Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1038/nri1687
PERSPECTIVES
Table 1 | A comparison of e-learning and conventional learning methods models are also resource intensive; to cover
basic and clinical immunology, several
Dimension e-learning Conventional learning faculty experts are required, each of whom
Audience Students can hail from several institutions Often restricted to students must repeat the process of designing and
worldwide; limited class size is preferable enrolled at one institution; limited delivering one or more courses. Moreover,
for group-learning activities; class size is class size is preferable
unlimited for individual learning conventional models can affect how students
learn over time as they encounter different
Content Course content is often created Individual faculty members
and delivery collaboratively and benefits from often develop and deliver their
instructors whose courses might diverge
several experts and peer review; own course content; access to from institutional learning objectives.
multimedia technology can offer animation and video is possible e-learning offers a strategy that can
real-time animation and video to but is often limited; experts in standardize the content produced by experts
simulate complex concepts; experts information technology are not
in information technology are required required; classroom-based who are collaborating within or across
to post and maintain content; course instruction does not require extra institutions. This requires a coordinated
faculty members often require further training of faculty members in curriculum-planning process that promotes
training in online teaching online teaching
shared learning objectives and facilitates the
Accessibility Computer hardware and software are Computers and Internet creation of up-to-date content. Moreover,
required by users; high-speed Internet connections are not required
access is preferable
depending on the capacity of the Internet-
based platform that is used, it might be
Interactivity An independent learning style is Both independent and instructor- possible to track centrally the learning of
favoured; fosters interaction among dependent learning styles can be
students and teachers online; limited accommodated; fosters interaction an individual student and to provide feed-
face-to-face contact in distance among students and teachers in back to both the student and the instructor
learning person; considerable face-to-face regarding whether the course objectives
contact at one institution
have been met.
Flexibility Online lectures, case-based learning Instruction often relies on lecture- There are, however, notable limitations
or other approaches can be tailored to style teaching in a classroom
the material; learning methods can be setting; pace of learning depends
when using an Internet-based approach to
tailored to individual students to meet on instructor and student feedback; teach immunology, many of which are appli-
learning objectives learning objectives might or might cable to e-learning in general. Sophisticated
not be met by all students animation, which can enhance learning of
the biological sciences, requires students
to have access to individual computers
Network (see the Online links box), which the need for on-site face-to-face training with sufficient data-handling capacity and
is supported by the National Institute of visits, which are particularly useful for high-speed connections to the Internet if
Allergy and Infectious Diseases (United training in laboratory methods, while they are to appreciate properly the content
States), engages a global network of inves- acknowledging the value of reinforcing key of a web site. Also, text-heavy web sites can
tigators who are dedicated to speeding the concepts after the trainers have departed. be difficult to read on a computer screen.
delivery of an effective preventive vaccine This article explores the advantages and Furthermore, there is the risk of reducing
against infection with HIV. Spread across limitations of e-learning compared with social interactions, which can foster learning
4 continents at 30 clinical-trial sites, the conventional approaches to teaching, and both among students and between students
network faces a challenge to train its new- it details how Immunology Online and the and teachers. To remedy this, Internet-
est investigators and affiliated laboratory OCTAVE project plan to reach their target based communication tools, such as online
staff to participate in protocol develop- audiences in the coming years. chat groups and forums, have been used
ment and implementation. To support effectively in distance learning and can be
this essential capacity-building effort, the Pros and cons of e-learning adopted by new online courses to optimize
network has spearheaded a new online Recent studies indicate that students are blended approaches to learning.
training programme in collaboration with satisfied with e-learning, lending support
the EuroVacc Foundation (see the Online to this method as a viable alternative to Customization using an LMS
links box) and other partner institutions. conventional teaching methods in basic sci- The ability of the Internet to foster an
The LMS platform mentioned earlier will ence and applied public-health practice1,2. integrated approach to learning immunol-
also be utilized by this programme, which However, many university-based immu- ogy depends, in part, on the technologi-
is known as the Online Collaborative nology curricula still rely exclusively on cal capacity of the platform that is used.
Training for AIDS Vaccine Evaluation several individual instructors who develop The LMS platform, which is used by both
project (OCTAVE project; see the Online lecture-orientated courses independently Immunology Online and the OCTAVE
links box). The OCTAVE project will of one another without attempting to har- project, begins with a reference curriculum
deliver training in priority areas, including monize the content. This vertical approach that is assembled by several experts. This
good clinical and laboratory practices, HIV to course development (FIG. 1) upholds the core curriculum offers succinct overviews
pathogenesis and HIV vaccinology. The autonomy of each individual teacher and of peer-reviewed material that prepare
use of e-learning by the OCTAVE project his or her control of all phases of the edu- students for case-based exercises or other
will complement, rather than replace, cational process, but it complicates broader active methods of learning. The compo-
face-to-face training offered by trial spon- attempts to standardize curricula across nents of the curriculum and the order in
sors. This blended approach to learning, institutions, which is a goal of the SVC which they are accessed can be customized.
although resource intensive, responds to and other groups. Conventional teaching Instructors or online tutors can organize
Table 2 | Examples of web-based immunology teaching programmes Pascal Py is at the EuroVacc Foundation, Swiss
Institute for Experimental Cancer Research,
Programme Author Access URL Chemin des Boveresses 155, CH 1066 Epalinges,
Switzerland, and at the Department of Psychiatry
Basic V. Klimov, Tomsk Password http://www.immunology.klimov. Research, University of Zurich, Zurich 8032
Immunology Polytechnic University protected tom.ru/index.html Switzerland.
(Tomsk, Russia)
Jonathan Fuchs is at the HIV Research Section,
BIOL 230 G. E. Kaiser, Community Free http://student.ccbcmd.edu/courses/ San Francisco Department of Public Health,
Microbiology College of Baltimore bio141/lecguide/index.html 25 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 500, San Franscisco,
Lecture Guide County (Catonsville, California 94102, USA, at the Department of
Maryland, USA ) Medicine, University of California, San
Microbiology A. Ghaffar, G. Mayer, Free http://pathmicro.med.sc.edu/book/ Francisco, California 94117, USA, and at the
and Immunology W. Bowers and R. Hunt, immunol-sta.htm HIV Vaccine Trials Network, Fred Hutchinson
Online University of South Cancer Research Center, Seattle, Washington
Carolina (Columbia, 98109, USA.
South Carolina, USA) Correspondence to J.-P.K.
Essentials of A. C. Reese, Medical Password http://imc.meded.com/ e-mail: jean-pierre.kraehenbuhl@isrec.ch
Immunology College of Georgia protected doi:10.1038/nri1687
(Augusta, Georgia, USA)
Published online 19 August 2005
Molecular D. Focosi, Santa Chiara Free http://www.mi.interhealth.info
Immunology Hospital (Pisa, Italy) 1. Johnson, S. D., Aragon, S. R., Shaik, N. &
Palma-Rivas, N. Comparative analysis of learner
Kimball’s Biology J. Kimball Free http://users.rcn.com/jkimball. satisfaction and learning outcomes in online and face
Pages ma.ultranet/BiologyPages to face learning environments. J. Interact. Learn. Res.
11, 29–49 (2000).
Infection and A. Cann, University of Free http://www-micro.msb.le.ac.uk/ 2. Davis, M. V., Sollecito, W. A., Shay, S. & Williamson, W.
Examining the impact of a distance education MPH
Immunity Leicester (Leicester, UK) mbchb/default.html program: a one-year follow-up survey of graduates.
J. Public Health Manag. Pract. 10, 556–563 (2004).
3. The Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS.
AIDS Epidemic Update: 2003 (The Joint United
Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS, Geneva, 2003).
the European Union adopted ambitious pro- In addition, considerable resources, 4. Kelly, J. A. et al. Distance communication transfer of HIV
posals for a new generation of programmes both financial and human, are needed to prevention interventions to service providers. Science
305, 1953–1955 (2004).
— entitled Lifelong Learning — in the fields conceive of, and develop, web sites that 5. Serres, M. The Troubadour of Knowledge (Univ. Michigan
of education and culture, and these include incorporate innovative learning strategies. Press, Ann Arbor, 1997).
6. Europa. Education council agrees on European
an e-learning action plan. The Council of However, both the creators and funders benchmarks [online], <http://europa.eu.int/rapid/
the European Union predicts that at least must have the foresight to plan the scope of pressReleasesAction.do?reference=IP/03/
620&format=HTML&aged=0&language=EN&guiLanguage
12.5% of the adult, working-age population e-learning resources so that such web sites =en> (5 May 2003).
will participate in lifelong learning activi- can be adequately maintained. Consistent 7. European Parliament and the Council of the European
Union. Adopting a multiannual programme (2004 to 2006)
ties 6, of which e-learning initiatives will investment in infrastructure, including for the effective integration of information and
feature prominently, at a cost of €44 million information technology and methods to communication technologies (ICT) in education and
training systems in Europe (eLearning Programme)
in the next two years7. This reinforces the track content creation and reliability, are (2318/200/EC). Official J. Eur. Union L345/9 (31 Dec
stated commitment of the European Union therefore crucial. Finally, soliciting input 2003).
8. Artelt, C., Baumert, J., Julius-McElvany, N. & Peschar, J.
to work towards an ‘advanced knowledge’ from representatives of the target audi- Learners for Life — Student Approaches to Learning:
society with sustainable development, job ence throughout the development and Results from PISA 2000 (Organisation for Economic
Co-operation and Development, Paris, 2003).
creation and greater social cohesion. Many implementation phases of web sites does
people assert that this goal could be reached not guarantee the rapid uptake and appli- Acknowledgements
partly by harmonized educational and train- cability of the educational programme. N.D. is supported by the University of Lausanne (Switzerland)
a n d t h e F e d e r a l O ff i c e f o r E d u c a t i o n a n d S c i e n c e
ing opportunities. This approach will pro- e-learning initiatives should carry out pro- (Switzerland). P.P. and J.-P.K. are supported by the EuroVacc
mote considerable growth in Internet-based cess and impact evaluation, when feasible, Foundation (Switzerland) and the Office of AIDS Research at
the National Institutes of Health (United States). J.F. is sup-
learning. and can incorporate experimental methods ported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
As e-learning programmes are put for- that compare different teaching approaches Diseases (United States).
ward, particularly those that are explicitly among diverse student populations, the Competing interests statement
focused on reaching audiences in resource- results of which can then inform future The authors declare no competing financial interests.