Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ICRU-38 (Braquiterapia)
ICRU-38 (Braquiterapia)
U.S.A.
THE INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION
ON RADIATION UNITS AND MEASUREMENTS
INDIVIDUALS PARiflCIPATING IN THE PREPARATION OF THIS REPORT
The Commission wishes to express its appreciation to the individuals involved in the preparation of this report
for the time and effort they devoted to this task and to express its appreciation to the organizations with which they
are affiliated.
some cases too specialized to justify single-volume Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences
publication, initiated the publication of a series of re- Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
International Council of Scientific Unions
ports, each dealing with a limited range of topics. This International Electrotechnical Commission
series was initiated with the publication of six re- International Labor Office
ports: International Organization for Medical Physics
International Radiation Protection Association
ICRU Report lOa, Radiation Quantities and Units International Union of Pure and Applied Physics
ICRU Report lOb, Physical Aspects of Irradiation United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organiza-
ICRU Report lOc, Radioactivity tion
ICRU Report 10d, Clinical Dosimetry
ICRU Report lOe, Radiobiological Dosimetry The Commission has found its relationship with all
ICRU Report 10f, Methods of Evaluating Radiological Equip- of these organizations fruitful and of substantial benefit
ment and Materials
to the ICRU program. Relations with these other in-
These reports were published, as had been many of ternational bodies do not affect the basic affiliation of
the previous reports of the Commission, by the United the ICRU with the International Society of Radi-
States Government Printing Office as Handbooks of the ology.
National Bureau of Standards. Operating Funds
In 1967, the Commission determined that in the fu-
Society of Nuclear Medicine ipating in ICRU activities, (2) travel costs involved in
Statens laegevidenskabelige Forskningsrad ICRU meetings, and (3) meeting facilities and ser-
Toshiba Corporation
United Nations
vices.
U.S. Bureau of Radiological Health of the Food and Drug Admin- In recognition of the fact that its work is made pos-
istration sible by the generous support provided by all of the or-
World Health Organization ganizations supporting its program, the Commission
Xerox Corporation expresses its deep appreciation.
In addition to the direct monetary support provid-
ed by these organizations, many organizations provide HAROLD O. WYCKOFF
indirect support for the Commission's program. This Chairman, ICRU
support is provided in many forms, including, among Bethesda, Maryland, U.S.A.
others, subsidies for (1) the time of individuals partic- 15 January 1985
In 1978, the ICRU published Report 29, Dose Spec- system (Paterson, 1948)1. Most of the systems used
ification for Reporting External Beam Therapy with throughout the world are derived from these three basic
Photons and Electrons (ICRU, 1978). The present re- systems.
port deals with the problem of dose and volume speci- As used here, the term "system" denotes a set of rules
fication for reporting intracavitary therapy. The prin- taking into account the source strengths, geometry and
cipal subject is dose and volume specification for the method of application in order to obtain suitable dose
intracavitary treatment of cervix carcinoma. However, distributions over the volume(s) to be treated. For re-
the concepts developed in this report are designed to be porting, the system includes recommendations for
applicable to other types of intracavitary applications, specifying the application and possibly, as in the
such as uterine body, etc. Manchester system, for calculating the dose rate (or
Intracavitary therapy is often used in combination dose) at specific points.
with external beam therapy and, therefore, the same Typical applications according to the Stockholm
terminology and definitions of terms are advocated. In system and the historical Paris system are presented in
particular, it would be desirable, whenever possible, to Figures 1.1 and 1.2, respectively. In both systems, ap-
use the concepts of target volume, treatment volume plications have been reported in terms of "mg.h" (mil-
and irradiated volume, as defined for external beam ligram hours), i.e., the product of the total mass or ra-
therapy. However, due to the high dose-gradient around dium contained in the sources (in mg) and of the dura-
the sources (throughout the tumor and target volume), tion of the application (in hours).
the specification of the target absorbed dose in terms The Manchester system (Paterson and Parker, 1934),
of the dose absorbed either at one or several reference derived from the original Paris system, initiated about
point(s) within the target volume is not considered 1920, was designed to deliver a constant dose rate to
meaningful; therefore, the approach used in external defmed points near the cervix, irrespective of variation
beam therapy cannot be used. in size and shape of the uterus and vagina. In the
The problem of dose specification is still more com- Manchester system, an application was specified in
plicated when two or more target volumes are identified, terms of the "dose" in roentgens delivered at specific
some being treated either by external, or by intracavi- points such as points "A" and "B" (Figure 1.3). Points
tary therapy and some by both methods. Furthermore, A and B are still widely used throughout the world, al-
attention should be paid to the different time-dose though their exact meaning and their definition have
patterns linked to each treatment method. not always been interpreted in the same way in different
Based on clinical experience, different systems have centers and even in a given center over a period of time.
been proposed for the treatment of cervix carcinoma. In particular, some centers relate point A to anatomical
Three basic systems have been developed: the Stock- references in the patient, others to the geometry of the
holm system (Kottmeier, 1964)1, the Paris system sources.
(Lamarque and Coliez, 1951)1 and the Manchester The different methods of definition provide different
values for the calculated dose rate to point A. As a result,
1The references quoted are not the first references but those which where a prescribed dose to point A is used to calculate
seem to be the most comprehensive. the total time for an insertion, different values of time
1
2 • • . 1. Introduction
B B
•
Fig. 1.3. The Manchester system. Definition of points" A" and "B".
In the classical Manchester system, point A is dermed as a point 2 em
lateral to the central canal of the uterus and 2 em up from the mucous
mem brane of the lateral fornix, in the axis of the uterus. Point B is
defined as being in the transverse axis through points A, 5 cm from
the midline. In clinical practice, dose calculations are often made from
radiographs and point A is taken 2 em up from the flange of the in-
trauterine source and 2 em lateral from the central canal as indicated
in the figure (Meredith, 1967). In a typical application, the loading of
intrauterine applicators varied between 20 and 35 mg of radium and
between 15 and 25 mg of radium for each vaginal ovoid. The resultant
treatment time to get 8000 R at point A was 140 hours.
1. Introduction... 3
will be obtained, depending on the method used. It is (i) radium is being progressively replaced by gamma-
therefore important to give a precise description of the ray emitting substitutes (137CS, 192Ir and 60CO)2;
method used to calculate the dose rate at specific (ii) new sets of sources are available, for which the old
points. systems are not always suitable;
On the other hand, the Manchester system is based (iii) SI units are now being widely used in the field of
on a set of strict rules concerning the method of insert- radiology; and
ing the radium sources (in particular the choice of vag- (iv) computers are routinely used for calculations and
inal ovoids and their separation, and the relative complete sets of intracavitary dose distribution
strengths ofthe intrauterine and intravaginal sources). in several planes are now becoming available, from
Assuming that the Manchester definition of point A is which new information and relationships can be
used, this will be the location where there is least vari- derived.
ation in the dose rate from one source arrangement to
another one.
It is opportune now to reconsider dose and volume 2 Californium-252, a neutron emitter, is also used but will not be
specification for several reasons: discussed in this document.
4
2.2 Absorbed-Dose Pattern and Volumes • •• 5
sented an opportunity for investigating different dose afterloading techniques as well as modifying their ir-
rates and, in particular, very high dose rates. In this radiation procedures, attention needs to be given to the
Report, the term high dose rate refers to any dose rate problems of dose specification and dose-time relation-
higher than 0.2 gray per minute (12 grays per hour), ships. As already stressed, the clinical experience ac-
although it usually refers to dose rates as high as 2 to 5 cumulated with radium techniques cannot be applied
grays per minute, i.e., treatment sessions of a few min- to new irradiation conditi{)ns without careful consid-
utes duration. eration.
Some radiotherapists are now exploring intermediate
dose rates, between 2 and 12 grays per hour and we
2.2 Absorbed-Dose Pattern and Volumes
propose to refer to such dose rates as medium dose
rates.
2.2.1 Absorbed-Dose Pattern
Such definitions of low dose rate, medium dose rate
and high dose rate are arbitrary and debatable. In this The pattern of the absorbed dose to the soft tissue in
connection, it must be stressed that the treatment du- intracavitary therapy differs from the dose pattern
ration should always be clearly reported (see Section encountered in external therapy. In external beam
4). therapy, one aim is to reduce variations in dose over the
target volume. In general, variations greater than ±10%
'/
; --- .....
,
1/;-.... "
..... , ''
\ \' ,
'/,_
-_
-,'
..... ,,,
,\ \
I
~"
\'I \ \
\
\\ '\
,
"
I I , \
I I I \ \ \
I I \ \ \ \
A ...j....£_I_.l--->.
1110\\\ \ \
7050 30 20
,\\ ~
\ \\ . . . - - _
I _ __
\
10 cGy,h- 1
B
\ ,
' ......... ",'
\
,
\
\
\
~c...=..:..;:..:...-~2::.....::ccm~
..... "
\ \" \I II
\ I I I
® /,, I I
J I I I I
_/ " I I I
_",,/ I I I
____ - .... ",I' /1
/
---
--- -
..,'"
-"
/
/
/
1
, _------/
.....
-----IRIDIUM WIRES
/
-" '"
RADIUM TUBES
uterine tubes 3 x 10 mg (same reference air kerma
rates as radium tubes )
vaginal tubes 2 x 15 mg
filtration 1 mm Pt correction made for oblique
fill ration
2.2b
2.2 Absorbed-Dose Pattern and Volumes . . . 7
1//'
I
I//l
100
I~I
l;/j
I
'"
01
tU
~ 50
v
....
'"
a.
'"
III
o 3
a
2.2c
Fig. 2.2. Comparison of absorbed dose patterns between external and intracavitary therapy. 2.28 shows the dose distribution for an irradiation
of the pelvis with a 6OCO teletherapy machine and four fields-the so-called "box technique" (see ICRU Report 29, Figure 3.4). The border of
the target area is indicated by the heavy dotted line. 2.2b shows a typical dose distribution in an intracavitary application (IAEA, 1972; Dutreix
et al., 1982). 2.2c shows the dose variation along a lateral axis. The full line refers to external therapy (Figure 2.2a, along the beam axis 3 and
4). The dotted line refers to intracavitary therapy (Figure 2.2b, along the AB axis). The absorbed dose has been normalized to 1000/0 at a distance
of 2 cm from the uterine axis. The shaded areas (2 cm wide) show the high dose-gradient regions beyond the border of each of the two treatment
volumes.
ment of cervix carcinoma where, depending on the ex- ume. In intracavitary therapy, it is not feasible to ex-
tent of disease, some target volumes may be treated press the value of the isodose surface enclosing the
partly or totally by an intracavitary application, while treatment volume as a percentage of the dose at any
others are treated mainly by external therapy, The point within the treatment volume. This is because of
target volume(s) must always be described, indepen- the steep dose gradient around the sources and the
dently of the dose distribution, in terms of the patient's variation encountered in the techniques used. It is
anatomy, topography and tumor volume, For the pur- necessary to plan the treatment to include the target
pose of reporting intracavitary treatment, that part of volume within the treatment volume.
the target volume which has to be irradiated by means Reference Volume
of intracavitary application should be separately de- The reference volume is defined as the volume en-
scribed, It should also be stated whether this volume will closed by the reference isodose surface. In order to fa-
receive treatment only by intracavitary application or cilitate intercomparisons between radiotherapy centers,
will receive treatment by both modalities. The physical it is necessary to agree upon a reference dose level. The
dimensions of the target volume must be given. Exam- treatment dose level defining the treatment volume may
ples illustrating target volumes in patients with carci- be equal to or different from this reference dose level.
noma of the cervix are given in Figure 2.3. For reporting intracavitary therapy, it is necessary to
Treatment Volume determine the dimensions of the reference volume.
The treatment volume is defined as the volume en- Irradiated Volume
closed by a relevant isodose surface selected by the ra- The irradiated volume is that volume, larger than the
diotherapist, and encompasses at least the target vol- treatment volume, which receives an absorbed dose
8 ... 2. Definition of Terms and Concepts Currenlly Used in Intracavlly Therapy
\
·• .J
Fig. 2.3. Treatment of cervix carcinoma. Stage II.b. Examples of target volumes and treatment volumes. A-Tumor volume (hatched): 4 cm
X 3 cm X 2 em. The almost pear-shaped target volume includes the entirety of palpable and visible tumor as well as the whole uterus. The planned.
pear-shaped treatment volume encompasses the target volume. Additional methods such as combined surgery or combined external radiation
may be used. B-Tumor volume (hatched): 9 cm X 5 cm X 4 cm. The target volume for brachytherapy will only include the major parts of the
tumor volume. but will include the whole uterus. To treat the rest of the tumor volume and further subclinical disease throughout the pelvis
and the regional lymphatics. external beam therapy will be used. and brachytherapy will be used as boost therapy.
essarily produce the same effect as a similar dose from means of characterizing an intracavitary application
intracavitary therapy alone. and/or of specifying the target absorbed dose, particu-
For intracavitary therapy at medium or high dose larly if rigid source combinations are not used. Such
rates, the therapist has to indicate the dose level which points are not recommended.
he believes to be equivalent to 60 Gy delivered at the b. Reference Points Relatively Close to the Sources but
classical low dose rate and should clearly state this. Related to Organs at Risk
b. Reference Volume: Description of the Pear-Shaped The determination and specification of the absorbed
Volume dose to organs at risk (bladder, rectum, etc.) are ob-
When uterine source(s) are combined with vaginal viously useful with respect to normal tissue tolerance
sources, or when the uterine source is more heavily limits. However, such information will be meaningful
loaded at the lower end, the tissue volume to be de- only to the extent that it is obtained and expressed in
scribed presents a pear shape with its longest axis precise and well-codified ways.
coincident with the intrauterine source. This reference (i) Calculated Values: Reference points for the ex-
volume is defined by means of three dimensions (see pression of the absorbed dose to the bladder and the
Figure 3.1): absorbed dose to the rectum (see Figure 3.2.) have
(i) the height (d h ) is the maximum dimension along been proposed by Chassagne and Horiot (1977).
requirement, it is recommended that the dose distri- -in the case of vaginal irradiation with a central source
butions be computed in two planes: the oblique frontal from a cylindrical applicator.
plane and the oblique sagittal plane both containing the In estimating the volume (Section 3.3.2.b) in this
intrauterine source. simple case, the width is equal to the thickness.
When practicable, it is recommended that dose dis-
tributions be calculated in additional sets of planes and
that these dosimetric data be correlated with that ob- 3.4.2 Vaginal Sources Only
tained from radiographs or CT sections, in order to When only vaginal sources are present, width is the
determine the absorbed dose at any relevant anatomical largest dimension from right to left in an oblique frontal
point. plane through the main axis of the vagina.
While this additional information will be of value in Thickness is the largest dimension in a direction
assessing effects in any individual patient, it will also perpendicular to the above oblique plane. Height is
provide: measured along the vaginal axis, and is commonly
(i) the possibility of comparing the methods of spec- shorter than the other two dimensions.
ification used in different centers and of evaluating
their respective merits;
3.4.3 Rigid Applicator
4.1 Radiobiological Considerations dose rate may be significant (Van Limbergen et al.,
1985). Its location and thickness will vary with the total
Radiobiological effects often depend on dose rate but
reference air kerma rate and the application time. In
to a greater or lesser extent according to the actual level
addition, the time between fractions is important in the
of the dose rate and the nature of the effect (Hall, 1978).
case of fractionated high dose-rate intracavitary
For example, it is generally observed for mammalian
therapy.
cells irradiated in vitro that for dose rates larger than
It can be concluded that any significant change in the
about 1 Gy·min- 1 survival is independent of dose rate,
source strength and the time-dose pattern should be
but becomes increasingly dependent on dose rate at
made with the greatest care. Furthermore, early tissue
lower rates. For dose rates below about 1 Gy·h- 1 survival
reactions alone should not be used to select the pre-
again becomes independent of dose rate.
scribed dose since late reactions, which are most rele-
The relationship between dose rate and tissue re-
vant, depend to a greater extent on dose rate.
sponse in vivo is complex because many factors have to
15
5. Conclusions and Final Recommendations
In intracavitary therapy, due to the high dose-rate different tissues or organs are directly proportional to
gradient, the specification of the target absorbed dose the total reference air kerma.
as that dose observed at one (or several) reference Third, it is recommended that the reference volume
point(s) within the target volume or close to the sources, be described in terms of the height, width and thick-
does not appear to be meaningful. Under these condi- ness of the volume enclosed in the 60 Gy isodose surface
tions, the same approach to reporting as in external for cervix-carcinoma treatment by low dose rates. For
beam therapy cannot be recommended. higher dose rates a dose level lower than 60 Gy has to be
The following are proposed in this Report (see Table selected.
0.1). Fourth, the absorbed dose at reference points in or-
gans at risk (rectum, bladder) should be determined
First, as already pointed out in ICRU Report 29 (computed or measured) and expressed in well-codified
(ICRU, 1978), any method of specification will be ways to provide additional safety limits.
meaningful only to the extent that the treatment In addition, the absorbed dose(s) at reference point(s)
16
APPENDIX
Specification of Radioactive Sources Used in Intracavitary Therapy
Only some aspects of the problem of the specification terms of its output, i.e., exposure rate at a reference
of sources will be reported here since this topic will be distance. The reference exposure rate in milliroentgens
dealt with at length in a forthcoming ICRU Report and per hour at 1 meter was used (mR·h- l ·m 2) (Wambersie
has been treated recently (Dutreix et at., 1982). et at., 1973; NCRP, 1974; Dutreix, 1974; Dutreix and
(1) When radium tubes were the only radioactive Wambersie, 1975).
sources used in intracavitary therapy, their strength was (6) Recently, the Comire Fran~ais pour la Mesure des
specified in terms of the mass of radium in mg con- Rayonnements Ionisants (CFMRI, 1983) has recom-
17
References
BJORNSSON, M. (1980). "Some new treatment methods the uterine cervix by remote afterloading with cycling
with afterloading techniques" p. 102 in High Dose- sources," Am. J. Roentgenol. 96,45.
Rate After-Loading in the Treatment of Cancer of HIMMELMANN, A., KARLSTEDT, K, and RAGNHULT,
the Uterus, Bates T. D. and Berry R. J., Eds., Br. J. I. (1980). "Early experience with high dose-rate
Radiol. Special report 17. (Ralstron) treatment in Goteborg" p. 106 in High
BUSCH, M. (1973). "Three-dimensional optimization Dose-Rate Afterloading in the Treatment of Cancer
in intracavitary application of radium and other of the Uterus, Bates T. D. and Berry R. J., Eds., Br.
sealed gamma sources," p. 658 in Proceedings XIII J. Radiol. Special report 17.
International Congress of Radiology. Madrid,1973, IAEA (1967). International Atomic Energy Agency,
Vol. 2 (Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam). Physical Aspects of Brachytherapy, Reports Series
BUSCH, M., MAKOSKI, B., SCHULTZ, U., and SAUER- no. 75 (International Atomic Energy Agency,
WEIN, K (1977). "Das Essener Nachlade-Verfahren Vienna).
fur die intracavitare Strahlentherapie," Strahlen- IAEA (1972). International Atomic Energy Agency,
Binders for ICRU Reports are available. Each binder will accommodate
from six to eight reports. The binders carry the identification, "ICRU Re-
ports," and come with label holders which permit the user to attach labels
showing the Reports contained in each binder.
The following bound sets of ICRU Reports are also available:
Volume I. ICRU Reports lOb, lOc, lOf
Volume II. ICRU Reports 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18,20
Volume III. ICRU Reports 22, 23, 24, 25, 26
Volume IV. ICRU Reports 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32
Volume V. ICRU Reports 33, 34, 35, 36
(Titles of the individual Reports contained in each volume are given in the
list of Reports set out above.)
23