You are on page 1of 4

Architecture and Decorative System of the Teatro Marittimo at Villa Adriana: a new integrated approach to an understanding of the building’s

original
aspect.
Benedetta Adembri, Sergio Di Tondo, Filippo Fantini

Architecture and Decorative System of the Teatro Marittimo


at Villa Adriana: a New Integrated Approach to an Under-
standing of the Building’s Original Aspect

B. Adembri1, S. Di Tondo2, F. Fantini3


1
Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici del Lazio, Italy
2
Dipartimento di Progettazione dell’Architettura, University of Florence, Italy
3
Instituto de Restauración del Patrimonio, Universidad Politecnica de Valencia, Spain
sergioditondo@ndas3a.it

1. Premise
The Villa Adriana, declared to be a Cultural Heri- The Teatro Marittimo trabeation, beside its evident
tage site by UNESCO in 1999, and still today a sub- curvilinear shape, possessed friezes figured on both
ject for systematic study by a team of international faces (concave and convex) with portrayals of the
architects and archaeologists, has always been a fo- sea-thiasos and chariot races driven by Erotes at the
cus for spoliation and even excavations, starting from circus. The presence of curvilinear friezes with a sea-
the fifteenth century, aimed at recovering precious thiasos theme also on the trabeation of the southern
works of art for the antiques market. pavilion of Piazza d’Oro may cause some uncertainty
Starting from the ’fifties, finds from excavations in the attribution of the single items, especially when
are preserved in various archaeological areas of the they are very fragmentary or have an excoriated sur-
Villa. Such finds comprise a very considerable num- face. Indeed, although the Piazza d’Oro friezes are
ber of often highly fragmentary pieces, never prop- larger in size and their relief is more accentuated than
erly identified or catalogued. Quite recently, with a those of the Teatro Marittimo, it is difficult to distin-
view to the logistic rearrangement of items and to guish the two figured cycles, especially in the case of
ascertaining the Villa’s stock of archaeological as- tiny fragments. The literature on the subject bears
sets, a scientific study was launched, involving sev- witness to this fact (Bonanno 1975, Conti 1976, Ca-
eral categories of the most numerous items kept at prino 1985, Mari 1994) by not providing univocal
the so-called Cento Camerelle warehouse. attributions for the fragments. A possible solution
may be found in utilising laser scanning surveys on
Among the stored items are several figured friezes samples of the single characters and elements com-
with a characteristic curvilinear shape, belonging to posing the figured decoration. The high level of pre-
the Teatro Marittimo, some of which were subjected cision obtained by laser scanning facilitates metric
to anastylosis operations in 1957/1958 and have been comparison of the digital models and highlights data
replaced inside the building, while others can be that can be used to distinguish the two sets of thiasos
found in public and private collections, both in Italy friezes.
and elsewhere in Europe. One fragment is preserved
at London’s British Museum (n° 2319), a further A further note should be added on the current state
three are found at the Louvre Museum in Paris (MA of preservation of the collection friezes (or those that
151; MA 1575; MA 152); two fragments are kept in have come from collections and are currently kept at
the Vatican Museums (n° 1610; n° 364). Yet another Villa Adriana). Having been detached from their
fragment is in Liverpool, at the Merseyside County original trabeation blocks and re-employed as sepa-
Museum; two others are preserved at the Berlin rate decorative elements, they are in the form of con-
Staatliche Museen (n° 934; n° 904). Three other cave or convex marble slabs with one decorated side
fragments have been employed in the masonry of and the other purposely chisel-pitted to improve ad-
Villa Doria Pamphili in Rome. We also have infor- herence to the new masonry.
mation about at least four other fragments preserved As far as the Teatro Marittimo is concerned, the
on properties in the Tivoli area, to which a further trabeation may have portrayed the same subject, i.e.
small fragment can be added, identified in September the sea-thiasos, on both faces (concave and convex),
2009 by the author on a private property close to the or else have had the circus chariot race on the con-
Villa Adriana archaeological area. cave side. The latter subject is always portrayed on

CAA’ 2010 - Fusion of Cultures


Granada, Spain
B. Adembri, S. Di Tondo, F. Fantini / Architecture and Decorative System of the Teatro Marittimo at Villa Adriana: a new integrated ap-
proach to an understanding of the building’s original aspect.

the concave side of the trabeation on the numerous posing synthetic solutions on which the virtual re-
pieces preserved. Proof is provided by the fragments construction assumptions can be based.
replaced in situ on the trabeation of the entrance ves-
tibule to the Teatro Marittimo. In this case, however,
the anastylosis operation involved a gross error (al-
ready pointed out by Catia Caprino in 1985), since
on the inner side of the same trabeation fragments
were recomposed portraying, on their concave face, a
mixture of the two figured cycles.

2. Aims
1) The systematic documenting and cataloguing of
all known fragments, using available technology to
produce an archive that will be useful for metric and
formal characteristics.

2) The implementation of virtual models, based on


the survey carried out using laser scanning technol-
ogy, for the purpose of reconstructing virtually (but Figure 1: Plan of Teatro Marittimo. Metrological and
with the possibility of producing physical models) compositional aspects of architectural design.
the ensemble of the surviving frieze elements of the
curvilinear trabeation of the Teatro Marittimo. 3. Methodological Approach
This research is based on the decision to re-order,
3) The construction of a language shared with the document and catalogue the original fragments, both
various research sectors involved (archaeologists, those preserved at Villa Adriana and those in private
architects, engineers, art historians, etc.), so as to and public collections, both in Italy and elsewhere in
operate in close synergy and thus optimise research Europe; to acquire graphic (engravings and old draw-
results. ings) and photographic (historical photography)
documentation concerning the friezes, with the aim
of amassing the greatest amount of information pos-
4) The outlining of I.T. solutions for the smooth sible in order to recompose the figurative cycles; to
management of heterogeneous data. survey the curvilinear architectural structures of the
Teatro Marittimo to which the marble friezes must
The above aims are essential to the attainment of have been fixed.
the second set of objectives established for this re- Digital survey campaigns have been planned to in-
search. clude the digital models both of the architectural
decoration preserved elsewhere and that at the Villa,
as well as those concerning the architecture of the
1) Reconstruction of the design mechanisms on Teatro Marittimo. The employment of digital survey
which the Teatro Marittimo system was based. This tools appears to be best suited to documenting the
requires a review of archaeological evidence in order friezes with regard to their formal characteristics and
to verify the foundation of the original structures, a to the dispersal of the architectural decoration.
metric survey of the original structures and an analy-
sis of the measurements to compare with ancient Up to now, two surveys of the Teatro Marittimo
textbooks on the metrological, compositional and are available: the first, carried out in 2006 by the
implementation aspects of architectural design. Università Politecnica delle Marche (DARDUS),
(Figure 1) relates to the whole complex, while the second, car-
ried out in 2009 by the University of Florence (Ar-
chitectural Design Dept.), relates exclusively to the
2) A study of the formal and metric features of the island. As far as the architectural decoration is con-
building’s decorative system and continual compari- cerned, we have digital models both of the friezes
son with the architectural basis, with the aim of pro- preserved in situ, and those at the Villa Adriana Di-
dactic Museum.

Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archeology, 2010 – Fusion of Cultures


Granada, Spain
B. Adembri, S. Di Tondo, F. Fantini / Architecture and Decorative System of the Teatro Marittimo at Villa Adriana: a new integrated ap-
proach to an understanding of the building’s original aspect

The survey makes a considerable volume of con-


tinually consultable data available to researchers.
Verification of compatibility between the frieze and
the metric characteristics of the building, for exam-
ple, makes it possible to confirm or exclude with
absolute certainty whether the fragments belong to
the Teatro Marittimo rather than to other buildings
with curvilinear trabeations (not only Piazza d’Oro,
but also buildings such as the so-called Serapeum).
Such an operation would solve one of the most recur-
rent problems at Villa Adriana: that of attributing
single pieces to one building or another. Further-
more, comparing the bend radius of the decoration Figure 2: Frieze figured with portrayals of the sea-
with that of the architectural outline accomplishes thiasos. 3D model portrayed the orthogonal projection
one more step in establishing the original placing of method.
the friezes within the same building, in this case, the
Teatro Marittimo.
2) Analysis of the measurements, applied mainly to
In actual fact, although it has been widely tackled the bend radius of the architectural decoration and
using traditional methodologies, the problem of relo- the building plan, has made it possible to replace
cating the friezes still presents unsolved questions virtually the concave frieze with the sea-thiasos
and unconvincing answers. Consequently, it has been (frieze with marine fauna and dolphin, preserved at
decided that such problems should be tackled again Villa Adriana) on the right side of the trabeation of
using a different methodological approach, also em- the entrance vestibule of the Teatro Marittimo. This
ploying digital technology, so as to achieve a further new hypothesis makes it possible to exclude the solu-
step in the research that will provide more scientifi- tion proposed in 1985 by Mathias Ueblacker, which
cally reliable and certain answers. places the frieze on the back wall of the Tablinum.
The methodology utilised employs I.T. tools suited (Figure 3/4/5)
to the concrete need to manage a heterogeneous
quantity of data. Data processing technology, as-
sisted by video-game applications, has made it possi-
ble to diminish the computational load considerably
by transferring detail data from the 3D model to raser
images interconnected through a local UV reference
system (cf. B. Adembri, S. Di Tondo, F. Fantini
“Tools for archiving and managing cultural heritage:
The finds from Hadrian’s Villa in the territory of
Tivoli. The case study of the friezes from the Teatro
Marittimo”, Workshop 14 Archaeology and Com-
puter, soon to appear). Figure 3: Analysis of the measurements, applied mainly
to the bend radius of the architectural decoration and the
building plan.
4. First Research Results and Subsequent De-
velopments 3) The comparative study of the architectural deco-
ration and the original plan of the building has also
4.1 Results
highlighted several errors in the current anastylosis
solution for the entrance vestibule of the Teatro
1) Definition of a procedure for documenting sin- Marittimo (the works were performed between 1957
gle fragments, based on image codes shared by the and 1958). The new proposal, still being processed,
various research sectors and functional for immediate will be studied during the continuation of research.
consultation of surface measurements and features
(colour and material treatment). It has been decided
to portray the 3D model using the orthogonal projec-
tion method, with plan, elevation and section.
(Figure 2)

Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archeology, 2010 – Fusion of Cultures


Granada, Spain
B. Adembri, S. Di Tondo, F. Fantini / Architecture and Decorative System of the Teatro Marittimo at Villa Adriana: a new integrated ap-
proach to an understanding of the building’s original aspect.

Figure 4: Analysis of the measurements, applied mainly


to the bend radius of the architectural decoration and the
building plan.
Figure 5: Virtual replacement of the concave frieze with
the sea-thiasos on the right side of the trabeation of the
entrance vestibule of the Teatro Marittimo.
4.2 Immediate Developments of the Research

1) Surveying and documentation of the large-size References


concave frieze fragments with the motif of chariots
driven by eroti (fragment n° 2319, preserved at the BONANNO M., 1975. Nuovi frammenti del fregio
British Museum; fragment from the Fontana della del «Teatro Marittimo» di Villa Adriana. In Archeo-
Rometta at Villa d’Este, currently in storage at Villa logia Classica, vol. XXVII, Fasc. 1 (1975), pp. 33-
Adriana). 40.

2) Definition of the number of slabs composing the MARI Z., 1994. Scoperte archeologiche nel territorio
trabeation of each curvilinear portico of the Teatro tiburtino. In Atti e Memorie della Società Tiburtina
Marittimo. di Storia e d’Arte, vol. LXVII (1994), pp. 156-160.

3) Linear development of the existing frieze frag- UEBLACKER M. 1985. Das Teatro Marittimo in der
ments, catalogued by type (concave or convex) and Villa Hadriana. Verlag Philipp Von Zabern, Mainz
by bend radius. Am Rhein.

LÉVY B. 2001. Constrained Texture Mapping for


Polygonal Meshes. In Proc. SIGGRAPH ‘01(2001).

PIPONI D., BORSHUKOV G. 2000. Seamless Tex-


ture Mapping of Subdivision Surfaces by Model
Pelting and Texture Blending. In Proc. SIGGRAPH
‘00 (2000).

SCATENI R., CIGNONI P., MONTANI C.,


SCOPIGNO R. 2005. Fondamenti di Grafica Tridi-
mensionale Interattiva.McGraw-Hill, Milano.

Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archeology, 2010 – Fusion of Cultures


Granada, Spain

You might also like