Professional Documents
Culture Documents
En Wikipedia Org Wiki Annunciation (Memling)
En Wikipedia Org Wiki Annunciation (Memling)
Description
Subject
The Annunciation was a popular theme in European art,[3]
although a difficult scene to paint, because it depicts Mary's union
with Christ as she becomes the tabernacle for the Word made
flesh. The doctrine of Mary as Theotokos, the Godbearer, was
affirmed in 431 at the Council of Ephesus; two decades later the
Council of Chalcedon affirmed the doctrine of Incarnation – that
Christ was of two natures (God and Man) – and Mary's perpetual
virginity was affirmed at the Lateran Council of 631. In Byzantine
art, Annunciation scenes depict the Virgin enthroned and dressed
in royal regalia.[4] In later centuries she was shown in enclosed
spaces: the temple, the church, the garden.[5] Robert Campin's c. 1420s Mérode
Altarpiece, (The Cloisters), with
In Early Netherlandish art the conventional iconography of a hearth
Annunciation is typically set in and a vase of flowers
contemporary domestic interiors,
a motif and tradition established
by Robert Campin, and followed by Jan van Eyck and Rogier van der
Weyden.[1] Neither Campin nor van Eyck went so far as to set the scene
in a bedchamber,[4] although the motif is found in van der Weyden's
Louvre Annunciation of c. 1435 and his Saint Columba Altarpiece of
c. 1455, in which the Virgin kneels by the nuptial bed, rendered in red
made from costly pigments.[6] Memling's depiction of the scene is nearly
identical to that in the Saint Columba Altarpiece.[7]
Figures
The archangel Gabriel appears before Mary to announce that she will
bear the Son of God.[8] He is shown standing in a threequarter view,[9]
wearing a small jeweled diadem and dressed in vestments. He has a
richly embroidered redandgold brocade cope, edged with a pattern of
Left panel of Rogier van der
gray seraphim and wheels, over a white alb and amice. He holds his staff
Weyden's Saint Columba
altarpiece, c. 1455, Alte of office in one hand, and raises the other towards the Virgin.[10] He
Pinakothek, Munich. Rays of bends his knees, honoring and acknowledging her as Mother of Christ
light stream through the open
and Queen of Heaven,[1] and his feet are bare and positioned slightly
window toward the Virgin.
behind hers.[11]
The Virgin is in a frontal view;[9] directly behind her the redcurtained bed acts as a framing device, similar
to the traditional canopy of honor or baldachin.[6] Unlike in the work of Memling's predecessors, whose
Virgins are garbed in heavily jeweled and costly robes, the plain white shift she wears beneath a blue
mantle is minimally jeweled at the hem and at the open neckline. A purple underdress peeks out at her
neck and wrists, indicating her royal status.[5] Mary seems neither surprised nor fearful at the
announcement; according to Blum the scene is rendered with a great sense of naturalism and
successfully depicts "the transformation of Mary from girl to Godbearer".[11]
A curtain sack, commonly found on beds of the period, hangs in the central axis between Gabriel and the
attendant angel.[15] A sideboard beside the bed contains two types of candles and a flask of water
standing in bright light falling from the window to the left.[1] The floor is multicolored tilework, similar to
that in van der Weyden's Saint Columba Altarpiece; Memling truncates the ceiling rafters in the mid
ground, at the end of the bed, with the floor extending into the foreground. Blum describes the effect as
acting "like an open stage for the holy figures".[9]
Iconography
The iconography is not overly labored, and Memling avoids extraneous symbolism.[11] Many elements
emphasize Mary's role as the Mother of God; the chamber is furnished with simple everyday objects that
indicate her purity. The vase of lilies and the items on the sideboard are objects 15thcentury viewers
would have associated with her.[8] White lilies were often used to signify her purity, while irises or sword
lilies were used as metaphors for her suffering.[14] Memling emphasizes symbols associated with her
womb and virginity, "introduces two additional angelic priests, and floods the room with natural light,
thereby rearranging the anecdotal to emphasize the doctrinal meaning".[11] Charles Sterling describes the
work as "one of the finest examples of Memling's ability to take a pictorial convention inherited from his
predecessors and infuse it with a heightened sense of emotion and narrative complexity".[16]
Light
From the 9th century Light became associated with Mary and the
Incarnation. Millard Meiss notes that from the 12th century a
common way to convey the conception was to compare light
passing through glass to the passage of the Holy Spirit through the
body of the Virgin.[17] Saint Bernard likened it to sunshine,
explaining in this passage: "Just as the brilliance of the sun fills
and penetrates a glass window without damaging it, and pierces
its solid form with imperceptible subtlety, neither hurting when
entering nor destroying when emerging; thus the word of God, the
splendor of the Father, entered the virgin chamber and then came
forth from the closed womb."[18] Detail showing the light shining on
the sideboard, a flask of clear water, a
Three objects on the bedside cabinet represent the Virgin's purity: ropewick light, a candlestick, and a
curtainsack
the water flask, the candleholder, and the ropewick light. The light
passing through the glass of the wombshaped flask symbolizes
her flesh, pierced by divine light;[19] its clear and undisturbed water represents her purity at the moment of
conception,[1] a device found also in the earlier paintings as a metaphor of the Virgin's sanctity.[20] The
flask shows a reflection of the window's crossbar as a cross, a symbol of the Crucifixion – another small
detail in which Memling "lays one translucent symbolic form upon another".[19]
Mother of Christ
The Virgin birth is indicated by the red bed and red wombshaped
curtainsack. During the early 15th century hanging beds or
curtainsacks became symbols of the Incarnation, and "served to
affirm [Christ's] humanity". Blum notes that at a time "when artists
did not hesitate to depict the breast of the Virgin, Memling did not
shun her womb".[15] Christ's humanity was a source of fascination,
and it was only in Netherlandish art that a solution was found for
visualizing his embryonic state with curtainsacks draped to
suggest the shape of a womb.[25]
The painting's domestic setting belies its liturgical meaning. The dove
is a reminder of the Eucharist and Mass. Lotte Brand Philip observes
how throughout the 15th century "eucharistic vessels made in the
form of doves and suspended over altars ... were lowered at the
moment of transubstantiation"; here it suggests that in the same way
the Holy Spirit gives life to the bread and wine, it gave life to the
Virgin's womb.[10] She carries the Body and Blood of Christ, and is
attended by three priestly angels.[10] Mary's function is to bear "the
Savior of the World"; the angels' role is to "support, present and
protect her sacred being".[5] With the birth of Christ her "miraculous
womb passed its final test" to become an object of veneration.[4]
Bride of Christ
Memling presents the Virgin as the Bride of Christ about to assume
her role as Queen of Heaven, with attendant angels indicating her
royal status.[24] Angels of this kind are usually shown hovering above
the Virgin, holding her crown, and some German painters showed Stefan Lochner, The Virgin
Crowned by Angels, c. 1450,
them hovering close in Annunciation scenes, but angels rarely Cleveland Museum of Art, depicts
approach or touch the Virgin.[26] Only a single previous version of the Virgin as Queen of Heaven with
such attendant angels has been found: in the Boucicaut Master's two barely visible attendant angels
hovering above her crown.
early 15thcentury illuminated manuscript version of the "Visitation",
the pregnant Virgin's long mantle is held by attendant angels, about
which Blum notes that "her queenly appearance surely commemorates the moment when Mary is first
addressed as Theotokos, the Mother of the Lord".[5] Memling often depicted pairs of angels dressed in
addressed as Theotokos, the Mother of the Lord".[5] Memling often depicted pairs of angels dressed in
vestments attending the Virgin, but these two, dressed in simple amices and albs, were never repeated in
his art. Their dual function is to "present the eucharistic offering and proclaim the Virgin bride and
queen".[5]
The only person to question Gustav Friedrich Waagen's 1847 attribution to Memling is W. H. J. Weale,
who in 1903 declared that Memling "would never have dreamt of introducing into the representation of this
mystery these two sentimental and affected angels".[30]
Generally the condition is good. Memling painted the work on two panels of about 28 cm each. The dated
and inscribed frame, probably the original, was discarded in 1830.[29] There have been three documented
restorations. The painting had been pierced by an arrow when Antoni Radziwiłł found it; he had it restored
and the damage repaired. At that time the Virgin's mantle and the flesh tones sustained heavy
overpainting. The original frame was discarded, but its inscription was inserted into the new frame.[24] A
description of the original frame suggests that it bore a coat of arms, perhaps belonging to Jerzy
Radziwiłł.[31] The second restoration was after its exhibition in Bruges in 1902, and the third when Lehman
had it restored and transferred to canvas sometime after 1928. The painting survived the transfer without
significant damage. A late 19thcentury photograph shows wood on all four sides of the painted surface,
which suggests that the edges may have been extended during the transfer. Areas that suffered paint loss
and overpainting are Gabriel's cope and the vase holding the flowers.[29]
When Boisserée saw the painting he recorded the inscription's date as 1480. The last digit of the
inscription was faded and difficult to read and had become illegible by 1899. Waagen suggested that the
date could have been 1482, and the art historian Dirk de Vos suggested 1489.[2] Memling's style does not
lend itself well to assigning dates, making a determination difficult. According to Sterling, an earlier date is
easily accepted, especially because of stylistic similarities to Memling's 1479 St John Altarpiece,[2]
whereas Ainsworth leans toward the later date as more in keeping with the mature style of the late
1480s.[1]
References
1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q Ainsworth (1998), p. 118
2. ^ a b c d e Sterling (1998), p. 81
3. ^ "The Annunciation" . Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved April 28, 2015.
4. ^ a b c d e Blum (1992), p. 52
5. ^ a b c d e Blum (1992), p. 53
6. ^ a b c d Blum (1992), p. 43
7. ^ Snyder (1987), p. 38
8. ^ a b Howard (2000), p. 353
9. ^ a b c d Blum (1992), p. 55
10. ^ a b c d e Blum (1992), p. 49
11. ^ a b c d e Blum (1992), p. 50
12. ^ a b Jolly (2014), pp. 40, 57
13. ^ Blum (1992), p. 54
14. ^ a b Blum (1992), p. 48
15. ^ a b Blum (1992), p. 44
16. ^ a b c Sterling (1998), p. 80
17. ^ Meiss (1945), p. 177
18. ^ Meiss (1945), p. 176
19. ^ a b c Blum (1992), p. 46
20. ^ a b Meiss (1945), p. 175
21. ^ Koslow (1989), p. 10
22. ^ a b Meiss (1945), p. 178
23. ^ a b Blum (1992), p. 47
24. ^ a b c Sterling (1998), p. 83
25. ^ Koslow (1989), pp. 11–12
26. ^ Sterling (1998), p. 82
27. ^ a b Borchert (2008), p. 87
28. ^ Blum (1992), p. 56
29. ^ a b c Sterling (1998), p. 78
30. ^ Weale (1903), p. 35
31. ^ a b Sterling (1998), p. 84
Sources
Ainsworth, Maryan. "Hans Memling: The Annunciation". In: From Van Eyck to Bruegel: Early Netherlandish Painting
in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1998. ISBN 9780870998706
Baynes, T. S., ed. (1878), "Annunciation" , Encyclopædia Britannica, vol. 2 (9th ed.), New York: Charles
Scribner's Sons, p. 90
Blum, Shirley Neilsen (1992). "Hans Memling's Annunciation with Angelic Attendants". Metropolitan Museum
Journal. The University of Chicago Press. 27: 43–58. doi:10.2307/1512934 . JSTOR 1512934 .
S2CID 193013508 .
Borchert, TillHolger. "Hans Memling and Rogier van der Weyden". In: J. Chapuis (ed), Invention: Northern
Renaissance Studies in honor of Molly Faries. Turnhout, Belgium: Brepols, 2008. ISBN 9782503527680
Howard, Kathleen (ed). The Metropolitan Museum of Art Guide. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000.
ISBN 9780870997112
Jolly, Penny Howell. Picturing the 'Pregnant' Magdalene in Northern Art, 1430–1550: Addressing and Undressing
the SinnerSaint. Farnham, Surrey: Ashgate, 2014. ISBN 9781472414953
Koslow, Susan (1986). "The CurtainSack: A Newly Discovered Incarnation Motif in Rogier van der Weyden's
Columba Annunciation". Artibus et Historiae. IRSA. 7 (13): 9–33. doi:10.2307/1483245 . JSTOR 1483245 .
S2CID 194328498 .
Meiss, Millard (September 1945). "Light as Form and Symbol in Some FifteenthCentury Paintings". The Art
Bulletin. CAA. 27 (3): 175–181. doi:10.2307/3047010 . JSTOR 3047010 . S2CID 191469058 .
Snyder, James (ed). The Renaissance in the North. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1987. ISBN 9780
870994340
Sterling, Charles. Fifteenth to Eighteenthcentury European Paintings in the Robert Lehman Collection. New York:
Metropolitan Museum of Art with Princeton University Press, 1998. ISBN 9780691006987
Weale, James W. H. (March 1903). "The Early Painters of the Netherlands as Illustrated by the Bruges Exhibition
of 1902". The Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs. Vol. 1, no. 1. Burlington Magazine Publications. pp. 40–43,
46–49, 51–53. JSTOR 855565 .
External links
Metropolitan Museum of Art, Memling's The Annunciation Wikimedia Commons has
media related to Annunciation
(Memling).
V ꞏ Tꞏ E Hans Memling
Virgin and Child Enthroned with two Musical Angels, c. 1467 ꞏ
Scenes from the Passion of Christ, c. 1470 ꞏ Adoration of the Magi, c. 1471 ꞏ
Mater Dolorosa, c. 1475 ꞏ Madonna and Child with Angels, c. 1479 ꞏ
Allegory with a Virgin, c. 1479–1480 ꞏ Advent and Triumph of Christ, c. 1480 ꞏ
Individual
Mater Dolorosa, c. 1480 ꞏ Mystic Marriage of St Catherine, c. 1480 ꞏ
religious panels
Angel Musicians, 1480s ꞏ Pagagnotti Triptych, c. 1480 ꞏ
Christ Surrounded by Musician Angels, c. 1480s ꞏ Annunciation, 1480s ꞏ
Adam and Eve, c. 1485 ꞏ Bathsheba, c. 1485 ꞏ
Madonna and Child with Saint James and Saint Dominic, c. 1485
Last Judgment, c. 1467–1471 ꞏ Diptych of an elderly couple, c. 1470–1472 ꞏ
Diptych of Jean de Cellier, c. 1475 ꞏ Jan Floreins Altarpiece, 1479 ꞏ
St John Altarpiece, 1479 ꞏ Adoration of the Magi, c. 1479–1480 ꞏ
Polyptychs Adriaan Reins Altarpiece, 1480 ꞏ Donne Triptych, c. 1480 ꞏ Moreel Triptych, 1484 ꞏ
Earthly Vanity and Divine Salvation, c. 1485 ꞏ Benedetto Portinari Triptych, 1487 ꞏ
Diptych of Maarten van Nieuwenhove, 1487 ꞏ St. Ursula Shrine, c. 1489 ꞏ
Christ Surrounded by Singing and Musicmaking Angels, c. 1483–1494
Portrait of a Man in a Red Hat, c. 1465–1470 ꞏ Portrait of a Man, c. 1470–1472 ꞏ
Portrait of Tommaso Portinari, c. 1470–1472 ꞏ Portrait of Maria Portinari, c. 1470–
1472 ꞏ Portrait of an Elderly Man, c. 1470–1475 ꞏ Portrait of an Elderly Woman, c.
1470–1475 ꞏ Portrait of a Man with a Pink Carnation, 1475 ꞏ
Portraits
Portrait of Benedetto Portinari, 1478 ꞏ Portrait of Willem Morell, c. 1480 ꞏ
Portrait of a Man with a Roman Medal, c. 1480 ꞏ
Portrait of Barbara van Vlaendenbergh, c. 1480 ꞏ Sibylla Sambetha, c. 1480 ꞏ
Portrait of Folco Portinari, c. 1490
Categories: 1480s paintings Paintings by Hans Memling Paintings depicting the Annunciation
Paintings in the Metropolitan Museum of Art Doves in art Books in art
Text is available under the Creative Commons AttributionShareAlike License 4.0; additional terms may apply. By using this
site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation,
Inc., a nonprofit organization.
Privacy policy About Wikipedia Disclaimers Contact Wikipedia Code of Conduct Developers Statistics