Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
A stratum of bentonite in the North Park (?) formation near Granby, Colorado, is
composed largely of a dioctahedral Ca-montmorillonite whose formula is calculated
to be
Xo.86
4'
(Ah.8,Feo.~oMgo.7~Mno.~)(Alo.~oSiT.6o)02o(OH),.
Na +, K § Li+, H § NHd, Ca+§ and Mg *+ modifications were stored at 52 percent
relative humidity and at 105~ C-110~ C. Results of X-ray diffraction, differential
thermal, and thermal balance analysis depend upon the exchangeable cation and prior
treatment. As with many montmorillonoids, d(001) ----22.7--30.1 .A. under room condi-
tions ; a0 ----5.20 A and bo----9.00 A. The (001) interference indicates that the unit cell
typically includes two packets, or possibly more, which may be derived geometrically
from each other by a glide of 1.73 A. along (1]-0) and 180~ rotation. Weight loss above
190~ C-367~ C exceeds that indicated by the Hofmann structure but conforms reasona-
bly with loss indicated by a structure after that proposed by Edelman. Inverted Si-O
tetrahedra are presumed to equal the number of univalent cations
It is suggested that the exchangeable cations form hydroxides during thermal analysis
by reaction with ( O H ) - at the apex of inverted Si-O tetrahedra. The resulting HQO
and NH4OH are lost during thermal analysis, thus explaining excessive weight loss.
Ca(OH), and Mg(OH), so produced release one mole of H.O during thermal analysis.
KOH, NaOH, and LiOH are not decomposed below 1,000~ C.
Thermal products vary with exchangeable cation and crystallinity increases with
prior drying. The Li+ and Ca++modifications produce beta-quartz and alpha-cristobalite
with spinel and glass, whereas the other modifications produce only spinel and glass.
INTRODUCTION
The following report summarizes our initial studies to establish by X-ray
diffraction and thermal studies the mineralogic n a t u r e of a bentonite en-
countered in the f o u n d a t i o n of the W i l l o w Creek p u m p i n g plant near
Granby, Colorado. T h e f o u n d a t i o n is a part of a sedimentary sequence
tentatively correlated with the N o r t h P a r k formation of Miocene age. I n
this locality, the N o r t h P a r k ( ? ) f o r m a t i o n mainly is composed of alter-
n a t i n g strata of sandstone a n d siltstone ; beds of claystone and conglomerate
are sparse.
* Deceased.
146
MIELENZ~ SCHIELTZ. AND KING 147
Purified
Natural montmorillonite,
Component bentonite Na treated ~
SiO, 51.23 57.68
AhO* 18.98 19.72
Fe,O8 3.83 4.71
TiO~ 0.57 0.76
MnO Tr. 0.41
MgO 3.86 3.48
CaO 3.76 Tr.
Na,O 0.93 n.d.
K,O 0.54 n.d.
H,O (+105 ~ C) 6.21 7.05
H,O (--105 ~ C) 9.17 4.14
P~O5 0.00 0.00
Total 99.08 97.95
a Includes 2.5 percent of quartz.
148 ]~,XCHANGEABLE CATION ~FFECT ON X-RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERNS
Milliequivalents
per 100 g.
Component or property of sample
Cation exchange capacity 95.0
Extractable sodium 2.15
Water soluble sodium 0.13
Exchangeable sodium 2.02
Extractable potassium 0.70
Water soluble potassium 0.05
Exchangeable potassium 0.65
Extractable calcium 111.2
Water soluble calcium 3.2
Exchangeable calcium 108.0
Extractable magnesium 13.6
Water soluble magnesium 1.0
Exchangeable magnesium 12.6
Exchangeable calcium and magnesium, by difference 92.332
Exchangeable calcium and magnesium, by extraction 120.62
1Determined by Methods 18 and 19 of the U.S. Salinity Laboratory (Richards, 1954,
pp. 100-101).
2The discrepancy in these two values indicates the presence of compounds of calcium
and magnesium which are soluble in neutral ammonium acetate solution but insoluble
in distilled water.
K~~J f
w
n.-
n--
ILl
(1.
Z~
LU
I--
.--I
Ca§ -'~
I--
Z
b.I
n"
ILl
I,.r
Q
a§ '~
F
HEATING RATE II~
WILLOW CREEK MONTMORILLONITE
A F T E R H U M I D I F I C A T I O N A T 52% R . H .
O IOO 200 300 4~ r,oo eoo 76o 8~o 9~ ~ .oo
TEMPERATURE ( D E G . C.)
NO "1"
~~_ ...... _..~/-~~___
rw
...I-.- -,,,
-
t-
; -----\ _
z
" ' -
Li +
~
I00
E
15C
200
.!~ -,..Z_: "-- .--.. ~
\x \
K+
0
__i
I--
-r"
~{\ ......
',~
.........
"--NH4+
(.9 250
IJJ
\'\-""~1:~---............' .... Li +
300 "'-:',............ H§
.~.. ("n ++ i
HEATING RATE 5 " C . / M I N . ~---"~
~-,~-i
WILLOW CREEK MONTMORILLONITE
Z AFTERI IHUMIDIFICATIONI
i T A T 52*/oiR. [H"
o too 200 3oo 400 5oo eoo zoo BOO 900 1000
T E M P E R A T U R E (DEG. C.)
of the base weight, that is, the weight of the sample following volatilization
of all adsorbed water (Table I V ) .
After prior drying of the samples at 105 ~ C-110 ~ C to constant weight,
all of the cationic modifications except those containing K + or NH4 § regain
water during heating until the furnace temperature approaches 1 0 0 ~
(Fig. 4 ) . In the range from room temperature to 190 ~ C-225 ~ C the sam-
ples lose 0.50 to 6.96 percent in weight, the maximum being from the Mg +§
modification (Table I V ) . Only for the Mg +~ modification does the shoulder
beginning at 225 ~ C persist as an indication that water of cation hydration
is being released. It is interesting to note that the dehydration endotherm
produced by the N H [ modification during differential thermal analysis does
not change in size with oven drying even though the weight loss in this
temperature range is reduced by a factor of more than 10.
In the temperature range between 380 ~ C and 505 ~ C all of the cationic
1V~IELENZ, SCHIELTZ, AND K ~ 153
~2
v
oo ~ ~ ~ ~
.N
~,~ ~ ',~ ,,
~,,, ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~
dO
~o
o~
'L'~~ ,Ib,,9
~:~ ~. . .
, .~ . .
~ o~ ~ ~
o o
0i-,,
I cqeo
t J ~ . t i ~ .
r ,,,Q
9 ~o ~o ,.-,~ ,-,~ ~o ~o =~
~'~'~ o ~ ~''~ o r ~'-'~
0 0
0
o 0
+~ ,,~ ,H
154 EXCHANGEABLE CATION EFFECT ON X-RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERNS
o
o.~
D.,
Jd
o o
tm
0
',~0o
0
D 0 0
o ~o ~o ~o ~o ~o~ ~o~ ~
m
0 0
m
. ~ o~
~.)
0 o
+~ + ,.t r
1V~IELENZ~ SCHIELTZ~ AND K I N G 155
o_7~S.f
~o I
2o i
30 ~'~''~ ~ <.(,........ . ",,, '\ _
40 - -
50
g so
~ 70
E 80 - -
\ ! \ ........
(/)
u) 90 \.,. ~ _ .
0
._l
I-- . ................ H +
"1-
(.9
,T, mo
130
~
g
9
o ~g
~
~0
~ ~/~
9~ ~I~
i |~g 0
~e
i 9
.[--~ ~
o "g
m
I
+~ +
N
158 E X C H A N G E A B L E CATION EFFECT O N X-RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERNS
~I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
o ~
~J~u
~ / ~
~
o ~ / ~ '~
~/~o w
o g~
o~
z
=
~ " ~ o ~ ,~
o ,.
o
~ =
o
~0
~.~
o
Izl
~o
N
MIELENZ, SCHIELTZ, AND KING 159
and usually has been rejected because the suggested structure requires ex-
cessive water loss during dehydroxylafion inasmuch as each inverted Si-O
tetrahedron requires addition of a hydroxyl group to the octahedral layer
as well as one at the apex of the inverted tetrahedron. In a later paper
(1947, p. 4), Edelman accepted the possibility that the number of inverted
tetrahedra might be less than was proposed originally.
I f it is assumed that the inversion of the Si-O tetrahedra is related elec-
trostatically and numerically to the cation exchange capacity, a reasonable
explanation of the thermal data can be developed. Assuming that one Si-O
tetrahedron is inverted for each exchangeable cation, the H o f m a n n - E n d e l l -
Wilm structure becomes as follows:
Content of Unit Cell Charge
Xo.,, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,.. 0.43
(OH) 0.,. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -- 0.43
Sio.,, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.72
Oe.0o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.00
Si3.3TAlo.,o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.08
(OH),.,,O ................................................ -- 9.57
Al2.~,Feo.,oMgo.,,Mno.o, ............... 9 ..................... 11.54
(OH),.,80,.~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ -- 9.57
Si3.8,Alo.,o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.08
Os.~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.00
Si. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.72
(OH) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -- 0..43
Xo.,, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.43
Net charge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.00
According to this arrangement 0.43 of each four Si-O tetrahedra are
inverted, or approximately 1 in 11. This structure is really a compromise
between the Hofmann-Endell-Wilm structure and the Edelman-Favajee
structure inasmuch as only 6 of 7 unit cells, on the average, will differ at
all from the Hofmann-Endell-Wilm structure. The possible hydroxyl
water in the proposed structure (including both that derived from the
( O H ) groups in the interlayer space and that from those in the octahedral
layer) ranges from 6.56 to 6.85 percent, depending upon the atomic weight
and valence of the exchangeable cation. I f the exchange capacity is re-
duced by a factor of 7 to 12 percent to compensate for cation exchange
at broken edges and corners of the lattice (Cornet, 1943, p. 226), the excess
hydroxyl water will be decreased proportionately. W a t e r of dehydroxyla-
tion from the octahedral layer theoretically i'anges from 5.57 to 5.82 percent.
As will be indicated below, all of the potential hydroxyl water may not be
released during the thermal analysis due to formation in the (001) interlayer
space of hydroxides which are not decomposed below 1,000 ~ C.
Inversion of a Si-O tetrahedron means that (1) the Si .... nests in the
same three O - - at the base of the tetrahedron but is shifted to the opposite
side of the plane containing the centers of the oxygen ions, a distance of
1.04 A approximately parallel to the "c" axis and (2) an ( O H ) - is affixed
to this Si .... by virtue of the polarity of the Si-O tetrahedron resulting
16G EXCHANGEABLECATION EFFECT ON X-RAY DIFFRACTION PATTERNS
from the asymmetrical position of the Si .... . The exchangeable cation like-
wise is held weakly to the ( O H ) - , which, like an H 2 0 molecule, becomes
strongly polar. In this structure, the electrostatic field of the Si .... may
be considered to replace one H § of the H20 molecule and the exchangeable
cation to be bonded to the ( O H ) - at the polar area opposite the location of
the Si .... and H § Both the adsorbed cation and the ( O H ) - should be
subject to exchange reactions.
The inverted position of the Si .... may depend upon the substitution of
an ( O H ) - group spacially in the octahedral layer. In turn, the replacement
of O-- by ( O H ) - probably would take place most readily in a dioctahedral
montmorillonoid when the octahedrally coordinated cation is divalent rather
than trivalent. It will be noted that the additional ( O H ) - groups in the
modified Edelman structure in the montmorillonite under investigation ex-
ceeds just slightly the number of octahedrally coordinated Mg ++ and Mn §247
per unit cell. The ( O H ) - group, being polar with the hydrogen atom
oriented toward the tetrahedral layer, would inhibit deposition of the Si ....
in the adjacent space. Rather, the Si .... would tend to be deposited in an
equivalent position 1.04 A away parallel to the "c" axis, nesting in the ring
of three oxygen ions at the base of the tetrahedron, external to the silicate
packet.
A distal position of the Si .... also might result from accumulation of
oxygen atoms in the outer portion of the tetrahedral layer at a rate exceed-
ing the emplacement of Si .... , such that the normal site for the Si .... is
closed before a cation is deposited there.
At some elevated temperature, it is expected that the external, adsorbed
( O H ) - group in the interlayer space will break away from the silica sheet
either to produce water by the reaction 2 (OH)--->H20 + O-- or to combine
with the exchangeable cation to produce a hydroxide by reactions such as
NH4 §+ ( O H ) ---> N H 4 O H
Mg+++ 2 (OH)---> Mg ( O H ) 2
Na ++ ( O H ) ~--->N a O H
These reactions will maintain the electrostatic neutrality of the structure by
removal of equal numbers of positive and negative ions.
If the hydroxide resulting from this reaction is volatile at temperatures
attained during the thermal analysis, the hydroxide will escape into the
atmosphere of the furnace. H + and NH4 + would be affected by this action.
If the hydroxide is decomposed in the temperature range attained in the
thermal analysis, one molecule of water for each two equivalents of ex-
change capacity will be released. Such dehydration would be expected of
C a ( O H ) ~ and M g ( O H ) 2 , which in the crystalline form decompose at
580~ and 350 ~ C, respectively. In contrast, the Li § Na § and K + will
produce hydroxides which would not be expected to decompose below
1,000 o C.
The experimentally determined weight losses can be distributed into vari-
MIELENZ, SCHIELTZ~AND KING 161
ous categories on the basis of the modified Edelman structure as was done
for the Hofmann-Endell-Wilm structure (Tables V I I and V I I I ) . t A rea-
sonable correlation is established.
T h e hypothesis that hydroxides are formed is consistent with considerable
data. As has been pointed out, the differential thermal analysis data indi-
cate that water of cation hydration is lost during drying at 105 ~ C from the
H § modification. This is indicated also by the distribution of water accord-
ing to the modified Edelman structure. The weight loss in the intermediate
temperature range is correlated with the loss of water produced by the
reaction of the H + and the O H - at the apex of the inverted Si-O tetrahedra.
According to the modified Edelman structure the NH~ + is anhydrous, as
is indicated also by the differential thermal analysis. The weight loss during
the intermediate temperature range is considered to represent volatilization
of N H 4 O H . This release develops the small endotherm between 400 ~ C
and 500 ~ C. The loss of N H 4 O H takes place predominantly in two inter-
vals, one from room temperature to 200 ~ C-234 ~ C, and the second from
307 ~ C to 505 ~ C or from 250 ~ C to 490 ~ C. Two intervals of release of
ammonia by Nt-I4§ montmorillonite were reported also by Cornet (1943,
pp. 225-226).
Decomposition of the secondary M g ( O H ) 2 takes place below 4 9 0 ~
and evidently contributes to the persistent endotherm whose peak is at
300 ~ C. A similar loss for the Ca ++ modification is indicated below 481 ~ C,
and largely below 263 ~ C. This dehydration might be expected close to
580 ~ C, because of the resistance of crystalline calcium hydroxide to de-
composition. However, the thermal balance analysis indicates that if the
decomposition occurs at all, it must take place below 481 ~ C. The break-
down may combine with dehydration of the Ca ++ ion to produce the large
endotherm whose peak is close to 250 ~ C.
~9 ~9
~ 0 ~ o ~ o ~
t"q
oo
~d
~/
~ /~
g
o
~ o
~ ""/f~ ~' ~,O O0 %D t-~ O0 0 0 t O r
cO ~ - r ~ r vO r
~D
-~- r
8 l~
o6
.=.
~0
o
~1~ o
0 ~'~ I ~ ~_~
~ | ~ a
~ I ~
~S
~g ~I~
~5
~5 oo
o .o~ P,
i h0
§ +
MIELENZ~ SCHIELTZ~ AND KING 163
.=~
~.~ w ~ ~ = ~ ~=
~ ~ ~ ~ ~~
P
~I ~
o
o
.~,~
.~ J ~ r )
N ~I~o o
o
~=", ~ / ~ b~O
0[=
o
~ ~
6
8
u~
§ § § ,.a
N
164 EXCHANGEABLECATION EFFECT ON X-RAY DIFFRACTIONPATTERNS
FIGOm~ 6 . - X-ray diffraction patterns of oriented flakes of the Na- and Mg-
modifications under room conditions (flakes set at 30~ to beam).
This line is considered to represent the first order of the (001) group
because (1) its dimension agrees with that calculated from the position of
the line representing d spacings of 9.5 to about 15 A, assuming that the
latter represents d(002) (Table I X ) ; (2) some of the higher orders of
(001) require that this line be correlated with d(001), or even with d(002)
in the case of the K+, H § and NH4 § modifications, in order that they may
be indexed as integers; and (3) the line orients itself with the other orders
of (001) in the patterns produced by the oriented films of clay and varies
in position with water content of the sample.
(..q ,..-~
aO '~-
0 ~'~0
~3
Ox
P, ('.4 ,.-~
~. ~ ~
mu ,-~i
LD +. ~ , / U
m
9
L~ ,.~ ~ c~ c,,~ ~ ,-4
o
o .!~I -ooo
~~o
~. ~.o, o. o. ~.
~I ~"
o LN~'~
~
.~ o ~
,..1 ~o~
I
~~ ~2
L :!
gl
166
MIELENZ, SCHIELTZ, AND KING 167
exchangeable cation rather than with the amount and structure of the
adsorbed water.
The position of this,line is useful in identifying the adsorbed cation
present if one cation greatly predominates. However, with differing condi-
tions of hydration, the position of the line might be approximately the same
for several cationic modifications.
(hkO) Interferences
The (hk0) interferences are identified readily and the equivalent d spac-
ings are essentially constant with change of exchangeable cation and con-
tent of adsorbed water. The d spacings for given (hk0) planes agree closely
with those compiled for montmorillonite by MacEwan (1951, Table IV, 1)
from several sources. Variations in the spacings are random and nearly al-
ways within the experimental error. From d(600) =0.866 .A_and d(060) =
1.50 A, a0 and b0 are calculated to be 5.20 A and 9.00 A, respectively.
(hkl) Interferences
Detailed study o f X-ray diffraction patterns reveals no (hkl) inter ferences.
Those interferences identified by Winkler (1943) as (hkl) interferences of
Na § montmorillonite are apparent in patterns of the montmorillonite under
investigation, but they are either (001) interferences, interferences arising
from Kfl radiation, interferences developed by granular constituents of the
bentonite, such as quartz, or combinations of these.