You are on page 1of 7

Ohio - Criminal Procedure MBE University of Akron

U of Akron alum
Uploaded to quizlet Sept 2016
100 terms
crivero10
https://quizlet.com/144264571/crim-pro-mbe-flash-cards/

Title - Arrests and Seizures ...


Burdens of Proof - Conviction - Beyond reasonable doubt
- Arrest - Probably cause (more likely than not)
- Stop - Reasonable Suspicion
Seizure - Rule officer intentionally terminates or restrains subject's freedom of
movement through use of physical force ro show of authority
Seizure - Test Whether the reasonable person would feel free to disregard the
officer
Types of Seizures Terry stops, traffic stops, arrests
Stop and Frisk/Terry Stops officer must have reasonable suspicion, based on articulable
facts, to believe the suspect is or is about to be engaged in
criminal behavior.
What is officer allowed to do pat down for weapons, but cannot search for evidence
during Terry Stop?
if pat down reveals objects whose shape make their identity
obvious, officer can seize those objects

if probable cause develops during the Terry Stop officer can


make an arrest
Arrest requires probably cause to believe suspect committed crime

misdemeanor arrest - officer witnessed the crime


Warrant authorized an officer to arrest someone
Who issues a warrant neutral judicial officer and detached magistrate
Burden in order to issue warrant probable cause that person committed the crime; warrant must
name the suspect
3 warrant requirements 1. probable cause to believe items sought are fruits or evidence of
a crime

2.issued by neutral magistrate

3. describe place a property with particluarity


7 Exceptions to warrant 1. Exigent circumstances - Hot pursuit
requirement - ESCAPES 2. Search incident to lawful arrest
3. Consent
4. Automobiles
5. Plain view
6. Evidence obtained from administrative searches
7. Stop and Frisk
Search incident to arrest - Rule lawful arrest permits officers to search arrested person and
immediate area for:
officer and public safety

prevent destruction of evidence


Search incident to arrest on the can search suspect and his wingspan
street
Search incident to arrest at home search suspect and immediate arrest area
Arrest in car search suspect and passenger compartment as long as suspect still
has access to vehicle at the time.
Example of arrest and search of a Cannot arrest suspect, cuff him, put him in the back of squad car,
car and go search the car. Suspect is not a danger to officers
anymore; he cannot access a weapon from the car; he cannot
destroy evidence in the car.
Exam tip Remember, search is proper if reasonable to believe that that
vehicle contains evidence of the offense of arrest.
Inventory Search police arrest a driver and impound the car, it may be searched for
inventory purposes.
Exam tip search and seizure step 1 - is there probable cause
questions step 2 - was search beyond scope of search incident to arrest?
Search definition Occurs when government conduct violates a reasonable
expectation of privacy.
Places where we have an 1. Homes
expectation of privacy against 2. Hotel Room
govt. 3. Offices
4. Backyard
5. Luggage
Places we do not have an 1. Public streets
expectation of privacy 2. Open fields
3. Garbage cans left out in street
4. Abandoned property
Fifth Amendment Self incrimination. No person shall be compelled to testify
against or incriminate himself.
Scope of 5th amendment privilege natural persons (not corporations or unions)

testimonial evidence

incriminating

any proceeding as long as reason to believe future criminal


prosecution
Does 5th amendment protect No. If I tell my Pops I committed a crime, they can force them to
something said to 3rd party? testify.
Statements made as result of Inadmissible unless accompanied by procedural safeguards
custodial interrogation (warnings). If not in custody, no warning is required.
Custodial - definition arrested or detained (not free to leave)
Interrogation - definition any conduct likely to elicit or induce a response (does not include
routine booking questions
Miranda Warning must be given prior to custodial interrogation

must ask if suspect understands rights

as long as substance of Miranda rights is communicated, it will


be sufficient
Police returning to question same after substantial period of time, police can go back to the suspect,
suspect give warnings again, and seek to talk to her.
Invoking the right to an attorney not enough to say I think I should talk to someone - must say I
want a lawyer!
Public safety Miranda exception police do not have to give Miranda warnings if public safety is at
risk
Title - Interrogation Rules ...
Confessions must be voluntary - confession obtained by threat are not
admissible

However, confession can be based off deception


Involuntary obtained statements fruit of the poisonous tree - never admissible
Miranda violation statements in inadmissible in prosecution's case in chief, but admissible for
court impeachment purposes to challenge credibility of D
Voluntary Miranda violation evidence obtained as a result of a voluntary statement taken in
statements violation of Miranda is admissible.
Sixth Amendment Right right to counsel
How to invoke sixth amendment attaches automatically upon indictment, information, or other
right formal charges - unless D knowingly and intelligently waives the
right
When does 6th amendment right All felonies and all misdemeanors in which jail time is imposed.
apply?
All critical stages of prosecution
When does 6th amendment not investigative lineups (pre indictiment), witness looking at photo
apply arrays, discretionary appeals and post conviction
Title - Identification procedures ...
Two kinds of ID procedures line up and photo array
Photo array no right to be present, but police must turn array over to D
Pre-indictment lineup no right to counsel
Post-indictment lineup right to counsel; if counsel not present, evidence is inadmissable
Lineup evidence at trial must not be impermissibly suggestive
In court identification ...
Title - The Exclusionary Rule ...
and its Exceptions - Highly
tested
The Exclusionary Rule illegally obtained evidence is inadmissible at the criminal trial of
the person whose rights were violated.

only applies at trial, not pre-trial proceedings


The Exclusionary Rule - Evidence obtained in violation of the 4th, 5th, or 6th amendments
Definition cannot be introduced at trial.
Standing must be of D's rights - no one elses
Passengers in a car where driver is arrested without probably
cause are deemed to have been seized. They can challenge
constitutionality of the stop.
Fruit of the poisonous tree exclusionary rule also applies to all evidence obtained as a result
of the initial constitutional violation.

Example - Cops illegally search and find a key. They use the key
to open a safe box which leads them to more evidence. Key is
found in violation. Stuff inside the box is fruit of the poisonous
tree.
5 1/2 Exceptions to Exclusionary 1. Knock and Announce
Rule
2. Inevitable Discovery

3. Independent Source

4. Attenuation in Causal Chain

5. Good faith

5 1/2. isolated Negligence by Law Enforcement


Knock and Announce officer required to knock, announce, and request admission

if they burst in without knock/announcing, the evidence they find


will still be admissible
Inevitable discovery evidence would have been discovered anyway through lawful
means, is admissable
Attenuation in the causal chain intervening events and the passage of time can remove the taint
Good faith officers who relied on existing law that was later declared
unconstitutional

officers relied on defective warrant (hidden defect)


- warrant cannot be obtained by fraud
- warrant not defective on its face
- magistrate did not wholly abandon his judicial role
Isolated Negligence isolated negligence by law enforcement personnel does not
trigger the exclusionary rule

Ex: someone thinking there was a warrant when there really


wasn't
Overturning a conviction use harmless error analysis - would keeping the evidence out
make a difference in the outcome?
Fifth Amendment Presentment Federal felony charges must be initiated by indictment unless D
Clause waives indictment
Indictment - Definition claims there is probable cause to believe D committed the crime
Title - Grand Jury Proceeding ...
Hearsay grand jury can consider hearsay evidence
Exculpatory Evidence Prosecutors have not duty to present exculpatory evidence
Defendant appearance D has no right to appear in front of the grand jury
Witnesses Witnesses have no right to bring counsel with them to grand jury
room
Secret proceedings Grand jury proceedings are held in secret
unanimous grand jury does not have to be unanimous
Eighth Amendment forbids excessive bail, but does not state bail is required
When is Bail available? always unless D is flight risk or danger to community

there's a presumption in favor of release prior to trial and


presumption against release after conviction
Pretrial release conditions court can impose pretrial release conditions
Title - Guilty Pleas ...
Valid Guilty Pleas D intelligently and knowingly waive rights thorugh plea
allocution
Plea Allocution Judge
informs D of rights and makes sure D understands those rights
informs D of possible sentences
Ensures there is factual basis for plea
Ensure plea was not made in exchange for anything or by use of
force or threat

D can challenge for involuntary waiver of rights f plea allocution


is not proper
Title - Trial Process ...
6th Amendment right to jury trial - attaches when asked for and offense
punishable by MORE THAN 6 months in jail.
Jury Sizes Federal - 12 - unanimous

States - 6 do not have to be unanimous


Jury Selection must be fair cross section of the community form which no
distinctive group is excluded

voir dire - cause or preemptory challenges can remove jurors


Speedy Trail Rights due process clause and speedy trial clause of 6th amendment
protect against delay

four factors to speedy trial claim


1. length of delay
2. reason for delay
3. whether defendant asserted right to speedy trial
4. prejudice to the defendant
Trial open to public must be open unless likelihood in prejudice or unfairness
6th amendment confrontation right to confront witnesses against them and produce their own
clause witnesses
Prosecutorial duties 1. turn over exculpatory evidence

2. evidence that could be used to impeach state witness

3. Material evidence (could change the outcome)

4. May not knowingly present false testimony


5. May not contact defendant outside presence of his counsel

6. May not comment on D failure to testify


Prosecutorial misconduct If it affects veridct, may require a mistrial or reversal of
conviction. Otherwise, only discipline.
Defense Counsel and 6th guarantees defendants EFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF
amendment COUNSEL
Joint representation judge can choose to allow joint representation. Must warn D's of
conflict
Strickland test: effective assistance Supreme Court has developed this test. 2 parts - Performance and
of counsel Prejudice

Performance - did defense counsel engage in objectively


reasonable conduct?

Prejudice - did deficient performance prejudice defendant? would


result had been different?
Choice of Counsel defendants who can afford retained counsel are entitled to the
counsel of their choice
Proceeding Pro Se entitled to waive the right to counsel and rep themselves - no
constitutional right to "back-up" lawyer
Title - Sentencing ...
3 primary issues in sentencing 8th amendmet - Cruel and Unusual Punishment

5th amendment - Double Jeopardy

6th amendment - The Apprendi cases


8th amendment cruel and unusual crimes involving actual individual victim - imposed only in cases
punishment - Capital Punishment in which victim dies

Cannot be imposed:
under 18 when crime committed
mentally retarded defendants
insane at the time of execution
Double Jeopardy protection against:
1. prosecution for same offense after acquittal
2. prosecution for same offense after conviction
3. multiple prosecutions or punishments for the same offense
Defining the same offense: each statutory provision requires proof of an element that the
Blockburger Test other does not
Double Jeopardy tricky situation different victims equal different offenses - Ex: killing two victims
with one shot

separate sovereign rule - two separate sovereigns can try D


separately (the U.S. and a state or two separate states).
When does double jeopardy when jury is sworn in, or in a bench trial when first witness is
attach? sworn in.

Case end upon acquittal or reversal of conviction upon appeal.


Prosecution cannot appeal.
Mistrial Two Kinds:
1. Manifest Necessity - Defendant can be retried (jury is
deadlocked or defense counsel misconduct

2. No manifest necessity - Defendant cannot be retried by that


jurisdiction (judge declares mistrial so he does not miss his plane)
Apprendi Doctrine - 6th D entitled to have jury decide, by proof beyond a reasonable
amendment doubt, all of the elements necessary to impose a particular
criminal punishment.

You might also like