You are on page 1of 5

Moratuwa Engineering Research Conference (MERCon) 2020

The Tensile Electroplasticity of Low Carbon Steel


with Low Amplitude Pulse Current
Nayanathara Hendeniya Gayan Aravinda Abeygunawardena
Department of Materials Science & Eng. Department of Materials Science & Eng.
University of Moratuwa University of Moratuwa
Moratuwa, Sri Lanka Moratuwa, Sri Lanka
150217t@uom.lk aravinda@uom.lk

Indika De. Silva Shiranga Wickramasinghe


Department of Materials Science & Eng, Department of Materials Science & Eng.
University of Moratuwa University of Moratuwa
Moratuwa, Sri Lanka Moratuwa, Sri Lanka
indikagip@uom.lk 150592k@uom.lk

Abstract—The significant improvement of the plasticity of to the temperature rise results in an apparent reduction of flow
a metal that undergoes deformation in the presence of electricity stress. The effect of Joule heating is less significant compared
is called electroplasticity. Manufacturing processes such as to the electron wind force [5]. It is shown that at sufficiently
drawing, and rolling are depending on heat to reduce the forces high temperatures, flow stress reduction can happen due to
associated with fabrication. The high-temperature requirement thermally activated plastic flow [6].
is potentially leading to stress, warpage, and reduced tolerance
control. The manufacturing method called Electrically Assisted The modern theory of electroplasticity suggests that the
Manufacturing is introduced as an effective solution for these flow stress reduction is attributed to the combination of
obstacles. The electroplastic deformation of low carbon steel softening due to Joule heating, depinning of dislocations by
under the simultaneous combination of uniaxial tensile paramagnetic obstacles (magnetic effect of electroplasticity)
conditions and electrical pulses was investigated. A reduction of and the electron wind force [7]. It is difficult to describe the
the yield stress of low carbon steel having 0.2 wt% of carbon characteristic changes that happen inside the metal without
content was observed due to the electroplasticity. This work referring to a combination of these three mechanisms.
focused on developing a pulsed current generator to achieve the
required combination of current density and pulse width for When studying the electroplasticity effect in any metal,
electroplasticity effect in these steel samples, and analysis of pulsed current feed to the work specimen is the most
yield stress reduction qualitatively. challenging concern. According to literature, electroplasticity
effect has observed under three scenarios.
Keywords—Electroplasticity, Dislocations, Uniaxial Tensile
Test, Electrically Assisted Manufacturing, Low Carbon Steel
1. Continuous current supply [3], [6], [8].
2. Single pulsation at high current amplitude [9-11].
I. INTRODUCTION
3. Continuous pulsation at moderate or low current
The effect of the electric current on improving the
amplitude [10].
plasticity of metal by reducing the flow stress is introduced as
the electroplasticity. This phenomenon was first observed in Generally, continuous current supply is not recommended,
Zn single crystals [1]. The reduction in flow stress leads to since controlling the heat effect of continuous current supply
reduced drawing force hence the energy used in metal forming is much difficult. Furthermore, the peak current density of
is decreased. Industrially, this is an important feature to reduce continuous current is lower than the peak current density of
the cost of manufacturing since reduced wear results in pulsed current with the same effective current density [10].
minimum die replacement and reduced drawing force leads to Meanwhile, researchers have shown that the effective current
decrease the stresses on die and wires [2]. density is the factor that affects the heating effect. Low
amplitude pulse current is highly motivated for industrially
However, there is no proper mechanism that can explain
applicable Electrically Assisted Manufacturing (EAM)
the electroplasticity effect. The first assumption about the
system [10]. Electrically Assisted Manufacturing is a metal
mechanism was that electroplasticity occurs in metal by
forming method, that is supported by current pulses to reduce
electron wind force which drags dislocations [3]. For usual
the energy consumption [4].
current density values that electroplasticity effect was
observed in laboratory scale, the theoretically calculated effect Traditionally, metals are deformed at elevated
of electron wind force is negligible [4]. Therefore, the electron temperatures to increase their formability. Forming the metals
wind force is not the only mechanism that drives at elevated temperatures results in several significant
electroplasticity. drawbacks; decrease in die strength and poor lubrication due
to increased adhesion between the die and the workpiece [17].
A model was proposed by Molotskii and Fluorov without
involving the electron wind force. The movement of Alternative methods such as hydroforming and
dislocations is impeded by pinning centers. If these centers incremental forming are time-consuming, and the capital
possess paramagnetism, then the depinning rate is severely investment is high. The requirement is to develop a cost-
affected by the magnetic field induced by the current [5]. effective metal forming process that can enhance the
formability while reducing the forming force without an
Various studies about electroplasticity favored the idea of
thermal effect. Contribution of Joule heating i.e. dilatation due

978-1-7281-9975-7/20/$31.00 ©2020 IEEE

165
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Brighton. Downloaded on September 27,2020 at 22:12:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Moratuwa Engineering Research Conference (MERCon) 2020

extreme escalation in temperature while having a lower power TABLE II. SPECIFICATIONS OF THE PRIMARY AND THE SECONDARY
utilization [12]. COIL OF THE TRANSFORMER AFTER MODIFICATION
Voltage (V) Current (A)
Several studies have shown the capability of electricity to
enhance the formability of metal without a considerable Primary Coil 230 6.52
increase in temperature. Furthermore, it was revealed that the
metal tends to have a reduction in flow stress under the Secondary Coil ~1.2 ~1250
application of current pulses [13], [14]. The pulsed current of
short duration and high frequency has been incorporated into
the metal manufacturing industry [10].
Low carbon steel is one of the most versatile engineering
materials. Although there were many advanced materials
developed through the years, low carbon steels still have a
great significance in engineering applications, influenced by
some properties, mainly due to moderate formability and low
cost [15]. However, concerns are raised about effective power
consumption in metal forming, regardless of the formability
or the cost of the materials.
In this study, a customized current supply was built to
provide the pulse current requirement for low carbon steel, Fig. 2: Control unit of the pulsation set up (a) timer (b) contactor (c) bulb
and the mechanical behavior of low carbon steel under low indicator and transformer (d) secondary winding (e) primary winding
amplitude pulse current and uniaxial tensile deformation were
studied. Hence the feasibility of EAM for low carbon steel was
assessed in the laboratory scale.
II. EXPERIMENTAL
A. Preperation of Tensile Test Specimens
Low carbon steel samples in strip form having 0.2wt.% of
carbon was acquired from a local dealer. As-received samples
were subjected to Spark Emission Compositional Analysis to
verify the chemical composition (TABLE I). Tensile
specimens were prepared according to customized design
(Fig. 1). Prepared specimens were homogenized at 2000C for
two hours to remove any residual stresses induced in metal
forming and machining.
B. Development of a Pulsed Current Generator
For the tensile test with pulsed current, the current was
supplied using a step-down transformer with an adjustable
pulse controller. A transformer with 1.5kVA power was Fig. 3: Schematic representation of the experimental set-up
modified to obtain the required current by changing the
winding. The secondary coil was modified as containing six C. Tensile Test Under Pulsed Current Supply
windings, with each winding consists of 23 copper wires. The
The quasi-static tensile tests were carried out at room
primary coil was remained unchanged. The currents and
voltages that can be obtained from primary and secondary temperature, using a universal tensile testing machine, with a
coils after the modification is shown in TABLE II. A constant displacement rate of 20mm/min. In the experimental
calibrated timer was used to obtain a discrete pulse current as setup, both the gripping ends of the specimen were carefully
desired. Components of the developed pulsed current insulated to isolate the current flow from the testing machine.
generator are shown in Fig. 2. However, due to copper loss of The current flowing through the specimen was measured
the connecting wires, it was difficult to pass the total output using an oscilloscope. The current amplitude, nominal
current of 1250 A through the specimen. A schematic current density (based on the original cross-section of the
representation of the experimental set-up is shown in Fig. 3. specimen), frequency, and the pulse width are shown in
TABLE III. For the tensile test with pulsed electric current,
TABLE I. CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF THE AS-RECEIVED LOW
CARBON STEEL SAMPLE
the specimen was continually pulsed with a constant
amplitude of electric current until the fracture. A set of three
C Mn Si P S Cr Fe
0.201 0.55 0.189 0.0127 0.066 0.028 98.8
specimens was tested for each condition to verify the
repeatability of the test, and the load vs. extension behavior
was obtained from the in-built tensile behavior tracking
software of the tensile machine. Temperature rise during the
tensile test was monitored using an infrared thermal gun. Data
sets comprising 30 data points were taken from the obtained
Fig. 1: Detailed design of the test specimen load vs. extension graphs and were digitized using OriginPro
software to convert load and extension into stress and strain

166
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Brighton. Downloaded on September 27,2020 at 22:12:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Moratuwa Engineering Research Conference (MERCon) 2020

values respectively. The average yield stress was calculated visual representation of the area under the curve for samples
using the obtained yield stress values. To verify the effect of tested with current is lower than the area under the curve for
current on ductility, area reduction was measured relative to samples tested without current. This justifies the phenomena
samples tested without current. The lengths of the two sides that the strain energy absorbed by the sample has been reduced
of the fractured surface were measured using Vernier caliper. under the pulsed current [18].
This was repeated for both pieces of the sample, tested TABLE III. CURRENT DENSITY, PULSE WIDTH, AND FREQUENCY USED
without current and with current for all three specimens. By IN THE EXPERIMENT
using these measurements, the average area of the separated Current Current Pulse width (s) Frequency
samples was calculated to compare the relative reduction of amplitude density (Hz)
the area. (A) (A/mm2)
64 10.6 10 20
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A. Current Supply Method TABLE IV. YIELD STRESS OF THE SAMPLES TESTED IN THE PRESENCE
OF CURRENT AND UNDER NORMAL CONDITION
Previous studies proved that there are several possible
methods for supplying current to the specimen. Sample no. Yield Stress without Yield Stress with
current (MPa) current (MPa)
• Increasing the current from the normal supply 1 373.11 284.62
using transformers, 2 388.24 334.02
• Using a welder (A similar method to 3 365.35 321.42
transformers that is specially used in welding Standard 11.64 25.67
machines) [16] Deviation
(MPa)
• Using capacitor banks [17] Average 375.57 313.35
However, the foremost task was to identify the most (MPa)
Reduction (MPa) 62.22
appropriate current supply method for this study.
The pulsed current can be increased up to kA range using TABLE V. UTS OF THE SAMPLES TESTED IN THE PRESENCE OF PULSED
transformers and current can be transmitted to the specimen CURRENT AND UNDER NORMAL CONDITIONS
through a regulation circuit. Vedal SP- 1000U welder is a Sample no. Yield Stress without Yield Stress with
transformer type welding power supply. It can convert the current (MPa) current (MPa)
moderate current and voltage from the domestic supply (230 1 513.03 459.67
or 115 VAC), into a high current and low voltage supply, 2 502.50 475.83
typically between 55 to 590 A (open- circuit) and 17 to 45 V.
Since welding transformers provide less power, only when the 3 505.67 440.83
cross-section is smaller, welder transformers can be used to Standard 5.40 17.41
give the required current density. Deviation
(MPa)
There have been studies conducted using capacitor banks Average 507.06 458.78
comprising the R-L-C supply circuit. Inside the capacitor (MPa)
bank, the capacitors are connected in parallel to obtain the Reduction (MPa) 48.28
maximum capacitance. Then the capacitor bank should be
connected in series to the circuit. The drawback of capacitor
banks is to control of the pulse. Since the discharging of the
capacitor is not uniform, it affects the generated pulse.
Additionally, there is another issue due to the high voltage
used to charge these capacitors, once it is discharged, creating
a high voltage difference which affects the safety aspects.
Furthermore, capacitors cannot be kept at constant capacity
because once it is charged, starting to discharge even under
normal conditions. These drawbacks lead to limit the use of
the capacitor bank method for this task. Under these
circumstances, to overcome these drawbacks effectively, the
transformer method was chosen as the current supply method.
B. Reduction of Yield Stress and Ultimate Tensile Strength
(UTS)
The stress vs. strain graphs plotted for the cases of with
and with and without the current supply was shown in Fig. 4.
Average yield stress and ultimate tensile strength values under Fig. 4: Stress vs. Strain variation of the 0.2%C steel sample under the
these two conditions are shown in TABLE IV and TABLE V. two conditions (Black: without current, Red: with current)
As shown in Fig 4 the stress vs. strain curve for samples
tested with current lies below the samples tested without
current. The area under the curve represents the energy
absorbed by the sample during deformation. Therefore, the

167
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Brighton. Downloaded on September 27,2020 at 22:12:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Moratuwa Engineering Research Conference (MERCon) 2020

This setup was developed at the laboratory scale to verify According to previous studies, the grain rotation concept
the electroplasticity effect of low carbon steel could be further is another factor that affects the flow stress. Grain rotation can
improved up to the industrial level to introduce for forming, be induced by applying electric pulses to materials [19]. A
drawing, and machining operations of low carbon steel. recent study conducted by Rahnama and Quin has shown that
a peak current density of 10.18 A/mm2 can induce grain
Samples tested under pulsed current showed a relatively rotation in duplex steel at room temperature [10]. Grain
lower UTS compared to the samples tested without current by rotation changes the Schmid’s factor thereby it affects directly
comparing the true stress vs. true strain of the two conditions to the flow stress. Generally, grain boundaries are considered
(Fig. 5). as an obstacle for dislocation motion due to the mis-
The average values of UTS were compared. Once the orientation of lattice planes at grain boundaries. However,
current was applied, plastic deformation characteristics are with the rotation of grains, lattice planes in some areas of the
significantly affected by electroplasticity. Furthermore, grain boundaries are oriented and allowing to move
results showed that the UTS of the specimens tested in the dislocations from one grain to another.
presence of electric pulses is lower than the specimens tested Therefore, it is obvious that the elimination of obstacles
without current pulses. for dislocation movement with this favorable orientation leads
C. Reduction in Flow Stress to reduce the flow stress.
Generally, the plastic region of the true stress vs. true D. Effect of Pulsed Current on Ductility
strain curve represents the flow behavior of the material (Fig.
The ductility of a metal can be determined by using the
5). Flow stress is defined as the sudden value of stress required
percentage reduction of area. The reduction of area compares
to maintain the plastic deformation of a material. Once the
elastic region is neglected, a significant difference between the between the original cross-sectional area and the minimum
flow curves with and without pulsed current was observed. cross-sectional area of the same sample after complete
The flow stress of the samples tested under pulsed current is fracture failure.
lower than samples tested without pulsed current. This Measure of ductility is given by,
reduction can be explicated using the Taylor strengthening
equation (1) [10]. −
% = × 100
= √ (1) (2)
Here,
The ductility of samples tested under electricity is higher
b- Burger’s vector than the normal test (TABLE VI). This provides evidence to
α- Dimensionless constant validate the point that electricity enhances the ductile
properties of the material.
ρ- Dislocation density
E. Temperature Variations
μ- Shear modulus According to the thermal camera images taken while the
M- Schmid’s factor sample is deforming, an increase of temperature was
observed in specimens tested with current (Fig. 7) when
The pulsed electric current affects the Schmid’s factor and
compared with the specimens tested without current (Fig. 6)
the dislocation density. Increasing the pulsed current causes
that is known as joule heating. The metal becomes slightly
annihilation of dislocations, which means, reduction of
dislocation density. According to the above equation (1), flow soft due to the joule heating and that affects the increase of
stress is reduced with the reduction of dislocation density. ductility. In contrast to the phenomenon observed in
specimens tested with current, when specimens were tested
without current, the temperature changes are only associated
with strain energy, where Joule Heating is absent. There have
been many reports about the combined effect of Joule
heating, de- pining of dislocations by paramagnetic obstacles
and electron wind force on the electroplasticity. Nevertheless,
the degree of the individual contribution of these factors was
yet to be explained.
IV. CONCLUSION
Low carbon steel having 0.2 wt.% shows a reduction of
62.22 MPa in yield stress when subjected to uniaxial tension
under low amplitude high-frequency pulse current. The UTS
is also reduced by 48.28 MPa due to the effect of
electroplasticity. The flow curve suggests the reduction in
flow stress due to the application of electric pulses
Fig. 5: True stress vs. true strain behavior of 0.2%C steel sample without continuously. This suggests that electrical pulses help to
current (Black), with current (Red) increase the plasticity of low carbon steel.
Energy used in the forming of low carbon steel can be
saved in huge amounts by applying electric pulses while
deformation. The increase in temperature during the

168
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Brighton. Downloaded on September 27,2020 at 22:12:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Moratuwa Engineering Research Conference (MERCon) 2020

experiments clarified the contribution of Joule heating for the [11] T.A. McNeal, J.A. Beers, and J.T. Roth, "The microstructural effects
electroplasticity. on Magnesium alloy AZ31B-O while undergoing an electrically-
assisted manufacturing process," in ASME 2009 Int. Manuf. Sci. and
These results lead to implement the Electrically Assisted Eng. Conf., West Lafayette, Indiana, United States, 2009, doi:
10.1115/MSEC2009-84377.
Manufacturing process for low carbon steel. The method
developed in this work for generating the low amplitude high- [12] N. T. Vinh et al., "The tensile electroplasticity of magnesium AZ31
alloy with a single pulse of electric current," in AIP Conf. Proc., 2014,
frequency electrical pulses could be further modified for the vol. 938, pp. 938–941.
future industrial EAM processes. [13] C. D. Ross, D. B. Irvin, and J. T. Roth, “Manufacturing aspects relating
to the effects of direct current on the tensile properties of metals,” J.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Eng. Mater. Technol. Trans. ASME, vol. 129, no. 2, pp. 342–347, 2007,
The researchers would like to extend their gratitude to the doi: 10.1115/1.2712470.
Electrical Machines Laboratory of the Department of [14] T. A. Perkins, T. J. Kronenberger, and J. T. Roth, “Metallic forging
using electrical flow as an alternative to warm/hot working,” J. Manuf.
Electrical Engineering, University of Moratuwa for the Sci. Eng. Trans. ASME, vol. 129, no. 1, pp. 84–94, 2007, doi:
guidance and assistance they offered in making this study a 10.1115/1.2386164.
success. [15] S. Mishra, “The unique features of textures in low-carbon steels,” Bull.
Mater. Sci., vol. 16, no. 6, pp. 583–599, 1993, doi:
TABLE VI. AVERAGE DUCTILITY WITHOUT CURRENT AND WITH 10.1007/BF02757657.
CURRENT
[16] N. T. Thien, Y. Jeong, S. Hong, M. Kim, H. N. Han, and M. Lee,
Average ductility Average Ductility Increase in ductility “Electrically assisted tensile behavior of complex phase ultra-high
without current (%) with current (%) (%) strength steel,” Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. Technol.- Green Technol.,
21.51 35.05 13.54 vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 325–333, 2016, doi: 10.1007/s40684-016-0041-3.
[17] L.A. Coles et. al, "Analysis of pulsed electroplasticity in metals,"
presented at the 2017 IEEE 21st International Conference on Pulsed
Power (PPC), Brighton, 18-22 June, 2017, doi:
10.1109/PPC.2017.8291317.
[18] V. I. Stashenko, O. A. Troitskii, and N. N. Novikova, "Electroplastic
Drawing Medium Carbon Steel," J. Mach. Manuf. Rel., vol. 38, no. 4,
pp. 369–372, 2009, doi: 10.3103/S1052618809040128.
[19] A.S. Budiman et. al., "Crystal plasticity in Cu damascene interconnect
lines undergoing electromigration as revealed by synchrotron x-ray
microdiffraction," Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 88, no. 23, pp. 2004–2007,
2006, doi: 10.1063/1.2210451.

Fig. 6: Temperature variation of Fig. 7: Temperature variation of the


the sample when tested without tested specimen when tested with
current current

REFERENCES
[1] O.A. Troitskii, V.I. Likhtman, "The anisotropy of the action of electron
and γ radiation on the deformation of zinc single crystals in the brittle
state," Sov. Phys. Dok., vol. 8, no. 91, 1963.
[2] H. Nguen-Tran et. al., "A Review of Electrically-Assisted
Manufacturing", Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. Technol., vol. 2, no. 4, pp.
365–376, 2015, doi: 10.1007/s40684-015-0045-4.
[3] V. Kravchenko, "Effect of directed electron beam on moving
dislocations," Sov. Phys JETP, vol. 25, no. 51, pp. 1676-1688, 1967.
[4] L. Guan, G. Tang, and P. K. Chu, "Recent advances and challenges in
electroplastic manufacturing processing of metals," J. Mater. Res., vol.
25, no. 7, pp. 1215–1224, 2010.
[5] M. Molotskii and V. Fleurov, "Magnetic effects in electroplasticity of
metals," Phys. Rev. B, vol. 52, no. 22, pp. 15829–15834, 1995.
[6] R. Timsit, "Remarks on recent experimental experimental observations
of the electroplastic effect," Scr. Metall., vol. 15, no. 4, pp. 461-464,
1981.
[7] A. Lahiri, P. Shanthraj, and F. Roters, "Understanding the mechanisms
of electroplasticity from a crystal plasticity perspective," Model. Simul.
Mater. Sci. Eng., vol. 27, no. 8, 2019, doi: 10.1088/1361-651X/ab43fc.
[8] K. Okasaki, M. Kagawa, and H. Conrad, "A study of the electroplastic
effect in metals," Scr. Metall., vol. 12, pp. 1063-1068, 1978.
[9] B. Ma, Y. Zhao, H. Bai, J. Ma, J. Zhang, and X. Xu, "Gradient
distribution of mechanical properties in the high carbon steel induced
by the detour effect of the pulse current," Mater. Des., vol. 49, pp. 168–
172, 2013, doi: 10.1016/j.matdes.2013.02.015.
[10] J. Zhao, Z. Ren, H. Zhang, G. X. Wang, Y. Dong, and C. Ye,
"Electroplasticity in AZ31B subjected to short-duration high-frequency
pulsed current," J. Appl. Phys., vol. 125, no. 18, 2019, doi:
10.1063/1.5087465.

169
Authorized licensed use limited to: University of Brighton. Downloaded on September 27,2020 at 22:12:04 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like