You are on page 1of 12

Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Cities
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cities

A master plan for low carbon and resilient housing: The 35 ha area
in Hashtgerd New Town, Iran
Sebastian Seelig ⇑
Technische Universität Berlin, Hardenbergstraße 40a, 10623 Berlin, Germany

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: With 60% of the population younger than 26 years, a need of about 1.5 million residential units per year
Available online 23 July 2011 for the next 5 years and the necessity of mitigating its rapidly growing GHG emissions together with
adapting cities to the expected drastic effects of climate change, Iran’s urban agglomerations are facing
Keywords: tremendous challenges now and in the future. The paper presents interim findings of the German–Iranian
Iran research initiative ‘‘Young Cities’’ (2005–2013) that investigates approaches for these immense chal-
Climate change lenges. The project aims at developing energy-efficient and resilient housing in a real-life pilot project,
Urban planning
the 35 ha area in Hashtgerd New Town in the Tehran province. The article explores the framing condi-
Urban design
Mitigation
tions and the master plan of this pilot and identifies four key planning strategies. Besides applying cli-
Adaptation mate-sensitive urban form, the project stresses the need to develop culturally adapted building
typologies for reduced heating and cooling, an efficient public transport in a mixed and dense urban
structure and integrated water and energy systems on the neighborhood level. Simulations of these plan-
ning approaches have proven a significant reduction of energy- and resource consumption and the capac-
ity of the design to adapt to (a potentially changing) environment. These promising strategies for energy-
efficiency and resilience were transferred into a legally binding comprehensive plan commissioned in
October 2010, though the major challenge in the second phase of the project (2011–2013) will be making
these innovations a built reality.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction: urban growth and climate change in Iran urban migration has led to an explosive urbanization process
(Roudi-Fahimi & Mederios, 2007) with serious social, ecological
This article presents interim findings of the German–Iranian re- and economic consequences (such as social segregation and gender
search initiative ‘‘Young Cities’’ (2005–2013) that investigates inequities, pollution of air and water, unemployment and a lack of
strategies for building energy-efficient and resilient neighborhoods urban services) (Modarres, 2006a, 2006b). Though birth rates have
in the Tehran megacity region based on the case study of Hasht- plummeted since the mid-1980s, the enormous pressure on cities
gerd New Town. The article focuses on the master plan for the remains unchanged – in 2007 the Iranian Ministry of Housing
so-called 35 ha area, an urban design pilot project in Hashtgerd, and Urban Development estimated the need for about 1.5 million
which has been bilaterally elaborated since 2005. The paper com- new housing units per year until 2013. This deficit and a lack of
mences with a brief overview of the current challenges related to alternatives for long-term investments in Iran are certain to keep
climate change with special emphasis on the role of the built envi- the construction sector booming in the years to come. Thus the
ronment in Iran, and next proceeds to outline the 35 ha pilot pro- quality of current and future building activities will affect Iran’s
ject, including its responsible stakeholders, its master plan and the energy consumption and GHG-emissions for decades: 30% of the
key planning strategies that were applied in its development pro- country’s entire energy consumption can be traced to the residen-
cess. The author thus highlights promising strategies but also cur- tial sector, and an additional 27% to the closely related transport
rent challenges to developing low carbon and resilient urban form sector (see Fig. 2) (World Resources Institute, 2009). Energy con-
in Hashtgerd New Town, Iran. sumption in Iran has steadily increased during the past century,
In the last 30 years, Iran’s population has doubled, reaching 73 with domestic primary energy consumption doubling every decade
million inhabitants in 2010, with a median age of only 23.5 years. since the 1950s. Because 99% of the country’s primary energy
Besides this natural demographic development, massive rural– needs are met with oil and gas, carbon emissions have also in-
creased continuously (Bakhtiari & Shahbudaghlou, 2000). On a
world wide scale Iran accounts for approximately 1.3% of total car-
⇑ Tel.: +49 (0)30 314 28118; fax: +49 (0)30 314 28150. bon emissions, ranking number eleven among global CO2-emitters
E-mail address: seelig@youngcities.org in 2007 (Boden, 2010).

0264-2751/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.cities.2011.06.001
546 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Due to the rising energy demand and the impact of the built envi- Industry
ronment on GHG-emissions, sustainable housing is crucial for miti- 4% Transport
gating climate change in Iran. At the same time, adaption to 27%
30% Agriculture
climate change is also a critical challenge for the country since 82%
Commercial
of its territory is located in arid and semi-arid climate zones and dra-
matic impacts are expected (Amiri & Eslamian, 2010). It is estimated Residential
that if the CO2-concentration doubles by the year 2100 (based on sce- 8% 4% 27% Non Energy
narios IS92a, IS92c, IS92e), the average temperature in Iran will in-
crease by 1.5–4.5 °C, causing significant changes in water Fig. 2. Energy consumption by sector in 2005. Source: World Resources Institute
(2009).
resources, agriculture, land use and energy demand. The effects will
be severe, especially regarding water and energy supply, for example
levels of pollution in Iran’s cities. In Tehran, vehicles account for
to cover increased cooling needs. The demand for electricity is esti-
more than 70% of air pollution, making it one of the most polluted
mated to increase by about 20,000 MW in the next 50 years (Climate
cities on Earth (Muir, 2007). Modernization not only affected urban
Change Office of Iran, 2007). Minimizing GHG-emissions and
form and infrastructure but also policies and regulations, especially
enabling the newly constructed urban fabric to adapt to changing
since the 1950s, when comprehensive planning was introduced
environmental conditions therefore requires major attention now
based on existing American models (Farhoodi, Gharakhlou-N,
and in the near future.
Ghadami, & Panahandeh Khah, 2009). This technocratic approach,
Tehran Metropolitan Region, which is one of the most rapidly
which still prevails in Iran, overemphasizes physical planning
growing agglomerations in the Middle East, exemplifies these tre-
and operates from the top down. Besides lacking possibilities for
mendous challenges. In 2006 the region had approximately 13.4
stakeholder participation, plans often fail to consider economic
million inhabitants (Statistical Center of Iran, 2006) who held
and social goals (Madanipour, 1998). These instruments leave little
70% of Iran’s economic and financial powers, making it the politi-
room for innovation and are therefore not suitable for the multilay-
cal, economic and cultural center of the country (Fanni, 2006). De-
ered, complex problems related to climate change. Numerous Ira-
spite the fact that the city of Tehran only occupies 1.2% of Iran’s
nian building regulations were also elaborated according to
total landmass, it houses 20% of its population and about 35% of
Western models. For example the ‘‘mass and space’’ regulation that
the country’s industries (Tehran Geographic Information Centre,
is common in Tehran prohibits buildings to cover more than 60% of
2004). More than half of Iran’s CO2 is emitted by the transport sec-
their plot. This has greatly influenced the city’s building form by
tor and by power plants, and most energy is consumed by indus-
fostering the construction of higher, extroverted apartment
tries, transport and the residential sectors (see Figs. 1 and 2). It is
buildings that are not adapted to the local climate and culture
therefore safe to assume that Tehran province is responsible for a
but that have nevertheless become the dominant housing type
large share of the country’s total CO2-emissions, though empiri-
(Mirmoghtadaee, 2009). Energy systems also contribute to rising
cally sound data is currently not available.
GHG-emissions; most houses in Iran are heated and cooled with
The role of the built environment in Iran’s rising GHG-emissions individual devices that are powered by electricity supplied by
highly inefficient central oil driven plants. Energy-efficient supply
A closer look into practices and policies concerning Iran’s built systems are barely employed and the use of renewable energies
environment reveals the main drivers and defines the starting is negligible (Atabi, 2004). In addition excessive energy
points for reducing GHG-emissions within the presented research consumption in Iran is fueled by high energy subsidies, estimated
project. Energy consumption related to buildings holds the highest to be the highest in the world (total of US$ 55 billion in 2007,
share in the country (see Fig. 2) due to fast and cheap construction Daneshdoust, 2010). Subsidy rates of the different energy carriers
practices often without building insulations or double-glazed win- vary between 62% and 98% with the transport and residential
dows (Kari & Fayaz, 2006). On the urban scale, insufficient urban sectors being the most heavily subsidized sectors (International
design aggravates the problems. Since the 1930s traditional urban Energy Agency (IEA), 2005). This has left a legacy of inefficient
patterns, which were entirely adapted to the country’s climatic energy use and excessive fuel dependence – problems that the gov-
conditions, have increasingly been abandoned (Kheirabadi, 2000). ernment is recently trying to address with the so-called ‘‘economic
This transformation is rooted in the modernization process that Ir- evolution plan’’. The plan will gradually eliminate subsidies and
an’s cities underwent especially under Reza Shah Pahlavi, which simultaneously provide cash to poor inhabitants in order to
was characterized by imported Western designs without consider- mitigate the impact of rising utility bills, which are expected to
ation of local characteristics or climatic conditions (Mazayan & increase by at least 40% (Erdbrink, 2010). Consequently energy-
Diba, 2004). This modernist approach also heavily encouraged efficiency has suddenly become a high priority on the Iranian
automobile use by adapting urban form to the new technology government’s political agenda.
(Madanipour, 1998; Modarres, 2006a, 2006b). Due to the absence
of functional public transportation systems this has made the Young Cities – approaching energy-efficient and resilient
transport sector one of the major energy consumers in Iran as well housing in Iran
as the largest emitter of CO2 (see Figs. 1 and 2) (World Bank, 2003).
Widespread use of inefficient vehicles has added to the significant Observing the drastic impacts of climate change to be expected,
examining the huge mitigation potential and considering a rising
Transportation
political awareness for energy-efficiency in the Tehran–Karaj re-
8.70% gion, the ‘‘Young Cities’’ project aims at developing methodological
Power Plants
27.50% and applicable solutions for low carbon and resilient housing in the
15.10%
Industries specific climatic, cultural and economic context of Iran. On the
German side, the project is directed by Technische Universitaet
Household/Commercial Berlin, in cooperation with two further Berlin-based universities,
24.40% and various companies and consultancies. On the Iranian side,
the project is directed by the Building and Housing Research Center
Fig. 1. Emission of CO2 by main pollutants in 2003. Source: Sabetghadam (2006). (BHRC), which is directly subordinated to the Iranian Ministry for
S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556 547

Housing and Urban Development. The New Towns Development into the surrounding new towns. Hashtgerd was supposed to at-
Corporation of Iran (NTDC), the Housing Investment Company tract diverse income groups and economic activities in order to
(HIC) and a range of consulting companies, academic institutions keep pace with the area’s residential development. In addition,
and NGOs supplement the Iranian consortium. Research within the government also aimed at ecological qualities by promoting
the ‘‘Young Cities’’ project focuses on four main fields (see Fig. 3), public transportation and offering green spaces (New Towns
ranging from urban development (first ‘‘Strategic Dimension’’) to Development Corporation of Iran, 1993). As a result the master
infrastructure systems (second ‘‘Strategic Dimension’’) and archi- plan proposes 25 neighborhood units for 20,000 residents each,
tecture (third ‘‘Strategic Dimension). A fourth module works on that are separated by large green spaces and equipped with facili-
crosscutting issues such as project management, environmental ties such as shopping centers, leisure centers and a university, all of
assessment and capacity development (see Fig. 3). which are organized in a grid pattern (see Fig. 4). However, after
Their main research questions are: 20 years, the New Town’s development has not lived up to these
ambitious plans: mono-functional five-floor apartment blocks that
 Which strategies and methodologies are needed to create are separated by vast open spaces dominate the city. Housing is
energy-efficient and resilient housing in Iran? strictly organized in terraced buildings with a North-to-South ori-
 How can they be applied in concrete planning and design solu- entation that creates uniform urban spaces that lack a spatial hier-
tions in Hashtgerd New Town? archy (see Fig. 5). The city’s unattractive image is due to a serious
 Which instruments are viable for replication in other parts of lack of infrastructure (such as poor public transportation), a num-
Iran and the region? ber of unsolved environmental issues (such as the absence of a lo-
cal wastewater treatment plant), and its slow economic
The research project expects to produce the following outcome development, most notably its lack of sufficient employment
after its full 5-year duration: opportunities. These shortcomings have significantly slowed
Hashtgerd’s growth, so that in 2008 it only had approximately
 Criteria and objectives for energy-efficient and resilient urban 16,000 inhabitants (Paykadeh Consultants, 2008).
development in Hashtgerd New Town and other semi-arid
regions on the neighborhood scale. The 35 ha area as central demonstration grounds for the Young
 Appropriate planning and design strategies tested on the basis Cities project
of pilot projects, including their evaluation according to the pro-
ject goals. The Young Cities research project plans to build an energy-
 Policies for urban planning and design for climate change in efficient and resilient urban settlement within Hashtgerd. The
Iran that might result in adapted or new planning codes on 35 ha area in the southern part of Hashtgerd (see Fig. 4) was
the local, regional and even national level. chosen by the Iranian partners for development as the central
demonstration area of the Young Cities’ research results. The pilot
The project follows a ‘‘research-by-design’’ approach, in which sci- project aims at demonstrating a range of innovations in the areas
entific results are derived from the planning and realization process of of urban planning, urban design, architecture, landscape planning,
various pilot projects that will successively be implemented in Hasht- transportation planning, climatology, water-, waste water- and en-
gerd New Town, a settlement that lies 80 km west of Tehran. The pilot ergy management, participation, and environmental assessment.
projects include a number of single buildings such as the ‘‘New Qual- The joint planning process is expected to also enhance the capaci-
ity’’ residential building, which was inaugurated in July 2010, as well ties of the partners on both sides. The main goals of the pilot are:
as larger urban design projects such as the 35 ha area settlement.
The city of Hashtgerd is located in an arid climate zone with  To develop approaches in all involved dimensions for minimiz-
semi-arid characteristics and an annual mean temperature of just ing energy consumption (and thus the emission of CO2) and
below 18 °C (Koeppen, 1900). The area lies at a relatively high alti- adapting to the expected effects of climate change in Hashtgerd
tude of 1350 m in direct vicinity of the Alborz mountains, and New Town.
therefore in winter receives significant precipitation (average of  To arrive at concepts that minimize technical complexity and
280 mm/year). Thus Hashtgerd’s climate can be characterized by costs.
cold winters and warm and dry summers (Nasrollahi, 2010).  To enforce solutions, which are adapted to the cultural, climatic
With a target population of 500,000 inhabitants, Hashtgerd and social context and that build on the traditional regional
New Town is the largest of Iran’s new towns (Ziari, 2006). It was knowledge of energy-efficient and resilient settlements.
planned in the 1980s, and is the built manifesto of the govern-  To plan in an integrated manner, creating as many closed
ment’s ambition to attract migration away from Tehran and Karaj resource loops as possible.

Fig. 3. Set-up of the Young Cities project. Source: TU Berlin.


548 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Fig. 4. Hashtgerd New Town master plan. The 35 ha is marked in black. Source: TU Berlin.

Fig. 5. Hashtgerd New Town. Source: TU Berlin.

 To implement solutions that are economically viable and to become a neighborhood with 2000 housing units for 8000
include a wide group of potential residents. inhabitants. The master plan defines strategic social, economic,
 To support all planning activities with awareness raising and and environmental development goals and designates land uses
capacity building measures. and densities, and is therefore the central instrument for Hasht-
gerd New Town’s development. Since the Young Cities project aims
According to the effective master plan of the New Town at respecting effective national, regional and local regulations, the
(approved in 1993 and revised in 2009) the 35 ha area is projected existing land use regulations and quantities for the 35 ha area were
S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556 549

adopted with only one exception concerning the category of mixed the construction site all revenues are shared after the units are sold
uses. The proposed land uses on the 35 ha include: at arranged rates (Assmann et al., 2007). This partnership arrange-
ment is also intended for the 35 ha area which is owned by NTDC
Land use Details Share on but shall be distributed to HIC. The HIC is an Iranian public joint
35 ha area (%) stock company and one of country’s largest mass constructors.
The project will be financed by the HIC but presumably supported
Residential Min. 35a
by governmental subsidies since a recent internal feasibility study
Mixed-use Residential, commercial, Max. 10a
(Faulenach, 2010) showed that building costs will be substantially
social
higher than in common housing developments in Hashtgerd New
Office New Towns Development 3
Town. This is due to the quality of construction and the complexity
Corporation Office
of infrastructure solutions. It is currently being discussed within
Retail 2
the Young Cities project whether or not to enlist in the ‘‘Mehr’’
Education Kindergarten, primary 4
scheme, a governmental program that was launched in 2007 with
school, secondary school
the aim to provide housing for the low and middle income sections
Culture/ Mosque, library 1
of Iranian society. Developers in this scheme receive the construc-
religion
tion site for free in order to erect residential housing for first-time
Open space Including constructed 32
home owners on the basis of 99-year lease contracts.
wetlands
The division of labor between Iranian and German partners for
Infrastructure Streets, parking 13
the 35 ha development follows the same logic in all phases of the
35 ha – though responsibilities vary in each pilot project. Within
a
Mixed-use areas combined with residential areas; a maximum share of 10% of the 35 ha the German side develops conceptual ideas, transforms
other than residential uses of the total residential areas is permitted.
them into technical concepts and elaborates their basic design in
The Young Cities project connects research and realization close coordination with the Iranian partners. They, especially the
activities, which is why research institutions and practitioners partners at MHUD, NHRC and NTDC generally hold the power of
are involved on both sides. The Iranian research consortium is decision-making and facilitate the planning process. They are final-
led by BHRC, which coordinates all activities in Iran and is respon- ly responsible for the detailed and approval planning as well as for
sible for all research related issues in Iran. Another important realization, which is supported by Iranian consulting engineers.
stakeholder on the governmental level is the Ministry of Housing Moreover the Iranian side finances all construction activities. Sci-
and Urban Development (MHUD) that is responsible for the entific monitoring and support is shared between TU Berlin and
Iranian New Towns program, including the formulation of its BHRC according to interest and expertise. The work flow is secured
development goals and monitoring implementation (Ziari, 2006). in frequent workshops and meetings in Hashtgerd New Town,
The Iranian New Towns program aims at managing and control- Tehran and Berlin, and by sharing an online-based data sever and
ling the rapid population growth in the large cities by offering an online-GIS-platform.
new employment opportunities, overcoming urban housing prob- The first two years after the research project’s initiation in 2005
lems and preventing the formation of informal settlements (Atash, were used for its set-up, including development of the project
2000). By 2002, 18 New Towns were under construction in Iran structure and building partnerships. During this phase the
(Ziari, 2006). The ministry also oversees the NTDC, which is the German–Iranian teams discussed common goals and project strat-
central development agency for the new towns program through- egies for the 35 ha area and elaborated initial planning scenarios.
out Iran. This national holding forms the third important Iranian From 2007 to 2009, one planning scenario was developed into a
partner within the Young Cities project. NTDC headquarters full master plan by the German side. In 2010 the German and Ira-
establishes a local branch in each New Town that is developed. nian partners elaborated a legally binding comprehensive plan
This local NTDC acts like a municipal authority in all issues (Persian: ‘‘Tarh-e Tafsili’’) together, which was commissioned in
concerning the town’s development by bringing together the October 2010. Transferring the master plan into the ‘‘Tarh-e
responsibilities of all relevant national ministries and local admin- Tafsili’’ revealed the need for strong instruments to maintain inno-
istrative actors. This includes issuing building permits, defining vations in effective planning law. It also showed that comprehen-
rules and standards of construction, providing urban services, sive plans in Iran mainly concentrate on technical planning
supervising construction and concluding the sales and transfer of elements such as land use and plot ratio, but lack the necessary
properties. The local NTDC manages the New Town until it is depth of control and the integration of objectives concerning
handed over to the relevant municipal organizations, which usu- climate change, such as the use of renewable energy sources or
ally takes approximately 25 years (Assmann, 2007; Ziari, 2006). gray water recycling. Thus a range of regulatory possibilities were
The local NTDC branch in Hashtgerd forms the fourth important identified in the comparable German planning instrument, and the
partner in the project. ‘‘Tarh-e Tafsili’’ was enhanced with several energy and resource-
related regulations, though the planning document and process
Site development on the 35 ha area pilot project followed Iranian planning law. In a next step the ‘‘Land Prepara-
tion Plan’’ (‘‘Tarh-e-Amadehsazi’’) and the architectural plans will
Two processes of site development are common in Iranian New be elaborated. The Young Cities project aims to start constructing
Towns. The first process, which prevailed during the first decade of the first buildings in 2011.
Hashtgerd’s development, leaves the responsibility for infrastruc-
ture provision with the NTDC. After selling the plot to the (private,
half-governmental or governmental) developer, NTDC was respon- Low carbon planning strategies in the 35 ha pilot project
sible for developing the site including all necessary technical and
social infrastructures. Infrastructure provision was financed by The following section presents the master plan for the 35 ha area,
selling the land to a developer. In recent years the NTDC has concentrating on the design strategies and criteria, with reference to
increasingly adopted an alternative ‘‘partnership’’ approach, in the responsible partners in footnotes. Before the pilot project is
which large portions of land are distributed to one developer, explored in more detail, the main characteristics of the traditional
who constructs the site’s infrastructure. Since the NTDC provides Iranian city and their climatic advantages shall be briefly
550 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Fig. 6. 35 ha area master plan. Source: TU Berlin.

summarized, which form the underlying spatial rationale of the ur- Climate-sensitive urban form1
ban design:
Climate-sensitive urban form based on passive design bears
 The access system in the historic city based on pedestrian considerable mitigation and adaptation potentials by reducing en-
movement that is composed of different sized pathways facili- ergy consumption especially for cooling and heating without losing
tates a clear spatial hierarchy from public to private spheres thermal comfort. The 35 ha area exploits this potential by referring
(Kheirabadi, 2000). to the traditional Iranian city whose characteristics translate into a
 The introverted courtyard house, omnipresent in the traditional dense and compact urban form with a clear hierarchy of public,
Iranian city, combines privacy, social interaction and protection semi-private and private spaces and access systems in a ‘‘low-rise
against climate, in addition to providing light in the interior – high-density’’ design (see Fig. 6). Twenty-nine compact neighbor-
(Manzoor, 1989). hood clusters that are organized in four rows and are located on the
 The compact, attached housing arrangement minimizes the ridges of the hills on the site stretch from north to south (see Fig. 7).
amount of exposed surfaces (reducing cooling and heating Every cluster (approximately 100 m by 60 m) is defined by a cen-
demand) and provides thermal comfort by creating external tral courtyard (15 m by 30 m) and four building groups arranged
spaces sheltered from direct sunlight (Kheirabadi, 2000). around it. The courtyard forms the inner center of each cluster
 Narrow lanes bordered by high walls in the densely built tradi- and works as a shaded semi-public space for the inhabitants. The
tional city structure create well-shaded spaces during hot sum-
mer afternoons and protect inhabitants against harmful winds
(Kheirabadi, 2000). 1
Results cited in the following paragraph have been elaborated by members of the
 In the historic cities of Iran the proximity of land uses, though research team. The copyright of the concepts and of the results is with the following
functionally separated by the access network, provides an persons: Dimension Urban Planning and Design: Chair for Urban Renewal, Prof. Elke
Pahl-Weber, Dipl.-Ing. Sebastian Seelig, TU Berlin; Dimension Urban Design and
appropriate amount of privacy and easy accessibility of services
Architecture: Chair for Urban Renewal, Prof. Elke Pahl-Weber, Dipl.-Arch. Philipp
at the same time (Manzoor, 1989). Wehage, TU Berlin; Dimension Energy Management: Chair for Building Services
Engineering, Prof. Dr. Nytsch-Geusen, M.Sc. Dipl.-Ing Jörg Huber, Universitaet der
These characteristics can be found throughout the region of Künste Berlin; Dimension Climatology: Institute of Meteorology, Dr. Eberhard Reimer,
‘‘Islamic Urbanism’’ (Ehlers, Bonine, Krafft, & Stober, 1994), and Dr. Sahar Sodoudi, Dr. Ines Langer, Freie Universitaet Berlin; Dimension Landscape
Planning: Chair of Landscape Planning and Development, Prof. Dr. Stefan Heiland, Dr.
form the basic principles for the 35 ha area’s urban design, though Bernd Demuth, TU Berlin and Dimension Environmental Assessment: Environmental
they were adapted to contemporary needs e.g. concerning path Assessment and Planning Research Group, Prof. Dr. Elke Bruns, Dipl.-Ing. Holger
dimensions and building sizes. Ohlenburg, TU Berlin.
S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556 551

Fig. 7. 35 ha massing model. Source: TU Berlin.

Fig. 8. Shading analysis of one neighborhood on 35 ha. Source: UdK Berlin.

clusters are accessible via narrow 6-m wide streets that connect  Building configuration influences the cooling demand by pro-
the neighborhoods from north to south and east to west (see ducing shaded areas. On the 35 ha area this effect reduces cool-
Fig. 6). Except for service and emergency purposes, cars are not ing demand by a maximum of 6% in shaded buildings compared
supposed to enter the neighborhoods. Parking is provided in under- to non-shaded buildings (see Fig. 8).
ground parking lots below the neighborhoods units – thus creating  The orientation of each building has the largest influence on
direct accessibility in otherwise car-free neighborhoods. energy demand. The predominant north–south orientation of
Three main factors that contribute to reducing energy consump- the buildings reduces the cooling demand by up to 23% and
tion were identified in a series of simulations conducted with heating demand by up to 16% compared to unfavorable building
ECOTECT by the Chair for Building Services Engineering at orientations on the 35 ha site.
Universitaet der Künste Berlin, which compared the urban design
on the 35 ha area to alternative scenarios elaborated. The results By configuring buildings and open spaces (open space planning:
show that urban form alone can have a remarkable influence on Chair of Landscape Planning and Development and the Environmen-
energy consumption (Klempert, 2010; Ljubijankic, Nytsch-Geusen, tal Assessment and Planning Research Group of TU Berlin with
& Unger, 2009): Strein/Fenk) according to sun, wind and vegetation, climate sensitive
urban form not only reduces energy consumption but also creates
 Compactness contributes to the reduction of direct solar radia- outdoor thermal comfort, which is extremely important considering
tion and to the reduction of thermal loss. Minimizing exposed Iran’s rising mean temperatures. Micro-climate impacts were
building surfaces by minimizing the surface-area-to-volume simulated by the Institute of Meteorology of FU Berlin (Langer &
(SA:V) ratio is of major importance. The SA:V-ratio on the Schartner, 2011) with the micro-climate model ENVI-met (Bruse,
35 ha area is 0.47 (mean value). 1999), using information from the master plan and different
552 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Fig. 9. Wind rose for Hashtgerd. Source: Paykadeh (2009).

Fig. 10. 35 ha area neighborhood layout. Source: TU Berlin.

vegetation scenarios (Langer & Schartner, 2011). The results were the cool north–south winds from Alborz Mountains to channel
compared. through the site (see Figs. 7 and 9). The simulation results
showing calm wind in inner courtyards measured at a height
 In semi-arid climates protection from solar radiation is extre- of 2 m support this hypothesis. The reduction of the building
mely important in summer, and can be achieved by integrating height to three floors and the flat roofs – also being integral part
vegetation and favorably arranging the geometry of buildings. of traditional Iranian architecture (Manzoor, 1989) – allow for
Due the 35 ha area’s geographic location the degree of shading free movement of air and for fresh air supply.
is rather low. Flexible blinds were proposed for this reason.  Another factor of importance is the vegetation with its poten-
 The arrangement of building aims at blocking the prevailing tially positive effects on the microclimate in summer months.
western and northwestern winds as well as the hot and dusty The increase of unbuilt areas in the 35 ha and the increased
winds from the southeast in summer. At the same time it allows greenery (compared to the original land use program of the site)
S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556 553

Fig. 11. Mixed Use District with potential small-scale mixed use areas. Source: TU Berlin.

fosters cooling by vegetation and an increase of air humidity majority of plots have a north–south orientation and are between 20
through trees’ evaporation. Simulations have shown that plant- to 35 meters depth so as to maximize energetic potentials. In order
ing vegetation on the road sides such as trees leads to a to increase solar radiation for energy production, the building vol-
decrease of the soil temperature of 3 K compared to scenarios umes have terraces and niches in the upper floors. The dominant
with no plants. This indicates the importance of vegetation in vertical organization of the building volumes provides sun for every
mitigating rising mean temperatures. residential unit. The orientation of the living zones within the units
around the courtyard combines the need of privacy with microcli-
matic advantages (Seelig, Wehage, & Pahl-Weber, 2011).
Culturally adapted building typologies for reduced heating and
cooling2
Public transport and dense mixed-use neighborhoods for
Energy demand is also significantly influenced by housing types reducing transport energy3
(Santamournis, 2006). The courtyard house supports ventilation and
permits natural cooling (Fathy, Shearer, & Sultan, 1986), while Density, land use and the availability of public transportation
reducing direct exposure to the sun. At the same time its introverted systems indirectly affect users’ mobility patterns and thus can
building form reduces the amount of exposed surfaces. The court- reduce individual energy consumption (Jenks & Jones, 2010). The
yard house is also culturally sensitive because it creates private 35 ha Area proposes an average floor area ratio of 1.6, which is
and introverted spaces in dense urban form, which is why it is the equivalent to 228 persons per hectare. This relatively dense urban
prevailing housing type in the traditional Islamic city. The urban de- form is complemented by an integrated network of public trans-
sign for the 35 ha Area (urban planning, design and architecture: portation lines, footpaths and bicycle lanes. In addition, a higher
Chair for Urban Renewal of TU Berlin) makes use of these potentials capacity transport system that connects the site to the planned
by introducing a contemporary interpretation of the courtyard Hashtgerd–Karaj–Tehran metro line and to Old Hashtgerd is
house (see Fig. 10). It proposes two to three story stacked courtyard
house buildings with widths of between six and fifteen meters. The 3
Results cited in the following paragraph have been elaborated by members of the
research team. The copyright of the concepts and of the results is with the following
2
Results cited in the following paragraph have been elaborated by members of the persons: Dimension Urban Planning and Design, Dimension Urban Design and
research team. The copyright of the concepts and of the results is with the following Architecture with Dimension Transport and Mobility: Center for Technology and
persons: Dimension Urban Design and Architecture. Society, Dr.-Ing. Wulf-Holger Arndt, Technische Universitaet Berlin.
554 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

for more regulatory flexibility in land uses than otherwise common


in Hashtgerd.

Integrated infrastructure systems at the neighborhood level4

Furthermore, the compact mixed-use urban form is inter-


connected with innovative infrastructure systems, mainly in the
areas of wastewater and energy. The waste water concept, elabo-
rated by the companies of inter3 and p2m reduces energy and
fresh water demand without compromising comfort. This flexible
concept proposes separate collection, treatment and reuse of gray
water in decentralized constructed wetlands as well as co-fermen-
tation of black water and organics for biogas production. The gray
water is generated from domestic equipment such as showers,
sinks and washing machines, the black water comes from the
water closet. After treatment in the constructed wetlands on site,
the quality of the gray water is sufficient for the use in artificial
water bodies such as ponds, as non-drinkable service water in
the courtyards (e.g. for cleaning of surfaces) and for the irrigation
of the site’s green spaces (Mohajeri & Vocks, 2011). The design of
the green spaces within the 35 ha area is sensitive to the need
for reducing water consumption for maintenance and preservation
measures, for example by selecting suitable vegetation and by
limiting the scale of water-intensive green areas (see Fig. 13)
(Mohajeri & Vocks, 2011).
Fig. 12. Mixed use zone in courtyard. Source: TU Berlin.
The use of various energy technologies and components is cur-
rently being considered for the area’s energy concept, elaborated
by the Chair for Building Services Engineering at Berlin University
of the Arts. They are based on locally available non-renewable re-
sources (such as natural gas and oil) and regenerative energy
envisaged in order to ensure horizontal spatial integration. The sources (such as solar irradiation, and biomass from wastewater
neighborhoods themselves will be served by a minibus whose treatment). Several concepts for central, semi-central and de-cen-
stops will be distributed at a distance of no more than 250 m from tral thermal energy supply have already been designed using de-
any residential unit. tailed simulation models in ECOTECT and ENERGYPLUS and
The proposed transport concept elaborated at the Center for MODELLICA. A possibility that is currently being discussed pro-
Technology and Society of TU Berlin is combined with a mixed land poses a central heat supply system and decentralized solar cold
use concept (see Fig. 11). Aside from an increased urban vitality air production, that would need only one central thermal distribu-
and flexibility, mixed land uses in compact urban environments tion network and otherwise use separate decentralized absorption
offer high potentials for the reduction of fossil energy use and chillers and solar thermal collectors (Ljubijankic, Nytsch-Geusen, &
therefore GHG emissions. This is mainly related to shorter travel Unger, 2009).
distances and to the increased use of public transportation, and a
greater incentive for walking and cycling (Bundesamt fuer Bauwe-
sen und Raumordnung (BBR), 2000). These assumptions translate Conclusion
into a two-layered land use concept that proposes a center with
larger social functions in the heart of the site and a fine mix of This paper concludes that Iran’s urban agglomerations and spe-
smaller commercial uses with residential units at the neighbor- cifically the megacity of Tehran face tremendous challenges due to
hood level. For the latter, the project has also developed appropri- urbanization processes and their social, ecological and economic
ate housing typologies – so called ‘‘vertical mixed units’’ – which consequences. These are increasingly related to the effects of cli-
provide space for small scale commercial and social units on the mate change such as extreme weather events, water scarcity and
ground floors of the residential buildings that are concentrated increasing energy demand. In the face of current building and plan-
around the courtyards (see Fig. 12). Distances between housing, ning practice in Iran and the pressure on the Iranian housing mar-
work, supply infrastructure and social infrastructure are kept short ket new approaches towards energy-efficient and resilient housing
by the quality of the mixed-use zones, their integration of larger development are urgently needed.
social functions within walking distance and the connection to The German–Iranian research initiative ‘‘Young Cities’’ aims at
the city-wide public transportation system, as well as to walking contributing a series of innovations to the housing sector in Iran, that
and cycling routes. This combination of measures aims at achieving will be implemented and monitored in a 35 ha pilot settlement in
a modal shift and thus reducing CO2 emissions. Preliminary traffic the new town of Hashtgerd. The site’s master plan includes key plan-
simulations conducted at the TU Dresden with VISUM show that ning strategies for energy-efficiency and resilience designed for the
the land use concept for the 35 ha Area has the potential to reduce specific socio-economic and climatic context of Hashtgerd. This pa-
the traffic volume in general: individual car trips are reduced by 3% per highlights the importance of non-technical, low-cost strategies
and trips with public transportation by 7% as compared to a func-
4
tionally separated land use concept; the impacts of the measures Results cited in the following paragraph have been elaborated by members of the
on the model split of the transport modes have not been explored research team. The copyright of the concepts and of the results is with the following
persons: Dimension Water and Wastewater Management: Dr. Sharooz Mohajeri,
yet. All elements of this proposal are part of the ‘‘Mixed Use Dis- Dipl.-Ing. Tamara Nuñez von Voigt, Dr. Martin Vocks, inter3, p2m, Berlin; Dimension
trict’’ (MUD) as defined for the 35 ha Area in the ‘‘Tarh-e Tafsili’’. Landscape Planning; Dimension Environmental Assessment with Dimension Energy
The MUD is a model district with special regulations that allows Management.
S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556 555

Fig. 13. Extensive landscaping for reduced water consumption. Source: Strein/Fenk.

for urban form such as orientation, compactness and building con- Acknowledgment
figuration that have the potential to reduce cooling and heating de-
mand and ensure thermal outdoor comfort on the basis of mere The work presented has been substantially supported by fund-
planning measures. The ‘‘low rise – high density’’ approach that is ing from the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research
founded on the principles of traditional Iranian urban form also re- within the program ‘‘Sustainable Development of the Megacities
flects the cultural importance. This vernacular approach is combined of Tomorrow’’.
with a mixed land-use model that effectively reduces the incidence
of individual motorized traffic if linked to a public transportation
References
system. In order to reduce resource consumption, the master plan
also proposes a sustainable water management concept based on Amiri, M. J., & Eslamian, S. S. (2010). Investigation of climate change in Iran.
water recycling in constructed wetlands, which serve for irrigating International Journal of Environmental Science & Technology, 3(4), 208–216.
the open spaces. Through this measure, an estimated 50% of water Assmann, U. (2007). Feasibility study for the New Town of Hashtgerd, stakeholder-
approach and policy analyses. Unpublished results, Diploma thesis, Institute of
can be kept in the local cycle, which is especially important given Architecture, TU Berlin, Berlin.
the area’s water scarcity. Numerous simulations have shown how Atabi, F. (2004). Renewable energy in Iran: Challenges and opportunities for
the proposed concepts save energy and create resilience to the ef- sustainable development. International Journal of Environmental Science &
Technology, 1(1), 69–80.
fects of climate change.
Atash, F. (2000). New Towns and future Urbanisation in Iran. Third World Planning
Their actual effectiveness, however, will only be proved by real- Review, 22(1), 67–86.
izing and monitoring the pilot project. At this point, realization is Bakhtiari, S., & Shahbudaghlou, A. M. (2000). Energy consumption in Iran. OPEC
still linked to a number of open questions, most importantly the Energy Review, 24(3), 211–233.
Bruse, M. (1999). ENVI-met, Die Auswirkung kleinskaliger Umweltgestaltung auf
financing of the project. Nevertheless, the approval of the legally das Mikroklima-Entwicklung des prognostischen numerischen Modells zur
binding land use plan for the pilot site is a highly significant step Simulation der Wind- Temperatur- und Feuchteverteilung in städtischen
in the right direction, which was mainly achieved due to the Strukturen, PhD Thesis, Universität Bochum.
Bundesamt fuer Bauwesen und Raumordnung (BBR) (2000). Nutzungsmischung im
involvement of high-ranking Iranian partners, all of whom hold di- Staedtebau. Endbericht, Werkstatt: Praxis 2/2000, Bonn.
rect decision making powers even over the allocation of financial Boden, T. A. (2010). Global, regional, and national fossil-fuel CO2 emissions. Carbon
resources, and who were open to the implementation of innovative Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, US
Department of Energy. <http://cdiac.ornl.gov/trends/emis/tre_tp20.html>
solutions. Moreover, the pilot site’s location in a new town greatly Accessed 15.07.09.
facilitated the planning process, because the local NTDC brings to- Daneshdoust, D. (2010). Energy subsidies: Can Iran kick the habit? <http://
gether all municipal competencies in all fields of urban develop- www.globalsubsidies.org/en/subsidy-watch/analysis/energy-subsidies-can-
iran-kick-habit> Accessed 17.11.10.
ment, which greatly accelerates approval procedures. It is worth Ehlers, E., Bonine, M. E., Krafft, T. & Stober, G. (1994). The Middle Eastern City and
mentioning that (other than originally intended) this top-down Islamic urbanism. An annotated bibliography of western literature, Bonner
planning process does not endorse many participative elements. Geographische Abhandlungen 91, Bonn.
Erdbrink, T. (2010). After currency crash, more worries for Iranian economy.
Hence the project collaborates closely with a number of Iranian
<http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/05/
and German Masters, PhD, and post doctoral students who serve AR2010100506165_2.html?sid=ST2010100506735> Accessed 17.11.10.
as highly appreciated alternative reference persons. With this pro- Fanni, Z. (2006). Cities and urbanization in Iran after the Islamic revolution. Cities,
ject set-up and scientific network the project team hopes to further 23(6), 407–411.
Farhoodi, R., Gharakhlou-N, M., Ghadami, M., & Panahandeh Khah, M. (2009). A
elaborate the concepts and realize the first buildings on site from critique of the prevailing comprehensive urban planning paradigm in Iran: The
2011 onwards. need for strategic planning. Planning Theory, 8, 335–361.
556 S. Seelig / Cities 28 (2011) 545–556

Jenks, M., & Jones, C. (Eds.). (2010). Dimensions of the sustainable city (Future cities 2). Modarres, A. (2006b). Modernizing Yazd: Selective historical memory and the fate of
New York: Springer. vernacular architecture. Costa Mesa: Mazda Pub.
Fathy, H., Shearer, W., & Sultan, A. (1986). Natural energy and vernacular architecture. Mohajeri, S., & Vocks, M. (2011). Resource-efficient wastewater disposal system for
Principles and examples with reference to hot arid climates. Chicago: University of arid and semi-arid regions – case study Iran/Hashgerd. Bluefacts 2011.
Chicago Press. International Journal of Water-Management, 44-50.
Faulenach, D. (2010). Feasibility study Hashtgerd New Town. Young Cities pilot project Muir, J. (2007). Tehran declares war on pollution. BBC news. <http://news.bbc.co.uk/
‘‘35ha area’’. Unpublished results, Master thesis, Department of Real Estate 2/hi/middle_east/1124024.stm> Accessed 15.07.09.
Management, TU Berlin, Berlin. Nasrollahi, F. (2010). Climatic analysis of Hashtgerd New Town. Institute of
International Energy Agency (IEA) (2005). World energy outlook 2005, Middle East Architecture, TU Berlin, Berlin, Unpublished results.
and North Africa Insights, Paris. National Climate Change Office of Islamic Republic of Iran (2007). <http://
Kari, M., & Fayaz, R. (2006). Evaluation of the Iranian thermal building code. Asian www.climate-change.ir> Accessed 17.10.07.
Journal of the civil Engineering (Building and Housing), 6, 675–684. New Towns Development Corporation of Iran (1993). An outlook: The New Town of
Kheirabadi, M. (2000). Iranian cities: Formation and development. Syracuse: Syracuse Hashtgerd, Tehran.
University Press. Paykadeh Consultants (2008). Revision of Hashtgerd New Town master plan –
Klempert, O. (2010). Solar pilot project in Iran. Sonne Wind & Wärme, 34(14), Summary. Unpublished results, Tehran (in Persian).
78–81. Roudi-Fahimi, F., & Mederios, M. K. (2007). Challenges and opportunities – The
Koeppen, W. (1900). Versuch einer Klassifikation der Klimate vorzugsweise nach population of the Middle East and North Africa. Washington, DC: Population
ihren Beziehungen zur Pflanzenwelt. Geographische Zeitschrift 6, 593–611, 657– Reference Bureau.
679. Sabetghadam, M. (2006). Sustainable energy watch 2005/2006. Energy and sustainable
Langer, I., & Schartner, Th. (2011). Micro climate simulation in New Town development in Iran. Paris: Helio International.
HASHTGERD. In Proceedings CET 2011, Shanghai, 26-30, Oct. 2011, in press. Santamournis, M. (2006). Environmental design of urban buildings. An integrated
Ljubijankic, M., Nytsch-Geusen, C., & Unger, S. (2009). Modelling of complex approach. London: Earthscan.
thermal energy supply systems based on the Modelica-Library fluid flow. In Seelig, S., Wehage, P., & Pahl-Weber, E. (2011). Energie und Identität –
Proceedings 7th modelica conference, Como, Italy, Sep. 20-22 2009 (pp. 335–340). Stadtgestaltung für eine energiegerechte New Town in Iran. Stadtbauwelt, 189,
The Modelica Association. 64–69.
Madanipour, A. (1998). Tehran. The making of a metropolis. Chichester: Wiley. Statistical Center of Iran (2006). National census, Tehran.
Manzoor, S. (1989). Tradition and development: An approach to vernacular Tehran Geographic Information Centre (2004). Atlas of Tehran City 2004. <http://
architectural patterns in Iran. Gothenburg: Chalmers University of Technology. www.tehrangis.com/atlas/> Accessed 17.10.07.
Mazayan, D., & Diba, D. (2004). Trends in modern Iranian architecture. In P. Jodidio World Bank (2003). Islamic Republic of Iran – Urban transport review, Washington,
(Ed.), Iran: Architecture for changing societies (pp. 31–37). Torino: Umberto DC.
Allemandi. World Resources Institute (2009). Energy consumption by sector 2005. Earth trends
Mirmoghtadaee, M. (2009). Process of housing transformation in Iran. Journal of date tables. <http://earthtrends.wri.org/pdf_library/data_tables/ene3_ 2005.pdf>
Construction in Developing Countries, 14(1), 69–80. Accessed 15.07.09.
Modarres, A. (2006a). Urbanization and the revolution: An introduction to the Ziari, K. (2006). The planning and functioning of new towns in Iran. Cities, 23(6),
special issue. Cities, 23(6), 405–406. 412–422.

You might also like