Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The effect of Token Economy on Negative Symptoms and Non Vocational Domains on
Institutionalized Patients with Chronic Schizophrenia: A Prospective Study
[1]
Nandha Kumara Pujam
Abstract:
The token economy is a form of treatment intervention based on principles of operant conditioning developed for the patients
with schizophrenia and other chronic mental illnesses. With the help of a rehabilitation program, non-vocational domains such
as self esteem and quality of life have shown improvement in patients with schizophrenia. Work was related to higher self-esteem
which increases the motivation to engage in self-care behaviors that ultimately reduce negative symptoms. The present study
aimed to examine the effect of vocational rehabilitation using token economy principle on negative symptoms and non functional
domains of patient with schizophrenia. This was a hospital based longitudinal study conducted at Central Institute of Psychiatry,
Ranchi and purposive sampling was used. The sample consisted of 15 patients with chronic schizophrenia according to ICD-10
DCR criteria. After taking informed consent from the patient, Socio-demographic and clinical data sheet, Work Behavior
Assessment Scale, The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS), Social Adaptive Functioning Evaluation (SAFE) Scale,
The Quality of life- BREF, The Subjective Well Being Inventory, Self Esteem Scale, were administered for all the patients (Pre
and Post intervention) After that the patient’s were involved in the vocational rehabilitation training using token economy
principles, for six months. Data was analyzed using SPSS 16.0 version. Paired‘t’ test was used to see the efficacy of intervention.
Result showed that vocational rehabilitation significantly improved patient’s work behaviour negative symptoms, quality of life,
self esteem, subjective well being and socio adaptive functioning.
Keywords: Schizophrenia, Vocational Rehabilitation, quality of life, self esteem, subjective well being, Token economy
I. INTRODUCTION
The token economy program is a treatment intervention and toileting (McGurk et al., 2000). Additionally, the goal of
based on the principles of operant conditioning developed for psychiatric rehabilitation is to enable individuals to achieve
the patients with schizophrenia and other chronic mental the highest feasible quality of life (Browne, 1999). In a study
illnesses (Dickerson, Tenhula and Green Paden., 2005). by Rosenheck et al. (2006) evaluated more than 1400 patients
Token economy which functions on the two laws of operant with schizophrenia and reported that Quality of life was better
behaviour (Skinner, 1953) the law of effect and the law of in competitive employment and other kind of employment
association by contiguity, these principles are combined with than those who were not working (Browne, 1999).
vocational rehabilitation and applied to all kinds of patients in Researchers have identified that lack of social participation
psychiatric hospitals (Dickerson et al., 2005). In a study by and inability to fulfil social roles is a significant factor to low
Maley, Feldman, & Ruskin (1973) randomly assigned 40 self-esteem for schizophrenic population (Petryshen,
patients with chronic schizophrenia to token economy Hawkins, & Fronchak, 2001; Bracke, Christiaens &
program. They found that the patients in the token economy Verhaeghe, 2008). Interestingly, lack of work seems to give
program were more cooperative and communicative, more rise to an increase in negative self-appraisal rather than a
socially desirable, and exhibiting less psychotic behaviour. decrease in positive self-appraisal (Warr & Jackson, 1983).
Schizophrenia is a chronic psychosis which affects the Moreover, in a study by Sing et al. (2010) evaluated 50
patient’s employment condition gradually disabling patients with chronic schizophrenia who were undergoing
functional and non-vocational domains of the patients. One rehabilitation and reported improvement in subjective well
of these classes of symptoms in these patients is “negative being.
symptoms”, it has gained considerable attention over the last There is a proclivity that improvements in vocational
few years. Negative symptoms, includes blunted affect, functioning are correlated with improvements in other
withdrawal or apathy, are particularly crucial for recovery outcomes, such as reduced symptoms and gain in self esteem,
and are associated with negative functional outcomes in these quality of life and subjective well being, but it is not clear that
patients, such as incapability to get an employment and there is any causal relationship between this correlation and
conduct normal daily living activities. Whilst positive vocational rehabilitation interventions (Lehman 1995).
symptoms are usually treated by antipsychotic drugs, Therefore the present study aimed to examine the effect of
negative symptoms are usually residual, which indicates the vocational rehabilitation using token economy principle on
need for better treatment. Some work has suggested that negative symptoms and non functional domains of patients
negative symptoms are inversely correlated with functional with chronic schizophrenia (Kumari et al., 2010)
outcomes (Rabinowitz et al., 2012) such as dressing, eating
[1]
Central Institute of Psychiatry (CIP), Ranchi Email: nandhakumara2008@gmail.com
1
International Journal of Education and Psychological Research (IJEPR) Volume 6, Issue 1, March 2017
Table-3: Comparison of pre and post scores of Positive and experienced increase in work skills (Anthony, 1995). One
Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) scores in schizophrenia possible explanation for this effect is simple instructions and
patient group (N=15) monetary reinforcement were sufficient to increase
performance on a measure of span of apprehension, a
presumed trait marker of schizophrenia that is thought to be
highly stable (Bellack, Gold, & Buchanan, 1999). However,
these practice-related changes typically fall short of full
normalization of performance and may not be long lived
(Bellack, Gold, & Buchanan, 1999).
Table 3: shows comparison of pre and post scores of PANSS The present study observed that Vocational Rehabilitation
scores in schizophrenia patient group using paired samples t significantly improved patient’s socio adaptive functioning.
test. Post scores of PANSS negative and general These findings are in agreement with other earlier research’s
psychopathology scales were significantly lower (p<.01) (Lysaker & Bell, 1995) indicate that participation in
than the pre scores. No significant difference in the scores rehabilitation has been shown to improve the social Skills,
over time with intervention was found in positive scale. cooperativeness, personal hygiene significantly over time
Table-4: Comparison of pre and post scores of WHO- (Lysaker & Bell, 1995; Bell & Bryson, 2001). Previous
Quality of Life (QOL) in schizophrenia patient group (N=15) research has indicated that the ability to get along with others
in the work place is a significant predictor of successful
vocational functioning (Anthony & Jansen, 1984) and
improved social functioning has been associated with a
variety of clinical improvements including decreased
likelihood of relapse (Benton & Schroeder, 1990). One
possible explanation for this effect can be, being productive
Table 4: shows comparison of pre and post scores of WHO- in a well defined worker role may have been intrinsically
QOL scale in schizophrenia patient group using paired rewarding for participants and led to enhancements of self-
samples t test. Post scores of WHO-QOL were significantly esteem and self-confidence. These might have helped
higher (p<.001) than the pre scores. participants to overcome fears of rejection and more
Table-5: Comparison of pre and post scores of Self Esteem in willingly socialize with co-workers. Secondly, our
schizophrenia patient group (N=15) observations suggest that participants’ job sites (sheltered
workshop) expected appropriate social behaviour and
encouraged (token economy) withdrawn participants to
engage more openly in conversation (Lysaker & Bell, 1995).
In this longitudinal study we found that vocational
rehabilitation showed reduce in patient’s negative symptoms
Table 5: shows comparison of pre and post scores of self
and general psychopathology. Our findings are in
esteem in schizophrenia patient group using paired samples t
concordance with many earlier researches (Bell, Lysaker, &
test. Post scores of self esteem were significantly higher
Milstein,1996; Torrey, Mueser, & Drake, 2000; Srinivasan &
(p<.001) than the pre scores.
Tirupati, 2005; Kumar, 2008; Bio & Gattaz, 2011). In another
Table-6: Comparison of pre and post scores of Subjective study by Kilian et al. (2012) showed being in competitive
Well Being in schizophrenia patient group (N=15) work has a positive influence on the level of psychopathology
in people with schizophrenia (Kilian et al., 2012). This
finding’s is also supported by some Indian studies a study by
Ajmol (2001) documented a higher degree of overall
functioning and reduce symptoms in rehabilitated patients
compared to those not vocationally rehabilitated (Kumar and
Table 6: shows comparison of pre and post scores of Mohanty 2013). This effect can be explained by the powerful
subjective well being in schizophrenia patient group using role of work in organizing the lives of people in modern
paired samples t test. Post scores of subjective well being society. As stated by Di Masso et al. (2001) ‘‘work requires
were significantly higher (p<.001) than the pre scores. people to concentrate on the tasks at hand while blocking out
any distressing thoughts’’( (Kilian et al., 2012).
IV. DISCUSSION The Current study found significant improvement in the
patient’s quality of life after 6 months of vocational
The present study found that vocational rehabilitation rehabilitation; this finding was consistent with earlier studies
significantly improved patient’s work behaviour. These (Mueser et al., 1997; Browne, 1999; Drake et al., 1999;
findings are in accord with previous research (McGurk, 2003; Torrey et al., 2000; Bryson et al., 2002; Prouteaua et al., 2005;
Kumar, 2008; Lysaker et al., 2009). In a study by Hoffmann & Rosenheck et al., 2006; Bio & Gattaz, 2011). Participation in
Kupper (1996) documented that differences in work vocational rehabilitation program is associated with
performance became obvious only after 2-3 months in the improvement in quality of life of the patients and was
rehabilitation program (Hoffmann & Kupper 1996). independent of the type of medication prescribed, illness
Similarly, other earlier study reported, those participant who duration. One possible explanation could be that, when the
remained in the psychosocial program for at least one year positive and negative symptoms decrease, the quality of life
3
International Journal of Education and Psychological Research (IJEPR) Volume 6, Issue 1, March 2017
4
International Journal of Education and Psychological Research (IJEPR) Volume 6, Issue 1, March 2017
• Harvey, P. D., Davidson, M., Mueser, K. T., Parrella, M., • Torrey, W. C., Mueser, K. T., & Drake, R. E. (2000). Self
White, L., & Powchik, P. (1997). The social adaptive esteem as an outcome measure in vocational
functioning evaluation: An assessment measure for rehabilitation studies of adults with severe mental illness.
elderly psychiatric patients. Schizophrenia bulletin, 22, Psychiatric Services, 51, 229-233.
231-283 • Srinivasan, L., & Tirupati, S. (2005). Relationship
• Kay, S. R., Fizszbein, A., & Opler, L. A. (1987). The between cognition work functioning among patients with
positive and negative syndrome scale for schizophrenia. schizophrenia in an urban area of India. Psychiatric
Schizophrenia Bulletin, 13, 261-276. Services, 56(11), 1423-1428.
• WHOQOL-BREF (1996). Introduction, Administration, • Kumar, P.N.S. (2008). Impact of vocational rehabiitation
Scoring and Generic version of the assessment field trial on social functioning, cognitive functioning and
version. psychopathology in patients with chronic schizophrenia.
• Rosenberg, M. (1965). Society and the adolescent self Indian journal of psychiatry, 50(4), 257-261.
image. New Jersey. Princeton university press, 113-127. • Bio, D. S., & Gattaz, W. F. (2011). Vocational
• Sell, H., & Nagpal, R. (1992). Assessment of subjective rehabilitation improves cognition and negative symptoms
well being. Regional health paper, SEARO, 24. in schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research, 126, 265–269.
• McGurk, S. R., & Mueser, K. T. (2003). Cognitive • Kilian, R., Lauber, C., Kalkan, R., Dorn, Wulf., Rossler,
functioning and employment in severe mental illness. W., Wiersma, D., Bushbach, J. T. V., Fioritti, A., Tomov,
Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 191, 789-798. T., Catty, J., Burns, T., & Becker, T. (2012). The
relationship between employment, clinical status, and
• Kumar, P. N. S. (2008). Impact of vocational psychiatric hospitalisation in patients with schizophrenia
rehabilitation on social functioning, cognitive receiving either IPS or a conventional vocational
functioning and psychopathology in patients with chronic rehabilitation programme. Social Psychiatry and
schizophrenia. Indian journal of psychiatry, 50(4), 257- Psychiatric Epidemiology, 47, 1381-1389.
261.
• Ajmol, M. (2001). Impact of vocational rehabilitation on
• Lysaker, P. H., Davis, L. W., Bryson, G. J., & Bell, M. D. persons with schizophrenia: A comparative study.
(2009). Effects of cognitive behavioral therapy on work NIMHANS Journal, 19, 69-93.
outcomes in vocational rehabilitation for participants
with schizophrenia spectrum disorders. Schizophrenia • Kumar S, & Mohanty S. (2013). Effects of paid work
Research, 107, 186-191. assignments on psychopathology in hospitalized chronic
schizophrenic patients. Indian journal of psychosocial
• Hoffmann, H., & Kupper, Z. (1996). Patients dynamic in sciences, 3(2), 20-27.
early stages of vocational rehabilitation: A pilot study.
Comprehensive Psychiatry, 37(3), 216-221. • Di Masso, J., Avi-Itzhak, T., & Obler D. R. (2001). The
clubhouse model: an outcome study on attendence, work
• Anthony, W. A., Rogers, E. A., Cohen, M., & Davies, R. attainment and status, and hospitalization recidivism.
R. (1995). Relationship between psychiatric Work, 17, 23–30.
sy7mptomatology, work skills and future vocational
performance. Psychiatric Services, 46(4), 353-358. • Drake, R. E., McHugo, G. J., Bebout, R. R., Becker, D. R.,
Harris, M., Bond, G. R., & Quimby, E. (1999). A
• Bellack, A. S., Gold, J. M., & Buchanan, R. W. (1999). randomized clinical trial of supported employment for
Cognitive rehabilitation for schizophrenia: Problems, inner-city patients with severe mental disorders. Archives
prospects, and strategies. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 25(2), of General Psychiatry, 56, 627-633.
257-274.
• Bryson, G., Lysaker, P., & Bell, M. (2002). Quality of life
• Lysaker, P., & Bell, M. (1995). Work performance over benefits of paid work activity in schizophrenia.
time for people with schizophrenia. Psychosocial Schizophrenia Bulletin, 28(2), 249-257.
Rehabilitation Journal, 18(3), 141-145.
• Prouteaua, A., Verdoux, H., & Briand, C. (2005).
• Bell, M. D., & Bryson, G. (2001). Work rehabilitation in Cognitive predictors of psychosocial functioning
schizophrenia: does cognitive impairment limit outcome in schizophrenia: A follow-up study of subjects
improvement. Schizophrenia bulletin, 27(2), 269-279. participating in a rehabilitation program. Schizophrenia
• Anthony, W. A., & Jansen, M. A. (1984). Predicting the Research, 77, 343– 353
vocational capacity of the chronically mentally ill: • Romney, D. M. (1995). Psychosocial Functioning and
Research and policy implications. American Subjective Experience in Schizophrenia: A Reanalysis.
Psychologist, 39, 537-544. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 21(3), 405-410.
• Benton, M. K., and Schroeder, H. E. (1990). Social skill • Bond, G. R., Becker, D. R., & Drake, R. E. (2001).
training with schizophrenics: A meta-analytic evaluation. Implementing supported employment as an evidence
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 58, 6, based practice. Psychiatric Services, 52, 313-322.
741-747.
• Salyers, M. P., Becker, D. R., Drake, R. E., Torrey, W. C.,
• Bell, M. D., Lysaker, P. H., & Milstein, R. M. (1996). & Wyzik, P. F. (2004). A ten year follow-up of a supported
Clinical benefits of paid work activity in schizophrenia. employment program. Psychiatric Services, 55(3), 302-
Schizophrenia Bulletin, 22, 51-67. 308.
5
International Journal of Education and Psychological Research (IJEPR) Volume 6, Issue 1, March 2017