Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Use of Integrated Learning Media of TikTok and Instagram Social Media
on Student Learning Motivation on Cation Qualitative Analysis Materials
Groups I and II
Hayuni Retno Widarti*1, Munzil2, Neena Zakia3, Deni Ainur Rokhim4, Afis Baghiz Syafruddin5,
Zalfa Adhya Rachmanita6
1,2,3,4,5,6
Jurusan Kimia, Universitas Negeri Malang, Jl. Semarang No.5, Kota Malang, Indonesia
Abstract. This study was conducted to determine the effect of using integrated learning media TikTok
and Instagram in increasing students' learning motivation in qualitative analysis materials for groups
I and II. The research method used is descriptive qualitative research method using a distributed
questionnaire to determine the increase in students' learning motivation. This research was conducted
in one of the State Vocational High Schools in Malang City which involved 29 students of class XII
Analytical Chemistry 1. Data analysis was in the form of a qualitative test on students' learning
motivation. The results of the study indicate that the use of TikTok and Instagram learning media can
increase students' motivation to study qualitative analysis materials for groups I and II. The existence
of integrated learning media for TikTok and Instagram social media, allows students to learn material
anytime and anywhere.
169
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
has shifted to distance learning. Based on the still have difficulty in this case [12]. This is in
results of research conducted by Pujiono (2021) line with the findings from research conducted
it was found that social media is a learning by Fathonah et al. (2015), where 53.33% of the
medium that is relevant in becoming a bridge or 30 students of SMK Bhakti Mulia Wonogiri
intermediary between teachers and students in chose qualitative analysis as material that was
today's digital era. One of the social media that difficult to understand. [13]. In addition, the
can be used as learning media is TikTok and results of observations made by Widarti et al.
Instagram [5]. (2021) on analytical chemistry teachers at
Research conducted by Ramdani, et al. SMKN 7 Malang in 2020, showing that
(2021) show that TikTok can be an effective, qualitative analysis material is one of the most
interesting, interactive, and innovative learning difficult materials to teach [14]. To understand
media in online learning that can accommodate analytical chemistry material, learning media
the abilities of students in the 21st century. integrated with social media TikTok and
TikTok can make it easier for educators to Instagram can be used with a multi-
deliver material as interesting as possible with representational approach.
the various features provided [6]. Pujiati, H., There are 3 levels of representation,
and Tamela, E. (2019) stated that Instagram has namely macroscopic, submicroscopic, and
an important role in helping students to increase symbolic representations. Macroscopic
their motivation in learning. Instagram helps representation is the level of concrete
students in encouraging them to learn English representation that can be observed with the
and even improving their knowledge and skills five senses such as color, temperature, pH, and
[7]. the formation of precipitates. Submicroscopic
Chemistry is defined as the study of representations are abstract levels such as
composition, structure, properties, changes in atomic and molecular representations of
matter, and the energy that accompanies these processes that depict invisible processes in
changes [8]. Basically, chemistry has two macroscopic representations. While the
aspects. First, the visible and invisible aspects. symbolic representation is a chemical language
Visible aspects can become concrete facts, but in the form of symbols, rate equations, chemical
invisible aspects cannot become concrete facts, formulas, pictures, and numbers to explain at
but must be logical [9]. Therefore, chemistry the molecular level. The three representations
studies the concrete and the abstract in a single complement each other to explain chemical
unit. It is this invisible and abstract chemical phenomena [15].
aspect that often makes it difficult for students This study aims to determine the effect of
to understand the material. using TikTok and Instagram integrated learning
One branch of chemistry is analytical media in increasing student learning motivation
chemistry. Analytical chemistry deals with the in qualitative analysis material groups I and II.
chemical characterization of matter to answer
four basic questions about a sample material, METHOD
“What? Where? How many? And What is the
arrangement, structure, or form?” [10]. Based The research method used is descriptive
on its purpose, analytical chemistry is classified qualitative. The research design is described as
into qualitative analysis and quantitative follows:
analysis. Qualitative analysis states the This research was conducted in one of the
presence of an element or compound in the State Vocational Schools in Malang City. This
sample, while quantitative analysis states the study involved 29 students of class XII in
number of elements or compounds contained in Analytical Chemistry 1. The learning media
the sample in numerical terms [11]. used are social media-based learning media that
Qualitative analysis of group I and II have been validated by experts. The media is
cations is one of the materials studied in declared fit for use.
analytical chemistry. Kurniasih and Rahayu, This research was conducted from August
(2017) suggest that understanding analytical to September in the odd semester of the
chemistry is needed to be able to think 2022/2023 school year in 3 meetings. The
critically, logically, creatively, and instrument used is a student learning motivation
innovatively. But the facts show that students
170
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
20%
10%
50% 45% 45% 7% 7%
10% 3%
0%
40% 34% 34% 0%
Sebelum Sesudah
30%
21%
17% 1 2 3 4 5
20%
1 2 3 4 5
In figure 3 regarding paying attention to
the material explained by the teacher, there is a
Figure 1 Interest in Studying Materials decrease. Before the operational test as many as
Qualitative Analysis of Group I and II Cations 45% of students chose scale 4. After the
171
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
50% 45% 1 2 3 4 5
38%
40%
28%
31% Figure 6 Don't Think About The Relationship
30% 24% Of Qualitative Analysis Of Group I And II
21%
20% Cations With Daily Life
7%
10% 3% 3%
0% In Figure 6, regarding not thinking about
0%
Sebelum Sesudah the relationship between qualitative analysis of
group I and II cations with daily life, there was
1 2 3 4 5
a not too significant increase. Before using
Figure 4 Recording the Material Described social media-based learning media, students
who chose scale 2 were dominated by 45%,
In Figure 4, regarding recording the students who chose scale 3 were 31%, and 17%
material explained by the teacher, there is a of students chose scale 4 for the results of the
decrease. Before the operational test, as many questionnaire. After using social media-based
as 45% of students chose a scale of 4 and 21% learning media, the results of the questionnaire
of students chose a scale of 5. After the were dominated by students who chose scale 2,
operational test, the results of the questionnaire which was 48%, students who chose scale 3
were dominated by students who chose a scale were 28%, and 17% of students chose scale 1.
of 3, namely 38% of students. In addition, as This shows that there are TikTok and
many as 31% of students chose scale 2 and 24% Instagram-based learning media encourage
of students chose scale 1. It can be seen that students to think about the relationship between
classes using integrated learning media TikTok learning materials and everyday life.
and Instagram do not feel the need to take notes
on the material explained. This is because the 40% 34%
31%
material can be accessed at any time. 28%
30% 24%
21% 21%
60% 20% 14% 14%
48% 10%
50% 10%
3%
40% 31%
28% 28% 0%
30% 21% Sebelum Sesudah
20% 14% 14%
7% 7% 1 2 3 4 5
10% 3%
0%
Sebelum Sesudah Figure 7 Concerns Other Students Have Better
Achievements
1 2 3 4 5
Figure 5 Activeness in the Independent Figure 7 concerns the concerns that other
Learning Process at Home students have better performance. In classes
that use integrated learning media TikTok and
In Figure 5, regarding the activity in the Instagram, 31% of students choose a scale of 2,
independent learning process at home, there is 28% of students choose a scale of 3, and 24%
no significant change after the use of integrated of students choose a scale of 5 before the
learning media TikTok and Instagram. operational test . After the operational test, 31%
of students chose a scale of 3, 21% of students
chose a scale of 4, and 21% of students chose a
scale of 5. In classes that use social media
172
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
173
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
38% 20%
40% 34% 7%
31% 31% 10% 3%
0% 0%
30% 24% 24% 0%
Sebelum Sesudah
20% 14%
1 2 3 4 5
10%
3%
0% 0%
0% Figure 15 Happy To Observe Natural Events in
Sebelum Sesudah Everyday Life
1 2 3 4 5
Figure 15 explains the results of a
Figure 13 Qualitative Analysis of Groups I and questionnaire regarding the behavior of
II Cations Is Not Fun To Study students who enjoy observing natural events in
everyday life. It can be seen that there was no
In Figure 13 regarding the qualitative significant change. Students in the class enjoy
analysis material for groups I and II are not observing natural events in everyday life. This
pleasant to study, there is a decrease that is not is in line with the results of the analysis in
too significant. Before the operational test, 31% Figure 6, where the existence of integrated
of students chose scale 1, 38% of students chose learning media, TikTok and Instagram, makes
scale 2, and 31% of students chose scale 3. students think about the linkage of group I and
After the operational test, 34% of students II qualitative analysis with everyday life.
chose scale 1, 24% of students chose scale 3,
and 24% of students chose scale 4. Students feel 70%
66%
that qualitative analysis material for groups I 60%
and II are not fun to learn. 50% 41%
38%
40%
30% 21%
50% 45% 20% 10% 10%
7% 7%
40% 34% 34% 10% 0% 0%
0%
30% 24% Sebelum Sesudah
17%
20% 14%
10% 1 2 3 4 5
7% 7% 7%
10%
Figure 14 Qualitative Analysis Materials for Figure 16 explains whether the material
Groups I and II Cations That Are Difficult for qualitative analysis of group I and II cations
Can't Be Learned Alone can be easily understood. It can be seen that
there was a not-so-significant increase. Before
In Figure 14 related to qualitative analysis the test, 66% of students chose scale 3 and 21%
material for groups I and II which are difficult of students chose scale 4. After the test, 41% of
to learn alone, there has been a significant students chose scale 3 and 38% of students
increase. Before the operational test, 45% of chose scale 4. It can be seen that the integrated
students chose scale 3 and 24% of students learning media TikTok and Instagram can make
chose scale 2. After the operational test, 34% of it easier for students to understand learning
students chose scale 1 and 34% of students materials.
chose scale 2. It can be concluded that TikTok
and Instagram integrated learning media can
facilitate students in understand the learning
material.
174
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Figure 17 Material for Qualitative Analysis of Figure 19 Happy to Learn Qualitative Analysis
Group I and II cations is interesting to study of Cations Groups I and II With the Help of
Pictures and Videos
Figure 17 explains whether the qualitative
analysis material for group I and II cations is Figure 19 describes the results of the
interesting to study. It can be seen that there was questionnaire regarding the behavior of
a not-so-significant increase. Before the students who enjoy studying qualitative
operational test was dominated on a scale of 3 analysis of group I and II cations with the help
by 55% of students. After the operational test, of pictures and videos. It can be seen that there
31% of students chose a scale of 3, 24% of is an increase after using TikTok and
students chose a scale of 4, and 28% of students Instagram-based learning media. Before the
chose a scale of 5. This shows that after using operational test, 41% of students chose scale 3.
TikTok and Instagram integrated learning After the operational test, 55% of students
media students are more interested in learning chose scale 4. It can be concluded that students
qualitative analysis material. group I and II enjoy learning qualitative analysis of class I and
cations. II cations with the help of pictures and videos
using social media.
60%
48% 48% 76%
50% 80% 69%
40%
28% 60%
30% 24%
17%
20% 14% 40%
10%
7%
10% 3% 17% 14%
0% 20%
7% 10% 7%
0% 0% 0% 0%
Sebelum Sesudah 0%
Sebelum Sesudah
1 2 3 4 5
1 2 3 4 5
Figure 18 No Enthusiasm to Learn Qualitative
Analysis of Group I and II Cations Figure 20 Desire to Get the Best Class I and
Class II Qualitative Analysis Scores
Figure 18 describes the results of the
questionnaire regarding the behavior of Figure 20 explains the results of a
students who are not enthusiastic about questionnaire regarding the behavior of
studying the qualitative analysis of group I and students who want to obtain the best group I and
II cations. It can be seen that there is no II qualitative analysis grades in the class. It can
significant change. Students who use integrated be seen that classes that use TikTok and
learning media TikTok and Instagram are Instagram integrated learning media have a
excited to learn qualitative analysis of group I stronger desire to get the best grades in class.
and II cations. This is because as many as 76% of students
chose a scale of 5 after the operational test.
The results show that the integrated
learning media of TikTok and Instagram in
general can increase students' learning
motivation. This can be seen from the behavior
of students who are worried that other students
175
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
will have better achievements and want to get Journal of Literature and Language
the best grades I and II qualitative analysis in Teaching, 12(1): 91-111.
the class. [3] Malik, A. R., dan Asnur, M. N. A. (2019).
Based on the results obtained, after Using Social Media As A Learning Media
learning using the learning media, students Of Foreign Language Students In Higher
think more about the relationship between Education. Bahtera: Jurnal Pendidikan
qualitative analysis of group I and II cations Bahasa Dan Sastra, 18(2): 166-75.
with everyday life. This is because students in
classes who use integrated learning media [4] Asosiasi Penyelenggara Jasa Internet
TikTok and Instagram are more interested in Indonesia. (2022). Profil Internet
studying qualitative analysis materials for Indonesia 2022. Jakarta: Asosiasi
groups I and II. Penyelenggara Jasa Internet Indonesia.
The existence of integrated learning media [5] Pujiono, A. (2021). Media Sosial Sebagai
for TikTok and Instagram social media, allows Media Pembelajaran Bagi Generasi Z.
students to study the material at home and feel Didache: Journal of Christian Education,
no need to record the material because it can be 2(1), 1.
watched repeatedly. https://doi.org/10.46445/djce.v2i1.396
The disadvantage of using TikTok and [6] Ramdani, N. S., Nugraha, H., &
Instagram social media as learning media is that Hadiapurwa, A. (2021). Potensi
in their use students can be distracted by other Pemanfaatan Media Sosial Tiktok Sebagai
things when studying qualitative analysis Media Pembelajaran Dalam Pembelajaran
material for groups I and II. This is in line with Daring. Akademika, 10(02), 425–436.
research conducted by Mekler (2021) on the https://doi.org/10.34005/akademika.v10i0
correlation between time spent on TikTok and 2.1406
how it affects students to be distracted in class
and their schoolwork. The study shows that the [7] Pujiati, H., & Tamela, E. (2019, August).
more time a student spends on TikTok, the The use of instagram to increase students’
more they will lose time and be distracted for motivation and students’ competence in
their class [16]. learning English. In 1st International
Conference on Education Social Sciences
CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS and Humanities (ICESSHum 2019) (pp.
651-656). Atlantis Press.
Based on the results of the research and [8] Purba, M. (2006). Kimia Untuk SMA Kelas
discussion, it can be concluded that learning X. Jakarta: Erlangga.
media integrated with social media TikTok and [9] Adnyana, G. P. (2012). Keterampilan
Instagram can increase student learning Berpikir Kritis dan Pemahaman Konsep
motivation in qualitative analysis material for Siswa pada Model Siklus Belajar Hipotetis
groups I and II. Therefore, similar learning Deduktif. Jurnal Pendidikan dan
media can be developed for qualitative analysis Pengajaran. 45(3) : 201-209.
material for group III, IV, and V cations, as well
as other chemical material for further research. [10] Christian, G. D., Dasgupta, P. K., dan
Schung, K. A. 2013. Analytical Chemistry.
John Wiley dan Sons.
REFERENCES
[11] Skoog, D. A., West, D. M., Holler, F. J.,
[1] Dick, W., Carey, L. and Carey, J. (2005). dan Crouch, S. R. 2013. Fundamentals of
The Systematic Design of Instruction. Analytical Chemistry. Boston: Cengage
Boston, MA; Pearson. Learning.
[2] Ariantini, K. P., Suwastini, N. K. A., [12] Kurniasih, D., dan Rahayu, H. M. (2017).
Adnyani, N. L. P. S., Dantes, G. R., dan Pengembangan Perangkat Pembelajaran
Jayantini, I. G. A. S. R. (2021). Integrating Kimia Analitik Materi Kromatografi
social media into English language Berorientasi Inkuiri Terbimbing. Jurnal
learning: How and to what benefits Pendidikan Matematika Dan IPA, 8(2),
according to recent studies. NOBEL: 31.
176
Journal of Chemistry Education Research ISSN: 2549 - 1644
177