Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 7
MARKETING RESEARCH, DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS, AND SALES
FORECASTING
CHAPTER OVERVIEW
Collecting and managing information about what customers need and want is a challenging task for
any marketer. This chapter focuses on marketing research—the process of collecting and using
information for marketing decision making. It explains that data comes from a variety of sources—
from well-planned studies, sales force reports, accounting records, or published reports, and from
controlled experiments and computer simulations.
The chapter also focuses on the impact of technology in the market research process—right from
data mining, data collection, analysis of the gathered information to market research decision
making and planning—which is aimed at gathering business and competitive intelligence.
Chapter 7 also includes the ways market research affects promotional decisions, sales forecasts,
and growth predictions. Why is research needed? Marketers use research to understand their
customers, target customer segments, and develop long-term customer relationships—all keys to
profitability. Information collected through marketing research underlies much of the decision
making involved in market segmentation, discussed in Chapter 8.
The marketing research function is the primary source of information and is clearly central to
effective marketing decisions. This chapter also explains how marketing research techniques are
used to make accurate sales forecasts, a critical component of marketing planning.
The chapter has been updated and revised in several ways. New material has been added to
several sections, including an expanded discussion of interpretative and ethnographic research.
• The Opening Vignette and Connecting with Customers profile how loyalty or points cards
are used in marketing research. This section has been updated to reflect the changes in
loyalty programs since the last edition. Loyalty programs such as Air Miles track shoppers’
buying habits based on information collected from retailers. The input is anonymous, so it
can be pooled into a shared, or cooperative, base that creates reports for clients without
compromising the privacy of those who volunteered the information. Loyalty programs are
an effective means of collecting information about shopping habits because so many
Canadian participate in at least one program.
• Solving an Ethical Controversy looks at issues around the type of information being
collected by marketers. Is the collection of sensitive information an invasion of an
individual’s privacy? Does the collection of sensitive information lead to stereotyping and
prejudiced behaviour or do the benefits to organizations outweigh the privacy issues?
• Go Green looks at how LoyaltyOne Inc., the company that introduced the Air Miles program,
took the results of their research into the importance of the environment and introduced a
new loyalty program. The My Planet program rewards consumers who purchase products
that reduce carbon dioxide emissions and other harmful chemicals in order to conserve
natural resources.
• Marketing and the SME profiles the FACESofCHANGE research project. The project
combined online research with more traditional research methods to uncover a deeper
understanding of the relationships between media, people, and brands in the 18- to 24-year-
old demographic.
• Marketing in a Digital World examines the Optimum Public Relations study into whether
Facebook Likes could predict elections. Starting with a study conducted in the United
States, the company followed Canadian candidates from across the country during a recent
election to determine if there was link between how many “likes” a candidate received and
their success in the election.
• Chapter Case 7.1 looks at how “Market Research Companies Scan the Globe for Marketing
Data.” Two companies, NPD and Nielsen, use various techniques to research such issues
as whether an increase in gas prices will affect consumer spending patterns. The results of
the research projects undertaken by these companies are discussed and how these types of
research projects can assist marketing decision makers.
• Video Case Synopsis includes an overview of Ogden Publications. The video is designed
to expand and highlight the concepts in this chapter and the concepts and questions
covered in the written video case.
LECTURE OUTLINE
Opening Vignette and Connecting with Customers—“Points Cards or Market Research.” Should data from
shoppers be cross-referenced to form consumer profiles? Would you care if your purchases were used to
create a massive database?
Chapter Objective 1: Describe the development of the marketing research function and its major
activities.
Key Terms: marketing research, syndicated service, full-service research supplier, limited service
research supplier
Basic PowerPoint: 1,3,7
Expanded PowerPoint: 1-8
1. What is marketing research?
a. Marketing research is the process of collecting and using
information for marketing decision making.
b. Data comes from a variety of sources, such as well-planned
studies, sales force reports or accounting records, or controlled
experiments and simulations.
c. By presenting pertinent information in a useful format, marketing
research aids decision makers in analyzing data and suggesting
possible actions.
d. Marketing research helps marketers in understanding
customers, targeting customer segments, and developing long-
term relationships.
2. The marketing research function
a. The underlying purpose of marketing research is to find out
more about consumers, clearly central to effective customer
satisfaction and long-term relationships.
b. Development of the marketing research function
i. In 1879 the first organized marketing research project
was organized; in the early part of the 20th century, the
first commercial research department was established.
ii. In the first known study, Charles Parlin counted soup
cans and found that working-class families bought more
canned soup than wealthy ones, convincing Campbell
Soup to place ads aimed at this population.
iii. Research methods became more sophisticated in the
1930s due to the development of statistical techniques.
iv. Advances in computer technology have led to significant
changes, including the addition of simulations that allow
marketers to pose “what if” questions.
c. Who conducts marketing research?
i. The size and organizational form of the marketing
research function are usually tied to the firm’s structure.
ii. Firms organize research units by product lines, brands,
geographic areas, or the type of research needed.
d. Many organizations depend on independent marketing research
firms due to several factors:
i. Cost is often the reason for using an external firm.
ii. Information collected is often more reliable and accurate
1. What are the six steps in the marketing research process? The marketing
research process can be divided into six specific steps: (1) defining the
problem, (2) conducting exploratory research, (3) formulating a hypothesis, (4)
creating a research design, (5) collecting data, and (6) interpreting and
presenting research information.
Chapter Objective 3: Distinguish between primary and secondary data and identify the sources of
each type.
Key Terms: secondary data, primary data
Basic PowerPoint: 15
Expanded PowerPoint: 15-17
1. Collect data
a. Marketing research gathers two kinds of data—secondary and
primary.
Chapter Objective 4: Explain the different sampling techniques used by marketing researchers and
identify the methods by which marketing researchers collect primary data.
Key Terms: sampling, population, probability sample, nonprobability sample, interpretative research, mall
intercepts, focus groups, controlled experiment, test-market
Basic PowerPoint: 18,19,22-24
Expanded PowerPoint: 18-24
1. Sampling techniques
a. Sampling is the process of selecting survey respondents or
research participants.
b. It is one of the most important aspects of research design
because if a study uses a sample different from a target market,
the results will be misleading.
c. A population or universe is the total group of people the
researcher wants to study.
d. Unless it’s very small, data is rarely gathered from an entire
population, resulting in a census, due to high costs.
e. Instead they work with a sample, a representative group chosen
from this population and classified as either probability or
nonprobability types.
2. Probability sample
a. A probability sample gives every member of the population a
chance of being selected.
b. Types of probability samples:
i. Simple random sample—every member of the relevant
universe has an equal opportunity of selection.
ii. Stratified sample—randomly selected subsamples of
different groups represented in the total sample.
iii. Cluster sample—researchers select areas (or clusters)
from which they draw respondents.
3. Non-probability sample
a. A nonprobability sample relies on personal judgment in the
selection process as researchers decide what groups to study.
7. Survey method
a. Observation cannot supply all of the desired information, so
researchers must ask questions to get information on attitudes,
motives, and opinions.
b. Observation doesn’t obtain exact demographic information—to
get that, researchers use interviews or questionnaires.
c. Telephone interviews
Marketing and the i. Telephone interviews are a quick and inexpensive
SME: method for obtaining a small quantity of relatively
FACESofCHANGE. impersonal information.
Do you think the ii. Simple, clearly worded questions are easy for
FACESofCHANGE interviewers to pose over the phone and are effective in
research was an drawing appropriate responses.
effective way to reach iii. Telephone surveys have relatively high response rates,
the 18- to 24-year-old particularly with repeated calling, and some firms use
consumer? Why or computerized random dialing to speed up the process.
why not? Are there
iv. However, phone surveys have drawbacks: people
other research
refuse to do them due to the time needed, the nuisance
methods that may be factor, negative associations with telemarketing, or
more effective? poorly designed surveys.
v. Also, results may be biased by the omission of certain
households or those with unlisted numbers.
vi. Caller ID and other electronic devices are designed to
block calls and act as obstacles to phone surveys.
vii. Consumers are increasingly concerned about privacy
issues and information given over the phone.
viii. Phone surveys can be useless abroad in areas where
telephone ownership is rare, directories are lacking, or
charges are made when accepting calls; results in these
cases will be highly biased.
d. Personal interviews
i. Personal interviews are the best method for obtaining
detailed information about consumers, as the
interviewer can establish rapport and explain confusing
or vague questions.
Chapter Objective 5: Explain the challenges of conducting marketing research in global markets
and outline the most important uses of computer technology in marketing research.
Key Terms: marketing information system (MIS), marketing decision support system (MDSS), data mining
Basic PowerPoint: 25, 26, 29-31
Expanded PowerPoint: 25-31
1. Conducting international marketing research
a. Though the steps are similar, new challenges arise when
gathering information about consumers in foreign markets.
b. Canadian firms can tap many secondary resources when
researching global markets, particularly through the government.
i. Industry Canada and U.S. Department of Commerce are
good sources of Information.
2. Challenges of conducting international marketing research:
a. Language issues—communicating the message in the most
effective way
b. Cultural issues—capturing local citizens’ interests while avoiding
missteps that could unintentionally offend them
c. Business environment—political and economic conditions,
potential for growth, and trade regulations that affect research
studies and data collection
d. Some adjustment in the collection of data for primary research
may be necessary.
i. Some methods do not easily transfer across national
boundaries.
opinion, Delphi technique, survey of buyer intentions, trend analysis, sales force composite,
exponential smoothing
Basic PowerPoint: 32-34
Expanded PowerPoint: 32-35
1. Sales forecasting
a. A sales forecast is an estimate of a firm’s revenue for a specified
future period.
b. Forecasts play major roles in new-product development,
production scheduling, financial planning, inventory planning
and procurement, distribution, and human resource planning.
c. An inaccurate forecast can lead to poor or incorrect decisions in
these areas.
Table 7.1 Benefits and d. Marketing research techniques are used to create and deliver
Limitations of Various effective sales forecasts.
Forecasting
e. A forecast sets standards against which to measure actual
Techniques, Which
performance; without standards, no comparisons can be made.
techniques would be
best for a firm with a f. A short-run forecast covers up to one year, an intermediate
limited budget? For a forecast covers one to five years, and a long-run forecast
firm with a time extends beyond five years.
crunch? For a firm g. Types of sales forecasting methods:
willing to pay for i. Qualitative forecasts—techniques that rely on subjective
detailed and realistic data rather than exact historical data
information?
ii. Quantitative forecasts—techniques that rely on
statistical computations
iii. Each method has benefits and limitations; most firms
rely on a combination of the two
2. Qualitative forecasting techniques
a. Planners use qualitative forecasting techniques when they want
judgmental or subjective indicators.
b. Qualitative forecasting techniques include jury of executive
opinion, Delphi technique, sales force composite, and survey of
buyer intentions.
c. Jury of executive opinion
i. The jury of executive opinion technique combines and
averages the outlooks of top executives from each of
the functional areas of the firm.
ii. It’s a quick and inexpensive method that often generates
good forecasts for sales and new-product development.
iii. It works best for short-term forecasting.
d. Delphi technique
i. The Delphi technique solicits opinions from several
people, but also gathers thoughts from experts outside
the firm, such as academic researchers.
ii. It is most appropriately used to predict long-run issues,
such as technological breakthroughs, that could affect
future sales.
iii. A firm selects a panel of experts and sends each a
questionnaire, combines and averages answers,
develops another questionnaire based on the results,
1. Nielsen offers data collected by optical scanners from the United Kingdom, France, Germany,
Belgium, the Netherlands, Austria, Italy, and Finland. This scanner data tracks sales of UPC-coded
products in those nations. In small teams, imagine that you are one of Nielsen’s clients. One team
might be a retail chain, another an Internet company, and still another a toy manufacturer. Discuss
the types of marketing questions these data might help you answer. Share your list with other
teams.
Start a discussion on ACNielsen and the ways in which it collects data via optical scanners from the
United Kingdom, France, Germany, Belgium, the Netherlands, Austria, Italy, and Finland. Ask
students to explain how this scanner might track sales of UPC-coded products in those nations.
Then have teams (representing retail chains, Internet companies, and toy manufacturers) talk about
the types of marketing questions that this data might help answer. Have students write down the
questions that come to mind and then share them with the class.
2. Discuss some of the challenges Pizza Hut might face in conducting marketing research in
potential new international markets. What types of research would you recommend the company
use in choosing new countries for expansion?
Have students talk about the challenges Pizza Hut may be facing in conducting marketing research
on the potential new international markets. When a country wants to expand into foreign nations,
what kind of information does it need? What types of research would provide it?
3. Working alone or with a partner, choose a new product idea, or a variation on an existing
product, that you think will appeal to your classmates, such as yogurt or an energy drink in new
flavour, and devise a test-marketing plan for it. Determine where you will test your product and
which variables you will assess, such as price and promotion activities. Be prepared to present your
plan to the class and include a description of the information you hope your test market will provide.
Have students select a product that is new, or modified. Existing products are to be avoided in this
exercise. Students must select the appropriate, relevant variables, and suggest plans to test market
the product. There are many ways to do test marketing, such as showing it to potential buyers,
creating a blog or a website, determining the correct prices, asking a buyer, comparing product with
others, and taking it to a trade show. They should present their ideas, as well as the expected
responses.
4. Interpretative research offers marketing researchers many possibilities, including the opportunity
to improve product features such as packaging for food or over-the-counter medication that is
difficult for seniors or people with disabilities to open. List some other ways in which you think this
observation method can help make existing product offerings more appealing or more useful to
specific kinds of users. What kind of products would you choose, and how would you test them?
Have students share their lists of the ways in which the observational method works to make
existing products appear more appealing or useful. Have them explain how interpretative research
can be used to explore product features such as packaging for food or over-the-counter medication
that is difficult for seniors or the disabled to open. What kind of products did they choose? How
would they test them? Start a discussion on the ways in which interpretative research can be used,
and the situations in which it might not be the best choice.
5. McDonald’s conducts extensive marketing research for all its new products, including new menu
items for its overseas stores. Due to cultural and other differences and preferences, the company
cannot often extrapolate its results from one country to another. For instance, Croque McDo fried
ham and-cheese sandwiches are unlikely to be as popular in North America as they are in France,
which invented the croquet monsieur sandwich on which McDonald’s product is based. Can you
think of any other kinds of firms that share this limitation on global applications of their research? In
contrast, what sorts of questions could multinational firms answer on a global basis? Why?
Start a discussion on this broad topic. As McDonald’s conducts extensive marketing research for its
new products, it must take into account differences in cultures, tastes, and preferences. But it can’t also
use results of one study for its marketing in another country. What other industries or broad business
areas did students think of that are also limited in this way on a global basis. How can their global
research be improved? And what questions could multinational firms answer? Continue the discussion
by having students suggest names of well-known companies and their products that might have trouble
transferring their product from one nation to another.
Critical-Thinking Exercises
1. Some companies are broadening their markets by updating classic products to appeal to younger
people’s tastes and preferences. What primary and secondary market information would you want
to have if you were planning to reinvigorate an established brand in each of the following
categories? Where and how would you obtain the information?
a. household cleaner
b. moist packaged cat food
c. spray starch
d. electrical appliances
Students should have little trouble with this exercise assuming they understand the difference
between secondary and primary data, as well as the sources of both. You might want to focus the
exercise a little by restricting it to a specific type of data, one that is easy to obtain, such as Census
data.
2. Prepare a list of data (primary information) that you would want to obtain from a mystery shopper
surveying a chain of gas stations in your area. Devise a format for gathering the information that
combines your need to compile the data electronically and the researcher’s need to remain
undetected while visiting the stores.
Most students will be able to come up with four or five data items that they would like to obtain. As
for the device, ask students to think of a common electronic device, one whose use is widespread
and doesn’t attract attention.
3. Select a sales forecasting method (or combination of methods) for each of the following
information needs and explain your pick(s).
a. prediction of next year’s sales based on last year’s figures
b. prediction of next year’s sales based on weighted data from the last five years
c. expected sales categorized by district and by region
d. estimated product usage for the next year by typical consumers
e. probable consumer response to a new product
Student answers will vary and there really are not right or wrong answers. Make sure students fully
understand the differences between qualitative and quantitative forecasting techniques, and can
clearly justify their responses. An important point perhaps to stress is that there isn’t any one
perfect forecasting technique. Many times it is appropriate to employ multiple techniques.
4. The Internet provides ready access to secondary market information but is also a portal to an
almost limitless store of primary information via message boards, chat rooms, email questionnaires,
newsgroups, and website registration forms. What are some specific drawbacks of each of these
methods for obtaining primary information from customers?
Expect some variation in student responses. Make sure they consider the privacy implications of
using some online sources of data. As we discussed earlier, privacy concern is still one of the major
impediments to the growth in e-commerce.
Ethics Exercises
Consumer groups sometimes object to marketers’ methods of collecting primary data from
customers. Research the code of ethics of the Canadian Marketing Association (CMA), American
Marketing Association (AMA), and the Marketing Research and Intelligence Association (MRIA).
Note especially the guidelines for use of the Internet in marketing research.
1. Check the websites of a few large consumer products companies. How effectively do you think
these sites are at informing visitors about the use of “cookies” on the sites? Do you think marketers
could or should improve their protection of visitors’ privacy? If so, how?
2. Do you think it violates the code of ethics if marketers compiled a mailing list from information
provided on warranty and product registration cards and then used the list to send customers new-
product information? Why or why not? Does your opinion change if the company also sends list
members special discount offers and private sale notices?
The exercise deals with several important ethical issues affecting marketing research. It also
illustrates a potential dilemma. On the one hand, product registration forms, contests, and so forth
are effective ways of collecting primary data. On the other hand, if customers conclude that the
company is asking for too much information, it may end up hurting sales. The issue of balance may
be raised by some students. As for the questions, student opinions on the effectiveness of policies
regarding cookies, and other data collection devices, will vary substantially. Is full and fair
disclosure sufficient? Student opinion on the second question will also be divided.
Internet Exercises
1. Focus groups: Visit some websites that discuss the proper way to organize and conduct a focus
group (managementhelp.org). After reviewing the material, prepare a brief report on this subject.
The purpose of this exercise is to give students some guidelines for setting up and running focus
groups. The website expands on the material in the chapter. Make sure students understand both
the purpose of focus groups and their limitations
2. Marketing research firm services. Nielsen is one of the world’s largest marketing research
firms. Go to the firm’s website (http://ca.nielsen.com). Assume you run a small online retailer. What
types of marketing research services could a firm like Nielsen provide to your company? What are
some of the benefits?
Students must visit Nielsen’s website and take a note of the services offered by them. They may
analyze and identify the services that Nielsen can provide a small online retailer. The potential
benefits, insights, solutions, tools, and support need to be documented and presented by the
students.
3. Data analysis. Statistics Canada publishes data on the Canadian population. Visit its website
(http://www.statcan.gc.ca). Review the types of information available. How up-to-date is it? Is there
information that you don’t find that could be helpful for marketers?
This exercise is fairly straightforward and students should be able to complete it with minimal
supervision. The exercise will illustrate the range and depth of data available from Statistics
Canada, as well as the ease at which the data can be accessed. Students should see for
themselves why census data is so important to marketers. Specific answers will depend on when
the data were accessed.
Case 7.1 “Marketing Research Companies Scan the Globe for Marketing Data”—Questions
for Critical Thinking
1. Do you think filmmakers and film companies should actively cultivate the Internet
community? Why or why not? What possible and advantages and drawbacks could such a
strategy have?
Most students will conclude that cultivating the Internet community is a good idea. Internet
users, as they learned in previous chapters, are an attractive market for most films. The
advantages of the Web are clear. It can help make decisions regarding the film (the Hulk
example in the case, for instance), it helps to create a buzz for an upcoming film, and so
forth. On the downside is the issue of security. Another important issue is the fact that not all
moviegoers are regular Internet users and not all Internet households have high-speed
Internet access. Ask students how frustrating it can be to visit a movie site with just dial-up
access. Ever try to watch a trailer?
2. Find an upcoming film that has an official website. What features does the site have? Which
ones are designed to deliver information to the public and which are designed to capture
information? How successful do you think this site will prove to be as a marketing research
tool? Why?
Student answers will vary. You may want to show students an example in class to help get
them started.
3. How can filmmakers control the information that appears on the Internet? Should they take
these steps? Why or why not?
Student opinion will vary. Essentially, however, the question of control relates to the use of
material that is covered by copyright. If an Internet user sets up a chat room concerning a
film, and only posts negative comments, there is little the studio or the filmmaker can do so
long as the site doesn’t violate copyright.
Case 7.2 “Forecasting Pitfalls for SUV Makers”—Questions for Critical Thinking
1. Should the auto industry base its sales forecasts more heavily on qualitative or quantitative
techniques? Why?
Student answers will vary. Encourage students to consider specific benefits and limitations of these
techniques.
2. What forecasting techniques would help auto industry executives more accurately forecast
movements in the price of oil? How should they factor these forecasts into their sales projections?
This type of forecasting is likely going to require expertise from outside the firm and that makes the
Dephi Technique a viable approach. These forecasts should definitely be considered when
compiling their own sales projections.
Marketing Research
Purpose:
To introduce marketing research through hands-on experience
Background:
Marketing research is the foundation of successful marketing, yet many students find the
topic somewhat dry. This exercise is designed to introduce marketing research in a way that
sparks student interest while previewing the basic concepts from the chapter.
Relationship to Text:
Chapter Overview
Preparation/Materials:
You’ll need to buy one package each of four or five different brands of chocolate chip
cookies. Look for a variety of sizes and types, but beyond that, whatever is on sale will work.
Put each type of cookie in a generic bag, and mark the bags Cookie A, B, etc. You’ll also
need either napkins or paper plates, and if you’d like, a litre or two of milk and paper cups.
Exercise*:
Announce that your class will be doing research on chocolate chip cookies. Working in small
groups, their job is to develop and implement a research methodology to determine which
cookie brand is the chippiest, which is the tastiest, and which is the overall best. They will
need to report to the class their results, their methodology, and their level of certainty. Divide
them into groups, and give them about 15 minutes to work. When the groups report to the
class, write the results in a matrix on the board. Don’t tell them how the letters correspond to
actual brands until the whole class is finished. (Interestingly, store brands seem to do
surprisingly well.) Group discussion questions: Which factors were hardest to determine?
Which were the easiest? Which answers were subjective, and which were objective? Why
wasn’t every student’s answer the same? How could a marketer for one of the
manufacturers use this information? Encourage them to consider issues such as target
market (are college students really an important target market for chocolate chip cookies?)
and sample size (are the results from just one class representative of the larger
population?). When you do share the actual brands, ask them if there were any surprises.
Why?
Questions for Reflection:
• Given that all marketing research techniques have limitations, why is it important to
invest in research? How do you know when you have enough information?
• What role (if any) should intuition or “gut feel” play in marketing research? Why?
* Source: Sharon H. Ulanoff, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Elementary Reading and Bilingual
Education, California State University, Los Angeles
Purpose:
To help students apply the marketing research process
Background:
On-going marketing research can play a significant role in keeping a business viable over
the long term. This exercise is designed to help students understand how to approach the
research process by applying it to a specific situation.
Relationship to Text:
The Marketing Research Process
Preparation/Materials:
You may want to copy the scenario and challenge (below) for each student.
Exercise:
After you have reviewed the material on the marketing research process, divide your class
into small groups and distribute the scenario outlined below:
Scenario: You and your partners are the owners of an upscale nightclub called Amnesia
Nights. When you opened the club two years ago, it quickly became a trendy hotspot,
attracting crowds of partiers in their 20s and 30s, plus a fair share of celebrities on the
weekend evenings. However, in the last six months, attendance has declined significantly.
You know that some clubs have a short (yet glamorous) lifespan, but you are determined to
be part of the scene for years to come. You have decided that the first step in recovering
from the slump is marketing research.
The Challenge: You and your team have 10 minutes to develop your ideas for marketing
research by responding to the following questions:
The teams will need to work quickly, but the time limit works well because they often
generate their best ideas for this project in the first few moments. Ask each group to share
their responses with the class, and encourage them to evaluate the merits of each approach
honestly, but respectfully. By the end of the discussion, they should have a strong
understanding of both the potential value and the limitations of marketing research.
Sampling Techniques
Purpose:
Background:
Some students have difficulty distinguishing between probability and non-probability
samples in actual practice. This quick, discussion-based exercise is designed to highlight
the difference.
Relationship to Text:
Sampling Techniques
Preparation/Materials:
None needed
Exercise:
Ask your class if it is a representative sampling of the entire school. At first many students
will nod, but after a moment or two they usually begin to realize that it may not be. Ask them
to identify how the class make-up might be different from that of the general student body
(business majors, time of day, employment status, etc.). Then, ask how you could collect a
true random sample of students (they typically develop a variety of sound approaches).
Finally, ask if it would ever make sense to use one class of students for marketing research.
They should be able to identify several viable scenarios.
Purpose:
To demonstrate a useful projective research technique
Background:
While gathering information through traditional marketing research methods (surveys, focus
groups, etc.) can produce excellent results, using projective techniques can yield insights
that respondents may find tough to articulate directly. This exercise is designed to give your
students experience with a specific projective research method.
Relationship to Text:
Primary Research Methods
Exercise:
Ask your students to brainstorm a list of five to 10 different automobile makes and models
that they know and like. Then, request five volunteers and invite them to the board. Ask
each one to choose a car from the list, and then to draw a picture of how that car would look
if it were a person (assure them that stick figures are fine). Ask them also to complete either
a speech or a thought bubble. When the drawings are complete, ask the volunteers to briefly
describe their person’s appearance, character traits, profession, and lifestyle. (For example,
is the person uptight, friendly, geeky, handsome, or smooth? Does he or she live at home,
share an apartment with friends, or own a mansion in the hills?) After the presentations, ask
the class to analyze the results. How would this information be helpful to market
researchers? What did they learn that might not be as clear by asking more straightforward
questions? In what product categories would projective research be most helpful? (It tends
to work best for visible products that people identify with themselves in a personal way.
Examples include spas, vacation destinations, computers, and alcoholic beverages.)
Garbology
Purpose:
To explore a rather unorthodox method of primary research
Background:
The text indicates that modern marketing research emerged more than a hundred years
ago, due in large part to a study of garbage for Campbell Soup. Ad salesman Charles Parlin
did one of the first marketing research studies using a very hands-on approach—he counted
discarded soup cans in various neighborhoods and found that working-class families bought
more canned soup than wealthy ones, convincing Campbell Soup to aim its ads toward this
population. The field of garbology—defined by the American Marketing Association as “the
study of consumer behaviour and preferences for food and products by examining . . . items
found in the trash and garbage”—continues to play a small but significant role in marketing
research today. This quick discussion exercise is designed to introduce students to
garbology and its various uses.
Relationship to Text:
Primary Research Methods
Preparation/Materials:
You may want to do a quick Google search to determine whether searching garbage without
permission in your area is legal.
Exercise:
Share the definition of garbology with your students. (Be prepared for a lot of groans. In fact,
you can tease them and suggest that this exercise involves doing a survey of the garbage
can in your classroom.) Ask them to quickly create a list of things found in a classroom,
library, or dorm trash can. Then have them brainstorm some ways that information collected
through garbology could be useful to marketers (e.g. recycling habits, beer consumption,
fast-food leftovers). Help them see the benefits of tracking what people do (rather than what
they say they do) by studying their trash. Then, encourage them to consider the ethical
implications of this approach. Does it need to involve some level of deceit? Why or why not?
Does it violate privacy? How could these issues be resolved?
Two of the stories related to Sir John on the march by the Sultan’s
stirrup-holder may be inserted here as exemplifying the manners and
customs of the officials about the Moorish Court, and especially
those of the military class. The first may be called ‘A Story of a
Moorish Prince.’
Mulai Ahmed, second son of Sultan Mulai Abderahman Ben
Hisham, was appointed by his father Viceroy of the districts of Beni
Hassén, Zair, Dukála, Shedma, &c. His residence was at Rabát.
This Prince was clever, and endowed with many good qualities,
but he was extravagant and reckless in his expenditure, and thus
became deeply indebted to the merchants and shopkeepers of
Rabát; but no man ventured to press his pecuniary claims on the
wayward youth. His debtors, moreover, had only to ask some favour
by which they might be benefited in their trade, and it was
immediately granted by the Prince; the favour thus conferred amply
recouping them for their unpaid goods.
On the occasion of a visit of the Sultan to Rabát in 1848, Mulai
Ahmed was still Viceroy. Various complaints had been brought by the
inhabitants to the Uzir, Ben Dris, against His Royal Highness for not
paying his debts; but the Uzir endeavoured so to arrange matters as
to avoid reporting the misconduct of the young Prince to his father.
One day, however, when the Sultan was going to mosque, an
Arab from the country called out, from a high wall—on which he had
climbed to avoid being silenced by the troopers who formed the
escort of the Sultan—‘Oh Lord and Master, Mulai Abderahman, my
refuge is in God and in thee! I have been plundered and unjustly
treated during this your reign.’
The Sultan, restraining his horse, desired his attendants to learn
who this man was; and, after hearing their report, sent for the Uzir
and directed him to inquire into the case and report thereon.
On the man presenting himself before the Uzir, the latter
reprimanded him for brawling in the streets for justice. ‘One would
suppose,’ said Ben Dris, ‘that there were no longer governors or
kadis in Morocco! Whence are you? what have you to say?’
‘I am an Arab from Shedma,’ the man replied. ‘I had a fine horse,
for which I had been offered by the chief of my tribe three hundred
ducats, but I refused to sell; for, though a poor man, my horse was
everything to me; I would not have parted with him for all the wealth
that could be offered me. Some weeks ago I came to Rabát, and
Mulai Ahmed—may God prolong his days!—in an evil hour saw my
horse, and ordered his soldiers to seize it, sending me a purse of
three hundred ducats, which however I refused to accept. For forty
long days have I been seeking justice, but can obtain hearing neither
of Mulai Ahmed nor of any one else.’
The Uzir replied, ‘If your story be true, your horse shall be
returned to you; but, if false, you shall be made an example of for
daring to bring a complaint against the son of the Sultan.’
The Uzir then sent a messenger to inquire of Mulai Ahmed
concerning the matter, and by him the Prince sent reply that he knew
nothing about the horse. The Uzir was consequently about to order
the Arab to be bastinadoed, when the latter begged Ben Dris to send
him, accompanied by some of his—the Uzir’s—attendants, to the
stables of Mulai Ahmed, where he felt sure he would find the horse;
begging that his whole tribe might, if necessary, be called upon to
give evidence respecting the identity of the horse.
The Uzir accordingly sent the Arab, with a guard, to the Prince’s
stables to point out the horse, with directions that it should be
brought before him. He also sent to inform Mulai Ahmed that this
order of his father the Sultan must be obeyed.
The attendants took the Arab to the stable, where he immediately
recognised his horse, but had no sooner done so than he was
arrested, along with the Uzir’s men, by some soldiers sent by Mulai
Ahmed, and brought before the Prince, who had them all
bastinadoed and dismissed.
On the return of the Uzir’s men, they reported to their master what
had taken place. The Uzir had them again bastinadoed for not
having carried out his orders, viz. to bring back the Arab and his
horse in safety. Then, mounting his mule, he rode direct to the
palace, where he recounted to the Sultan what had occurred.
His Majesty was highly incensed; his eyes flashed lightning, and
his voice was as thunder. ‘Dare any son of mine disobey the orders
of his father? Are my people to be robbed and ill-used at his caprice?
Summon the chief kaid of our guard.’
The officer appeared. ‘Take,’ said the Sultan, ‘a saddled mule to
the palace of Mulai Ahmed. Bind the Prince hand and foot. Conduct
him this day to Meknes, where he is to be imprisoned until further
orders. Let the Arab have his horse and an indemnity for the rough
treatment he has received. Let a proclamation be issued that all
persons who have been unjustly used by Mulai Ahmed are to
present themselves to me; for there is no doubt,’ added the Sultan,
‘that is not the only case of injustice of which my son has been
guilty.’
The orders of Sultan Mulai Abderahman were obeyed. The chief
of the guard appeared before Mulai Ahmed with a mule saddled and
bridled, and informed the Prince he was deposed from his position
as Viceroy, and that he was to proceed at once with him to Meknes.
At first Mulai Ahmed refused to obey his father’s commands, but,
on being threatened by the officers with fetters and manacles if he
showed any resistance, consented to mount the mule and start at
once on his journey. The third day they arrived at Meknes, where
Mulai Ahmed was confined in prison, whence he was not liberated
for five years.
I suppose the young Sultan intends to tread in the footsteps of his ancestors
and remain stagnant.
My belief is that these people, or rather this Government, will never move
ahead until the lever acts at headquarters continuously, by the presence and
pressure of the Foreign Representatives. So long as we preach and pray at a
distance, nothing will be done. On the other hand, if the Foreign Representatives
were removed to the Court, there would no doubt be a rupture of relations, or
some tragedy, before twelve months elapsed.
Again, shortly after the accession of Mulai Hassan, Sir John writes
to the same correspondent:—
I shall make a fresh effort to induce the young Sultan to introduce some
reforms and improvements, but I have but faint hope of success, as the Ministers
and satellites of the Court are either rogues or fools.
From my experience of Turkey and the Turks I confess I have little confidence
in the beneficial effect of any attempt to introduce European grafts on the old
Mohammedan stock. The tree which showed signs of vigour has been cut down,
and the fruit of the European graft contains rather the evils than the virtues of both
the West and the East.
When this letter was written, Sir John was already on his way to
Fas. On March 3, 1875 he left Tangier, accompanied by several
members of his family, some personal friends[51], and the officers
appointed by the British Government to attend the Mission.
The reception at Fas was magnificent, some six thousand troops
having been sent to do honour to the Representative of Great
Britain; but what was more pleasing to him and greatly enhanced the
effect of the entry, was the presence of the citizens of Fas, who had
come to meet him in their thousands, bringing with them their wives
and children; to show, they said, their appreciation of his friendship
and love of justice. The shrill ‘zagharit’ continually raised by the
women as Sir John passed through the crowd, attended by his staff
and escort, completely drowned at times the sound of the brass
band which the Sultan had sent to play before the procession. Soon
after the instalment of the Mission at Fas, the incident occurred
which Sir John relates as follows:—