Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EL13/57600/22
CHUKA UNIVERSITY
I declare that this research proposal is my original work and has not ever been
presented or submitted by anyone or any institution for certification.
Signature.........................Date............
EL13/57600/22
RECOMMENDATION
This thesis have been examined, passed and submitted for examination with my
approval as the university supervisor.
Signature.....................Date.......
[ii]
DEDICTION
This work I dedicate to my concern and loving parents MR and MRS Korma
Bartuas for their good and excellent foundation in academic affairs as well as their
financial support to ensure successful academic excellent towards my studies.
[iii]
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First, I thank Almighty God for the gift of life, opportunity, mercies, good health
and His grace to complete this work. Sincerely, it was been difficult endeavors for
the last three years but God's grace have made me through such tendous journey
of Academic studies.
I also acknowledge the support of my fellow colleagues and friends notably, Linet
Jepkurui and Maximmillah Kwamboga for their support in guidance and responses
relating the academic studies.
[iv]
COPYRIGHT
[v]
ABSTRACT.
This thesis will adopt the curriculum theory proposed by John Bobbitt’s in 1998
and expound by Pinar 2003, featuring out its stages of development, its features,
weakness and its characteristics.
The study will apply the descriptive study design to attain its full information,
having a target population of 566 in totality, with 480 students in number, 56 CRE
teachers of day secondary schools and 30 heads of department in religious
education. Data collection will be both qualitative and quantitative in nature
taking note of analyzing the qualitative data by arranging its responses basing on
the research questions and objectives.
Despite this thesis focusing in day secondary school students’ behavior aspect in
Nakuru west, Nakuru county the study will therefore advance its finding to the
boarding and other secondary schools in general outside the region and province
thus will be implemented to other students in various schools countrywide.
[vi]
This study would employ the use of questionnaires and interviews as its methods
of study.
TABLE OF CONTENT
Declaration-------------------------------------------
Dedication--------------------------------------------
Acknowledgement---------------------------------
Abstract-----------------------------------------------
Table of contents----------------------------------
List of figures---------------------------------------
Acronyms and abbreviation--------------------
[viii]
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATION
[ix]
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses the background of the study, purpose of the study and its
objective, research question, scope of the study and the significance of the study.
It further brings in focus the assumptions, limitations and operation of definition
as well as the organization of the study.
Christian religious education (CRE) is designed to achieve many goals in the lives
of students ranging from teaching the students about god to the teaching of
moral values which is geared towards shaping human behavior.
[x]
1.3Purpose of the study
The purpose of this research thesis would be to establish the effects of religious
education values on students behavior change in day secondary schools in
Nakuru-west, Nakuru County.
The study sought to know the effects of Christian religious education values on
the behavior of secondary school students. Specifically, the study sought to;
This research study will be of immense benefit to other researchers who intend to
know more of the study and can also be used by non research to build more on
their research works. This study contributes to knowledge and could serve as a
guide for other study.
Religious bodies and instructors will not be left out as they would understand the
best way to educate children on principles and practices of Christianity which will
promote peace and harmony as well as co-existence in the society.
[xi]
The study results would also enable the CRE teachers to review their teaching
methodologies in regard of curriculum implementation and behavior change. The
teacher will use the recommendation of the study to improve their mistakes and
use as a guide to caution students against the bad behavior.
The findings of this study will offer insights to curriculum planners and developers
into the role and status of Christian religious education teaching in the secondary
schools in Nakuru and the key role performed by the subject in spiritual and
academic formation of the students towards behavior change.
It will be also important to Kenya institute of education in developing a curriculum
that can be used to enhance the capacity of the administrators, teachers and the
students in handling negative behavior in schools. It proposes solution to learning
institutions in Kenya prone to case of misbehaviors.
The study would provide literature review that can be used by future researchers
in the field of Christian religious education in secondary, tertiary and institutions
of high learning.
This study will be on the effects of Christian religious education values on the
behavior of secondary school students.
This study would be limited to one sub-county due to various factors such as
limited resource, time and financial insufficient.
Financial constrains involves insufficient funds which would tend to impede the
efficiency of the research in sourcing for the relevant materials and information
and in the process of data gathering.
Also, the unavailability of electricity in the remote areas in the region would arise
difficulty in data recording. secondly, the aspect of the Christian Religious
Education would be dealt in depth whereas other subjects would not be look up
in details despite the fact that those subjects also has an impact to behavior
change among the high school students in general.
[xiii]
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
Introduction
Christian Education
The Christian Religious Education curriculum covers three main areas: the Bible
(Old and New Testaments), African Religious heritage and Contemporary Christian
Living. The curriculum aims at generating awareness in the student of his/her life
and connection with God as revealed in Jesus Christ in an altering and increasing
society in which he/she may be an affiliate. The style that would be used for the
study of these comprehensive areas is thematic. This calls for a learning situation
in which the learner together with the teacher would use Christian insights to
critically analyze, evaluate, judge and discover the implications of the issues
raised, for his/her own life. The study of this curriculum would be progressive in
that it commences with the establishment of the universe, the fall of man, the
promise of salvation and its fulfillments in Jesus Christ (NIV, Bible). (Moore, 2007)
states that in China, the current critique of Christian education in particular, risks
undermining the place of this core subject in all schools, just at a moment
when deeper reflection on religion, belief, spirituality and ethics could contribute
enormously to the emergence of a society that seeks to embrace difference and is
comfortable to celebrate the presence of a variety of religious and other belief
systems. This, of course, means respecting the beliefs of majority religious
tradition, too, and seeking to contribute to the religious and spiritual literacy of all
young people and of adults. In the new CRE curriculum it calls for student to get
the required knowledge and by the end of the curriculum, the student would be
able to: gain insights into the unfolding of God’s self -revelation to human kind
through the use of the assimilated social, spiritual and moral insights, to think
critically and make appropriate moral decisions in a rapidly changing society,
appreciate and respect their own, and other people’s cultural and Christian
beliefs and practices, acquire the basic principles of Christian living and develop a
sense of self-worth and respect for others, promote international consciousness
through the understanding of universal brotherhood and sisterhood; contribute
positively to the transformation of self and the society as a whole and acquire
knowledge for future studies in various career fields (Ministry of Education
Report, 2017).
[xiv]
The school sponsors in Kenya also have a role to play through giving advises to the
students, teacher and the government (Baur, 2015). According to International
Handbook of Catholic Education, Stakeholder politics in education determine the
general direction and quality of any system of education. As stated and revised by
Apple (2014); stakeholder politics pose a great challenge to the various
stakeholders, in mooting ways of being accommodated to participate in policy
construction. Everywhere in the world, the Catholic Church recognizes and
contributes immensely to education as an important area of human development
through enhancing and developing informed evangelization process. Thus the
Catholic Church sees education as a process of holistic formation of individuals
enriching them in all spheres of life including intellectual, technical, and social
skills through the school, apart from spiritual sustenance. Kenya Institute of
Curriculum Development contends that CRE curriculum should target the
inculcation of faith in the minds and hearts of the upcoming and young
generation, the adjustment of morals and the spiritual empathy of an individual
soul. The goals in this curriculum would aim at acquisition of knowledge, the
combination of knowledge and work, faith and morality and the practical
application of theory in life. Individual responsibilities in life, towards the human
community, their relationship to society, other creatures and universal
phenomena, cannot be adequately realized without acquiring knowledge,
building and developing it. The study aims to expound the idea that majority of
the learners study CRE for academic determinations only at the cost of behavior
change.
The aim of CRE would therefore be to impart in the student or the pupil the
mental and spiritual capacity for behavior change and proper attitude change
towards Christian religious education as a subject in the society in general. In any
country, religious study is an exposition of what is right, excellent and just. CRE
has been considered by church as a religious organization and not just another
academic subject. It is a subject that has been expected to influence behavioral
changes among the learners. As both an educational and spiritual subject, CRE is
important for the moral development and deepening of personal religious
commitment in the Christian belief.
In this respect, the study will evaluate the role of secondary school Christian
religious education curriculum in behavior change .The formal education in Kenya
is organized in a way that it just allows it to make students to pass examinations
[xv]
and get certificates. The key purpose of any kind of education is for intellectual
growth and also physical and spiritual advancement. Passing exams and getting
certificates are just part of the education process.
Religious studies and behavior change
The report continues to support CRE to be taught based on moral change.
Teaching of CRE should be incorporated with Social Education and Ethics (SEE)
with an aim of enhancement of quality life. The two aims of the new syllabus are
to make religious education more effective and relevant and also link CRE to
cultural background of the students. Therefore, the students concerns are catered
for in this aspect. With the introduction of the two syllabuses, new phase of CRE
in Kenya was realized. The secondary school CRE has been established with the
aim of improving spiritual values and academic development of the learners.
Paramount of its content is derived from the 8-4-4 curriculum which is currently
being used but is under review to 2-6-3-3system. This review was primed because
there is a wide range of Christian topics that can be offered in a CRE curriculum.
Parents also recognize the importance of CRE class for the religious and moral
training. As an academic subject, CRE is inadequate in scope concerning time
distribution in school time table and therefore, cannot exchange the entire
content of religious and moral teachings offered in a CRE class (Craft, 2011). It
should be assigned equal amount of teaching hours same as the other art subjects
.A second probability is that the syllabus in Kenya does not contain relevant
elements that could enable students acquire and develop the needed in change
behavior. Emerging issues like radicalizations, conflict resolution and dialoguing
are not well expressed in the teachings. The major aim of education system in
Kenya is to endorse morality and social justice by inculcating the accurate
assertiveness required for training in both social and community responsibilities
and duties among the youth. The assumption has been that the teaching
of Christian religious education is a serious component that empowers the school
going person to obtain the above. In order to accomplish this, it is crucial that the
government through the ministry of education must ensure that academic
practices in education are geared towards realizing this purpose of the subject.
Students who learn and practice CRE teachings are those who are just critical
minded persons as they are able to brand themselves with rational decisions
based on individual and societal morality (Kingori, 2016). He expounds that, a
person who uses common sense may perceive things differently. This is why in
teaching Christian religious education the learner must be exposed to techniques
[xvi]
that promote behavior change in Christian education (Kingori, 2016). This
promotes self-discipline among the students. On the foundation of the Christian
religious education it points out that the discipline must be jumble-sale to enable
the learner acquire serious thinking skills (Kenya Institute of Education, 2013).
KIE (2002) asserts that athematic approach was adopted to enable effective
learning of CRE. One of the objectives reflected is enabling the learners to get
social, spiritual and moral insight to be able to creatively and critically think and
make sound decisions in a society that is rapidly growing. Therefore, CRE was
expected to give students spiritual, mental and social knowledge and skills.
Students chose religious studies because they can score highly in the subject
hence, attaining overall grades (Cochran, 2014). The study further showed that
students did not want to study CRE because they thought they would get the
knowledge from churches of worship.
SUMMARY OF LITERATURE REVIEW
Religion and education are inseparable in that religious institutions are the
sponsors of educational institutions and such they use the latter to propagate to
their faiths. Most Religious studies shows that attitude issues concerning CRE
indicate a low status of the subjects. Learners should thus be exposed to religious
education which will intern contribute to positive transformation of self and the
society as a whole. They will also be able to acquire knowledge of moral values
and respect for others and be taken through the basic principles of Christian living
and develop a sense of obedience and behavior modification in the society at
general.
Further learners should be exposed to religious education thus to curve the
current wave of moral, social and behavioral evils engulfing(drugs abuse, devil
worshipping sexual violence among others schools can be effectively confronted if
religious values are incarnated in the learners.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORKS
Curriculum Theory
Origin
The curriculum theories originate from different thinkers thus acquiring the
curriculum with different meaning, forms and purpose. Its task is ultimately
building a relationship among subjects matter people like the teachers, students,
parents and the society. Lewis 1972 also describes curriculum as an accumulation
[xvii]
of the knowledge, learning experience in different learning environment with
various cognitive content and instructional plan.
Curriculum theory (CT) is an academic discipline devoted to examining and
shaping educational curricula. There are many interpretations of CT, being as
narrow as the dynamics of the learning process of one child in a classroom to the
lifelong learning path an individual takes. CT can be approached from the
educational, philosophical, psychological and sociological disciplines. James
MacDonald states that“one central concern of theorists is identifying the
fundamental unit of curriculum with which to build conceptual systems” (Pinar,
2004).
According to ( Beauchamp 1961) the most important purpose of the curriculum
theory is to give meaning to various aspects of curriculum activity basing of the
subjects applied on. The theory was important to this study since it explains the
values which should be captured in the shaping of the education. Curriculum
theory is fundamentally concerned with values (Kliebard, 1989). The historical
analysis of curriculum is ways of viewing current educational curriculum and
policy decisions, and theorizing about the curricula of the future (Wallin, 2011).
Pinar (2004) defines the contemporary field of curriculum theory as “the effort to
understand curriculum as symbolic representation. This theory will help the
researcher to explain how Curriculum helps in shaping CRE. The publication of
John Bobbitt’s in 1918 took the prevalent industrial revolutionary concepts of
experimental science and social efficiency and applied them to the classroom.
John believed that “curriculum must directly and specifically prepare students for
tasks in the adult world” (Pinar, 2004).
He also believed that "human life consists in the performance of specific activities.
Education that prepares for life is one that prepares definitely an d
adequately for these specific activities" (Smith, 2000).From this idea, he
suggested that curriculum was a series of experiences that children have in order
to meet "objectives’’ or abilities and habits that people need for particular
activities. Various studies on CRE have been done but none has focused on the
role of Christian religious education curriculum in behavior change. Therefore,
the current study will answer the research questions concerning the effects of
CRE values, teaching impacts, CRE students’ attitudes and CRE curriculum
approaches in the behavior change of Day Secondary Schools students.
Person behind it
[xviii]
Tyler W Ralph is among the finders of this theory with several models
development among others.
Stages of development of curriculum theory
Ralph w. Tyler presented the four basic stages of curriculum development defined
as the basic principles of the curriculum and instruction known as Tyler’s
rationale. These four stages derived from the four questions raised by Tyler in
1949. The Tyler rationale specified the four components of the curriculum
purpose, experiences, methods and evaluation. He further stated that the
curriculum development theory means how to plan a curriculum according to the
goals and mission of the education.
Goals and objectives: what are the learning rationale as school should try
to find out.
Content: which learning principle can be presented that will probably
achieve these rationale
Learning experience in what manner these learning experience can be
organized.
Evaluation how to find out that the rationale are being accomplished
Origin
His theory originated by a series of moral dilemma presented to his study subject,
which involved the reasoning of decisions made by an individual.
Person behind it
American psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg developed this theory exploring some
of the basic questions of moral development among the individuals .His works
expanded and modified by Jean Piaget’s previous but was more centered on
explaining how children develop moral reasoning. He further proposed that moral
development is a continual process that occurs throughout human lifespan.
[xxi]
Weakness of the theory
Moral reasoning does not equal moral behavior in that it is not guarantee
that it fully leads to moral behavior
Overemphasizes justice when making moral choices
Cultural bias: in that individualist cultures emphasize personal right,
whereas collective cultures stress the importance of society and
community. Eastern collective cultures may have different moral outlooks
that Kohlberg’s theory does not take into account.
Age bias: most of his subjects were children under the age of 16 who
obviously had no experience with marriage
Gender bias: This is because all subjects in his sample were male. He
believed that women tended to remain at third level of moral development
because they place a stronger emphasis on things such as social
relationship and the welfare of others.
Characteristic of moral theory
It is self-manageable
Entail self-knowledge
It entails consciences
It entails social intelligence
Have pro-social values
Application
The application of Kohlberg’s theory of moral development is important to my
study in that it plays a key role in the emergence of the field of moral psychology.
Researchers continue to explore how moral reasoning develops and changes
through live of individual and mentally changes the life of the individual in the
society. Understanding these stages offers helpful insights into the ways that both
children and adults make moral choice and how moral thinking may influence the
decisions and behavior.
This study will be guided by Kohlberg’s theory of development, which contents
that adolescent tend to assimilate moral reasoning from those who are older and
who appear to have reached a stage beyond them, Pearce and
Simanowitz( 2003).Christian religious education being regarded as a more subject
that shapes the secondary school youths into ideal personalities in the society,
thus goes hand in an with moral development theory which mainly focuses on
explaining why is important for school systems to impart moral values in
adolescents who in the context are the secondary level of education
[xxii]
students .Religious education is a subject that goes beyond the classroom learning
more on character development rather than knowledge acquisition. The main
objective of studying CRE education among others is to enable learners to gain
insight in to the unfolding of Gods self-relevant to human kind and use the
acquired social and spiritual insights to think critically and to make appropriate
moral decisions in a rapid changing society (Kidakwa and Obonyo, 2004).
Conceptual framework
CHAPTER THREE
[xxiii]
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY
Research Design
This study would use a descriptive study design in that it aims at describing the
impact of the CRE values to the behavior change among the students life in day
secondary schools in the specified region. As per the scholar Gay (2003), a
descriptive method of gathering information in order to answer questions
concerning the current status of the subject matter. Orodho (2009), states that a
cross sectional descriptive method is a method of collecting data by interviewing
questionnaires to a sample of individuals.my application towards this method is
that it is the most frequently used to collect data about peoples feelings’
opinions, emotions, habits, attitudes as well as perspectives of individuals
behavior in the society. It also gives précised information from the interviewers.
2.1 Introduction
This chapter covers methodologies and processes that would be applied while
conducting this research. The chapter also will describe the research designs,
target population, location of the study, sampling procedures, data collection,
management and analysis. This study will use qualitative research techniques.
Finally, the chapter will focus on the validity and reliability as well as the ethical
issues that would be applied during the study. The sampling for this interview
mainly comes from the leaders and members target in the schools in an attempt
to understand their conceptualization of effects of CRE values among students
taking it as a subject.
The research study will take place at Nakuru West sub county secondary schools.
This is one of the Counties in Nakuru, located at Rift valley province of Kenya. I
prefer taking my research in that area in that it comprises of large population of
day secondary schools in that county and also it offers CRE studies in that they are
mostly sponsored by church denominations such as African Inland Church of
Kenya, catholic as well as Anglican Church. This simply signifies that the high
population in the area of Christian faith believers. Secondly, it is low cost in terms
[xxiv]
of funding in that the schools are easily accessible due to its location in that they
are not sparsely located.
3.3Target population
3.5Research instruments
I would employ two research instruments in my research thesis that will facilitate
gathering of information: questionnaire and interview
3.5.1Questionnaire
[xxv]
Questionnaire is set of questions or items that are used to collect data over a
large sample from respondent who are able to read and write. They are
preferable in that they enable the researcher to use minimal time to the
respondent to give correct and well formulated answers of the researched topic.
Financially questionnaires are less expensive and require minimal capital to
conduct and also less time in their administration. It has open and closed ended
item in a structure.
3.5.2Interview
Interview guide involves the researcher meeting face to face with the
interviewers and having direct discussions. According to Orodho (2005), the
interview schedules makes it possible to obtain the data required to meet the
objective of the study. The semi structured interview guide would be applied thus
to meet the personal interviews.
3.6Pilot study
It is an important aspect in that it enables both the reliability and validity of the
instruments to be determined. According to (Wiersa, 1999), it is important that
the researcher is piloted as the fine tuning. Pilot study would take place at Laikipia
County.
3.7Validity
Validity refers to whether a questionnaire is measuring what are purports to
measure. McMillan and Schumacher (2006), describes validity as the degree of
congruence between the explanation of the phenomenon and the realities of the
world. This study will apply both the construct validity as well as the content
validity to ensure full assess of information for the specific objectives in the study
as well as its framework. Also, questionnaires would be examined and evaluated.
3.8Reliability
Reliability is the extent in which results are consistent over time (Kombo, 2006). In
this thesis test retest method will be applied to ensure reliability of the study. The
data collection method which is questionnaire and interview would be tested
probably at a given percentage thus to ensure that it is relevant and effective
method of study.
[xxvi]
3.9Data collection procedure
Questionnaire includes questions given to the respondents with the aim of
collecting data. This research employs a questionnaire to purposefully obtain first-
hand information from the CRE teachers, head of department as well as the
students, in that it is a friendly method and it also allows easy data analysis.
Interview will be conducted face to face with Heads of Departments as well as the
establishment of good rapport with the respondents and explaining in details the
key purpose of the study and how to excellently respond to the questions that are
intended to be filled up for successful study of the research.
3.10Ethical consideration
The permission to proceed on with this researcher proposal was soughed the
supervisor of the department of education and resource management, Chuka
university as well as my prior visit of the respective 12 schools whereby have
assured respondents of confidential by keeping their information intact and not
exposing any information that would be gather to the public or any authority
without individual permission or the concern authority. The students will
participate after consultation from their teacher due to early preparation of the
informed consent about the study. The interviewers would have freedom to
withdraw if the so wished.
Reference
Ajzen, I., and Fishbein, M.(1980). Understanding attitudes and predicting social
behavior. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Printice-Hall, Inc
Beuchamp, G.A.(1961).Curriculum Theory, Kagg press.
Kliebard, H.M.(1995) “The Tyler Rationale revisited” Journal of Curriculum Studies
27(1):81-88
[xxvii]
Lewis, A. J.(1972) Supervision for Improved Instruction :new challenge, new
responses. Belmont, Calif, Wadsworth.
Oliva, P. F.(2009) Developing the Curriculum. BOSTON, MA :Allyn and Bacon.
Orodho, A. J. Techniques of writing Research proposal and Report in Education
and Social Science. Nairobi, Masola Publisher.
Orodho, J.A. and Kombo, D. K.(2002). Research Methods. Nairobi: Kenyatta
University.
Republic of Kenya (2001). Task Force On Students Discipline and Unrest in
Secondary Schools,(Wangai report).NAIROBI: Jomo Kenyatta Foundation.
[xxviii]