Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tamás BEZECZKY
T here were close trade connections between Italy and Ephesus from the late Hellenistic period to the late Roman
times. Here I shall discuss the Ephesian import of Adriatic foodstuffs and amphorae.1 These amphorae were found
at the excavations of the Tetragonos Agora, the Terrace House 2, and the Basilica Stoa. In addition, I shall give a
brief account of the export of the foodstuffs and amphorae from Ephesus and its vicinity to Adriatic region.
*
I would like to thank my brother
1. Late Republican - early Roman obvious targets. Cheap slave labour came to Italy through Gábor Bezeczky for translating my
Delos. The slaves gave an impetus to agriculture, and the manuscript and David Peacock for
production in Italy correcting the English text.
surplus was exported to East and West, which needed the 1
Ephesus olive oil import from
The Roman power in the Eastern Mediterranean gained support of troops, merchants and businessmen. Brindisi region: Bezeczky 2002,
355-358.
momentum after the victory of Pydna and the Pergamon 2
Peacock and Williams 1986,
inheritance. Delos was declared to be a free port in order to The earliest Western wine came from Campania and Sicily Class 2; Will 1982, 338-356;
Tchernia 1986, 42-44, 314-315;
undermine the role of Rhodes. Roman expansion reached to Ephesus: the characteristic Greco-Italic amphora type2 Empereur and Hesnard 1987,
a new stage at the end of the second century B.C. This here - like elsewhere - is restricted to a few pieces. There 25-29; Manacorda 1986, 581-586;
started the large-scale immigration of Italian merchants Vandermersch 1994, 69-92; Lund,
are more Italian amphorae among the objects belonging 2000, 80; Williams, Panella and
in the Eastern Mediterranean, and Ephesus was one of the to the period from the end of the second century to the first Keay 2005, Greco-Italic.
351
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
3
Peacock 1971, 162-165; Tchernia
1986, 42-48; Peacock and Williams
1986, Class 3-5; Lund 2000, 82-83; part of the first century B.C. Among the earliest amphorae is not known where these were produced.
Williams, Panella and Keay 2005, (Dressel 1A and 1C) which had wines from Campania.3 The olive oil in the Brindisi type amphorae (Fig. 1, no. 1)
Dressel 1;
4
Peacock and Williams 1986, Class They were followed by the Lamboglia 2, as well as the was exported by well-known workshops.6 The best-known
8; Tchernia 1986, 68-73; Cipriano Brindisi amphorae. owners were Visellius, Betilienus and Vehilius. Their
and Carre 1989, 80-85; Cipriano
1994, 205-208; Lund 2000, 84; amphorae can be found all over the Mediterranean region.
Bezeczky 2005, Lamboglia 2. The Lamboglia 2 amphorae (Fig. 1, no. 2) contained The amphorae produced in the Giancola and “La Rosa”
5
Bezeczky 2004, 85-91; Bezeczky
2006, 289-301.
various wines from the Adriatic coast.4 The petrological workshops, with the [V]ISELLI, STABVA, DEMETRIVS? and
6
Manacorda 2001, 229-240; analysis shows that some of the amphorae were produced PHILIPVSBETIL stamps can be dated to the second quarter
Palazzo 1989, 550-553; Cipriano near Brindisi. Other amphorae probably came from middle of the first century BC. The one with the MENOPILVS
and Carre 1989, 68-80; Lund 2000,
84-85. or northern Italy. Some of the amphorae have stamps: stamp can be dated to the second half of the first century.7
7
Bezeczky 2002, 355-358. (ER[TE]C, LICIN, L. OPIM, DAM, CADMVS).5 However, it There are other Brindisi or Adriatic ovoid amphora types
352
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
353
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
It was Ulrike Outchar25 who first came up with the idea One handle jar and variation from first century BC to the
of local production. She suggested that some of the fourth century AD
Roman amphorae (Late Roman 1, Late Roman 3 and The Agora F 65/66 type (Fig.) of one-handled jar that
Kapitän II) may have been produced in Ephesus. The was first isolated in the Athenian Agora.32 This type is
petrographical analyses have confirmed that the LR 3 the earliest form of a series which was produced from the
amphorae were produced near Ephesus. The Kapitän II middle of the first century BC to the fourth century AD.33
amphorae have only circumstantial evidence. There are The development of the form, its variants: Agora F 65-66
Kapitän II amphora fragments in Pannonia province26 first century BC; M 45 mid first to early second century
which are considered to have been produced in Ephesus. AD.; J 46-47, M 125-126 second to early third century; M
The possibility of local production of Late Roman 1 240, M 255-256-257, L 50-51 fourth century; M 275-276-
amphorae can be excluded. All the analyses are based on 277, M 279-280-281-282 late fourth century; M 315 sixth
the comprehensive geological survey of the region which century. Sometimes it is called the one-handle variant
was performed during the 90s.27 of the LR 3 amphora.34 According to the petrological
analyses, the Agora F65/66 jars were produced from the
Recently Roman Sauer distinguished three main types of Fabric A of Ephesus.
clay. One of them (Fabric A, garnet rich) came from the
area south of Ephesus near the Kuşadasi region, as well The one-handled vessels are supposed to have been made
as from the Meander valley. The other (Fabric B, epidot/ in number of workshops in the coastal areas of Asia Minor
25
Outchar 1993, 46-52.
26
Bezeczky 2005, 45; Sauer 2005, clinozoisite rich) originated from the immediate vicinity also be produced in Sardeis.
117-118. of Ephesus and from the Caystros valley. The third fabric
27
28
Sauer 1995.
is rich in carbonate (marls) with mica and epidote came The earliest one handle jars (Agora F65) on the Adriatic
Lawall 2001; Bezeczky 2006,
287-288. from the Caystros valley too. coast were found on a sunken ship from the Augustan
29
Grace and Savvatianou- period (Comancchio, Valle Ponti). There are similar pieces
Petropoulakou 1970, 365-367. in Magdalensberg via Aquileia (Fig. 1, no. 5).35 The one
30
Gassner 1997, 105-113; Lawall The types of the amphorae which are
2004, 177-182; Lawall 2007, 48-53. handle jar and its later versions (Agora F 66, J45/46, M125..)
31
Bezeczky 2006, 298, Fig. 4, nos. considered to come from Ephesus are
are found in Aquileia, Istrian peninsula, Brijuni Island,
25-26.
32
as follows: Slovenia,.36 It can also be found in the western provinces:
Robinson 1959, 17, Pl. 41.
33
Lang 1955, 277-278; Riley 1979, The group of Hellenistic / late Hellenistic France, Germany, Britain, Raetia, Egypt.37
183-186; Lemaître 1997, 3111-319;
Brun 2004, 92; Pieri 2005
amphorae
34
Peacock and Williams, 1986, The datable Ephesian amphorae in the Hellenistic period Mid- and later Roman production in Ephesus
188-190.
35
Berti 1990, ; Magdalensberg MB come from various layers. The period from the middle to During this period one of the most common amphorae was
75 NG/45. Personal discussion E. the end of the second century BC is characterized by the the Kapitän II type.38 In Ostia, there are such amphorae
Schindler-Kaudelka
36
Personal discussion F. Maselli significant amount of well-known Greek wine amphorae belonging to the late second century, but they were most
Scotti, L. Mandruzzato and M. from Rhodes, Kos, Chios and Knidos. There are a few common in the third and fourth centuries.39 For a long
Pavletić; Vidrih-Perko 1998, 100;
37
Robinson 1959, 17; Riley 1979,
amphorae from Egypt and the Black Sea (Sinope).28 In time it was thought that this type of amphorae came
184; Loeschke 1909, 292-293; addition, there is the group of vessels produced in the from production sites in the Aegean region. Based on
Panella 1973, 461-462, fig. 36; vicinity of Ephesus. The Mushroom rim type (Fig.) seems
Panella 1986, 622; Lemaître
morphological considerations, Virginia Grace40 thought
1997, 311-319; Hayes 1996, 172- to coincide with Nikandros group, so-called for one of the that the amphorae came from Samos. Panella41 has
173.; Tomber 2006, 167, 54-961; name-stamps.29 Its dominant presence at Ephesus suggests suggested Kos as a centres of production. The provenance
Wendrich at al. 2003, 75, “Late
Roman 3 amphora, … Probably a production site in the vicinity.30 The mushroom-shaped of this amphora cannot be defined by petrological analysis.
represented in the 1st c, but more rim types have different fabrics as well. These amphorae There are two groups of the Kapitän II amphorae. The one
typical of the mid-4th and later.
38
Kapitän 1972, 243-252.
can also be found in a number of sites in Asia Minor and with red fabric has wide distribution and is represented
39
Carandini and Panella 1981, 494. Athens. There are the less frequent Aegean Local 1 and 2 in substantial numbers in Ephesus and was common
40
Grace 1971, 72 footnote 51; Riley amphorae, sometimes with monogram stamps, outside
1979, 192, but Riley did not share both in the Mediterranean and in the provinces.42 The
this view; Majcherek 1993, 218. Ephesus.31 According to the petrological analyses, some amphorae with buff colour are less frequent. The analysis
41
Panella 1973, 228-229; Panella of the Mushroom rim type, Aegean Local 1 (Fig.) and of the fabric of this piece suggests that it may have been
1986, 617.
42
Peacock & Williams, 1986, 193- Aegean Local 2 (Fig.) amphorae were produced from the produced in the Caystros valley (Küçük Menderes) and
195. carbonate rich (marls) fabric in Ephesus. in the region of Ephesus (Samos can also be considered).
354
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
They are known from Pannonia (Vindobona) and Egypt The Ephesus 56 type of amphorae (Fig. 1, no. 7) can be
(Alexandria).43 It is an interesting question why the found only in a few places (Carthage, Rome, Bodrum).
locally produced Kapitän II amphorae can only be found The fabric of the pieces in Carthage is the same as that of
at faraway sites. The amphora in Vindobona must have the LR 3 amphorae studied by Peacock.47 The dating is also
come through Aquileia. In some cases, the amphorae were the same. They occur with LR 3 amphorae at most sites
found on shipwrecks with marble in Libia, Italy-Sicily, in Ephesus and can be dated from the end of the fourth
Greece and Turkey.44 century to the end of the sixth/beginning of the seventh
century A.D. This type also occurs in the villa on the island
Late Roman 3 and Ephesus 56 amphorae of Brijuni and in one of the cemeteries of Zadar.48
The Late Roman Amphora 3 (Fig. 1, no. 6 and 8) is one
of the best-known small forms. This type is dated from the Both amphora types (LR 3 and Ephesus
end of the fourth century to the end of the sixth. It had a 56) have micaceous fabric produced near
widespread distribution in the Empire from Britain, Spain, Ephesus (Fabric B).
Italy, the Istrian peninsula, the Balkans, Greece, the Black This brief account shows Ephesus and the Adriatic region
Sea, Turkey, Syria, Palestine, Egypt, Ethiopia to Sudan.45 had trade connection for centuries. In the first century BC.
There is a Late Roman 3 amphora in Ravenna. It has an the wine in the Lamboglia 2 amphorae and the olive oil
‘Aphrodisias’ (άφροδίσιος) graffiti.46 It is supposed to be in the Brindisi amphorae amounted to 5-10 percent of the
a name - perhaps that of the producer or the merchant. It Ephesan import. It is not easy to estimate the quantity of
is a recent development that LR 3 amphorae were found in the Ephesian export to the Adriatic region because there
a Byzantine villa in the island of Brijuni in the Northern is as yet no comprehensive survey. However, LR 3 and
Adriatic. Ephesus 56 amphorae have been found in a number of
sites on the Adriatic coastline.49
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
355
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
356
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
LAWALL, M.L. (2004) Archaeological Context and Aegean Amphora Chronologies: A Case Study of Hellenistic
Ephesos, in: Eiring, J. and Lund, J. (eds.) Transport Amphorae and Trade in the
Eastern Mediterranean, Acts of the International Colloquium at the Danish Institute
at Athens, September 26-29, 2002. Monographs of the Danish Institute at Athens
Volume 5, 171-188.
LAWALL, M.L. (2007) Hellenistic stamped Amphora Handles, in: V. Mitsopoulos-Leon and Cl. Lang-Auinger
(eds.) Die Basilika am Staatsmarkt in Ephesos, Forschungen in Ephesos IX.2.3,
(Wien), 28-60.
LEMAÎTRE, S. (1997) L`amphore de type Agora F65/66, dite “monoansée”, Essai de synthèse à partir
d´exemplaires lyonnais. S.F.E.C.A.G. Actes du Congrès du Mans, 1997, 311-319.
LINDHAGEN, A. (2009) The transport amphoras Lamboglia 2 and Dressel 6A: a central Dalmatian origin?,
JRA, 83-108.
LOESCHCKE, S. (1909) Ausgrabungen bei Haltern. Die keramischen Funde. Mitteilungen der Altertums-
Kommission für Westfalen, 5.
LUND, J. (2000) Transport Amphorae as Evidence of Exportation of Italian Wine and Oil to the Eastern
Mediterranean in the Helllenistic Period, in: Lund, J. & Pentz, P. (eds.), Between
Orient and Occident. Studies in Honour of P.J. Riis (Copenhagen), 77-99
MAJCHEREK, G. (1993) Roman Amphorae from Marina el-Alamein, MDAIK 49, 215-220.
MANACORDA, D. (1986) “A proposito della anfore cosidette greco-italiche, una breve nota” Recherches sur
les amphores grecques. Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique Supplément. 13,
581-582.
MANACORDA, D. (2001) “Le fornaci di Giancola (Brindisi): archeologia, epigrafia, archeometria”, in 20 ans
de recherches à Sallèles d’Aude, a cura di F. Laubenheimer, Besançon, 229-240.
MANGE, M.A. AND BEZECZKY, T., (2006)
Petrography and provenance of Laecanius amphorae from Istria, Northern Adriatic
region, Croatia. Geoarchaeology: An International Journal 21, 427-458
MARTIN, A. (1999) Amphorae, in : D. and N. Soren A Roman villa and a late Roman infant cemetery,
excavation at Poggio Gramignano Lugnanno in Teverina, Roma, 329-361.
MUFFANTI MUSSELLI, G. (1987) “Diffusione dell’anfora tronco-conica da olive nel I sec. D.C.”, Rivista Archeologica
dell’antica provincia e diocesi di Como, 168, 187-215.
OUTSCHAR, U. (1993) Produkte aus Ephesos in alle Welt ÖAI, Berichte und Materialen, Heft 5, 46-52.
PALAZZO, P. (1989) Le anfore di Apani (Brindisi), in: Amphores romaines et histoire économique dix
ans de recherche, Collection de l`École Française de Rome, 114, 548-553.
PANELLA, C. (1986) Oriente ed Occidente: ‘Considerazioni su alcune anfore ‘Egee’ di eta Imperiale a
Ostia, in: Recherches sur les Amphores Grecques, BCH Suppl. 13, 609-636.
PANELLA, C. (1973) Anfore, in: Carandini, A. & Panella, C. (eds.) Ostia III: Le Terme del Nuotatore.
Scavo dell’ambiente III, VI, VII, Scavo dell’ambiente V e di un saggio nell’area SO,
Studi Miscellanei 21, Roma, 463-696.
PANELLA, C. (2001) Le anfore di età imperiale nel Mediterraneo occidentale, in Céramiques héllenistiques
et romaines 3, E. Geny (ed.), Lyon, 28, 177-275
PAPUCI-WŁADYKA, E. AND KOKORZHITSKAIA, T. N, (2004)
Forlimpopoli Amphorae at Tanais in Second and Third Centuries AD, in: Eiring, J.
and Lund, J. (eds.) Transport Amphorae and Trade in the Eastern Mediterranean,
Acts of the International Colloquium at the Danish Institute at Athens, September
26-29, 2002. Monographs of the Danish Institute at Athens Volume 5, 309-312,
PARKER, A. J. (1992) Ancient shipwrecks of the Mediterranean and the Roman provinces. Oxford:
Archaeopress, BAR International Series No. 580, (Oxford).
PEACOCK, D. P. S. (1971) Roman Amphorae in Pre-Roman Britain, in ed. M. Jesson and D. Hill, The Iron Age
and its Hill Forts, Southampton, 161-188.
PEACOCK, D. P. S. & WILLIAMS, D. F. (1986)
Amphorae and the Roman Economy. London: Longman
PESAVENTO MATTIOLI, S. AND CIPRIANO, S. AND PASTORE, P. AND MAZZOCCHIN, S. (1992)
Anfore romane a Padova: ritrovamenti dalla città, Materiali d’archeologia 1, a
cura di S. Pesavento Mattioli, Modena.
357
Tamás Bezeczky, Trade connections... (351-358) Histria Antiqua, 19/2010.
PICCOTTINI, G. (1997) Amphorae litteratae vom Magdalensberg, in: G. Erath - M. Lehner - G. Schwarz
(Hrsg.), Komos. Festschrift für Thuri Lorenz zum 65. Geburtstag, Wien, 203-206
PIERI, D (2005) Le commerce du vin oriental à l’époque byzantine (Ve-VIIe siècles) Le témoignage
des amphores en Gaule. Bibliothèque archéologique et historique 174, (Beirut),
IFPO,
RILEY, J.A. (1979) The Coarse Pottery from Berenice, in: Lloyd, J.A. (ed.), Excavations at Sidi Khrebish
Benghazi (Berenice) II, Libya Antiqua Suppl. V.2 (Tripoli), 91-467
RIZZO, G. (2003) Instrumenta Urbis I, Ceramiche fini da mensa, lucerne ed anfore a Roma nei primi
due secoli dell`impero, Collection de l`École Française de Rome 307, Rome.
ROBINSON, H.S. (1959) The Athenian Agora V. Pottery of the Roman Period, Chronology, (Princeton).
ROSTOVTZEFF, M.I. (1957) The Social and Economic History of the Roman Empire (Oxford)
SAUER, R. (1995) Bericht über die archäometrischen Untersuchungen für das FWF-Projekt Nr. 9280,
Produktionszentren späthellenistischer und römischer Keramik an der W-Küste
Kleinasiens (mit einem Anhang von U. Outschar, unpubl. Manuskript).
SAUER, R. (2005) Ergebnisse der mineralogisch-petrographischen Analysen von ausgewählten römischen
Amphorenproben aus Wien, in: F. Krinzinger (Hrsg.), Vindobona. AForsch 12,
Denkphil 328, (Wien) 109-142.
SCIALLANO, M. & SIBELLA, P. (1994) Amphores: comment les identifier?, Aix-en-Provence.
TCHERNIA, A. (1986) Le vin de l’Italie romaine, BEFAR 261, Rome
TOMBER, R. AND WILLIAMS, D. (1986)
“Late Roman amphorae in Britain and the Western provinces.” Journal of Roman
Pottery Studies 1, 42-54.
TOMBER, R. (2006) Amphorae, in: Survey and Excavation Mons Claudianus 1987-1993, V.A. Maxfield
and D.P.S. Peacock (eds.) Volume III, Ceramic vessels and related objects, 142-
175.
TONIOLO, A. (1993) Le Anfore di Altino, Monografia di Archeologia Veneta, 14, 1991, Padova.
VANDERMERSCH, C. (1994) Vins et amphores de Grande Grèce et de Sicile, IVe-IIIe s. avant J. -C., Naples.
VIDRIH PERKO, V, (1998) The amphora evidence. The main areas of Mercantile exchange in the Roman period
in Slovenian territory, Novensia, 10, Acta of the International Conference Wykno,
Poland 18-22 November 1995, 99-108.
WENDRICH, W.Z., TOMBER, R.S., SIDEBOTHAM, S.E., HARRELL, J.A., CAPPERS, R.T.J., BAGNALL, R.S. (2003)
Berenike Crossroads : The integration of information, Journal of Economic and
Social History of the Orient, v. 46, n. 1, p. 46-87.
WILL, E. L. (1982) “Greco-Italic amphoras”, Hesperia, 338-356
WILLIAMS, D.F., PANELLA, C. AND KEAY, S. (2005)
Greco-Italic; Dressel 1; Forlimpopoli, in: S. Keay and D.F. Williams, Roman amphorae:
a digital resource, University of Southampton, http://ads.ahds.ac.uk/catalogue/
archive/amphora_ahrb_2005
SAŽETAK
TRGOVAČKE VEZE IZMEĐU EFEZA I JADRANSKOGA PODRUČJA
Tamás BEZECZKY
Postojale su čvrste trgovačke veze između Italije i Efeza prilikom iskapanja na tržnici (tetragonos agora), na
od kasnog helenističkog razdoblja do kasnog rimskog terasastoj kući 2 i bazilici-stoi. Osim toga, iznijet ću kratak
razdoblja. U ovom radu govorit ću o efeškom uvozu pregled izvoza namirnica i amfora iz Efeza i okolice u
jadranskih namirnica i amfora. Ove su amfore pronađene jadransko područje.
358