Tie-in Point

Flange
Sl. No. Tie-in Point Size Stress System Displacement
Class
(mm)

4.4
1 1-1405TP001 16" 300 # N-3024
(Axial)

18.4
2 1-1405TP002 16" 300 # N-3025
(Axial)

13.6
3 1-1405TP003 10" 600 # N-3024
(Vertical)

4 1-1405TP005 Hold Hold N-3054 Hold

0.5
5 1-1405TP010 6" 300 # N-3024
(Axial)
 Loads comparison
Tie-In Point Loads status
Load component -->> FX FY FZ MX MY
(N) (N) (N) (Nm) (Nm)

Loads exceeding LS 202-04 Observed 33887 3507 4772 8069 76556

Allowables LS 202-04 Loads 24500 27200 27200 30500 32600

Loads exceeding Observed 11792 6597 15703 4237 30261

Vendor Allowables Vendor Allowables 8500 10500 10500 8000 6500

Loads within LS 202-04

Allowables

Hold

Loads exceeding marginally Observed 888 2025 2555 1225 549

from Vendor Allowables Vendor Allowables 2000 2500 2500 1000 800
 Feedback / Suggested Solution
MZ
(Nm)
10753
32600

2449
8000

641
1000
Sl. No. Tie-in Point Size Flange # Stress System FP LS 202-04 Loads
1-1405TP001 16" 300 N-3024 Not possible OK
1
1-1405TP002 16" 300 N-3025 Not possible Exceeding
2
1-1405TP003 10" 600 N-3024 Not possible OK
3
1-1405TP005 2" Hold N-3054 Hold -
4

Can be maintained
5 1-1405TP010 6" 300 N-3024 Can be provided
within limits
 Displacement Remarks
4.4 mm Axial

18.4 mm Axial

13.6 mm Vertical

Load and fix point can be applied with

0.5 mm Axial additional measures (price impact will
be given after receipt from vendor)
Tie-in Point Stress System FX FY FZ MX MY MZ
Allowable 12000 10000 -12000 -10000 -10000 -8000
1-1405TP001 N-3024 Max-Ope -4207 -2870 -1404 1304 -10839 1505
Max-Design -32547 -3643 3144 -8075 -82876 10783

Allowable 10500 8500 -10500 -8000 -8000 -6500

1-1405TP002 N-3025 Max-Ope 1252 -4948 -5220 3071 6150 919
Max-Design 6058 -6594 -10974 4233 24915 930

Allowable 5000 4000 -5000 -3000 -3000 -2400

1-1405TP003 N-3024 Max-Ope 3814 -4640 -4713 2619 4028 -5310
Max-Design 3814 -5390 -6351 4010 4028 -5806

Allowable 1400 1000 -1400 -500 -500 -300

1-1405TP005 N-3054 Max-Ope -102 -600 -2833 134 -35 -270
Max-Design -264 -669 -3225 -340 -88 -539

1-1405TP008 N/A Allowable N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

Allowable 2500 2000 -2500 -1000 -1000 -800

1-1405TP010 N-3024 Max-Ope 126 -1512 -960 623 212 -159
Max-Design 153 -1953 -1037 1242 279 -187
Summary

MY exceeding marginally in OPE condition

FX, MY and MZ exceeding in Design condition

FZ and MY exceeding in Design condition

FY, MY and MZ exceeding in OPE condition

FY, FZ, MX, MY and MZ exceeding in Design condition

FZ exceeding in OPE condition

FZ and MZ exceeding in Design condition

Tie-in deleted in G2 P&ID

MX exceeding in Design condition

-876 -2025 -2555 -1225 -240 641 876
-888 -1972 -1650 797 -549 633 888
888
2025 2555 1225 240 641
1972 1650 797 549 633
2025 2555 1225 549 641
 Tie-in Point Observed Loads (Refer the below diag
Flange
Sl. No. Tie-in Point Size Stress System Displacement
Class FX FY
(mm)
(N) (N)
1 1-1405TP001 16" 300 # N-3024 DZ = 4.4 35000 15000

2 1-1405TP002 16" 300 # N-3025 DZ = 18.4 15000 10000

3 1-1405TP003 10" 600 # N-3024 DY = 13.6

4 1-1405TP005 Hold Hold N-3054 Hold Hold

5 1-1405TP010 6" 300 # N-3024 DZ = 0.5 2000 2500

ved Loads (Refer the below diagram for Axes system)
Tie-In Point Loads status
FZ MX MY MZ
(N) (Nm) (Nm) (Nm)
Loads exceeding LS 202-04
15000 15000 80000 15000
Allowables
Loads exceeding
20000 10000 35000 10000
Vendor Allowables
Loads within LS 202-04
Allowables
Hold Hold
Loads exceeding marginally
3000 2000 1000 1000
from Vendor Allowables