases. 305-314.
honey in the treatment of infected
sections and hysterectomies. 20, 10, 758-759. Gray D, White RJ (2005) Mesitran wounds: case studies. British
European Journal of Medical Cutting KF, White RJ (2002) Oinment case studies. Wounds UK. Journal of Nursing. 10, 22 Suppl,
Research. 4, 3, 126-136. Maceration of the skin and wound 1, 3, Suppl part II, 32-36. S13-S20.
Aminu SR, Hassan AW, Babayo UD bed. 1: Its nature and causes. Gray D, White RJ, Cooper P, Lusby PE, Coombes A,
(2000) Another use of honey. Journal of Wound Care. 11, 7, Kingsley A (2005) Understanding Wilkinson JM (2002) Honey: a
Tropical Doctor. 30, 4, 250-251. 275-278. applied wound management. potent agent for wound healing?
Dunford C (2005) The use of honey Wounds UK. Applied Wound Journal of Wound, Ostomy, and
Biswal BM, Zakaria A, Ahmad NM
in wound management. In White
Management Part 2: Continence Nursing. 29, 6, 295-300.
(2003) Topical application of honey
Implementation. 1, 2, Suppl, S4-S9.
in the management of radiation RJ, Cooper RA, Molan P (Eds) Marshall C, Queen J, Manjooran J
mucositis: a preliminary study. Honey: A Modern Wound Green AE (1988) Wound healing (2005) Honey vs povidone iodine
Supportive Care in Cancer. 11, 4, Management Product. Wounds UK, properties of honey. British Journal following toenail surgery. Wounds
242-248. Aberdeen, 116-129. of Surgery. 75, 12, 1278. UK. 1, 1, 10-18.
References (continued)
McInerney RJF (1990) Honey: a Alternative and Complementary Sofka K, Wisznewsky G, Blaser G Blair S, Parton J, Tonks A (2003)
remedy rediscovered. Journal of the Medicine. 11, 3, 511-513. et al (2004) Antibakterieller Honig Honey stimulates inflammatory
Royal Society of Medicine. 83, 2, (Medihoney) zur Wundpflege- cytokine production from monocytes.
Postmes TJ, Bosch MMC,
127. Wundantisepsis bei patiatrischen Cytokine. 21, 5, 242-247.
Dutrieux R, van Baare J,
Patienten in der Hamatologie-
Misirlioglu A, Eroglu S, Hoekstra MJ (1997) Speeding up Van der Weyden EA (2003) The
Onkologie? Krankenhaus-Hygiene +
Karacaoglan N, Akan M, Akoz T, the healing of burns with honey. An use of honey for the treatment of
Infektion Verhutung. 26, 5, 183-187.
Yildirim S (2003) Use of honey as experimental study with histological two patients with pressure ulcers.
an adjunct in the healing of assessment of wound biopsies. In Somerfield SD (1991) Honey and British Journal of Community
split-thickness skin graft donor Mizrahi A, Lensky Y (Eds) Bee healing. Journal of the Royal Society Nursing. 8, 12, Suppl, S14-S20.
sites. Dermatologic Surgery. 29, 2, Products: Properties, Applications of Medicine. 84, 3, 179.
Vandeputte J, Van
168-172. and Apitherapy. Plenum Press, New
York NY, 27-37. Stephen-Haynes J (2004) Waeyenberge PH (2003) Clinical
Molan PC (2002) Re-introducing Evaluation of a honey-impregnated evaluation of L-Mesitran®, a
honey in the management of Prescription Pricing Authority, tulle dressing in primary care. honey-based wound ointment.
wounds and ulcers: theory and Department of Health (2005) British Journal of Community European Wound Management
practice. Ostomy Wound Drug Tariff. September. The Nursing. 9, 6, Suppl, S21-27. Association Journal. 3, 2, 8-11.
Management. 48, 11, 28-40. Stationery Office, London. Also
available at Drug Tariff Online: Stephen-Haynes J (2005) Vardi A, Barzilay Z, Linder N,
Molan PC (2005) Mode of action. Implications of honey dressings Cohen HA, Paret G, Barzilai A
www.drugtariff.com/
In White RJ, Cooper RA, Molan P within primary care. In White RJ, (1998) Local application of honey
(Eds) Honey: A Modern Wound Rolfe G (1999) Insufficient Cooper A, Molan P (Eds) Honey: A for treatment of neonatal
Management Product. Wounds UK, evidence: the problems of Modern Wound Management postoperative wound infection.
Aberdeen, 1-23. evidence-based nursing. Nurse Product. Wounds UK, Aberdeen, Acta Paediatrica. 87, 4, 429-432.
Education Today. 19, 6, 433-442. 33-53.
Moore OA, Smith LA, Campbell F, White RJ (2001a) Managing
Seers K, McQuay HJ, Moore RA Schultz GS, Sibbald RG, Subrahmanyam M (1991) Topical exudate: Part 1. Nursing Times. 97,
(2001) Systematic review of the Falanga V et al (2003) Wound bed application of honey in treatment of 9, 11.
use of honey as a wound dressing. preparation: a systematic approach burns. British Journal of Surgery.
BioMed Central Complementary and to wound management. Wound White RJ (2001b) Managing
78, 4, 497-498.
Alternative Medicine. 1, 2, Epub, Repair and Regeneration. 11, exudate: Part 2. Nursing Times. 97,
1-4. Suppl 1, S1-S28. Subrahmanyam M (1993) 14, 59.
Honey-impregnated gauze versus
Natarajan S, Williamson D, Schumacher HH (2004) Use of White RJ, Molan P (2005) A
polyurethane film (OpSite®) in the
Grey J, Harding KG, Cooper RA medical honey in patients with summary of published clinical
treatment of burns: a prospective
(2001) Healing of an chronic venous leg ulcers after research on honey in wound
randomised study. British Journal of
MRSA-colonised, hydroxyurea- split-skin grafting. Journal of management. In White RJ,
Plastic Surgery. 46, 4, 322-323.
induced leg ulcer with honey. Wound Care. 13, 10, 451-452. Cooper A, Molan P (Eds) Honey: A
Journal of Dermatological Subrahmanyam M (1998) A Modern Wound Management
Simon A, Sofka K, Wiszniewsky
Treatment. 12, 1, 33-36. prospective randomised clinical and Product. Wounds UK, Aberdeen,
G, Blaser G, Bode U, Fleischhack G
histological study of superficial burn 130-143.
Okeniyi JA, Olubanjo O, (2005) Wound care with
wound healing with honey and
Ogunlesi TA, Oyelami OA (2005) antibacterial honey (Medihoney) in Wood B, Rademaker M, Molan P
silver sulfadiazine. Burns. 24, 2,
Comparison of healing of incised pediatric hematology-oncology. (1997) Manuka honey, a low cost
157-161.
abscess wounds with honey and Supportive Care in Cancer. August leg ulcer dressing. New Zealand
EUSOL dressing. Journal of 2, epub, 1-14. Tonks AJ, Cooper RA, Jones KP Medical Journal. 110, 1040, 107.