Strategic Analysis of

Apple Inc.

Module Title: Strategy Formulation

Author:

Student No:

Submission Date: 14/11/2023

Contents
Apple Inc....................................................................................................................................4

Executive Summary...............................................................................................................4

Introduction............................................................................................................................4

Strategist.................................................................................................................................5

Mission Statement Vision.......................................................................................................5

Macro environment (PESTEL)..................................................................................................6

Industry Environment.............................................................................................................8

Porter’s Five Forces...............................................................................................................9

Threat of New Entrants Low..................................................................................................9

Bargaining Power of Suppliers Moderate..............................................................................9

Bargaining Power of Buyer Moderate...................................................................................9

Threat of Substitute Products or Services High...................................................................10

Competitive Rivalry High....................................................................................................10

SWOT Analysis....................................................................................................................10

BCG Matrix Analysis...........................................................................................................12

Price & Service Differentiation............................................................................................13

Value Chain..........................................................................................................................14

Conclusion............................................................................................................................16

Bibliography.............................................................................................................................17

1
 Apple Inc.

Executive Summary

In the scope of this case study, we will conduct a comprehensive analysis of Apple Inc.'s
business strategies employing various frameworks, namely Pestel analysis, Porter’s Five
Forces, SWOT analysis, and the Boston Matrix. This examination will explore Apple's
industry environment, examining the market in which the company operates, and examini the
mechanisms by which it establishes distinctions in terms of pricing and service
differentiation.

Introduction

In the dynamic landscape of global technology, Apple Inc. stands as a perennial trailblazer,
shaping industry standards and consumer expectations. This case study offers an in-depth
exploration of Apple's intricate value chain, dissecting the intricacies of its inbound logistics,
operational strategies, and outbound logistics. Focused on efficiency, innovation, and
sustainability, Apple's supply chain practices have become a benchmark for global
businesses. From the procurement of raw materials to the distribution of finished products,
this study delves into the intricacies of Apple's operations.

Examining Apple's inbound logistics reveals a meticulous approach to supplier relationships,

quality standards, and advanced procurement processes. A notable absence of vertical
integration in manufacturing prompts an exploration of the company's outsourcing strategies
and their impact on cost efficiency and control. The study then shifts its focus to Apple's
operational footprint, uncovering its extensive manufacturing network spanning various
countries. The centrality of China in the assembly process, negotiations with the Indian
government, and Apple's commitment to environmental responsibility form integral
components of this analysis.

Additionally, Apple's multifaceted distribution channels, include retail stores, online

platforms, and branded outlets. The company's commitment to minimising inventory
depreciation, embracing e-commerce for cost-effective sales, and a global market penetration
strategy underscores its adaptability and market leadership.

2
Strategist

CEO Tim Cook's leadership approach can be characterised as democratic, transparent, and
marked by open communication. Although he advocates for innovation, Apple has not
introduced entirely new products since the era of the late Steve Jobs. However, Cook has
overseen incremental advancements in innovation by building upon the company's existing
product design, hardware, and software. This progress has been achievable because Cook has
surrounded himself with executives who provide candid and precise feedback.

Mission Statement Vision

Apple's mission statement is quite simple “To bringing the best user experience to customers
through innovative hardware, software, and services.”

This mission statement underscores Apple's dedication to providing superior products and
services tailored to meet the distinct requirements of every customer. It serves as a guiding
principle steering the company toward its enduring objectives, significantly contributing to its
remarkable success. Comprising three fundamental elements, Apple's mission statement
embodies its core values and aspirations.

Regardless of whether it's the iPhone, iPad, or wearable devices, Apple meticulously crafts all
its products with a focus on user-friendliness. The company steadfastly upholds its
commitment to delivering unparalleled user experiences. Apple's products are equipped with
innovative features, ensuring a seamless and intuitive experience for the end-user. In 2020,
Apple implemented stringent location and Bluetooth permissions in iOS 13 (Acres, 2020),
followed by the introduction of an opt-in ad-tracking feature for iOS 14 in 2021 (Heisler,
2023). These privacy features, which were designed with user convenience in mind, serve to
safeguard the personal data of iPhone users, enhancing their overall user experiences.

Apple is renowned for its commitment to crafting products tailored to meet the distinct
requirements of its diverse customer base. Since its inception, the company has consistently
set high standards in product design, usability, and functionality. Apple's range of hardware
and software solutions is designed to cater to various market sectors, such as education,
business, and healthcare. In recent years, Apple has significantly expanded its presence in the
healthcare industry by introducing innovative products like the Apple Watch, capable of
detecting heart irregularities (Balasubramanian, 2022). Additionally, its Apple Health Records
feature for iPhone empowers patients to access their medical data conveniently through their

3
mobile devices. This strategic move into the healthcare sector has proven lucrative for Apple,
as evidenced by its impressive financial performance.

Apple places a strong emphasis on customer service, which is evident through its offerings
such as the App Store, Apple Care, and tech support services. The company meticulously
manages all aspects, including design, development, sales, and repairs, ensuring a
comprehensive and hands-on approach. This meticulous attention to customer service
provides Apple with a distinct advantage over its competitors (Meyer & Schwager, 2007).

Macro environment (PESTEL)

By conducting a PESTEL analysis, businesses gain valuable insights into market trends,
regulatory changes, and socio-economic shifts, enabling informed decision-making and
strategic planning.

Political

Government policies significantly impact Apple's business, particularly changes in European

and Irish tax laws and new regulations that can complicate operations (Brennan & O’Leary,
2023). To safeguard its interests, Apple must stay updated on policies in the countries it
operates in. Political stability is crucial, unrest could disrupt the supply chain or lead to
closures. Thorough assessments of political climates are essential to mitigate these risks.
Trade conflicts, including tariffs, can raise product prices and reduce competitiveness,
necessitating vigilant monitoring of international trade relations. Additionally, government
subsidies to Apple's competitors may create unfair advantages, demanding Apple's vigilance
to maintain a level playing field in the market.

Economic

Economic growth in countries where Apple operates boosts product demand, particularly in
thriving economies like China, but can also lead to inflation, raising operational costs.
Exchange rate fluctuations impact profitability, making products more expensive in certain
markets. Unemployment rates affect the customer base, with job security enabling purchasing
power. Interest rate fluctuations affect Apple's borrowing costs, directly influencing
profitability. Consumer spending, vital for economic growth, directly impacts Apple's sales. A
slowdown in consumer expenditure negatively affects the company's financial performance,
highlighting the intricate connection between consumer behaviour and Apple's bottom line.

4
Social

Apple faces evolving global demographics as urban populations rise, particularly in China
and India, driving demand for its products. Changing consumer preferences for ethical and
sustainable products challenge Apple, prompting reductions in conflict minerals usage to
align with ethical sourcing practices. Nationalism-related trade tensions, exemplified by US
tariffs on Chinese goods, impact Apple's pricing and manufacturing strategies, leading to
investment in US facilities. Increasing awareness of mental health concerns linked to
technology usage necessitates Apple's introduction of features like Screen Time, prioritising
user well-being and fostering a healthier digital experience, showcasing the company's
commitment to user welfare.

Technological

Apple prioritises technological innovation, pioneering touchscreen smartphones and

advancing with products like Apple Watch and AirPods to maintain a competitive edge. The
growing cybersecurity threat prompts Apple to invest in robust measures, fortifying its
infrastructure and educating customers on best practices (McGee, 2023). Embracing
emerging technologies, Apple invests in artificial intelligence, evident in products like Siri
and Face ID. However, heightened technology regulations, exemplified by EU legislation
mandating user consent for data collection, pose challenges. Apple adapts its privacy policies
to comply, showcasing its commitment to compliance amid evolving regulatory landscapes
while ensuring innovation and customer data protection.

Legal

Apple prioritises safeguarding its intellectual property and defending patents and trademarks
through legal action against infringing competitors (Brittain, 2023). However, facing legal
challenges over alleged infringements underscores the complexity of protecting innovations
in a competitive market. Complying with stringent data privacy regulations is crucial,
exemplified by the European Union's mandate for user consent (Mikkelsen, Scheurle, &
Strandell-Jansson, 2023). Apple swiftly adjusted its privacy policies to align with the law,
demonstrating its commitment to evolving data privacy standards. Ongoing legal battles,
including a class-action lawsuit disputing planned obsolescence, pose potential repercussions
for Apple's business and reputation. Adapting to tightening data protection laws, particularly
in the EU, necessitates constant policy revisions, showcasing Apple's dedication to adapting
to legal changes while safeguarding user privacy.

5
Environmental

Apple is prioritising environmental sustainability to meet consumer demands. The company

is striving to transition to 100% renewable energy by 2030, reduce its carbon footprint, and
incorporate recycled materials into its products (Apple, 2023). Addressing electronic waste,
Apple has partnered with organisations for responsible recycling and introduced trade-in
programmes for eco-friendly disposal. Additionally, Apple is committed to a 75% reduction
in carbon emissions by 2030, implementing energy-efficient practices. To tackle water
scarcity, the company uses water judiciously and installs water-efficient fixtures in its
facilities, demonstrating its dedication to responsible environmental practices.

Industry Environment

Apple engages within an oligopolistic market structure, where its heterogeneous products
possess the ability to regulate both the supply and demand of its products (Dario Maradin,
Malnar, & Đipalo, 2022). This is accomplished through the strategic application of the
scarcity principle, a dynamic that would be challenging to uphold within a more competitive
market framework (Soliman, 2017). The deliberate limitation of product supply serves to
enhance the perceived value of Apple's offerings in the eyes of the consumer, a phenomenon
less likely to occur in a market characterised by heightened competition. In the absence of
robust competitive forces within Apple's oligopolistic domain, the company can effectively
shape consumer decision-making, fostering a perception of heightened product value.

This strategic manoeuvring contributes to an augmented demand for Apple products, as

consumer perceptions drive purchases even in response to price fluctuations. Additionally,
Apple leverages the scarcity principle as a potent advertising technique, creating a sense of
anticipation among consumers eagerly awaiting product releases. This approach not only
bolsters brand loyalty but also stimulates demand for the product well before its official
launch (Ratra, 2023). The resultant surge in product sales translates into increased
profitability for the company.

6
Porter’s Five Forces

Porter's Five Forces as devised by (Porter, 2008) constitutes a framework designed to identify
and assess the five distinct competitive forces influencing and moulding every industry. This
model serves the purpose of pinpointing the inherent strengths and weaknesses within an
industry, thereby facilitating a comprehensive understanding of its structural dynamics. The
frequent application of the Five Forces analysis proves instrumental in unravelling the
intricate framework of an industry, playing a pivotal role in the formulation of effective
corporate strategies.

Threat of New Entrants Low

The prospect of new entrants in the technology industry remains relatively modest,
particularly for a market frontrunner such as Apple. Substantial capital investments, robust
brand loyalty, economies of scale, and substantial research and development (R&D)
expenditures of $29.92 billion (Statista, 2023), collectively function as formidable barriers to
entry in this sector. Although new firms can venture into the market, contending with
established giants like Apple proves challenging. Apple, with its extensive customer base,
widespread distribution networks, and cutting-edge technology, establishes a formidable
presence that makes competition a formidable task for newcomers.

Bargaining Power of Suppliers Moderate

Given Apple's dependency on multiple vendors for vital components and manufacturing
processes, its negotiating leverage with suppliers is somewhat limited. The substantial
demand for parts, driven by Apple's vast operations, does provide a degree of negotiation
power versus its suppliers. Nevertheless, suppliers may exert bargaining influence,
particularly if specific components, like OLED displays or microprocessors, face scarcity.
Apple's persistent efforts to diversify its supply chain and invest in internal component
development contribute to mitigating the negotiating strength of its suppliers (McGee, 2023).

Bargaining Power of Buyer Moderate

The bargaining advantage of Apple's consumers is relatively constrained. Apple caters to a

diverse clientele, comprising individual consumers and businesses. The appeal of Apple's

7
products stems from their robust brand loyalty, innovative product range, and unique user
experience. However, the existence of more affordable alternatives and the growing
population of tech-savvy consumers contribute to an increased negotiating strength for
purchasers. In response to this dynamic, Apple prioritises the creation of an exceptional user
experience, offers value-added services, and sustains a high level of customer satisfaction to
counterbalance these factors.

Threat of Substitute Products or Services High

Apple confronts a substantial risk of alternative products. Consumers have alternatives from
companies such as Samsung, Huawei, and Xiaomi, offering comparable functionality at
varying price points. However, technological advancements may result in the obsolescence of
older products. Notably, the proliferation of tablets and smartphones has significantly
impacted the sales of laptops (Plunkett-Research, 2018). To maintain competitiveness, Apple
must consistently invest in research and development (R&D), differentiate its products, and
uphold robust brand loyalty.

Competitive Rivalry High

Intense competition characterises the technology sector, especially within the smartphone and
personal computing segments. Apple faces persistent challenges from key competitors,
namely Samsung, Huawei, and Xiaomi, who consistently introduce new products to contest
Apple's dominance. These rivals possess substantial research and development (R&D)
capabilities, offering a range of devices across various price points to appeal to a diverse
audience. To sustain its competitive advantage, Apple must continually differentiate its
products, bolster brand loyalty, and expand its global presence.

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

Apple enjoys strong brand loyalty and maintains a reputation for innovative products.
Operating in an oligopolistic market, Apple has significant control over supply and demand
dynamics, allowing strategic manipulation through the scarcity principle. Apple's diversified
product portfolio, including iPhones, iPads, MacBooks, Apple-TV and wearables, contributes
to its market resilience.

8
Weaknesses

Apple's dependency on multiple vendors for components poses a vulnerability, and

negotiations with suppliers are somewhat constrained. Intense competition, especially from
rivals like Samsung, Huawei, and Xiaomi, challenges Apple's market dominance, and the
high pricing of its products may lead to substitution.

Opportunities

Apple can leverage the increasing urban populations in emerging markets like China and
India to expand its market reach. The rising demand for ethical and sustainable products
represents an opportunity for Apple to align with consumer preferences by prioritising
environmental sustainability.

Threats

Changes in US, European and Irish tax laws, political instability, and evolving regulations
pose risks to Apple's operations. Increasing regulations, such as those regarding data privacy,
may challenge Apple's technological innovations. The technology sector's high
competitiveness, coupled with the threat of substitute products, poses challenges to Apple's
market share.

Expansion Trajectory

Apple intends to launch a new subscription-based health service in the upcoming year, along
with the integration of a blood pressure sensor and a sleep apnea detection system in the
Apple Watch (Jowitt, 2023).

While recent discussions have not revealed any fresh developments concerning an Apple car,
there are indications that Apple is actively expanding its team with a mandate to create what
could potentially be the company's venture into smart cars.

Notably, the term "electric car" has not been explicitly used. It is implicit that for Apple to
remain competitive, any envisioned car would need to be electric. Nevertheless, this is
perceived as a structural consideration rather than a distinctive categorisation (Bajarin, 2023).

9
BCG Matrix Analysis

Stars

Apple's iPhone and MacBook Pro are Stars in the BCG Matrix, with high market share and
growth in rapidly evolving markets. The iPhone is a flagship product with cutting-edge
technology and consistent demand, while the MacBook Pro captures the premium laptop
market with its sleek design and robust performance.

Cash Cows

The iPad and MacBook Air are Cash Cows, with mature markets and stable market share,
generating reliable and consistent revenue for Apple. The iPad is a particularly strong
performer in the tablet market.

Question Marks

The Apple Watch and AirPods are Question Marks, operating in dynamic markets with
significant growth potential but facing intense competition. The wearables market is
expanding rapidly, and Apple's success in these segments will depend on its ability to sustain
and enhance its market share.

Dogs

It is challenging to identify any products in Apple's current portfolio that fit the traditional
definition of a "Dog." However, some older-generation products or those facing declining
demand may fall into this category, such as the iPod. Apple's focus on innovation and product
evolution helps to minimise the presence of Dogs in its lineup.

The BCG Matrix analysis highlights the need for Apple to continue investing in innovation
and differentiation to maintain its competitive edge in the technology market. While the
iPhone remains a dominant Star, Apple should also prioritise expanding the wearables market
and ensuring that the iPad and MacBook Air maintain their Cash Cow status through ongoing
innovation and adaptation.

10
Price & Service Differentiation

Branding

The company strategically presents itself as a brand synonymous with high-end and premium
offerings in the market. This is achieved through a deliberate promotion strategy coupled
with premium pricing tactics applied to flagship products like the MacBook and iPhone
smartphones. It's noteworthy that the company is renowned for introducing products with
higher price points compared to alternatives in the market. However, notwithstanding this
pricing approach, possessing the company's products conveys a certain level of social status.

Minimalist Design

An integral aspect of Apple's differentiation strategy involves its design philosophy,

consistently applied across its array of products, including personal computers, smartphones,
various consumer electronic devices, operating systems, and software applications.
Embedded within its marketing mix and specific product strategy is the deliberate
incorporation of minimalism and elegance in design. This choice aims to foster a clear and
cohesive user experience while maintaining a premium brand image, all without
compromising on functionalities.

Product Ecosystem

Another distinguishing factor setting Apple apart from its competitors is its renowned Apple
Ecosystem. The company has established a closed product ecosystem by exercising
comprehensive control over both hardware specifications and software application
requirements. While this particular product strategy might not be suitable for other firms,
Apple has leveraged its ecosystem by creating products that seamlessly complement each
other. Consequently, owning multiple Apple products aligns logically with consumers.

Customer Experience

In “The Apple Experience” by (Gallo, 2012). It states Apple's customer engagement strategy
can be summarised by the following. A warm and personalised welcome sets the tone for a
positive experience. This approach is evident globally as Apple Store staff warmly greet
customers, guiding them or connecting them with the right department. Customer satisfaction
is a priority, whether in-store or during remote interactions. The goal is to leave a lasting

11
impression from the initial encounter. Employees inquire politely to comprehend customer
needs, utilising an extensive array of products and features at Apple Stores. This customer-
centric approach involves asking questions to understand requirements and reserving detailed
product information for later interactions. Apple's non-commissioned sales floor emphasises
assistance and education, offering immediate solutions and fostering loyalty. For founders
without a physical storefront, educational content on platforms like YouTube engages
customers over time. Active listening is paramount, addressing customer concerns with
tailored product pitches. The experience concludes with a warm farewell and an invitation to
return, creating a positive and memorable exit, even for non-purchasers.

Value Chain

Figure 1 Apple's Value Chain

Apple's intricate supply chain involves over 3 million individuals employed by numerous
businesses across 52 countries. The company's purchase commitments extend up to 150 days,
showcasing its strategic planning in managing requirements. Tim Cook, an adept supply
chain professional, was brought in by Steve Jobs in 1998 to address challenges threatening
Apple's solvency. Under Cook's stewardship, significant changes were implemented,
including a reduction in the number of suppliers, a halving of warehouses, and the
establishment of relationships with contract manufacturers. Cook successfully diminished
Apple's inventory turnover from one month to a remarkable 2-5 days. Subsequently, as CEO
from 2011, Cook further streamlined the supplier base (Dudovskiy, 2023).

12
These transformative initiatives have positioned Apple's supply chain practices as a
benchmark for global business efficiency. The key sources of value in Apple's inbound
logistics stem from economies of scale due to its expansive operations and strategic
relationships with suppliers. Apple wields substantial bargaining power in its dealings with
suppliers, securing cost advantages in resource procurement. The company's supply chain
practices exemplify efficiency and strategic acumen, making it a notable model for the
industry (Dudovskiy, 2023).

Inbound Logistics

Apple, with its expansive supply chain, strategically procures raw materials from a diverse
array of sources. The top 200 suppliers, encompassing component providers and others,
constitute approximately 97% of its material, manufacturing, and assembly procurement
expenditure in 2016. Key suppliers, such as 3M and Foxconn, play pivotal roles in providing
raw materials. Apple's substantial financial influence bestows negotiating leverage upon the
company. To maintain quality standards, stringent requirements are set for suppliers, ensuring
that products meet the highest benchmarks. Employing advanced methodologies, Apple
reduces storage needs and expedites the procurement process (Insights, 2023).

Operations

Apple's global manufacturing network spans various countries, with a predominant share of
assembly activities occurring in China, as indicated by the "Made in China" label on many
products. Negotiations with the Indian government suggest production expansion in that
region (Das & Mehta, 2023). While a significant portion of assembly transpires in China,
labour cost advantages in Asian countries contribute to Apple's overall cost efficiency. The
company, committed to environmental responsibility, has curtailed the use of hazardous
chemicals and increasingly integrates recyclable materials into its production processes.
Outsourcing production enables Apple to manage production costs effectively (Insights,
2023).

Outbound Logistics

Apple boasts a vast distribution network employing both direct and indirect channels. The
distribution strategy encompasses retail outlets, online platforms, and Apple's proprietary
stores. Continuous enhancements in the distribution route and an expansion of branded
outlets underscore Apple's commitment to efficient product dissemination. In tandem, the

13
company prioritises environmentally conscious practices, emphasising green packaging and
waste reduction throughout its outbound logistics processes (Insights, 2023).

This comprehensive approach across inbound, operations, and outbound logistics elucidates
Apple's strategic and environmentally mindful supply chain management.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the amalgamation of these analytical frameworks offers a panoramic view of

Apple Inc.'s strategic crusade. The company's resilience in the face of external challenges,
strategic adaptation to market dynamics, and sustained commitment to innovation underscore
its enduring global influence. As Apple navigates future expansions, the mixture of these
analyses serves as a compass, guiding stakeholders through the multifaceted landscape of one
of the world's foremost technology giants.

14
 Bibliography

Acres, T. (2020). iOS 13: Why new iPhone update is forcing apps to ask for Bluetooth
permissions. Sky News.

Apple. (2023, October 27). Apple charges forward to 2030 carbon neutral goal. Retrieved
from Apple Newsroom: https://www.apple.com/ie/newsroom/2021/10/apple-charges-
forward-to-2030-carbon-neutral-goal-adding-9-gigawatts-of-clean-power-and-
doubling-supplier-commitments/

Bajarin, T. (2023). Is The Apple Car A Computer On Wheels? Forbes.

Balasubramanian, S. (2022). Apple’s Latest Report Details Its Bold Vision For Healthcare.
Forbes.

Brennan, J., & O’Leary, N. (2023). The €13bn Apple Tax case is entering its final chapter.
The Times.

Brittain, B. (2023). Apple wins U.S. appeal over patents in $502 mln VirnetX verdict.
Reuters.

Dario Maradin, Malnar, A., & Đipalo, E. (2022). The market structure of the smartphone
operating. University of Rijeka, Faculty of Economics and Business.

Das, K. N., & Mehta, T. (2023). India sees Apple nearly tripling investment, exports in
coming years. Reuters.

Dudovskiy, J. (2023). Apple Value Chain Analysis. Business Research Methdology .

Gallo, C. ( 2012). Apple Experience. McGraw-Hill Publishing.

Graham, C., & O’Rourke, B. K. (2021). New Discourse & Power. Routledge.

Heisler, A. (2023, October 15). Apple iOS 14 Privacy Update: Impact on Advertisers.
Retrieved from Digtal Third Coast: https://www.digitalthirdcoast.com/blog/ios-14-
consumer-privacy-update#:~:text=The%20New%20iOS%2014%20Consumer,opt
%2Dout%20of%20ad%20tracking.

Insights, B. (2023, November 1). Apple’s Value Chain Analysis. Retrieved from Business
Strategy Insights: https://www.bstrategyinsights.com/apples-value-chain-analysis/

15
Jowitt, T. (2023, October 31). Apple Watch To Include Blood Pressure, Sleep Apnoea
Detection – Report. Retrieved from Silicon Tecnology Powering Business:
https://www.silicon.co.uk/e-innovation/wearable/apple-watch-to-include-blood-
pressure-sleep-apnoea-detection-report-536978

McGee, P. (2023). How Apple tied its fortunes to China. Financial Times.

Meyer, C., & Schwager, A. (2007). Understanding customer experience. Harvard business
review, 116.

Mikkelsen, D., Scheurle, S., & Strandell-Jansson, M. (2023, October 27). The EU digital
strategy: The impact of data privacy on global business. Retrieved from McKinsey &
Company: https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/risk-and-resilience/our-insights/
the-eu-digital-strategy-the-impact-of-data-privacy-on-global-business

Plunkett-Research. (2018). Tablets and Smartphones Cause Decline in PC and Laptop

Computer Market. Plunkett Research.

Porter, M. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. , 86(1), p. Harvard
business review, 78.

Ratra, G. (2023, October 28). The Apple Phenomenon - How Consumer Behaviour Shapes
Brand Loyalty. Retrieved from Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/case-study-
apple-phenomenon-how-consumer-behaviour-shapes-ratra/

Soliman, M. (2017). The impact of scarcity message on impulsive purchase intention among
smartphone shoppers (Doctoral dissertation, Trident University International).
Proquest, 176.

Statista. (2023, October 28). Apple Inc's expenditure on research and development from fiscal
year 2007 to 2023. Retrieved from Statista:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/273006/apple-expenses-for-research-and-
development/

16