Design Treatise – Emily Grise

When asking someone to define good architecture, you will receive answers that differ with who

you ask. A client would say good architecture is what succeeds in carrying out their intentions

for the space. Those who do not use the architecture, but rather see its façade may scale its

“goodness” on its delightful appearance. An architect, or those familiar with the profession, has a

much more complex view of good architecture, Vitruvius would put the terms firmness,

commodity and delight to use when faced with this question, and this is a solid foundation.

Firmness and commodity incorporate durability and purpose (what transforms a space into a

memorable place). These are measurable aspects of design. Delight shifts to the immeasurable

and is where architecture passes just a building and can begin to be constituted good. This shapes

the experience of passersby and users while using intentional materials and symbols to portray

meaning. If a modern-day architect was presented with this question, they may turn to the AIA’s

Framework for Design Excellence. These ten principles incorporate a variety of factors. The AIA

recognizes the power of the profession, even stating that, “The Framework for Design

Excellence represents the defining principles of good design in the 21st century.” The last couple

of words put the idea that what constitutes good architecture has the ability to evolve over time.

Good architecture is an ever-changing idea founded on the three Vitruvian principles along with

the intentions of those apart of the design process and the effectiveness of the design to shape the

experiences of those who interact with the place. Today it is summarized by the principles

described in the AIA’s framework. These principles are what I see as the foundation for my

career development. Putting these principles at the core of my design will enable me to design

good architecture. I am not set on a focus within the field, however, healthcare and restoration

have sparked an interest.