Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Discussion Unit 1

    Uploaded by

    steph
    3 views2 pages
    This document discusses the importance of following the spirit rather than just the letter of the law in two scenarios involving a school smoking ban. In the first scenario, a student technically did not break the rules by keeping cigarettes in his backpack, but still went against the intention of the smoking ban. In the second scenario, students smoking outside the school grounds still undermined the smoke-free environment. The document argues that strictly following the letter of the law is not always ideal, and that respecting the underlying purpose or spirit of the law is also important, especially for maintaining a healthy school or business environment. It then discusses how the rule of law provides predictability, fairness, and contract enforcement that are crucial for businesses to function effectively.

    Original Description:

    discussion

    Original Title

    discussion unit 1

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    This document discusses the importance of following the spirit rather than just the letter of the law in two scenarios involving a school smoking ban. In the first scenario, a student technically did not break the rules by keeping cigarettes in his backpack, but still went against the intention of the smoking ban. In the second scenario, students smoking outside the school grounds still undermined the smoke-free environment. The document argues that strictly following the letter of the law is not always ideal, and that respecting the underlying purpose or spirit of the law is also important, especially for maintaining a healthy school or business environment. It then discusses how the rule of law provides predictability, fairness, and contract enforcement that are crucial for businesses to function effectively.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    3 views2 pages

    Discussion Unit 1

    Uploaded by

    steph
    This document discusses the importance of following the spirit rather than just the letter of the law in two scenarios involving a school smoking ban. In the first scenario, a student technically did not break the rules by keeping cigarettes in his backpack, but still went against the intention of the smoking ban. In the second scenario, students smoking outside the school grounds still undermined the smoke-free environment. The document argues that strictly following the letter of the law is not always ideal, and that respecting the underlying purpose or spirit of the law is also important, especially for maintaining a healthy school or business environment. It then discusses how the rule of law provides predictability, fairness, and contract enforcement that are crucial for businesses to function effectively.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 2

    Is it more important for you to follow the letter of the law or to follow the spirit of the law?

    In what circumstance would you believe the opposite to be true?

    Consider the two scenarios, there’s a rule at school stating that “Students are not allowed
    to smoke inside the school premises”. In relation to the letter of the law, a student brings a
    cigarette bag and did not take it out of his back bag. Technically he has not smoked in the
    school premises as it was in his backpack. On the other hand, a group of teenagers are
    outside the compound smoking and creating a mess, they haven’t technically broken the
    law, although their actions go against the intended purpose of maintaining a nonsmoking
    environment for everyone.

    This situation, blindly following the letter of law Student bringing the cigarette in his
    backpack) might technically permissible, but it does not necessarily align with the spirit of
    the law which is to protect the school environment and resources for all users ((Lau &
    Johnson, 2011). Similarly, adhering to the spirit of the law by avoiding smoking in the school
    premises, even outside of school premises demonstrating respect for the school
    environment and prevents potential problems. Therefore, the rule of law provides a crucial
    foundation for a healthy and vibrant business environment. While strict adherence of the
    letter of law might not always be ideal (Lau & Johnson, 2011).

    How does the rule of law affect business?

    The rule of law is crucial for its predictability, fairness, and contract enforcement. It
    provides a stable foundation for informed decisions and fair competition, ensuring equal
    treatment for all players. Businesses rely on contracts and the rule of law enables their
    enforcement, securing investment and collaborations. Additionally, strong legal systems
    offer access to justice, allowing for fair and efficient dispute resolutions (Lau & Johnson,
    2011).

    What would business be like in a land without any rule of law system? Be specific.

    In a lawless environment, business faces immense challenges marked by unpredictability,


    corruptions, and unfair advantages. The absence of rules breeds uncertainty, risking
    investments due to arbitrary interpretations. Corruption thrives unchecked, exposing
    businesses to exploitation by powerful individuals. Fair competition is stifled as connection
    determines success, hindering innovation. Enforcing contracts becomes near impossible,
    undermining trust in agreements. Access to justice is limited, with disputes unresolved and
    collaboration hindered by distrust (Lau & Johnson, 2011).

    Reference
    Lau, T. & Johnson, L. (2011). The Legal and Ethical Environment of Business (Vol. 1). Flat World
    Knowledge. Available at
    https://my.uopeople.edu/pluginfile.php/1823942/mod_page/content/6/
    LegalEthicalEnvironmentBusinessChapter01.pdf

    You might also like