Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Due to escalating urbanization and population growth around the world, there is a
significant demand for the construction of tall buildings, and earthquakes have the
capacity to causing the damage to those tall structures. Seismic Base Isolation is one
of the most prevalent techniques for shielding a building from earthquake forces. It is a
collection of structural elements that should substantially decouple a superstructure from
its substructure,which is resting on the shaking ground, thereby protecting the integrity
of a building or structures. Superstructure typically move like rigid bodies rather than
collapsing even whenthe earth is moving violently. The installation of isolators at the
base of buildings significantly increases the time period of the structure, decreasing the
resonance of structureand improving the building's seismic performance. In this study a
Non-Linear Dynamic Analysis (Time History Analysis) is performed of a high-rise
(G+14) Storey RC building with dynamic isolators (lead-rubber-bearing), in
comparison with Fixed base system of thesame building for Different Ground Motion
Data (El Centro and Corralit) using ETABS software. The results obtained from the
analysis are collatted in terms of base shear, storey displacement, storey drift, storey
stiffness, and storey acceleration. Storey stiffness for the isolated base structure
decreases and it promotes structural flexibility. When compared to a fixed foundation
building, the isolator considerably reduces the stiffness and acceleration ofthe stories in
both the X and Y directions.
Keywords: Nonlinear Time History Analysis, Base Isolation, Lead Rubber Bearing,
StoreyDisplacement, Storey Stiffness, Storey drift, Base Shear.
.
In the modern world, population growth and population density is increasing very
rapidly, which causes the amount of space accessible for people to continue decreasing
daily. The invention of multi-storey structures is a result of the need for more comfort
in a less space. When constructing and erecting a multi-storey building in a seismically
active area, early safeguards must be taken due to the unpredictable behaviour of
earthquake. Because, the traditional approach to designing earthquake-resistant
structures in not economic which involves making buildings stiff and strong in order
to absorb all the lateral stresses produced by earthquake ground motion. As a Structural
Engineer has to take action to save lives and at least damage buildings during an
earthquake. Base isolation is the most recent advancement in earthquake protection
projects; it cannot stop ground movement but helps to reduce its consequences on
structure.
India is categorized into four (II, III, IV, and V) seismic zones, whereas zones III, IV, and
V covering over 60% of the country's surface area. The earthquakes are catastrophic and
can resultin considerable structural damage or even collapse. As the tectonic plates which
lies on the asthenosphere are always slowly moving due to friction, they become trapped
at their edges, which results in this natural hazard. Large strain energy is released at the
margins where tensionoverpowers friction and propagates as seismic waves throughout
the earth's crust in alldirections
It consist of laminated elastomeric bearing pad, top and bottom sealing & connecting
plates and lead plug inserted in the middle of the bearing as shown in the Fig 1.2.1. These
are mainly built up for dampers of low elastomers and cores of lead of around 15%-33%
of bearing bonded diameters. Use of combination of lead-plug and laminated-rubber
bearings which produce enormous dissipation energy (hysteretic energy) which leads to
a merging of single component and for the successful system or isolation system the
dampers are essential. Lead-plug bearings shear strain range between the 12.5% and 20%
and it varies as a purpose or function as producer or manufacturer. Usually, these LRB
isolators are of cylindrical in nature of bearings along with steel shims reinforcement.
There will be alternate arrangement of rubber and shims and at isolators both ends steel
plates are provided. Load carrying capacity is enhanced by the steel shims which in turn
stiffened under the vertical loading and which in turn flexible under the horizontal
loading. The rectification of the response of the building is the main essential
(fundamental) principle of base isolation system without any conveying these motions
into the frame. In an ideal system to achieve this flexibility in structure this separation
would be required. But in the existing world there is a necessity to have some contact
between the superstructure and sub structure. So, we provide some device that can help
to reduce the transfer of load through these isolators.
2.1 A. B. M. Saiful Islam and Walid A. Al-Kutti carried out a study on “SEISMIC
RESPONSE VARIATION OF MULTISTOREY BASE-ISOLATED BUILDINGS
APPLYING LEAD RUBBER BEARINGS”. The superstructures of the high-rise buildings
are represented by finite element assemblage adopting multi-degree of freedoms. Static and
dynamic analyses are carried out for Fixed base (FB) and base isolated (BI) buildings. The
dynamic analysis in finite element package has been performed by the nonlinear time history
analysis (THA) based on the site-specific seismic excitation and compared employing eminent
earthquakes. The influence of the model type and the alteration in superstructure behaviour of
the isolated buildings have been duly assessed. The results of the 3D multistorey structures
show that the lateral forces, displacement, inertia and storey accelerations of the superstructure
of the seismic prone buildings are significantly reduced due to bearing insertion. The nonlinear
dynamic analysis shows 12 to 40% lessening in base shear when LRB is incorporated leading
to substantial allowance of horizontal displacement. It is revealed that the LRB isolators might
be potential options to diminish the respective floor accelerations, inertia, displacements and
base shear whatever the condition coincides. The isolators with lower force intercept but
higher isolation period is found to be better for decreasing base shear, floor acceleration and
inertia force leading to reduction of structural and non-structural damage. However, LRB with
lower isolator period seems to be more effective in dropping displacement at bearing interface
aimed at reducing horizontal shift of building structure [1].
2.2 Vinodkumar Parma, G.S. Hiremath’s study is carried on “EFFECT OF BASE
ISOLATION IN MULTISTORIED RC IRREGULAR BUILDING USING TIME HISTORY
ANALYSIS”. Base isolation (BI) is a globally recognized method to safeguard buildings from
earthquake damage. By introducing isolators at the base, the technique notably extends the
structure's natural period, minimizing resonance risk and enhancing seismic performance.
This study compares the effectiveness of base isolation in multi-story RC frame buildings with
plan irregularity and vertical irregularity. The investigation centers on a 15-story RC frame
building, utilizing Time History analysis within ETABS 2013 software. Lead Rubber Bearings
(LRB) adhering to UBC 97 code are designed for the analysis of the base isolation system.
Results encompass time period and base shear. Isolated structures exhibit longer time periods
2.6 A.B.M. Saiful Islam and Mahmoud Sodangi study on “RUBBER BEARING
ISOLATION FOR STRUCTURES PRONE TO EARTHQUAKE - A COST
EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS” explores the effectiveness, design, and practical feasibility of
base isolation systems to reduce seismic demands on buildings of varying elevations. Thus,
static and dynamic analyses were conducted based on site-specific bi-directional earthquakes
for base-isolated as well as fixed-based buildings. Remarkably, it was discovered that isolators
used in low-rise to high-rise structures tend to significantly decrease the structural responses
of seismic prone buildings. The higher allowable horizontal displacement induces structural
flexibility and ensure good structural health of the building stories. Reinforcement from vertical
and horizontal members can be reduced in significant amounts for BI buildings. Thus, although
incorporating base isolators increases the initial outlay, it considerably diminishes the total
structural cost [6].
1. To analyze a Multistoried RC framed Building (G+14) with and without Rubber Base
Isolator.
2. To study the seismic behavior of multistoried RC framed Building under Nonlinear
dynamic analysis (Time History Analysis) for different Ground Motion Data (El Centro
and Corralit).
3. To collate the results obtained by analysis of multistoried building with and without
rubber base isolator
METHODOLOGY
Model 3. Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis (Time History) of Fixed base for Corralit ground
motion data.
Model 4 . Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis (Time History) of Isolated base for Corralit ground
motion data.
Model 5 . Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis (Time History) of Fixed base for El Centro ground
motion data.
Model 6 . Nonlinear Dynamic Analysis (Time History) of Isolated base for El Centro ground
motion data.
Number of storeys 15
Dead Load
Seismic zone= IV
Response Reduction Factor R= 5 (RC building with special moment resisting frame(SMRF))
Soil Type= II
Terrain Category= 3
Coefficient,k1= 1
Topography, k3= 1
The design is based on Indian Standard Codes and is analysed for Dead, Live, Wind, and
Seismic load conditions while taking into consideration relevant load combinations
recommended by the codes IS 456-2000, IS 875 (Part 5)-1987, and IS 1893-2016 (Part 1).
Vertical loads are transferred to the soil via columns and footings, which include dead and
superimposed loads. The ETabs software is used to analyse the structure for both vertical
and lateral loads. Floor slabs are thought to function as a rigid diaphragm transferring lateral
forcesto lateral load resisting elements. The following table shows the Load Combinations
used in analysis.
The following load combinations are considered as per IS 1893-2016 (Part 1) for
analysis:
1) 1.2 [DL+IL+(THX + 0.3THy)]
1.2[DL+IL+(THy+0.3THx)];
3) 0.9[DL+1.5(THX+0.3THy)];
It's important to note that the Equivalent Static Method is an approximation and may not
capture all the complexities of a structure's behaviour during an earthquake. It is satisfactory
for simple structures and regions with lower seismic hazard levels. For more complex
structures or high-seismic hazard regions, more advanced analysis methods, such as
response spectrum analysis or time history analysis, may be necessary to ensure accurate
seismic design.
It is a practical method for estimating structural deformation and damage patterns under
constant vertical loads and gradually increasing lateral loads. Nonlinear static analysis is a
seismic analysis method in which the behaviour of the structure is characterized by a
capacity curve that represents the relationship between the base shear force and the roof
displacement. It is also referred as Pushover Analysis.
Nonlinear time history analysis is particularly useful when dealing with complex and highly
dynamic systems, such as buildings, bridges, dams, and other structures subjected to severe
loading conditions, such as earthquakes or explosions. It provides insights into the structural
performance that linear analysis cannot capture and helps engineers design structures that
can withstand extreme events.
However, nonlinear analysis is computationally more intensive than linear analysis, and
accurate. In this study we used nonlinear time history analysis method as seismic analysis
of building.
Fig.4.5.1 El Centro Ground Motion Data Curve.