Find a course 

All posts Business Care Careers Early Years Education

Mental Health GCSEs  A Levels

Knowledge Hub » GCSEs » GCSE Psychology » Trait theory of personality

Trait theory of personality

June 6, 2022

In this post
Allport
Cattell
Strengths of trait theory
Weaknesses of trait theory
There are many criticisms of the way in which the humanistic theory attempts to
measure personality. Therefore, alternative measures have been put forward which
try to do the following:

 Measure personality more scientifically using more reliable methods

 Acknowledge the importance that genetic factors may play in the
development of personality
 Acknowledge that there are traits which people have in common

A ‘trait’ is something that refers to a way in which we generally tend to describe a

person. Therefore, you might refer to someone as being ‘short tempered’ or ‘kind’
or ‘needy’ – these are all traits that we might apply to ourselves or to other people.

A trait is also thought to be a stable characteristic that remains the same regardless
of the situation. Therefore, if three people were all caught in a rainstorm without a
coat, the short-tempered person might become angry about this, the kind person
might offer to let them walk under a shelter at their own expense and the needy
person might feel aggrieved that they have not been offered the shelter because
they feel like they will be more inconvenienced by the situation and therefore need
it more.

One individual does not have one trait; according to the trait theory, someone will
have several traits, which combine to make their personality. Allport and Cattell are
two of the main researchers in this area and we shall now consider their work.

Allport
Gordon Allport was one of the first researchers to come up with a trait theory. His
main idea was that personality came about like a series of building blocks; referred
to here, of course, as traits. He further believed that personality was biologically
determined but could be shaped by someone’s environment.

He argued that there are three classes of trait:

  Cardinal traits: these are the traits around which someone organises their
whole life. They are thought to develop later in life and become synonymous
with a person because that is how people primarily see them – ‘greedy Sam’
or ‘angry Tony’ for example
 Central traits: these refer to major characteristics of someone’s
personality and lead to its foundation, such as shy, intelligent, deceitful or
unkind
 Secondary traits: these refer to traits which refer to patterns of behaviour
that only occur under specific circumstances, for example a person who is
usually confident becomes nervous when they have to walk over a bridge

Cattell
Raymond Cattell based his theory on sources other than self-report, which can be
an unreliable method of testing anything, as it is subject to individual bias.

He also argued that other methods of exploring personality were too narrow and
that it was also necessary to consider other areas when determining someone’s
personality.

The traits were identified using factor analysis on three different kinds of data:

 L Data: life data, such as school grades and employment records

 Q Data: a questionnaire given to people in order to rate their personality
 T Data: objective testing designed to ‘tap into’ a person’s personality

Cattell contended that there were sixteen major source traits which everyone
possessed to a greater or lesser degree, and these were classified as either:
  Surface traits: very obvious traits that others can easily identify
 Source traits: less visible to other people and may be strong motivators
of some kinds of behaviour

Using this information, Cattell developed a personality test known as the 16PF
which has been used to provide personality profiles and which has been used quite
extensively within applied psychology.

Activity – Cattell’s 16PF model

You can have a go yourself at determining your personality according to Cattell’s

research here: http://similarminds.com/cattell-16-factor.html

Despite it being a new and unique way of trying to determine the origins of
personality, critics of Cattell contend that his categories are too rigid and exclude
people from fitting into them easily.
His personality model has also been criticised for being over simplified and
superficial and critics argue that his model is too focused on classifying people as
similar, meaning that we become blinded to the ways in which people are different.
Strengths of trait theory
 It acknowledges the potential role of biological influences in personality
development
 It acknowledges that although most traits are stable that there can be
some variation in behaviour dependent upon the situation

Weaknesses of trait theory

 It cannot predict an individual’s behaviour; research shows that even if
someone scores highly for a particular trait, they may not actually behave that
way in real life
  Although it acknowledges that there are differences between individuals,
it fails to explain why this might be the case
 Loehlin, Willerman and Horn (1988) found that only 50% of the variations
of scores on personality factors are due to inherited traits. This suggests that
environmental factors are also important
 Much of the research is based on the findings from self-reports, which
are open to bias.

Interested in a
Psychology GCSE?

We offer the Edexcel

GCSE in Psychology
through our online
campus.

Learn more about

our Psychology
GCSE courses

Read another one of our posts

Exploring How To Building Most

Our Planet: Communicate Rapport Common
Key Effectively With Clients Childhood
Concepts With Clients in Illnesses
from IGCSE in Care Counselling February 20, 2024

Geography March 11, 2024 February 20, 2024

 March 11, 2024

Read this article Read this Read this

article article
Read this
article

A Day in Crisis Promoting Top Five

the Life of a Intervention STEM Qualities
Zookeeper in Social Learning in Needed to
February 20, 2024 Care Early Become a
February 20, 2024 Childhood Playworker
February 20, 2024 February 16, 2024

Read this
article Read this
article Read this Read this
article article

Popular courses
Childcare
Teaching Assistant
Business
Health & Social Care
 Join the Online Learning College and bring GCSEs
the way you learn into the 21st century. CPD Courses
All courses

Quick links Get in touch

Home Online Learning College
Distance Learning 74 New North Road
Online Campus Huddersfield
Tutor Support HD1 5NE
FAQs
Contact T: 0800 772 0887
E: info@ol-college.com

© Online Learning College 2024

