Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The increase in greenhouse gas concentrations is the main reason for the global warming issue that is one of the most import-
ant aspects associated with the environment.
Nowadays, in addition, NOx emissions have to be smaller than 25ppmvd. For what concerns CO2, since its increased concen-
tration produces negative effects in the environment, from 2011 Kyoto Protocol stabilized that its emissions must be reduced
of at least 5%.
In the first part of this paper main pollutants emitted during the combustion reaction and the legislations they must undergo
are presented.
In the second part, the currently used technologies are set out. In the first section the methods to reduce emission in conven-
tional combustors are explained. Among these methods water injection, lean premixed combustion and selective catalytic
combustion will be mainly discussed.
In the last section, the main currently used technologies to limit both NOx and CO2 emissions are emphasized. Particular
attention will be given to the CCS technology, for its ability to limit both CO2 and NOx. Within the CCS family the Oxy-fuel
combustion will be mainly taken in consideration for the great interest it currently retains in the field of industrial low emis-
sion combustion system.
Keywords: Low Emission, Combustion, Dry-Low NOx combustion, Carbon Capture and Storage
1
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-4
L. Fracassi / Industrial Engine Low Emission Combustion System
The main intent of this chapter is to alert the reader to NOx and SOx respectively refers to oxides of nitrogen and
potential consequences of the emission of various kinds oxides of sulphur. Both of them are between the main
of pollutants during the combustion processes. These pollutant products of combustion in industrial gas tur-
pollutants have deleterious effects on the environment bines. NOx in particular is the main cause of smog, as
and there is evidence that may have an impact on the discovered in 1940s in Los Angeles area, where the
health of human and animals. combined action of sunlight on the NOx and subsequent
reaction with hydrocarbons, produced smog for the first
2.1. CO2 and CO time [7].
The dominant sources of CO2 are the combustion of The main product of oxides of nitrogen reacting in the
fossil fuels, industrial processes and cement production.
lowest part of the atmosphere with oxygen is the ozone as
In particular power generation and industry sectors cur-
shown in the following reaction:
rently account for the 60% of the global production of
CO2 [4]. Even if CO2 can not strictly be defined a pollu- NO2 + O2 → NO + O3
tant, since it is one of the main natural components of
atmosphere, its concentration does influence the envi- Although the presence of ozone in the stratosphere is
ronment and the mean temperature of the atmosphere
important, mainly to form the ozone layer, in the tropo-
throughout the change in Earth’s radiative balance. Con-
sphere €(the lower part of atmosphere) its presence causes
sequently since, from the industrial revolution, the con-
centration of CO2 has been continuously rising, a direct damage to human beings and animals and consequently
link between its rising concentration and the rise in should be avoided as much as possible [4]. Moreover,
earth’s average temperature can be found. without taking into account its influence on low-altitude
ozone production, oxides of nitrogen are toxic elements,
capable, on their own, to bring damage to human beings
and animals. For what concerns SOx its most predomi-
nant form and the main product of combustion process is
SO2, since it is preferably produced at high temperatures.
This kind of pollutant can be very corrosive in presence
of water and is generally considered a pollutant since it
causes a choking effect in the human respiratory system
[6]. Moreover sulphuric acid mist and other sulfate par-
ticulate matter are well established as important sources
of atmospheric contamination [7].
Figure 2: CO2 raise in concentration since industrial revolution 3. Legislation
For what concerns on the other hand carbon monoxide Regulations regarding pollutant emissions tend to be
(CO), it is actually considered a pollutant since it de- quite complex since are generally variable from one
creases the ability of the blood to carry oxygen, by com- country to another. In particular emission of UHC,
bining with hemoglobin in the blood, and consequently in
particulate matter and SOx are generally enough small to
high concentration can lead to asphyxiation and even to
be negligible. Consequently the most restricting
death [5]. This kind of pollutant is generally produced by
the incomplete combustion of a carbon-containing fuel legislation for gas turbine emissions regards in general
[6]. For this reason combustion systems are generally NOx emissions [8]. In the United States the emission
operated fuel-lean (in excess of oxygen), in order to standards depend-on-the-engine’s-input-energy and on
prevent CO formation. the-intended-use-(utility or industrial) (Federal Register
71 FR 38482 dated July 6, 2006 Standards 40 CFR Part
60) [9]:
2
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-4
L. Fracassi / Industrial Engine Low Emission Combustion System
Oxides of Nitrogen can generally be produced by In the previous section attention was focused on the
four diverse mechanisms: thermal NO, nitrous oxide various-mechanisms-and-processes involved in the for-
mechanism, prompt NO and fuel NO [4]. The most mation of pollutant emissions. Of-equal-importance-is the
relevant oxides of nitrogen are the ones produced by the application-of-this-knowledge to the problems of alleviat-
oxidation of atmospheric nitrogen in high-temperature ing these emissions. Consequently in this chapter the
regions of the flame [5]. This process is strongly pollutant reduction methods in conventional combustor
influenced by the flame temperature, as shown in figure will be treated. In this way it will be possible to under-
3
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-4
L. Fracassi / Industrial Engine Low Emission Combustion System
stand how it is achievable a reduction of harmful emis- leads to incomplete combustion and consequent produc-
sions in conventional combustors. Subsequently, the tion of CO and UHC.
following chapter will regard new kinds of combustion
that, with new technologies, allows introducing a signifi- 5.1.2. Gas Recirculation
cantly lower amount of pollutants in the environment.
In this chapter will be again useful treat separately the Gas Recirculation is a process that carries the products
various kinds of pollutant emissions and the technologies of the combustion back into the flame (internal gas recir-
used to limit them. culation). Consequently since furnace and flue gases,
although being hot, are considerably cooler than the
5.1. Oxides of Nitrogen flame itself, they act as diluent reducing the flame tem-
perature which leads to a reduction in NOx emissions as
In order to minimize the NOx emissions there are three well [6].
main goals to aim at [8]:
5.1.1. Diluent Injection In order to apply this method only very clean fuel are
required, in order to avoid issues regarding fouling and
Since the formation of NOx depends directly from contamination [5].
temperature, an obvious way to reduce it is to use diluent
injection into the combustion zone [8]. Usually heat sink, 5.1.3. Selective Catalytic Reduction
as water or steam, is introduced in the combustion zone.
Obviously this kind of approach is inappropriate for aero Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) involves the
engines, whereas it can be a practical proposition for injection of an NOx-reducing chemical, generally
stationary gas turbines [12]. ammonia (NH3), into an exhaust stream in presence of a
catalyst [8]. Ammonia, in particular, is injected in a
prescribed manner in order to achieve an intimate mixing.
NOx and NH3 subsequently react on the catalyst surface
to create N2 and H2O, as shown by the following
reactions [5]:
6NO + 4NH 3 → 5N 2 + 6H 2O
2NO + 4NH 3 + 2O2 → 3N 2 + 6H 2O
4
ESS-38-4
5
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-4
L. Fracassi / Industrial Engine Low Emission Combustion System
6
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-4
L. Fracassi / Industrial Engine Low Emission Combustion System
Afterwards at the exit of the HRSG the gases are re- [9] (July 2006) Federal Register 71 FR 38482, standards 40,
cycled back. After a condensation process, where water USA
vapour is converted to liquid water, the pure carbon [10] Hung, W.S. and Agan, D.D. (1985), The Control of NOx
and CO Emissions from 7-MW Gas Turbines with water
dioxide stream is compressed in order to be subsequently
injections as influenced by ambient conditions, ASME
stored [25]. Paper 85-GT-50
Since oxy-fuel combustion needs to provide power to [11] (1975) Effects of equivalent ratio and Dwell Time on
several units, that are not required during a conventional Exhaust emissions from an experimentale premixing pre-
combustion, it is generally less efficient per unit of en- vaporizing burner, ASME Paper 75-GT-69
ergy produced. [12] (1998) Twenty-Seventh Symposium on Combustion, NOx
formation and control, Vol 1, organised by the Combus-
7. Conclusion tion Institute, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
[13] . Marchionna, N.R. and Diehl, L.A. and Trout, A.M.
(1973) Effect of water Injection on Nitric Oxide emissions
In the previous sections the diverse technologies of a gas turbine combustor burning natural gas fuel,
associated to industrial low emission combustion systems NASA Technical Memorandum
have been discussed. After a brief introduction in which [14] Davis, L.B. and Washam, R.M. (1989), Development of
the main issues regarding environmental aspects have dry low NOx Combustor, ASME Paper 89-GT-255
[15] Hung, W.S.Y. (1974), Accurate Method of predicting the
been treated, the main pollutants and the different ways to
effect of humidity or injected water on NOx emissions
reduce their emissions have been exposed. In this part the from industrial Gas Turbines, ASME Paper 74-WA/GT-6
main parameters that influence the emissions of pollutant [16] Cowell, L. (2005), Combustion and Fuels, Solar Turbines
have been highlighted; subsequently different Inc., A caterpillar company
technologies useful to reduce these emissions have been [17] Davis, L.B. and Black, S.H. (2000), Dry Low NOx com-
bustion systems for GE Heavy-Duty Gas Turbines, GE
listed and explained. In conclusion in the last part of this Power Systems, Schenectady, NY
paper technologies recently and currently being [18] Ohkubo, Y., Low-NOx Combustion Technology, R&D
developed have been discussed, underlining in particular Review of Toyota, Vol 41 No 1
the Dry-Low NOx combustion and the Carbon Capture [19] Leonard, G. and Stegmaier, J. (1993), Development of an
and Storage technology. Since the more and more aeroderivative gas turbine dry low emission combustion
system, Journal of Engineering Gas turbines and Power,
restrictive laws on pollutant emissions around the world Vol 116, pp 542-6
the development of technologies capable of emitting low [20] Maroto-Valer, Developments and innovation in carbon
quantities of pollutant is of primary importance. In dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology, Vol 1, ed-
addition, considering that renewable energies still doesn’t ited by M. Mercedes
[21] Wang, J.H. and Bao, W. (2012), Carbon Capture: An
represents a valid alternative to fossil fuel burning, until
Overview, The Berkley Energy Review
they will definitely become a real main character of the [22] Rackley, A.S. (2010), Carbon Capture and Storage
energy sector, low emission technologies for [23] Teir, S. and Hetland, J. (2010), Potential for carbon cap-
conventional sources of energies will be needed. The ture and storage (CCS) in the Nordic region, VTT
Carbon Capture and Storage technology, in particular, [24] Buhre, B.J.P. and Elliot, L.K. and Sheng, C.D. (2005),
Oxy-fuel combustion technology for coal-fired power gen-
currently represents an extremely valid clean source of eration, Cooperative Research Centre for Coal in Sustai-
energy, that seems to be able to withstand to the new low- nable Development, Callaghan, Australia
emissions rules easily, and that consequently will keep [25] Kvamsdal, H.M. and Jordal, K. and Bolland, O. (2005), A
holding a fundamental role in the industrial sector in the quantitative comparison of gas turbine cycles with CO2
future. capture, SINTEF Energy Research, Trondheim, Norway
References
[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/climate/policies/Kyoto.shtml, 22nd
February 2013
[2] Pagone, E. (2009), Advanced Low Carbon Power Systems
– The Advanced Zero Emissions Power Plant, Cranfield
University
[3] Kyoto Protocol (2011) United Nations frame work con-
vention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)
[4] Badr, O. (2012), Global Environmental Impact of Atmos-
pheric Pollution, Environmental Management, Lecture
Notes
[5] Lefebvre, A. and Ballal, D. (2003), Gas Turbine Combus-
tion, 3rd edition
[6] Baukal, C.E. and Colannino, J. (2000), Combustion
Handbook, Pollutant Emissions, Ed. J. Zink
[7] Glassman, I. and Yetter, R.A., Combustion, 4th Edition,
Penn State University, NJ, USA
[8] Hung, W.S. and Agan, D.D. (1985), The Control of NOx
and CO Emissions from 7-MW Gas Turbines with water
injections as influenced by ambient conditions, ASME
Paper 85-GT-50