Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Queda de Cabelos e Recuperação Dos Cabelos
Queda de Cabelos e Recuperação Dos Cabelos
Keywords: androgenetic alopecia, chronic telogen e¥uvium, common balding, ¢nasteride, Florisene1,
hair loss, hair shedding, hair treatments, male pattern balding, Propecia1, Regaine1
Synopsis ReÂsumeÂ
Hair is considered to be a major component of an Les cheveux sont considërës comme ëtant une com-
individual's general appearance. The psychological posante majeure de l'aspect gënëral d'un individu.
impact of hair loss results in a measurably detrimen- L'impact psychologique de la perte des cheveux con-
tal change in self-esteem and is associated with duit a© une diminution mesurable de l'estime de soi et
images of reduced worth. It is not surprising that s'associe a© des images de contexte nëgatif. Il n'est pas
both men and women ¢nd hair loss a stressful experi- surprenant que les hommes comme les femmes
ence. Genetic hair loss is the major problem a¡ecting ressentent la perte de cheveux comme une expëri-
men and by the age of 50, up to 50% will be a¡ected. ence stressante. La perte gënëtique des cheveux est
Initial attempts to regenerate the lost hair have le proble©me principal qui touche les hommes et
centred on applying a topical solution of between autour de l'aªge de 50 ans, jusqu'a© 50% seront con-
2% to 5% minoxidil; however, the results proved dis- cernës. Les premie©res tentatives de rëgënëration des
appointing. Recently, ¢nasteride, a type II 5a reduc- cheveux perdus se sont focalisëes sur l'application
tase inhibitor has been found to regrow a noticeable topique d'une solution comprenant entre 2% et 5%
amount of hair in about 40% of balding men. Further de minoxidil; cependant, les rësultats se sont avërës
developments in treatments have lead to the use of a dëcevants. Rëcemment, le ¢nastëride, un inhibiteur
dual type I and type II inhibitor where 90% of those de la 5a-rëductase de type II s'est avërë permettre la
treated regrow a noticeable amount of hair. In repousse d'une quantitë signi¢cative de cheveux chez
women the major cause of hair loss before the age of environ 40% des hommes dëgarnis. Les dëveloppe-
50 is nutritional, with 30% a¡ected. Increased and ments ultërieurs des traitements ont conduit a© l'utili-
persistent hair shedding (chronic telogen e¥uvium) sation d'un inhibiteur associant type I et type II pour
and reduced hair volume are the principle changes lequel 90% des personnes traitëes constatent une
occurring. The main cause appears to be depleted repousse signi¢cative des cheveux. Chez les femmes
iron stores, compromised by a suboptimal intake of la cause principale de la perte des cheveux avant
the essential amino acid L -lysine. Correction of these l'aªge de 50 ans est d'origine nutritionnelle, avec 30%
imbalances stops the excessive hair loss and returns de la population a¡ectëe. Une perte de cheveux per-
the hair back to its former glory. However, it can take sistante et croissante (telogen e¥uvium chronique)
many months to redress the situation. et un volume des cheveux rëduit sont les principaux
e¡ets qui se produisent. La cause principale semble
Correspondence: Dr D Hugh Rushton, 24 Harmont House,
eªtre des rëserves de fer ëpuisëes, associëes a© une prise
20 Harley Street, London W1G 9PJ, U.K. E-mail: rushton@ insu¤sante de l'acide aminë essentiel L-lysine.
btinternet.com La correction de ces dësëquilibres stoppe la perte
excessive de cheveux et rend aux cheveux leur ëclat men (5%, D. H. Rushton, unpublished data), a di¡use
d'antan. Cependant, plusieurs mois peuvent eªtre pattern of loss similar to that seen in women prevails
nëcessaires pour redresser la situation. [7].
Introduction Pathology
Hair is considered to be a major component of an indi- Androgenetic alopecia occurs in a characteristic
vidual's general appearance. Throughout history, pattern and the changes can be summarized as
and in most (although not all) civilizations, scalp hair follows. Initially, a reduction in the percentage of
has been associated with positive signals such as hair follicles in the anagen growth phase occurs,
beauty and power. Baldness or hair loss on the other resulting in a reduction in the length of hair grown.
hand has a negative attribute [1]. This aspect can be speci¢cally evaluated in genetic
The psychological impact of hair loss results in hair loss by determining the percentage of telogen
a measurably detrimental change in self-esteem (resting) hair less than 3 cm in length, within the
and is associated with images of reduced worth a¡ected area [8]. As the genetically orchestrated
[2, 3]. It is not surprising that both men and changes emerge there is an increase in the propor-
women with genetic hair loss ¢nd it a stressful experi- tion of vellus hair (hair <40 mm in diameter being
ence. An Egyptian papyrus over 4000 years old <3 cm in length), followed by a reduction in hair
records the anxieties prompted by premature density [8].
hair loss at that time [4].The study by Cash [3] showed The expression of androgenetic alopecia requires a
that balding men had less body image satisfaction genetic predisposition as well as postpubertal levels
and su¡ered from preoccupation, stress and even of circulating testosterone or one of its metabolites.
distress, which was more marked in those who It is now known that men with male balding have an
were younger, single, and had hair loss which was increased capacity to convert testosterone to dihy-
more extensive or of earlier onset. Similar ¢ndings drotestosterone [9] via increased activity of the
have been observed in women with alopecia areata enzyme responsible for this conversion,5a reductase
(loss of hair in patches), totalis/universalis (complete [10]. There are two 5a reductase enzymes (Type I
loss of scalp/body hair), genetic hair loss and and Type II); both are present in the scalp [11] but
increased hair shedding (chronic telogen e¥uvium, the role they play is still unknown. Furthermore, it is
CTE). not yet clear whether the genetic and hormonal basis
Even in conditions such as CTE where a complete is the same in men and women.
recovery can be expected, the distress caused by the
loss of hair can have a profound e¡ect upon an indivi-
Treatment options
dual's self-con¢dence and quality of life. This can
result in the su¡erer seeking help from unscrupulous Historically, the treatment of hair loss has involved a
organizations who sell useless and ine¡ective lotions great deal of quackery and charlatanism. The ¢rst
and potions for large sums of money. real scienti¢c e¡ort at hair regeneration occurred
Signi¢cant amounts of time and money are with the drug minoxidil. Initially developed to treat
devoted to hair care, $2.2 billion in the USA and $3.3 hypertension, its hair growth properties were soon
billion in Europe (source, Procter & Gamble, UK), recognized and a 2% topical solution developed and
with an estimated $1 billion spent on trying to pre- approved in the USA in1988 as the ¢rst product clini-
vent or treat hair loss, yet none of the causes of hair cally proven to stimulate hair growth (Rogaine1
loss is life threatening. USA, Regaine1 UK). At the present time it is still
unclear precisely how minoxidil produces hyper-
trichosis (stimulates hair growth), which is not
Classifying hair loss in men
necessarily the same as preventing or reversing the
Male pattern hair loss, also known as androgenic, expression of genetic hair loss. Rushton et al. demon-
androgen-dependent or androgenetic alopecia is the strated the lack of e¤cacy of minoxidil in a¡ecting
most common type of hair loss in men [5, 6]. Over the genetic expression in 1989 [12], a ¢nding con-
40 years ago, Hamilton ¢rst described and categor- ¢rmed recently by Price & Menefee [13]. Furthermore,
ized the progressive pattern of hair loss in men, and over the past 10 years of use, patients have often
a modi¢ed version is still in use today [6]. In some been dissatis¢ed with statistically signi¢cant, but
Table I Within-group comparison (mean SE) for hair densities and percent of hair in the anagen growth phase from men
using topical 2% minoxidil (n 15)
Total Hair Density (THD) 195 16 199 13 NS
(Range) (78±303) (97±283)
Useful Hair Density (UHD) 73 14 69 12 NS
(Range) (0±177) (0±160)
Anagen % 56.8 4.88 59.2 4.97 yNS
(Range) (13.5±84.3) (12.1±84.7)
Table II Within-group comparison (mean SE) for hair densities and percent of hair in the anagen growth phase from men
taking ¢nasteride (1.25 mg d 1) (n 15)
Total Hair Density (THD) 229 12 242 10 0.06
(Range) (156±293) (182±310)
Useful Hair Density (UHD) 134 12 145 15 NS
(Range) (46±226) (45±224)
Anagen % 68.5 2.60 78.6 3.10 y<0.01
(Range) (48.1±88.4) (58.0±98.6)
Table III Within-group comparison (mean SE) for hair densities and percent of hair in the anagen growth phase from 25
men taking ¢nasteride (1.25 mg d 1), a Type II 5a reductase inhibitor (5-AR) and using a topical Type I 5-AR inhibitor
Total Hair Density (THD) 214 18 251 17 <0.0001
(Range) (83±467) (117±468)
Useful Hair Density (UHD) 111 14 155 17 <0.001
(Range) (27±264) (24±381)
Anagen % 66.8 2.6 72.0 2.6 y<0.01
(Range) (40.3±91.8) (53.1±95.7)
cosmetically insigni¢cant, increases in hair counts, was the ¢rst to described the pattern of hair loss in
leading to poor compliance with the twice-daily women. Reduced hair density also occurs in
topical application. A 5% variant is now available in hypothyroidism [15] and a¡ects around 2% of preme-
some countries but, as with 2% minoxidil, the loss of nopausal women; however, it is signi¢cantly more
hair continues unabated [13]. prevalent after the menopause.
Recently, ¢nasteride, a type II 5a reductase inhibi- Another problem that a¡ects women is a delay in
tor (5-AR), has been licensed in the USA and around the initiation of the new hair cycle, a so-called lag
the world, including the UK, under the name of Pro- phase e¡ect, where the hair does not re-enter the
pecia1. Results from clinical trials claim signi¢cant growth phase (anagen) when it should. Often the
increases in hair count in men with male pattern hair delay may last for several months during which time
loss treated with ¢nasteride for12 months compared the resting telogen hair is lost from the scalp leaving
to placebo [14]. an empty hair follicle [16]. However, the most com-
Employing the unit area trichogram, a quantita- mon cause of hair loss in women is CTE, which a¡ects
tive and validated method of hair evaluation [12], 30% of females in the UK (D. H. Rushton & M. J. Norris,
data from subjects treated with topical minoxidil unpublished data).
(Table I), ¢nasteride (Table II) and ¢nasteride to-
gether with a topical type I 5-AR inhibitor are pre-
Pathology
sented in Table III.
In women, androgenetic alopecia occurs in a charac-
teristic pattern where there is a progressive loss of
Results
hair from just behind the front hair line. There is a
Minoxidil was ine¡ective in preventing further reduction in hair density (hair per cm2) but the hair
expression of the underlying genetic hair loss. that remains is relatively normal in appearance [17].
Although anyone using minoxidil will have more, In the vast majority of a¡ected women there is no
¢ner hair than they would have had, had they not increase in circulating androgens, which has raised
used it, progression of their genetic hair loss will con- questions about whether or not this type of di¡use
tinue. In ¢nasteride-only treated subjects around loss is really androgen-mediated. There is some sup-
40% of individuals reported a noticeable increase in port for this because not all those treated with anti-
hair growth as de¢ned as an increase obvious to androgens respond, suggesting that the genetic and
themselves, their partner or their hairdresser. Objec- hormonal basis may not be the same in men and
tive changes, i.e., hair longer than 3 cm per cm2, women. Compounding matters, increased hair shed-
(Useful Hair Density, UHD) occurred in ¢nasteride ding is a complicating feature, with 70% having a
(but not minoxidil) treated subjects and amounted suboptimal nutritional status (see below) [18].
to a mean increase of11 UHD hairs. In comparison to The most frequent hair problem in premenopausal
these preparations, over 80% of men treated with women is increased hair shedding. This is where
the dual type I and II 5-AR inhibitor reported a there is a relative change in the proportion of growing
noticeable increase with a signi¢cant mean increase (anagen) to resting (telogen) hair. In most cases, the
of 44 UHD hairs per cm2. In both the ¢nasteride and excessive shedding has been present for at least
¢nasteride; a topical type I 5-AR inhibitor (but in 6 months [19].Where the problem persists there is a
the minoxidil) treated subjects, a signi¢cant increase reduction in hair volume, or less hair to clip up or tie
(P < 0.01) in the number of hairs in the anagen back in the ponytail. This condition is known as
growth phase occurred. chronic telogen e¥uvium (CTE) and studies have
shown that in 95% of such cases CTE arises from a
nutritional imbalance involving the essential amino
Classifying hair loss in women
acid L -lysine and iron (D. H. Rushton et al., unpub-
Whereas androgenetic alopecia is the most common lished data) ¢ndings con¢rmed in two recent
type of hair loss in men, in women it appears to a¡ect studies [20, 21].
less than 10% of premenopausal women (D. H.
Rushton, unpublished data). When it does occur, a
Treatment options
di¡use loss of hair a¡ecting the frontal-vertex area
with the sparing of a narrow (1 cm) band of denser Treatment for genetic hair loss in women has been
hair in the frontal hairline is observed. Ludwig [7] available since the late 1970s. The most e¡ective
Table IV Biochemical results obtained in 200 apparently healthy women complaining of increased hair shedding and
reduced hair volume (chronic telogen e¥uvium)
yReference range from [18], S serum, TIBC total iron binding capacity.
Table V Within-group comparison (mean SE) for the percent of hair in the telogen phase and serum ferritin concentration
obtained from 22 women taking an oral nutritional supplement (Florisene1) providing 72 mg of iron and1.5 g of the essential
amino acid L -lysine for 6 months
Hair in the telogen phase (%) 19.5 1.1 11.3 1.0 yP < 0.0001
(Range) (8.5±28.9) (4.4±21.9)
Serum ferritin values (ng mL 1) 33 4 89 11
P < 0.0001
(Range) (5±84) (27±211)
Student's t-test (paired samples).
yWilcoxon Signed Rank-test (paired samples).
5a-reductase in human scalp. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. review study. Proceedings,Tri-Continental Hair Research
89,10787^10791 (1992). Meeting,Tokyo, Japan, Poster157 (2001).
12. Rushton, D.H., Unger,W.P., Cotterill, P.C., et al. Quantita- 21. Haycox, C.The incidence of depleted iron stores in North
tive assessment of 2% topical minoxidil in the treatment American females presenting with hair loss. Proceed-
of male pattern baldness. Clin. Exp. Dermatol. 14, 40^ ings,Tri-Continental Hair Research Meeting,Tokyo, Japan,
46 (1989). Poster159 (2001).
13. Price, V.H. and Menefee, E. Quantitative estimation of 22. Mortimer, C.H., Rushton, D.H. and James, K.C. E¡ective
hair growth: comparative changes in weight and hair medical treatment for common baldness in women.
count with 5% and 2% minoxidil, placebo and no treat- Clin. Exp. Dermatol. 8,342^350 (1984).
ment. In: Hair research for the next millennium (D. J.Van 23. Rushton, D.H. and Ramsay, I.D. The importance of ade-
Neste and V. A. Randall, eds), pp. 67^71. Amsterdam: quate serum ferritin levels during oral cyproterone
Elsevier (1996). acetate and ethinyl oestradiol treatment of di¡use
14. Kaufman, K. Clinical studies on the e¡ects of oral ¢nas- androgen-dependent alopecia in women. Clin. Endocri-
teride, a type II 5a-reductase inhibitor, on scalp hair in nol. 36, 421^427 (1992).
men with male pattern baldness. In: Hair research for 24. Rushton, D.H., Futterweit, W., Kingsley, D.H., Kingsley,
the next millennium (D.J. Van Neste and V.A. Randall, P. and Norris, M.J. Quantitative assessment of spirono-
eds), pp.363^365. Amsterdam: Elsevier (1996). lactone treatment in women with di¡use androgen-
15. James, K.C., Norris, M.J., Rushton, D.H., et al. The in£u- dependent alopecia. J. Soc. Cosmet. Chem. 42, 317^325
ence of thyroid dysfunction on hair growth. J. Pharm. (1991).
Pharmacol. 39,64 (1987). 25. Rushton, D.H. and Fenton, D.A. Quantitative evaluation
16. Courtois, M., Loussouarn, G., Hourseau, C. et al. Ageing of topical 5% minoxidil in the treatment of di¡use
and hair cycles. Br. J. Dermatol.132,86^93 (1995). androgen-dependent alopecia in females. Br. J. Derma-
17. Rushton, D.H., James, K.C. and Mortimer, C.H. The unit tol.127, 423 (1992).
area trichogram in the assessment of androgen-depen- 26. Whiting, D.A., Waldstreicher, J., Sanchez, M. and Kauf-
dent alopecia. Br. J. Dermatol.109, 429^437 (1983). man, K.D. Measuring reversal of hair miniaturization
18. Rushton, D.H., Ramsay, I.D., James, K.C. et al. Biochem- in androgenetic alopecia by follicular counts in hori-
ical and trichological characterisation of di¡use alope- zontal sections of serial scalp biopsies: results of ¢nas-
cia in women. Br. J. Dermatol.123,187^197 (1990). teride 1 mg treatment of men and postmenopausal
19. Rushton, D.H. Investigating and managing hair loss in women. J. Invest. Dermatol. Symp Proc. 4, 282^284
apparently healthy women. Can. J. Dermatol. 5, 455^ (1999).
461 (1993). 27. Puolakka, J. Serum ferritin the evaluation of iron status
20. Roberts, J.L. Examining the etiology of telogen e¥u- in young women. Acta. Obstet. Gynecol. Scand. Suppl.
vium in pre-and postmenopausal women: a chart 95,35^41 (1980).