You are on page 1of 5

Laparoscopy and Robotics

Complications of
Transperitoneal Laparoscopic
Nephrectomy: A Single-center Experience
Bum Soo Kim, Eun Sang Yoo, and Tae Gyun Kwon
OBJECTIVES To present the incidence of complications of transperitoneal laparoscopic nephrectomy per-
formed for various indications during a 6-year period.
METHODS From 2002 to 2007, 505 transperitoneal laparoscopic nephrectomies were performed, consisting
of 125 live donor, 212 radical, 80 simple, and 28 partial nephrectomies and 60 nephroureter-
ectomies. We retrospectively analyzed the factors related to perioperative complications, includ-
ing the type of operation, body mass index, history of abdominal surgery, and American Society
of Anesthesiologists score.
RESULTS The overall complication rate was 13.7% (69/505). Major complications requiring open con-
version or reoperation occurred in 15 patients (3.0%). The remaining 54 patients experienced
minor surgical or postoperative medical problems. The mortality rate in our series was 0%. The
complication rates by the type of operation were not significantly different. Patients with a
history of abdominal surgery demonstrated slightly greater complication rates (19.2% vs 12.6%,
P ⫽ .069). When stratified by a body mass index of ⬍25 kg/m2 and ⬍25 kg/m2, no statistically
significant difference was found in the complication rates (13.1% vs 15.6%, respectively, P ⫽
.067). Patients with greater American Society of Anesthesiologists scores had greater compli-
cation rates (P ⫽ .038). The intraoperative complication rates decreased as our experience with
laparoscopic surgery increased (P ⫽ .042); however, the total complication rates remained
constant throughout the study period.
CONCLUSIONS In consideration of the contributing factors, the complication rates of transperitoneal laparo-
scopic nephrectomy were not related to the type of operation, body mass index, or history of
abdominal operation but to the American Society for Anesthesiologists score. Complications
unique to laparoscopic nephrectomy exist but they decrease with experience. UROLOGY 73:
1283–1287, 2009. © 2009 Published by Elsevier Inc.

S
ince the first laparoscopic nephrectomy was per- assessed to identify the risk factors associated with the
formed in 1991 by Clayman et al.,1 laparoscopy for perioperative complications.
renal malignancies and live kidney donation has
rapidly evolved and is becoming a part of the operative MATERIAL AND METHODS
repertoire of an increasing number of urologists. Clear
advantages to laparoscopy compared with open nephrec- From 2002 to December 2007, a single surgeon performed 505
tomy exist, including decreased postoperative pain, short- transperitoneal laparoscopic nephrectomies at our institution,
ened hospital stay, rapid recovery, and improved cosme- including 212 laparoscopic radical nephrectomies (LRNs), 125
sis.2-5 However, laparoscopic nephrectomy is associated laparoscopic donor nephrectomies (LDNs), 80 laparoscopic
simple nephrectomies (LSNs), 28 laparoscopic partial nephrec-
with unique complications and remains challenging for
tomies (LPNs), and 60 laparoscopic nephroureterectomies
beginners. In the present study, we analyzed the inci- (LNUs) (Table 1). The average patient age was 49.6 years
dence and types of complications occurring with trans- (range 9-89). Of the 505 patients, 290 were male and 215 were
peritoneal laparoscopic nephrectomy performed at our female. All surgeries, except for LDN, were performed using
institution during a 6-year period. Various factors were pure laparoscopy, and every LDN was performed with a hand-
assisted procedure. In the case of pure laparoscopic nephrec-
tomy, the pneumoperitoneum was obtained using a Veress
From the Department of Urology, Kyungpook National University Hospital, Daegu, needle, and 3 or 4 ports were used depending on the case. For
Korea hand-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy, a hand-assist device
Reprint requests: Tae Gyun Kwon, M.D., Department of Urology, Kyungpook
National University Hospital, 200 Dongduk-ro, Jung-gu, Daegu 700-721 Korea.
was placed through a 7-cm midline abdominal incision, and a
E-mail: tgkwon@knu.ac.kr 10-mm camera port was placed periumbilically. An additional
Submitted: July 7, 2008, accepted (with revisions): January 12, 2009 10-mm port was placed at the flank, and another 5-mm trocar

© 2009 Published by Elsevier Inc. 0090-4295/09/$34.00 1283


doi:10.1016/j.urology.2009.01.017
Table 1. Patient characteristics and complications stratified by operation type
Characteristic LDN LSN LRN LNU LPN Total
Patients (n) 125 80 212 60 28 505
Age (y)
Mean 39.7 41.3 56.1 63.2 47.6 49.6
Range 18-64 9-72 28-89 30-81 26-68 9-89
Sex (n)
Male 64 29 137 40 20 290
Female 61 51 75 20 8 215
Side
Left 90 42 85 34 17 268
Right 35 38 127 26 11 237
Complications (n)
Intraoperative 8 4 9 6 1 28 (5.5)
Vascular injury 4 2 3 1 0 10 (2.0)
Bowel injury 1 0 0 2 0 3 (0.6)
Splenic injury 0 0 1 2 0 3 (0.6)
Diaphragmatic injury 0 0 1 1 0 2 (0.4)
Suspicious pancreatic injury 3 1 4 0 0 8 (1.6)
Liver injury 0 1 0 0 0 1 (0.2)
Renal parenchymal bleeding 0 0 0 0 1 1 (0.2)
Postoperative 10 4 17 0 3 34 (6.7)
Chylous ascites 6 0 12 0 0 18 (3.2)
Wound infection 2 0 1 0 0 3 (0.6)
Delayed bleeding 0 1 1 0 2 4 (0.8)
Pleural effusion 0 1 1 0 1 3 (0.6)
Ileus 1 2 2 0 0 5 (1.0)
Atelectasis 1 0 0 0 0 1 (0.2)
Medical 1 0 3 3 0 7 (1.4)
Infectious diarrhea 0 0 1 0 0 1 (0.2)
Azotemia 0 0 2 0 0 2 (0.4)
Hepatic dysfunction 1 0 0 0 0 1 (0.2)
Delirium 0 0 0 3 0 3 (0.6)
Total 19 (15.2) 8 (10.0) 29 (13.7) 9 (15.0) 4 (14.3) 69 (13.7)
LDN ⫽ laparoscopic donor nephrectomy; LSN ⫽ laparoscopic simple nephrectomy; LRN ⫽ laparoscopic radical nephrectomy; LNU ⫽
laparoscopic nephroureterectomy; LPN, laparoscopic partial nephrectomy.
Data in parentheses are percentages.

was placed in the subcostal area, if needed. We used 3 or 4 patients (3.0%). The mortality rate was 0%. According
Hem-o-Lok clips, 10 or 15 mm, to control the renal artery. The to the complication classification system suggested by
renal vein was controlled by 3 or 4 Hem-o-Lok clips, 15 mm, or Clavien et al.,6 11 (2.2%), 43 (8.5%), and 15 (3%)
1 endovascular gastrointestinal anastomosis stapler. For LPN,
complications were grade I, II, III, respectively. Grade IV
the renal pedicle was clamped using a laparoscopic bulldog
complications did not occur in our series (Table 2).
clamp. The specimen was removed using an Endo Catch re-
trieval bag (Autosuture, London, UK) through a 7-cm lower The most common intraoperative complications were
abdominal incision in LRN and LSN. In LNU, a Gibson vascular injuries inn 10 patients that could not be con-
incision was made to dissect the distal ureter in an open fashion trolled laparoscopically and required open conversion. Of
and remove the specimen. We retrospectively analyzed the the 14 adjacent organ injuries, suspicious pancreatic in-
perioperative complications using various parameters, including juries (n ⫽ 8) were the most common. Pancreatic injuries
body mass index, previous history of abdominal surgery and were suspected when the postoperative drain amylase and
American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) score. Student’s lipase levels were elevated. All were managed conserva-
t test was used for statistical analysis, and statistical significance
tively. No severe parenchymal or ductal injury occurred.
was considered at P ⬍ .05.
One patient experienced a minor liver injury that was
managed conservatively. Splenic injuries occurred in 3
RESULTS patients; 1 was treated conservatively and 2 required
A total of 69 (13.7%) complications occurred in 505 open conversion to undergo splenectomy. Minor dia-
consecutive cases, including 28 (5.5%) intraoperative phragmatic injuries were found in 2 patients and were
(directly attributable to the technical execution at sur- repaired with laparoscopic suture. In these patients, post-
gery), 34 (6.7%) postoperative (directly or not directly operative chest x-rays were obtained to rule out pneumo-
attributable to the technical execution and identified thorax. Three bowel injuries occurred. One was a simple
after surgery), and 7 (1.4%) medical complications (Ta- injury of the small bowel caused by electrocautery during
ble 1). Major complications, which required conversion LNU and managed by laparoscopic suturing. The remain-
to an open procedure or reoperation, occurred in 15 ing 2 cases were unrecognized duodenal injuries that

1284 UROLOGY 73 (6), 2009


Table 2. Complication rates stratified by variables studied
LDN LSN LRN LNU LPN
Variable (n ⫽ 125) (n ⫽ 80) (n ⫽ 212) (n ⫽ 60) (n ⫽ 28) Total (n) P Value
Grade .105
I 2 1 4 3 1 11/505 (2.2)
II 12 5 22 2 2 43/505 (8.5)
III 5 2 3 4 1 15/505 (3.0)
History of abdominal surgery .069
Patients (n) 14/98 7/70 21/179 8/55 4/25 54/427 (12.6)
Complication 5/27 1/10 8/33 1/5 0/3 15/78 (19.2)
BMI (kg/m2) .067
⬍25 14/107 5/68 23/137 6/52 3/26 51/390 (13.1)
ⱖ25 5/18 3/12 6/75 3/8 1/2 18/115 (15.6)
ASA score* .038
1 19/125 2/43 5/53 0/20 1/17 8/133 (6.0)
2 5/33 20/142 5/31 2/9 32/215 (14.9)
3 1/4 4/17 4/9 1/2 10/32 (28.1)
Total 19 8 29 9 4 69/505 (13.7)
BMI ⫽ body mass index; ASA ⫽ American Society of Anesthesiologists; other abbreviations as in Table 1.
Data in parentheses are percentages.
* Complication rates by ASA score compared, except for LDN group.

Table 3. Complication rates by year


2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 P Value
Total operations (n) 26 59 87 129 106 98
Complications (n)
Intraoperative 3 (11.5) 7 (11.9) 5 (5.7) 7 (5.4) 3 (2.8) 3 (3.1) .042
Postoperative 1 (3.8) 2 (3.4) 5 (5.7) 7 (5.4) 9 (8.5) 10 (10.2)
Medical 0 (0) 0 (0) 1 (1.1) 1 (0.8) 3 (2.8) 2 (2.0)
Total 4 (15.4) 9 (15.3) 11 (12.6) 15 (11.6) 15 (14.2) 15 (15.3) .957
Data in parentheses are percentages.

required exploratory laparotomy. During LPN, 1 case of cally significant difference was found in each surgery
persistent parenchymal bleeding occurred that could not group (Table 2). For patients with previous abdominal
be controlled laparoscopically. Because the tumor was 4 surgery, the complication rate (19.2%) was greater than
cm and 50 minutes of warm ischemic time had already for patients who had not undergone previous abdominal
passed, we converted to laparoscopic radical nephrec- surgery (12.6%); however, the difference was not statis-
tomy instead of open partial nephrectomy. tically significant (P ⫽ .069; Table 2). All patients were
Of the postoperative complications, chylous ascites (n ⫽ subdivided into 2 groups according to their BMI (nono-
18) was the most common. Most patients were treated bese, ⬍25 kg/m2; and overweight or obese, ⬎25 kg/m2)
conservatively with total parenteral nutrition for 3-7 for comparison of complication rates. Stratifying the data
days. However, 1 patient required surgical management by BMI for obesity, the comparison between overweight
because of persistent chyle drainage despite conservative or obese and nonobese patients demonstrated no signif-
management for 2 months. Delayed bleeding occurred in icant difference in the complication rates (15.6% vs
4 patients (2 after LPN, 1 after LSN, and 1 after LRN). 13.1%, respectively; P ⫽ .067; Table 2). The complica-
Of the 2 patients who had undergone LRN, 1 required tion rates of the laparoscopic nephrectomies, except for
open abdominal exploration, One LPN patient under- LDN, had a close relationship with a high ASA score
went angioembolization, and the remaining 2 patients (P ⫽ .038; Table 2). No statistically significant difference
were treated conservatively. The remaining minor post- was found in the total complication rates between the
operative complications included 5 cases of persistent early (2002-2003) and late (2006-2007) period of lapa-
ileus that lasted for ⬎5 days, 3 wound infections, 3 roscopic surgery (P ⫽ .957). However, the intraoperative
pleural effusions, and 1 atelectasis. All were managed complication rate decreased as the experience increased
conservatively. (P ⫽ .042; Table 3).
The complication rates according to the operation
type were not signficantly different statistically (P ⫽
.076): 13.7% (29/212) in LRN, 15.2% (19/125) in LDN, COMMENT
10.0% (8/80) in LSN, 15.0% (9/60) in LNU, and 14.3% Laparoscopic skills evolve with repetition, and a slow
(4/28) in LPN (Table 1). Comparing the incidence of learning curve exists for achieving these skills. Vallan-
major (grade III) and minor (grade I and II) complica- cien et al.7 suggested in a review of laparoscopic urologic
tions according to the Clavien classification, no statisti- complications that experience with a minimum of 50

UROLOGY 73 (6), 2009 1285


difficult cases is needed to acquire adequate laparoscopic The most fatal is the unrecognized bowel injury by inad-
skills. In their study, the complication rate was 13.3% for vertent electrocautery out of the laparoscopic view.
the first 100 cases and subsequently decreased to 3.6% for Therefore, careful insertion of the Veress needle and the
the remaining cases. In our series, the intraoperative first trocar is important. Moreover, careful attention is
complication rates decreased as the experience with lapa- always needed to avoid unrecognized electrocauterization
roscopic surgery increased; however, the total complica- out of the laparoscopic view. Bishoff et al.14 reported 8
tion rate remained constant throughout the study period. bowel injuries (0.8%) in 915 patients, including 4 unrec-
This result might have been because we performed more ognized injuries. Similarly, 3 bowel injuries (0.6%), in-
complex laparoscopic nephrectomies in the latter period. cluding 2 cases of unrecognized injury, were found in our
For example, chylous ascites occurred frequently in a series.
recent series because we performed excessive lymph node Chylous ascites is a rare complication after major ret-
dissection during LRN. roperitoneal surgery such as nephrectomy. With the use
During laparoscopic surgery, fatal complications such of laparoscopic nephrectomy increasing, not a few cases
as major vascular injuries or adjacent organ injuries can of chylous ascites after laparoscopic nephrectomy have
occur. In such cases, prompt and adequate management is been reported.15-18 It is unknown whether laparoscopic
mandatory, and open conversion is often required. The lymphadenectomy tends to cause postoperative lym-
incidence of major vascular and adjacent organ injuries phatic leakage more frequently than does open surgery.
has been reported at 1.7%-2.5% and 0.25%-0.4%, respec- However, coagulation procedures during laparoscopic
tively.8-10 The major cause of vascular injuries includes a surgery often result in incomplete lymphostasis. Lym-
lack of meticulous dissection skill, malfunctions of clips phatic leakage can occur after a patient resumes oral
or staplers, accidental thermal injury, and unrecognized intake and lymphatic flow increases significantly. Postop-
aberrant vessels or severe adhesions around the hilar area. erative chylous ascites are closely related to skeletoniza-
In our series, 6 vascular complications occurred that were tion of the renal artery, vein, or aorta in LDN and
caused by factors related to the endovascular gastrointes- para-aortic lymph node dissection in LRN. Most patients
tinal anastomosis stapler. A clip in the line of the can be treated conservatively with total parenteral nutri-
stapler caused improper placing of staples and severe tion, a medium-chain triglyceride diet, or a somatostatin
bleeding. Therefore, minimizing the use of clips analog.16 However, prompt surgical repair is recommended
around the renal hilum is important to reduce the risk for refractory cases.16,17 Moreover, if severe symptoms, in-
of stapler malfunction. With increased laparoscopic cluding abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, and severe
experience, bleeding can often be controlled with var- hypoproteinemia cannot be managed medically, early
ious laparoscopic methods, including compression, su- surgical intervention is essential. In our series, most cases
turing, clipping, and cauterization. However, cases of of chylous ascites (17/18) were successfully managed con-
hemodynamic instability or brisk bleeding that cannot servatively. However, 1 patient required surgical repair
be controlled laparoscopically require conversion to an because of persistent chylous ascites despite conservative
open procedure.11 The incidence of open conversion management for 2 months.
due to vascular injuries has been reported at 1.5%- The pneumoperitoneum used during laparoscopic sur-
4%,11-13 similar to our results (2%). gery can tamponade the veins and mask intraoperative
Adjacent organ injuries are not uncommon complica- venous bleeding. This can be a cause of postoperative
tions during laparoscopic nephrectomy. The liver, spleen, delayed bleeding. Therefore, careful inspection of the
pancreas, and diaphragm are adherent to the kidney and operative field and trocar site with the intra-abdominal
can easily be injured. To minimize the risk of injury, it is pressure lowered to 5 mm Hg is mandatory before exiting
important to recognize the anatomic position between the abdominal cavity. Serial hematocrit measurements
the kidney and other adjacent organs, as well as mini- and physical examination can usually secure the diagno-
mizing spleen or liver retraction. Minor injuries of the sis. Most postoperative bleeding can be managed conser-
liver or spleen without severe bleeding can be managed vatively, except for severe and persistent bleeding. In our
conservatively. In the case of massive bleeding, however, series, 4 cases of delayed bleeding occurred and 2 were
it is mandatory not to hesitate to execute open conver- managed conservatively. One LRN patient had bleeding
sion. In our series, 1 liver, 3 splenic, 2 diaphragmatic, and from an epigastric artery that required reoperation. The
8 minor pancreatic injuries occurred. Most were managed remaining case of bleeding after LPN was managed by
conservatively with a laparoscopic method. However, 2 selective angioembolization.
(0.4%) of the splenic injuries required open splenectomy Abdominal surgery promotes the formation of adhe-
because of severe bleeding. The incidence of splenic sions and can cause significant difficulties during reop-
injury requiring splenectomy was similar to that in other eration. Furthermore, previous surgery at the same ana-
series (0.7%).11 tomic site can be associated with high rates of morbidity.
Bowel injuries usually occur during Veress needle ac- However, it has been thought that previous laparoscopic
cess, the first trocar insertion, paracolic gutter dissection, surgery leaves fewer adhesions compared with open sur-
or incidental electrocauterization during any procedure. gery. In our series, 73 patients had undergone previous

1286 UROLOGY 73 (6), 2009


open abdominal surgery, including 25 appendectomies, References
19 hysterectomies, 15 cholecystectomies, 6 gastrecto- 1. Clayman RV, Kavoussi LR, Soper NJ, et al. Laparoscopic nephrec-
mies, 3 bowel perforation repairs, 2 pyeloplasties, 2 ure- tomy: Initial case report. J Urol. 1991;146:278-282.
terolithotomies, and 1 nephrolithotomy. The complica- 2. Dunn MD, Portis AJ, Shalhav AL, et al. Laparoscopic versus open
tion rate for these patients was 19.2% (14/73). The radical nephrectomy: a 9-year experience. J Urol. 2000;164:1153-
1159.
remaining 5 patients had undergone previous laparo-
3. McDougall EM, Clayman RV, Elashry OM. Laparoscopic radical
scopic surgery, including 2 hysterectomies, 2 cholecystec- nephrectomy for renal tumor: the Washington University experi-
tomies, and 1 renal cystectomy, and the complication ence. J Urol. 1996;155:1180-1185.
rate was 20% (1/5). In the previous urologic surgery 4. Ratner LE, Kavoussi LR, Sroka M, et al. Laparoscopic assisted live
group (same anatomic site), only 1 postoperative com- donor nephrectomy—a comparison with the open approach. Trans-
plication (pleural effusion) and no intraoperative com- plantation. 1997;63:229-233.
plications occurred. The complication rate was not af- 5. Shalhav AL, Dunn MD, Portis AJ, et al. Laparoscopic nephroure-
terectomy for upper tract transitional cell cancer: the Washington
fected by the type of previous abdominal surgery. University experience. J Urol. 2000;163:1100-1104.
It has been well documented in urologic reports that 6. Clavien PA, Sanabria JR, Strasberg SM. Proposed classification of
obese patients have a greater rate of postoperative com- complications of surgery with examples of utility in cholecystec-
plications. Appropriately, it has been considered that tomy. Surgery. 1992;111:518-526.
obesity is closely related to technical difficulties and poor 7. Vallancien G, Cathelineau X, Baumert H, et al. Complications of
outcomes after laparoscopic surgery; therefore, obesity is transperitoneal laparoscopic surgery in urology: review of 1,311
procedures at a single center. J Urol. 2002;168:23-26.
regarded as a relative contraindication to laparoscopy.19 8. Fahlenkamp D, Rassweiler J, Fornara P, et al. Complications of
However, it is not clear that obesity is a risk factor for laparoscopic procedures in urology: experience with 2407 proce-
complications during laparoscopic nephrectomy. For ex- dures at 4 German Centers. J Urol. 1999;162:765-770.
ample, Feder et al.20 reported fewer complications in 9. Thiel R, Adams JB, Schulam PG, et al. Venous dissection injuries
obese patients than in nonobese patients. In our study, no during laparoscopic urological surgery. J Urol. 1996;155:1874-1876.
significant difference was found between the nonobese 10. Meraney AM, Samee AA, Gill IS. Vascular and bowel complica-
tions during retroperitoneal laparoscopic surgery. J Urol. 2002;168:
and overweight or obese groups. 1941-1944.
Recent studies have shown that greater ASA scores 11. Simon SD, Castle EP, Ferrigni RG, et al. Complications of lapa-
correlate closely with the complication rates of urologic roscopic nephrectomy: the Mayo Clinic experience. J Urol. 2004;
laparoscopic surgery.12,13 Our results also suggest that the 171:1447-1450.
ASA score is a strong predictor for complications, except 12. Permpongkosol S, Link RE, Su LM, et al. Complications of 2,775
for in the LDN group. This trend suggests an expected urological laparoscopic procedures: 1993-2005. J Urol. 2007;177:
580-585.
baseline complication rate solely associated with patient 13. Parsons JK, Varkarakis I, Rha KH, et al. Complications of abdom-
comorbidity. inal urologic laparoscopy: longitudinal five-year analysis. Urology.
2004;63:27-32.
CONCLUSIONS 14. Bishoff JT, Allaf ME, Kirkels W, et al. Laparoscopic bowel injury:
Incidence and clinical presentation. J Urol. 1999;161:887-890.
Complications that are unique to laparoscopy exist, but 15. Shafizadeh SF, Daily PP, Baliga P, et al. Chylous ascites secondary
they should decrease with experience. In our analysis of to laparoscopic donor nephrectomy. Urology. 2002;60:3456-3459.
the contributing factors, the complication rates of lapa- 16. Leibovitch I, Mor Y, Golomb J, et al. Chylous ascites after radical
roscopic transperitoneal nephrectomy were not related to nephrectomy and inferior vena cava thrombectomy: successful con-
the operation type, BMI, or history of abdominal surgery, servative management with somatostatin analogue. Eur Urol. 2002;
41:220-222.
but were related to the ASA score. Despite a progressive
17. Molina WR, Desai MM, Gill IS. Laparoscopic management of
increase in the complexity of laparoscopic transperito- chylous ascites after donor nephrectomy. J Urol. 2003;170:1938.
neal nephrectomy with time, the overall rate of compli- 18. Nishizawa K, Ito N, Yamamoto S, et al. Successful laparoscopic
cations did not increase significantly and the intraoper- management of chylous ascites following laparoscopic radical ne-
ative complication rate decreased as the experience with phrectomy. Int J Urol. 2006;13:619-621.
laparoscopic surgery increased. We believe that appropri- 19. Kapoor A, Nassir A, Chew B, et al. Comparison of laparoscopic
radical renal surgery in morbidly obese and non-obese patients. J
ate understanding of the possible complications and man-
Endourol. 2004;18:657-660.
agement techniques is essential to reduce the risk of 20. Feder MT, Patel MB, Melman A, et al. Comparison of open and
complications and improve the safety of laparoscopic laparoscopic nephrectomy in obese and nonobese patients: out-
transperitoneal nephrectomy. comes stratified by body mass index. J Urol. 2008;180:79-83.

UROLOGY 73 (6), 2009 1287

You might also like