YMP.6p.469/2022 BO VIMETO HA rPAFAHMTE HA PENYBJIMKA CEBEPHA MAKEAOHMJA. YMPABHMOT CYP npexy cyqujata noeauHey Aputa Memerv co sanucHayap ‘Areme Myamen - CYfCKM COBeTHMK, opny'ysajia no TyxGaTa Ha TyxsTenuTe ONYTVHT MAK JJOOEN Pagosvul » Bacnnes Tpajat oa Pagosuus Kao oprosopHo MMe 80 npabHo nMYe, npoTMB PeweHneTO Ha Peny6niKa CesepHa Maxenonnjat Musucrepctzo 3a BuatpewHn Pa6otn Ognenenme sa npexpwioy Crpymnya YI1.6p.19.2.8-20/18 on 30.04.2019 roguna, no OcHOB Ha NPeKpLIOK, Ha CeAHMYaTa Ha COBETOT OAPKaHa Ha AeH 23.03.2023 ronmHa, AoHeCE: nPECYAA Tyxara na tyaxmrenute OFYTHHE MAK AOOEN Pagosn 4 Bacunes Tpajar on, PagoBmus Kako oproBsopHo nye BO NpaBHo nHye, CE YBAXKYBA. Pewenneto Ha Peny6nuxa Ceaepria Makenorvja Mituuctepctao sa BHaTpelna PaGoTm Onnenenme sa npexpwoun Crpymaya YT.6p.19.2.8-20/18 og 30.04.2019 rogwna, CE NOHULUTYBA. OG6pasnoxeHne ‘Tyxnrennte ONYTMHT MAK HOOEN Pagoauu 1 Bacunes Tpajak on Pagosmus kako OAroB0pHo NMYe BO NpasHo Nuye, KesanoBONeH on PewexneTo Ha PenyOnnka CesepHa Maxegounja Muanctepcteo sa Brarpewsn PaGotu, OngencHne sa npexpwoun - Crpymuna YI.6p,19.2.8-20/18 on 30.04.2019 roguna, nonHen Tyx6a AO 080) cya, Co ocnopeHoTo pewieHMe, TyKMTeNMTe ce OrnaceHK 3a OATOBOPeHM 3a CTOpeH npexpWoK no uneH 42 craB 1, 5 4 6 op SakOHOT 3a BosuNa 3a Koj NPeKPLIOK Ha npasHOTO AMYe My e HapeYeHa NpeKpWoNHa caHKUWja rnoba BO M3HOC Of 1400 espa, BO AeHapcKa npoTHBePeAHOCT Of 86.100 AeHapH, a Ha OATOBOPHOTO MMYe BO TpaBHoTo NMYe My € HapeveHa NpexpuloMHa CaHK\Wja rm06a BO WsHOG OA 420 eBpa BO BeHapcKa npoTHEPERHOCT BO MaHOG Of 25.830 AeHApH, NPM LITO HCTMTe Ce SaAOTDKeHH ‘fa ja nnavat mnoGara 80 pox on 15 AeHa Of AEHOT Ha NpaBoCMNHOCTa Ha PeLeHHETO. Ynpasunor cyp, co Pewenne YIP.6p.116/2021 on 11.02.2021 ronuna Ty6aTa Ha TyxnTenuTe ONYTVHT MAK HOOEN Pagoauui 4 Bacunes TpajaH oa Pagosmu kaKo OpFoBOpHO Nye BO NpasHo NMYe WajaseHa NpoTHs PeuseHHeTo Ha Peny6nnKa CesepHa Makegonvja Munuctepcreo 2a Buatpewnn PaGorm Opgenenne sa Tpexpuioun Crpymnya Y11.6p.19.2.8-20/18 on 30.04.2019 roauka ja oTébpnian KaKo Henaepemena. Brumor ynpaseH cya nocranysajin no xanGara Ha cera TyxwTenoT co Pewenne Ynpx.6p.211/2021 on 06.09.2021 roqmna, ro ykuHan PeweHneTo Ha 080) cya YiIP6p.116/2021 op 11.02.2021 ronmaa co Koja TyxGaTa NpoTHB peWweHHETO ‘oaHa4eHo BO MapexaTa Ha Npecyaata Gewe ordbpnena Kako HeHaBpemeHa.2 Ynpashnor cya, noctanysajin no TyxGata Ha tyxurpngt’ NobuBaHOTO Pewee Cornacko uNeH 35 on BaKOHOT 2a ynpaBHuté énopc oueHa Ha HaBonTe Eo Tyx6aTa M enMoHTe no peaMeTor, yrepau eka, Cygor Hajae aeka TyGara e ochopana. On cnichte Ha npeameroT npowsnerysa eka, TyKHTeNHTe Ha eH 15.09.2017 fonua 80 10,20 vacot Ha per nat KywaHoso Ceern Hixone eo cfloSpouare so Kymatiogo of ctpana na YMC sanpevio © TMB mapxa Mepueac co pernctpackn Opo| UWIT-574-P Bo oncTeeHocT Ha npaBHoTo muye OYTUHT MAK QOOEN Panosuw a ynpasysaro og Creso Nerpywes, co Kon aejcranja cTopune npexpiox no unen 42 crap 1 , 5 46 0A SakonoT 3a Bama, TyxeHnoT opraH noctanyBajia no npeaMeToT eps OcHoBa Ha.NpANOxeHMTe goKAsH To AOHEN ocnopeHoTo PeweHne YIT.6p.19.2.8-20/18 08 30.04.2019 rogmna co Koe Ha npasHoTo nnue My © MSpeveHa npexpuio“Ha caHKyaja moGa BO UsHOC og 1400 espa, 80 AeHapCKa NpoTMBBpegHOCT of 86.100 AeHaph, @ Ha OproBOPHOTO MULE BO NpasHoTO MMYe My & WaPeYeHA npeKpWuOYHA Canwuija rnoGa Go waHoe on 420 espa BO AeHapCKA NPOTHBpEMHOCT BO HBOS OA 25.830 geHapu, mpi wro woTHTe ce sagomKeH Aa ja nnatart rno6ata Bo pok on 15 AeHa og AeHOT Ha NpasocunHoCTa Ha PeLeHHMETo. Cynor Hajge aexa TyK6aTa Ha TyxMTenoT e ocHoBaHa, a ocnopexoTo peluenne € HesaKoHHTo M Co UCTOTO e MoBpe/IEH 3aKOHOT Ha wTeTa Ha TyNaTOnUTe Cornacho unek 35 crae 1 of SaKoHoT 3a ynpabHute cnoposn (,CryiGeH BecHinK Ha Peny6nuxa Maxeqounja 6p.96/2019), cyaor opnnyuysa 80 rpanmute Ha TyABeHOTO Gapaibe, Ho He & epsaH,.co npMMiHHTé Ha TyHOaTa . | Cornacho wneH 38 craa 1 Touka 2 og SaKoHoT 2a ynpasuite cnopoel, cyqoT no vCKny'oK Of oAPENOUTE OR 4NeH 37 Of OBO] 3aKOH CANyMYyBa No ynpaBHMOT chop Ges a BPX pacnpasa camo AoKONKy Ty~KmTeNoT ja ocnopyBa npuMeHaTa Ha MaTepjanioTo npago, a ke yrepgeHara cbaxtuuka coctoj6a. Cornacho ner 2 cas 1 o@ SaKoHoT 3a npekpuioyure (,Crypx6eH BecHHK Ha ! PenyOnuka Maxenounja’ Opoj 124/2015), 3a npexpuioxor wm npexpwounara | 0uTOBOpHOCT CooGpasHo ce NpuMeHysaaT OAPENSHie OA ONUMTMOT Aen Ha KPMEMUHUOT '3aKOH. Cornacho uneviot 3 ctas' 2 of Kphexsinot saxon (,CrynkGen BecHak Ha PM 6p.37/1996, 80/1999, 4/2002, 43/2003, 19/2004, 73/2006, 7/2008, 139/2008, 114/2009, §1/2011, 135/2011, 185/2011, 142/2012, 166/2012, 55/2013 w 82/2013), ako no WaBPLIYBareTO Ha KDHBMNHOTO Aeno e MSMeHET ZaKOHOT, EAHalU MNM TOBE; NATH, ke Ce npiMevin saKoHOT urTo e noBnar sa cropmTenor. i Cornacto unex 2 cras 1 og SaxoHoT 3a npexpwouwre (,CayxGeH Bechnk Ha PenyGnaka Makenonnja" 6poj 96/2019), sa npexpulokor u npekpwlowHaTa oproBsopKocT coo6pasio ce npumexysaaT onpenGuTe on onuITHOT Aer Ha KPHBUMNMOT saKOH, Cornacho une 41 crap 1, 4 4 10 of SakoHor 9a npeKpuioumTe (,Cryxéex Becki na Peny6nka Makeponuia" 6p.96/2019), npexpwowara nocTanka Ke MOxe fa Ce osene HuTY Aa Ce BORM Axo MoMMHaT ABE ToAMHM OA AeHOT Kora e cTOpeH NPeKPUUOKOT. BacTapyBarseTo Ha NPEKPLIOUHOTO roHelLe 3aNOUHyRA Of MeHOT Kora &3 YNP.6p.469/2022 CTOpeH MpexpwioKot. BacrapeHoct Ha NPeKPLIOYHOTO roHeKe HACTAHyBa BO cekoj chyyaj Kora Ke uaMuHe ABANATA OHONKY BpeMe KOrKy LITO cnopen saKOH ce Gapa 3a BaCTapeHOCT Ha MPEKPUIOYHOTO ToHElbe. Co 3aKOH CO KO} Ce MponMuulysa-npeKPUUOK, Moxke 3a OAMERHH NpeKpWOUM Aa Ce Onpenenar PoKOBM Ha 3acTapeHocT noponra on POKOBiATe of cTABOT (1) Ha OBO} YNeH, HO He NogoNrM on net ronMHN. Tipa saxsia cocroj6a Ha paSorure, Cyaor Haofa zeKa Bo cny4ajor Hactanina sacrapeHoct 3a NOHATaMOWHO Bofeme Ha npeKpuiowwata nocranka. VimeHo, TYxEHMOT Oprah yTBPAMN HeKa NPeKPLIOKOT LITO My Ce CTaBa Ha TOBAp Ha TyKUTENUTE © cTopeH Ha eH 15.09.2017 roqmna, na‘so cmmena Ha uneH 3 ctas 2 op KphBHYHNOT 3aKOHMK Koj ynatysa Ha NpiMeHa Ha noGnar sakoH 3a cTopuTenuMTe, OLHOCHO BO KoHKpetHuoT cny4aj nex 41 cra 2 of 3aKoHOT 3a npexpulounre (,CryKGer BecHHK ka’ Peny6nixa Maxenorwja* 6p.96/2019), Koj 3aKoH oprakoT npn nosTopHo NocTanysabe 1 OANyuyBatbe fla ro Ma BO NpenBMA,_NeKa HacTanuna sacTpeHocTa Ha NpeKpWOKOT Ha KOe HELuTO CyfoT BHHMaBa NO cnyGeHa AomKHOCT na CygoT oAAyYH kako 80 wapeKaTa Ha. npecynaTa CO yKaMyBarke eka TyXeHHOT OpraH TpeGa fa Nocfanu cormacHo oapep6ata Koja ro perynmpa npaulaibeTo 3a 3acTapeHocT Ha CTOpeHMTe YaPHHCKH NPEKPUIOUM H Aa ja'sanpe npeAMeTHaTa npexpwo¥Ha nocTanka. Cyaot ykakysa feKa, npsocTeneHMoT opraH BO NOBTOpHata nocTanka, npw oanyuyeatbeto 3a noBeaysaise WM Bojelbe Ha NPexpuioNHara NocTanka 2a NPeKpUIOKOT uo My ce CTaBa Ha ToBap Ha TyKuTenmTe, TpeGa Aa ro NpAMeHA SaKOHOT 3a npexpwounte (,CnyxGex BecHHK Ha PenyOnuka Cenepra Marenounja® 6p.96/19), kako noGnar 3aKoH vnpH Toa Aa ro uMaaT npegena 4neHOT 41 cTaB 1, 41 10 og HaBeAeHnoT 3aKoH Wt Ra AoHeCe npaBvnHa u saKoHuTa oAnyKa Co ornea Ha ceto HaBeneNd, cyAOT ONY'N Kako BO VspeKaTa Ha OBaa Npecyna, a ‘cornacho unek 38 Cras 1 TouKa 2 on SaKoHOT 3a ynpasunte cnoposn, ZOHECE! NPECYAEHO BO YNPABEH CYA] va 23.03.2023 roguna nog YMP.6p.469/2022. Sanucuimap - cyacKn copeTHiK Npercenaren na coner-Cyauja ‘ATeme Myamean Dputa Memeru NIPABHA TOYKA: Mporve o8aa npecyga xxan6a He e AosBoneHa, cornacHo uneH 69 ras 4 of 3akoHOT 3a ynpapnn cnopoan . Npecynara na ce gocrasy Ha: = TykTent ~ TykeHNOT opraH Nipetcenaren ta coset - Cyauja Tpwra Memera KB/