COLLEGE OF NURSING

RECHEN SOLIVEN MENA February 12,

2024
Logic and Critical thinking

Title: Preserving National Unity: Against the Separation of Mindanao from the
Philippines

Introduction:
The issue of secession in Mindanao, a region with a predominantly Muslim
population, has long been a popular topic. The struggle for autonomy and self-
governance among certain groups in the so-called Land of Promise (Mindanao) has led
to periodic calls for its secession from the Philippines.
The roots of the secessionist movement in Mindanao can be traced back to
centuries of historical grievances, including marginalization, economic disparities, and
cultural differences between the Muslim-majority population in Mindanao and the
predominantly Catholic Filipino government. However, this essay argues against the
separation, emphasizing the importance of national unity for the prosperity and stability
of the Philippines.
Body Paragraphs:
1. Historical Unity and Shared Identity:
- Topic Sentence: Mindanao has been an integral part of the historical and cultural
tapestry that defines the Philippines.
- Explanation: Mindanao's history is intertwined with the nation's narrative,
contributing to the rich diversity that characterizes the Filipino identity.
- Evidence: Historical records and cultural artifacts attest to the shared
experiences that bind Mindanao with the rest of the Philippines. Mindanao, like other
regions in the Philippines, has a deep-rooted history of integration within the
archipelago. The shared history, traditions, and struggles have contributed to the
development of a national identity that transcends regional boundaries (Wurfel, 1979).

2. Economic Interconnectedness:
- Topic Sentence: The separation of Mindanao could disrupt the economic synergy
that benefits both the region and the nation.
 COLLEGE OF NURSING
- Explanation: Mindanao plays a vital role in the national economy, contributing
significantly to agriculture, resource extraction, and trade. Separating Mindanao from
the Philippines would mean severing its ties to national economic support and could
lead to a further increase in poverty and economic disparities between Mindanao and
the rest of the country.
- Evidence: Economic data illustrating Mindanao's contributions and the impact of its
separation on national economic stability. (Secession would actually hold Mindanao
back: NEDA official, 2024) According to the National Economic and Development
Authority, Mindanao relies on the national government for monetary and technical
assistance to improve the well-being of its regions.
The economic ties between Mindanao and the rest of the Philippines are substantial.
The interconnectedness of industries, trade, and labor markets fosters economic
stability and growth. Separation could disrupt these interdependencies, leading to
economic challenges for both Mindanao and the rest of the country (Fabella, 1986).

3. Strengthening Autonomy within the Existing Framework:

- Topic Sentence: Addressing regional concerns can be achieved without resorting
to separation.
- Explanation: Enhancing autonomy within the existing political structure allows for
the accommodation of regional needs while preserving national unity. National unity is
key to the nation's strength and international standing. Division may further exacerbate
regionalism, causing Filipinos to identify more as Northerners or Southerners rather
than as a united nation (Salvosa, 2018). Moreover, this division might lead to unequal
resource distribution, where one region may become wealthier than the other depending
on their respective resources. It could result in political tension and possibly conflict, as
the regions compete for control over these resources. Moreover, establishing new
systems of governance, constitutions, and bodies of law may lead to legal and
bureaucratic complications that could disrupt daily life and further strain relationships
among Filipinos.
- Evidence: Economic data illustrating Mindanao's contributions and the impact of
its separation on national economic stability. (Secession would actually hold Mindanao
back: NEDA official, 2024) According to the National Economic and Development
Authority, Mindanao relies on the national government for monetary and technical
assistance to improve the well-being of its regions.
Examples of successful autonomy models within federal or decentralized systems
and their positive impact on regional development.
 COLLEGE OF NURSING
4. Mitigating Security Risks through Unified Governance:
- Topic Sentence: A united Philippines is better equipped to address security
challenges, ensuring the safety and stability of the nation.
- Explanation: Dividing the country could lead to increased security risks, including
territorial disputes and potential external influences.
- Evidence: Historical instances and geopolitical analyses highlighting the benefits
of a unified governance structure in safeguarding national security. One of the foremost
security risks associated with the separation of Mindanao is the potential for territorial
disputes to arise. The proposed creation of a new political entity may lead to contested
borders and competing claims over land and resources, potentially sparking conflicts
with the remaining Philippines (Balagtey, 2019). These disputes can escalate tensions,
strain diplomatic relations, and pose challenges to regional stability.
The proposed separation provides an opportunity to address these grievances by
allowing Mindanao greater autonomy and control over its affairs (Casiple, 2008).
Acknowledging historical injustices is a crucial step toward reconciliation and the
establishment of a more just and equitable political order.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the separation of Mindanao from the Philippines, despite addressing
regional issues, poses substantial risks to the nation's historical, economic, and security
fabric. A more viable and inclusive approach involves strengthening existing structures
to accommodate regional autonomy while preserving the unity that defines the
Philippines. By acknowledging and celebrating the diversity within the nation, the
Philippines can navigate challenges while maintaining its collective strength as one
cohesive entity.
 COLLEGE OF NURSING

LESLIE SHANE LAURETA February 12,

2024
Logic and Critical Thinking

Title: Agree in Dividing the Philippines into North and South

Dividing the Philippines into North and South could lead to better administration
and governance. According to Dr. Jesus Estanislao, former secretary of finance and
founder of the Institute of Solidarity in Asia, in an article published in ABS-CBN News,
having more regional or decentralized management systems will allow local authorities
to be more effective and provide well for the needs of their communities. He argues that
this will ease the administrative burden on the central government, reducing
bureaucracy and red tape. Dividing the country could mean an improved economic
distribution and further development of local cultural identity, considering the diverse
cultures, languages, and resources present throughout the country.
The Moro insurgency and other historical conflicts in Mindanao have created
deep-seated grievances. Separation is seen by some as a means to address these
issues and pave the way for a more harmonious relationship between Mindanao and the
rest of the Philippines (Balay Mindanaw Foundation, 2015). A negotiated separation
agreement could be a way to foster reconciliation and address the root causes of past
conflicts.
Proponents argue that agreeing to the separation of Mindanao from the
Philippines could lead to a more stable and peaceful coexistence between the two
entities. Learning from international examples where peaceful separations have
occurred, such as the dissolution of Czechoslovakia, advocates envision a future where
both Mindanao and the Philippines can pursue their unique paths while maintaining
amicable relations (Havel, 1993).