You are on page 1of 6

LEVEL III SCHWESER’S QuickSheet

Critical Concepts for the 2024 CFA® Exam


CAPITAL MARKET EXPECTATIONS Pitfalls of MVO analysis include: estimating the Choosing Options Strategies Based on Direction
Long-term economic growth rate: inputs, concentrated allocations, and a single and Volatility of the Underlying Asset
pop growth + labor force part. + new cap. period analysis. Outlook on the Trend of Underlying Asset
spending + TFP Utility maximization: Um = E(Rm) − 0.005 × λ × Varm Bearish Neutral Bullish
Write
Taylor rule: Um = the investor’s utility from investing Expected Decrease Write calls
straddle
Write puts
ntarget = rneutral + iexpected + [0.5(GDPexpected in a portfolio with asset allocation m move in
Remain Write calls Calendar Buy calls and
implied
− GDPtrend) + 0.5(iexpected − itarget)] E(Rm) = the expected return of the portfolio with volatility
unchanged and buy puts spread write puts
asset allocation m (expressed as a %) Increase Buy puts Buy straddle Buy calls
ntarget = target nominal short-term interest rate λ = the investor’s risk aversion Interest rate swaps
rneutral = neutral real short-term interest rate coefficient (“lambda”) Converting fixed-rate and floating-rate exposures:
GDPexpected = expected GDP growth rate Varm = σ2m= the variance of the portfolio with asset
Existing Interest Rate
GDPtrend = long-term trend in the GDP growth allocation m (expressed as a %) Exposure Converting Swap Required Beneficial When:
rate • Reverse optimization solves for the E(R)s based Floating-rate floating rates
Floating to fixed Payer swap
iexpected = expected inflation rate on market weights. liability expected to rise
• Black-Litterman view adjusts these returns and Fixed-rate floating rates
itarget = target inflation rate liability
Fixed to floating Receiver swap
expected to fall
then resolves for an EF.
Floating-rate floating rates
• Monte Carlo simulation models how an allocation Floating to fixed Receiver swap
Risk premium approach to expected bond asset expected to fall
return: may perform over time. Fixed-rate floating rates
Fixed to floating Payer swap
asset expected to rise
risk-free rate + term premium + credit premium
+ liquidity premium The notional principal of the interest rate swap.
​​(​  _________​​ )​​​ ​(​MV​  P​​)​​​​​​
​MD​  T​​− ​MD​  P​​
Grinold-Kroner model:
E(Re) ≈ D/P + (%ΔE − %ΔS) + %ΔP/E
DERIVATIVES AND CURRENCY NPS − ​MD​   ​ S

E(Re) = expected equity return MANAGEMENT where:


NPS = notional swap principal
D/P = dividend yield Option Strategies
%ΔE = percentage change in earnings MDT = target modified duration
Know the inherent payoff patterns of the option
%ΔS = percentage change in shares MDP = current portfolio modified duration
combinations, then:
outstanding MDS = modified duration of swap
%ΔP/E = expected repricing return • Calculate profit/loss at any ending price for the
underlying as sum of initial investment versus MVP = market value of portfolio
Singer-Terhaar model: ending value of the positions held. Forward rate agreements are typically used to hedge
Risk premium assuming full integration: • Max gain and loss: examine the payoff pattern the uncertainty about a future short-term borrowing
RPi = ρi,Mσi(market Sharpe ratio) and, from that underlying’s price, sum the initial or lending rate.
Risk premium assuming full segmentation: investment versus ending value of the positions
RPi = σi(market Sharpe ratio) held. Hedging Interest Rate Risk Using Treasury
• Breakeven(s): examine the payoff pattern and, from Futures
Weighted average risk premium: either max gain or loss, determine how much the To hedge the interest rate risk of a long bond portfolio
RPi = (degree of integration of i) (ERP assuming underlying must increase or decrease. the fund manager will use Treasury bond futures.
full integration) + (degree of segmentation of i) Synthetic long forward = long call + short put. A duration-based hedge ratio (BPV HR) is
(ERP assuming full segmentation) Both options are short the underlying. calculated to determine the number of futures
contracts required for a hedge.
Commercial real estate: ​−BPV​  portfolio​​
Cap rate = NOI / (property value) • Covered Call Protective Put ​BPVHR​ = _________ ​​ × CF
​​  ​BPV​   ​​​​
E(Rre) = cap rate + NOI growth rate CTD

For a finite time period: E(Rre) = cap rate + Basis point value (BPV) is the expected change in
NOI growth rate − %Δcap rate value of a security or portfolio given a one basis
point (0.01%) change in yield.
• Bull Spread BPVHR = number of short futures
Collar: Payoff pattern is BPVPortfolio = MDPortfolio × 0.01% × MVPortfolio
ASSET ALLOCATION identical to a bull spread
but includes owning the
MD = modified duration
BPVCTD = MDCTD × 0.01% × MVCTD
Asset Allocation Approaches underlying.
MVCTD = CTD price / 100 × $100,000
• Asset-only: focuses on asset return and standard
deviation. To achieve a target duration, the formula can be
• Bear Spread Straddle amended to:
• Liability-relative: focuses on growth of the surplus ​BPV​  target​​ ​−BPV​  portfolio ​​
and standard deviation. ​BPVHR​ = ________
  
​​  ​BPV​   ​​​​
​​ × CF
• Goals-based: uses subportfolios to meet specified CTD

goals. BPVTarget = MDTarget × 0.0001 × MVPortfolio


Asset classes: • Calendar spread—Options have different Currency forwards and futures allow users to
• Assets within a class are similar and don’t fit in expirations. exchange a specified amount of one currency for a
more than one class. • Volatility smile—Further-from-ATM options have specified amount of another currency on a future
• Classes have low correlation to other classes, cover higher implied volatilities resulting in a U-shaped date. Forwards are customized while futures are
all investable assets, and are liquid. (smiling) curve when implied volatility is plotted standardized contracts.
Calendar rebalancing is done at a set frequency. against strike price. The hedge ratio for futures can be calculated as:
Percentage range rebalancing is when a band • Volatility skew—Implied volatility increases for amount of currency to be exchanged
is violated. Wider bands for: higher transaction more OTM puts, and decreases for more OTM ​HR = _____________________________
   
​       ​​
futures contract size
cost and correlations between classes, higher risk calls. Explained by OTM puts being desirable
tolerance, momentum markets, and less volatile asset as insurance against market declines while the Equity swaps can be used to create a synthetic
classes. demand for OTM calls is low. exposure to physical stocks, allowing market
MVO use E(R), σ, and correlations to solve • For an expected increase in equity market volatility participants to increase or decrease their exposure to
for the efficient frontier (EF) and asset buy an ATM call on volatility index (VIX) futures equity returns.
allocation. and sell an OTM put on VIX futures. continued on next page...

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 1 15/05/23 1:19 PM


DERIVATIVES AND CURRENCY MANAGEMENT continued... Long (purchaser) describes the counterparty who • Carry trade: borrow in a lower interest rate
The three main types of swaps: receives the realized variance (actual) and pays the currency and invest in a higher interest rate currency.
1. Pay fixed, receive equity return swap’s variance strike (implied volatility). • Volatility trading: profit from predicting changes
2. Pay floating, receive equity return Realized Buyer (long) of swap in currency volatility. If volatility is expected to
> strike increase, purchase an at-the-money call and put
3. Pay another equity return, receive equity return volatility makes a profit
(long straddle). Sell volatility by selling both
Equity Futures and Forwards Realized Buyer (long) of swap
< strike options (a short straddle).
Equity futures are exchange-traded, standardized, volatility makes a loss
Forward Premiums or Discounts and Currency
require margin, have low transaction costs, and are The notional amount for a variance swap can be Hedging Costs
available on indexes and single stocks. They enable expressed as either variance notional (NVAR) or
If the hedge requires: FP/B > SP/B, iB < iP FP/B < SP/B, iB > iP
market participants to: vega notional (NVEGA).
The forward price The forward price
• Implement tactical allocation decisions (alter the vega notional curve is upward curve is downward
exposure to equity of a portfolio). variance notional = ___________
​​      ​​, so sloping. sloping.
2×strike price (K)
Š Selling futures (short position) reduces equity A long forward Negative roll yield, Positive roll yield,
exposure. profit or loss = NVAR × (σ2 − K2) = position in currency B which increases which decreases

​ ​  vega​​​ × ​(​  ___ )​​ ​​


​ ​​ 2​− ​K​​ 2​
σ the hedge earns: hedging cost and hedging cost and
2K ​
Š Buying futures (long position) increases equity N discourages hedging. encourages hedging.
exposure. ​ A short forward Positive roll yield, Negative roll yield,
• Achieve portfolio diversification. where: position in currency B which decreases which increases
the hedge earns: hedging cost and hedging cost and
• Gain exposure to international markets. σ = realized volatility encourages hedging. discourages.
• Make directional bets on the direction of the K = strike volatility (implied volatility)
The minimum-variance hedge ratio (MVHR): a
market. Both the actual (σ) and the implied volatility (K)
regression of past changes in value of the portfolio
Forwards provide the same advantages but lack on the swap are quoted in standard deviations, but
to past changes in value of the foreign currency.
liquidity, are not subject to mark-to-market margin remember that this is a variance swap; therefore, we
The hedge ratio is the beta (slope coefficient) of
adjustments, counterparty credit risk exists, major must square the volatility.
that regression.
advantage is they can be customized. The market convention is to quote the notional • Strong positive correlation between RFX and RFC
Achieving a target portfolio beta: on a swap as vega notional (NVEGA) rather than increases the volatility of RDC resulting in a hedge
number of futures required = ​( ​​ )​(
​β_____
​T​​− ​β​P​​
)​​
​MV​  ​​ variance notional (NVAR). Recall that vega refers to ratio > 1.0.
​ ​  ​β​  ​ ​ __ P
​  F ​ the change in option premium per a 1% change • Strong negative correlation between RFX and RFC
F
where: ∆premium decreases the volatility of RDC resulting in a hedge
βT = target portfolio beta in volatility, _
​​   ​​, a natural way to think ratio < 1.0.
∆volatility
βP = current portfolio beta about the return for volatility.
βF = futures beta (beta of stock index)
MVP = market value of portfolio
Foreign Currency Equations
RDC = (1 + RFC)(1 + RFX) − 1 = RFC + RFX + FIXED INCOME
F = futures contract value = futures price × (RFC)(RFX) Liability-based mandates:
multiplier RDC ≈ RFC + RFX • Cash flow matching directly funds liabilities with
Note that to fully hedge the portfolio from market RFC = return on the foreign asset and coupon and par amounts.
risk βT = 0. RFX = return on the foreign currency • Duration matching requires:
VIX Futures σ2(RDC) ≈ σ2(RFC) + σ2(RFX) + 2σ (RFC) σ(RFX) • PVA = PVL; there are exceptions when asset
• Negative correlation between the VIX and stock ρ(RFC,RFX) and liability discount rates differ.
returns which becomes more pronounced during • DA = DL or BPVA = BPVL
If RFC is a risk-free asset:
equity market downturns. σ(RDC) = σ(RFX)(1 + RFC) • Minimize portfolio convexity but make it
• An equity holding can be protected from greater than that of the liabilities.
extreme downturns (tail risk) by buying VIX Currency Management Strategies • Derivatives overlays:
futures. If volatility increases the equity portfolio • Passive hedging: eliminates currency risk relative • involving the use of futures or swaps contracts,
will decline in value but VIX futures should to the benchmark. can be used to implement duration matching or
increase in value. • Discretionary hedging allows the manager to contingent immunization strategies.
• VIX futures will increase in value when the deviate modestly from passive hedging. The goal is Regularly rebalance the portfolio:
market’s expectation of future volatility at risk reduction. Š BPVfutures ≈ BPVCTD / CFCTD
contract maturity increases. • Active currency management allows a manager to
have greater deviations from passive hedging. The Š BPV = MD × V × 0.0001
Position Term structure Roll yield Š Nf = (BPVL − current BPV) / BPVfutures
goal is adding value.
Long futures position Contango Negative
• Currency overlay is the outsourcing of currency • Nonparallel yield curve shifts can be
Short futures position Contango Positive
Long futures position Backwardation Positive
management to another manager. a problem, match key rate durations:
Short futures position Backwardation Negative Factors That Shift the Strategic Decision Toward %Δ value = −MDkey rate n Δyn
a Benchmark Neutral or Fully Hedged Strategy • Contingent immunization: active management
VIX Options if the surplus is positive.
• A short time horizon for portfolio objectives.
• Call options gain in value if expectations of (PV− ) − (PV+ )
• High risk aversion. Effective duration =
volatility at maturity of the option increase.
• Little weight given to the opportunity costs of 2 ( ∆ Curve ) (PV0 )
• Put options gain in value if expectations of
missing positive currency returns.
volatility fall. (PV− ) + (PV+ ) − 2(PV0 )
• High short-term income and liquidity needs. Effective convexity =
Variance swaps are based on variance (σ2) rather
than volatility (standard deviation).
• Significant foreign currency bond exposure. (∆ Curve )2 (P V0 )
• Low hedging costs.
Implied variance K2 • Clients who doubt the benefits of discretionary where:
(fixed at initiation)
management. PV0 = current value of the portfolio
Counterparty Counterparty
1 2 Tactical Currency Management PV− = value of portfolio when benchmark curve
Realized variance σ2 • Economic fundamentals: in the long term, is shifted down
(unknown at initiation) relative currency values will converge to their fair PV+ = value of portfolio when benchmark curve
There is no initial exchange of notional principal, values. Increases in currency values are associated
is shifted up
no interim settlement periods, and a single with currencies:
Š That are undervalued relative to their ΔCurve = change in benchmark curve
payment at the expiration of the swap based on the
difference between actual and implied variance over fundamental value. Return can be projected (or actual return
Š That have the greatest rate of increase in decomposed) as the sum of:
the life of the swap.
fundamental value. 1. Coupon income: annual coupon amount /
Settlement amountT = current bond price
(variance notional)(realized variance − variance Š With higher real or nominal interest rates.
Š With lower inflation relative to other countries. 2. Rolldown return, assuming no change in yield
strike)
Š Of countries with decreasing risk premiums. curve: (projected ending bond price (BP) −
beginning BP) / beginning BP

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 2 15/05/23 1:20 PM


3. Price change due to investor yield change EQUITY quantitative pair trading referred to as statistical
predictions: (−MD × ΔY) + (½C × ΔY2) arbitrage.
Constructing and maintaining the index involves:
4. Price change due to investor spread change • The weighting method to construct the index: Benefits of long/short strategies include the ability
predictions: (−MD × ΔS) + (½C × ΔS2) (1) market-cap weighting, (2) price weighting, to better express negative views, the ability to gear
5. Currency G/L: projected change in value of foreign (3) equal weighting, or (4) fundamental weighting. into high-conviction long positions, the removal
currencies weighted for exposure to the currency • Considering the level of stock concentration. The of market risk to diversify, and the ability to better
Coupon income + rolldown return may be referred “effective number of stocks” can be determined as the control risk factor exposures.
to as rolling yield. reciprocal of the Herfindahl-Hirschman index (HHI): Drawbacks of long/short strategies include
n potential large losses since share prices are not
Leveraged return = rI + [(VB / VE) × (rI − rB)].
HHI = ∑ w 2i bounded above, negative exposures to risk
where:
rp = return on portfolio i =1 premiums, potentially high leverage for market-
rI = return on invested assets effective number of stocks = _
effective number of stock s =HHI
​ ​ 1 1 ​​ neutral funds, and the costs of borrowing securities
rB = rate paid on borrowings HHI and collateral demands from prime brokers. Being
Common equity risk factors: growth, value, size, subject to a short squeeze on short positions is also
VB = amount of leverage yield, momentum, quality, and volatility.
VE = amount of equity invested a risk.
Factor-based strategies: return oriented, risk
Active management for a stable upward sloping oriented, and diversification oriented.
yield curve:
Common approaches to passive equity investing
• Buy and hold: extend duration to get higher yields.
• Roll down the yield curve: portfolio weighting
use: (1) pooled investments, such as open-end mutual ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS
funds and ETFs, (2) derivatives-based strategies, and
highest for securities at the long end of the Hedge Funds Strategies:
(3) separately-managed index-based portfolios.
steepest yield curve segments, maximize gains on 1. Equity related with the primary source of risk
securities from declines in yield as time passes. Three methods of constructing passively managed
index-based equity portfolios: (1) full replication, being equity risk.
• Repo carry trade: borrow at lower rates to a. Long/short equity—The fund manager takes
purchase securities with higher rates. (2) stratified sampling, often based on cell matching,
(3) technical and quantitative approach (optimization) long positions in stocks that they think will
• Long futures position rise in value, and takes short positions in stocks
• Receive-fixed swap Fundamental managers use discretionary judgment
vs. quantitative managers use rules-based that they believe will fall in value.
Active management for a changing yield curve: b. Dedicated short bias funds—These seek
• Increase (decrease) portfolio duration if rates are (systematic) data-driven models.
overpriced securities to sell short.
expected to decrease (increase). Fundamental law of active management: c. Equity market neutral—These seek to attain a
• Add call options on either a bond price or a bond E(R A ) IC BRσ RA TC near-zero overall exposure to the stock market.
futures contract to increase duration.
Š Take long positions in undervalued stocks
• Add put options on either a bond price or bond Active share measures the degree to which the number and short positions in overvalued stocks with
futures contract to decrease duration. and sizing of the positions in a manager’s portfolio the betas of the positions summing to zero.
• A payer swaption (right to enter a pay-fixed swap differ to those of a benchmark:
n Š Alpha occurs through mean reversion.
decreases duration. 1
• A receiver swaption (right to enter a receive-fixed Active share ∑ Wp,i – Wb,i 2. Event-driven relate to corporate actions such
2 as governance activities, mergers, acquisitions,
swap) increases duration. i=1
bankruptcies, and other major business events.
change in portfolio value Active risk (tracking error), is the standard The main risk is event risk.
KeyRateDur = −
portfolio value × change in key rate deviation of active returns (portfolio returns minus a. Merger arbitrage earns a return from the
benchmark returns). uncertainty that exists in the market from when
• Increase portfolio convexity (decreasing yield)
when large changes in rates are expected. The contribution of Asset i to portfolio variance an acquisition is announced until completed
• Bullet portfolios have more yield, but barbells (CVi) is given by the equation: (i.e., the fund manager purchases the stock of
n
have more convexity and also tend to outperform the target company and shorts the stock of the
​​CV​  i​​ ​= ​ ∑ ​​​​w​  i​​ ​w​  j​​ ​C​  ij​​ ​= ​w​  i​​ ​C​  ip​​​
in curve-flattening environments. acquiring company, anticipating the deal will be
j=1
Curvature of the yield curve can be measured through completed).
the butterfly spread: butterfly spread = −(short-term where:
b. Distressed securities take positions in the securities
yield) + (2 × medium-term yield) − long-term yield wj = Asset j’s weight in the portfolio
of firms that are in financial distress, including
• % Δ value = −MDΔy Cij = the covariance of returns between Asset firms that are in bankruptcy or near-bankruptcy.
• %Δrelative value = −SDΔs where spread i and Asset j 3. Relative value strategies profit from the relative
duration (SD) measures a portfolio’s percentage valuation differences between securities.
Cip = the covariance of returns between Asset
sensitivity to a 1% change in credit spreads (Δs). a. Fixed-income arbitrage takes advantage
• spread = yhigher yield − ygovernment n

( j=1 )
i and the portfolio ​​​ ​​=​  ∑ ​​ ​​w​  j​​ ​C​  ij​​​ ​​​​ of temporary mispricing of fixed-income
• credit spread ≈ POD × LGD instruments by going long undervalued
(PV– ) – (PV ) securities and short overvalued securities.
• EffRateDurFRN = The contribution of Factor i to portfolio variance is Š Yield curve trades go long and short fixed-
2 (∆ MRR ) (PV0 ) income investments in order to profit from the
given by the formula:
• EffSpreadDurFRN =
(PV− ) − (PV+ ) n
anticipated yield curve steepening or flattening.
2( ∆ DM)(PV0 ) ​​CV​  i​​ ​= ​∑​  ​​​β​  i​​ ​β​  j​​ ​C​  ij​​ ​= ​β​  i​​ ​C​  ip​​​ Š Carry trade the portfolio manager shorts a
j=1
(PV− ) − (PV+ ) low-yielding security and goes long a high-
where:
• effective spread duration = yielding security.
2( ∆ spread )(PV0 ) ​β​i​ = sensitivity of portfolio to Factor i b. Convertible bond arbitrage the manager purchases
(regression coefficient) the convertible bond which is often underpriced
(PV− ) + (PV+ ) − 2(PV0 )
• effective spread convexity = Cij = the covariance of Factor i and Factor j and short sells the underlying equity.
( ∆ spread )2 (PV0 ) Cip = the covariance of Factor i and the 4. Opportunistic strategies employ a top-
down approach making macro investments on a
portfolio (
​​​ ​= ​  ∑​​ ​β​j​​C​ij​)​​​
• %Δprice = (−EffSpreadDur × Δspread) + n
(½ × EffSpreadCon × Δspread2) global basis across regions, sectors, and asset classes.
j=1
• Expected excess spread = spread − (EffSpreadDur a. Global macro profits from making correct
× Δspread) − (POD × LGD) Long extension portfolios guarantee investors assessments and forecasts of various global
• Effective spread for a buy order = trade size × 100% net exposure with a specified short exposure. economic variables.
(trade price − midquote) A typical 130/30 fund will have 130% long and b. Managed futures strategies take long and short
• Effective spread for a sell order = trade size × 30% short positions.
positions in derivatives contracts.
(midquote − trade price) where: midquote = (bid Market-neutral portfolios aim to remove market 5. Specialist strategies require specialized market
+ ask) / 2 exposure through offsetting long and short expertise or knowledge.
• CDS price ≈ 1 + [(fixed coupon − CDS spread) positions. Pairs trading is a common technique a. Volatility strategies trade volatility-related assets
× EffSpreadDurCDS] in building market-neutral portfolios, with
globally.

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 3 15/05/23 1:20 PM


b. Insurance/reinsurance strategies: constructing the portfolio, monitoring and Strategies for managing a concentrated position in
Š Insurance strategy—An insured person sells rebalancing the portfolio, monitoring portfolio public equities:
their insurance policy (through a broker) to costs and third-party providers, and reporting • Staged diversification strategy over multiple years
a hedge fund. portfolio performance. to spread out tax liability
Š Reinsurance strategies—Insurance companies • IPS Appendix includes modelled portfolio • Completion portfolio using other assets to
sell off some of their risk to reinsurance performance and capital market expectations. complement/complete the concentrated position
companies who may then sell the risk to Portfolio Construction: • Equity monetization by hedging a large part of
hedge funds in exchange for capital. • Traditional Approach—views risk in an overall the risk in the position using derivatives and then
6. Multimanager strategies use other hedge fund portfolio context. borrow using the hedged position as collateral
strategies as building blocks, combining different • Goals-based investing—separate portfolios are • Zero-cost collars are used to lower initial cost by
strategies together, rebalancing exposures over time. created for each of the client’s goals. Mean-variance giving up some stock upside. The put premium
optimization used to maximize expected returns paid and call premium received are equal.
Drawdown: • Covered call writing is possibly a staged
for a given level of risk or to meet a specified
• Defined as the percentage peak-to-trough decline diversification assuming the share price
probability of success is carried out for each goal
for a portfolio. appreciates sufficiently
portfolio rather than for the entire portfolio.
• High-water mark refers to the maximum value the • Exchange fund with a pooling of investments on
portfolio has ever reached. a tax-free basis
Estimating investor cash flows to and from a TOPICS IN PRIVATE WEALTH
MANAGEMENT • Charitable remainder trust to benefit both
private investment: beneficiaries and a designated charity
• Main categories of taxes: income tax, capital gains
• Capital contribution in period t = percentage Strategies for managing concentrated positions in
tax, wealth/property tax, stamp duties, wealth
to be called in period t × (committed capital − privately owned businesses:
transfer tax.
capital previously called)
• General equation for capital gains: net sales price • IPO
• Distributions in period t = percentage to be
− tax (cost) basis = capital gain/loss. • Direct sale to another investor
distributed in period t × [NAV in period t − 1 ×
• Three main types of investment accounts: taxable, • Sale of non-essential business assets
(1 + growth rate)]
tax-deferred (TDA), and tax-exempt (TEA). • Personal line of credit secured by company shares
• NAV in period t = [NAV in period t − 1 ×
Common metrics used in examining tax (owner borrows from company or from a third-
(1 + growth rate)] + contributions in period t −
efficiency: party lender)
distributions in period t
1. After-tax holding period return R' = • Leveraged recapitalization (e.g., private equity
[(value1 − value0) + income − tax] / value0 firm)
PRIVATE WEALTH MANAGEMENT Alternatively, R' = R − (tax / value0). • Sale to employee stock ownership plan
Lifetime Gifts vs. Testamentary Bequests
2. After-tax post-liquidation return (RPL) involves
OVERVIEW OF PRIVATE WEALTH deducting the implied tax: Basic form of the relative value (RV) ratio: FV
MANAGEMENT RPL = [(1 + R' 1)(1 + R' 2)…(1 + R' n)(1 − liqui- after-tax to the receiver if gifted now / FV after-tax
Behavioral Biases Associated with Retirees: dation tax/final value)]1/n − 1. Liquidation tax = to the receiver if bequeathed at death:
• Increased loss aversion. Affects return assumptions (final value − tax basis) × tax rate on capital gains Two tax scenarios to consider:
and asset allocation decisions in retirement. 3. After-tax excess return (x') is computed as the • The gift now is tax free to both the receiver and
• Consumption gaps. Consumption spending tends after-tax return of the portfolio (R') minus the the donor
to be lower than what economic studies forecast, after-tax return of the benchmark (B'): • The gift is taxable with tax paid by the receiver
can be attributed to loss aversion and uncertainty x' = R' − B'. In this regard, the tax alpha would Relevant tax factors to consider:
about future retirement spending. be defined as after-tax excess return (x') minus the • rg and tg are the pretax return earned and the
• The “annuity puzzle”. Individuals tend to applicable tax rate on those earnings for assets
pretax excess return (x): αtax = x' − x
avoid buying annuities, possible explanations held by the gift receiver
4. Tax-efficiency ratio (TER) is calculated as after-tax
include: (a) clinging to hope of funding a • re and te are the pretax return earned and the
better retirement lifestyle, (b) a desire to keep return (R') divided by pretax return (R):TER = R' / R
Taxable accounts involve one or more tax rates on applicable tax rate on those earnings for assets
control of assets, and (c) the high cost of annuities. held by the gift giver
• Mental accounting and lack of self-control. Retirees income (e.g., interest, dividends) or return (e.g., realized
capital gains) to determine R’: FVAT = (1 + R’)n • Te is the estate tax rate and would be paid from
prefer to meet their spending needs from investment the estate
income rather than liquidating securities. Tax exempt accounts (TEAs), after-tax funds are
• Tg is the gift tax rate and is assumed to be paid
IPS for a Private Clients: deposited so no tax is due on the returns earned or
by the receiver
• Client Background obtained from relevant on withdrawals: FVAT = (1 + R)n
FVgift = [1 + rg(1 − tg)]n
personal, financial and tax information. Investment Tax deferred accounts (TDAs), pretax funds
Objectives may be planned, unplanned, ongoing, or are deposited and the investor may take a tax FVbequest = [1 + re(1 − te)]n(1 − Te)
one-off. Multiple objectives should be prioritized deduction for the amount contributed thereby • RV of a tax-free gift, Tg = 0
into primary and secondary objectives. reducing taxable income and taxes due. All tax is ​FV​  ​​ ​ 1+​r​  ​​​ 1−​t​  ​​ ​ ​​​​ n​
[ g( g)]
• ​​RV​ Tax Free Gift​​= ​​  ____ ___________
​FV​   ​​​​ =   
​​      ​​
Gift
• Key Investment Parameters: deferred until withdrawal allowing tax-deferred
compounding: FVAT = (1 + R)n(1 − t) ​[1+​r​  e​​​(1−​t​  e​​)​]​​​​ ​​(1−​T​  e​​)
n
Š Risk tolerance—willingness and ability, low risk Bequest

tolerance usually associated with high priority Tax-efficient assets (e.g., equities that generate capital • RV of a taxable gift, Tg paid by receiver
goals and near-term goals. gains are often subject to lower tax rates) should be
​FV​  ​​ ​[1+​r​  g​​ ​(1−​t​  g​​)​]​n​(1−​T​  g​​)​
Š Time horizon—described as a range (e.g. in excess placed in taxable accounts. Tax-inefficient assets (e.g., ​​ V​Taxable Gift​​​ = ____
• R ​​  Gift
​FV​  Bequest​​
____________
 ​ =   
​      ​
​[1+​r​  e​​​(1−​t​  e​​)​]​ ​(1−​T​  e​​)
n
of 15 years for a long horizon and less than 10 taxable bonds that generate taxable interest, which is
years for a short horizon). If multiple objectives, a often subject to higher tax rates) should be placed in
different time horizon for each objective. tax-exempt or tax-deferred accounts. RISK MANAGEMENT FOR ­INDIVIDUALS
Š Other investment parameters—include asset class Four common investment vehicles include: • Total wealth is composed of both human capital
preferences, liquidity preferences (including a cash • Partnership (HC) and financial capital (FC). HC is the
reserve), unique investment preferences. • Mutual fund discounted present value of expected future labor
Š Constraints—restricting investments for client’s • Exchange-traded fund (ETF) income. FC is the sum of all the other assets of an
portfolio. • Separately managed account (SMA) individual.
• Asset Allocation—Strategic long-term target Tax loss harvesting involves the sale of securities • Net wealth is the sum of the individual’s FC
asset allocation for each asset class and tactical with embedded losses to offset gains, which will and HC less any liabilities owed by the individual.
asset allocation as an active management strategy lower the tax liability for the current year. • The economic (holistic) balance sheet extends the
specifying a range for each asset class. traditional balance sheet assets to include HC.
• Highest in, first out (HIFO) is generally optimal
• Portfolio Management and Implementation Liabilities can also be extended to include
• In case future tax rates are expected to be higher
guidelines for discretionary authority, portfolio consumption and bequest goals.
than current tax rates, first in, first out (FIFO)
rebalancing, tactical asset allocation changes, and • Earnings risk: Use disability income insurance.
may be better
acceptable investment vehicles. • Premature death risk: Use life insurance.
• In case future tax rates are expected to be lower
• Wealth Manager Duties and Responsibilities • Longevity risk of living too long: Use annuities.
than current tax rates, last in, first out (LIFO)
include; formulating/reviewing the client’s IPS,
may be better continued on next page...

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 4 15/05/23 1:20 PM


PRIVATE WEALTH MANAGEMENT continued... Invest- Short term Long/me- Long Long Long Liquidity Driven by deposit Varies by product
ment dium term term term term needs withdrawals and line—P&C liquidity
• Property risk: Loss in value of physical property potential need to raise needs generally higher
time dependent
(FC). Use property insurance (homeowner’s and horizon on in- liquidity in adverse than life. Liquidity
market conditions. needs will increase in times
automobile). vestment
Regulators apply of high interest rates due to
• Liability risk: If legally responsible for damages. projects
liquidity coverage ratios policyholders surrendering
Liquidity Highest Generally Lowest Interme- Varies: and net stable funding in search of high yields
Use liability insurance. needs low diate low ratios. elsewhere.
• Health risk: Direct loss of FC to pay illness or during
External Highly regulated due to importance to real
injury related expenses and may reduce HC. Use accumula-
constraints economy and systemic risk, particularly SIFIs.
tion stage,
health and medical insurance. higher Main goal of regulators is to ensure the institution
holds sufficient risk-based capital to absorb losses.
Asset allocation based on investor’s total economic during
Three different types of accounting systems apply:
wealth, FC and HC: decumu-
lation 1. Standard financial reporting (GAAP or IFRS)
• Individual employed in a high risk profession stage 2. Statutory accounting for regulators (more
conservative than financial reporting)
would choose lower risk FC. External Established by national legislation. Best practice set by 3. True economic accounting (marked-to-market)
• If HC is positively correlated with the stock con- ISWF’s Santiago Principles. Banks and insurers are fully taxable.
straints Generally tax exempt.
market then best to select asset classes other than Investment Manage liquidity and risk mismatches between
Invest- Capital Real Maintain Grow Earn objectives the institution’s non-investment assets and
equity for risky assets used. ment ob- preserva- growth real faster returns liabilities. This needs to be done in the context
• Avoid FC tied directly to employer. jectives tion higher perpetual than to meet of the institution’s overall profit maximization
than real spending yield on future objective.
Risk Management Decision Matrix GDP central unfunded
growth bank/ govern- The change in the market value of equity for banks
Characteristic of the Loss Occurs Regularly Infrequent
govern- ment and insurers:
Very severe Risk avoidance Risk transfer ment pension
bonds payments
%∆E = ​ %∆A(M) − ​ %∆L(M − ​ 1)
Not severe Risk reduction Risk retention where:
Stakeholders and key elements of the IPS for %ΔE ​ = percentage change in the value of equity
university endowments and private foundations: %ΔA ​ = percentage change in the value of assets
INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS University Endowments Private Foundations %ΔL ​ =p  ercentage change in the value of
Stakeholders and key elements of the IPS for Stakeholders Current and future Founding family, donors, liabilities
defined benefit (DB) pension plans vs. defined students, alumni, grant recipients and M ​ = leverage multiplier, A /​ E
university employees broader community,
contribution (DC) pension plans: governments The duration of the equity of a bank or insurer:

( ∆y )
DB Plan DC Plan Liabilities Set by the future
spending promised to
U.S. tax rules require
minimum spending ​  ∆i  ​ ​​​​​​
​​D​  E​​ ​= ​D​  A​​  (M) ​− ​D​  L​​  (M ​− 1)​​​​ _
Stakeholders Employers, plan Employers, plan the university. of 5% of assets plus
beneficiaries, beneficiaries, where:
Spending policy should investment expenses.
investment staff, investment staff, consider (1) ongoing Must also spend DE ​ = modified duration of the institution’s
investment committee/ investment committee/
board, governments, board, governments
donations, (2) reliance donations in the same equity capital
of university on year they are received. DA ​ = modified duration of the institution’s
shareholders spending, (3) ability to
Liabilities Present value of future No liability to plan issue debt. Spending assets
benefits promised sponsor once required may use a spending rule DL ​ = modified duration of the institution’s
to plan participants. contribution to plan has which takes a weighted
Higher when: been met average of last period’s
liabilities
• Employees work longer spending adjusted for M ​ = leverage multiplier, A /​ E
​​  ∆i  ​​ =
• Salaries are higher inflation and a fixed _
• Participants live longer spending rate applied to ​ estimated change in yield of liabilities, i,
• Lower employee average AUM. ∆y relative to a unit change in yield of assets, y
turnover leads to Investment Perpetual Typically perpetual, but
higher vesting time horizon shortened for limited-life
The expected volatility (i.e., standard deviation) of
• Discount rate is low foundations the percentage change in the market value of equity
Investment Longer if proportion of Dependent on the age Liquidity The spending rate net of Higher than capital for a bank or insurer:
time horizon active lives is higher of participant: longer if needs donations is very low at endowments—legally
younger 2%−4% of assets. required to spend 5% ​​σ2​ E ​ ​  = ​M​​ 2​ ​σ2​ A ​  ​  + ​(M − 1)​​ 2​ ​σ2​ L ​  ​  − 2(M)(M − 1) ​σ​ A​​ ​σ​ L​​ ​ρ​ AL​​​
Liquidity Higher with: Higher with: of assets. Reliance
needs • More retired lives • Older workforce on spending by where:
• Older workforce • Flexibility of foundation is usually ​​σ​  E ​​ ​  = standard deviation of percentage
• Higher funded participants to switch higher than the change in the market value of equity
status (may reduce plans reliance of a university
contributions) on endowment ​​σ​  A ​ ​  ​ = s tandard deviation of percentage
• Flexibility of spending. change in the value of assets
participants to switch
plans
External Typically tax exempt. Regulation varies by ​​σ​  L ​​ ​  = standard deviation of percentage
constraints jurisdiction but generally requires a total return change in the value of liabilities
External • Regulations vary by • Regulations vary by approach and prudence in investing (UPMIFA in
constraints country: IORP II country: IORP II U.S., The Trustee Act in the U.K.). M = leverage multiplier, A / E
in Europe, ERISA in Europe, ERISA Investment Generate a total real Generate a real ρAL = c orrelation of percentage value changes
in U.S. in U.S.
• Tax treatment • Sponsor must offer
objectives return after inflation return over consumer in assets and liabilities
measure by the HEPI price inflation of
favorable appropriate default of about 5% on a the spending rate
• Accounting rules: ASC option to disengaged 3−5 year rolling basis, (minimum 5%) plus
715 requires funded participants
TRADING, PERFORMANCE
with reasonable annual investment expenses on
status to be shown • Plans are tax deferred volatility in the range of a 3−5 year rolling basis,
on balance sheet 10%−15% with reasonable annual
(U.S. GAAP); public
pension plans follow
volatility in the range of
10%−15%
EVALUATION, AND MANAGER
Investment
GASB
Achieve a long-term Prudently grow assets to Stakeholders and key elements of the IPS for banks SELECTION
objectives target return over a meet spending needs in and insurers: Implementation shortfall (IS) at the highest level
specified horizon with retirement.
appropriate risk to meet Banks Insurers the absolute value is:
contractual liabilities. Stakeholders External: shareholder, External: shareholders, IS = paper return − actual return
Stakeholders and key elements of the IPS for the depositors, borrowers, policyholders, derivatives
creditors, credit counterparties, creditors, IS can be decomposed into the following parts:
five types of sovereign wealth funds (SWF): ratings agencies, regulators, credit ratings • Execution cost occurs due to executing shares at a
regulators, and agencies
Budget
communities Internal: employees, less favorable price than the original decision price.
Stabiliza- Develop- Pension Execution cost can be further broken down into:
tion ment Savings Reserve Reserve Internal: employees, management, and board
management, and board Š Delay cost occurs due to adverse price movements
Stake- Country’s citizens, the government, external and inter-
holders nal investment management Liabilities Primarily deposits Life insurers: long in the time between the portfolio manager
which are short term duration contract
Liabilities Uncertain: Linked to Spending Yield Future payouts submits the order to the trader and the time the
linked to socio- on future promised pension P&C insurers: shorter trader releases the order to the market. For a buy
commod- economic genera- on cen- Payments and less certain contract
ity prices/ invest- tions tral bank/ order: delay cost = shares executed × (arrival
payouts
economic ments govern- price − decision price)
cycle ment Investment While perpetual organizations, investments are Š Decision price = price when manager decides
bonds time horizon run on a short/medium term LDI basis. to buy (or sell).

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 5 15/05/23 1:20 PM


Š Arrival price = price when the order is placed • Allocation effect refers to the portfolio Appraisal ratio is calculated as alpha divided by the
by trader. manager’s decision to overweight or underweight standard deviation of the residual/unsystematic risk
Š Trading cost: due to the market impact of specific sector weightings versus the benchmark. Using (the standard error of regression).
executing the trade. the Brinson-Fachler model, the contribution to the ith α
AR =
Trading cost = shares executed × (average sector is equal to the portfolio’s sector weight minus σε
purchase price − arrival price) the benchmark’s sector weight, times the benchmark
Sortino ratio only considers the standard deviation
• Opportunity cost is the cost of not trading any unfilled sector return minus the overall benchmark return:
of the downside risk where rT refers to the
part of the order. The paper portfolio assumes that Ai = (wi − Wi)(Bi − B). For the BHB model, the
minimum acceptable return (MAR) and (σD) refers
all shares are executed immediately at the original contribution to the ith sector is equal to the portfolio’s
to target semistandard deviation.
decision price. The actual trade may have only filled sector weight minus the benchmark’s sector weight,
part of the order and the lost profit on the unfilled times the benchmark sector return: Ai = (wi − Wi)Bi E (rp ) – rt
portion is the opportunity cost. For a buy order: • Security selection is the portfolio manager’s SR D =
σD
Opportunity cost = portion of order not filled × value added by selecting individual securities
(closing price − decision price) (stock picking) within the sector and weighting the Capture ratios determine the manager’s relative
• Fixed fees are any explicit commissions or fees portfolio differently compared to the benchmark’s performance when markets are up or down.
incurred in executing the trade. weightings. The contribution to selection in the Capture is calculated as portfolio return divided by
Fixed fees = ∑ executed × commission per share ith sector is equal to the benchmark sec­tor weight benchmark return. The capture ratio is calculated as
Total IS value ($) = delay cost + trading cost + times the portfolio’s sector return minus the upside capture divided by downside capture.
opportunity cost + fixed fees benchmark’s sector return: Si = Wi(Ri − Bi) Type I and II errors in hiring managers and
All of the components of and total IS can be expressed • Interaction effect is a residual amount (e.g., continuation decisions
in terms of basis points (bps) of the original cost of the plug) that ensures the arithmetic return minus • Null hypothesis (H0) is that there is no value
paper portfolio. A basis point is 1/100th of one percent. the relative benchmark is fully accounted for in added.
A decimal number is multiplied by 10,000 to convert attribution analysis. The contribution to the ith • Type I error is when the null hypothesis is rejected
it to basis points. sector is equal to the portfolio sector weight minus when in fact there was no value added.
Trade costs represent costs relative to the benchmark, the benchmark sector weight, times the portfolio • Type II error is when the null hypothesis is not
a positive value represents underperformance: sector return minus the benchmark sector return: rejected when in fact there was value added.
Absolute cost ($) = side × (execution price − Ii = (wi − Wi)(Ri − Bi)
benchmark price) × shares executed Carhart model is a fundamental factor model
Trade cost (bps) = calculating the excess return from active
(execution price – benchmark price)
management decisions by determining the impact CASES IN PORTFOLIO
side ×
benchmark price
×10, 000 on the portfolio due to the following factors:
(1) market index (RMRF), (2) market-capitalization MANAGEMENT AND RISK
where: (SMB), (3) book-value-to-price (HML), and (4) MANAGEMENT
side = +1 for a buy order, −1 for a sell order momentum (WML):
Calculating life insurance needs
Market-adjusted cost is used to remove the impact Rp − Rf = ap + bp1RMRF + bp2SMB + bp3HML
Human life value method estimates the amount of future
of market movements on trade cost which ensures + bp4WML + Ep earnings that must be replaced.
a trader is not penalized or rewarded for general Benchmark quality of a portfolio return can be 1. Start with the current amount of after-tax income
market movements over the trade horizon. broken up into three components: market, style, to be replaced
index cost (bps) = and active management.
2. Subtract annual expenses attributable to the
P=M+S+A
(index VWAP – index arrival price) where:
person passing away
side × ×100, 000
index arrival price P = investment manager’s portfolio return 3. Add any employee benefits such as contributions
M = return on the market index to pension plans that would not be earned
Market-adjusted cost (bps) = arrival cost (bps) − β
S = B − M = excess return to style; difference 4. Gross up to a required pretax payout
× index cost (bps)
between the manager’s style index 5. Use the growth-adjusted discount rate (r*) to
where: (benchmark) return and the market return
arrival cost is the arrival cost of the trade based on calculate the present value of the pretax annuity due.
(S can be positive or negative) These calculations use the growth-adjusted discount
an arrival price benchmark A = P − B = active return; difference between
β = beta of the security vs. the index used to rate (r*) entered as I/Y on your financial calculator to
the manager’s overall portfolio return and calculate a growing annuity due (beginning of period
calculate index cost the style benchmark return
Added value is a different method of trade cost payments) with the calculator in BGN mode.
analysis comparing the arrival cost of the trade with
Performance Appraisal r* = (1 + r)/(1 + g)
the estimated pre-trade cost. Sharpe ratio where:
Added value (bps) = arrival cost (bps) − R – r r = annual discount rate
estimated pre-trade cost (bps) SA = A f g = annual growth rate
σA 6. Subtract existing life insurance = additional life
A negative cost is a benefit—the trader has added
value through their trading decisions. Treynor ratio insurance needs
Micro Attribution vs. Macro Attribution Needs analysis method estimates the amount needed to
R – rf
• Micro attribution analyzes the portfolio at the TA = A cover living expenses.
portfolio manager’s level. βA 1. Determine the total cash needs (funeral,
• Macro attribution analyzes investment decisions at emergency fund, debts)
Information ratio is used to measure a portfolio’s
the fund sponsor’s level. 2. Plus the capital needs which are the PV of surviving
performance against the benchmark accounting for
Returns-Based, Holdings-Based, and spouse’s annual living expenses minus PV of
differences in risk.
Transactions-Based Attribution survivor’s income until retirement using the growth-
E (rp ) – E (rB ) adjusted discount rate r* = total financial needs
• Returns-based attribution uses regressions to analyze IR =
the portfolio returns over time and isolates the σ (rp – rB ) 3. Subtract the capital available (savings)
asset class components through indices that would 4. Less PV of vested retirement accounts attributable to
have generated these returns. the surviving spouse = additional life insurance needs
• Holdings-based attribution uses beginning-of-period
portfolio assets. ISBN: 978-1-0788-3748-4 • Review the SchweserNotesTM and/or Module Videos.
• Transactions-based attribution updates the
beginning-of-period holdings-based attribution for
any subsequent trades.
Brinson-Fachler and Brinson, Hood,
Beebower (BHB) models quantify the portfolio ETHICS (INCLUDING GIPS)
9 781078 837484
returns into three attribution effects: allocation Review the SchweserNotesTM and/or Module
effect, security selection effect, and the Videos and questions in the SchweserNotesTM,
interaction effect. © 2023 Kaplan, Inc. All Rights Reserved. CFA® text, and SchweserProTM Qbank.

CFA_L3_QS_Spreads.indd 6 15/05/23 1:20 PM

You might also like