Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Salvatore Sembronio, MD, PhD, FEBOMFS, Alessandro Tel, MD, Fabio Costa, MD,
Massimo Robiony, MD, FEBOMFS
PII: S0278-2391(19)30192-2
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joms.2019.02.008
Reference: YJOMS 58658
Please cite this article as: Sembronio S, Tel A, Costa F, Robiony M, An updated protocol for the
treatment of condylar hyperplasia: computer-guided proportional condylectomy, Journal of Oral and
Maxillofacial Surgery (2019), doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joms.2019.02.008.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
DEPARTMENT OF MEDICINE
UNIVERSITY OF UDINE
PT
An updated protocol for the treatment of condylar hyperplasia: computer-
guided proportional condylectomy
RI
Salvatore Sembronio, MD, PhD, FEBOMFS 1 *
SC
Alessandro Tel, MD 2
Fabio Costa, MD 1
U
AN
1. Assistant Professor, Maxillofacial Surgery Department, Academic Hospital of Udine, Department of
Medicine, University of Udine
M
corresponding author:
Assistant Professor
Department of Medicine
University of Udine
AC
KEYWORDS:
condylar hyperplasia; condylectomy; virtual surgical planning; cutting guides; Facial Care Project
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
DEPARTMENT OF MEDICINE
UNIVERSITY OF UDINE
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
An updated protocol for the treatment of condylar hyperplasia:
PT
RI
SC
PURPOSE: To present an updated protocol for proportional condylectomy in which virtual sur-
U
gical planning and 3D printing allow one to precisely define the osteotomy level.
AN
METHODS: 3D mirroring was performed to generate a virtual replica of the healthy hemi-
M
mandible, which was subsequently aligned and overlapped with the actual mandible to esti-
mate the level for condylectomy. A custom-fitted 3D printed surgical guide was modeled for
D
TE
the condylar head allowing one to reproduce virtual planning in the surgical scenario. The up-
RESULTS
C
For all patients, a follow-up period of twelve months was considered. Surface deviation color
AC
maps showed a high correspondence between the virtually calculated condylectomy and the
surgical outcome achieved with the aid of the surgical guide. No cases of condylar hyperplasia
CONCLUSION
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
An updated protocol based on accurate three-dimensional analysis was performed by means
of virtual surgical planning and 3D printing. Virtual surgical planning allows one to precisely
define the level of condylectomy, and custom-made 3D printed cutting guides are useful to
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
Introduction
EP
terized by asymmetry of the lower third of the face due to an excessive growth of the condylar
AC
mal posterior vertical growth and it should be differentiated from other patterns of unilateral
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
asymmetric mandibular growth, such as hemi-mandibular elongation, which involves the hori-
UCH typically begins at puberty and predominantly affects young women. Patients present
progressive facial asymmetry, with both occlusal and aesthetic impairment. Additional clinical
PT
appearances of UCH consist of contralateral chin deviation, unilateral posterior crossbite or/and
RI
ipsilateral open bite and variable canting of the maxilla with a dento-alveolar compensation
SC
that follows the overgrowth of the condyle.
The etiology of this condition is poorly understood: traumatic and mechanical causes have
U
AN
been proposed, as well as genetic and hormonal factors, but the ultimate cause remains un-
clear.
M
Nowadays, cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) provides optimal anatomical visualization,
D
TE
allowing for the diagnosis of the form of the asymmetry pattern and can be used for three-
helpful to differentiate between active and inactive forms of UCH. A 10% difference between
AC
the two condyles in SPECT analysis is associated with the active form of condylar hyperplasia3.
Condylectomy was established to be the preferred technique for the treatment of active con-
dylar hyperplasia4,5. In the literature, many papers report that the standard treatment for these
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
patients consists of high condylectomy and, eventually, orthognathic surgery, which might be
High condylectomy involves the removal of the upper 5 mm of the mandibular condyle; it
aims to eliminate the most active part of condylar head which drives the overgrowing process.
PT
Delaire7 proposed a systematic protocol for proportional condylectomy, which is a low con-
RI
dylectomy resecting the growth centre and decreasing the posterior vertical excess, thus allow-
SC
ing for the correction of the mandibular deformities.
Modern CAD (computer-aided design) software allows for the accurate analysis of morphologi-
U
AN
cal differences between the healthy and hyperplastic condyle, and provides surgeons with the
possibility to virtually designing the level of the osteotomy, in order to restore the symmetry of
M
the face.
D
TE
The combination of virtual surgical planning and 3D printing has been used to produce surgi-
cal guides, defined as patient specific intraoperative templates allowing one to trace surgical
EP
The aim of this study is to develop a protocol for the treatment of unilateral condylar hyper-
AC
plasia by means of virtual surgical planning and a novel 3D printed custom surgical guide to
Seven patients were treated from 2016 to 2017 at Maxillofacial Surgery Department, Academic
PT
Hospital, University of Udine. Patients clinical and demographic characteristics are described in
RI
Table 1. The present study was approved by Regional Ethical Committee, with the registration
SC
number protocol 2056 CEUR . All patients recruited in this study had a diagnosis of active
condylar hyperplasia.
U
AN
Inclusion criteria were the following: 1) patients developing a progressive asymmetry of the
lower face; 2) computed tomography (CT) scan showing a unilateral enlargement; 3) single
M
positron emission computed tomography (SPECT) assessing a difference of more than 10% in
D
TE
condylar uptake.
EP
The following patients were excluded: 1) condylar enlargement associated with neoplastic
C
growths; 2) patients that previously underwent any other facial or condylar surgical procedures;
AC
CT scanning provided raw data which could be reformatted into three-dimensional models for
Virtual planning
DICOM data obtained from CT scan were imported in ProPlan CMF (Materialise, Leuven, BE) for
PT
virtual surgical planning. First, skull models were aligned according to Frankfurt plane. In order
RI
to restore the correct occlusal plane, the supraorbital line, namely the line which joins the top
SC
of orbital roofs, was set as a reference. The mandible was realigned resulting in supraorbital
line being parallel to the tangent to the healthy condyle, and the vertical difference between
U
AN
hyperplasic condyle and healthy condyle was estimated. In order to perform a 3-D study, the
half mandible containing the healthy condyle was mirrored and overlapped with hyperplasic
M
condyle, allowing to identify the osteotomy plane for proportional condylectomy (Fig. 1b, 1c).
D
TE
In order to translate virtual surgical planning coordinates on the actual patient, a custom-fitted
surgical guide (Fig. 1d) was modeled in 3-Matic software (Materialise, Leuven, BE) and printed
EP
using stereolithographic resin (Formlabs, Somerville, MA, USA). The cutting edge of condylar
C
guide was designed in order to replicate the natural shape of healthy condyle and to fit the
AC
lateral part of the condyle that is the most easily accessible. Measurements of condylar head
diameters were performed in order to choose an appropriate length for the fixation screws.
3D printing (stereolithography) was used to manufacture the condylar cutting guide. The pro-
Surgical procedure
PT
RI
Patients underwent surgery in general anesthesia by the same surgeons (S.S. and M.R.). A
preauricular incision extending to the temporal region, curving backwards and upwards poste-
SC
rior of the main branches of the temporal vessels was performed. The incision was carried
U
though subcutaneous areolar tissue and superficial temporalis fascia. Blunt dissection was car-
AN
ried out to the point where the deep temporals fascia subdivides into two layers enclosing fat
M
tissue. The superficial layer of deep temporalis fascia and underlying fat tissue were incised,
D
and inferior layer of deep temporalis fascia was reached. When dissection was complete, a
TE
composite flap extending from the skin to the deep layer of deep superficial fascia was
EP
achieved, allowing for additional protection of the facial nerve. Subsequently, the periosteum
C
of the malar arch was incised and comfortable surgical approach to the articular capsule was
AC
performed. Surgical capsule was incised at the insertion of temporomandibular lateral liga-
ments in order to enter the inferior joint space, leaving the superior joint space and the disk
intact. After exposure of the condylar head and neck, Dunn-Dautrey temporomandibular joint
condyle retractors were used to protect and laterally distract the condyle, enabling the opera-
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
tor to position the surgical cutting guide fitting the lateral condylar pole. The surgical guide
was secured to the condylar head with an 11 mm screw (Fig. 3). A condylectomy was per-
formed with the aid of condylar cutting guide, designing the osteotomy by means of piezosur-
PT
RI
Postsurgical care
SC
After surgery, all patients underwent combined physiotherapy and orthodontic treatment.
U
AN
normal range of motion in 10 days.
important to warn patients that condylar reduction could result in malocclusion, with a precontact
D
Intermaxillary elastic therapy consisted of nocturnal fixation and intermittent passive/active re-
habilitation8. Elastic propulsion on the affected side was directed to bring the occlusion into
EP
trusion and move upwards the point of ipsilateral dental contact on the operated side, in order to
further enhance mandibular rotation. Additionally, orthodontics allows one to correct maxillary oc-
clusal plane canting, remove pre-contacts, and stabilize the occlusion. According to our protocol in
which a follow-up of 12 month is required, the average time of postoperative orthodontic treatment
was 1 year.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Results
The condylectomy did not cause any major complications. No transient or permanent facial
palsy was observed. Condylectomy did not result in functional limitation of mouth opening and
PT
all patients showed normal postoperative mouth opening (> 35 mm), with a mean postopera-
RI
tive (1 year) maximal interincisal opening (MIO) of 41,3 mm. None of the patients at 1-year fol-
SC
low-up reported pain of the operated joint.
In all patients, the amount of resected bone was superior to 5 mm, with a mean value of 9
U
AN
mm.
Postoperative CBCT was performed 1 year after surgery and a postoperative 3D model was
M
achieved and overlapped with the planned counterpart. Surface deviation color map showed
D
TE
high correspondence between the original virtual surgical plan and postoperative result (Fig. 4).
Immediately after surgery all patients presented with a precontact on the ipsilateral side, man-
C
In the group of 7 patients who were treated by proportional condylectomy, at one-year follow-
up, six had clinically satisfactory results with aesthetic improvement of the facial asymmetry,
occlusal cant correction and a stable occlusion. One patient, because of residual asymmetry,
needed further treatment and underwent subsequent orthognathic surgery consisting of bi-
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
maxillary surgery. Figure 5 (a-b) and figure 6 (a-b) show clinical preoperative and postoperative
PT
RI
Discussion
SC
In literature, proportional condylectomy was demonstrated to be an effective method to re-
move the overgrowth of the condylar head and to establish adequate symmetry and occlusion.
U
AN
Farina et al.9 in 2015 showed that a low or proportional condylectomy is suitable for the treat-
ment of facial asymmetry caused by condylar hyperplasia and illustrated the efficacy of the
M
procedure: the mandible is rotated on the side in which condylectomy has been performed
D
TE
and it is vertically lifted until dental contact is achieved. Facial symmetry improves due to
mandibular rotation. The rationale of such a treatment is to intervene early with a single pro-
EP
fact, the same authors10 in 2016 compared high condylectomy with proportional condylectomy,
AC
concluding that proportional condylectomy reduced the need for secondary orthognathic sur-
gery, since it avoided the progression of homolateral occlusal plane tilting and dento-facial
adaptive deformities.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Multidisciplinary care is necessary to provide patients with the best treatment options and co-
operation with the orthodontist is to be encouraged. In our experience the main advantage of
elastic therapy and orthodontic treatment was to guide the mandible until the new condylar
head reached the glenoid fossa. An additional advantage of orthodontic treatment was to de-
PT
termine the intrusion of ipsilateral molars to improve the orthopaedic effect of intermaxillary
RI
elastic fixation in maximal occlusion8. As a consequence of combined use of orthodontic and
SC
elastic treatment for the correction of posterior vertical excess, rise and flattening of the occlu-
sal plane were observed, as well as rotation of the mandible and improvement of the asym-
U
AN
metry. The correction of symmetry was generally not complete, although in the majority of
cases patients significantly improved their aesthetic facial appearance (Fig. 5a-b; Fig. 6a-b).
M
Once condylar hyperplasia is no longer active because of condylar surgery, there is residual
D
TE
asymmetry, as reported by Higginson et al.11; traditional orthognathic surgery allows for further
correction. In our protocol orthognathic surgery was considered in case of inactive disease
EP
(SPECT -) or if at 1-year follow-up patients were unsatisfied with the restoration of symmetry.
C
Moreover, low condylectomy does not restrict mandibular range of motion and does not inter-
AC
fere with temporomandibular function12. In our patients we did not observe any temporoman-
my.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
In previous reports, the determination of the condylar resection size was based on two-
dimensional cephalometric analysis. Mouallem et al. proposed to measure vertical distance be-
tween mandibular angles and supraorbital line on the coronal plane8. Farina et al. obtained dif-
ferential measurements drawing a line from the uppermost point of the condyle to the man-
PT
dibular angle10.
RI
In condylar hyperplasia, although the growth center is localized into the condylar head, the en-
SC
tire anatomy of the mandibular body and ramus-condyle unit is distorted, resulting in difficult
U
AN
the entity of proportional condylectomy may not be reliable.
The advent of CBCT has allowed for comparable resolution, sensitivity, and specificity to con-
M
ventional CT with lower doses of radiation. CBCT should be used for extensive comprehension
D
TE
of the surgical problem and three-dimensional virtual planning11. Digital techniques, such as
mirroring and superimposition, allow to create a virtual replica of the healthy hemi-mandible,
EP
which can be in turn used as a reference to orient the osteotomy performed on the condyle.
C
As suggested in previous reports, this ultimately allows to remove the hyperplastic growth cen-
AC
ter and to perform simultaneous correction of the posterior vertical excess. 3D virtual surgical
planning has a very important role in our protocol, consisting of three steps: mirroring of the
contralateral healthy side, measurement of vertical amount excess, and positioning of the re-
section plane. Specifically, three-dimensional mirroring allows to recreate symmetry in the af-
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
fected side, and enables to quantify the vertical excess, overcoming the imprecise traditional
a precise level for condylectomy, in order to restore the symmetry of the mandible.
However, the process of transferring preoperative measurements to the operating room could
PT
be subject to procedural errors because intraoperative measurements to perform condylectomy
RI
were traditionally operator-dependent and not precise. Our updated protocol for computer
SC
guided proportional condylectomy provides a method to exactly reproduce the level of oste-
otomy, based on the creation of a 3D printed custom-made surgical guide, which fits the con-
U
AN
dylar head. The use of a surgical guide permitted to trace the precise level of osteotomy as
planned. Moreover, the surgical guide was designed to replicate the morphology of a new
M
condyle, making it unnecessary to perform a reshaping of the condylar head after condylecto-
D
TE
my. The intraoperative positioning of this custom-designed surgical guide on the lateral condy-
lar pole was straightforward and fast, thus providing a feasible solution to connect results of
EP
computer guided condylectomy with surgical maneuvers. Modern 3D-printers are widespread
C
and economically affordable, and rapid prototyping might become part of the daily surgical
AC
Postoperative CBCT after 1 year was three-dimensionally reconstructed and allowed to assess
PT
CONCLUSIONS
RI
Proportional condylectomy has the advantage of reducing the need for secondary orthognathic
SC
surgery. The updated protocol for proportional condylectomy introduces two novel key steps:
1) the exact position of the resection plane based on three-dimensional virtual mirroring and
U
AN
the definition of the vertical discrepancies; 2) the use of an intraoperative custom designed
surgical cutting guide to transfer the virtual planning in the operating room. A computer-
M
guided proportional condylectomy allows for precise reproduction of the virtual planning in
D
TE
the surgical field and provides advantages in terms of precision and predictability.
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
References
2. Kanishi D: 99mTc-{MDP} accumulation mechanisms in bone. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral
PT
Pathol 75: 239, 1993.
RI
3. Saridin CP, Raijmakers PGHM, Shamma S Al, Tuinzing DB, Becking AG: Comparison of
SC
different analytical methods used for analyzing SPECT scans of patients with unilateral
U
AN
4. Brusati R, Pedrazzoli M, Colletti G: Functional results after condylectomy in active
5. Farina R, Pintor F, Pérez J, Pantoja R, Berner D. Low condylectomy as the sole treatment
D
TE
for active condylar hyperplasia: facial, occlusal and skeletal changes. An observational
6. Jones RH, Tier GA. Correction of facial asymmetry as a result of unilateral condylar hy-
C
7. Delaire J, Gaillard A, Tulasne JF: [{The} place of condylectomy in the treatment of hyper-
9. Fariña R, Pintor F, Pérez J, Pantoja R, Berner D: Low condylectomy as the sole treatment
PT
for active condylar hyperplasia: Facial, occlusal and skeletal changes. An observational
RI
study. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 44: 217, 2015.
SC
10. Fariña R, Olate S, Raposo A, Araya I, Alister JP, Uribe F: High condylectomy versus pro-
U
AN
fac Surg 45: 72, 2016.
11. Higginson JA, Bartram AC, Banks RJ, Keith DJW: Condylar hyperplasia: current thinking.
M
12. Saridin CP, Gilijamse M, Kuik DJ, Veldhuis EC te, Tuinzing DB, Lobbezoo F, Becking AG:
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
FIGURE LEGENDS
C EP
identify asymmetry of the lower third and occlusal plane tilting. b) Virtual mirroring of contrala-
teral healthy side is superimposed to the side of condylar hyperplasia. c) the amount of vertical
Figure 3: Surgical phases. a) custom-designed condylar cutting guide is positioned over the
PT
condylar head. b) Detail. The surgical guide allows to create a curved osteotomy in order to
RI
replicate the preoperative shape of the condylar head. c) Condylar head after cutting guide is
SC
removed.
U
AN
Figure 4: Surface deviation analysis. Green color corresponds to neglectable discrepancies be-
tween preoperative and postoperative entities while red color accounts for differences. Range
M
is set to 1 mm difference detection. After one year, there is high similarity between preopera-
D
TE
TABLES
PT
RI
Age Gender Side of hyperplasia Clinical results after condylectomy Further treatment
SC
23 female right Satisfactory Elastic therapy and
Orthodontics
22 female right
Orthodontics
D
Orthodontics + orthog-
EP
nathic surgery
Orthodontics
AC
Orthodontics
Orthodontics
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Table 1: Demographic and clinical data of patients included in the study.
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Dear Editor and Reviewers,
PT
RI
Best regards,
SC
The Authors
U
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC