You are on page 1of 7

Anaesthesia 2012 doi:10.1111/j.1365-2044.2012.07102.

Original Article
A randomised controlled trial comparing rocuronium priming,
magnesium pre-treatment and a combination of the two methods*
M. H. Kim,1 A. Y. Oh,2 Y. T. Jeon,3 J. W. Hwang3 and S. H. Do4

1 Full-time Instructor, 2 Assistant Professor, 3 Associate Professor, 4 Professor, Department of Anesthesiology and Pain
Medicine, Seoul National University, Bundang Hospital, South Korea

Summary
We investigated whether magnesium sulphate combined with rocuronium priming shortens the onset of neuromuscular
blockade, compared with these methods used alone. Ninety-two patients scheduled for general anaesthesia
were randomly allocated to one of four groups: controls were given 0.6 mg.kg)1 rocuronium; patients in the prime
group were given 0.06 mg.kg)1 rocuronium three minutes before a further dose of 0.54 mg.kg)1 rocuronium; patients in
the magnesium group were given an infusion of 50 mg.kg)1 magnesium sulphate before rocuronium and patients in the
magnesium and prime group were given both the magnesium sulphate and the priming dose of rocuronium. Tracheal
intubation was attempted 40 s after the rocuronium injection. The time to onset of neuromuscular blockade was the
primary outcome; duration of blockade and tracheal intubating conditions were also measured. The group allocation and
study drugs were coded and concealed until statistical analyses were completed. The magnesium and prime group had
the shortest mean (SD) onset time (55 (16) s; p < 0.001), and best tracheal intubating conditions (p < 0.05). No
statistical difference was found for the duration of blockade. As for adverse events, a burning or heat sensation was
reported in eight (35%) and six (26%) patients in the magnesium and magnesium and prime groups, respectively. The
combination of magnesium sulphate and rocuronium priming accelerated the onset or neuromuscular blockade and
improved rapid-sequence intubating conditions, compared with either magnesium sulphate or priming used alone.
. ..............................................................................................................................................................
Correspondence to: Dr S. H. Do
Email: shdo@snu.ac.kr
*Presented in part at the Annual Scientific Meeting of the Korean Society of Anesthesiologists, Seoul, South Korea,
November 2011.
Accepted: 27 January 2012

Rapid-sequence intubation and resistance to neuromus- cords to open fully, failed tracheal intubation [3], and
cular blocking drugs are clinical situations in which poor intubating conditions [4], which can cause
producing sufficient neuromuscular blockade for tra- laryngeal injury, vocal cord morbidity and postoperative
cheal intubation may be difficult [1, 2]. In such cases, the hoarseness [5].
depth of neuromuscular block at the time of tracheal Suxamethonium is generally considered to be the
intubation can be inadequate, because insufficient time drug of choice when rapid neuromuscular block is
has been allowed for the drugs to take effect. Inadequate required [6]. However, it is associated with a number of
neuromuscular blockade may lead to failure of the vocal serious complications and contraindications, leading to

Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland 1


Anaesthesia 2012 Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium

various attempts to accelerate the onset of available non- to one of four parallel groups using opaque sealed
depolarising neuromuscular blocking drugs (NBDs) [6]. envelopes: control; prime; magnesium; and magnesium
In this regard, the use of a large dose of rocuronium has and prime. The group allocation and names were coded
been suggested [6], but rocuronium may have a ceiling and concealed until completion of the statistical analysis.
effect for onset time [1]. Increasing the dose of Magnesium, and magnesium and prime groups received
rocuronium beyond a particular amount does not an intravenous infusion of 50 mg.kg)1 magnesium
always guarantee a shortened onset time [1], and it sulphate over 10 min. Control and prime groups were
markedly prolongs the duration of action [1, 6]. Opioids given the same volume of 0.9% saline. Neuromuscular
can be used to improve tracheal intubating conditions monitoring, adhering to the neuromuscular research
without increasing the NDMR dose, thus avoiding consensus [14], was performed with TOF-Watch SX
delayed recovery; however, this may be associated with (Organon Ltd., Dublin, Ireland) after 0.04 mg.kg)1
a higher incidence of failed tracheal intubation [6]. midazolam was administered intravenously. Two pae-
Injecting a small priming dose of NDMR before diatric surface electrodes were attached 3–6 cm apart
administration of the full intubation dose has been along the ulnar nerve on one forearm without a blood
shown to speed up onset [7] without delaying recovery pressure cuff or intravenous cannula on this side. A
[8]. Despite concerns for potential muscle weakness hand adapter (Organon) was placed on the thumb, and
produced by such a priming dose, this has been the other fingers and forearm were immobilised. Single
investigated in a number of recent studies [7, 9–12]. twitches (0.1 Hz, stimulus duration of 200 ls, square
Another method is the use of magnesium sulphate, wave) were performed every 10 s, after calibration (with
which can accelerate the onset of neuromuscular implanted mode 2) and confirmation of stable twitches
blockade produced by rocuronium; the mechanism is (< 5% deviation, for 2 min).
thought to be mainly by decreasing the presynaptic Subsequently, 0.06 mg.kg)1 rocuronium (prime,
release of acetylcholine [13]. and magnesium and prime groups) or the same volume
In the present study, we combined magnesium of 0.9% saline (control and magnesium groups) was
sulphate and a priming technique to investigate whether administered. Propofol (2 mg.kg)1), remifentanil
this could further accelerate the onset of neuromuscular (1 lg.kg)1) [15], and rocuronium (0.6 mg.kg)1 (mag-
blockade during rapid-sequence intubation. Secondary nesium and control groups) or 0.54 mg.kg)1, diluted in
outcomes included duration of neuromuscular blockade 0.9% saline to a volume equal to 0.6 mg.kg)1 rocuro-
and tracheal intubating conditions. nium (prime, and magnesium and prime groups)) were
injected in rapid succession, 170 s after the priming
Methods dose.
This double-blind randomised controlled study was The time from injection of rocuronium (0.6 or
approved by the Institutional Review Board of Seoul 0.54 mg.kg)1) to 95% depression of the single twitch
National University Bundang Hospital. Written in- (onset time) and return of adequate neuromuscular
formed consent was obtained from all participating transmission as measured by train-of-four (TOF) equal
patients; inclusion criteria were: age 18–65 years; ASA to two (duration of neuromuscular blockade) were
physical status 1–2; body mass index 18.5–24.9 kg.m)2; measured. The stimulation mode was changed to TOF
Mallampati grade 1–2; and elective surgery under (2 Hz, stimulus duration of 200 ls, square wave, 15-s
general anaesthesia (Fig. 1). Patients with neuromuscu- intervals) after measuring the onset time. Laryngoscopy
lar disease, renal or hepatic insufficiency, allergy to the for tracheal intubation was commenced 40 s after the
study drugs, drugs that might influence neuromuscular injection of rocuronium, intubation was completed
function, breast-feeding or pregnancy, and an antici- within 20 s, and the intubation score (Appendix) [14]
pated difficult airway were excluded. was assessed by an experienced anaesthetist who was
After connecting routine monitoring, including blinded to the study drugs. If tracheal intubation was not
electrocardiography, pulse oximetry, and non-invasive successfully completed within 20 s (i.e. 60 s after the
blood pressure, patients were allocated in equal numbers rocuronium), it was recorded as a failed attempt. After

2 Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland


Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium Anaesthesia 2012

Figure 1 Flow chart for enrolment and allocation.

intubation, total intravenous anaesthesia was maintained 23 patients in each group, using a two-sided test with
with a target-controlled infusion of propofol and a = 0.05 and b = 0.2, allowing for 10% drop-outs.
remifentanil, titrated to maintain a bispectral index The distributions of all data were assessed with the
between 40 and 60, with < 20% variation in baseline Kolmogorov–Smirnov test; ANOVA (Welch’s ANOVA
mean arterial pressure and heart rate. in case of different variances) with a Bonferroni post-
Patient temperature was maintained at > 35 C hoc comparison or Kruskal–Wallis test (for skewed
measured using a rectal probe and > 32 C measured by data) was used for comparison of onset and duration of
a skin probe at the hypothenar eminence. Controlled neuromuscular blockade. The chi-squared or Fisher’s
ventilation with 50% oxygen in air was used to maintain exact test was used for comparing tracheal intubating
the end-tidal CO2 at 4.7–5.3 kPa. conditions. All statistical analyses were performed using
Enrolment of patients, preparation of opaque sealed PASW Statistics 17, release version 17.0.2 (SPSS, Inc.,
envelopes, preparation and administration of drugs, and Chicago IL, USA).
collection and analysis of data were performed by
doctors, nurses, and research assistants who were Results
blinded to the study drugs. All datasets were normally distributed. There were no
Sample size calculation was based on a previous differences in mean arterial blood pressure or heart rate
study in which mean (SD) onset time using 0.6 mg.kg)1 between the groups at baseline or at the time of
rocuronium was 105.4 (29.9) s with the priming tech- rocuronium injection (Table 1).
nique [7] and 77 (18) s with magnesium sulphate pre- The onset time was shortest in the magnesium and
treatment [13]. We decided to look for a 20% reduction prime group (p < 0.001) (Table 2). No significant dif-
in onset time in the magnesium and prime group ference was observed for duration of neuromuscular
compared with both magnesium and prime groups blockade between the groups (p = 0.054) (Table 2). The
respectively. We calculated that we would therefore need absolute value of the SD for the onset time was smallest

Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland 3


Anaesthesia 2012 Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium

Table 1 Patients’ characteristics and haemodynamic data in patients randomly allocated to rocuronium alone (Control),
priming with rocuronium, magnesium pre-treatment and a combination of rocuronium priming and magnesium. Data
are mean (SD) or number (proportion).

Control Prime Magnesium Magnesium and prime


(n = 23) (n = 23) (n = 23) (n = 23)
Age; years 39 (12) 46 (13) 46 (12) 41 (13)
Men 9 (39%) 8 (35%) 10 (43%) 10 (43%)
Weight; kg 58 (10) 59 (6) 56 (8) 61 (9)
Height; cm 163 (8) 163 (7) 160 (7) 164 (8)
BMI; kg.m)2 21.6 (2.0) 22.0 (1.4) 22.0 (2.3) 22.6 (1.9)
ASA status 1 or 2 22 (96%) 20 (87%) 21 (91%) 20 (87%)
MAP at baseline 84 (11) 82 (10) 85 (10) 84 (9)
HR at baseline 74 (11) 71 (12) 74 (10) 75 (8)
MAP at injection of rocuronium 67 (10) 70 (8) 70 (8) 70 (8)
HR at injection of rocuronium 72 (11) 67 (11) 72 (9) 70 (9)

BMI, body mass index; MAP, mean arterial blood pressure; HR, heart rate.

Table 2 Time until onset and duration of neuromuscular blockade after administration of rocuronium (total dose
0.6 mg.kg)1) in patients randomly allocated to rocuronium alone (Control), priming with rocuronium, magnesium pre-
treatment and a combination of rocuronium priming and magnesium. Data are mean (SD).

Control Prime Magnesium Magnesium and prime


(n = 23) (n = 23) (n = 23) (n = 23)
Onset; s 150 (56)* 125 (47)* 94 (25)** 56 (16)
Duration; min 33 (12) 39 (18) 42 (12) 43 (10)

*p < 0.001 vs. magnesium and prime group; **p < 0.01 vs. magnesium and prime group.

in the magnesium and prime group, so we performed


Levene’s test to assess the homogeneity of variance
between the magnesium (which showed the second
smallest SD value) and the magnesium and prime
groups. The variance between the two groups was
heterogeneous (p = 0.038). Tracheal intubation was
successful within 60 s in all subjects. The intubating
conditions were best in the magnesium and prime group
(Fig. 2).
A burning or heat sensation was reported in eight
(35%) and six (26%) patients during magnesium
sulphate infusion, respectively, and mild pain at the
cannula site was noted in two (9%) and three (13%)
patients in the magnesium, and the magnesium and
prime groups, respectively. This was reported as toler-
able in each instance and did not require treatment or Figure 2 Tracheal intubating conditions in patients
randomly allocated to rocuronium alone (Control),
interruption of the magnesium sulphate infusion. No
priming with rocuronium, magnesium pre-treatment
adverse events such as difficulty with breathing or and a combination of rocuronium priming and
aspiration of gastric contents were observed after magnesium, evaluated as excellent ( ), good ( ), and
injection of the rocuronium priming dose. poor ( ).

4 Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland


Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium Anaesthesia 2012

Discussion a more predictable onset than with magnesium sulphate


The onset of neuromuscular blockade was shortened alone.
compared to control by 17%, 37%, and 63% with We set the interval from rocuronium injection until
priming, magnesium sulphate, and the combination of laryngoscopic manipulation at 40 s in this study to
magnesium sulphate plus priming respectively, consis- minimise the apnoeic period during rapid-sequence
tent with previous reports (19% and 36% decreases with tracheal intubation. This was at the expense of sufficient
priming [16] and magnesium sulphate [13], respec- time for the induction agents to take effect, which is
tively). In previous studies, suxamethonium (1 mg.kg)1) likely to entail poor intubating conditions. Intubating
[16] and high-dose rocuronium (1.2 mg.kg)1) [17] had conditions can be influenced by not only the neuro-
40% and 39% faster onset times, respectively, compared muscular block but also various other factors including
with a standard dose of rocuronium (0.6 mg.kg)1). the choice of induction agent [6]. Hence, we chose
Therefore, it is conceivable that the magnesium and propofol and remifentanil, which provide superior
priming combination method may result in faster rapid-sequence intubating conditions compared with
neuromuscular block than that achieved with suxame- many other induction agents [6, 15]. Nevertheless,
thonium, although we have not studied this. clinically unacceptable intubating conditions were found
Facilitated neuromuscular blockade with magne- in the three other groups except for the magnesium and
sium involves the following mechanisms: (1) decreased prime group. In contrast, the intubating conditions in all
pre-junctional release of acetylcholine via the inhibition patients in the magnesium and prime group were
of voltage-dependent calcium channels [18]; (2) reduced clinically acceptable (good to excellent), probably due to
sensitivity of the endplate to acetylcholine; and (3) the rapid neuromuscular block.
attenuated direct excitability of muscle fibres, presum- Duration of neuromuscular blockade in our study
ably by altering the electrical threshold of the muscle increased by 27% and 30% in the magnesium, and
membrane [18]. The concept behind the priming magnesium and prime groups, respectively; however, the
technique is that the initial sub-paralysing dose of increases were not statistically different between the
NDMR occupies the acetylcholine receptors, which groups, possibly due to group size. In a previous study,
decreases the time that the remaining receptors can be magnesium sulphate prolonged duration of neuromus-
occupied by the subsequent paralysing dose, causing cular blockade by 27–34% [13]. In contrast, magnesium
profound neuromuscular blockade [19]. The specific sulphate decreases the amount of rocuronium required
sites or stages at which neuromuscular transmission is to maintain adequate neuromuscular blockade during
impaired seem to differ between magnesium and surgery [20, 21], which may offset the possible prolon-
priming. Therefore, the number of phases of neuromus- gation of neuromuscular blockade. In addition, the time
cular transmission that are inhibited presumably from skin closure to tracheal extubation was not
increase with the combination of magnesium and delayed, even though magnesium sulphate was infused
priming, which may cause the synergistic acceleration continuously throughout surgery after the bolus
of the effects of rocuronium. (50 mg.kg)1) [20]. Thus, the duration of neuromuscular
Magnesium sulphate is associated with a lower blockade of 43 min in the magnesium and prime group
variance for rocuronium onset time compared with that is not likely to have substantially greater clinical
in controls [13]. In our study, the absolute value of the implications than the 33 min duration in the control
SD for the onset time was consistently smaller in the group.
magnesium group than in the controls. The magnesium Rocuronium (1.6 mg.kg)1) is required to achieve
and prime group showed significantly smaller SD and intubating conditions equivalent to the magnesium and
variance compared with those in the magnesium group. prime group using high-dose rocuronium and opioids
Hence, the magnesium sulphate ⁄ priming combination [22], and its duration is extended by 2.5 times compared
not only facilitated the onset of neuromuscular blockade to 0.8 mg.kg)1 rocuronium [22]. Therefore, the magne-
but also reduced the variability of onset time, providing sium sulphate ⁄ priming combination would seem to be

Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland 5


Anaesthesia 2012 Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium

better than high-dose rocuronium in terms of faster 3. Kovacs G, Law JA, Ross J, et al. Acute airway management in the
emergency department by non-anesthesiologists. Canadian
recovery from neuromuscular block. Journal of Anesthesia 2004; 51: 174–80.
The onset time of 0.6 mg.kg)1 rocuronium in this 4. Baillard C, Adnet F, Borron S, et al. Tracheal intubation in routine
study (150 s) was longer than that reported (90 s) in a practice with and without muscular relaxation: an observational
study. European Journal of Anaesthesiology 2005; 22: 672–7.
previous study [16]. Onset time is influenced by various 5. Mencke T, Echternach M, Kleinschmidt S, et al. Laryngeal
factors, including body mass index, anaesthetic agents, morbidity and quality of tracheal intubation. Anesthesiology
2003; 98: 1049–56.
modes or devices of nerve stimulation, and the defini- 6. El-Orbany M, Connolly LA. Rapid sequence induction and
tion of onset time [14]; thus, results from different intubation: current controversy. Anesthesia and Analgesia
protocols cannot be directly compared. Consequently, 2010; 110: 1318–25.
7. Schmidt J, Irouschek A, Muenster T, Hemmerling TM, Albrecht S.
variable rocuronium (0.6 mg.kg)1) onset times of 178– A priming technique accelerates onset of neuromuscular block-
226 s have been reported [2, 23–25]. ade at the laryngeal adductor muscles. Canadian Journal of
Anesthesia 2005; 52: 50–4.
Magnesium sulphate (50–60 mg.kg)1) was not asso- 8. Griffith KE, Joshi GP, Whitman PF, Garg SA. Priming with
ciated with serious complications in the present or rocuronium accelerates the onset of neuromuscular blockade.
previous studies [13, 26]. The dose used was less than that Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 1997; 9: 204–7.
9. Bock M, Haselmann L, Bottiger BW, Motsch J. Priming with
used for the treatment of pre-eclampsia [21]. Priming rocuronium accelerates neuromuscular block in children: a
with 0.06 mg.kg)1 rocuronium did not result in critical prospective randomized study. Canadian Journal of Anesthesia
2007; 54: 538–43.
complications such as hypoxia, respiratory difficulty, or 10. Leykin Y, Dalsasso M, Setti T, Pellis T. The effects of low-dose
aspiration in previous studies either [9, 11]. No signif- ephedrine on intubating conditions following low-dose priming
icant reduction in evoked laryngeal electromyography is with cisatracurium. Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 2010; 22: 425–
31.
observed during the priming period [7]. However, 11. Leykin Y, Pellis T, Lucca M, Gullo A. Effects of ephedrine on
surveillance should be conducted for potential compli- intubating conditions following priming with rocuronium. Acta
Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 2005; 49: 792–7.
cations related to magnesium sulphate and priming. 12. Schmidt J, Albrecht S, Petterich N, Fechner J, Klein P, Irouschek A.
A limitation of this study is that the sample size may Priming technique with cisatracurium Onset time at the
have been too small to detect a difference in the duration laryngeal muscles. Anaesthesist 2007; 56: 992–1000.
13. Czarnetzki C, Lysakowski C, Elia N, Tramer M. Time course of
of neuromuscular blockade, because the sample size was rocuronium induced neuromuscular block after pre-treatment
calculated for the primary outcome. with magnesium sulphate: a randomised study. Acta Anaes-
thesiologica Scandinavica 2010; 54: 299–306.
In conclusion, pre-treatment with both magnesium 14. Fuchs Buder T, Claudius C, Skovgaard L, Eriksson L, Mirakhur R,
sulphate and a priming dose of rocuronium provided Viby Mogensen J. Good clinical research practice in pharmaco-
faster onset of neuromuscular blockade and superior dynamic studies of neuromuscular blocking agents II: the
Stockholm revision. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica
tracheal intubating conditions for rapid-sequence intu- 2007; 51: 789–808.
bation, compared with magnesium sulphate or priming 15. Kim JT, Shim JK, Kim SH, et al. Remifentanil vs. lignocaine for
attenuating the haemodynamic response during rapid sequence
alone. induction using propofol: double-blind randomised clinical trial.
Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 2007; 35: 20–3.
Acknowledgements 16. Naguib M. Different priming techniques, including mivacurium,
accelerate the onset of rocuronium. Canadian Journal of
This study was financially supported by a grant from the Anesthesia 1994; 41: 902–7.
Seoul National University Bundang Hospital Research 17. Magorian T, Flannery KB, Miller RD. Comparison of rocuronium,
succinylcholine, and vecuronium for rapid-sequence induction of
Fund. No competing interests declared. anesthesia in adult patients. Anesthesiology 1993; 79: 913–8.
18. Dube L, Granry JC. The therapeutic use of magnesium in
References anesthesiology, intensive care and emergency medicine: a
review. Canadian Journal of Anesthesia 2003; 50: 732–46.
1. Han TH, Kim HS, Bae JY, Kim KM, Martyn J. Neuromuscular
19. Schwarz S, Ilias W, Lackner F, Mayrhofer O, Foldes FF. Rapid
pharmacodynamics of rocuronium in patients with major burns.
tracheal intubation with vecuronium: the priming principle.
Anesthesia and Analgesia 2004; 99: 386–92.
Anesthesiology 1985; 62: 388–91.
2. Soltesz S, Mencke T, Stunz M, Diefenbach C, Ziegeler S, Molter G.
20. Ryu JH, Kang MH, Park KS, Do SH. Effects of magnesium sulphate
Attenuation of a rocuronium induced neuromuscular block in
on intraoperative anaesthetic requirements and postoperative
patients receiving prednisolone. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scan-
analgesia in gynaecology patients receiving total intravenous
dinavica 2009; 53: 443–8.
anaesthesia. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2008; 100: 397–403.

6 Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland


Kim et al. | Rocuronium priming versus magnesium Anaesthesia 2012

21. Herroeder S, Schonherr ME, De Hert SG, Hollmann MW. 25. Lee H, Kim K, Jeong J, Cheong M, Shim J. Comparison of the
Magnesium - essentials for anesthesiologists. Anesthesiology adductor pollicis, orbicularis oculi, and corrugator supercilii as
2011; 114: 971–93. indicators of adequacy of muscle relaxation for tracheal
22. Heier T, Caldwell JE. Rapid tracheal intubation with large-dose intubation. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2009; 102: 869–74.
rocuronium: a probability-based approach. Anesthesia and 26. Na HS, Lee JH, Hwang JY, et al. Effects of magnesium sulphate on
Analgesia 2000; 90: 175–9. intraoperative neuromuscular blocking agent requirements and
23. Topcuoglu PT, Uzun S, Canbay O, Pamuk G, Ozgen S. Ketamine, postoperative analgesia in children with cerebral palsy. British
but not priming, improves intubating conditions during a Journal of Anaesthesia 2010; 104: 344–50.
propofol-rocuronium induction. Canadian Journal of Anesthesia
2010; 57: 113–9.
24. Lee HJ, Kim KS, Yeon JT, Suh JK, Sung IH, Shin IC. Potency and
recovery characteristics of rocuronium mixed with sodium
bicarbonate. Anaesthesia 2010; 65: 899–903.

Appendix
Assessment of intubating conditions. Excellent, all qualities excellent; good, all qualities either excellent or good; poor, a
single quality assessed as poor [14].

Clinically acceptable Clinically unacceptable


Variable
evaluated Excellent Good Poor
Laryngoscopy Easy Fair Difficult
Jaw Relaxed Not fully relaxed Poor relaxation
Blade insertion No resistance Slight resistance Active resistance
Vocal cords Abducted Intermediate ⁄ moving Closed
Reaction to None One to two weak More than two movements for > 5 s
intubation movements for < 5 s

Anaesthesia ª 2012 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland 7

You might also like